Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 104; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 288
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 1 Judge: Justice Bela M. Trivedi
- Decided
- 12 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1162/2011
- Sections
- 302, 5, 235
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 288 : 2024 INSC 104 Mallappa & Ors.
v.
State of Karnataka (Criminal Appeal No. 1162 of 2011)
12 February 2024 [Bela M. Trivedi and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The trial Court acquitted appellants-accused nos.3, 4 and 5 for the commission of murder of one ‘M’. However, the High Court reversed the order of acquittal and held the appellants guilty of the commission of murder. Whether the High Court was correct in reversing the order of acquittal of the trial Court and thereby convicting the accused persons u/s. 302 IPC.
Headnotes Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 – Acquittal under – As per prosecution eight accused persons armed with axes, knives and clubs attacked ‘M’ and assualted him – PW-4 tried to run away, however, was assaulted with an axe on his head, back and on scrotum – PW-4 sustained injuries, became unconcious and fell on the ground – PW-3 hid himself inside the jali-trees – After assailants left, PW-3 went to M and found that he was dead and PW-4 was unconcious with blood flowing out of his injuries – PW-3 fearing for his life kept on hiding then left during night – On the next day he informed PW-2 (father of deceased) about the incident – Eight accused persons were tried and acquitted by the trial Court – The High Court acquitted all the accused persons except the three appellants – Propriety: Held: In the instant case, the case of prosecution substantially rests on the testimonies of PW-3 and PW-4 read with various documents, especially the reports of medical examination and post mortem – The conduct of PW-3 renders his very presence at the place of incident as doubtful – Despite a heavy assault by multiple accused persons, he did not suffer any injury at all – That too when he was indeed chased by A-3 while attacking PW-4 – It is extremely doubtful that the assailants simply chose to give up on PW-3 and did not pursue him behind the bushes, * Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 289Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka despite knowing that PW-3 could turn out to be an eye witness of the incident – The story that follows the story of hiding behind the bushes is equally doubtful and leaves one speculating – The timelines, the route taken by PW-3, complete disregard for severely injured PW-4, failure to inform the police post despite access to it etc. are some of the factors that raise a reasonable doubt on the entire story – The chain of circumstances created by the testimony of PW-3 is not consistent with the outcome of guilt – The version of PW-4 is that he was attacked from the back by A3 and thereafter, he fell unconscious – As per his testimony and the testimony of PW-3, PW-4 was attacked by an axe on his head, back and scrotum – The first point of corroboration is to be seen from the circumstances following the assault – The assault on PW-4 took place at around 4 P.M. and he was admittedly unconscious thereafter – He remained as such until he was “selfadmitted” in the hospital at around 12:30 P.M. the following day – The second point for corroboration of this version could be taken from the wound certificate issued by PW-8 during the treatment of PW-4 at Government Hospital – The Trial Court relied upon the wound certificate and noted a contradiction between the condition of PW-4 at the time of admission – In the certificate, PW-4 is stated to be “self-admitted” but at the same time, he is stated to be unconscious – The injuries found on PW-4, as per the wound certificate, were simple in nature – PW-8 gave some treatment to PW-4, however the nature of treatment is not indicated – In the ordinary course of natural events, an injury inflicted by an axe, that too in a manner that the injured immediately fell unconscious and remained unconscious for almost 20 days, could not have been a simple injury – The High Court omitted to take note of two material aspects-the fact that the statement of PW-4 was recorded after a period of one month from the date of incident and the factum of family relationship between the deceased and PW-4 – The former aspect raises a grave suspicion of credibility, whereas the latter raises the suspicion of being an interested witness – The High Court went on to reverse the decision by taking its own view on a fresh appreciation of evidence without recording any illegality, error of law or of fact in the decision of the Trial Court – Thus, the High Court had erred in reversing the decision of acquittal, without arriving at any finding of illegality or perversity or error in the reasoning of the Trial Court. [Paras 29, 30, 33, 34, 39] 290 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Criminal Jurisprudence – Criminal jurisprudence is essentially based on the promise that no innocent shall be condemned as guilty – All the safeguards and the jurisprudential values of criminal law, are intended to prevent any failure of justice – The principles which come into play while deciding an appeal from acquittal could be summarized as:
