In Re: T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India and Others
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 59; [2024] 1 S.C.R. 704
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Aravind Kumar, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 24 Jan 2024
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 202/1995
- Sections
- 22, 2, 3(2)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 1 S.C.R. 704 : 2024 INSC 59 In Re: T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v.
Union of India and Others (Writ Petition (Civil) No.202 of 1995)
24 January 2024 [B. R. Gavai, Aravind Kumar* and Prashant Kumar Mishra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to criteria issued for the identification of private ‘forest’ land in the State of Goa.
Headnotes Environmental laws – Forests – Criteria issued by the State of Goa for the identification of private ‘forest’ land in the State of Goa – Challenge to, by the appellant seeking change in the criteria:
Held: Existing criteria for identification of private forests in the State of Goa are adequate and valid, thus, requires no alteration – Criteria of the canopy density of 0.4 and minimum area of 5 ha if reduced to 0.1 and 1 ha as contended by the appellant, would result in the plantations of coconut, orchards, bamboo, palm, supari, cashew, etc., grown by farmers on their private lands into the category of ‘private forest’ – Even for a minor development on the concerned land, the permission of the Government under the FCA 1980, for the landholders, would become indispensable – Also none of the States have adopted the 0.1 density criteria – Furthermore, on the one hand, the appellant is challenging the criteria adopted by the Sawant and Karapurkar Committees for the identification of inter alia private forests and on the other hand has relied on the same criteria, the the appellant cannot be permitted to approbate and reprobate – Also the appellant having not challenged the criteria as prescribed by the Expert Committee and published in the public notice is estopped from raising the said issue at this stage – Process of physical demarcation of such forests in State of Goa seems to have attained finality by virtue of the Reports and the State of Goa has issued a gazette notification notifying 46.11 sq. km. as [2024] 1 S.C.R. 705T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s private forest – Furthermore, the application of criteria cannot be universally standardized across the country, as it is contingent upon the specific geographical conditions prevalent in each State, and as a result, the criteria may vary from one State to another – Thus, the task of identifying forest areas expressly delegated to Expert Committees to be constituted by State Governments, thereby recognising that there can be no uniform criteria for such identification across the country. [Paras 63, 67-69] Environmental laws – Forests – ‘Forest Cover’ and ‘Recorded Forest Area’ – Distinction between:
Held: ‘Forest Cover’ encompasses all lands exceeding 1 (one) hectare in size with a tree canopy exceeding 10%, regardless of land use, ownership, and legal status – This category may encompass various features like orchards, bamboo groves, palm plantations, etc., and is evaluated through remote sensing techniques – Term ‘Recorded Forest Area’ or ‘Forest Area’ refers to all geographic areas officially designated as ‘Forests’ in government records – Recorded forest areas primarily include Reserved Forests and Protected Forests which are notified under the provisions of the Forest Act, 1927, or equivalent State Acts – Recorded forest area may also cover regions recorded as forests in revenue records or established as such under any State Act or local laws. [Para 66] Case Law Cited Shivanand Salgaocar v. Tree Officer & Ors. Writ Petition No.162 of 1987; T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India [1996] 9 Suppl. SCR 982 : (1997) 2 SCC 267;
Goa foundation v. State Government of Goa Writ Petition (Civil) No. 181 of 2001; TN Godavarman Thirumulpad v.
Union of India & Ors. [2008] 6 SCR 321 : (2008) 7 SCC 126; Lafarge Umiam Mining Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India and Ors [2011] 7 SCR 954 : (2011) 7 SCALE 242; Tata Housing Development Corporation v. Goa Foundation (2003) 11 SCC 714; Nisarga v. Asst. Conservator of Forests OA No.19 (THC) of 2013; T.N. Godavarman Thirumalpad (87) v. Union of India [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 552 : (2006) 1 SCC 1; Park-Anand Arya v. Noida [2010] 15 SCR 783 : (2011) 1 SCC 744 – referred to.
