Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 503; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 640
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 10 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2845/2024
- Sections
- 7, 13(1), 13(2), 313, 20, 164
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 640 : 2024 INSC 503 Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v.
The State of A.P.
(Criminal Appeal No. 2845 of 2024)
10 July 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The question arose whether the prosecution was able to prove beyond all manner of doubt the fact that the appellant demanded and accepted bribe from the complainant; and whether the courts below were justified in convicting and sentencing the appellant for offence punishable u/ss.7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, for the demand and acceptance of illegal gratification.
Headnotes† Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 – ss. 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) – Demand and acceptance of illegal gratification – Prosecution case that the the appellant-Forest Section Officer and the co-accused-Forest guard demanded and accepted bribe from the complainant who operated a sawmill – Complaint filed by the complainant to the DySP, alleging that the flying squad led by the appellant imposed a fine of Rs.50,000/- on his saw mill in relation to the recovery of illegal and unlicensed teakwood in the saw-mill – Next week, the appellant and the Forest guard again demanded a monthly amount of Rs.5,000/- to refrain from taking any further action on the saw-mill – DySP organized the pre-trap proceedings, wherein the appellant demanded and accepted the bribe amount from the complainant – Conviction and sentence of the appellant and the co-accused u/ss. 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) by the trial court – High Court acquitted the co-accused whereas upheld the order as regards the appellant – Correctness: Held: Grave suspicion on the prosecution case that the appellant demanded the bribe money from the complainant – Prosecution miserably failed to prove the factum of demand of bribe against the appellant by reliable direct or circumstantial evidence – Allegation regarding acceptance of bribe by the appellant is primarily based * Author [2024] 7 S.C.R. 641Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P. on the evidence of the complainant, PW-2 and DySP whereas the complainant and PW-2 being close friends, it can safely be assumed that PW-2 was an interested witness – No satisfactory evidence on record to establish that the appellant had actually handled the tainted currency notes as claimed by the complainant – No justification for the DySP to have straight away register the FIR on the mere ipse dixit of the complainant and to have planned the trap proceedings without the minimum endeavour to verify the background facts leading to the alleged demand of bribe – Prudent and unbiased police officer would be persuaded to make at least a basic enquiry into these facts rather than following the dictat of the complainant – Furthermore, PW-2 was the only witness associated by the DySP to accompany the complainant for witnessing the transaction of demand and acceptance of bribe – PW-2 was kept as a shadow witness in the case – DySP did not make any effort whatsoever to associate an independent person to act as a shadow witness in the trap proceedings – Also call detail records completely demolish the complainant’s case – Manner in which the worker in the saw mill was associated as a panch witness in the trap proceedings, creates a grave doubt that the entire case was orchestrated against the appellant at the instance of the worker – Prosecution case full of embellishments contradicting and doubting and thus, would not be safe to convict the appellant for having demanded and accepted the bribe money from the complainant – Prosecution failed to bring home the charges against the appellant by leading evidence of an unimpeachable character – Appellant to be acquitted of the charges – Impugned judgments quashed and set aside. [Paras 48, 52-57] Case Law Cited Neeraj Dutta v. State (Government of NCT of Delhi) [2023] 2 SCR 997 : (2023) 4 SCC 731 – referred to.
List of Acts Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Demand and acceptance of bribe; Conviction and sentence for offence punishable u/ss. 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) of the PC Act, 1988; Pre-trap proceedings; Trap Laying Officer; Interested witness; Tainted currency notes.
642 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.2845 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 02.08.2022 of the High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad in CRLA No.1036 of 2008 Appearances for Parties Dama Sheshadri Naidu, Sr. Adv., Hitesh Singh, Ms. Nisha, Ms. Tanvi Munjal, Sunil Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant.
Kumar Vaibhav, Ms. Devina Sehgal, Advs. for the Respondent. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal by special leave filed on behalf of the appellant lays a challenge to the judgment dated 2nd August, 2022 passed by the High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad in Criminal Appeal No.1036 of 2008, whereby the appeal preferred by the appellant was dismissed and the judgement dated 5 th August, 2008 passed by the learned Additional Special Judge for SPE and ACB Cases, City Civil Court, Hyderabad (hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’) was affirmed. By the said judgment, the appellant herein i.e., Accused Officer No.1 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘AO1’) and Accused Officer No.2 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘AO2’) were convicted and sentenced as below:i) Offence punishable under Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘PC Act’): Rigorous Imprisonment of one year and a fine of Rs.1,000/- each (in default, simple imprisonment for three months)
ii) Offence punishable under Section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of PC Act: Rigorous Imprisonment of one year and a fine of Rs. 1,000/- each (in default, simple imprisonment for three months) Both the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 643Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P.
