Shivani Tyagi v. State of U.P. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 343; [2024] 5 S.C.R. 36
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice C.T. Ravikumar, Justice Rajesh Bindal
- Decided
- 5 Apr 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1957/2024
- Sections
- 389, 302, 420, 376
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Authors [2024] 5 S.C.R. 36 : 2024 INSC 343 Shivani Tyagi v.
State of U.P. & Anr.
(Criminal Appeal Nos.1957-1961 of 2024)
05 April 2024 [C. T. Ravikumar* and Rajesh Bindal,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to suspension of sentence of life imprisonment of the convicted persons, and their consequential enlargement on bail, in an acid attack case.
Headnotes Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 389 – Suspension of sentence pending appeal, and releasing on bail – Acid attack on victim at the hands of the accused persons – Victim suffered 30-40 percent burn injuries resulting in total disfigurement of her face – Conviction of the accused persons u/ss. 307/149 and 326A/149 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment – High Court suspended the sentence and enlarged them on bail – Interference:
Held: (per C. T. Ravikumar, J) Mere factum of sufferance of incarceration for a particular period and likelihood of delay in disposal of cases, in a case where life imprisonment is imposed, cannot be a reason for invocation of power u/s. 389 without referring to the relevant factors – Each case has to be examined on its own merits and based on the given parameters – Acid attack may completely strip off the victim of her basic human right to live a decent human life owing to permanent disfiguration – Impugned judgment reflects only non-application of mind and non-consideration of the relevant factors required for invocation of power u/s. 389 despite the fact that the case involved an acid attack on a young woman resulting into permanent disfiguration – High Court took into account the offer made on behalf of the convicts that they would give a payment of Rs. 25 lakhs, and that the evidence that the victim had incurred an amount of Rs. 21 [2024] 5 S.C.R. 37Shivani Tyagi v. State of U.P. & Anr. lakhs for her treatment besides the period of incarceration and also the delay likely to occur in the consideration of appeal – Serious nature of the offence involved was not taken into account besides the other relevant parameters for the exercise of power u/s. 389 – Thus, the impugned judgment cannot be sustained and is set aside, and the bail granted to the accused is cancelled [Paras 9-12] – Held: (per Rajesh Bindal,J) (Supplementing) One of the principles of sentencing, being proportionality, if the appropriate punishment is not awarded or if, after conviction for a heinous crime, the court directs the suspension of the sentence without valid reasons, the very purpose for which the criminal justice system exists would fail – High Court directed the suspension of the sentence of the accused on payment of ₹ 25 lakhs to the victim – Amount was not accepted by the victim and the convicts could not be released from the jail – Also despite spending ₹ 21 lakhs on the treatment, victim still has not been cured – Infirmity of the court is evident from the fact that the High Court went on to modify the earlier order and noted that a Demand Draft having been handed over to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, the accused be released on bail subject to Surety Bonds – Order passed in the Correction Application does not suggest that there was any consideration of the parameters laid down for grant of bail or suspension of sentence, instead, the High Court noticed and directed that the convicts have offered to pay compensation to the victim for grant of suspension of sentence, which when she refused to accept, was directed to be deposited in the court – It was in a way kind of “Blood Money” offered by the convicts to the victim for which there is no acceptability in the criminal justice system [Paras 6, 7, 13] Case Law Cited In the judgment of C.T. Ravikumar, J.
Bhagwan Rama Shinde Gosai & Ors. v. State of Gujarat [1999] 3 SCR 545 : (1999) 4 SCC 421;
Kishori Lal v. Rupa & Ors. [2004] Supp. 4 SCR 628 :
(2004) 7 SCC 638; Anwari Begum v. Sher Mohammad & Anr. [2005] Supp. 3 SCR 287 : (2005) 7 SCC 326; Khilari v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. [2009] 38 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 1 SCR 543 : (2009) 4 SCC 23; State of Haryana v.
Hasmat [2004] Supp. 3 SCR 132 : (2004) 6 SCC 175 – referred to.
In the judgment of Rajesh Bindal, J.