Held: (i) Appreciation of evidence is the core element of a criminal trial and such appreciation must be comprehensive – inclusive of all evidence, oral or documentary; (ii) Partial or selective appreciation of evidence may result in a miscarriage of justice and is in itself a ground of challenge; (iii) If the Court, after appreciation of evidence, finds that two views are possible, the one in favour of the accused shall ordinarily be followed;
(iv) If the view of the Trial Court is a legally plausible view, mere possibility of a contrary view shall not justify the reversal of acquittal; (v) If the appellate Court is inclined to reverse the acquittal in appeal on a re-appreciation of evidence, it must specifically address all the reasons given by the Trial Court for acquittal and must cover all the facts; (vi) In a case of reversal from acquittal to conviction, the appellate Court must demonstrate an illegality, perversity or error of law or fact in the decision of the Trial Court. [Para 36] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Appellate Power – Qualified Power of the High Court:
Held: In the exercise of appellate powers, there is no inhibition on the High Court to re-appreciate or re-visit the evidence on record – However, the power of the High Court to re-appreciate the evidence is a qualified power, especially when the order under challenge is of acquittal – The first and foremost question to be asked is whether the Trial Court thoroughly appreciated the evidence on record and gave due consideration to all material pieces of evidence – The second point for consideration is whether the finding of the Trial Court is illegal or affected by an error of law or fact – If not, the third consideration is whether the view taken by the Trial Court is a fairly possible view – A decision of acquittal is not meant to be reversed on a mere difference of opinion – What is required is an illegality or perversity. [Para 25] Criminal Jurisprudence – Two-views theory – Reiterated. [2024] 2 S.C.R. 291Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka Case Law Cited Selvaraj v. State of Karnataka, [2015] 9 SCR 381 :
(2015) 10 SCC 230; Sanjeev v. State of H.P., (2022) 6 SCC 294; Sanwat Singh v. State of Rajasthan, [1961] 3 SCR 120 : AIR 1961 SC 715; Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Murder; Acquittal; Testimonies; Chain of circumstances; Reasonable doubt; Appreciation of evidence; Illegality, error of law or of fact; Qualified Power of the High Court; Criminal Jurisprudence; Two-views theory; Material pieces of evidence.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1162 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 31.05.2010 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in CRLA No. 1363 of 2005 Appearances for Parties Basavaprabhu Patil, Sr. Adv., Ms. Supreeta Sharanagouda, Sharanagouda Patil, Advs. for the Appellants.
Nishanth Patil, A.A.G., D. L. Chidananda, Adv. for the Respondent. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Satish Chandra Sharma, J.
1. The wheels of justice may grind slow, but they grind fine. Mallappa S/o Ningappa Kanner, Hanamanth S/o Ningappa Kanner and Dharamanna S/o Ningappa Kanner are the appellants before us who were put on a trial, as accused no. 3, 4 and 5, for the commission of murder of deceased namely Marthandappa and were acquitted by the Trial Court/Fast Track Court-I at Gulbarga on 24.03.2005. The 292 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports judgment was not meant to finally seal the fate of the appellants as the State of Karnataka preferred an appeal against the order of the Trial Court before the High Court of Karnataka which was registered as Criminal Appeal No. 1363/2005. On 31.05.2010, the High Court reversed the order of acquittal and held the appellants guilty of the commission of murder of deceased Marthandappa. Accordingly, the appellants stood convicted and were sentenced to undergo life imprisonment. The appellants stand before us assailing the order of conviction of the High Court and praying for a declaration of innocence.
2. Pertinently, eight accused persons were tried and acquitted by the Trial Court. The High Court agreed with the acquittal of all the accused persons, except the three appellants before us.
PROSECUTION CASE
3. The case of the prosecution begins from one Nagamma, who is the wife of Accused No. 5 and deceased Marthandappa was allegedly having an illicit relationship with her. On account of the alleged illicit relationship, the relations between A1-A8 and Marthandappa were strained. On 28.06.1997, the fateful day, Marthandappa (the deceased), PW3 and PW4 were travelling in a bullock-cart from village Aidbhavi to the village Nagaral for cultivating their lands. They left the house of PW-2 (father of the deceased) at around 9 A.M. in a bullock cart to go to village Nagaral. PW-2 had agricultural lands at Aidbhavi as well as Nagaral. While they were travelling to village Nagaral, they crossed village Shantpur as they were proceeding on the bullock-cart towards Nagaral village. At around 4 P.M., when their bullock-cart arrived near the land of Balwantappa Channur, A1 to A8 came out of their hiding place and stopped the bullock-cart.