3. In appeal, the High Court overturned the conviction of AO2 and affirmed the conviction of the appellant (AO1) herein.
4. The case of the prosecution in a nutshell is that the appellant (AO1) being the Forest Section Officer and co-accused (AO2-N. Hanumanthu) (since acquitted) being the Forest Guard were both part of the Flying Squad of the Forest Department. On 6 th January, 2003, the appellant (AO1) and AO2 had gone to a saw-mill at Vanasthalipuram, purportedly operated by the complainant Mukka Ramesh (hereinafter being referred to as ‘PW-1’), which was taken on lease in the name of PW-1’s wife from one Sri E. Ramachary. During their visit, the appellant (AO1) and AO2 detected teakwood lying in the saw-mill. It is alleged that both the accused (AO1 and AO2), threatened PW-1 that he would be booked in a case for the illegal and unlicensed possession of teakwood in the saw-mill. It is further alleged that on the plea of PW-1, the appellant (AO1) booked a case against one M. Ashok, a worker in the saw-mill and not against PW-1 and thereafter, a compounding fee of Rs.50,000/- was charged, by issuing a receipt (Exhibit P-2) in the name of M. Ashok.
5. It is further alleged that after their visit on 6th January, 2023, the appellant (AO1) and AO2 started demanding mamool (monthly gratification) to the tune of Rs.5,000/- from the PW-1 under a threat that they would book a case against him and in that manner his business would be ruined. Threatening calls were allegedly made to PW-1 on a regular basis. On 21st January, 2003, AO2 called PW-1 and asked him to keep the mamool money ready with further instruction that he would make a call and give directions for delivery of the said bribe. On 22nd January, 2003, the appellant (AO1) called PW-1 and asked him to reach Hotel Quality-Inn Residency, Nampally (hereinafter being referred to as ‘Hotel Quality-Inn’), on early morning of 23rd January, 2003 with the demanded mamool amount of Rs. 5,000/-. Disinclined to pay the bribe, PW-1 lodged a complaint (Exhibit P-1) on 22 nd January, 2003 with Shri G. Ramachander, Deputy Superintendent of Police, ACB (hereinafter being referred to as ‘DySP’)(PW-10) and a crime report was registered thereupon. The trap was arranged on 23rd January, 2003. The complainant (PW-1), along with his friend Potagunta Ramesh Naidu (hereinafter being referred to as ‘PW-2’) reached the ACB office with the currency notes to the tune of Rs.5,000/being the bribe amount. Two independent witnesses, namely, Kathi Srinivas Rao (PW-3) and Md. Mahmood Ali were summoned to act 644 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports as mediators (panchas). At 9:45 am, the trap party conducted the pretrap proceedings which were recorded in the memorandum (Exhibit P-4). After completing the pre-trap proceedings, the trap party, under the leadership of DySP (PW-10) proceeded to the Hotel Quality-Inn at 10:30 am. The complainant (PW-1) and PW-2 entered the Hotel and met the appellant (AO1) in the coffee shop of the said Hotel. It is further alleged that the complainant (PW-1) offered the bribe amount to the appellant (AO1) at the coffee shop, who showed reluctance to accept the same and asked them to follow him into the cellar of the hotel. The DySP and the other trap party members followed them from a distance. After reaching the cellar, the appellant (AO1) demanded and accepted the bribe amount from the complainant (PW-1) and pushed it down into the rexine bag which he was carrying. The prosecution claims that the above sequence of events which transpired between the appellant (AO1) and the complainant (PW-1) in presence of PW-2 was also visible to the trap party which was waiting in the hotel lobby, however, they could not overhear the conversation.
