Urban Improvement Trust v. Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 980; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 993
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice Manoj Misra
- Decided
- 13 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 14473/2024
- Sections
- 60A, 52(2), 52(7), 52(1), 4, 53(3), 53, 60A(4), 52, 52(3), 52(5), 3A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 993 : 2024 INSC 980 Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 14473 of 2024)
13 December 2024 [J.B. Pardiwala* and Manoj Misra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The present appeals arise from a common judgment passed by the High Court dated 29.10.2009, whereby the High Court allowed the writ appeals and thereby quashed the land acquisition proceedings initiated by the appellant Trust.
Headnotes† Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 – s.52(2), s.52(7), s.60A – Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Condonation of delay in filing writ petition – The appellant challenges the inordinate delay of 21 years in filing writ petition by the respondent, whether the same needs to be considered in the facts and circumstances of the case:
Held: The courts have consistently held that undue delay in approaching the court can be a ground for refusing relief, the courts have also recognized that in exceptional cases, where the impugned action is patently illegal or affects fundamental rights, the delay must be condoned – The right of an individual to vindicate and protect private property cannot be brushed away merely on the grounds of delay and laches – In the instant case, there are three instances of procedural irregularity that may prejudice the rights of the respondents herein: (1) the notice under Section 52(2) of the RUI Act was not served individually to the landowners and the same was not pasted at a conspicuous area of the locality where the property was situated; (2) the possession was allegedly taken by the State Government and handed over to the appellant Trust prior to the deposit of compensation in contravention to Section 52(7) of the RUI Act; and (3) the compensation in respect of the Nangli Kota lands was not paid in terms of the timelines * Author 994 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports stipulated in sub-sections (3) and (4) of Section 60A of the RUI Act – These procedural anomalies are glaring and necessitate discussion regarding the propriety of the acquisition proceedings so as to ensure that the landowners are not dispossessed of their property without following due procedure – Therefore, the writ petition filed before the High Court, despite the significant delay, raised substantial questions regarding the legality of the land acquisition proceedings – The alleged patent illegality in the acquisition process justify the condonation of delay in this exceptional case. [Paras 46, 51, 52, 53, 54] Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 – s.52(1) – Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Notification for acquisition u/s.52(1) of RUI Act – Publication of Notice:
Held: The provisions of the Section 52(2) are akin to Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – To initiate the acquisition proceedings, the State must publish a notice under Section 52(2) of the RUI Act for the owners or any other interested parties to show cause as to why their land should not be acquired – The object of issuing a notice under Section 52(2) prior to a notification under Section 52(1) is to allow the owners and interested parties to put forth their case as to why a land proposed to be acquired should not be acquired or to make representations regarding the amount of compensation – A reading of Section 52(2) shows that the conditions of publication of notice in the official gazette and pasting the same at a conspicuous area of the locality are together considered to be sufficient notice. [Paras 56, 57(b), 57(d)] Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 – s.52(1) – Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – The validity of the notification u/s.52(1) for the acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands:
Held: It is an admitted fact by both the parties that there were no individual notices served upon the owners as required u/s.52(2) nor was the notice of the proposed acquisition pasted on some conspicuous space in the locality where the property was situated – The State Government had only published the notice u/s.52(2) in the official gazette – A reading of s.52(2) shows that the conditions of publication of notice in the official gazette and pasting the same at a conspicuous area of the locality are [2024] 12 S.C.R. 995Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
together considered to be sufficient notice and fulfilment of just one requirement out of the two risked causing prejudice to the respondents herein – What remains to be seen is whether the improper service of notice did in fact deprive the respondents from making their representations and objections to the acquisition proceedings – The documents placed on record show that the seven sons of late ‘RN’ participated in the proceedings before the OSD and were aware that the Nangli Kota lands were proposed to be acquired – Therefore, the participation in the proceedings by the landowners themselves is sufficient evidence that the object of the publication of the notice u/s.52(2) was met – The acquiring authority that is, the State was not required to prove actual notice of the proposal to acquire in this case and the knowledge of the appellants about the acquisition proceedings is equivalent to implied notice to the appellants – Therefore, the non-service of individual notices upon the owners u/s.52(2) cannot be a ground to invalidate the acquisition proceedings. [Paras 57(a), 57(d), 57(e), 57(f), 57(g)] Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 – s.52(1) – Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – The validity of the notification u/s.52(1) for the acquisition of the Moongaska lands:
Held: The State did not serve individual notices upon the owners – The notice u/s.52(2) was also not pasted at a conspicuous area of the locality in which the property is situated – The State Government only published the notice in the official gazette – From the documents placed on record, it is found that the representations were made by the legal heirs of two of the original landowners that is the RN and Y – There is no evidence of the participation by the other two original landowners that is, RS and ML or their legal heirs – The appellant Trust or the State Government has also not adduced any evidence whether written or oral that these two landowners and their legal heirs actively participated in the acquisition proceedings and made their objections heard – From the records, it is clear that improper service of notice u/s.52(2) did in fact prejudice the rights of the two original landowners and their legal heirs and they were not provided with an opportunity to be heard – Such factum is sufficient to declare the notification u/s.52(1) for the Moongaska land, invalid. [Paras 58(a), 58(c), 58(e)] 996 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 – Rajasthan Urban Improvement (Amendment) Act, 1987 – s.60A – Land Acquisition Act, 1894:
Held: After the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was extended to the State of Rajasthan on 24.09.1984, an amendment in the RUI Act was introduced vide the Amending Act, 1987 which provided for the transitory measures for facilitating the application of the Land Acquisition Act to the State of Rajasthan – The legislature enacted Section 60A with a view to address the pending acquisition proceedings which were initiated under the RUI Act – While subsection (4) puts an embargo on the challenge to an acquisition on the ground of non-payment of compensation, it is accompanied with a proviso that the compensation must be paid within six months from 01.08.1987. [Paras 67, 68] Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 – Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Whether the compensation was determined and paid lawfully to the respondents:
Held: Since the improper service of notice u/s.52(2) invalidates the notification issued u/s.52(1) of the RUI Act for the Moongaksa land, so the discussion hereby is restricted to the acquisition proceedings for the Nangli Kota lands – The OSD passed an order u/s.53(3) of the RUI Act for settlement of compensation at Rs. 90,000/- in lieu of the acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands – However, the payment of compensation was delayed – There are atleast two inconsistencies in the payment of compensation to the respondents and the procedure of acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands: (i) As per Section 52(7), the possession of the land being acquired cannot be handed over to the appellant Trust till it deposits the compensation amount determined u/s.53 of the RUI Act – However, in the present case, the possession of the Nangli Kota lands was handed over to the appellant Trust long before it deposited the compensation amount with the reference court;
(ii) Even though the parallel litigation on the questions of nature and ownership of the land bearing Survey no. 229 was concluded in 1985, the compensation amount was deposited by the appellant Trust in the reference court only on 31.12.1997 that is after 12 years – The present case is squarely covered by Section 60A(4) as the Nangli Kota lands were already deemed to be vested in the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 997Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
State after the notification under Section 52(1) was published – While sub-section (4) puts an embargo on the challenge to an acquisition on the ground of non-payment of compensation, it is accompanied with a proviso that the compensation must be paid within six months from 01.08.1987 – It is worth noting that neither the State Government nor the appellant Trust deposited the amount towards compensation to be paid to the respondents within a period of 6 months – In fact, there was an inordinate delay of almost 10 years in depositing the compensation amount in the reference court – Further, no reason worth the name has been provided by the State Government and the appellant Trust for such delay – Therefore, in considered view of this Court, the notification under Section 52(1) is liable to be declared invalid on the ground that the compensation was not deposited and paid to the respondents within the timeline specified in Section 60A(4) as well as on the ground that the acquisition process was not fair and in accordance with law – The improper procedure being adopted by the State Government and the appellant Trust when it took possession of the Nangli Kota lands before depositing compensation for the same was in contravention of the mandate of Section 52(7) of the RUI Act. [Paras 60, 63, 66, 71] Case Law Cited Vidya Devi v. State of Himachal Pradesh [2020] 1 SCR 749 : (2020) 2 SCC 569; Sukh Dutt Ratra v. State of Himachal Pradesh [2022] 2 SCR 1041 : (2022) 7 SCC 508; Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Balwant Regular Motor Service [1969] 1 SCR 808; D.B. Basnett (D) through LRs v. Collector, East District, Gangtok, Sikkim and Another [2020] 4 SCR 513 : (2020) 4 SCC 572; Ultra-Tech Cement Ltd. v. Mast Ram [2024] 9 SCR 443 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2598; N. Padmamma v.