Parivartan Kendra v. Union of India and Others [2015] 12 SCR 607 : (2016) 3 SCC 571 : 2015 INSC 893;
Suresh Chandra Jana v. State of West Bengal and Others [2017] 13 SCR 1 : (2017) 16 SCC 466 : 2017 INSC 1296; State of Himachal Pradesh and Another v. Vijay Kumar alias Pappu and Another (2019) 5 SCC 373 : 2019 INSC 377; Deepak Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another [2022] 4 SCR 1 : (2022)
8 SCC 559 : 2022 INSC 610; Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another [2012] 8 SCR 753 : (2012) 10 SCC 303 : 2012 INSC 419; The State of Jharkhand v. Md. Sufiyan SLP (Crl) No. 1960 of 2022 decided on 16.01.2024; Sahab Alam alias Guddu v. State of Jharkhand and another (2022) SCC Online SC 1874 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Acid attack case; Suspension of sentence; Life imprisonment; Enlargement on bail; Disfigurement of face; Sufferance of incarceration; Delay; Public interest and social security; Permanent disfiguration of young woman; Principles of sentencing; Criminal law; Proportionality; Criminal justice system; Compensation; Blood Money.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 1957- 1961 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 12.12.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CRLA Nos.2467, 996, 801, 1155 and 467 of 2021 [2024] 5 S.C.R. 39Shivani Tyagi v. State of U.P. & Anr. Appearances for Parties Niranjan Sahu, Adv. for the Appellant.
Vinay Navare, Sr. Adv., Rajat Singh, Divyanshu Sahay, Sarthak Chandra, Akhand Pratap Singh Chauhan, Anil Verma, Tungesh, Nagendra Kasana, Rajesh Rathod, Ms. Palak Munjal, Aditya Sharma, Arun Kumar Arunachal, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order C. T. Ravikumar, J.
Leave granted.
1. In these quintuplet appeals the victim of an acid attack assails the suspension of sentence of life imprisonment of the convicted persons, the private respondents and their consequential enlargement on bail.
2. Heard learned counsel appearing for the self-same appellantvictim in the captioned appeal, learned counsel appearing for the common first respondent-State of Uttar Pradesh and learned counsel appearing for the private respondents.
3. Section 389 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short the “Cr. PC”) deals with the suspension of execution of sentence pending the appeal against conviction and release of appellant(s) on bail. The said provision mandates for recording of reasons in writing leading to the conclusion that the convicts are entitled to get suspension of sentence and consequential release on bail. The said requirement thus indicates the legislative intention that the appellate Court invoking the power under Section 389, Cr. PC, should assess the matter objectively and that such assessment should reflect in the order.
4. We will briefly refer to some of the relevant decisions dealing with Section 389, Cr. PC. In the case of short-term imprisonment for conviction of an offence, suspension of sentence is the normal rule and its rejection is the exception. (See the decision in Bhagwan Rama Shinde Gosai & Ors. v. State of Gujarat 1 ). However, we 1 [1999] 3 SCR 545 : (1999) 4 SCC 421 40 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports are of the considered view that the position should be vice-versa in the case of conviction for serious offences when invocation of power under Section 389 is invited. This Court, in the decision in Kishori Lal v. Rupa & Ors. 2, held in paragraphs 4 and 5 thus:- “4. Section 389 of the Code deals with suspension of execution of sentence pending the appeal and release of the appellant on bail. There is a distinction between bail and suspension of sentence. One of the essential ingredients of Section 389 is the requirement for the appellate Court to record reasons in writing for ordering suspension of execution of the sentence or order appealed against. If he is in confinement, the said Court can direct that he be released on bail or on his own bond. The requirement of recording reasons in writing clearly indicates that there has to be careful consideration of the relevant aspects and the order directing suspension of sentence and grant of bail should not be passed as a matter of routine.
5. The appellate Court is duty-bound to objectively assess the matter and to record reasons for the conclusion that the case warrants suspension of execution of sentence and grant of bail. In the instant case, the only factor which seems to have weighed with the High Court for directing suspension of sentence and grant of bail is the absence of allegation of misuse of liberty during the earlier period when the accused-respondents were on bail.”
