Bharti Airtel Limited and Another v. Vijaykumar V. Iyer and Others
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 15; [2024] 1 S.C.R. 140
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice Sarasa Venkatanarayana Bhatti
- Decided
- 3 Jan 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3088/2020
- Sections
- 25, 238, 243, 5(1), 408, 14(4), 53, 529, 325, 46, 173, 36(4)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 1 S.C.R. 140 : 2024 INSC 15 Case Details Bharti Airtel Limited and Another v.
Vijaykumar V. Iyer and Others (Civil Appeal Nos. 3088-3089 of 2020)
03 January 2024 [Sanjiv Khanna* and S.V.N. Bhatti, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The present appeals raise a question on the right to claim set-off in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, when the Resolution Professional proceeds in terms of clause (a) to sub-section (2) of s.25 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 to take custody and control of all the assets of the corporate debtor.
Headnotes Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – clause (a) to subsection (2) of s.25, s.238, s.243 – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 – Regn. 29 – The appellant-Airtel entities argued that they are entitled to statutory set-off or insolvency set-off, in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Proceedings under Chapter II Part II of the IBC:
Held: The IBC is a complete code relying upon the opening part of the enactment and s.238 and s.243 nullifies the argument raised by the appellant Airtel entities that they are entitled to statutory set-off or insolvency set-off, in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Proceedings under Chapter II Part II of the IBC – Regulation 29 of the Liquidation Regulations does not apply to Part II of the IBC – The legislation or even the legislative intent permits neither statutory set-off, nor insolvency set-off. [Para 37] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Difference between the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process and the liquidation process:
Held: There is a difference between the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process and the liquidation process of the IBC – The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process focuses on and fosters rehabilitation, revival and resolution of the corporate debtor, [2024] 1 S.C.R. 141BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
whereas the liquidation process focuses on the constellation of assets of the company in liquidation, and distribution and payment to the creditors from the liquidation estate in terms of the order of preference set out in the insolvency statute. [Para 12] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 – Regn. 29 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or. VIII, r.6 – Application of the Provisions of statutory set-off to Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process:
Held: The provisions of statutory set-off in terms of Or. VIII, r. 6 of CPC or insolvency set-off as permitted by Regulation 29 of the Liquidation Regulations cannot be applied to the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process – The aforesaid rule would be, however, subject to two exceptions or situations – The first, if at all it can be called an exception, is where a party is entitled to contractual set-off, on the date which is effective before or on the date the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process is put into motion or commences – The reason is simple – The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process does not preclude application of contractual set-off – The second exception will be in the case of ‘equitable set-off’ when the claim and counter claim in the form of set-off are linked and connected on account of one or more transactions that can be treated as one – The set-off should be genuine and clearly established on facts and in law, so as to make it inequitable and unfair that the debtor be asked to pay money, without adjustment sought that is fully justified and legal – The amount to be adjusted should be a quantifiable and unquestionable monetary claim, as the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process is a time-bound summary procedure. [Paras 30 and 32] Words and Phrases – Set-off – Meaning of:
Held: Set-off in generic sense recognises the right of a debtor to adjust the smaller claim owed to him against the larger claim payable to his creditor – Set-off is given legal preference for three reasons – First, in economic terms, set-off is a form of security recognised in law – It is, however, not a security in a strict sense, but a right that enhances provision of credit and acts as a stimulus to trade and commerce by giving a degree of confidence to parties dealing with each other – Secondly, it helps reduce litigation, promotes economy of time and is an efficient method in resolving debt between parties – Thirdly, natural equity requires that cross- 142 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS demands should compensate each other by deducting the lesser sum from the greater – At least five different meanings can be ascribed to the term ‘set-off’, namely, (a) statutory or legal set-off;
