Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 465; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 246
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice * Cji and J B Pardiwala, Justice J.]
- Decided
- 8 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7230/2024
- Sections
- 7, 3, 5B(2), 5A, 5, 4, 8, 5B, 377, 2, 3(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 246 : 2024 INSC 465 Nipun Malhotra v.
Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 7230 of 2024)
08 July 2024 [Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud,* CJI and J B Pardiwala, J.] Issue for Consideration The appellant is a person with arthrogryposis and is aggrieved by the manner in which persons with disabilities have been portrayed in the movie titled ‘Aankh Micholi’. The appellant seeks guidelines against filmmakers, regarding the provisions of the Right of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 and the composition of the Board and the Advisory panel under the Cinematograph Act and recommendations to beep certain parts of the present film as well.The issues arises for consideration include the impact of the provisions of RPwD Act 2016 on the certification of films and under the Cinematograph Act.
Headnotes† Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – The appellant seeks recommendations to beep certain parts of the present film as well:
Held: This Court endorses slow interference with the determination of an expert body under the Cinematograph Act, particularly to allow the exhibition of a film – It is for the Board to draw the line between permissible and impermissible portrayal of social ills through visual media, and ensure that the Guidelines are meant to be read as broad standards for the same – The certification in the present case implies that the Board found that the overall message of the film was in accordance with the guidelines and the RPwD Act – This Court is not inclined to interfere with this finding by recommending beeping out parts of the film, especially considering the inclusion of a disclaimer in the film.[Para 72.1] Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Recommendation that Sony Pictures make an awareness film according to Section 7 (d) of the RPwD Act: * Author [2024] 7 S.C.R. 247Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. Held: The recommendation that Sony Pictures make an awareness film according to Section 7 (d) of the RPwD Act cannot be granted – Section 7(d) is directed towards the appropriate government – This Court has underlined that the principle of reasonable accommodation includes positive obligations of private parties to support persons with disabilities and facilitate their full participation, this Court does not agree that Section 7(d) includes such an obligation against private persons – Even otherwise, such a direction would amount to compelled speech – Such compelled speech has been allowed by this Court under Article 19(1) of the Constitution, albeit in a very different context from the present – The recommendation sought in the present case is for creation of a whole different film on the ground of a statutory mandate of spreading awareness which is not even directed towards a private entity such as Sony Pictures – The positive obligation mentioned in Vikash Kumar cannot be so extended to compel speech in the manner suggested by the appellant. [Para 72.2] Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024 – Inclusion of subject matter experts to the Board and advisory panels:
Held: On inclusion of subject matter experts to the Board and advisory panels, this Court believes that the field is sufficiently occupied by the Cinematograph Act and the certification Rules of 1983 and 2024 does not merit interference – Under the 1983 Rules, the Board may take steps to assess public reactions to films – The Examining Committee is supposed to include women as its members – The 1983 Rules and the 2024 Rules envisage consultation with a subject matter expert: the Examining Committee’s final report is forwarded to the Chairperson in 10 days, unless the Committee feels that expert opinion is necessary – In that case, it may submit a provisional report and seek expert opinion before submitting the final report – The 2024 Certification Rules go a step further and provide that a Regional Officer may invite subject matter experts for the examination of the film by the Examination Committee or Revising Committee. [Para 72.3] Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024 – Disparaging portrayal of person with disabilities:
248 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Held: The Board must decide whether a disparaging portrayal stood redeemed by the overall message or not – No doubt this entails a complex balancing of interests – It would be ideal if the statutory bodies included subject matter experts – The 2024 Rules are a welcome acknowledgment of this principle and consultations with subject matter experts on disability would certainly better inform the perspective of the Board – The policy underlying the Act and the Rules already accounts for expert consultation – This Court cannot interfere merely because it could be better or that a better alternative is available, when the legality of such policy is not in question. [Para 72.5] Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024 – The appellant has sought formulation of guidelines to restrict content that contravenes the Constitution and the RPwD Act 2016:
Held: The guidelines under the Act are quite extensive and cover the field – Such directions are issued to fill legislative gaps – If allowed, such guidelines would be akin to reading the provisions of one statute that is, the RPwD Act 2016 into another statute, that is the Cinematograph Act, even though the latter does not suffer from a vacuum on the issue, and the statutory expert body is presumed to have account for the effect of the former anyway – Courts cannot trench into policy-making. [Para 72.6] Constitution of India – Art. 19 – Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983 – Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024 – Provision of a framework of the portrayal of persons with disabilities in visual media that aligns with the anti-discrimination and dignity affirming objectives of the Constitution as well as the RPwD Act – The framework is laid down is in line with findings in Vikash Kumar case where it was emphasised that fundamental rights under Part III of the Constitution apply with equal rigour to persons with disabilities:
Held: The representation of persons with disabilities must regard the objective social context of their representation and not marginalise persons with disability: (i) Words cultivate institutional discrimination – Terms such as “cripple” and “spastic” have come to acquire devalued meanings in societal perceptions about persons [2024] 7 S.C.R. 249Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. with disabilities – They contribute to the negative self-image and perpetuate discriminatory attitudes and practices in society; (ii) Language that individualises the impairment and overlooks the disabling social barriers (e.g. terms such as “afflicted”, “suffering”, and “victim”) should be avoided or adequately flagged as contrary to the social model; (iii) Creators must check for accurate representation of a medical condition as much as possible – The misleading portrayal of what a condition such as night blindness entails may perpetuate misinformation about the condition, and entrench stereotypes about persons with such impairments, aggravating the disability; (iv)Persons with disabilities are underrepresented – Average people are unaware of the barriers persons with disabilities face – Visual media must reflect their lived experiences – Their portrayal must capture the multitudes of their lived realities, and should not be a uni-dimensional, ableist characterisation; (v) Visual media should strive to depict the diverse realities of persons with disabilities, showcasing not only their challenges but also their successes, talents, and contributions to society – This balanced representation can help dispel stereotypes and promote a more inclusive understanding of disability; (vi) They should neither be lampooned based on myths (such as, ‘blind people bump into objects in their path’) nor presented as ‘super cripples’ on the other extreme – This stereotype implies that persons with disabilities have extraordinary heroic abilities that merit their dignified treatment; (vii) Decision-making bodies must bear in mind the values of participation – The ‘nothing about us, without us’ principle is based on the promotion of participation of persons with disabilities and equalisation of opportunities – It must be put to practice in constituting statutory committees and inviting expert opinions for assessing the overall message of films and their impact on dignity of individuals under the Cinematograph Act and Rules; (viii) The CPRD also requires consultation with and involvement of persons with disabilities in the implementation of measures to encourage portrayal that is consistent with it; (ix) Training and sensitization programs should be implemented for individuals involved in creating visual media content, including writers, directors, producers, and actors – These programs should emphasize the impact of their portrayals on public perceptions and the lived experiences of persons with disabilities – Topics should include the principles of the social model of disability, the importance of respectful language, and the need for accurate and empathetic representation. [Para 74] 250 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Disability humour and Disabling humour:
Held: Humour and disabilities are viewed as uneasy companions – This is primarily because of the historical use of humour to mock disability, make jokes at the expense of persons with disabilities and to use them for comic relief – This Court must distinguish ‘disabling humour’ that demeans and disparages persons with disability from ‘disability humour’ which challenges conventional wisdom about disability – While disability humour attempts to better understand and explain disability, disabling humour denigrates it – The two cannot be equated in their impact on dignity and on stereotypes about persons with disabilities. [Para 66] Constitution of India – Art. 19(1)(a) – Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression – Cinematograph Act, an instance of reasonable restriction: Held: A filmmaker’s right to exhibit films is a part of their fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), which is subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2) – The Cinematograph Act is an instance of reasonable restrictions on this right under the ‘decency and morality’ rubric of Article 19(2) – Prior certification under the Act has been regarded as a valid restraint on cinematic speech because of its ‘instant appeal’ and the ability to stir emotions more deeply than other artistic media. [Para 22] Constitution of India – Art. 19(1)(a) and Art. 19(2) – Cinematograph Act, 1952 – Restraints on films – Principles: Held: Restraints on films are founded on principles of due process, social interest, limited application in cases of absolute necessity and clear purpose of the restraint – Among the principles which must be borne in mind when deciding the fitness of a film for public exhibition include the following: (i) Social impact of the film is judged from the perspective of an ordinary person of reasonable intelligence and not a hypersensitive person; (iii) Social change, rather than orthodox notions or what is right and moral must be borne in mind; and (iv) The film must be judged by its overall message and not from isolated depictions of social evils. [Para 25] Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 – Core aim:
Held: The RPwD Act represents a fundamental shift from viewing disability through a charity lens to a human rights perspective – [2024] 7 S.C.R. 251Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. Its core aim is to empower persons with disabilities by upholding their inherent dignity and autonomy – The Act broadly underscores principles of non-discrimination, full and effective participation in society, and the inclusion of all individuals, emphasizing the respect for differences and the acceptance of disabilities as an integral part of human diversity – It enshrines equality of opportunity, accessibility, gender equality, and the recognition of the evolving capacities of children with disabilities, ensuring their right to maintain their identities. [Para 38] Jurisprudence – International Jurisprudence –Persons with disabilities – Discussed.
Jurisprudence – Indian Jurisprudence aligns with the human rights approach – Persons with disabilities – Discussed.
