Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 90; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 165
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 7 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1776/2024
- Sections
- 3, 3(2), 3(1), 4, 4(2), 6, 6(2), 6(4), 10, 30, 9A, 9
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 165 : 2024 INSC 90 Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors.
v.
Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 1776 of 2024)
07 February 2024 [Vikram Nath and K.V. Viswanathan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether Appellant No.1 was entitled to the protection of ss.3 and 4, Maharashtra Temporary Extension of Period for Submitting Validity Certificate (for certain elections to Village Panchayats, Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis) Act, 2023; whether the proceedings of 19.06.2023 holding the No Confidence Motion against Appellant No.2 as not carried for want of the requisite votes is tenable.
Headnotes Maharashtra Temporary Extension of Period for Submitting Validity Certificate (for certain elections to Village Panchayats, Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis) Act, 2023 – ss.3, 4 – Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 – ss.35, 10(1A), 30(1A) – Maharashtra Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Denotified Tribes (Vimukta Jatis), Nomadic Tribes, Other Backward Classes and Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Act, 2000 – ss.3, 4 of the 2023 Act – Protection under – When not available – No Confidence Motion against Appellant No.2-Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat – Validity – Appellant No.1 if was a member of the Panchayat entitled to vote and covered by the protective umbrella u/ss.3 and 4:
Held: Temporary Extension Act was enacted since the Scrutiny Committees were overburdened with the work of verification of Caste Certificates and the elected members were facing difficulties in obtaining the Validity Certificates within the prescribed time – It aimed to protect the applicants whose applications were still pending before the Scrutiny Committee – The idea was that such elected candidates ought not to be deprived merely because of 166 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports non-issuance of Validity Certificates when the applications are still pending – Appellant No.1 stood automatically disqualified as a Member since he failed to produce the Validity Certificate within 12 months from the date of his election – The protective umbrella of s.3 of the Temporary Extension Act, 2023 will not be available to Appellant No.1 since he is hit by s.3(2)(b), as there was no valid application pending on the date of the commencement of the said Act – Appellant No.1 ceased to be a member because of the automatic disqualification – The contention that there was no rejection and that it was only a “filing” or “lodgment” of the application by the Scrutiny Committee, not accepted – The rejection in s.3(2)(b) will also include those cases where applications came to be rejected on account of defaults committed at the end of the applicants themselves – Proceedings of the Tahsildar dtd.19.06.2023 rejecting the No Confidence Motion on the ground that the voting requirement of three-fourth of the members “entitled to sit and vote”, was not fulfilled, cannot be sustained and was rightly set aside by the High Court – High Court also rightly set aside the rejection of the No Confidence Motion holding that the No Confidence Motion against Appellant No. 2-Sarpanch, was duly carried – Order of the High Court affirmed. [Paras 31, 39, 40, 42-44] Maharashtra Temporary Extension of Period for Submitting Validity Certificate (for certain elections to Village Panchayats, Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis) Act, 2023 – s.3(1)(b), (2)(b):
Held: s.3 covers the cases of persons who had applied to the Scrutiny Committee for verification of their Caste Certificate before the date of filing of the nomination papers and who were elected on the reserved seat; and whose applications were pending before the Scrutiny Committee on the date of commencement of the Act– It is mandated that they can produce the certificate within twelve months from the date of commencement of the Temporary Extension Act, 2023 i.e. till 09.07.2024 – Under s.3(1), the further period of twelve months from 10.07.2023 was for those whose applications were validly filed and pending and where their applications have been submitted before the date of nomination – Sub-section (2)
(b) clearly states that the provisions of sub-section (1) shall not apply where the member whose application of Validity Certificate had been rejected by the Scrutiny Committee. [Paras 31, 38] [2024] 2 S.C.R. 167Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors. Case Law Cited Shankar S/o Raghunath Devre (Patil) Vs. State of Maharashtra & Others. (2019) 3 SCC 220 – referred to.
Anant H. Ulahalkar & Anr. Vs. Chief Election Commissioner & Ors. 2017 (1) Mh.L.J. 431; Mandakani Kachru Kokane alias Mandakani Vishnu Godse Vs State of Maharashtra & Ors. 2021 (3) Mh.L.J. 221 – referred to.