S. Ramakrishna Reddy [2008] 9 SCR 535 : (2008) 15 SCC 517 – relied on.
Pratap v. State of Rajasthan [1996] 2 SCR 1088 : (1996) 3 SCC 1; Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition CMDA v. J. Sivaprakasam and Ors. [2010] 15 SCR 491 : (2011) 1 SCC 330; Delhi Airtech Services (P) Ltd. v. State of U.P. [2022] 19 SCR 757 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1408; Kolkata Municipal Corporation & Anr. v. Bimal Kumar Shah & Ors. [2024] 5 SCR 831 : 2024 998 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports SCC OnLine SC 968; Ramchandra Shankar Deodhar v. State of Maharashtra [1974] 2 SCR 216 : (1974) 1 SCC 317; Ahuja Industries Ltd. v. State of Karnataka & Others [2003] 3 SCR 351 : (2003) 57 SCC 365; Urban Improvement Trust, Bikaner v. Gordhan Dass (D.) through LRs. & Others [2023] 14 SCR 520 : (2024) 3 SCC 250 – referred to.
List of Acts Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959; Rajasthan Urban Improvement (Amendment) Act, 1987; Evidence Act, 1872; Land Acquisition Act, 1894; Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Inordinate delay in filing writ petitions; Fundamental Rights; Delay; Laches; Right to property; Protection of property; Compensation; Deposit of compensation; Acquisition proceedings; Legality of acquisition proceedings; Condonation of delay; Notification of acquisition; Compulsory acquisition of land; Notice; Service of notice; Publication of notice; Implied notice; Section 60A(4) of Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959; Section 52 of Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 14473 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 29-10-2009 of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur in DBSAW No. 669 of 1999 and SBCWP No. 2171 of 1998 Appearances for Parties Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, Sr. Adv., R. Gopalakrishnan, Raghav Sharma, Vaibhav Dwivedi, Ms. Ankita Chaudhary, Parmod Kumar Vishnoi, Advs. for the Appellant.
Shiv Mangal Sharma, A.A.G., S. K. Verma, Milind Kumar, Swadeep Singh Hora, Manish Kumar Choudhary, Ashutosh Kumar, Ms. Namita Choudhary, Ms. Srishti Choudhary, Ms. Shefali Choudhary, Advs. for the Respondents.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 999Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts: - INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ………………………………………........ 2 B. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS BY THE APPELLANT ……...… 14 C. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS BY THE RESPONDENTS ….... 28 D. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION ……………………….......... 34 E. ANALYSIS ………………………………………………......… 35
(i) On the question of delay in filing the writ petitions before the High Court ………………………………………...........
(ii) On the validity of the notification for acquisition under Section 52(1) ……………………...…………………….....
(iii) On the question of whether the compensation was determined and paid lawfully to the respondents …….... F. CONCLUSION ………………………..………………………... 57
1. Leave granted.
2. Since the question of law involved in all the captioned appeals is the same, they were taken up for hearing analogously and are being disposed of by this common judgment and order.