Case Law Cited Bobby Art International v. Om Pal Singh Hoon [1996] Supp. 2 SCR 136 : (1996) 4 SCC 1; Director General, Directorate General of Doordarshan & Ors. v. Anand Patwardhan [2006] Supp. 5 SCR 403 : (2006) 8 SCC 433; S Rangarajan v. P Jagjivan Ram and Ors. [1989] 2 SCR 204 : (1989) 2 SCC 574; Union of India v. KM Shankarappa [2000] 5 Suppl. SCR 117 : (2001) 1 SCC 582; Prakash Jha v. Union of India [2011] 10 SCR 496 : (2011) 8 SCC 372; KA Abbas v. Union of India [1971] 2 SCR 446 : (1970) 2 SCC 780; Ramesh v. Union of India [1988] 2 SCR 1011 : (1988) 1 SCC 668; Nachiketa Walhekar v. Central Board of Film Certification (2018) 1 SCC 778; Anuj Garg v. Hotel Association of India [2007] 12 SCR 991 : (2008) 3 SCC 1; Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India [2018] 7 SCR 379 : (2018) 10 SCC 1; Indian Young Lawyers Association v. State of Kerala [2018] 9 SCR 561 : (2019) 11 SCC 1; Vikash Kumar v. Union Public Service Commission [2021] 12 SCR 311 : (2021) 5 SCC 370; Jeeja Ghosh v. Union of India [2016] 4 SCR 638; Rajive Raturi v. Union of India [2017] 12 SCR 827 : (2018) 2 SCC 413; Ravindra Kumar Dhariwal v. Union of India [2016] 4 SCR 638; Sakal Papers (P) Ltd v. Union of India [1962] 3 SCR 842 : (1962) 3 SCR 842; Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India [1978] 2 SCR 621 : (1978) 1 SCC 248; Indibly Creative Private Limited v. Government of West Bengal [2019] 5 SCR 679 : 2020 12 SCC 436; In Re Noise Pollution [2005] 1 Suppl. SCR 624 : (2005) 5 SCC 733; Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India v. Subash Chandra Agarwal (Civil Appeal No. 10044 252 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of 2010); Union of India v. Motion Pictures Association [1999] 3 SCR 875 : (1999) 6 SCC 150; Raj Kapoor v. State [1980] 1 SCR 1081 : (1980) 1 SCC 43; Directorate of Film Festivals v Gaurav Ashwin Jain [2007] 5 SCR 7 : (2007) 4 SCC 737; Padma Sundara Rao v. State of Tamil Nadu [2002] 2 SCR 383 : (2002) 3 SCC 533; State of Punjab v. Salil Sabhlok [2013] 5 SCR 18 : (2013) 5 SCC 1; P. Ramachandra Rao v. State of Karnataka [2002] 3 SCR 60 : (2002) 4 SCC 578; Census Commissioner v. R Krishnamurthy [2014] 11 SCR 463 : (2015) 2 SCC 796 – referred to.
Glor v. Switzerland 13444/04, para 53; Bacher v. Austria (026/2014), views CRPD/C/19/D/26/2014, para 3.3 – referred to.
F.A. Picture International v. Central Board of Film Certification (2004) SCC OnLine Bom 961 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Madhavi Goradia Divan, Facets of Media Law, Second Edition pg 284-285; Madhavi Divan, ‘Morality, Obscenity and Censorship’, Supreme Court Cases (Journal), Vol 1 (2003), 1– 16; Ronald Dworkin, Foreword, in Hare and Weinstein, eds., Extreme Speech and Democracy, v–ix.as cited in Jeremy Waldron, The Harm in Hate Speech, Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England (2012), Pg 175; John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (Penguin Books, 1982) [99, 106] as cited in Jeremy Waldron, The Harm in Hate Speech, Pgs 194, 197; Colin Barnes, Disabling Imagery and the Media, An Exploration of the Principles for Media Representation of Disabled People, The British Council Of Organisations Of Disabled People, Part Two :Commonly Recurring Media Stereotypes (1992); Angharad E. Beckett, Citizenship and Vulnerability: Disability and Issues of Social and Political Engagement, Palgrave Mamillan (2006); Colin Barnes et al., Exploring Disability. A Sociological Introduction, Cambridge, Polity Press, (1999) Pg 10; Allan Sutherland, Disabled we Stand, London: Souvenir Press (1981); Teresa Milbrodt, Today I Had an Eye Appointment, and I’m Still Blind”: Crip Humor, Storytelling, and Narrative Positioning of the Disabled Self, Disability Studies Quarterly, University of Missouri, Columbia, Volume 38 (2018) [11]; Tom Shakespeare, Joking a part, Body and Society, (1999) Volume 5(4), 47-55 as cited in Kinda Abujbarah, Laughing Back: A Phenomenological Study of Disability Humor Using Culturally Responsive Methodologies (Doctoral Dissertation) (2019); The Handbook for Parliamentarians on the Convention on the Rights of [2024] 7 S.C.R. 253Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. Persons with Disabilities and its Optional Protocol, From Exclusion to Equality: Realizing the rights of persons with disabilities (2007); The UN General Assembly adopted the WPA, and declared at the same time the United Nations Decade of Disabled Persons, 1983- 1992. See also Paul Harpur, ‘From Disability to ability: changing the phrasing of the debate’ (2012) 27 (3) Disability & Society 325, 327; United Nations, Improving Communications about People with Disabilities (Recommendations of a United Nations Seminar, 8-10 June 1982, Vienna), p. 5; Allison Hobgood and David Wood, Disability Humour and the Meanings of Impairment in Early Modern England, Hobgood, Recovering Disability in Early Modern England. The Ohio State University Press, 2013; Shawn Bingham and Sara Green, Aesthetic as Analysis: Synthesizing theories of humor and disability through stand-up comedy, Humanity & Society, Volume 40(3), 1, 6 (2016); 7 Mike Oliver, The social model of disability: Thirty years on, Disability & Society, 28(7), 1024-1026; Teresa Milbrodt, Today I Had an Eye Appointment, and I’m Still Blind”: Crip Humor, Storytelling, and Narrative Positioning of the Disabled Self, Disability Studies Quarterly, University of Missouri – Columbia Vol. 38 No. 2 (2018); Robin Smith and Mara Shapon-Shevin, Disability Humor, Insults, and Inclusive Practice Social Advocacy and Systems Change, 1(2), 2008-2009; “Nothing about Us, Without Us”, International Day of Disabled Persons: Themes and Observances of Previous Years, United Nations (2004) – referred to.