List of Acts Maharashtra Temporary Extension of Period for Submitting Validity Certificate (for certain elections to Village Panchayats, Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis) Act, 2023; Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959; Maharashtra Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Denotified Tribes (Vimukta Jatis), Nomadic Tribes, Other Backward Classes and Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Act, 2000; Maharashtra Scheduled Castes, Denotified Tribes (Vimukta Jatis), Nomadic Tribes, Other Backward Classes and Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Rules, 2012; Maharashtra Municipal Councils, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Townships Act, 1965.
List of Keywords Caste Certificate; Verification of Caste Certificates; Validity Certificate; Scrutiny Committees; No Confidence Motion; Automatic disqualification; Sarpanch.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.1776 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.09.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WP No.7924 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Gaurav Agrawal, Manav, Mr./Ms. Suman Sharma, Muesh Kumar Tripathy, Ms. Swati Vaibhav, Advs. for the Appellants.
Vinay Navare, Sr. Adv., Anand Dilip Landge, Siddheshwar Kalel, Vivek Salunkhe, Aniruddha Joshi, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Raavi Sharma, Advs. for the Respondents.
168 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. Leave Granted.
2. The ‘war’ in this case is over the validity of a No Confidence Motion against Appellant No. 2 – Sushila Sitaram Kalel, the Sarpanch (Village head) of Jambulani Gram Panchayat. However, there is a ‘battle’ within, which entirely determines the result of the war. It is on the validity of the membership of Appellant No. 1 – Sudhir Vilas Kalel in the Panchayat. A Motion of No Confidence is to be carried by not less than three-fourth of the total number of members who are entitled, to ‘sit’ and ‘vote’. If the Appellant No. 1 was entitled to ‘Sit’ as a member on 19.06.2023, then the No Confidence Motion against Appellant No.2 cannot ‘Stand’, to deploy a Denning-esque phrase. The High Court has found against the appellants. Aggrieved, they are before us in appeal.
3. Was the Appellant No.1, in law, a member of the Panchayat, entitling him to vote, is the question that arises for consideration in this case. Is the Appellant No. 1 covered by the protective umbrella under Sections 3 and 4 of the Maharashtra Temporary Extension of Period for Submitting Validity Certificate (for certain elections to Village Panchayats, Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis) Act, 2023 [hereinafter referred to as the “Temporary Extension Act, 2023”]? If the answer is in the affirmative, the election of the Appellant No. 1 as a reserved Member in the election of the Gram Panchayat of Village Jambulani would stand validated. Consequently, the No Confidence Motion expressing No Confidence in the Appellant No. 2 – Sushila Sitaram Kalel (the Sarpanch) would also stand nullified. If Appellant No. 1 is held not to be entitled to the benefit of Section 3 of the Temporary Extension Act, 2023, then he would be deemed to have vacated his seat and consequently, the No Confidence Motion would stand carried. For a fuller understanding, the background facts and the statutory regime need to be set out in some detail. Brief facts and the Legislative Regime:
4. On 30.12.2020, the Appellant No. 1 filed his nomination papers for contesting elections as a Member of the Panchayat of Village Jambulani, District Satara on a seat reserved for the OBC category. [2024] 2 S.C.R. 169Sudhir V i l a s K a l e l & O r s . v . B a p u Rajaram K a l e l & O r s . As early as on 03.02.2013 itself, the Appellant No. 1 was issued a Caste Certificate by the Sub Divisional Officer, District Satara certifying that he belongs to ‘Lonari’ Caste which is an Other Backward Class. He had on the same day of filing his nomination papers i.e. on 30.12.2020 applied for a Validity Certificate. This Validity Certificate is an essential requirement under the Maharashtra Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, De-notified Tribes (Vimukta Jatis), Nomadic Tribes, Other Backward Classes and Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Act, 2000 [hereinafter referred to as the “Caste Certificate Act, 2000”]. There are elaborate rules framed under this Act which will be discussed later in the judgment.