6. At about 11:25 am, PW-2 came out of the cellar and gave the prearranged signal upon which, the trap party proceeded towards the appellant (AO1). The DySP (PW-10) questioned him about having accepted the bribe amount. The complainant (PW-1) immediately informed the DySP(PW-10) that the appellant (AO1) had demanded and accepted the bribe amount of Rs.5,000/- from him and had placed the same in a rexine bag. The hands of the appellant (AO1) were rinsed in sodium carbonate solution. The wash of the fingers of his right hand turned pink. The appellant (AO1), upon being questioned about having accepted the bribe, stated with trepidation that he had accepted the said amount towards compounding fee and opened the rexine bag which he was carrying. The mediator, Kathi Srinivas (PW-3) took out the currency notes from the rexine bag being held by the appellant (AO1) and on verification, numbers of the notes tallied with the numbers of the currency notes submitted by the complainant (PW-1) at the time of the pre-trap proceedings. The bribe amount and a diary along with the rexine bag held by the appellant (AO1) were seized. The diary too was tested for presence of phenolphthalein because it had also come into contact of the tainted currency notes which was kept in the bag. A money-receipt book was also seized (via memorandum (Exhibit P-6)). The post-trap proceedings were recorded in the memorandum (Exhibit P-11).
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 645Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P.
7. The prosecution sanction was procured and upon concluding the investigation, charge sheet came to be filed against the appellant (AO1) and AO2 in the Court of learned Additional Special Judge for SPE and ACB Cases, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. The learned trial Court framed charges against the appellant (AO1) and AO2 for the offences punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the PC Act. They denied the charges and claimed trial. The prosecution examined as many as 11 witnesses and exhibited 19 documents and 8 material objects in order to prove its case. The accused (AO1 and AO2) upon being questioned under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred as ‘CrPC’) and when confronted with the allegations as appearing in the prosecution evidence, denied the same and claimed to be innocent.
8. The appellant (AO1) categorically stated in his statement under Section 313 CrPC, that while he and the complainant (PW-1) were having coffee in the hotel, he inadvertently left his rexine bag behind at the coffee shop. He conjectured that the complainant (PW-1) might have planted the tainted currency notes in his rexine bag without his knowledge because he was aggrieved by the fine of Rs.50,000/- imposed upon M. Ashok (employee of the saw-mill) by the appellant (AO1) earlier.
9. Upon hearing the arguments of the learned defence counsel and the learned Special Public Prosecutor and after evaluating the evidence available on record, the trial Court proceeded to convict and sentence the appellant (AO1) and AO2 as above vide judgment dated 5th August, 2008.
10. The said judgment was assailed by both the accused by filing separate appeals before the High Court of Telangana. The appeal preferred by AO2 was accepted whereas, the appeal preferred by the appellant (AO1) was rejected by judgment dated 2 nd August, 2022 which is subjected to challenge in this appeal by special leave. Submissions on behalf of the appellant: -
11. Shri Dama Sheshadri Naidu, learned senior counsel representing the appellant, vehemently and fervently contended that the entire prosecution case is false and fabricated. No convincing evidence was led by the prosecution to prove the factum of demand of bribe by the AO1 (appellant). G.Ramachander (PW-10) DySP, who was 646 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports also the Trap Laying Officer (hereinafter being referred to as ‘TLO’) did not make any effort to get the factum of demand of bribe verified by means of any independent or tangible evidence.
12. Shri Naidu submitted that the prosecution failed to prove that the appellant (AO1) had ever demanded any bribe from the complainant (PW-1) because neither did the TLO (PW-10) make any endeavour to get the telephonic conversation between the complainant (PW-1) and the appellant (AO1) recorded nor did he make any attempt to place a recording device on the person of the complainant (PW-1) during the trap proceeding so as to verify the factum of demand of bribe. Furthermore, other than the interested witness i.e., PW-2, no independent witness was directed by the TLO to overhear the conversation which took place between the complainant (PW-1) and the appellant (AO1) on the day of the trap.