Websites https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/ library/Barnes-disabling-imagery.pdf https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/ library/Sutherland-CHAPTER6.pdf https://dsq-sds.org/index.php/dsq/article/view/6163/4902 https://web.archive.org/web/20200506223854id_/ https:/digitalcommons.chapman.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1 008&context=education_dissertations https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/toolaction/ipuhb.pdf https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/general-comments-andrecommendations/general-comment-no6-equality-and-nondiscrimination 254 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Publications/ Disabilities_training_17EN.pdf https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/30/oa_monograph/chapter/897500 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0160597615621594 h t t p s : / / s i t e s . c o r t l a n d . e d u / s a s c / w p - c o n t e n t / u p l o a d s / sites/12/2012/12/Disability-Humor-Final.pdf h t t p s : / / w w w . u n . o r g / e s a / s o c d e v / e n a b l e / i d d p 2 0 0 4 . htm#:%7E:text=The%20motto%20%E2%80%9CNothing%20 About%20Us,and%20with%20persons%20with%20disabilities List of Acts Constitution of India; Cinematograph Act, 1952; Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016; Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983; Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024.
List of Keywords Article 19(1)(a) of Constitution of India; Article 19(2) of Constitution of India; Section 7 (d) of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016; Persons with disabilities; Impact of the provisions of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 on the certification of films;Principle of reasonable accommodation; Expert on disability; Experts for the examination of the film; Complex balancing of interests; Cripple and spastic; Societal perceptions about persons with disabilities; Negative self-image and perpetuate discriminatory attitudes; Language that individualises the impairment; Accurate representation of a medical condition; Misleading portrayal of a condition; Barriers persons with disabilities face; Visual media; Showcasing diverse realities of persons with disabilities; Promotion of inclusive understanding of disability; Promotion of participation of persons with disabilities; Equalisation of opportunities; Expert opinions for assessing the overall message of films; Involvement of persons with disabilities in the implementation of measures; Training and sensitization programs; Lived experiences of persons with disabilities; Principles of the social model of disability; Importance of respectful language; Accurate and empathetic representation of persons with disabilities; Humour and disabilities; Disability humour; Disabling humour;Cinematograph Act an instance of reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2); Restraints on films; Principles of due process, social interest; Equality of opportunity; Gender equality; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 255Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. Recognition of the evolving capacities of children with disabilities, ensuring their right to maintain their identities.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No.7230 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 15.01.2024 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in WP(C) No.522 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Jai Anant Dehadrai, Pulkit Agarwal, Sudhanshu Kaushesh, Siddharth Sharma, Md Tasnimul Hassan, Martin George, Prashant Kumar, Md Anas Chaudhary, Md Sharyab Ali, Zahid Ali, Vibhu Tandon, Avnish Chaturvedi, Advs. for the Appellant.
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Parag Tripathi, Sr. Adv., Ritin Rai, Alipak Banerjee, Karishma Karthik, Salvador Santosh Rebello, Raghav Sharma, Ms. Kritika Grover, Jaskirat Pal Singh, Prateek Tanmay, Madhav Sinhal, Mrs. Sansriti Pathak, Mayank Pandey, Mrs. Aarushi Singh, Amrish Kumar, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI Contents* A. Factual Background ................................................................ 3 B. The High Court ........................................................................ 6 C. Legislative Framework ............................................................ 7 I. The 1991 guidelines ............................................................. 10 II. Article 19(1)(a) and The Cinematograph Act ...................... 11 D. The Context of speech ........................................................... 14 I. Disabling imagery: stereotypical portrayal of persons with disabilities in the media. ....................................................... 15 II. Stereotyping as an anti-thesis to dignity and non-discrimination ............................................................... 17 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
256 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports III. The Framework of the RPwD Act, 2016............................. 18 IV. International Jurisprudence ................................................ 20
1. Equality and Non-Discrimination ................................... 22
2. Awareness-raising .......................................................... 24 V. Indian jurisprudence aligns with the human rights approach... 28 E. Speech must not prejudice the marginalised and disenfranchise them further .................................................... 30 F. Caveat: Disability Humour v. Disabling Humour ..................... 31 G. The Present Case ................................................................... 33
1. Leave granted.
2. The appellant is the founder of an organisation that promotes awareness about disabilities, conducts policy research and provides education to underprivileged children. The appellant is a person with arthrogryposis and is aggrieved by the manner in which persons with disabilities have been portrayed in the movie titled ‘Aankh Micholi’.