5. Under Section 3 of this Act, any person belonging to Other Backward Class for the purpose of contesting for any elective post in any local authority, should apply in such form and in such manner as may be prescribed, to the Competent Authority for the issuance of a Caste Certificate. Under Section 4 of this Act, the Competent Authority is entitled to issue a Caste Certificate. This is a Certificate which the Appellant No. 1 possessed on 03.02.2013. However, this alone is not conclusive. Under Section 4(2), the Caste Certificate issued by the Competent Authority would be valid subject to the verification and grant of Validity Certificate by the Scrutiny Committee. Under Section 6 of this Act, the Government is authorized to constitute a Scrutiny Committee and prescribe the area of its jurisdiction. Under Section 6(2) of this Act, after obtaining the Caste Certificate from the Competent Authority, any person, desirous of availing of the benefits or concessions provided to the said caste, is authorized to make an application, well in time, in such form and in such manner as may be prescribed to the concerned Scrutiny Committee for the verification of such Caste Certificate and issue of a Validity Certificate. Under Section 6(4) of this Act, the Scrutiny Committee was to follow such procedure for verification of the Caste Certificate and adhere to the time limit for verification and grant of Validity Certificate as prescribed.
6. The Rules called the Maharashtra Scheduled Castes, De-notified Tribes (Vimukta Jatis), Nomadic Tribes, Other Backward Classes and Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Rules, 2012 [hereinafter referred to as the “2012 Rules”] have been framed. Rule 11 prescribes the constitution of the Scrutiny Committee. Rule 14 sets out that any person desirous 170 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of availing of the benefits and concessions provided to the reserved category shall submit an application in the prescribed form with an affidavit to the concerned Scrutiny Committee for verification of his caste claim and issuance of Caste Validity Certificate well in time. Rule 15 mandates that the application for verification of Caste Certificate under Rule 14 shall be filed or submitted well in time in such form and in such manner as may be prescribed in Rule 17. Further Rule 16 provides for the information to be supplied by the applicant. It states that to enable the Scrutiny Committee to decide the application expeditiously, the documents/information set out therein, was to be produced. Apart from setting out certain documents, subclause (f) provides for the furnishing of other relevant evidence, if any, subject to admissibility. Explanation 2 of Rule 16 speaks of the applicant undertaking the production of original documents as and when required by the Scrutiny Committee.
7. Rule 17, which prescribes the procedure of Scrutiny Committee, is significant for this case. Sub-Rules 1 to Sub- Rules 3 of Rule 17 are extracted herein below:
“17 (1) On receipt of application, the Scrutiny Committee shall ensure that the application and the information supplied therewith is complete in all respects and to carry out scrutiny of the application.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, the claimant or applicant or complainant shall be personally responsible for removal of objections raised by Scrutiny Committee, if any, within two weeks or within such extended period, which shall not be more than six weeks, failing which the claim or application or complaint shall be disposed of, by appreciating available records and such decision may be communicated to the applicant by the Scrutiny Committee.
(3) The incomplete application may be rejected by recording reasons.”
8. As is clear from the above, Rule 17 (2) states that applicant was personally responsible for removal of objections raised by the Scrutiny Committee within the time prescribed. Sub-Rule 3 of Rule 17 categorically states that incomplete application may be rejected by recording reasons.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 171Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors.
9. For the purpose of adjudicating this case, alongside the above statutes, certain provisions of the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959 [hereinafter referred to as the “Panchayats Act”] which come into play, need to be set out and analyzed. Section 10-1A, reads as follows:
“10-1A. Person contesting election for reserved seat to submit Caste Certificate and Validity Certificate.
- Every person desirous of contesting election to a seat reserved for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes or, as the case may be, Backward Class of Citizens, shall be required to submit, alongwith the nomination paper, Caste Certificate issued by the Competent Authority and the Validity Certificate issued by the Scrutiny Committee in accordance with the provisions of the Maharashtra Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, De-notified Tribes (Vimukta Jatis), Nomadic Tribes, other Backward Classes and Special Backward Category (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Caste Certificate Act, 2000:
Provided that, for the General or by-elections for which the last date of filing of nomination falls on or before the 31 st December 20231, in accordance with the election programme declared by the State Election Commission, a person who has applied to the Scrutiny Committee for verification of his Caste Certificate before the date of filing of the nomination papers but who has not received the Validity Certificate on the date of filing of the nomination papers shall submit, along with the nomination papers, -
(i) a true copy of the application preferred by him to the Scrutiny Committee for issuance of the Validity Certificate or any other proof of having made such application to the Scrutiny Committee; and
(ii) an undertaking that he shall submit, within a period of twelve months from the date on which he is declared elected, the Validity Certificate issued by the Scrutiny Committee:
1 (This date was originally 28.02.2021, at the time of the election in question) 172 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Provided further that, if such person fails to produce the Validity Certificate within a period of twelve months from the date on which he is declared elected, his election shall be deemed to have been terminated retrospectively and he shall be disqualified for being a member.’’ A similar provision in the form of Section 30(1A) exists for persons contesting for the reserved office of Sarpanch.
