Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 175; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1598
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 17 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2248/2025
- Sections
- 51, 58, 115, 25, 22, 47, 136, 501CA(4), 501CA, 499
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1598 : 2025 INSC 175 Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr.
v.
Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 2248 of 2025)
17 January 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration A suit for confirmation of possession or in the alternative recovery of possession and injunction was filed by the predecessor in interest of the Respondents against the predecessor in interest of the Appellants. The suit was decreed and 40 years later, Execution Application was filed claiming breach of decree of permanent injunction. When the written objections of the Appellants were not accepted to the same by the Trial Court, a Revision Application was filed before High court; During its pendency, Trial Court allowed the Execution Application ex-parte and ordered arrest and detention of Appellants in civil prison for a period of 30 days and attachment of their property in accordance with law. Against this, a Revision Application was filed by appellants before the High Court. That was dismissed holding that there was no jurisdictional error in the order of the executing court.
The issues before the Hon’ble Supreme Court are as to whether the Execution Application is belated; whether the Courts have applied correct procedure to come to their decisions; and what constitutes jurisdictional error.
Headnotes† Sections 51 and 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – To be read harmoniously:
Held: Section 51 defines the jurisdiction and power of the court to enforce execution and enumerates modes by which the court may order execution of a decree according to the nature of relief granted in favour of a decree-holder – Proviso to Section 51 as inserted by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1936 (Act 21 of 1936) limited the grounds on which a judgment-debtor could be arrested or detained – Section 58 fixes the period for which the judgment-debtor can be detained in a civil prison – Sections 51 and 58 should be read together. [Paras 19, 22, 24, 33] [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1599Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
Order XXI Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Explained:
Held: The Rule 32 in its sub-rules: (1) States that where a decree is for specific performance of a contract, or for an injunction, and the judgment-debtor willfully disobeys such decree, it may be executed by attachment of property of the judgment-debtor or by his detention, or by both; (2) Declares that where in a decree for specific performance or for injunction, the judgment-debtor is a corporation, it may be enforced by attachment of the property of the corporation, or with the leave of the court by detention of the directors or other principal officers or by both, attachment and detention; (3) Provides for sale of attached property and payment of the sale-proceeds to the decree- holder where the attachment remains in force for six months and the judgment debtor fails to obey the decree; (4) Deals with cases where the judgment debtor obeys the decree or the decree-holder commits default; (5) Empowers the executing court to take appropriate action for enforcing the decree at the cost of the judgment-debtor who willfully disobeys such decree; and the Explanation clarifies that the expression “the act required to be done” covers prohibitory as also mandatory injunctions. [Paras 26-31] Order XXI Rule 11A Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 examined in light of Section 51:
Held: The Law Commission considered the amendment of 1936 to Section 51 and held that the existence of the circumstances mentioned in Section 51, proviso (a) to (c) should be alleged either in the execution application or in an accompanying affidavit – As per Order XXI Rule 11-A an application made for the arrest and detention of the judgment-debtor must state or be accompanied by an affidavit specifying the grounds on which arrest is sought – This Rule is in conformity with the substantive provisions of proviso to Section 51 – Stating of grounds or filing of affidavit is essential and thus mandatory – Unless it is complied with, no arrest or detention of the judgment-debtor can be ordered. [Paras 32, 34, 35] Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC, 1908 and its effect on permanent injunction – Examined in light of judicial pronouncements: Held: A decree of permanent injunction is executable under Order XXI Rule 32 – Breach of decree of permanent injunction is a 1600 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports continuing disobedience entailing penal consequences – In Jai Dayal and Others v. Krishan Lal Garg and Anr., (1996) 11 SCC 588, this Hon’ble Court held that the decree of attachment made for enforcement of the perpetual injunction and mandatory injunction requires to be complied with and in case of its disobedience, the judgment-debtor is liable to detention in the civil prison and his property is liable to attachment under Order XXI Rule 32, CPC, 1908. [Para 37] Art.136 of the Limitation Act and execution of decree of permanent injunction – In the light of judicial pronouncements: Held: The High Court of Rajasthan in Maga Ram & Anr v. Kana Ram & Ors., AIR 1993 Rajasthan 208 held that Art.136 of the Limitation Act has no application in case of execution of decree granting mandatory injunction and also the decree for prohibitory injunction become enforceable only when the judgement debtors made fresh encroachment on the disputed land – The High Court of Bombay in the case of Shri Benedito (Betty) Dias v. Armando Benedita Fernandes, 2017(4) AIR Bom. R 381 relied on: (a) Jai Dayal (supra) wherein it was held that non-compliance of decree of mandatory or prohibitory injunction is a continuing disobedience and therefore the plea of execution being barred by limitation, cannot be accepted; and (b) A decision of the High Court of Kerala wherein it was held that an application for enforcement of the decree granting prohibitory injunction shall not be subject to any period of limitation – The High Court of Punjab and Haryana in the Dilbagh Singh and Others v. Harpal Singh Alias Harpal Singh Chela and Ors., 2020 Supreme (P&H) 944 held that Order 21 Rule 32(5) has been interpreted by the Supreme Court in various judgments viz. Samee Khan vs. Bindu Khan, 1998(4) RCR(Civil) 125 (SC) to mean that in an execution proceedings of a decree for injunction, if it is found that the decree holder has been dispossessed after the date of decree, the restoration of possession can also be ordered by the Executing Court. [Paras 38-43] Order XXI Rule 32 – Imprisonment of or attachment of property of judgment debtor – When ordered:
Held: If it is proved that the judgment debtor willfully and with impunity disobeyed an order of injunction, the court owes it to itself to pass an order of imprisonment or attachment – Failure to exercise this power in appropriate cases might verily undermine the [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1601Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
respect for judicial institutions in the eyes of litigants – The court has to record a finding that the judgment-debtor willfully disobeyed or failed to comply with the decree in spite of opportunity afforded to him – Each breach of injunction is independent and actionable in law and the doctrine of res judicata has no application – The person seeking execution of the decree for injunction is onerous under the Rule 32(1) is to place materials before the executing Court as would enable it to conclude (i) That the person bound by the decree, was fully aware of the terms of the decree and its binding nature upon him; and (ii) That person has had an opportunity of obeying such decree, but has willfully, i.e., consciously and deliberately, disobeyed such decree, so that it can make an order of his detention as sought for. [Paras 44-46, 50] Arrest and attachment – Whether correct procedure was adopted by the Courts in this case:
Held: There was absolutely no material placed by the respondents/ decree holders before the Courts that the appellants/judgment debtors have had an opportunity of obeying the decree for injunction, but have willfully disobeyed it – Only few complaints of breaches made to the police were placed before the executing court – It is true that there was some delay on the part of the appellants herein in responding to the summons issued by it, but at the same time, having regard to the severe consequences, the executing court should have been a little more considerate while declining even to take the objections on record and give one opportunity of hearing to the appellants before passing the order of arrest, detention in a civil prison and attachment of the property – If at all a fresh application is filed with the same prayer before the Executing Court by the Respondents in future, it has to be dealt by the Court with keeping in mind this decision. [Paras 51-52, 59, 61] Principle of Jurisdictional Error – High Court wrongly applied it – The principle explained in light of judicial pronouncements and publication:
Held: High Court was not able to see the gross error in the order passed by the executing court, be it called an error of law or a jurisdictional error – Observation of Sir John Beaumont in Joy Chand Lal Babu v. Kamalaksha Chaudhury, AIR 1949 PC 239 that if erroneous decision which has resulted in the subordinate Court or tribunal exercising jurisdiction, not vested in it by law, 1602 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports or it having failed to exercise jurisdiction, vested in it by law, that will come within the scope of Section 115 of the Code or, for the matter of that, of Article 227 of the Constitution, as the case may be – Joy Chand case identified non-exhaustive list of jurisdictional errors like: (a) identified a wrong issue; (b) asked a wrong question;
(c) ignored relevant material; (d) relied on irrelevant material; (e) failed to observe a requirement of procedural fairness; (f) made a decision involving fraud; (g) made a decision in bad faith; (h) made a decision without evidence; (i) applied a policy inflexibly – After the decision of the House of Lords in Anisminic v. The Foreign Compensation Commission, 1967(2) AER 986 every error of law is a jurisdictional error – This concept is best explained by K.S. Paripoornan, J., in His Lordship's separate Judgment in Mafatal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India, (1997) 5 SCC 536, summarised as: I. Errors of fact – (i) Old rule: The court would quash only if the erroneous fact that was jurisdictional (ii) New rule: The court will quash if an erroneous and decisive fact was (a) jurisdictional; (b) found on the basis of no evidence; or (c) wrong, misunderstood or ignored; II. Errors of law – (i) Old rule: The court would quash only if the error was (a) jurisdictional; or (b) on the face of the record (ii) New rule: The court will quash for any decisive error, because all errors of law are now jurisdictional — Also referred to an erudite article authored by Krystal Cunningham-Foran on the topic “Jurisdictional Error” wherein a judgment rendered by the High Court of Australia setting out practical guidance for establishing jurisdictional error in the context of judicial review proceedings was discussed. [Paras 53-58] Case Law Cited Jai Dayal And Others v. Krishan Lal Garg and Anr. [1996] Supp. 8 SCR 538 : (1996) 11 SCC 588; Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India [1996] Supp. 10 SCR 585 : (1997) 5 SCC 536 – relied on. Shivamurthy Mahalingappa Kuchanaur v. Dannammadevi Cycle Mart, Rabakavi, AIR 1987 Karnataka 26; Joy Chand Lal Babu v. Kamalaksha Chaudhury, AIR 1949 PC 239; Anisminic v. The Foreign Compensation Commission, 1967(2) AER 986 – relied on. Maga Ram & Anr v. Kana Ram & Ors., AIR 1993 Rajasthan 208; Shri Benedito (Betty) Dias v. Armando Benedita Fernandes, 2017(4) AIR Bom. R 381; Dilbagh Singh and Others v. Harpal Singh Alias Harpal Singh Chela and Ors., 2020 Supreme (P&H) 944 – discussed.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1603Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
Books and Periodicals Cited Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 by Justice C.K. Thakker, 2009 Edn.