706 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Acts National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980; Goa Daman and Diu Preservation of Trees Act, 1984; Scheduled Tribe and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006; Forest Rights Act, 2006; Forest Act, 1927. List of Keywords Forests; Forest land; Identification of forest; Demarcation of private forest; Sawant Committee, Karapurkar Committee; Sharma Reports; Deep Shikha Committee; Degraded forest lands; Private forests; Open forest; Forest Survey of India; Tree canopy density; Non-forestry purpose; Net Present Value; Compensatory Afforestation costs; Central Empowered Committee; Very dense forest; Moderate dense forest; Forest cover; Forest area; Policy decision, Forest Clearance; Forest identification criteria; Conversion Sanad; Principle of sustainable development; Deemed forest; Res judicata; Estopped; Minimum Mappable Area; India State of Forest Report 1989; India State of Forest Report 1999; India State of Forest Report, 2008; India State of Forest Report, 2017; Coastal Regulation Zone Notification; Ecologically Sensitive Area; Areas under riverine and other wetlands; Expert Appraisal Committee; Deforestation; Recorded Forest Area; Remote sensing techniques; Geographical ecosystem; Specific geography; Approbate and reprobate.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (Civil) No.202 of
(UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA)
With Civil Appeal No.12234-35 of 2018 Appearances for Parties Harish N. Salve, A.D.N. Rao, Ms. Aparajita Singh, Sr. Advs. [A.Cs.], K. Parameshwar, Siddhartha Chowdhury, Advs. [A.Cs.], M.V. Mukunda, Ms. Kanti, Ms. Aarti Gupta, Chinmay Kalgaonkar, Advs.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 707T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G., A.N.S. Nadkarni, Sr. Adv., Ms. Shagun Thakur, Ms. Manisha Chava, Gurmeet Singh Makker, Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, Ms. Suhashini Sen, S. S. Rebello, Shyam Gopal, Raghav Sharma, Sughosh Subramanyam, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Atul Sharma, Salvador Santosh Rebello, Ms. Deepti Arya, Ms. Arzu Paul, Siddhant Gupta, Ms. Manisha Gupta, Rishikesh Haridas, Abhishek Atrey, Ms. Vidyottma Jha, Advs for the appearing parties. Petitioner/Applicant-in-person Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Aravind Kumar, J.
1. The present civil appeals arise out of common order dated 30.07.2014 passed by the National Green Tribunal (Western Zone) Bench, Pune1 in Application No.14 (THC) of 2013 (WZ) and Application No.16 (THC) of 2013 (WZ) filed by the appellant, whereunder the NGT has disposed of both the applications on the ground that the issue of determination of criteria for the identification of ‘forest’ forms part of the proceedings in TN Godavarman Case 2 which is presently seized by this Court and hence, granted liberty to the appellant to approach this Court for the remedy. Therefore, the appellant has filed the present civil appeals under Section 22 of the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010, 3 seeking the modification of such criteria.
2. We have heard the arguments of Mr. Sanjay Parikh, Senior Advocate for the Appellant assisted by Ms. Srishti Agnihotri, Ld. Advocate, Mr. Nalin Kohli, Ld. Advocate for State of Goa assisted by Mr. Sanjay Upadhyay, Ld. Advocate, Ms. Suhashini Sen, Ld. Advocate for Union of India and Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, Ld. Senior Advocate for impleading applicant, perused the case-papers.
FACTUAL MATRIX IN BRIEF
3. The challenge in the present appeals revolves around the criteria issued by the Respondent(s) i.e., the State of Goa and Others for the identification of ‘forests’ in the State, hence, it is important to trace 1 Hereinafter to be read as “NGT”.
2 In Re: TN Godavarman Thirumulpad (Writ Petition No.202 of 1995). 3 Hereinafter to be referred as “NGT Act, 2010”.
708 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the history of adoption of these criteria which are under challenge before us. Accordingly, in the subsequent paragraphs we have traced the brief history of these criteria.
4. Pursuant to the Judgement of the High Court of Bombay in Shivanand Salgaocar v. Tree Officer & Ors.4 declaring the application of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 19805 to all lands, whether government or privately owned, the Conservator of Forests, State of Goa, in 1991 set out the guidelines for identifying ‘forest’ in private properties. Vide letter dated 04.10.1991 the attention of the Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF) was sought on the said guidelines with a request to issue suitable guidelines to implement the FCA 1980 on the basis of the aforesaid decision of the Bombay High Court. The guidelines were as follows:
“Criteria for application of Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 to private forests.
i) Extent of area: Long term viability of a piece of forest land is an important consideration. Obviously, very small patches of forest cannot be viable in the long run from conservation Point of view. Therefore, a minimum extent of area will have to be determined to which the Forest (Cons.) Act, 1980 would be applicable in private and revenue areas not recorded as ‘forest’. I propose that this area should be at least 5 hectares. It is not worthy that the Forest (Cons.) Act, 1980 and guidelines made there under do not prescribe any such minimum area for application of the Act.
ii) Proximity and/or contiguity: The proximity of the private forests concerned to a larger forest area and / or its contiguity with the later area should also be an important aspect to consider while examining such areas.
iii) Composition of crop: It is important to prescribe minimum standards in terms of crop composition in order to distinguish forest species from horticultural species. This is particularly relevant in State like Goa where occurrence 4 Writ Petition No.162 of 1987.