10. In view of the above provision, every person desirous of contesting election to a membership in the reserved category, shall submit alongwith the nomination paper, Caste Certificate issued by the Competent Authority and the Validity Certificate issued by the Scrutiny Committee in accordance with Caste Certificate Act, 2000. The proviso sets out that for elections for which the last date of filing of nomination fell on or before the date prescribed in the proviso, a person who has applied to the Scrutiny Committee for verification of his Caste Certificate before the date of filing of the nomination papers but who has not yet received the Validity Certificate shall submit, along with the nomination papers, an undertaking that he shall submit the same, within a period of twelve months from the date on which he is declared elected. The further proviso sets out that if such person fails to produce the Validity Certificate within a period of twelve months from the date on which he is declared elected, his election shall be deemed to have been terminated retrospectively and the person was to be disqualified for being a member.
11. In pari materia provision exists in the Maharashtra Municipal Councils, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Townships Act, 1965 in the form of Section 9A therein.
12. A raging legal debate arose in Maharashtra about the nature of these provisions – are they mandatory or are they directory? The issue was settled by a Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Anant H. Ulahalkar & Anr. Vs. Chief Election Commissioner & Ors. [2017 (1) Mh.L.J. 431]. This judgment of the Full Bench was affirmed by this Court in the case of Shankar S/o Raghunath Devre (Patil) Vs. State of Maharashtra & Others.[ (2019) 3 SCC 220].
13. There were earlier divergent views in the High Court. The parties contending that the provisions were “directory”, primarily argued that the time taken for disposal by the Scrutiny Committee was not in [2024] 2 S.C.R. 173Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors. their control. According to them, as long as the Validity Certificate was produced within a reasonable time, the strict time limit provided in the statute should be construed as directory and that elections should not be invalidated for the said reason. On the other hand, the proponents of the theory that the provision was mandatory contended that the statute is couched in mandatory terms, with the use of the word ‘shall’ and that consequences had been provided for non-compliance. The Full Bench, after considering the statutory provision and the decided cases, in para 45 and 46 of the judgment first held the following:
“45. In case of Sujit Vasant Patil (supra), the Full Bench of this Court, in the context of inter play between similar Municipal Legislations and the Caste Act, 2000, has held that the legislature expects a person to claim benefit of contesting to a reserved post only after obtaining Validity Certificate from the Scrutiny Committee, though it also permits a person to claim such benefit on the basis of a tentative caste certificate issued by the Competent Authority, if such a person is willing to take the risk. Such reasoning is reflected in paragraphs 12A, 12B and 12C.
Since paragraph 12B is most relevant, it is transcribed below for reference of convenience:— “12B. Thus the scheme is that a person who obtains a caste certificate has to himself apply to the Scrutiny Committee for scrutiny of his caste certificate, so that he can secure a valid certificate from the Scrutiny Committee, and it is only after the Scrutiny Committee issuing a valid certificate that the caste certificate issued in favour of the person by the Competent Authority becomes final. In our opinion, the scheme of subsection (2) of section 6 is that any candidate who desires to avail of any benefit available to backward class has to get a caste certificate as also the validity certificate before he makes a claim for the benefits. But if a candidate chooses to make claim to the benefits on the basis of a tentative certificate namely a certificate issued by the Competent Authority, he takes the risk of his losing the benefits that he has claimed and obtained and also being visited with penal consequences on the refusal of the Scrutiny Committee to validate his caste claim. The Act 174 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports contemplates conscious decision being made by a person at the time of claiming benefits. The Legislature expects a person to claim the benefits only after obtaining the validity certificate, but the Legislature also permits a person to claim the benefits on the basis of a tentative certificate issued by the Competent Authority, if he is willing to take the risk mentioned above. In our opinion, therefore, the validity certificate is one of the essential ingredient of the candidate being qualified to contest for the reserved seat….”