List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Limitation Act, 1963. List of Keywords Prohibitory injunction; Arrest; Attachment; Limitation; Civil prison. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2248 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.09.2019 of the High Court at Calcutta in CO No. 3283 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Rabin Majumder, Joydeep Mukherjee, Advs. for the Appellants. Mrs. Lalita Kaushik, Adv. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
2. Exemption Application is allowed.
3. Leave granted.
4. This appeal arises from the order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Calcutta dated 23.09.2019 in CO. No. 3283 of 2019 by which the High Court rejected the CO filed by the appellants herein (judgment debtors) and thereby affirmed the order passed by the Executing Court dated 4.9.2019 in Title Execution Case No. 1 of 2017 arising out of Title Suit No. 25 of 1965.
5. For the sake of convenience, the appellants herein shall be referred to as the judgment debtors and the respondents herein shall be referred to as the decree holders.
1604 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
6. The facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarised as under: i. In 1965, the predecessor-in-interest of the decree holders herein instituted a Title Suit No. 25 of 1965 for confirmation of possession and in the alternative for recovery of possession based on title to the suit land and for permanent injunction. The respondents herein are the legal heirs of the original plaintiffs of the Title Suit No. 25 of 1965 referred to above. The Subordinate Judge 2nd Court, Hooghly decreed the suit vide the judgment and decree dated 26.06.1976. The operative part of the decree reads thus:
“Considering the facts, circumstances and evidence on record I, therefore, hold that the plaintiff has been able to establish his title to the suit properties and possession follows title and the defendant has failed to prove his alleged title. So he had no occasion to disturb plaintiffs possession of the suit properties. The plaintiff is therefore, entitled to have a declaration of title and confirmation of possession and injunction with respect to peaceful possession of the suit properties against the defendants. The suit is also maintainable, issue nos.2 to 5 are thus disposed of with a remarks that there is no need for consideration of alternative prayer for recovery of possession in the aforesaid context.
Issue No.6:- In the result the suit succeeds.
Court fees paid upon the plaint sufficient.
Hence,
ORDERED
That the suit is decreed on contest with costs against defendant no. 1 Ka to Jha and 2 and without contest and without cost against the rest. Plaintiff’s title with respect to Ka and Kha schedule is hereby declared and his possession thereof is hereby confirmed.
The defendants are permanently restrained from disturbing possession of the plaintiff of the suit properties. The prayer for damage etc. is rejected under the present frame of the suit.”
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1605Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
ii. Thus, the appellants herein were permanently restrained from disturbing the peaceful possession of the respondents herein in so far as the suit property is concerned.
iii. The appellants herein being dissatisfied with the judgment and decree dated 20.06.1976 referred to above, challenged the same by filing Title Appeal No. 214 of 1976. The record does not reveal in what manner the Title Appeal came to be disposed of, however, according to the appellants, the same was disposed of by the Appellate Court vide order dated 10.06.1980. iv. Sometime in the year 2017, i.e., after a period of almost 40 years, the respondents herein filed an Execution Case seeking to execute the decree dated 26.06.1976 referred to above on the ground that the appellants herein were disturbing & creating trouble in their peaceful enjoyment of the property and thereby alleged that the appellants have committed breach of the decree of permanent injunction. The same came to be registered as Title Execution Case No. 1 of 2017. The appellants were served with the summons of the suit execution case.
v. The application filed by the respondents herein (decree holders) which came to be registered as Execution Case No. 1 of 2017 concerning title Suit No. 25/1965 reads thus:
“IN THE COURT OF THE LD. CIVIL JUDGE SENIOR
DIVISON AT ARAMBAGH, HOOGHLY
Executive Case No. 2017 concerning Title Suit No.