5. In the decision in Anwari Begum v. Sher Mohammad & Anr.3 this Court in paragraphs 7 and 8 held thus:- “7. Even on a cursory perusal the High Court’s order shows complete non-application of mind. Though a detailed examination of the evidence and elaborate documentation of the merits of the case is to be avoided by the Court while passing orders on bail applications, yet a Court 2 [2004] Supp. 4 SCR 628 : (2004) 7 SCC 638 3 [2005] Supp. 3 SCR 287 : (2005) 7 SCC 326 [2024] 5 S.C.R. 41Shivani Tyagi v. State of U.P. & Anr. dealing with the bail application should be satisfied as to whether there is a prima facie case, but exhaustive exploration of the merits of the case is not necessary. The Court dealing with the application for bail is required to exercise its discretion in a judicious manner and not as a matter of course.
8. There is a need to indicate in the order reasons for prima facie concluding why bail was being granted, particularly where an accused was charged of having committed a serious offence. It is necessary for the Courts dealing with application for bail to consider among other circumstances, the following factors also before granting bail, they are:
1. The nature of accusation and the severity of punishment in case of conviction and the nature of supporting evidence;
2. Reasonable apprehension of tampering with the witness or apprehension of threat to the complainant;
3. Prima facie satisfaction of the Court in support of the charge.
Any order dehors of such reasons suffers from nonapplication of mind as was noted by this Court in Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh (2002) 3 SCC 598, Puran v. Rambilas (2001) 6 SCC 338 and in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan (2004) 7 SCC 528.”
6. After referring to the aforesaid paragraphs in the decisions in Kishori Las’s case (supra) and Anwari Begum’s case (supra), this Court in the decision in Khilari v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.4 interfered with an order suspending the sentence and granting bail for non-application of mind and non-consideration of the relevant aspects.
7. Applying the principles and parameters for invocation of the power under Section 389. Cr. PC, revealed from the decisions, 4 [2009] 1 SCR 543 : (2009) 4 SCC 23 42 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports as above, we will have to consider the sustainability of the challenge against the impugned orders by the appellant victim. In that regard a succinct narration of the facts involved in the case, strictly confining to the requirement for consideration of these appeals, is required. The private respondents in the appeals, five in numbers, were convicted finding guilty of offences, including under Sections 307/149 and 326A/149, IPC. The appellant-victim was then aged about 31 years and, in the incident, she suffered attack with sulfuric acid and her body was burnt 30 to 40 percent. PW-6, Dr. Uttam Jain with Ext.A5, would reveal that she suffered deep burn on the face, chest and both hands and injuries on her were grievous in nature.
8. We may hasten to add that regarding the merits of the appeals by the party respondents against their conviction, we shall not be understood to have held or made any observation as it is a matter to be considered on its own merits in the pending appeals.
9. We have already referred to the mandate under Section 389 Cr.PC that the order passed invoking the said provision should reflect the reason for coming to the conclusion that the convicts are entitled to get suspended their sentence and consequential release on bail. In the decision in State of Haryana v. Hasmat5, this Court held that in an appeal against conviction involving serious offence like murder punishable under Section 302, IPC the prayer for suspension of sentence and grant of bail should be considered with reference to the relevant factors mentioned thereunder, though not exhaustively. On its perusal, we are of the opinion that factors like nature of the offence held to have committed, the manner of their commission, the gravity of the offence, and also the desirability of releasing the convict on bail are to be considered objectively and such consideration should reflect in the consequential order passed under Section 389, Cr.PC. It is also relevant to state that the mere factum of sufferance of incarceration for a particular period, in a case where life imprisonment is imposed, cannot be a reason for invocation of power under Section 389 Cr.PC without referring to the relevant factors. We say so because there cannot be any 5 [2004] Supp. 3 SCR 132 : (2004) 6 SCC 175 [2024] 5 S.C.R. 43Shivani T y a g i v . State o f U .P. & A n r . doubt with respect to the position that disposal of appeals against conviction, (especially in cases where life imprisonment is imposed for serious offences), within a short span of time may not be possible in view of the number of pending cases. In such circumstances if it is said that disregarding the other relevant factors and parameters for the exercise of power under Section 389, Cr. PC, likelihood of delay and incarceration for a particular period can be taken as a ground for suspension of sentence and to enlarge a convict on bail, then, in almost every such case, favourable invocation of said power would become inevitable. That certainly cannot be the legislative intention as can be seen from the phraseology in Section 389 Cr.PC. Such an interpretation would also go against public interest and social security. In such cases giving preference over appeals where sentence is suspended, in the matter of hearing or adopting such other methods making an early hearing possible could be resorted. We shall not be understood to have held that irrespective of inordinate delay in consideration of appeal and long incarceration undergone the power under the said provision cannot be invoked. In short, we are of the view that each case has to be examined on its own merits and based on the parameters, to find out whether the sentence imposed on the appellant(s) concerned should be suspended during the pendency of the appeal and the appellant(s) should be released on bail.