4. As per the prosecution case, A3, A4 and A6 were armed with axes (MO 1 s. 5, 6 &7), A5 was armed with knife (MO8) and Al, A2, A7 and A10 were armed with clubs (MOs 9, 10 and 1). The accused persons started by threatening Marthandappa stating that on account of his illegal acts, village women folk are not able to lead their life peacefully and then they proceeded towards Marthandappa, with the intention to kill him. A3 assaulted him with an axe on his right leg and caused injuries. A4 also assaulted him with an axe five/six 1 MO = Material Object [2024] 2 S.C.R. 293Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka times on the right side of the stomach. A5 assaulted with a knife on the lip and back of Marthandappa, A6 assaulted with an axe on the right and left temple region and chin of Marthandappa. He also assaulted with an axe on the lap of Marthandappa. As the offensive act continued, A7 assaulted with a bullock-cart peg on the head of Marthandappa. A1, A2 and A8 assaulted with clubs on the back of Marthandappa.
5. Fearing for his life, PW-4 tried to run away and at that point of time, A3 assaulted him with an axe on the head, back and on the scrotum. PW-4 sustained injuries, became unconscious and fell on the ground.
6. PW-3, an eye witness of the incident, rushed to save himself and went inside the jali-trees. He saw the incident hiding from that particular place. Eventually, Marthandappa fell on the ground and Al to A8, believing that Marthandappa was no more, left the place. Finding it safe for him, PW3 then went to Marthandappa and found that Marthandappa was no more. He noticed that PW-4 was also lying unconscious with blood flowing out of his injuries. Thereafter, PW-3, fearing for his life, kept on hiding amidst the jali-trees and sometime during the night, he left the jali-trees and left for Devpura. On the next day, PW-3 reached the house of PW-2 at Aidbhavi and informed him regarding the incident. PW-2 then visited the scene of offence and saw the dead body of Marthandappa. He also saw PW-4 lying on the ground in an unconscious condition. Thereafter, on 29.06.1997 at around 3 P.M., he went to P.S. Shorapur and lodged a written complaint to the PW-10 as per Ex.P1 and PW-10 registered a case as Crime No. 78/97 and sent FIR (Ex.P13) through PW-1 to the Judicial Magistrate First Class 2 , Shorapur. The copy of FIR was handed over to JMFC at around 4:30 P.M.
7. The facts further reveal that on 29.06.1997 at about 12:30 P.M., PW-4 went to the Government Hospital, Shorapur, and met the doctor (PW- 8). He showed his injuries to PW-8 and PW-8 found three injuries (simple) on PW-4 and gave treatment to him, and later sent him for further treatment to the Government Hospital, Gulbarga. The doctor at Gulbarga treated PW-4 and issued a simple injury certificate to PW-8 (Ex.P12). After registering the case, PW-10 went to the scene of offence at Shorapur village along with PW-9 and saw the dead 2 Hereinafter referred as “JMFC”
294 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports body of Marthandappa and collected panchas (PW-7 and Malleshi). In the presence of Panchas, he conducted inquest mahazar on the dead body of Marthandappa, as per Ex.P9. On 29.06.1997, between 4.30 P.M. to 6.00 P.M. and thereafter, he handed over the dead body of Marthandappa to PW-9 with the requisition letter (Ex.P2) directing PW-9 to take the dead body to Government Hospital, Kakkera for getting the post-mortem examination done. PW-9 took the dead body of Marthandappa to the Government Hospital, Kakkera, and handed over the dead body to PW-5 (doctor) for post-mortem examination on 30.06.1997 at about 6.30 A.M. On 29.06.1997, PW-10, in the presence of Panchas (PW7 and Malleshi) conducted mahazar of scene of offence as per Ex.P10. From the scene of offence, he seized MO-1 (bullock-cart peg), MO-12 (pair of chappal), MO-13 (towel), MO-14 (blood stained mud), MO-15 (sample mud), MO-16(taita) and MO-17 (waist thread) and slips were affixed bearing signatures of the Panchas on them.
8. On 30.06.1997, PW-5 (doctor) conducted post-mortem examination on the dead body of Marthandappa from 6.30 am to 9.30 am. The doctor found 9 ante mortem injuries on him and issued a post-mortem report as per Ex.P3 stating the cause of death to be haemorrhage shock as a result of laceration of liver tissue. Notably, the report stated the time of death to be 36 to 48 hours prior to the post mortem examination. The doctor further handed over clothes and articles (MOs) found on the dead body as well as the dead body to PC (PW9). Thereafter, PW9 handed over the dead body to the relatives of Marthandappa for burial. The clothes and articles found on the dead body were brought to Kakkera by PW9, who produced them before PW-10. PW-10 seized them in the presence of panchas (PW7 and Malleshi) and also conducted mahazar of seizure as per Ex.P11 (MOs 1 to 4). Thereafter, he went to Aidbhavi village and recorded the statement of witnesses. Thereafter, he went to Mudagal and recorded the statement of Nagamma (wife of A5).