25/1965 Heirs of Late Choto Chandi Charan Ghosal and heirs of the said property 1 : Shri Ajit Kumar Ghoshal 2: Sri Ranjit Ghoshal father of 1 and 2 Late Choto Chandi Charan Ghoshal 3: Anup Kumar Ghoshal son of Shri Swapan Ghoshal 4: Sri Arup Kumar Ghoshal 5: Sri Guru Charan Ghoshal father of 4 & 5 Sri Dilip Kumar Ghoshal 6: Sri Rabindra Nath Ghoshal son of Shri Asit Kurriar Ghoshal all residents of Harihar Post Debkhand PS Goghat District Hooghly 1/ Jaidev Mallick 2/ Mahadev Mallick 3/ Bhoot Mallick aka Bhudev Mallick aka Sahadev Mallick 4/ Laxman Chandra Mallick all S/o Late Nagendranath Mallick 1606 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports all resident of Harlhar, Post Debkhand PS Goghat, District Hooghly.
26/06/1976 AD Civil Appeal No. 214/1976 Settlement 10/06/1980 -no- -no- -no- -no- 1/Shri Jaydev Mallick 2/ Mahadev Mallick 3(Bhoot Mallick aka Bhudev Mallick aka Sahadev Mallick 4/ Laxman Chandra Mallick all S/o Nagendranath Mallick all resident of Harihar, Post Debkhand PS Go ghat, District Hooghly.
The defendants/debtors wilfully defying the Permanent Restraining order of the Court and creating obstacles to the peaceful possession of the plaintiff decree holder’s property by the heirs of the plaintiff decree holder. Therefore, the instant petition is being field with the prayer that the Defendants/Debtors must be stopped from creating obstacles to the peaceful possession of the property by the heirs of the decree holders and the order/direction may also kindly be issued for sending the Defendants/Debtors to Civil Jail and their property should also be attached and auctioned so that the debtors cannot create obstacles on possession of the property of plaintiff ‘decree holder’s heirs by breaking the perpetual restraining order of the trial court and court assistance is required to attack and auction their property and to send them to Civil Jail.”
vi. It is the case of the appellants that although the summons was received by them yet due to non-availability of old records they were not in a position to appear before the court concerned and later learned that the execution case was fixed by the court for ex parte disposal. On 12.12.2018, the appellants herein filed their written objections to the execution case along with a petition requesting to accept the written objections & give them an opportunity of hearing.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1607Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
vii. The written objections lodged in writing by the appellant herein (judgment debtors) read thus:
“Objection against Application for Execution filed by the Decree Holders
1. That the application for Execution flied by the Decree Holders with respect to the original suit Is not maintainable.
2. That the application Is vague and Indistinct. The decree holders in their petition has not stated the schedule of property and hence It 1s ambiguous and since the petition Is handwritten it 1s 1lleglble to a huge extent and should be rejected.
3. That the properties described in the schedule of the plaint of the original suit was purchased by the predecessor of the Judgement debtors and at no point of time was possessed by the decree holders or their predecessors. The decree holders have obtained the judgement and decree on 26.06.1976 but even then they did not possess the suit property. The properties were all along in possession of the judgement debtors which was unaffected and even after procuring the alleged decree from the Ld. Lower Court the decree holders did not possess the same till today. Thus after such a long time the decree holders could not pray for relief for alleged violation of any order of injunction.
4. That after obtaining the alleged judgement and decree on 26.06.1976 the decree holders have filed several cases before the Ld. Executive Magistrate and In almost every case the possession of the Judgement debtors have been confirmed.
5. That the decree holders in order to snatch possession of the suit properties from the judgement debtors have filed the instant petition at this belated stage knowing very well that they never possessed the property. Moreover the decree holders in several applications have stated that they did not have 1608 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports possession over the suit properties.
6. That unless the truth regarding the possession comes before the Ld. Court the Instant execution Is not maintainable.
7. That the decree holders are putting forth claim on the basis of erroneous record of rights whereas the judgement debtors have come to own the suit properties by virtue of purchase. The judgement debtors have much better title than the decree holders which can be ascertained by seeking evidence.
8. That since the, decree holders did not clalh1 possession over the suit properties the judgement debtors have been openly, as of their own right, uninterruptedly, without any protest from the decree holders have been possessing the suit tank since purchase and later on since 10.06.1980 i.e. from the date of disposal of the appeal case. The decree holders are thus stopped from putting forth illegal claim over the suit properties. Without taking due process of law the Ld. Court and in absence of due proceeding the Ld. Court could not pass any order in this case.