(b) common law set-off; (c) equitable set-off; (d) contractual set-off; and (e) insolvency set-off. [Paras 3, 4 and 5] Words and Phrases – Contractual set-off – Meaning of:
Held: Contractual set-off is a matter of agreement, rather than a separate application of set-off – The parties are free to mutually agree on the outcomes they desire – Being consensual, when expressly stated, the normal rules of set-off regarding mutuality of credits or debts, liquid debts, and connected debts-aspects relevant and noticed below while dealing with statutory/legal set-offs or even insolvency set-off - may not apply – The contract, however, should be within bounds of legality and public policy – Further, the normal requirements of the law of contracts, viz. intention to create legal relationship, acceptance, consideration etc. should be established for a valid contractual set-off – Ascertaining the applicability of contractual set-off requires an assessment of the understanding whether the right is conferred by the agreement, as the court gives effect to the intention of the parties as to how they should deal – The right to set-off may be explicit in the words of the agreement, or can be gathered by existence of oral or implied agreement to set-off, reflecting an understanding to the said effect. [Paras 6 and 7] Words and Phrases – Statutory or legal set-off:
Held: Statutory or legal set-off is created by a statute – For example, Order VIII Rule 6 of the CPC states that where a suit for recovery of money is filed, the defendant can claim set-off against the plaintiff’s demand for any ascertained sum of money legally recoverable by the defendant from the plaintiff, but not exceeding the pecuniary limits of the jurisdiction of the court – It requires that both the parties should fill the same character as they fill in the plaintiff’s suit. [Para 8] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 – Regn. 29 – Mutual dealings: Held: The expression ‘mutual dealings’ for the purpose of Regulation 29 of the Liquidation Regulations, is wider than the statutory set-off postulated under Order VIII Rule 6 of CPC, as well as, equitable set-off under the common law as applicable in [2024] 1 S.C.R. 143BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
India – Insolvency set-off applies when demands are between the same parties – There must be commonality of identity between the person who has made the claim and the person against whom the claim exists – Even when there are several distinct and independent transactions, mutuality can exist between the same parties functioning in the same right or capacity – Mutual dealings are not so much concerned with the nature of the claims, but with the relationship and apposite identity of the parties giving rise to the respective claims, such that it would offend one’s sense of fairness or justice to allow one to be enforced without regard to the other. [Para 22] List Of Citations and Other References Indian Overseas Bank v. RCM Infrastructure Ltd. and Another:(2022) 8 SCC 516; Innoventive Industries Limited v. ICICI Bank and Another [2017] 8 SCR 33:(2018) 1 SCC 407; Embassy Property Developments Private Limited. v. State of Karnataka and Others [2019] 17 SCR 559:(2020) 13 SCC 308; V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat and Power Limited and Others (2022) 2 SCC 244; Career Institute Educational Society v. Om Shree Thakurji Educational Society, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 586; The Official Liquidator of High Court of Karnataka v. Smt. V. Lakshmikutty [1981] 2 SCR 349:(1981) 3 SCC 32 – referred to.
Ebix Singapore Private Limited v. Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions Limited and Another. (2022) 2 SCC 401; Swiss Ribbons Private Limited and Another v. Union of India and Others [2019] 3 SCR 535:(2019)
4 SCC 17 – held inapplicable.
Jurong Aromatics Corporation Pte Ltd. and Others v.
BP Singapore Pte Ltd. and Another, (2018) SGHC 215;
Federal Commerce and Navigation Co. v. Molena Alpha Inc., (1978) Q.B. 927; Ministre du Revenu national c.
Caisse Populaire du bon Conseil, 2009 SCC 29; Jeffs v. Wood, [1723] 2 Eq Ca. Ab. 10; Citibank Canada v.
Confederation of Life Insurance Company, 42 CRB (3)
(d) 288; Ramdhari v. Premanand, 19 Cal WN 1183;
Re.: Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA (No. 8) [1996] Ch. 245; Stein v. Blake [1996] A.C.
243; National Westminster Bank Ltd. v. Halesowen 144 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS Presswork & Assemblies Ltd. 1972 AC 785; Gye v.
McIntyre (1991) 171 CLR 609; BP Singapore Pte Ltd v. Jurong Aromatics Corp Pte Ltd and Others (2020)
SGCA 09; Belmont Park Investments v. BNY Corporate Trustee Services Ltd. [2012] 1 AC 383; British Eagle International Airlines Ltd v. Compagnie Nationale Air France 1975 1 WLR 758 – referred to.
Maheswari Metals & Metal Refinery, Bangalore v.
Madras State Small Industries Corporation, AIR 1974 Mad 39; Gokul Chit Funds and Trades Private Ltd. v.
Thoundasseri Kochu Ouseph Vareed and Others AIR 1977 Ker 68 – referred to.