13. Shri Naidu urged that even the allegation of acceptance of illegal gratification by the appellant (AO1) is surrounded in a cloud of dubiety. In order to buttress these submissions, Shri Naidu drew the attention of the Court to the following admissions as appearing in the cross-examination of the complainant, Mukka Ramesh (PW-1): - “We ordered coffee took ½ an hour for servicing. I removed the amount and about to give the amount to the AO. I did not give it to his hand. The accused refused and asked me to come downstairs. After ordering coffee the coffee being served we 3 took coffee. The Accused No.1 started to going out and we follow the accused at that time I kept the amount in my pocket and while going out from coffee inn the amount was with me. We have to get down the same ramp by 50ft. We have to take turns After the accused 1 going out I found the bag of him in the hotel 1 picked it up I handed over the bag to the accused 1 after crossing 2 tables in the hotel. A1 was going to since I paid the bill of the hotel I was to little bit late to follow AO.1. We have to again pass the ramp down the cellar by about 50ft. Where there are two different stands for parking motor cycles and four wheelers. The generators are situated near to the parking stand of two wheelers. The accused came on two wheeler I asked the accused 1 to show the papers.
He showed the papers to me. It is not true to suggest that [2024] 7 S.C.R. 647Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P. after accused showing the papers to me I snatched them and myself and Pw2 turned them and throw them away. It is not true to suggest that I paid the money to the Accused 1 near the generator and the accused asked me to put it in bag is false. It is not true to suggest I kept the tainted amount in the rexyne bag which was left by the accused before leaving coffee inn and I planted the currency notes in the bag and handed over it to him and the accused has no knowledge the tainted amount was in the rexyne bag.
It is not true to suggest that myself and Pw2 used our influence to ACB to organize the false trap against Alas AO.1 insisted of filing case against my wife, Manjula. It is not true to suggest that the AO1 and 2 did not telephone me and my statement is false.”
(emphasis supplied)
14. Referring to the above admissions as appearing in the testimony of the complainant (PW-1), Shri Naidu contended that it is clear that the appellant (AO1) had forgotten his rexine bag in the coffee shop from which the tainted currency notes were recovered later by the trap party, and it was the complainant (PW-1) who handed over the same rexine bag to the appellant (AO1). Shri Naidu urged that fuelled by ulterior motive, the complainant (PW-1) misused this window of opportunity to plant the tainted currency notes in the bag of the appellant (AO1).
15. Learned counsel also urged that the prosecution did not take any steps to get the wash collected from the hands of the appellant (AO1) during the trap proceedings, tested through the FSL and thus, there is no corroborative evidence to show that the appellant (AO1) had accepted or handled the tainted currency notes as alleged by prosecution.
16. Shri Naidu further contended that the trial Court as well as the High Court rendered the findings of guilt against the appellant (AO1) merely on the basis of assumptions and presumptions drawn from the tainted and vacillating deposition of the complainant (PW-1) and PW-2, who was admittedly a close friend of the complainant (PW-1) and thus, he can be categorized as being an interested witness.
17. Learned counsel also urged that the TLO (PW-10) was under an obligation to send an independent shadow witness with the 648 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports complainant (PW-1) and PW-2 to oversee and overhear the events as they unfolded during the course of the transaction of demand and acceptance of the bribe. Admittedly, neither the mediators nor any other witness associated in the trap proceedings heard the conversation which took place between the AO1 (appellant), the complainant (PW-1) and PW-2, despite the positive case that they all were sitting on the nearby table. It was the complainant (PW-1) who voluntarily took his friend, PW-2, and got him associated during the trap proceeding. As per Shri Naidu, this was a clear attempt by the complainant (PW-1) in connivance with the TLO (PW-10) to create evidence through a partisan witness acting and hence, the prosecution is guilty of deliberately associating an interested witness so as to fortify the alleged transaction of demand and acceptance of bribe.
18. Shri Naidu urged that the High Court cursorily brushed aside the crucial admission as appearing in the cross-examination of the complainant (PW-1)(reproduced supra) that the rexine bag of the appellant (AO1) from which the tainted currency notes were recovered had been handled by the complainant (PW-1), by observing that this was an afterthought. As per Shri Naidu, the said vital admission was spontaneously elicited during the cross-examination conducted from the complainant (PW-1) and thus, it cannot be ignored as being an afterthought. He contended that the prosecution consciously chose not to re-examine the complainant (PW-1) on this aspect of his testimony and thus, the defence cannot be denied to the benefit thereof.