9. That the Judgement debtors. will be put to Irreparable loss and injury if the execution application filed by the decree holders Is entertained.
10. That since the petition is illegible and since the order in the original suit has been passed more than 40 years ago the judgement debtors crave leave to file additional written objection if found necessary for proper adjudication of this case.
In the above circumstances the judgement debtor pray that the Ld. Court be kind enough to reject the execution application flied oy the decree holder.
AFFIDAVIT
I Shri Bhudeb Mallik, s/o Late Nagendranath Mallik, aged about 55 years, by faith Hindu, by occupation cultivation, residing at viii-Harihar, p.o. - Debkhanda, [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1609Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
p.s. - Goghat, dist - Hooghly do hereby solemnly affirm and declare that the statements made by me above are true to the best of my knowledge and belief.”
viii. On 21.01.2019, the Executing Court declined to take the written objections on record saying that the same were not maintainable. The court fixed the matter for final arguments on 25.01.2019. The appellants being aggrieved by the order dated 21.09.2019 referred to above, preferred a Revision Application being C.O. No. 1120 of 2019 before the High Court. The High Court vide order dated 27.03.2019 admitted the Revision Application and stayed all further proceedings of the Title Execution Case No. 1 of 2017.
ix. Later the appellants herein filed an application being CAN 74 of 2019 dated 26.07.2019 in the High Court seeking extension of the interim order dated 27.03.2019 referred to above and accordingly informed the trial court about the pendency of the Revision Application being C.O. No. 1120 of 2019 and the Application being CAN 74 of 2019 filed for extension of the interim order dated 27.03.2019.
x. However, on 4.09.2019, the Civil Judge Arambagh proceeded to pass an Order 21 in Title Execution Case against appellants herein by allowing the execution case ex parte. The Civil Judge ordered that the appellants herein (judgment debtors) shall be arrested and detained in civil prison for a period of 30 days and their property be attached in accordance with law.
xi. The order passed by the Civil Judge referred to above reads thus: “Order No.21 dated 04.09.2019 The plaintiffs file hazira.
The fact of the case in short is that this is a case for execution of permanent injunction passed by the Ld.
Second Court of the Subordinate Judge, Hooghly, in T.S. No.25 of 1965. The plaintiffs of the original suit got the decree of permanent injunction in the form of permanent restrainment of the defendant/judgment debtors from disturbing possession of the plaintiffs in the suit property as well as the property over which the execution is prayed for.
1610 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports The present petitioners are the legal heirs of the deceased Chota Chandicharan Ghoshal i.e. the original plaintiff of the said T.S. 25 of 1965.
The present execution case, prays in made by execution application dated 25.11.2017, praying for execution of contested judgment and decree in T.S.
no.25/1965, dated 26.06.1976, of the Ld. Second Court of the. Subordinate Judge, Hoogly. It is averred in the application that the Jdrs. are willfully, in violation of the decree, disturbing the peaceful possession of the Dhrs upon decretal property and thus it is necessary to execute the same by relief of Civil Jail as well as attachment and sale of the properties of Jdrs. In argument Ld. Counsel for the Dhr Submits that they were granted a contested decree of declaration and permanent injunction, but the Jdrs are willfully violating the same, and which is apparent from the evidence on record and thus the decree maybe put into execution by putting the Jdrs in Civil Jail and by attachment of their properties. In this regard, the Ld. Counsel cited the landmark judgment passed by Ld. Punjab Haryana High court on 9th October, 1979 and which is published in AIR 1980 P and H.
The impugned decree filed along with the execution application shows that the present applicants are Dhrs and that the defendants of the suit are Jdrs.
The same was decreed on contest on 26.06.1965 declaring the title of the plaintiff/Dhrs in respect of the suit property and confirming their possession. The defendants/Jdrs were restrained by way of permanent injunction from disturbing possession of the plaintiff m the suit property.
It is noted that the Jdrs had appeared in such case and have knowledge of all averments reports. Moreover, the decree was contested decree. The police report shows that despite the decree, the Jdrs are claiming forceful possession. In Iyyam Perumal Vs Chinna Gounder, (1984) it was observed that direction of [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1611Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
arrest may be restored to if there is adequate proof of refusal to comply with a decree inspite of Jdrs possessing sufficient means to satisfy the same. Thus, there are enough circumstances to put the decree into execution as prayed for. Hence, it is,
ORDER
That the execution case is allowed ex-parte and the Judgment Debtors are directed to be arrested and detained in civil prison for a period of thirty days and also to attach judgment Debtors properties as per the provision of law.