3. The present appeals arise from a common judgment passed by the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur dated 29.10.2009 in D.B. Special Appeal (Writ) No. 669/1999 in Civil Writ Petition No. 2171/1998 and D.B. Civil Special Appeal (Writ) No. 673/1999 in S.B. Civil Writ Petition No, 2204/1998 respectively whereby the High Court allowed the writ appeals and thereby quashed the land acquisition proceedings initiated by the appellant Trust.
* Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
1000 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
4. The Urban Development Department, Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur, issued a notice under Section 52(2) of the Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959 (the “RUI Act”), published in the official gazette on 01.07.1976, to one Ram Narain, proposing to acquire land bearing Survey no.229 measuring 2 bighas & 2 biswas and Survey no.229/ 287 measuring 2 bighas & 18 biswas situated in Village Nangli Kota, Tehsil & District Alwar (the “Nangli Kota lands”). These parcels of land were owned and possessed by Yogesh Chandra Goyal, Radheyshyam Goyal, Manohar Lal, Krishan Murari, Omprakash Goyal, Suresh Chandra Goyal and Ashok Kumar Goyal, the sons of Ram Narain as well as Kamla and Kesar Bai, the daughters of Ram Narain.
5. The appellant and the State Government also sought to acquire the land bearing Survey no. 141 measuring 3 bighas and 9 biswas situated in Village Moongaska, Tehsil and District Alwar (the “Moongaska land”), owned and possessed by Ram Narain, Radheyshyam, Manohar Lal and Yogesh Chandra Goyal.
6. Ram Narain was the khatedar of the Nangli Kota and Moongaskar parcels of land. He passed away in 1973. The Nangli Kota land was inherited by his seven sons and two daughters. As regards the Moongaska land, the same was purchased on 25.07.1966 by four individuals jointly by way of different sale deeds. Ram Narain’s portion of the Moongaska land was inherited by his seven sons and two daughters after his demise. However, the names of the two daughters were not included in the list of legal heirs submitted by the seven sons of late Ram Narain and did not become a part of the mutation records until much later on 22.03.1985.
Acquisition proceedings for the Nangli Kota lands
7. The acquisition proceedings for the Nangli Kota lands came to be initiated on 01.07.1976 when the Urban Development & Housing Department, Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur issued a notification under Section 52(2) of the RUI Act. Accordingly, Ram Narain was informed about the intention to acquire the Nangli Kota lands.
8. In response to the said notice, the legal heirs of late Ram Narain that is, his seven sons, appeared before the Officer on Special Duty, [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1001Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
Urban Improvement Trust (the “OSD”) from time to time and sought time to submit proof regarding their ownership of the said land.
9. On 28.04.1977, the OSD sent a letter to the State Government under Section 52(3) of the RUI Act recommending for issuance of notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act.
10. Thereafter, the State Government issued a notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act on 16.06.1977 and the same was published in the official gazette on 23.06.1977 showing the names of all seven sons of late Ram Narain. In such circumstances, as per the subsections (1) and (4) of Section 52, the said lands vested completely, free from all encumbrances, in the State Government.
11. On 06.06.1980, the respondents submitted a statement of admission agreeing to receive compensation amount of Rs. 90,000/- for the acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands. The OSD issued an order dated 01.07.1980 under Section 53(3) of the RUI Act for settlement of compensation amount at Rs. 90,000/- in respect of the Nangli Kota lands.
12. In the meantime, the Registrar, Board of Revenue, Ajmer sent a letter dated 22.03.1980 to the appellant Trust apprising them of the ongoing litigation before the Revenue Appellate Authority with respect to the land bearing Survey no. 229 and instructed the appellant Trust not to deposit the compensation amount till the final decision of the appeal.