3. The appeal arises from the judgment dated 15 January 2024 of the High Court of Delhi by which a petition under article 226 was dismissed on grounds of maintainability.
A. Factual Background
4. The appellant addressed a legal notice to the first respondent, Sony Pictures, on 6 October 2023 raising objections to the trailer of their film. The appellant was particularly aggrieved by the introduction of some of the characters of the film, who were portrayed to suffer from physical impairments. Sony Pictures replied to the notice on 17 October 2023. The movie was released on 3 November 2023 with ‘U’ certification from the Central Board of Film Certification.
5. The appellant claims that the film violates the constitutionally protected rights of persons with disabilities; and the provisions of the Cinematograph Act, 19521 and the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016 2 . The appellant claims that the Central Board 1 “Cinematograph Act”
2 “RPwD Act”
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 257Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. of Film Certification 3 has violated its statutory duty to certify films in accordance with the applicable guidelines.
6. He therefore sought directions:
(i) Mandating the inclusion of an expert on disability within the Central Board of Film Certification and its advisory panel constituted under Sections 3 and 5 of the Cinematograph Act;
(ii) Mandating the inclusion of the expert under Section 3 of the Cinematograph Act, 1952;
(iii) Seeking relief against the first respondent, including punitive damages; and
(iv) A public apology from the first respondent.
7. The appellant has highlighted instances in the trailer as well as the film where certain medical conditions have been misrepresented and derogatory terms have been used for characters who are persons with disabilities. These include (a) misrepresentation of the condition of night blindness; and (b) derogatory references to (i) a person with Alzheimer’s as “bhulakkad baap”, (ii) a hearing-impaired person as a “soundproof system”; and (iii) a character with speech impairment as an “atki hui cassette”. The appellant submits that the film portrays a family of persons with various disabilities and revolves around their attempts to conceal their disabilities in a bid to come across as a ‘normal family’. The female lead is a person with nyctalopia or night blindness, while the male lead is a person with hemeralopia, which is an inability to see clearly in bright light. The plot of the film revolves around the two families of the lead characters concealing their impairments, in order to arrange a matrimonial alliance.
8. The appellant has urged that the film’s portrayal is derogatory to persons with disabilities generally and conveys the message that they ought to conceal their impairments in order to deserve a matrimonial partner. The appellant has further urged that the film (i) reinforces stereotypes with its misguided portrayals of persons with disabilities, thereby creating misconceptions, biases and prejudices against them; (ii) promotes the idea that persons with disability are unequal; (iii) presents them as subjects of comic relief; (iv) creates 3 “CBFC”/”The Board”
258 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports an environment of ridicule; (iv) does not generate empathy towards persons with disabilities; and (v) fails to promote inclusive and accurate representations of disabilities. In response, Sony Pictures stated that the overall message of the film was one of ‘overcoming the challenge of disability’; the film sought to depict the struggles faced by persons with disabilities and their families and in an effort to overcome them. The film, they claimed in the reply, sought to dislodge the idea that disability obstructs a fulfilling life. The reply stated further that (i) the introduction of the characters in the trailer is protected by the freedom of speech and expression; (ii) the film does not pity or look down upon the characters but depicts their agency and skills; (iii) the depiction is neither derogatory nor stereotypical. B. The High Court
9. The High Court of Delhi noted that the appellant had not disputed the explanation offered by the first respondent that the overall message of the film was around overcoming the disability and dwelt on the strength of the characters suffering from disabilities. The Court noted that the primary challenge that the film is offensive to the sensibilities of persons with disabilities, is thus not established. Underlining that the film was granted certification for unrestricted public exhibition by CBFC, the High Court held that the reliefs sought by the appellant were non-maintainable.
10. Summarised briefly, the High Court’s findings are:
(i) The first respondent’s reply refutes the allegations made in the notice. They contested any suggestion that the movie’s intent was to offend or humiliate differently-abled persons. Instead, they elucidated the overarching message of the film as intended by its creator;
(ii) The appellant did not raise further grievances after receiving the reply and until filing the petition, indicating a lack of challenge to the film’s alleged offensive nature;
(iii) There is a lack of legal justification for the reliefs sought; and
(iv) This dismissal is reinforced by the existence of guidelines issued by the Central Government under Section 5B(2) of the Act of 1952. These guidelines, including specific provisions for persons with disabilities provided a comprehensive framework for film certification.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 259Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. C. Legislative Framework
11. We have heard Mr Sanjoy Ghose, senior counsel and Mr Jai Anant Dehadrai, counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant; Mr Parag Tripathi, senior counsel appearing on behalf of Sony Pictures and Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General of India who has appeared to assist the Court on its request. The issues that arise for our consideration include the impact of the provisions of the RPwD Act 2016 on the certification of films under the Cinematograph Act.
12. The appellant has alleged that the Board has violated its duties under the statute for film certification in granting a certificate to the film. The Cinematograph Act 1952, the Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 19834 and the Guidelines for Certification of Films for Public Exhibition 1991 5 , constitute the framework for certification of films. These provide for certification of films for exhibition and for regulation of the exhibition of such films. Every film must obtain a prior certificate for exhibition from the Board under Section 5A of the Act. The Board is constituted under Section 3 by the Central Government and consists of a chairperson and a minimum of twelve, and a maximum of twenty-five members 6 . An application for the grant of a certificate has to be in the format prescribed in the Rules7 .