Philip R. Wood, Set-off and Netting, Derivatives, Clearing Systems, (Sweet & Maxwell 2007); Kelly R. Palmer, The Law of Set Off in Canada (Canada Law Book 1993); Canadian Encyclopedic Digest, Release 3, “Personal Property” by Gloria Mintah, § 187, CD-ROM (Thomson Reuters Canada Limited, August 2009); Rory Derham, Derham on the Law of Set-Off (Oxford University Press 4th ed. 2010) ;Gerard McCormack, Set-off under the European Insolvency Regulation (and English Law), 29 IIR 100, 100-117 (2020); UNCITRAL Legislative Guide on Insolvency Law, Chapter G. p.155-156 (2005) – referred to.
List of Acts Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Insolvency; Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process; Set-off; Statutory or legal set-off; Common law set-off; Equitable set-off; Contractual set-off; Insolvency set-off; Mutual dealings. Other Case Details Including Impugned Order and Appearances CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos.3088-3089 of 2020.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 145BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
From the Judgment and Order dated 13.07.2020 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi in Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) Nos.530 and 700 of 2019.
Appearances:
Darius Khambata, Sr. Adv., Harsh Kaushik, Sandeep Devashish Das, Ramakant Rai, Somesh Srivastava, Tushar Hathiramani, Kumar Gourav, Varun Kumar Tikmani, Advs. for the Appellants.
N Venkataraman, A.S.G., Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Rishi Agrawala, Mahesh Agarwal, Victor Das, E. C. Agrawala, M/s. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, Raunak Dhillon, Ms. Ananya Dhar Choudhury, Ms. Niharika Shukla, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of The Supreme Court Judgment Sanjiv Khanna, J.
The present appeals raise an interesting question on the right to claim set-off in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, when the Resolution Professional proceeds in terms of clause (a) to sub-section
(2) of Section 25 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 1 to take custody and control of all the assets of the corporate debtor.
2. In order to decide the issue raised in these appeals, we are required to refer to the facts in brief:
2.1 In April 2016, Bharti Airtel Limited and Bharti Hexacom Limited 2 entered into eight spectrum trading agreements with Aircel Limited and Dishnet Wireless Limited 3 for purchase of the right to use the spectrum allocated to the latter in the 2300 MHz band. The agreement was contingent on approval of the Department of Telecommunications 4 , Government of India. The DoT for grant of approval demanded bank guarantees in relation to certain licence dues and spectrum usage dues from the Aircel entities. Challenging this direction, the Aircel entities 1 For short, ‘IBC’.
2 For short- ‘The appellants’ or ‘Airtel entities’.
3 For short- ‘Aircel entities’.
4 For short- ‘DoT’.
146 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS approached the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal 5 . By the interim order dated 3 rd June 2016, TDSAT directed Aircel entities to submit the bank guarantees. As the Aircel entities did not have the means to procure and submit the bank guarantees for approximately Rs.453.73 crores, they approached the Airtel entities to submit bank guarantees on their behalf to the DoT.
2.2 In terms of the eight spectrum transfer agreements, the Airtel Entities were to pay Rs.4,022.75 crores to the Aircel entities. The Airtel entities and Aircel entities entered into three Letters of Understanding whereby the Airtel entities agreed to furnish the bank guarantees to the DOT on behalf of the Aircel entities. The Airtel entities were to deduct Rs.586.37 crores from the consideration payable to the Aircel entities under the spectrum transfer agreements. On the Aircel entities replacing the bank guarantees furnished by the Airtel entities and the Airtel entities receiving the bank guarantees from the DOT, Rs.411.22 crores were payable by the Airtel entities to the Aircel entities. 2.3 TDSAT vide order dated 9th January 2018 held that the DOT’s demand of Rs.298 crores against the Aircel entities was untenable, and directed the DoT to return the bank guarantees to the Aircel entities. However, the bank guarantees were not returned by the DoT, which preferred Civil Appeal No. 5816 of 2018 before this Court. Cross-appeals were filed by Aircel entities.
2.4 This Court by order dated 28th November 2018 held at the interim stage, that the order of the TDSAT dated 9th January 2018, insofar as bank guarantees are concerned, shall be given effect to. However, the DoT did not return the bank guarantees. 2.5 In view of the aforesaid, the Airtel entities wrote to the bank seeking confirmation of cancellation of the bank guarantees. As the banks were reluctant, the Airtel entities approached this Court, which vide order dated 8th January 2019, directed that the bank guarantees shall be cancelled and shall not be used for any purpose whatsoever.