5 Hereinafter to be read as “FCA 1980”.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 709T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s of large number of cashew, jackfruit and coconut trees in private areas is a common feature. We may perhaps prescribe that at least 75 of the crop should comprise of forest species.
iv) Crown density: It would not be meaningful to apply the Forest (Cons.) Act, 1980 to degraded and open areas under private ownership. Therefore, a minimum crown density of 40% may be adopted as a standard assessing the applicability of the Act in such private and revenue areas which are not recorded as ‘forests’ in the land records.” [Emphasis supplied]
5. By an order dated 12.12.1996 in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India6 , this Court explained that the word “forest” for the purpose of Section 2(i) of the FCA 1980 must be understood according to its dictionary meaning, and would cover “all statutorily recognised forests, whether designated as reserved, protected or otherwise”. This Court further explained that the term “forest land”, occurring in Section 2 would include not only “forest” as understood in the dictionary sense, but also “any area recorded as forest in the Government record irrespective of the ownership”.
6. Further, this Court vide order dated 12.12.1996 in TN Godavarman Case (supra) directed all the States to constitute an expert committee for the following tasks:
“(i) Identify areas which are “forests”, irrespective of whether they are so notified, recognised or classified under any law, and irrespective of the ownership of the land of such forest;
(ii) identify areas which were earlier forests but stand degraded, denuded or cleared; and
(iii) identify areas covered by plantation trees belonging to the Government and those belonging to private persons.”
7. The Government of Goa, to implement the said order, constituted the Sawant Committee in 19977 which identified a total of 46.89 sq. kms as private forest. Thereafter the Karapurkar Committee
6 (1997) 2 SCC 267.
7 Under the Chairmanship of Shri SM Sawant on 24.01.1997. 710 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports was constituted in 2000 8 to identify the remaining areas. Since the Karapurkar Committee suggested a revisit to exclude some of the forest areas already identified by the Sawant Committee, the present appellant herein, Goa Foundation, filed Writ Petition (Civil) No.181 of 20019 before this court challenging the appointment of the Karapurkar Committee. Meanwhile, the Karapurkar Committee submitted its final report and identified 20.18 sq. kms of private forests. Both the Committees for identification of an area as private forest followed the same criteria as was formulated by the Forest Department of Goa in 1991. However, the task of both the Committees was incomplete as some areas were left unidentified. This Court vide order dated 10.02.2006 disposed of the W.P. (C) No.181 of 2001 in following terms:- “……bulk of private forests in the State of Goa still remains to be identified and the same is being sacrificed in collusion with developers and vested interest persons and no action has been taken by the State Government to set up a fresh committee that will bring a finality to the order dated 12.12.1996 passed in WP Civil No. 202/1995. In substance, the prayer in the application is for appointment of another committee or for consideration of the issue by the Central Empowered Committee to identify the private forests. These issues, we are afraid, do not arise out of the writ petition which has become infructuous on Karapurkar Committee and Sawant Committee having submitted their reports. In case, the petitioner has any further relief to seek, it may, in accordance with law, file a fresh substantive petition before an appropriate forum which would be considered on its own merits”.
8. As a result of the order dated 10.02.2006, the present appellant i.e., Goa Foundation, filed Writ Petition No.334 of 2006 for directions to the State Government of Goa to complete the process of identification of forest and to identify the degraded forest lands in accordance with this Court’s order dated 12.12.1996.
8 Under the Chairmanship of Dr. H. Karapurkar on 04.09.2000. 9 Goa foundation v. State Government of Goa.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 711T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s
9. The State Government appointed two new Committees10 to identify the remaining areas of private forests in North and South Goa districts that had not been identified by the previous Committee(s). The criteria used by these Committees to identify private forest were same as adopted earlier.
10. Further, the Appellant filed another Writ Petition being W.P. No.495 of 2010 before the High Court of Bombay, seeking the quashing of criteria pertaining to the canopy density which should not be less than 0.4. It was the Appellant’s case that the non-consideration of forest areas having canopy density of 0.1-0.4 (10-40%) was contrary to the criteria allegedly accepted by this Court in the order dated 28.03.200811. Hence, appellant claimed that category of open forest or degraded forest having canopy density of 10-40% were totally omitted from the identification process. Subsequently the petition was amended and the criteria of minimum 5 (five) Hectare was also challenged in view of the affidavit filed by the Forest Survey of India12 wherein the forest cover was defined as being “all lands more than 1 ha in area, with tree canopy density of more than 10% irrespective of ownership and legal status”. Meanwhile, by a notification dated 27.11.2012, the State of Goa again constituted two Committees 13 to identify the balance areas of private forests that had not been covered by the previous Committees. The criteria for identification of forest lands were same as followed earlier.
