Shyamsundar Radheshyam Agrawal & Anr. v. Pushpabai Nilkanth Patil & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 730; [2024] 9 S.C.R. 881
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 24 Sept 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 10804/2024
- Sections
- 4, 17, 53A, 4(2), 53, 4(1), 32, 2, 11, 3, 34
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 881 : 2024 INSC 730 Shyamsundar Radheshyam Agrawal & Anr.
v.
Pushpabai Nilkanth Patil & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 10804 of 2024)
24 September 2024 [Pankaj Mithal and R. Mahadevan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appellants are liable to pay stamp duty and penalty on the agreements to sell executed prior to the sale deed executed in their favour.
Headnotes† Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958 – s.4 and Explanation 1 to Article 25 of Schedule I – Registration Act, 1908 – s.17 – Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – s.53A – Appellants instituted a suit seeking declaration and injunction – Defendant No.46 took out an application u/ss. 33, 34 & 37 of the 1958 Act r/w. s.17 of the Registration Act, to impound the six original agreements for sale viz., Exh.145/3 dated 20.07.1994, Exh.145/9 dated 20.07.1994, Exh.145/15 dated 12.10.1994, Exh.145/19 dated 12.10.1994, Exh.145/23 dated 27.04.2006 and Exh.145/25 dated 19.09.2004 produced by the appellants, so as to get them registered, on the premise that the said documents include a clause that the physical possession of the properties mentioned therein, was transferred to the purchasers; however, they were not duly stamped; and hence, the documents require the payment of stamp duty of the conveyance – Correctness: Held: In the instant case, in the documents, though there was a clause for conveyance between the vendors and purchasers in relation to the respective properties, the value of the properties were above Rs.100/- and there was also a clause by which possession was admittedly handed over on the date of the agreement, implying acquisition of possessory rights protected under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, which requires payment of proper stamp duty and registration as mandated under Section 17 of the Registration Act – Further, as per Section 4(2) of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, the parties are at liberty to determine as to which * Author 882 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of the document shall be principal document – As noted, the agreement for sale consists of a clause whereby the possession was handed over to the purchaser satisfying the requirement to treat the instrument as conveyance and what remained was only the formality of execution of the sale deed – Therefore, it can be safely concluded that the agreement for sale was the principal document on which stamp duty was to be paid as per Article 25 – Even considering the contention of the appellant, that the sale agreements ultimately concluded in the sale deed on which stamp duty was paid, would not by ipso facto absolve the primary liability of paying the appropriate stamp duty at the time of execution of the sale agreement as it was the principal document – Therefore, this Court is of the opinion that Section 4 of the Act cannot come to the aid of the appellants – Therefore, all these six documents ought to have been necessarily stamped and registered. [Para 14] Case Law Cited Veena Hasmukh Jain v. State of Maharashtra [1999] 1 SCR 302 : (1999) 5 SCC 725 : 1999 SCC Online SC 78 – relied on. List of Acts Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958; Registration Act, 1908; Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
List of Keywords Stamp Duty; Penalty; Agreement to sell; Physical possession of properties; Conveyance; Sale deed; Section 4 of Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958; Section 17 of Registration Act, 1908; Section 53 A of Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 10804 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 03.03.2021 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WP No. 4695 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Rohan Thawani, C. George Thomas, Ansh Mittal, Advs. for the Appellants.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 883Shyamsundar Radheshyam Agrawal & Anr. v. Pushpabai Nilkanth Patil & O rs Abdul Azeem Kalebudde, Dr. Rajiv Masodkar, Satyajeet Kumar, Anand Dilip Landge, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Adarsh Dubey, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment R. Mahadevan, J.
Leave granted.
2. This appeal is filed assailing the final order dated 03.03.2021 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay (hereinafter shortly referred to as “the High Court”) in Writ Petition No.4695 of 2017, by which, the High Court has dismissed the said writ petition, thereby affirming the order dated 26.10.2016 passed by the Court of 4th Joint Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thane, (hereinafter shortly referred to as “the trial Court”) in allowing the application filed by the Defendant No.46 for impounding the six documents produced by the appellants herein.
3. Originally, the appellants instituted a suit in Special Civil Suit No.200 of 2008 seeking declaration and injunction. Denying the plaint averments, the defendants filed their written statements. Thereafter, the Defendant No.46 took out an application under Sections 33, 34 & 37 of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958 r/w Section 17 of the Registration Act, to impound the six original agreements for sale viz., Exh.145/3 dated 20.07.1994, Exh.145/9 dated 20.07.1994, Exh.145/15 dated 12.10.1994, Exh.145/19 dated 12.10.1994, Exh.145/23 dated 27.04.2006 and Exh.145/25 dated 19.09.2004 produced by the appellants, so as to get them registered, on the premise that the said documents include a clause that the physical possession of the properties mentioned therein, was transferred to the purchasers; however, they were not duly stamped; and hence, the documents require the payment of stamp duty of the conveyance. By order dated 26.10.2016, the trial Court allowed the said application, thereby impounding the documents and directing to send the same to the Collector of Stamp, Thane, for adjudication of stamp duty and penalty, if any, payable by the appellants. Aggrieved by the same, 884 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the appellants herein filed the aforesaid writ petition, which was dismissed by the High Court, by the order impugned in this appeal.
4. Referring to Section 4 of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958 (hereinafter shortly referred to as “the Act”), the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants contended that the agreements to sell in relation to the same immovable properties ultimately resulted into a sale deed in favour of the appellants and the said sale deed was also duly registered, upon payment of the required stamp duty and therefore, the prior agreements to sell are not required to be registered and stamped. Further, one of the agreements in respect of 2.550 sq. meters of land was executed in favour of Mira Bhayandar Municipal Corporation and hence, no separate stamp duty is required to be paid by the appellants. However, misinterpreting the said provision, the trial Court allowed the application filed for impounding the documents and directed to send the same to the Collector for adjudication of stamp duty and penalty, which was also erroneously affirmed by the High Court.
5. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents submitted that on a detailed analysis of the agreements to sell, wherein, there was a specific clause about the transfer of physical possession to the purchasers therein, the courts below have rightly allowed the application filed for impounding these documents and, therefore, the same need not be interfered with by this Court.
6. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties and perused the material on record, more particularly, the documents in question.
7. The issue involved herein is, whether the appellants are liable to pay stamp duty and penalty on the agreements to sell executed prior to the sale deed executed in their favour, in respect of two properties viz., (i) S.No.165/4 admeasuring 2,550 sq. mtrs. and (ii) S.No.208/3 admeasuring 860 sq. mtrs. and S.No.208/4 admeasuring, 5650 sq. mtrs.
8. In order to determine the stamp duty that is chargeable upon an instrument, the legal rule is that the real and true meaning of the instrument is to be determined by ascertaining the intention of the parties from the contents and the language employed in the whole [2024] 9 S.C.R. 885Shyamsundar Radheshyam Agrawal & Anr. v. Pushpabai Nilkanth Patil & O rs instrument and the description or the nomenclature given to the instrument by the parties is immaterial.
9. According to the appellants, the sale deed having been executed in relation to the same immovable properties and stamp duty having been paid, the earlier agreements to sell which are part and parcel of the same transaction, got merged with the said sale deed and hence, separate stamp duty is not required to be paid on the earlier agreements to sell. To buttress the same, reliance was placed on Section 4 of the Act, which is quoted below for ready reference: “4. Several Instruments used in single transaction of development agreement, sale, mortgage or settlement:
1) Where, in the case of any development agreement, sale, mortgage or settlement, several instruments are employed for completing the transaction, the principal instrument only shall be chargeable with the duty prescribed in Schedule – I for the conveyance, development agreement, mortgage or settlement, and each of the other instruments shall be chargeable with a duty of one hundred rupees instead of the duty (if any) prescribed for it in that Schedule. 2) The parties may determine for themselves which of the instruments so employed shall, for the purposes of sub-section (1), be deemed to be the principal instrument. 3) If the parties fail to determine the principal instrument between themselves, then the officer before whom the instrument is produced may, for the purpose of this section, determine the principal instrument:
Provided that the duty chargeable on the instrument so determined shall be the highest duty which would be chargeable in respect of any of the said instruments employed.”
10. The aforesaid provision, especially, Section 4(1), makes it clear that where several instruments are executed for completing a transaction, the principal instrument alone shall be chargeable with duty prescribed in Schedule I. The proviso makes it clear that the duty chargeable on the instrument so determined shall be the highest duty which could be chargeable in respect of any of the said instruments forming part of the same transaction. Each of the other instruments is chargeable 886 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports with a fixed duty. That apart, sub-section (2) also gives an opportunity to the parties to determine for themselves, which of the instruments shall be deemed to be the principal instrument. We shall therefore look into the documents in question and determine whether they are required to be stamped and registered.
11. The documents sought to be impounded at the instance of one of the defendants are:
(i) Exh.145/3 dated 20.07.1994 – agreement for sale-cumdevelopment executed by Vinayak Kashinath Gharat and others in favour of Naresh N. Jain, Sunita P. Jain and Kalawati N. Jain, which is on the stamp paper of Rs.20/-;
(ii) Exh.145/9 dated 20.07.1994 – agreement for sale-cumdevelopment executed by Vinayak Kashinath Gharat and others in favour of Naresh N. Jain, Sunita P. Jain and Kalawati N. Jain, which is on the stamp paper of Rs.20/-;
(iii) Exh.145/15 dated 12.10.1994 executed by Naresh N. Jain and others in favour of M/s.Chedda Enterprises, which is on the stamp paper of Rs.20/-;
(iv) Exh.145/19 dated 12.10.1994 – agreement for sale-cumdevelopment executed by Naresh N. Jain and others in favour of M/s.Chedda Enterprises, which is on the stamp paper of Rs.20/-;
(v) Exh.145/23 dated 27.04.2006 – agreement for sale executed by M/s.Sunshine Builders and Developers in favour of the appellants, which is on the stamp paper of Rs.100/-; and
(vi) Exh.145/25 dated 19.09.2004 – agreement for development -cum- sale executed by M/s.Sunshine Builders and Developers in favour of the appellants, which is on the stamp paper of Rs.100/-.
12. On a reading of all these six documents, it could be seen that the instruments /documents were not forming part of a single transaction between the same parties and they were different transactions between different vendors and purchasers. Further, for several documents to form part of a single transaction, there must be a transaction in furtherance of which several other documents are executed to complete that transaction and then it becomes imperative [2024] 9 S.C.R. 887Shyamsundar Radheshyam Agrawal & Anr. v. Pushpabai Nilkanth Patil & O rs to charge stamp duty on the principal instrument/document. The language used in the provision is very clear, whereby the stamp duty is on the instrument and not on the transaction. It will be useful to refer to Explanation 1 to Article 25 of Schedule I of the Maharashtra Stamp Act, which would read as under:
“Explanation I.—For the purposes of this article, where in the case of agreement to sell an immovable property, the possession of any immovable property is transferred or agreed to be transferred to the purchaser before the execution, or at the time of execution, or after the execution of such agreement without executing the conveyance in respect thereof, then such agreement to sell shall be deemed to be a conveyance and stamp duty thereon shall be leviable accordingly:
Provided that, the provisions of Section 32-A shall apply mutatis mutandis to such agreement which is deemed to be a conveyance as aforesaid, as they apply to a conveyance under that Section:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.