5 For short- ‘the TDSAT’.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 147BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
2.6 Thereupon the Airtel entities made a payment of Rs.341.80 crores due to the Aircel entities on 10th January 2019. The balance amount of Rs.145.20 crores was set-off by the Airtel entities on the ground that this amount was owed by the Aircel entities to the Airtel entities. According to Airtel entities, Rs.145.20 crores was the adjusted or the net amount payable by the Aircel entities towards operational charges, SMS charges and interconnect usage charges 6 to the Airtel entities. 2.7 In the meanwhile, Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process was initiated against Aircel entities, namely Aircel Limited and Dishnet Wireless Limited. The Adjudicating Authority 7 , Mumbai Bench, admitted the petitions against Aircel Limited and Dishnet Wireless Limited vide the orders dated 12th March 2018 and 19th March 2018.
2.8 Claims on account of the interconnect charges were filed by Bharti Airtel Limited, including the claim on behalf of Telenor (India) Communications Private Limited 8 , in light of Telenor’s merger with Bharti Airtel Limited, effective from 14th May 2018. Claim was also filed by Bharti Hexacom Limited. The total claim by the Airtel Entities was Rs.203.46 crores. However, the Airtel entities also owed Rs.64.11 crores towards interconnect charges to the Aircel entities.
2.9 The claims submitted by the Airtel entities were admitted by the Resolution Professional to the extent of Rs.112 crores. Claim on account of receivable of about Rs.5.85 crores owed by Aircel entities to Telenor India, which had been merged with Bharti Airtel Limited, was not accepted.
2.10 By the letter dated 12th January 2019, the Resolution Professional for Aircel Limited, Dishnet Wireless Limited and Aircel Cellular Limited, wrote to Bharti Airtel Limited, stating that they had suo moto adjusted an amount of Rs.112.87 crores from the amount of Rs.453.73 crores payable by Airtel entities to Aircel entities, consequent to the discharge and cancellation 6 For short- ‘interconnect charges’.
7 Section 5(1) of IBC– “Adjudicating Authority”, for the purposes of this Part, means National Company Law Tribunal constituted under Section 408 of the Companies Act, 2013 (18 of 2013). 8 For short- ‘Telenor India’.
148 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS of the bank guarantees. Bharti Airtel Limited was asked to pay Rs.112.87 crores to Aircel entities, which were undergoing Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, failing which the Resolution Professional would be obligated to take steps for recovery. The Airtel entities objected on several grounds, and also claimed set-off of the amount due to them by the Aircel entities from the amount payable by them to the Aircel entities. Their reply and claim for set-off was rejected by the Resolution Professional.
2.11 The Airtel entities thereupon approached the Adjudicating Authority in Mumbai, who, vide order dated 1st May 2019 held that the Airtel entities had a right to set off Rs.112.87 crores from the payment, which was retained, and due and payable to Aircel entities.
2.12 This order was challenged by the Resolution Professional before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal 9 . The NCLAT vide order dated 17th May 2019 allowed the appeal, inter alia, holding that set-off is violative of the basic principles and protection accorded under any insolvency law. Set-off is antithetical to the objective of the IBC. Reference was made to the non-obstante provisions in the form of Section 238 of the IBC. As moratorium under Section 14(4) applies till the date of completion of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, which is till the resolution plan is approved or the liquidation order is passed, to permit set-off will be contrary to law. Further, the set-off being claimed is in respect of two separate and unrelated transactions.
Meaning of set-off and types and principles of set-off.
3. Set-off in generic sense recognises the right of a debtor to adjust the smaller claim owed to him against the larger claim payable to his creditor.10 Philip R. Wood 11 calls it a form of payment. Palmer 12 notes a distinction between ‘set-off’ as in accounting, and ‘set-off’ as a defence. The former focuses on the practical effect of set-off which 9 For short- ‘NCLAT’.
10 Philip R. Wood, Set-off and Netting, Derivatives, Clearing Systems, (Sweet & Maxwell 2007). 11 Ibid.
12 Kelly R. Palmer, The Law of Set Off in Canada (Canada Law Book 1993). [2024] 1 S.C.R. 149BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
results in discharge of reciprocal obligations, while the latter focuses on set-off pleaded as a defence to a claim, albeit not as a ‘sword’.