13. Once an application is made, it is assessed by an Examining Committee, which makes recommendations to the relevant authority, which could be the Chairperson of the Board or the Regional Officer concerned. The authority, acting on the Board’s behalf may act on the recommendations or refer the application to the Revising Committee which includes members of the Board or of advisory panels.8
14. Section 5 provides for Advisory Panels 9 consisting of persons qualified to judge the effect of the films on the public. The Advisory panels are appointed to facilitate the efficient functioning of the Board. The Board may consult the panel in respect of any application for the 4 “1983 Rules”. The 1983 Rules have been superseded by the Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 2024 (“2024 Rules”).
5 “Guidelines”
6 Cinematograph Act 1952, Section 3.
7 Cinematograph Act 1952, Section 4; Cinematograph (Certification) Rules 1983, Rule 21. 8 Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 1983, Rule 24.
9 Cinematograph Act 1952, Section 5.
260 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports certification of a film. The panel has to examine the film and make its recommendations to the Board in accordance with the applicable rules.
15. Section 8 empowers the Central Government to make rules. The 1983 Certification Rules (and the 2024 Rules which superseded them) were framed under the rule making power. Under the Rules, the Regional Officer appoints an Examining Committee consisting of members of the Advisory Panel (constituted under Section 5) and an Examining Officer10 . The Examining Officer submits recommendations of the Examining Committee to the authority prescribed in the Rules, based on the type and length of the content, and takes personal responsibility for compliance with every guideline. 11 The Chairperson of the Board can require the Regional Officer to act on behalf of the Board, in conformity with the recommendations of the Examining Committee. The Chairperson may, in the alternative, on their own motion or on a request by the applicant, refer the record to the Revising Committee under Rule 24. The Revising Committee shall examine the film and send the recommendations to the Chairperson of the Board. If the Chairperson disagrees with the decision by majority of the Revising Committee, the Board shall itself examine the film or cause the film to be examined again by another Revising Committee and the decision of the Board or a second Revising Committee, as the case may be, shall be final.12 The certificate granted by the Board is published in the Gazette is valid for 10 years.13
16. The Board may sanction the film for unrestricted public exhibition (‘U’ certificate); public exhibition restricted to adults (‘A’ certificate); (U/A certificate); or public exhibition restricted to members of a class, having regard to the nature, content and theme of the film (‘S’ certificate). The Board may certify the film as it is, or subject to excisions or modifications or refuse to sanction the film for public exhibition altogether.
17. Section 5B provides that a film shall not be certified if in the opinion of the Board, it is against “the interests of the sovereignty and integrity 10 Cinematograph (Certification) Rules, 1983, Rule 22.
11 ibid, Rule 22 (13).
12 ibid, Rule 24.
13 ibid, Rule 29.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 261Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. of India, the security of the State, friendly relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality, or involves defamation or contempt of court or is likely to incite the commission of any offence.” Section 5B(2) states that the Central Government may delineate principles to guide the authority granting a certificate for public exhibition of films. Accordingly, Guidelines have been framed in 1991.
I. The 1991 Guidelines
18. The appellant states that the egregious portrayal of characters with disabilities in the film necessitates judicially mandated checks and the framing of guidelines for creators of content. The Guidelines, framed under Section 5B of the Cinematograph Act, are interpreted as broad standards and require (inter alia) that the Board must ensure that scenes showing abuse of physically or mentally handicapped persons are not presented needlessly. 14 The guidelines prescribe sensitive portrayal of women, children and persons with disabilities. 15 The film must be examined as a whole and in line with contemporary standards of the country and the people to whom it relates.
19. This Court has laid down tests to determine challenges to the portrayal of persons, situations and characters in films. The aversion defence states that the portrayal of a social evil meant to arouse revulsion, such as scenes of sexual violence or communal tension, are meant to draw attention to these evils rather than to glorify them. They must not be barred for mere portrayal and due regard must be had to the overall message of the film, rather than standalone scenes.16 Films must remain sensitive to standards of society and alive to social changes.17 The Board is required to view the film as a whole in applying the above metrics. The decision must not be based on isolated bits and scenes in the film.18
20. Once certified, the film is presumed to have complied with the applicable Rules and Guidelines, and its effect on the public 14 Guidelines For Certification of Films for Public Exhibition 1991, Clause 2 (iii) (b). 15 ibid, Clause 2 (iii) (a), (b).
16 Madhavi Goradia Divan, Facets of Media Law, Second Edition pg 284-285; Bobby Art International v. Om Pal Singh Hoon, 1996 4 SCC 1 [27-28] 17 Guidelines (supra), Clauses 1 (a) and 3 (ii)
18 Director General,Directorate General of Doordarshan & Ors. (2006) 8 SCC 433 [20, 34] (supra) [38]; S Rangarajan v P Jagjivan Ram and Ors. (1989) 2 SCC 574 262 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports cannot ordinarily be re-assessed by the Court, having already been considered by an expert body 19.