(emphasis supplied)
46. According to Sujit Vasant Patil (supra), therefore, a person who seeks to contest election to reserved posts without compliance with the general rule of producing Validity Certificate along with nomination papers, ‘takes a risk’. The first proviso to section 9-A, in such a case, makes this position quite clear by requiring such person to furnish a statutory undertaking to produce Validity Certificate within six months from the date of election. The second proviso, in terms, provides for consequence in case of breach. Such person, having taken the risk, cannot, in the absence of any ambiguity in the provision, be permitted to wriggle out from the consequences of breach so clearly and statutorily provided in the provision itself. Otherwise, such person, will avail of a conditional concession, without, fulfilling the condition subject to which such concession came to be granted in the first place by the provision.”
The Legislature expects a person claiming the benefit of contesting in a reserved post to be in possession of both the Caste Certificate and the Validity Certificate at the time of filing the nomination. The allowance to contest by submitting the Caste Certificate alone was with the undertaking that he would produce the Validity Certificate within the stipulated time, and this was the risk that the candidate was taking. It was a ‘risk’ because a Validity Certificate which he ought to have ordinarily possessed on the date of nomination being unavailable, he or she is granted the concession of contesting, subject to the undertaking. In the event of non-production within the stipulated time, even an elected candidate would automatically stand disqualified.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 175Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors.
14. Thereafter, the Full Bench went on to hold as follows in para 80 and 81, while construing the nature of the time limit for production of the Validity Certificate, as it then stood.
“80. ...If the legislature, for a limited period of time, taking into consideration pendency of applications for issuance of Validity Certificate before the Scrutiny Committee grants some exemptions or concession to persons who have applied for issue of Validity Certificate before the date of filing nomination papers, but who have not received such Validity Certificate on the date of filing of nomination papers, subject to such persons producing the Validity Certificate “within period of six months from the date of election”, there is no reason to treat the stipulation as to time has (sic.) merely directory and thereby enlarge or extend the exemption or the concession granted by the legislature.
81. If, the intention of the legislature was to grant exemption from the requirement of producing Validity Certificate, until, the elected candidate’s application is disposed of by the Scrutiny Committee, nothing prevented the legislature from saying so expressly or at least by necessary implication. Instead, in this case, and perhaps, for good reason, the legislature has consciously deemed it appropriate to insist that the person submits an undertaking that he shall produce the Validity Certificate within six months and further, the legislature, in clear, unambiguous and express terms has provided that upon the failure of such person to produce the Validity Certificate within six months from the date of election, his election shall be deemed to have been retrospectively terminated and he shall be disqualified for being a Councillor. If, the stipulation as to time is construed as directory, then, the legislative intent, so clearly expressed, will be defeated. The significant portions of the provision will be rendered a mere surplusage. In essence, this Court would be rewriting the statute on the basis of its own value judgments or notions of equity and inequity.”
176 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports After holding that the provision is mandatory, the Full Bench held that failure to produce the Validity Certificate from the Scrutiny Committee within the stipulated time would mean that the election was deemed to have been terminated retrospectively and the person was to be disqualified. It also held that retrospective termination of the election and disqualification were automatic in the following words:- “98. In the present case also the legislature in enacting section 9-A has provided for a statutory fiction, which is evident from the use of expression “his election shall be deemed to have been terminated retrospectively and he shall be disqualified being a Councillor”. The statutory fiction must be allowed to have its full play. No other provision or reason has been pointed out to take the view that consequences prescribed under second proviso to section 9-A are not automatic or would require any further adjudication once it is established that the person elected has failed to produce the Validity Certificate within a stipulated period of six months from the date of his election.
99. The validation of caste claim of the elected Councillor by the Scrutiny Committee beyond the prescribed period would have no effect upon the statutory consequences prescribed under the second proviso to section 9-A i.e. deemed retrospective termination of the election of such Councillor and his disqualification for being a Councillor. The subsequent validation or issue of the Validity Certificate will therefore be irrelevant for the purpose of restoration of the Councillor’s election but, such validation will obviously entitle him to contest the election to be held on account of termination of his election and the consequent vacancy caused thereby.