9. On 01.07.1997, PW-10 recorded statement of Balvantappa. On 04.07.1997, at about 5.30 A.M. at Tintini Bridge, PW-10 arrested A5 and interrogated him. A5 gave him information that he could produce knife from his house, thereby leading to discovery as per Ex.P14. A5, thereafter, took PW10 and panchas PW6 and Yamanappa) to his house situated in Aidbhavi vilage and from his house, he produced one knife (MO-8) and one axe (MO-5). PW-10 seized them as per [2024] 2 S.C.R. 295Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka Ex.P14. PW-10, thereafter obtained judicial custody remand of A5 from JMFC, Shorapur and obtained permission to retain properties. On 14.07.1997 at about 4.00 A.M., PW-10 arrested A1 to A4 from Shorapur Bus Stand and brought them to the police station for interrogation. A1 gave information leading to discovery as per Ex.P15. A2 gave information leading to discovery as per Ex.P16 and A3 gave information leading to discovery as per Ex.P17. Thereafter, on 15.07.1997, A1 led police and panchas (PW6 and Yamanappa) to his house and from his house, he produced one stick (MO9) before the police and panchas and PW-10 conducted mahazar of seizure as per Ex.P5. PW-10 took the signatures of the panchas on it. Thereafter, A2 led police and panchas to his house and from his house, he produced one stick (MO-10). PW-10 conducted mahazar of seizure of these articles, as per Ex.P7. A3 led police and panchas to his house at Aidbhavi and from his house, he produced one axe (MO7) and PW-10 seized the same as per mahazar (Ex.P6) and took signatures of the panchas on it. PW-10 thereafter obtained judicial custody remand of A1 to A4 from JMFC, Shorapur. On 25.07.1997, PW10 arrested A7 from his house and remanded him to judicial custody and on 17.07.1997 at 6.30 a.m., arrested A6 from Gurgunta bus stand and interrogated him. A6 gave him information leading to discovery as per Ex.P18 and from his house, one knife (MO8) was recovered and PW-10 seized it under mahazar Ex.P8. Thereafter, A6 was also remanded to judicial custody. On 07.10.1997, PW-10 sent all the seized articles to FSL, Bangalore through PW9.
10. On 07.08.1997, PW-10 recorded the statement of PW4. On 22.08.1997, PW10 collected post-mortem report (Ex.P3) from the doctor (PW-5). On 30.08.1997, PW9 returned from Bangalore FSL Office and PW-9 produced all the articles in re-sealed condition before PW10 and seized them. On the same day, he collected injury certificate of Laxman (PW4) as per Ex.P12. On 14.09.1997, PW-10 received FSL report as per Ex.P19 and Ex.P20.
11. After completing investigation, he filed the charge-sheet before JMFC, Shorapur on 29.09.1997. The JMFC Court, Shorapur, passed the order of committal on 19.01.1998 and the accused persons appeared before the Principal Sessions Judge, Gulbarga on 22.03.2002. The Principal Sessions Judge framed charges against the accused persons for the commission of offences under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302, 307 and 504 of the Indian Penal Code and all the accused persons 296 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The prosecution examined PW1 to PW10 as witnesses for the prosecution, got marked Ex.P1 to Ex.P21 as well as MOs. 1 to17 as exhibits and materials in support of the prosecution case and closed the prosecution evidence. The defence marked Ex.D1 in support of their case. The trial court, after appreciating the evidence on record, acquitted all the persons under Section 235 Cr.P.C. The order of acquittal was assailed before the High Court and vide order dated 31.05.2010, the High Court convicted A3 to A5 (present appellants) and upheld the acquittal order with respect to accused Nos. 1,2, 6, 7 and 8.
12. In the course of this proceeding, we have been informed that appellant no. 3 is no more, and the present appeal is confined only to appellant Nos. 1 and 2.