13. According to the appellant Trust, the memo of handing over of the possession of the Nangli Kota lands under Section 52(5) of the RUI Act was signed by all seven sons of late Ram Narain on 23.10.1980 and the subject land was handed over to the State Government by way of voluntary surrender. However, the respondents maintain that possession was not handed over to the State Government either voluntarily or forcibly. No record of possession of the subject land being taken by the OSD has been maintained in the note sheet of the OSD.
14. On 15.01.1981, the possession of the Nangli Kota lands was handed over to the appellant Trust under Section 52(7) of the RUI Act by the State Government. Thereafter, the said lands came to be mutated in the revenue records in favour of the appellant Trust on 15.06.1981.
1002 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
15. The appellant Trust, on 31.12.1997,made a reference before the court of the Senior Civil Judge, Alwar in which an amount of Rs. 2,72,714/- was deposited i.e., Rs. 90,000/- along with 12% interest p.a. from 15.01.1981 to 15.12.1997.
16. A notice was issued by the reference court to the respondents to collect the amount towards compensation. After receiving the said notice, the respondents challenged the acquisition proceedings before the High Court in S.B. Civil Writ Petition no. 2171/1998 on the ground that since no award was passed within a period of two years, the acquisition proceedings stood lapsed.
17. A single judge of the High Court vide order dated 13.04.1999 rejected the writ petition holding that in view of Section 60A(4) introduced by the Amending Act, 1987, any land having stoodvested in the State government prior to the 01.08.1987, the acquisition of the same cannot be challenged on the ground that no amount of compensation was deposited and paid to the landowners in accordance with Section 3A and Section 17A of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
18. After the above referred order, the Nangli Kota lands came to be mutated in the name of the appellant Trust.
Proceedings before the Revenue Authorities regarding ownership of the land bearing Survey no. 229
19. The Tehsildar, Alwar presented an application before the Court of Sub-divisional Officer, Alwar (the “SDO”) on 30.11.1968 for correction of entries under Section 88 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955 in respect of the land bearing Survey no. 229 (one of the parcels of land constituting the Nangli Kota lands). It was contended by the State Government that since the area under the said land was “Banjar Kadim” that is, it was never under cultivation, therefore, it was wrongly entered into the name of the predecessors of the respondents.
20. After a period of four years, the SDO rejected the application of the Tehsildar, Alwar on 28.03.1972 and held that the land bearing Survey no. 229 was “Abadi” land that is, the land was supposed to be used for residential purposes and was outside the purview of agricultural or commercial land.
21. Aggrieved by the order of the SDO, the Tehsildar, Alwar filed an appeal before the Revenue Appellate Authority, Alwar, which was [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1003Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
allowed on 06.07.1977, and the land was declared to be “siwaichak” land or government land available for allotment for agricultural purpose.
22. The appellant Trust addressed two letters dated 02.12.1980 and 05.01.1981 respectively to the Tehsildar, Alwar stating that the land bearing Survey no. 229 already stood vested with the State Government after the issuance of the notification under Section 52(1). It was further informed to the Tehsildar that asper Jamabandi Khatuni no. 37/ 20 the said land was shown running under the name of Ram Narain and only the compensation amount remained to be paid by the appellant Trust. Further, the appellant Trust requested the office of the Tehsildar to ascertain whether the nature of the subject land was determined to be ‘siwaichak’ (government land) or was in the name of Yogesh Chandra Goyal. However, the documents put on the record before us show no communication from the Tehsildar, Alwar or any official of the State Government to the appellant Trust informing about the status of the proceedings.
23. The respondents filed a revision application before the Board of Revenue, Ajmer against the order of the Revenue Appellate Authority. The Board of Revenue vide its order dated 30.12.1983 set aside the order of the Revenue Appellate Authority and allowed the revision application of the respondents.
24. Pursuant to the order of the Board of Revenue, the land bearing Survey no. 229 was mutated in the name of the respondents that is, the seven sons of late Ram Narain. The two daughters of Ram Narain also got their names substituted in the mutation records in respect of the said land.