Thus this T.Ex.Case is disposed of.”
xii. The appellants herein being dissatisfied with the order passed by the Civil Judge referred to above, challenged the same by filing Revision Application No. COC 283 of 2019 before the High Court invoking its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
xiii. The High Court vide its impugned order dated 23.09.2019 rejected the revision application and thereby affirmed the order passed by the Civil Judge referred to above.
xiv. The High Court in its impugned order observed thus: “The present challenge is directed at the behest of the judgment-debtors of a decree for permanent injunction.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners argues that in view of the application filed for arrest and detention in civil prison of the petitioners, the same ought to have been - governed under Order XXI Rule 11A of the Code of Civil Procedure, which, it is argued, contemplates an affidavit being filed, stating the ground on which arrest is applied for. In the absence of such an affidavit in the present case, the executing court acted without jurisdiction in allowing the execution case.
The next contention of learned counsel for the petitioners is that the petitioners’ written objection to 1612 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the application for execution was not accepted due to delay, which was challenged in a civil revisional application before this Court.
Although the petitioners prayed for stay of the execution case in view of pendency of an application for extension of stay granted in the previous revisional application, the executing court acted in hot haste in passing the impugned order, which was thus vitiated on such ground as well.
Learned counsel appearing for the decree-Holders, on the other hand, points out that the previous revisional application challenging the non-acceptance of written objection by the present petitioners was dismissed by a co-ordinate bench on the ground that the same had become infructuous in view of passing of the order impugned herein. As such, there is no challenge existing at present to the order refusing to accept the written objection of the petitioner.
In such view of the matter, the argument, that the petitioner did not get any opportunity to file written ‘objection, has been rendered academic since there is no existing challenge pending against the same.
Moreover, a plain reading of Rule 11A of Order XXI of the Code suggests that the same envisages an application being made for the arrest and detention in prison of the judgment-debtors, stating the grounds on which arrest is applied for, or be accompanied by an affidavit stating such grounds.
The language of Order XXI Rule 11A of the Code suggests clearly that the grounds for arrest and detention may be contained either in the application or in the accompanying affidavit.
In the present case, the execution application itself contained the ground, sufficient to entitle the executing court to pass an order of execution of the· decree for permanent injunction.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1613Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
As such, no jurisdictional error was committed by the executing court in passing the impugned order.
Accordingly, C.O. No. 3283 of 2019 is dismissed on contest.
There will be no order as to costs.
At this juncture, learned counsel for the petitioners prays for stay of the instant order for a limited period. However, since, in the opinion of this Court, no question of law of substantial importance is involved in this case, the prayer for such stay is refused.”
7. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellants herein (judgment debtors) are here before this Court with the present appeal.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS(JUDGMENT
DEBTORS)
8. Mr. Joydeep Mukherjee, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants vehemently submitted that the High Court committed an egregious error in passing the impugned order. He submitted that the execution petition itself was not maintainable at the instance of the respondents after a lapse of almost 40 years from the date of passing of the decree of declaration and permanent injunction.
9. He submitted that the Civil Judge committed a serious error in directing arrest of the appellants herein and their detention in civil prison for a period of 30 days with further order to attach their property.
10. The main bone of contention canvassed on behalf of the appellants herein is that the respondents had not filed any petition along with an affidavit as the same is a mandatory requirement under Order XXI Rule 11-A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, “the Code”).
11. He further submitted that the aforesaid aspect came to be overlooked even by the High Court while rejecting the revision application.
12. The learned counsel in the last submitted that the High Court should have at least permitted the appellants herein to file their written objections to the execution case.
1614 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
13. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being merit in his appeal the same may be allowed and the impugned order passed by the High Court and also the one passed by the civil court in execution case be set aside.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS (DECREE
HOLDERS)
14. On the other hand, Mrs. Lalita Kaushik, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents vehemently submitted that no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned order.
15. The learned counsel would submit that the contention on behalf of the appellants that the execution petition could not have been filed after 40 years from the date of the original decree is without any merit. She would submit that once there is a decree of permanent injunction having attained finality; if thereafter at any point of time, the possession of the decree holders is sought to be disturbed then in such circumstances it is always open for the decree holder to seek appropriate relief from the court in accordance with law.
16. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being no merit in this appeal, the same may be dismissed.
ANALYSIS
17. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned order.
18. Before adverting to the rival contentions raised on either side, it is necessary for us to look into few relevant provisions of the Code.