10. Having observed and held as above, we are deeply peeved on perusing the impugned judgment, for the same reflects only nonapplication of mind and non-consideration of the relevant factors despite the fact that the case involved an acid attack on a young woman resulting into permanent disfiguration. In the case on hand, a scanning of the impugned order would reveal that what mainly weighed with the Court is the offer made on behalf of the convicts that they would give a payment of Rs. 25 lakhs through demand drafts, taking into account the evidence that the victim had incurred an amount of Rs. 21 lakhs for her treatment. Paragraph 10 of the impugned order would reveal that taking note of the said offer besides the period of incarceration and also the delay likely to occur in the consideration of appeal, sentence imposed was suspended and the private respondents were enlarged on bail. Paragraph 10 of the order would reveal this position and it reads thus:- 44 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports “10. After hearing counsel for the parties and considering the voluntarily offer made by the appellants, which is without prejudice to the right of defence as well as right of the prosecution to be decided at the time of final adjudication and having no bearing on the merit of the case, over and above, the amount of compensation being paid by the District Legal Services Authority, Meerut, the appellants have offered to pay an amount of Rs. 25 lacs to the victim for her medical treatment and also in view of the long custody as well as the antecedents of the appellants and also considering the fact that the appeals pertain to the year 2021 and are not likely to be listed for final argument in near future, we deem it appropriate to grant suspension of sentence of the appellants.”
11. We have no hesitation to hold that the impugned order is infected with non-application of mind and non-consideration of the relevant factors required for invocation of power under Section 389 in the light of the settled position of law. An acid attack may completely strip off the victim of her basic human right to live a decent human life owing to permanent disfiguration. We have no hesitation to hold that in appeals involving such serious offence(s), serious consideration of all parameters should be made. Even a cursory glance of the impugned order would reveal the consideration thereunder was made ineptly. The serious nature of the offence involved was not taken into account besides the other relevant parameters for the exercise of power under Section 389, Cr. PC.
12. In such circumstances, the impugned judgment cannot be sustained. The upshot of the discussion is that the order suspending the sentence of the private respondents and enlarging them on bail, invite interference. Consequently, the impugned order is set aside and consequently the bail granted to the private respondent in all these appeals stands cancelled. Consequently, the appellants shall surrender before the trial Court for the purpose of their committal to judicial custody. This shall be done within a period of four days. In case of their failure to surrender as ordered, the private respondents who are convicts shall be re-arrested and committed to custody.
13. The Appeals are allowed as above.
[2024] 5 S.C.R. 45Shivani T y a g i v . State o f U .P. & A n r . Order Rajesh Bindal, J.
1. I have gone through the detailed reasons recorded by brother C.T. Ravikumar, J. Elaborate discussion has been made on the aspect of suspension of sentence in heinous crimes as it is a case where the High Court had directed suspension of sentence of the respondents in an acid attack case, which will haunt the victim throughout her life. The disfigurement of the face of the victim, as is evident from the photographs placed on record, could not even be seen.
2. It is a case in which after hearing the arguments raised by the appellant and going through the paper book our conscience was shocked. By a short order we granted the leave in the matters and allowed the appeals, for the reasons to follow. The respondents were directed to surrender before the Trial Court on or before 09.04.2024. The same is extracted below:
“Leave granted.
Appeals are allowed. Reasons to follow.
The respondents-life convicts shall surrender on or before 9.4.2024 before the concerned Trial Court. In case of their failure to surrender, they shall be taken into custody and produced before the Trial Court.”
2.1 I fully subscribe to the views expressed, but wish to add some more reasons.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.