19. Shri Naidu, further contended that no calls were made by the appellant (AO1) to the complainant (PW-1) proximate to the date of the trap. He drew the attention of the Court to the call detail records (CDR) of the appellant (AO1) and the complainant (PW-1) and urged that only two calls were exchanged between the appellant (AO1) and the complainant (PW-1), one being on 8th January, 2003 and the other on 17 th January, 2003 and hence, the allegation made by the complainant (PW-1) in the FIR and in his deposition, that the appellant (AO1) called him on 21 st January, 2003, 22 nd January, 2003 and 23 rd January, 2003 in connection with demand of bribe is falsified, creating a grave doubt on the veracity of the entire prosecution case.
20. Attention of the Court was also drawn to the pertinent admission made by the complainant (PW-1) in his testimony that while they were having coffee in the coffee shop of the Hotel Quality-Inn, he [2024] 7 S.C.R. 649Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P. took out the bribe amount and offered it to the appellant (AO1) who refused to accept the same. Shri Naidu thus, urged that it is crystal clear that the prosecution miserably failed to prove that the appellant (AO1) demanded or accepted any bribe amount from the complainant (PW-1).
21. On these grounds, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant implored the Court to accept the appeal, set aside the impugned judgments and direct acquittal of the appellant (AO1) from the charges. Submission on behalf of the respondent-State: -
22. Per contra, learned standing counsel appearing for the State, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant (AO1). He contended that the appellant (AO1) being the Forest Section Officer firstly, imposed an unwarranted fine amount of Rs.50,000/- on the saw-mill of the complainant (PW-1). Thereafter, extending a threat of repeated action thereby harming the business of the complainant (PW-1), the appellant (AO1), demanded a monthly amount of Rs.5,000/- as bribe (mamool) from the complainant (PW-1) which fact is duly corroborated from the evidence of the complainant (PW-1) and PW-2.
23. He urged that at the time of preparation of the memorandum of the post-trap proceedings (Exhibit P-11), the appellant (AO1) admitted that he had received the amount from the complainant (PW-1), offering a far-fetched explanation that the same was received as compounding fee in a case whereas, no such case was pending. It was thus, contended that this admission made by the appellant (AO1) can be read against him. The subsequent plea set up by the appellant (AO1) that the currency notes were planted by the complainant (PW-1) himself in his rexine bag without his knowledge is unacceptable on the face of record and that such frivolous defence plea was rightly discarded by the trial Court and the High Court.
24. He further urged that the appellant (AO1), having failed to offer a plausible explanation regarding the tainted currency notes found from the rexine bag in his possession and so also to the presence of phenolphthalein on the fingers of his right hand, was rightly convicted by the trial Court and his conviction was justifiably affirmed by the High Court. He thus, implored the Court to dismiss the appeal and affirm the impugned judgments.
650 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Discussion and Conclusion: -
25. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have perused the impugned judgments. With the assistance of learned counsel for the parties, we have thoroughly examined the evidence available on record.
26. Since fervent arguments were raised on behalf of the parties on the aspect of demand of bribe, it would be useful to recapitulate the relevant position of law on the use of circumstantial evidence to prove demand of illegal gratification.
27. A Constitution Bench of this Court in the case of Neeraj Dutta v. State (Government of NCT of Delhi),1 was called upon to answer a reference on the question as to whether the circumstantial evidence can be relied upon to prove the demand of illegal gratification and whether in the absence of evidence of the complainant direct/primary, oral or documentary, would it be permissible to draw an inferential deduction of culpability/guilt of a public servant under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Act based on other evidence adduced by the prosecution. This Constitution Bench traversed the entire history of the judicial pronouncements on the issue and held as below: - “88. What emerges from the aforesaid discussion is summarised as under:
88.1. (a) Proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification by a public servant as a fact in issue by the prosecution is a sine qua non in order to establish the guilt of the accused public servant under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) of the Act.
88.2. (b) In order to bring home the guilt of the accused, the prosecution has to first prove the demand of illegal gratification and the subsequent acceptance as a matter of fact. This fact in issue can be proved either by direct evidence which can be in the nature of oral evidence or documentary evidence.
1 [2023] 2 SCR 997 : (2023) 4 SCC 731 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 651Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P.
88.3. (c) Further, the fact in issue, namely, the proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification can also be proved by circumstantial evidence in the absence of direct oral and documentary evidence.
88.4. (d) In order to prove the fact in issue, namely, the demand and acceptance of illegal gratification by the public servant, the following aspects have to be borne in mind:
(i) if there is an offer to pay by the bribe-giver without there being any demand from the public servant and the latter simply accepts the offer and receives the illegal gratification, it is a case of acceptance as per Section 7 of the Act. In such a case, there need not be a prior demand by the public servant.