11. The Bombay High Court vide order dated 17.10.2013 transferred both the Writ Petitions14 to the NGT which were renumbered as Application No.14 (THC) of 201315 and Application No.16 (THC) of 2013 16 . The NGT by the impugned order has set aside both the applications and hence the appellant is before this Court. 10 The North Goa District Committee headed by K.G. Sharma and the South Goa District Committee headed by P.V. Sawant on 03.02.2010.
11 TN Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India & Ors. (2008) 7 SCC 126. 12 Hereinafter to be read as “FSI”
13 The North Goa Forest Division Committee headed by V.T. Thomas and the South Goa Forest Division Committee headed by Francisco Araujo.
14 W.P. No. 495 of 2010 & W.P. No. 334 of 2006.
15 Writ Petition No. 495 of 2010.
16 Writ Petition No. 334 of 2006.
712 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
12. It is pertinent to mention that this Court vide order dated 04.02.2015, converted the Civil Appeal No.37942 of 2014 filed by Goa Foundation in IA No. 3845 of 2015 in WP No. 202 of 1995 and passed the following directions:
“In the meanwhile, we direct that the respondents herein will not issue any ‘No Objection Certificate’ for the conversion of any plot that has natural vegetation with tree canopy density in excess of 0.1 and an area above one hectare.”
13. It is pertinent to note that the present appeal originally came to be filed on 19.11.2014 as Civil Appeal No.37942 of 2014 assailing the final judgment dated 30.07.2014 passed by NGT. Thereafter, this Court vide Order dated 04.02.2015 converted the Civil Appeal No.37942 of 2014 filed by present appellant to I.A. No.3845 of 2015 in the proceedings before this Court in W.P. No.202 of 1995 (T.N. Godavarman case). Vide order dated 04.02.2015, this Court issued a direction to State of Goa to not issue any ‘No Objection Certificate’ for conversion of any plot that has natural vegetation with tree canopy density in excess of 0.1 and an area above one hectare. Subsequent to Order dated 04.02.2015 of this Court, Respondent No.1 (i.e., State of Goa) filed I.A. No.40261 of 2017 for modification and clarification of Order dated 04.02.2015 of this Court. Thereafter, on 25.10.2018, this Court vide order dated 25.10.2018 passed in W.P. No.202 of 1995 directed to restore I.A. No.3485 filed by present appellant to its original status of a civil appeal and further it directed that I.A. No.40261 of 2017 filed by Respondent No.1 will be heard along with the said civil appeal. Accordingly, I.A. No.3845 in W.P. No.202 of 1995 came to be re-numbered as Civil Appeal No.12234-12235 of 2018, which are the present civil appeals for adjudication before us. In the present civil appeals, I.A. No.116495 of 2022, came to be filed by Confederation of Real Estate Developer’s Association of India (hereinafter referred to as “CREDAI”), seeking permission to be impleaded as party respondent, along with the said I.A., CREDAI has also filed I.A. No.116496 of 2022, wherein the impleading party sought vacation of Order dated 04.02.2015. Accordingly, the respondents in the present civil appeals along with the impleading party (i.e., CREDAI) are seeking to challenge the reliefs prayed for by the present appellant and have also sought vacation of the exparte interim order dated 04.02.2015 passed by this Court in W.P. No.202 of 1995.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 713T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India and Others
DISCUSSION PERTAINING TO IMPUGNED JUDGEMENT DATED
30.07.2014 PASSED BY NGT:
14. It was the contention of the appellant before the NGT that the subject applications raised the issue of identification and demarcation of private forests in the State of Goa as a result of this Court’s order dated 12.12.1996 in TN Godavarman Case (supra) as per which the State Governments were required to identify and demarcate the forest area and degraded forest areas.
15. The appellant stated before NGT that there was no basis for criteria No.(iii) in the guidelines of 1991, which related to canopy density, as there are several forest areas, which are presently degraded and having canopy density of less than 0.4 but which were originally dense or medium dense forests and which must, accordingly, be identified as forests. It was also submitted that such lands cannot be unilaterally diverted to non-forestry purpose except with the prior approval under the FCA 1980. It was submitted that if criteria No.(iii) was accepted there would be no compliance with the directions given in terms of reference No.2 of the order dated 12.12.1996.