25. Thereafter, the appellant Trust filed a writ petition bearing number S.B. C.W.P. No. 1223/1985 before the High Court praying for setting aside of the order of the Board of Revenue on the ground that the appellant Trust was not impleaded in the proceeding therein despite the transfer of possession of the land bearing Survey no. 229 to it in pursuance of the acquisition proceedings initiated on 01.07.1976. The single judge of the High Court dismissed the writ petition on the grounds that: (1) the appellant Trust should have sought a further relief of decree of possession of the land in addition to a declaratory relief, which was not done in the instant case; and (2) it was incumbent 1004 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports upon the State Government to have informed the Board of Revenue that the possession of the subject land was handed over to the appellant Trust, by giving an application under Order 22 Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, as this was a fact that was within the special knowledge of the State Government. It could not come to the knowledge of the respondents that the land had been transferred by the State to the appellant Trust and therefore, the respondents could not be held liable for not impleading the appellant in the proceedings before the Board of Revenue.
26. The appellant Trust, aggrieved by the judgment delivered by the single judge, filed an appeal in D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 20/2012. The division bench of the High Court in its order dated 01.12.2014 observed that the appellant Trust had only reiterated the submissions made before the single judge. The said submissions were considered at length by the single judge and therefore, did not warrant any interference from the division bench. Consequently, the appeal was held to be devoid of merits and was accordingly dismissed.
27. The appellant Trust filed a Special Leave Petition bearing SLP Civil Diary No. 29045/2018 before this Court, which is still pending adjudication.
28. In the meantime, the State Government issued a notification dated 07.01.1990 under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 in respect of the land bearing Survey no. 229, which was published in the official gazette on 03.09.1990. The purpose of the acquisition under the said notification was same as the purposes set out in the notification dated 16.06.1977 under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act. However, the notification under Section 4 was not followed by a notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Acquisition proceedings for the Moongaska land
29. The acquisition proceedings for the Moongaska land were initiated on 01.07.1976 when the Urban Development & Housing Department, Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur issued a notification under Section 52(2) of the RUI Act.Late Ram Narain was informed of the same by way of a notice. The subject land was individually purchased by Ram Narain, Radhey Shyam Goyal, Yogesh Chandra Goyal and Manohar Lal, however, the notice did not clearly specify as to from whose portion of land, the acquisition was sought to be done. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1005Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
30. In response to the said notice, the legal heirs of late Ram Narain that is, his seven sons appeared before the Officer on Special Duty, Urban Improvement Trust (the “OSD”) from time to time and sought time to submit proof regarding their ownership of the said land.
31. On 28.04.1977, the OSD sent a letter to the State Government under Section 52(3) of the RUI Act for issuing notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act.
32. Thereafter, the State Government issued a notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act on 16.06.1977 and the same was published in the official gazette on 23.06.1977 showing the names of late Ram Narain, Radhey Shyam, Yogesh Chandra Goyal and Manohar Lal, being the landowners. In such circumstances, as per sub-sections
(1) and (4) of Section 52, the said lands vested completely, free from all encumbrances, in the State Government.
33. The order of the OSD dated 25.09.1978 passed under Section 52(3) of the RUI Act recorded that the amount of compensation could not be determined by way of a mutual agreement, therefore, a reference under Section 53(4) of the RUI Act was made to the Collector, Alwar on 26.08.1982.
34. The OSD wrote a letter dated 29.05.1982 asking the respondents to handover the vacant and peaceful possession of the Moongaska land under Section 52(5) of the RUI Act within 30 days failing which, the possession would be taken over by force under Section 52(6) of the RUI Act. On 16.07.1982, the possession of the said land was taken over by the State Government under Section 52(6) of the RUI Act. However, the respondents maintain that no actual or physical possession of the subject land was ever taken by the State Government. Further, the payment of compensation by the appellant Trust was condition precedent for transferring possession of the subject land to it, yet the same was not done in contravention of the provisions of the RUI Act.