(ii) On the other hand, if the public servant makes a demand and the bribe-giver accepts the demand and tenders the demanded gratification which in turn is received by the public servant, it is a case of obtainment. In the case of obtainment, the prior demand for illegal gratification emanates from the public servant. This is an offence under Sections 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) of the Act.
(iii) In both cases of (i) and (ii) above, the offer by the bribe-giver and the demand by the public servant respectively have to be proved by the prosecution as a fact in issue. In other words, mere acceptance or receipt of an illegal gratification without anything more would not make it an offence under Section 7 or Sections 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii), respectively of the Act.
Therefore, under Section 7 of the Act, in order to bring home the offence, there must be an offer which emanates from the bribe-giver which is accepted by the public servant which would make it an offence. Similarly, a prior demand by the public servant when accepted by the bribe-giver and in turn there is a payment made 652 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports which is received by the public servant, would be an offence of obtainment under Sections 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) of the Act.
88.5. (e) The presumption of fact with regard to the demand and acceptance or obtainment of an illegal gratification may be made by a court of law by way of an inference only when the foundational facts have been proved by relevant oral and documentary evidence and not in the absence thereof. On the basis of the material on record, the court has the discretion to raise a presumption of fact while considering whether the fact of demand has been proved by the prosecution or not. Of course, a presumption of fact is subject to rebuttal by the accused and in the absence of rebuttal presumption stands.
88.6. (f) In the event the complainant turns “hostile”, or has died or is unavailable to let in his evidence during trial, demand of illegal gratification can be proved by letting in the evidence of any other witness who can again let in evidence, either orally or by documentary evidence or the prosecution can prove the case by circumstantial evidence. The trial does not abate nor does it result in an order of acquittal of the accused public servant.
88.7. (g) Insofar as Section 7 of the Act is concerned, on the proof of the facts in issue, Section 20 mandates the court to raise a presumption that the illegal gratification was for the purpose of a motive or reward as mentioned in the said Section. The said presumption has to be raised by the court as a legal presumption or a presumption in law. Of course, the said presumption is also subject to rebuttal. Section 20 does not apply to Sections 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii) of the Act.
88.8. (h) We clarify that the presumption in law under Section 20 of the Act is distinct from presumption of fact referred to above in sub-para 88.5(e), above, as the former is a mandatory presumption while the latter is discretionary in nature.”
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 653Mir Mustafa Ali Hasmi v. The State of A.P.
28. Thus, in addition to answering the primary issue raised in the matter, the Constitution Bench also went on to hold that in order to bring home the guilt of the accused, the prosecution has to prove the demand of illegal gratification and the subsequent acceptance, by either direct or circumstantial evidence.
29. Keeping in view the ratio of the above mentioned decision of the Constitution Bench, we now proceed to discuss the evidence available on record so as to find out whether the prosecution has been able to prove beyond all manner of doubt the fact that the appellant (AO1) demanded and accepted bribe from the complainant (PW-1).
30. First and foremost, we may note that the first allegation of demand as emanating from the prosecution case is reflected from the complaint (Exhibit P-1) submitted by the complainant (PW-1) to the DySP, ACB Department, Hyderabad Range on 22 nd January, 2003, alleging inter alia that a fine of Rs.50,000/- had been imposed on his saw mill by the flying squad led by the appellant (AO1) in relation to the recovery of illegal and unlicensed teakwood in the saw-mill. After a week of this event, the appellant (AO1) and the Forest guard (AO2) again came to the saw-mill and demanded a monthly amount (mamool) of Rs.5,000/- to refrain from taking any further action on the saw-mill. Thus the allegation of demand as emanating from the complaint (Exhibit P-1) is common to both the appellant (AO1) as well as the co-accused (AO2) who stands acquitted by the High Court. The complaint (Exhibit P-1) was lodged on 22 nd January, 2003. The DySP (PW-10) organized the pre-trap proceedings, on the next day i.e. on 23 rd January 2003 without making any attempt to verify the allegation of demand of bribe levelled against the appellant (AO1) by the complainant (PW-1) in the complaint (Exhibit P-1).
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.