16. To back its contentions, the appellant relied upon this Court’s order dated 28.03.200817 wherein this court while deciding the matters relating to Net Present Value (NPV) and compensatory afforestation costs accepted the report submitted by the Central Empowered Committee (CEC) titled “Supplementary Report of CEC in IA No.826 & IA No.566 regarding calculation of Net Present Value (NPV) payable on Loss of Forest Lands of Different Types in non-forest purpose”. This Court had accepted the CEC’s recommendations on certain economic values, proposed for Calculating the NPV and costs for Compensatory Afforestation (CA), involved in diversion of dense, moderate dense and open forest.
17. The appellant further relied upon the FSI Report, according to which, forest vegetation in the country falls specifically in three mutually inclusive canopy density classes:
i. Very Dense Forest (with crown density) 0.7 to 1.
ii. Moderate dense Forest (with crown density) 0.4 to 0.7. iii. Open forest (with crown density) 0.1 to 0.4.
17 Order in Writ Petition No.202 of 1995 714 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
18. It was, therefore, argued by the appellant before NGT that for the purpose of implementation of the FCA 1980, all the authorities including this Court, have clearly accepted that the areas of natural vegetation, having tree canopy density varying anywhere between 0.1 to 0.4, are to be considered as forest for the purpose of applicability of FCA 1980 and thereafter determination of NPV and CA. This aspect of enlarging the scope of criteria No.3 will be an essential step, as the report of the FSI, 2009 showed that the category of open forest (crown density of 0.1 to 0.4) is almost the same in extent, as both the categories of very dense forest and moderate dense forests are put together.
19. With regard to criteria No.(ii), which requires Minimum 5 Ha, the appellant had argued that the said criteria is defeating the purpose and mandate of FCA 1980 and the order of this Court dated 12.12.1996.
20. It was submitted before the tribunal that the FSI in its affidavit dated 23 rd March 2011, submitted that it defines ‘forest cover’ as being all lands, more than 1 ha area, with a tree canopy density of more than 10% irrespective of ownership and legal status. Such lands may not necessarily be recorded as forest areas. Therefore, the appellant sought the following reliefs in the Application No.14 (THC) of 2013: “For an order quashing the criteria nos. 2 & 3 of the Forest guidelines/criteria and the order of the Respondent No. 1, if any, approving the same”.
21. In the application No.16 (THC) of 2013, the appellant submitted that in TN Godavarman’s case (supra), this Court had issued various directions, vide its order dated 12.12.1996. It was the grievance of the appellant that the Sawant and Karapurakar Committees had not identified the areas, which were earlier forests but now stand degraded, denuded or cleared as per the directions of this Court. The appellant submitted that these Committees have not dealt with this issue or even formulated suitable criteria or framework for notifying such degraded forest areas and therefore, the appellant prayed for following relief(s) in Application No.16 (THC) of 2013: ● For an order directing the Govt of Goa to complete the process of identification of private forest in the State, within a time bound period in terms of Apex Court’s order dated 12.12.1996 and report compliance;
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 715T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s ● For an order directing the Govt. of Goa to complete the process of notifying the degraded forest within the State i.e., the areas which were earlier forest but stand degraded, denuded or cleared, in terms of Apex Court’s order dated 12.12.1996 and report compliance.
22. The Forest Department, Government of Goa, Respondent No.4, submitted that in the case of Shivananda Salgaonkar (supra), the High Court of Bombay, Goa Bench, in the judgement delivered on 27th November 1990 held that “since the term ‘forest’ is not defined in the Forest (Conservation) Act, the term has to be taken as per the dictionary meaning”. Pursuant to this judgement, the forest department framed guidelines in 1991, for identifying the forest in private properties. These guidelines were submitted to the Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF), Government of India on 04.10.1991 for their response.
23. The Forest Department further submitted that pursuant to the orders of this Court, dated 12.12.1996, the State Govt. had appointed Sawant Committee for the purpose of identification of forest lands in the State of Goa on 24 th January 1997, which submitted its report on 8 th December 1999. The Committee was given task to identify areas which are ‘forest’ irrespective of whether they are so notified, recognized or classified under any law and irrespective of ownership of land of such forest and to identify areas which were earlier forests but stand degraded, denuded or cleared.
24. Since no cut off was given for the tasks, Committee decided 1980 year in which the Forest Act was promulgated, to be the benchmark for Government forest lands. Subsequently, another Expert Committee was appointed on 4 th September, 2000 for further identification of private forest, which also submitted its report on 16.02.2002.
25. The respondent further submitted that the Sawant Committee has already obtained data on clearings and diversion made on Government forest lands for various purposes from 1980 and identified that total 13.078 Ha of forest Land has been diverted for various purposes. It was claimed that the Expert Committees have already considered all aspects of the Apex Court direction dated 12.12.1996.