21. The certification of the film in question is not in issue before us. In that regard, as the High Court has noted, the appellant has not contested Sony Pictures’ reply to their legal notice. During the course of the hearing it was stated across the Bar that since the film has been released in the meantime, the certification itself is not seriously in challenge. The appellant has sought the framing of guidelines and inclusion of recommendations for creators to follow while dealing with sensitive subjects such as the rights of persons with disabilities in the visual media.
II. Article 19(1)(a) and The Cinematograph Act
22. A filmmaker’s right to exhibit films is a part of their fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), which is subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2)20 . The Cinematograph Act is an instance of reasonable restrictions on this right under the ‘decency and morality’ rubric of Article 19(2).21 Prior certification under the Act has been regarded as a valid restraint on cinematic speech because of its ‘instant appeal’ and the ability to stir emotions more deeply than other artistic media. 22 Even so, like restraints on cinematic speech have to be narrowly construed because of their potential to imperil the significant value of free speech which is a constitutionally protected value.
23. In KA Abbas v. Union of India 23, this Court underlined that restraints on cinematic expression have to be extremely narrow. 24 The Court held that when determining the effect of a film, the Board must view it from the vantage of an ordinary person of common sense rather than 19 Union of India v. KM Shankarappa (2001) 1 SCC 582; Prakash Jha v. Union of India (2011) 8 SCC 372 20 19. Protection of certain rights regarding freedom of speech, etc.
(1) All citizens shall have the right-(a)to freedom of speech and expression; (2)Nothing in sub-clause (a) of clause (1) shall affect the operation of any existing law, or prevent the State from making any law, in so far as such law imposes reasonable restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred by the said sub-clause in the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of the State, friendly relations with Foreign States, public order, decency or morality or in relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence. 21 Madhavi Divan, ‘Morality, Obscenity and Censorship’, Supreme Court Cases (Journal), Vol 1 (2003), 1–16; KA Abbas v. Union of India, (1970) 2 SCC 780 [40].
22 KA Abbas (supra) [20,34] 23 [1971] 2 SCR 446 : (1970) 2 SCC 780 24 KA Abbas (supra) [34] [2024] 7 S.C.R. 263Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. a hypersensitive person. Moreover, the Board must be alive to social change and must not adopt a conservative or orthodox approach. The limits on expression must be ‘necessary’, rather than merely expedient or convenient, which are relatively lower thresholds. 25 The Board must make a “substantial allowance” in favour of freedom and allow creative works to interpret both the foibles as well as the good in the society.26
24. Since the Cinematograph Act provides for an elaborate procedure for certification of films by expert bodies, the approval of the statutory committees such as the Examination Committee must be given due weight. The Board has the benefit of hearing the perspective of the filmmakers, who make relevant representations before the Board. Courts are slow to interfere with the conclusions of specialised bodies, constituted under the Act. 27 In this narrow scope of intervention, the Court may not act like a film critic and must observe certain grounding principles. For instance, the mere mention of a subject in the film is not problematic in itself and a deeper examination of the manner in which the theme has been handled is required. 28 In Bobby Art International v. Om Pal Singh Hoon29 , this Court held that as long as the overall message of the film is not to extol a social evil, its mere depiction of a social evil is not impermissible. It was held there that the portrayal of sexual violence could not be construed as a promotion of such violence. 30 In Nachiketa Walhekar v. Central Board of Film Certification31 , a three-judge bench speaking through one of us (Dr DY Chandrachud J) refused to stay the release of a film on the ground of its apprehended use as evidence in a pending trial. It was held that the Court will be extremely slow to restrain creative works, once the Board had approved exhibition. 32
25. Restraints on films are founded on principles of due process, social interest, limited application in cases of absolute necessity and clear 25 S Rangarajan (supra) [21,53] 26 Ramesh v. Union of India, (1988) 1 SCC 668 [15] 27 Ramesh (Supra) [19] 28 KA Abbas (supra) [50]; See also Ramesh (supra) [17] 29 [1996] Supp. 2 SCR 136 : 1996 4 SCC 1 30 Bobby Art International (supra) [29-33]
31 (2018) 1 SCC 778
32 Nachiketa Walhekar (supra) [2,4]; See also, Viacom 18 vs Union of India 2018 1 SCC 761 [16] 264 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports purpose of the restraint. 33 Among the principles which must be borne in mind when deciding the fitness of a film for public exhibition include the following: (i) Social impact of the film is judged from the perspective of an ordinary person of reasonable intelligence and not a hypersensitive person; (iii) Social change, rather than orthodox notions or what is right and moral must be borne in mind; and (iv) The film must be judged by its overall message and not from isolated depictions of social evils.