13. Before we proceed to lay down the case set up by the parties before us, we may briefly highlight the reasons that prevailed upon the trial court while ordering acquittal. The trial court, after appreciating the evidence on record, acquitted the accused persons by assigning the following reasons:
i. The evidence of eyewitness PW3 is not worthy of credit and his conduct after the alleged murder was artificial.
ii. PW3 witnessed the assault on the deceased as well as on PW4, as per the prosecution version, however, he chose to hid behind the bushes till the sunset as he got frightened.
iii. PW-3 admitted that there were number of buses plying on the route between Lingasgur to Shorapur and Gulbarga. However, his version, that he could catch the bus only on the next day at 6.00 A.M., is artificial. He could have availed the transport facility on 28.06.1997 itself after the assailants had left.
iv. PW-3 states that his relatives are residing in Nagaral village, which is 4 km from the scene, but he did not go and inform them.
v. PW-3 did not inform the people at Devpura or the passengers plying in the bus in which he travelled to [2024] 2 S.C.R. 297Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka go to Gurugunte. From there, he catched another bus to Aidbhavi village. The incident took place around 4 P.M. and it took more than 18 hours for PW-3 to inform the father of the deceased PW-2. In the meanwhile, although he had opportunity, he did not inform the out-post police, which must have come in the course of his journey from Devpura to Aidbhavi.
vi. PW-3 admitted that he was conscious that he should get PW-4 treated after the incident, yet he did not make any sincere effort to get him treated. The deceased and PW-4 were assaulted by the accused.
There was no reason for the accused persons to not assault PW-3. His version that he escaped and hid behind the bushes is artificial. Further, the evidence of PW-4 that he was unconscious till he was taken to hospital is artificial. There is no evidence to show the nature of treatment given to PW4 and to show his physical condition at Gulbarga Hospital.
vii. T h e f a t h e r ’s n a m e o f P W- 4 i s s h o w n a s Siddaramegowda, whereas in the MLC register the name of the father of PW-4 is shown as Narasappa.
viii. In the wound certificate, it is mentioned that PW-4 “self admitted” at the hospital. The doctor PW-8 states that PW-4 was unconscious. In the wound certificate of PW-4, it is stated that the assault took place in the night. Whereas, the FIR shows that the incident took place around 4 P.M. in the day hours. The Trial Court finds that the evidence of PW-3 and PW-4 is incredible and thus, acquitted the accused.
14. The High Court, in appeal, after re-appreciating the evidence on record, held that the post-mortem report supported the case of the prosecution that the death of Marthandappa was homicidal. It further held that the prosecution has successfully proved the motive and occurrences of incidents on the basis of evidence of PW-3 and PW-4. The High Court further held that Wound Certificate of PW-4 corroborated the evidence of PW-4 regarding the injuries caused to him in the assault.
298 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
15. On the question of credibility, the High Court held that PW-4 is an injured witness and he has categorically stated that A1, A2, A7 and A8 assaulted the deceased with clubs on the head and on back, and A3, A4 and A6 assaulted the deceased with axe. His evidence established that A7 assaulted the deceased with knife and he was assaulted by A3 with an axe. The High Court has arrived at the conclusion that evidence of PW-4 is quite natural and there is nothing to disbelieve his veracity. It has also been observed that PW-4, after the assault, was found lying unconscious. He was admitted to the hospital on the next date at 12.30 P.M. The contents of the wound certificate at Ex.P8 show that PW-4 was semi-conscious and it corroborates the version of PW-4 about his condition that he fell unconscious and was semi-conscious at the time when he was admitted to the hospital.
16. In those circumstances, the High Court has arrived at a conclusion that there is no reason to disbelieve the evidence of PW-4, and also that he was a witness to the assault on the deceased and was also a victim of assault.
17. The High Court also considered the evidence of PW-3 who was the eye witness of the incident. The High Court has observed that PW-3 certainly had several options, like informing by-standers at the bus-stop, going to Nagaral village or going to the police, but he went to the village of the deceased father at his Aidbhavi village as he was keen on informing PW-2, as he was the most appropriate person to be informed about the incident. In such circumstances, the High Court has arrived at the conclusion that the conduct of PW-3 in not informing others and going to Aidbhavi village to inform PW-2, could not be a reason to disbelieve his statement. The High Court has arrived a conclusion that the evidence of PW-3 and PW- 4, if read together, proves the alleged incident and the evidence of PW-3 and PW-4 establishes that Al, A2, A7 and A8 assaulted the deceased with clubs, however, there are no injuries reflected on the dead body of the deceased.
18. It has been further held that in respect of A3 to A6, the evidence of PW-3 and PW-4 is consistent and establishes their involvement in the assault and proves their guilt. The manner of assault in the overt acts of A3 to A6 corresponds with the injuries noted in the wound certificate and the post-mortem report. In those circumstances, the High Court has set aside the acquittal of A3, A4 and A5, and convicted them for offences punishable under Sections 302 read with Section [2024] 2 S.C.R. 299Mallappa & Ors. v. State of Karnataka 34 of the Indian Penal Code and confirmed the order of acquittal in respect of A1, A2, A7 and A8.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.