26. The respondent further submitted that the State had already defined the forest identification criteria based on the scientific basis 716 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports considering various aspects as a policy decision and also, these two Expert Committees are functioning effectively and the work of identification of private forest area, is being carried out expeditiously and considering the above, the respondent had opposed both the applications.
27. The MoEF, Respondent No.2 stated that pursuant to the judgement in Lafarge Umiam Mining Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India and ors.18 , it was directed to prepare a comprehensive policy for inspection, verification and monitoring and overall procedure related to grant of Forest Clearance (FC) and Identification of Forest in consolidation with States and the process will likely take some more time and only after finalization of such comprehensive policy, the Ministry will be in position to put forth its stand as regards criteria, which is to be applied for identification of forests and further pleaded for sufficient time to place the stand of Ministry before the Tribunal.
28. The Forest Survey of India, Respondent No.3 submitted before the NGT that FSI has mandated to conduct survey and assessment of the Forest resources in the country. It was submitted that India’s States of Forest Report is published by the Respondent No.3 and in the said report forest cover is defined being of lands more than 1 Ha in area, with tree canopy density of more than 10% irrespective of ownership and legal status. Such lands may not necessarily be recorded as forest areas. It also includes the orchards, bamboo and palm.
29. Issues framed by NGT:
• Whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider and alter or newly fix the forest identification criteria?
• Whether the forest identification criteria set out by the Govt of Goa, needs modification, as prayed in the applications?
• Whether the Tribunal can issue directions for expediting forest identification and demarcation process, as prayed in the application?
• Whether the applications are barred by limitation?
18 (2011) 7 SCALE 242
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 717T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s
FINDINGS OF NGT IN THE IMPUGNED JUDGEMENT:
30. Having referred to the earlier pronouncements of this Court the Tribunal observed in paragraph 38 of the impugned order that all the States have formed Expert Committees for identification of forest and have submitted progress reports to this Court by evolving their own methodology for forest identification criteria. As such it was of the view that it would not be in the domain of the tribunal to render opinion with regard to the method of identification to be adopted for fixing the criteria for determining private forest to be adopted by State of Goa and answered point No.1 formulated by it in the negative.
31. In so far as the timeline to be fixed for expediting forest identification and its demarcation process is concerned, the tribunal took note of the fact that out of 256 square kilometres forest area, the work has been completed in respect of 67 square kilometres by the two Committees and as such called upon the Chief Secretary of Goa to call for a meeting of all the concerned and work out time bound action plan for early completion of forest identification and its demarcation within next six (6) weeks and submit a time bound program to the tribunal within 8 weeks thereof. All other reliefs sought for in the application of the appellant came to be denied. Hence the appellant has approached this Court by way of the present civil appeal.
CONTENTIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT IN THE
PRESENT APPEAL:
32. It is the contention of learned counsel appearing for the appellant that the tribunal erred in not passing an order on merits on the premise that the issue is seisin before this Court. It is further contended that WP No.495 of 2010 was filed challenging the criteria of minimum 40 per cent canopy density for identification as forest land. In the teeth of the order of this Court dated 28.03.2008 passed in batch of IA’s filed in WP No.202 of 1995 (T.N. Godavarman) in which the petition was amended and the minimum 5 (five) hectares area was also challenged in view of FSI’s affidavit which stated that minimum 1 (one) hectare of area and minimum 10 per cent canopy or the criteria adopted by FSI for identifying the forest cover in India and this writ petition was transferred to the tribunal. Hence, it is contended that identification of private forests on the basis of criteria accepted by FSI and by this Court in the order of 2008 passed for determining NPV also to be adopted and followed for identification of forest, 718 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports which would be in the interest of protection of environment and also a step for implementing the order dated 12.12.1996 passed by this Court as it has remained unmet by the State of Goa.
33. By referring to the three interim orders, namely 17.12.2006 and 26.03.2012 passed by the High Court and the order dated 04.02.2015 passed by this Court, it is contended that authorities have been injuncted from issuing conversion Sanad for any private properties with tree cover in excess of 0.1 all having natural vegetation and tree canopy density in excess of 0.1 and area above 1 (one) hectare which would clearly indicate that in order to protect the environment this relief was essential and so as to prevent any further degradation of the forest by its destruction.