4. Set-off is given legal preference for three reasons. First, in economic terms, set-off is a form of security recognised in law. It is, however, not a security in a strict sense, but a right that enhances provision of credit and acts as a stimulus to trade and commerce by giving a degree of confidence to parties dealing with each other. Secondly, it helps reduce litigation, promotes economy of time and is an efficient method in resolving debt between parties. Thirdly, natural equity requires that cross-demands should compensate each other by deducting the lesser sum from the greater.
5. At least five different meanings can be ascribed to the term ‘set-off’, namely, (a) statutory or legal set-off; (b) common law set-off; (c) equitable set-off; (d) contractual set-off; and (e) insolvency set-off.13 It is observed that the streams of common law and equity on the right of set-off have flown together and have so combined as to be in the modern era indistinguishable from one another.14 It is necessary to briefly explain the contours of contractual set-off, statutory/legal set-off, equitable set-off and insolvency set-off.
6. Contractual set-off is a matter of agreement, rather than a separate application of set-off. The parties are free to mutually agree on the outcomes they desire. Being consensual, when expressly stated, the normal rules of set-off regarding mutuality of credits or debts, liquid debts, and connected debts – aspects relevant and noticed below while dealing with statutory/legal set-offs or even insolvency set-off – may not apply. The contract, however, should be within bounds of legality and public policy. 15 Further, the normal requirements of the law of contracts, viz. intention to create legal relationship, acceptance, consideration etc. should be established for a valid contractual set-off. 16
7. Ascertaining the applicability of contractual set-off requires an assessment of the understanding whether the right is conferred by 13 Jurong Aromatics Corporation Pte Ltd. and Others v. BP Singapore Pte Ltd. and Another, (2018) SGHC
215. (High Court of Republic of Singapore)
14 Federal Commerce and Navigation Co. v. Molena Alpha Inc., (1978) Q.B. 927. (Lord Denning) 15 Palmer, supra note 12, at 263.
16 Palmer, supra note 12, at 263.
150 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS the agreement, as the court gives effect to the intention of the parties as to how they should deal. 17 The right to set-off may be explicit in the words of the agreement, or can be gathered by existence of oral or implied agreement to set-off, reflecting an understanding to the said effect. There are earlier judgments in common law countries that suggest that courts may rely on the equitable foundations of setoff to relax the evidentiary burden required to prove an agreement to set-off.18 It is suggested that courts accept slighter evidence of agreement to set-off than is usually required in order to establish disputed facts,19 but this is too broad a statement. Rather, the courts should consider that netting of cross dues is both legitimate and equitable, and in that context make an assessment of the relevant facts to decide whether or not the set-off rights are conferred.
8. Statutory or legal set-off is created by a statute. For example, Order VIII Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 20 states that where a suit for recovery of money is filed, the defendant can claim set-off against the plaintiff’s demand for any ascertained sum of money legally recoverable by the defendant from the plaintiff, but not exceeding the pecuniary limits of the jurisdiction of the court. It requires that both the parties should fill the same character as they fill in the plaintiff’s suit. The defendant may, at the first hearing of the suit, and not afterwards, unless permitted by the court, present the written statement containing particulars of debts sought to be set-off. 21 For set-off in law, the obligations existing between the 17 Ministre du Revenu national c. Caisse Populaire du bon Conseil, 2009 SCC 29 (S.C.C.) (Supreme Court of Canada)
18 Jeffs v. Wood, [1723] 2 Eq Ca. Ab. 10.
19 Canadian Encyclopedic Digest, Release 3, “Personal Property” by Gloria Mintah, § 187, CD-ROM (Thomson Reuters Canada Limited, August 2009); See also Palmer, supra note 12, at 263. 20 Order VIII Rule 6. Particulars of set-off to be given in written statement.—(1) Where in a suit for the recovery of money the defendant claims to set-off against the plaintiff’s demand any ascertained sum of money legally recoverable by him from the plaintiff, not exceeding the pecuniary limits of the jurisdiction of the Court, and both parties fill the same character as they fill in the plaintiff’s suit, the defendant may, at the first hearing of the suit, but not afterwards unless permitted by the Court, present a written statement containing the particulars of the debt sought to be set-off.
(2) Effect of set-off.—The written statement shall have the same effect as a plaint in a cross-suit so as to enable the Court to pronounce a final judgment in respect both of the original claim and of the set-off, but this shall not affect the lien, upon the amount decreed, of any pleader in respect of the costs payable to him under the decree.