D. The Context of speech
26. We are dealing with cinematic speech. In a slightly different context of anti-hate speech and group-defamation laws, Professor Ronald Dworkin argued that freedom of speech and expression extended even to hate speech. While he conceded the need to protect certain groups from violence and discrimination, he believed society could adopt laws to offer such protection. He regarded hate speech as protected speech and necessary, so that anti-discrimination laws could gain political legitimacy and enforceability among their opponents. His argument was that “if we want legitimate laws against violence or discrimination, we must let their opponents speak”. 34 John Stuart Mill on the other hand, argued that such speech served a public-education function by promoting public debate, and to sustain constant questioning of the truth 35 . Disagreeing with Dworkin’s legitimacy argument as well as Mill’s public debate argument, Jeremy Waldron argued in The Harm in Hate Speech that on certain issues, society is past the point where it needs to debate fundamental aspects of issues such as race. Waldron argued that if hate speech were to be allowed because of its ability to sustain a public debate, such debate would come at the cost of the dignity of racial minorities, who have had to bear humiliating attacks on their objective social standing due to such speech. 36 This affront to one’s dignity and objective treatment by society, rather than the 33 KA Abbas (supra) [40] 34 Ronald Dworkin, Foreword, in Hare and Weinstein, eds., Extreme Speech and Democracy, v–ix.as cited in Jeremy Waldron, The Harm in Hate Speech, Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England (2012), Pg 175.
35 John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (Penguin Books, 1982) [99, 106] as cited in Jeremy Waldron, The Harm in Hate Speech, Pgs 194, 197.
36 Jeremy Waldron (supra), Pg 195.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 265Nipun Malhotra v. Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors. more subjective notion of the ‘effect on one’s feelings’ by way of such speech must be curbed. 37
27. Even though Waldron was writing in a different context, he highlights the importance of the ‘context’ of speech as paramount in deciding the validity of restraints on it. Derogatory speech and stereotypes usually target the marginalised. The impact of the speech on human dignity; the identity of the speaker and the target; and the linguistic connotations of the speech may be considered in deciding issues around stereotypical speech. The standard of the ‘overall message’ of a film, in some ways, furthers this emphasis on the importance of context and manner of portrayal in visual media.38 I. Disabling imagery: stereotypical portrayal of persons with disabilities in the media.
28. Media portrayals of persons with disabilities have been historically oppressive. Consistent with the understanding that disability was ‘anomalous’ in a normative framework of ability, persons with disabilities were represented in disparaging ways. They were portrayed as evil, as objects of pity, violence, curiosity and ridicule, as burdens on society, sexually abnormal, and overall, as people incapable of community participation39. Such disabling imagery formed “the bedrock on which the attitudes towards, assumptions about and expectations of disabled persons are based” 40 . Such portrayal perpetuated stigmatising views about disability as a vulnerability or a ‘suffering’. 41 Recurrent negative portrayals as illustrated above and frequent use of patronising and offensive language such as “victim”, “differently abled”, or “unfortunate” 37 Jeremy Waldron (supra), Pgs 107,197 “I think we do need to ask whether we are past the stage where society is in such need of a robust debate about fundamental matters of race that we ought to bear the costs of what amount to attacks on the dignity of minority groups. Think of what those costs may involve. Are we re ally in need of such robust debate on racial ontology that we have no choice but to require individuals and families within minority groups to bear the costs of such humiliating attacks on their social standing?”
38 Bobby Art International (supra).
39 Colin Barnes, Disabling Imagery and the Media, An Exploration of the Principles for Media Representation of Disabled People, The British Council Of Organisations Of Disabled People, Part Two :Commonly Recurring Media Stereotypes (1992) Pg 7 <https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/ sites/40/library/Barnes-disabling-imagery.pdf>; Angharad E. Beckett, Citizenship and Vulnerability: Disability and Issues of Social and Political Engagement, Palgrave Mamillan (2006) Pg. 40 ibid.
41 Beckett (ibid) at Pg 109.
266 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to describe individuals continue to perpetuate negative attitudes towards persons with disabilities.
29. The problem with such portrayal is that it channels attention on the medical aspects of impairment rather than the social aspects that actually disable a person. This impacts persons with disabilities as individuals as well, subjecting them to stigma and social exclusion. 42
30. As Allan Sutherland wrote, “stereotyped views frequently act as selffulfilling prophecies, forcing the person with a disability into a role that can then be used to justify the original treatment.”43 They shape and strengthen the already existing negative assumptions about their abilities 44 . This resultantly exacerbates systemic inequalities, and inhibits their dignified participation in the public sphere for education or employment.45
31. Humour is a powerful medium of speech that can reinforce attitudes and influence behaviour towards groups. Pejorative jokes may reinforce stereotypical assumptions about disabilities, validating abusive attitudes and practices towards persons with disabilities.46 Humour, however, also has a complex dual role for persons with disabilities. It could be “both liberating and stigmatising” depending on the context of the joke and who is telling it. 47 We shall advert to this dual role later.
II. Stereotyping as an anti-thesis to dignity and non-discrimination.
32. This Court is cognisant of the impact of stereotypes on discrimination and the enjoyment of fundamental rights. We have traced safeguards 42 Colin Barnes et al., Exploring Disability. A Sociological Introduction, Cambridge, Polity Press, (1999) Pg 10.
43 Allan Sutherland, Disabled we Stand, London: Souvenir Press (1981) < https://disability-studies.leeds. ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/library/Sutherland-CHAPTER6.pdf> 44 Beckett (supra) Pg 3.
45 ibid Pg 109.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.