34. It is also contended that to meet the mandate of the order dated 12.12.1996 the identification and demarcation of private forest area on the basis of 1 (one) hectare and 10 percent (0.1) canopy density is an exercise which must be carried out for meeting the said criteria which would be over and above the identification of forest area done on the criteria that is 75 per cent forest species, 40 per cent canopy density and 5 (five) hectare of area, as the objective is to ensure restoration (and not diversion) of such forest area to their original status. Hence, contending if such identification is done on the basis of this criteria, it would sub-serve the interest of conservation and protection of environment and in a given case the Central/State Government can grant ‘prior permission’ within the provisions of FCA 1980 if it considers that such diversion is necessary in public interest and it would be in consonance with the principle of sustainable development. In this background the objection of the State of Goa to the criteria of the FSI to identify the open forest that is 0.1 canopy density and the area above 1 (one) hectare would not stand to reason. Elaborating the submissions, he would contend that the ISFR has identified 552 square kilometres on the basis of criteria fixed by it and if the said criteria is not adopted it would reduce the open forest area in the State of Goa to an extent of 552 square kilometre. Hence, he prays for the petition being allowed.
35. As mentioned in the submissions of the Appellant in the preceding paragraphs, to summarise, the Appellant herein prays for revisiting the criteria for identification of private forest/deemed forest on private lands in the State of Goa, by using the parameters used by FSI, that is based on 0.1 density forest in an area of 1 (one) ha. [2024] 1 S.C.R. 719T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s
CONTENTIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NO.(S) 1,4,5,6,7
& 8 ALONG WITH CONTENTIONS OF THE IMPLEADING PARTY
I.E., CREDAI.
36. The respondents have sought the modification and vacation of the above-mentioned order in the IA No.40261 of 2017 filed by them, and further have made submissions and raised various grounds for the dismissal of the present Civil Appeal Nos.12234-12235 of 2018. The respondents have urged that the Stay Order dated 04.02.2015 of this Court, has continued to operate for over eight years, which is impacting several developmental works in the State of Goa. In addition to this, by way of their Counter Affidavit, and numerous submissions made during the hearing of the present appeals, the Senior Counsel has raised several grounds for the dismissal of the present appeals and for vacation of the Order dated 04.02.2015.
37. Respondent No(s). 1,4,5,6,7 and 8, along with the impleading party i.e., CREDAI, have sought the vacation of the ex parte interim order dated 04.02.2015 passed by this Court in the present appeal, and they have also opposed the grant of relief sought by the Appellant in its appeal. In furtherance of this, the learned Senior Counsel for Respondent No.(s) 1,4,5,6,7 and 8 along with the learned Senior Counsel for the impleading party, i.e., CREDAI have raised various grounds and made elaborate submissions for the dismissal of the present appeals, which have been recorded by us in the subsequent paragraphs.
38. The respondent(s) contended that the criteria for identification of forest has attained finality and cannot be challenged on the principles of res judicata. It was submitted that the criteria for identification of forest on private land was determined in 1991 pursuant to the Judgement of the Bombay High Court dated 27.11.1990 in Shivanand Salgaonkar case (supra).
39. It was further submitted that the criteria for identification of forests, which forms the basis of the reports filed by the Sawant, Karapurkar and Sharma Reports, were first proposed by the Forest Department of the State of Goa, in 1991. The Forest Department had proposed a crown density of 40% and a minimum area of 5 (five) Ha since it was not viable in the long run for the forest department to conserve small patches of forest land, as is evident from the letter dated 04.10.1991, and from the Affidavit filed by the State of Goa before this Court on 21.08.2012.
720 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
40. The counsel for the respondents contended that the aforesaid criteria formulated in 1991 was adopted by the State of Goa (Sawant and Karapurkar Committees) pursuant to the order dated 12.12.1996 passed by this Court in T.N. Godavarman (supra), however, despite being aware of the same, the Appellant did not challenge it. The respondents further contend that the State of Goa, on 08.12.1997 issued a public notice, which delineated the following criteria for the purpose of classifying “Forest”:
i. 75% of the tress composition should be forestry species. ii. The area should be contiguous to the Govt. Forest and if in isolation, the minimum area should be 5 ha.
iii. Canopy density should not be less than 0.4.
41. The learned counsel for the respondents contended that the public notice dated 08.12.1997, has also not been challenged by the present appellants Further, the Appellant had an opportunity to challenge the same before this Court in Goa Foundation Case (supra) 19, wherein it had raised grievances about the Karapurkar Committee report, however, it did not do so, and the said proceedings were thereafter disposed of as being infructuous on account of the filing of the Karapurkar report, by an order dated 10.02.2006.