(3) The rules relating to a written statement by a defendant apply to a written statement in answer to a claim of set-off.
21 For the purpose of the present decision, we need not examine the contours and conditions of Order VIII Rule 6 CPC.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 151BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
two parties must be debts which are for liquidated sums or money demands which can be ascertained with certainty. Both the debts must be mutual cross-obligations, that is, cross-claims between the parties in the same right. 22
9. A few judgments of this Court and the High Courts allow the defendant to claim equitable set-off in respect of an unascertained sum of money payable as damages. Equitable set-off can also be claimed in respect of an ascertained sum of money.23 However, the claim for an equitable set-off must have a connection between the plaintiff’s claim for the debt and the defendant’s claim to set-off, which would make it inequitable to drive the defendant to a separate suit. 24 It has been accordingly held that the claim for set-off should arise out of the same transaction, or transactions which can be regarded as one transaction. Equitable set-off is allowed in common law, as distinguished from legal set-off, which is allowed by the court only for an ascertained sum of money and is a statutory right. We shall be subsequently examining the right to equitable set-off while examining the provisions of the IBC.
10. Rory Derham on the law of set-offs observes that insolvency setoffs should not be equated with equitable set-offs.25 This statement reflects the development of law in the United Kingdom, which has resulted in enactment of special provisions on set-off in case of insolvency. We need not examine in detail the law as applicable to insolvency set-off in the United Kingdom for the present decision, albeit it is relevant to state that they are broader and wider than the provisions of equitable set-off. Insolvency set-off under the law of the United Kingdom is permitted when there are mutual debts, mutual credits and other mutual dealings between the parties at the relevant cut-off time, which is essentially the stage of commencement of the liquidation process. We shall subsequently examine the term “mutual dealings” as applicable to liquidation proceedings in India. 22 Citibank Canada v. Confederation of Life Insurance Company, 42 CRB (3)(d) 288. 23 Ramdhari v. Premanand, 19 Cal WN 1183.
24 Maheswari Metals & Metal Refinery, Bangalore v. Madras State Small Industries Corporation, AIR 1974 Mad 39.
25 Rory Derham, D erham on the Law of Set-off (OxfOrd University Press 4th ed. 2010). 152 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS Analysis of the provisions of IBC relating to the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process, liquidation proceedings and application to the facts of present case.
11. In the present case we are examining and concerned with the provisions as applicable to the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process in Chapter II Part II of the IBC, which consists of the compendium of Sections from 6 to 32A of the IBC. In the course of our discussion, we would also be referring to Section 53 of the IBC, which is a part of Chapter III Part II, and relates to the liquidation process.
12. At the outset we should record, that there is a difference between the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process and the liquidation process of the IBC. The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process focuses on and fosters rehabilitation, revival and resolution of the corporate debtor, whereas the liquidation process focuses on the constellation of assets of the company in liquidation, and distribution and payment to the creditors from the liquidation estate in terms of the order of preference set out in the insolvency statute.
13. Unlike the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 or the Companies Act, 2013, IBC in the case of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process does not give the indebted creditors the right to set-off against the corporate debtor. The earlier enactments – the Companies Act, 1956 vide Section 529, and the Companies Act, 2013 vide Section 325 (now omitted) – did permit set-off per the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920, which enactment is now repealed. Accordingly, under the Companies Acts, in terms of the provisions of Section 46 of the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920, indebted creditors’ right to set-off against the corporate debtor was statutorily recognised subject to satisfaction of certain conditions. Significantly, in the case of partnerships and individual bankruptcies, Section 173 26 of the IBC 26 Section 173. Mutual credit and set-off.—(1) Where before the bankruptcy commencement date, there have been mutual dealings between the bankrupt and any creditor, the bankruptcy trustee shall—
(a) take an account of what is due from each party to the other in respect of the mutual dealings and the sums due from one party shall be set-off against the sums due from the other; and
(b) only the balance shall be provable as a bankruptcy debt or as the amount payable to the bankruptcy trustee as part of the estate of the bankrupt.