19. Section 51 of the Code prescribes the powers of the court to enforce execution. Section 51 of the Code reads thus:- “51. Powers of Court to enforce execution.—Subject to such conditions and limitations as may be prescribed, the Court may, on the application of the decree-holder, order execution of the decree—
(a) by delivery of any property specifically decreed; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1615Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
(b) by attachment and sale or by the sale without attachment of any property;
(c) by arrest and detention in prison for such period not exceeding the period specified in section 58, where arrest and detention is permissible under that section;
(d) by appointing a receiver; or
(e) in such other manner as the nature of the relief granted may require:
Provided that, where the decree is for the payment of money, execution by detention in prison shall not be ordered unless, after giving the judgment-debtor an opportunity of showing cause why he should not be committed to prison, the Court, for reasons recorded in writing, is satisfied—
(a) that the judgment-debtor, with the object or effect of obstructing or delaying the execution of the decree,—
(i) is likely to abscond or leave the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court, or
(ii) has, after the institution of the suit in which the decree was passed, dishonestly transferred, concealed, or removed any part of his property, or committed any other act of bad faith in relation to his property, or
(b) that the judgment-debtor has, or has had since the date of the decree, the means to pay the amount of the decree or some substantial part thereof and refuses or neglects or has refused or neglected to pay the same, or
(c) that the decree is for a sum for which the judgmentdebtor was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account. Explanation.—In the calculation of the means of the judgment-debtor for the purposes of clause (b), there shall be left out of account any property which, by or under any law or custom having the force of law for the time being in force, is exempt from attachment in execution of the decree.”
1616 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
20. There is no substantial change in the above quoted Section by the Amendment Act of 1976 except addition of words “for such period not exceeding the period specified in Section 58 where arrest and detention is permissible under that section” in Clause (c). In the unamended Section, there was no provision as to the period for which a debtor may be detained in a civil prison. That lacuna is now removed by the addition of this clause. The addition seeks to make the provision harmonious with Section 58.
21. Calcutta High Court Amendment : In clause (b) omit the words, “or by sale without attachment” between the words “sale” and “of any”. In the proviso, omit the words “for reasons recorded in writing” after the words “the Court” and before the words “is satisfied”. Also, add the proviso– “Provided also that the Court of Small Causes of Calcutta shall have no power to order execution of a decree by attachment and sale of immovable property or by appointing a receiver in respect of such property.”
22. Section 51 defines the jurisdiction and power of the court to enforce execution. The manner of execution of a decree is laid down in the First Schedule. The Section enumerates in general terms various modes by which the court may order execution of a decree according to the nature of relief granted in favour of a decree-holder.
23. After the decree-holder files an application for execution of a decree, the executing court can enforce execution. A decree may be enforced by delivery of any property specified in the decree, by attachment and sale or by sale without attachment of any property, or by arrest and detention in a civil prison of the judgment-debtor or by appointing a Receiver, or by effecting partition, or in such other manner as the nature of the relief may require.
24. Sections 51 and 58 respectively should be read together. Section 51 defines the power and jurisdiction of the executing court to enforce execution, Section 58 fixes the period for which the judgment-debtor can be detained in a civil prison.
25. Order XXI Rule 32 of the Code reads thus:- “32. Decree for specific performance for restitution of conjugal rights, or for an injunction.— (1) Where the party [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1617Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
against whom a decree for the specific performance of a contract, or for restitution of conjugal rights, or for an injunction, has been passed, has had an opportunity of obeying the decree and has wilfully failed to obey it, the decree may be enforced 1 [in the case of a decree for restitution of conjugal rights by the attachment of his property or, in the case of a decree for the specific performance of a contract or for an injunction] by his detention in the civil prison, or by the attachment of his property, or by both.
(2) Where the party against whom a decree for specific performance or for an injunction has been passed is a corporation, the decree may be enforced by the attachment of the property of the corporation or, with the leave of the Court, by the detention in the civil prison of the directors or other principal officers thereof, or by both attachment and detention.
(3) Where any attachment under sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2) has remained in force for 2 [six months,] if the judgmentdebtor has not obeyed the decree and the decree-holder has applied to have the attached property sold, such property may be sold; and out of the proceeds the Court may award to the decree holder such compensation as it thinks fit, and shall pay the balance (if any) to the judgmentdebtor on his application.
(4) Where the judgment-debtor has obeyed the decree and paid all costs of executing the same which he is bound to pay, or where, at the end of 2 [six months] from the date of the attachment no application to have the property sold has been made, or if made has been refused, the attachment shall cease.