42. Further, the counsel for the respondents have contended that Civil Appeal is ex facie barred by res judicata inasmuch as the very party that has preferred the same had sought to revisit the criteria twice before and failed. The respondents have pointed out to us that the Appellant preferred a Writ Petition before the High Court of Bombay at Goa disputing the criteria so adopted, and its application to a housing project. In an appeal preferred against the same, this Court in Tata Housing Development Corporation v. Goa Foundation (2003) 11 SCC 714 strongly disapproved any departure from such criteria and adoption of a new criteria.
43. The learned counsel has submitted that this Court in Tata Housing (supra), after examining the reports of the Sawant Committee, recorded the genesis of the criteria, and also took note of its facets. Further, the learned counsel has laid emphasis on paragraph 13 of the 19 Writ Petition No. 181 of 2001.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 721T. N. G o d avarman T h i r u m u l p ad v . U n i o n o f India and O t h e r s judgement in Tata Housing (supra), wherein this Court disapproved the approach of the High Court in accepting a new criterion, in what it termed as giving a “complete go-by” to the existing criteria. Accordingly, the counsel for the respondents contends that in sum and substance the pre-existing criteria received the imprimatur of this Court in Tata Housing (supra), hence, the principle of Res Judicata would apply and the present challenge to the criteria for identification of Forest deserves to be dismissed on this ground alone. The relevant paragraph 13 has been extracted below:
“13. From a bare perusal of the Third Interim Report, it would appear that the three criteria laid down in the Second Interim Report of the Sawant Committee have been given a complete go-by and in relation to the appellants’ plot altogether different criteria have been adopted. The course adopted by the Committee in taking into consideration different criteria while examining an individual case of the appellants’ plot was wholly unwarranted, especially when the Committee in its Report has not assigned any reason for making the deviation.”
44. The learned counsel for the respondent further contended that another judgment i.e., Nisarga v. Asst. Conservator of Forests OA No.19 (THC) of 2013, was concealed by the Appellant. The learned counsel submitted that the Appellant herein, approached the NGT arguing that the minimum canopy density to be adopted as a criterion ought to be 0.1 (i.e. 10%). It was submitted that the basis of this argument was identical to that advanced in this appeal, inasmuch as the Indian State of Forests Report, 2009 (ISFR) was relied upon to suggest that the said report had classified lands with canopy density between 10% to 40% as open forests. In other words, it was urged by the Appellant that even such lands were forest nonetheless. The NGT rejected this argument based on the judgment of this Court in Tata Housing (supra). The learned Counsel emphasized on the point that, the Appellant herein chose not to appeal the said judgment before this Court, and has allowed the same to attain finality. The counsel for the respondents submitted that Appellant cannot now be allowed to reagitate the very same issue on the very same basis before this Court.
722 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
45. The counsel for the respondent accordingly submitted that, criteria adopted by the State of Goa ought not to be interfered with; and the order dated 04.02.2015 passed by this Court directing a restraint on the grant of conversion sanads in the State of Goa ought to be vacated since the criterion for the identification of forest in the State of Goa has become final and binding, its variation having been rejected in Tata Housing (Supra) and Nisarg (Supra) by this Court and the NGT respectively.
46. The counsel for the respondent has submitted that the sheet anchor of the instant appeal is the formula adopted by this Court for the computation of NPV in T.N. Godavarman Thirumalpad v. Union of India 20, and in turn the reliance by this Court on the report of Ms. Kanchan Chopra, which in turn relies on the Indian State of Forests Report, 2008 (ISFR) issued by the FSI. It is submitted that ISFR has classified canopy density into 3 kinds, namely, very dense, moderately dense, and open. Furthermore, this Court while fixing the NPV rates has fixed them per Hectare, basis which the Appellant contends that even 1 (one) Ha of land can be a forest. It is submitted that the Appellant sought to change the criteria for a private forest in Goa to a minimum area of 1 (one) Ha, and also a minimum canopy density of 0.1 which was the least denominator employed by the ISFR in classifying an open forest for the purposes of fixing NPV rates. The counsel for the respondents urged and emphasized that this argument of the Appellant is misconceived as it fails to take into account that the private forest criteria not only in Goa but throughout the country is distinct from that for government lands. Importantly, government land of even 1 (one) Ha can be a forest, and accordingly can attract the imposition of NPV. Moreover, this Court in T.N. Godavarman Thirumalpad (87) v. Union of India21 observed that the criteria for NPV must be worked out on economic principles and hence it is submitted that this can have no nexus with identification. Furthermore, the NPV imposition also encompasses government forests which could even be of 1 (one) Hectare. Hence, it is understandable that the NPV criteria is per Hectare i.e., it conceives of NPV being imposed even for government forests of 1 (one) Ha.
20 (2008) 7 SCC 126.
21 (2006) 1 SCC 1.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 723T. N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India and Others
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.