(2) Sums due from the bankrupt to another party shall not be included in the account taken by the bankruptcy trustee under sub-section (1), if that other party had notice at the time they became due that an application for bankruptcy relating to the bankrupt was pending. [2024] 1 S.C.R. 153BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
permits set-off. Regulation 29 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 27 provides for mutual credits and set-off and reads:
“29. Mutual credits and set-off.— Where there are mutual dealings between the corporate debtor and another party, the sums due from one party shall be set off against the sums due from the other to arrive at the net amount payable to the corporate debtor or to the other party.”
The title of the Liquidation Regulations states that they shall apply to the process under Chapter III Part II of the IBC. In other words, the Liquidation Regulations are not applicable to Chapter II Part II of the IBC, which relates to the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process.
14. Section 36(4) in Chapter III Part II of the IBC 28 deals with the exclusion of assets that do not form part of the liquidation estate. Section 36(4) permits the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India29 to specify assets which could be subject to set-off on account of mutual dealings between the corporate debtor and the creditor. When an asset is excluded from the liquidation estate, it is not available for distribution in the liquidation process. It follows that if a creditor exercises and is allowed set-off, then in terms of Section 36(4) of the IBC this creditor is given a preferred status over others, including the secured creditors, to the extent of the set-off value. 27 For short- ‘the Liquidation Regulations’.
28 Section 36 (4). The following shall not be included in the liquidation estate assets and shall not be used for recovery in the liquidation—
(a) assets owned by a third party which are in possession of the corporate debtor, including—
(i) assets held in trust for any third party;
(ii) bailment contracts;
(iii) all sums due to any workman or employee from the provident fund, the pension fund and the gratuity fund;
(iv) other contractual arrangements which do not stipulate transfer of title but only use of the assets; and
(v) such other assets as may be notified by the Central Government in consultation with any financial sector regulator;
(b) assets in security collateral held by financial services providers and are subject to netting and set-off in multilateral trading or clearing transactions;
(c) personal assets of any shareholder or partner of a corporate debtor as the case may be provided such assets are not held on account of avoidance transactions that may be avoided under this Chapter;
(d) assets of any Indian or foreign subsidiary of the corporate debtor; or
(e) any other assets as may be specified by the Board, including assets which could be subject to set off on account of mutual dealings between the corporate debtor and any creditor. 29 For short- ‘the Board’.
154 [2024] 1 S.C.R.DIGITAL SUPREME COURT REPORTS
15. The Liquidation Regulations have been framed in exercise of powers conferred on the Board by Sections 5, 33, 34, 35, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 45, 49, 50, 51, 52, 54, 196 and 208 read with Section 240 of the IBC. Notwithstanding the omission in the Liquidation Regulations to refer to Section 36(4) of the IBC, set-off on account of mutual dealings is permitted in terms of Regulation 29 of the Liquidation Regulations. The sums due mutually can be set off to arrive at the net amount payable to the corporate debtor or the other party. The exclusion will result in reduction of the liquidation estate and therefore has consequences as noticed above. In the present case, we are not concerned with what is to be included and is a part, or not a part of the liquidation estate.
16. The expression ‘mutual dealings’ is the condition to be satisfied for insolvency set-off under Regulation 29. We will examine what is meant by the expression ‘mutual dealings’, and how insolvency set-off is different from contractual, statutory and equitable set-off.
17. Insolvency set-off under the United Kingdom insolvency law was examined in Re.: Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA (No. 8) 30, to imply that the set-off must relate to dealings prior to bankruptcy. It states in explicit terms that the requirement of mutuality is central to bankruptcy set-off and must be rigorously enforced. It is held that it is not the function of an insolvency set-off to confer a benefit to a debtor who has not been a part of mutual dealings, or to give preference to a creditor who has secondary or no liability. The insolvency set-off regime in the United Kingdom is wider than statutory/legal set-off or equitable set-off. However, there is a requirement that the debt should have been provable in the insolvency process.
17.1 An earlier decision in Stein v. Blake31 had held that the bankruptcy set-off applies to all claims from mutual credits or dealings prior to bankruptcy, including claims, which at the time of bankruptcy were due but not payable, unascertained or contingent. This is supplemented by the United Kingdom insolvency set-off regime permitting the estimation of liabilities and calculation of trends. The parties are not required at any 30 [1996] Ch. 245. (Appeal Committee of the House of Lords) 31 [1996] A.C. 243. (House of Lords)
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 155BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED AND ANOTHER v.
VIJAYKUMAR V. IYER AND OTHERS
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.