100. In the result, we hold that the time limit of six months prescribed in the two provisos to section 9-A of the said Act, within which an elected person is required to produce the Validity Certificate from the Scrutiny Committee is mandatory.”
Further, in terms of second proviso to section 9-A if a person fails to produce Validity Certificate within a period of six months from the date on which he is elected, his election shall be deemed to have been terminated retrospectively and he shall be disqualified for being a Councillor.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 177Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors. Such retrospective termination of his election and disqualification for being a Councillor would be automatic and validation of his caste claim after the stipulated period would not result in restoration of his election.
The questions raised, stand answered accordingly.”
15. This statutory background is essential to interpret the Temporary Extension Act, 2023. To consider whether the Appellant No. 1 is entitled to the protection of the Temporary Extension Act, 2023, it is necessary to recapitulate the facts of the present case. The Appellant No. 1 obtained his Caste Certificate on 03.02.2013. Only on 30.12.2020 (the date of his nomination) he submitted an application for the Validity Certificate to the Caste Scrutiny Committee. At the time of filing of his nomination, he also filed an undertaking that he will produce the Caste Validity Certificate within twelve months from the date of his election. On 18.01.2021, the elections were held and on 21.01.2021, the results were declared and the Appellant No. 1 was declared elected. The twelve months period expired on 20.01.2022.
16. On 30.12.2020, when he filed the application online to the Scrutiny Committee for obtaining the Validity Certificate, a receipt was issued to him. In the receipt, the following endorsement appears:- “I have been informed that, within seven days will file declaration otherwise the matter should be closed.”
Thereafter, it is undisputed that on 01-03/04/2021, the District Caste Certificate Verification Committee, Satara made the following order. This order also covered the case of the Appellant No. 1 along with 3013 other applicants. The order reads as under:
“As per above read No 1 the intended contestants of the elections of Local Bodies. Municipal Councils, Municipal Corporations have submitted their application for their cast certificates with the office of the Committee. As per the read No 2 and 3 above the elected candidates in local bodies, municipal councils and corporations from reserved seats, have to submit their cast verification certificate within one year from the election.
As per read No. 4 above notification regarding decision of the election dtd 23.03.2021 of Collector (Election Branch) and as per the notification submitted by the elected 178 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports candidates the committee scrutinized that, whether these applicants are elected in such elections or not? After scrutiny it found that, these applicant candidates have not been elected in the elections from the reserve seats. As such elected candidates have not filed the notification of elected candidates in time, this office cannot take decision in this regard. Hence this proposal has been filed as per the provisions of Rules 17(2)(3) of Maharashtra Rules of verification of caste certificate SC, ST, OBC, Spl BC 2012.” It is clear from the operative portion of the order that since the elected candidates have not submitted the notification of being elected, in time, the office was not able to take any decision in that regard. In view of that, the proposal was ‘filed’ as per the provisions of Rule 17 (2)(3) of the 2012 Rules.
17. Before we take up for consideration the interpretation of Sections 3 and 4 of the Temporary Extension Act, 2023, one judgment of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in the case of Mandakani Kachru Kokane alias Mandakani Vishnu Godse Vs State of Maharashtra & Ors. [2021 (3) Mh.L.J. 221] needs to be referred to. In the said judgment, in para 48, 49, 50(ii) and 50(iii), the following significant directions were issued:
“48. Shri Satyajit Dighe, learned counsel for the Petitioner rightly submitted that impugned order of the Caste Scrutiny Committee was passed almost on the last day of twelve months mandatory period and therefore, no time was left for approaching this Court which is the only remedy available i.e. the constitutional remedy. Thus Petitioner’s right to approach this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is violated….
49. However, in view of the law laid down by the Full Bench of this Court in the case of Anant H. Ulharkar (supra)
Section 30(1A) of the Maharashtra Village Panchayat Act, 1958 is mandatory and therefore time limit provided therein cannot be extended. However, we are constrained to issue directions to all the Caste Scrutiny Committees to decide the matters much before the mandatory period of twelve months if the aforesaid provisions are applicable. However, this will be subject to the condition [2024] 2 S.C.R. 179Sudhir Vilas Kalel & Ors. v. Bapu Rajaram Kalel & Ors. that the applicant completely co-operates in disposal of the proceedings in time bound manner and do not seek unnecessary adjournments.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.