(5) Where a decree for the specific performance of a contract or for an injunction has not been obeyed, the Court may, in lieu of or in addition to all or any of the processes aforesaid, direct that the act required to be done may be done so far as practicable by the decree-holder or some other person appointed by the Court, at the cost of the judgment-debtor, and upon the act being done the 1618 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports expenses incurred may be ascertained in such manner as the Court may direct and may be recovered as if they were included in the decree.”
26. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 32 states that where a decree is for specific performance of a contract, or for an injunction, and the judgmentdebtor wilfully disobeys such decree, it may be executed by attachment of property of the judgment-debtor or by his detention, or by both.
27. Sub-rule (2) declares that where in a decree for specific performance or for injunction, the judgment-debtor is a corporation, it may be enforced by attachment of the property of the corporation, or with the leave of the court by detention of the directors or other principal officers or by both, attachment and detention.
28. Sub-rule (3) provides for sale of attached property and payment of the sale-proceeds to the decree-holder where the attachment remains in force for six months and the judgment-debtor fails to obey the decree.
29. Sub-rule (4) deals with cases where the judgment-debtor obeys the decree or the decree-holder commits default.
30. Sub-rule (5) empowers the executing court to take appropriate action for enforcing the decree at the cost of the judgment-debtor who wilfully disobeys such decree.
31. The Explanation clarifies that the expression “the act required to be done” covers prohibitory as also mandatory injunctions.
32. Order XXI Rule 11-A of the Code reads thus:- “11-A. Application for arrest to state grounds.—Where an application is made for the arrest and detention in prison of the judgment-debtor, it shall state, or be accompanied by an affidavit stating, the grounds on which arrest is applied for.”
33. The proviso to Section 51, as inserted by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1936 (Act 21 of 1936) limited the grounds on which a judgment-debtor could be arrested or detained.
34. The Law Commission considered the amendment of 1936 and stated:- [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1619Bhudev Mallick Alias Bhudeb Mallick & Anr. v. Ranajit Ghoshal & Ors.
“This is new. Since Section 51, proviso, now limits the grounds on which a judgment-debtor can be arrested (after the 1936 amendment), it is desirable to provide that the application under Order XXI, Rule 11 should state the grounds on which arrest is sought for. This will assist the court in taking action under Order XXI, Rule 37 (notice to show cause), and also further proceedings under Order XXI, Rule 40. It has been held that the existence of the circumstances mentioned in Section 51, proviso (a) to (c) should be alleged either in the execution application or in an accompanying affidavit. Unless such a circumstance is alleged (it was pointed out), the court cannot think of the circumstances and, in its absence, the court cannot take action under XXI, Rule 37.”
35. Rule 11-A states that where an application is made for the arrest and detention of the judgment-debtor, it must state or accompanied by an affidavit - specifying the grounds on which arrest is sought. Rule 11-A of Order 21 is in conformity with the substantive provisions of proviso to Section 51 of the Code. Stating of grounds or filing of affidavit is essential. The provision is thus mandatory and unless it is complied with, no arrest or detention of the judgment-debtor can be ordered. But if the requisite affidavit is not filed by the decree-holder, the court should afford an opportunity to him to file such affidavit.
36. It is well settled that a decree of permanent injunction is executable with the aid of the provisions contained in Order XXI Rule 32 of the Code referred to above, and any act in violation or breach of decree of permanent injunction is a continuing disobedience entailing penal consequences.
37. In Jai Dayal And Others v. Krishan Lal Garg and Another reported in (1996) 11 SCC 588, this Court considered the effect of decree of permanent injunction as well as the scope of provisions of Order 21 Rule 32 of the Code and held as under:- “6. It is contended that the High Court has proceeded on the premise that the rights of parties are required to be adjudicated under Section 22 of the Easements Act. The view of the High Court is clearly in error. It is seen that once the decree of perpetual injunction and mandatory 1620 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports injunction has become final, the judgment-debtor is required to obey the decree. In whatever form he obstructs, it is liable to removal for violation and the natural consequence is the execution proceedings under Order XXI, Rule 32, CPC which reads as under:
“32.(3) Where any attachment under sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2) has remained in force for six months if the judgment-debtor has not obeyed the decree, if the decree-holder has applied to have the attached property sold, such property may be sold; out of the proceeds the Court may award to the decreeholder such compensation as it thinks fit, and shall pay the balance, if any, to the judgment-debtor on his application.
(4) Where the judgment-debtor has obeyed the decree and paid all costs of executing the same which he is bound to pay, or where, at the end of six months from the date of the attachment, no application to have the property sold has been made, or if made has been refused, the attachment shall cease.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.