35. On 22.07.1982, the possession was handed over to the appellant Trust by the State Government under Section 52(7) of the RUI Act.
36. By order dated 17.01.1988 passed by the City Magistrate, Alwar in compliance of Section 60A of the Rajasthan Urban Improvement (Amendment) Act, 1987 (the “Amending Act, 1987”), the total amount 1006 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports towards compensation was fixed at Rs. 27,600/-. The appellant Trust was liable to pay compensation to the extent of 80% of the total compensation decided, which was to be distributed amongst Radhey Shyam, Yogesh Chandra Goyal and Manohar Lal. A notice was issued to the respondents by the City Magistrate, Alwar on 27.01.1988, to collect the 80% compensation amount by 30.01.1988. A messenger from the appellant Trust also went to the residence of the respondents on 28.01.1988 to hand over the compensation amount but the respondents declined to receive the same on the grounds that compensation for the Moongaska land was supposed to be computed in accordance with the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, which was not done in the instant case and that no separate apportionment of the amount towards compensation was done for different owners.
37. The respondents challenged the legality and validity of the acquisition proceedings before the High Court in S.B. Civil Writ Petition no. 2204/1998 on the ground that since no compensation had been paid to the respondents, the acquisition proceedings stood lapsed. A single judge of the High Court vide order dated 13.04.1990 rejected the writ petition holding that no fault could be found with the final notification which was published in 1977 and having regard to the provisions of Section 60A(4) introduced by the Amending Act, 1987, the proceedings cannot be interfered with merely on the ground that compensation was not paid to the respondents. However, liberty was reserved in favour of the respondents to collect the amount towards compensation if they had not been paid yet.
38. The Land Acquisition Officer, Urban Improvement Trust, Alwar wrote a letter dated 11.08.1999 to Vinod Kumar Goyal and other respondents to collect the compensation amount otherwise, the same would be deposited in court through reference. After the order passed by the single judge, the Moongaska land was mutated in favour of the appellant Trust.
Impugned judgment of the High Court
39. A division bench of the High Court allowed the appeal filed by the respondents herein on three grounds. First,there was no substantial delay in filing of the writ petitions by the landowners. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1007Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
40. Secondly, it was held that Section 52(2) mandatorily required that individual notices be served on the landowners so that each owner would be in a position to lodge objections against the intended acquisition. It was also held that issue of individual notices under Section 52(2) is condition precedent to the issuance of notification under Section 52(1). As the notices under Section 52(2) were not served properly in accordance with the provisions of the said section in connection with both the Nangli Kota lands and Moongaska land, the notification under Section 52(1) was liable to be quashed.
41. Thirdly, the appellant herein and the State Government had failed to determine the amount towards compensation in respect of the Moongaska land in accordance with Section 60A of RUI Act as introduced by the Amending Act, 1987.
B. WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS OF THE APPELLANT
42. As regards the Nangli Kota lands, Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, the learned senior counsel for the appellant submitted as follows: a) Ms. Dave addressed herself mainly on two issues: (1) Whether the appellant fully complied with the mandatory requirements as laid in Section 52 of the RUI Act for the purpose of acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands and whether the acquisition proceedings initiated vide the notification dated 16.06.1977 could have been declared void?; and (2) Whether the appellant was required to pay Rs. 90,000/- towards compensation for the acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands?
b) As regards the first issue, the learned senior counsel submitted that the appellant issued a notification dated 01.07.1976 under Section 52(2) of the RUI Act to Ram Narain proposing to acquire the Nangli Kota lands. The said notice was also published in the official gazette. The learned senior counsel fairly conceded that on 01.07.1976, Ram Narain was dead and gone.
c) In response to the said notice, the legal heirs of Ram Narain that is, his seven sons appeared before the Officer on Special Duty (OSD) and sought time to place on record the proof of their ownership of the Nangli Kota lands. The respondents submitted various representations in respect of the proposed 1008 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports acquisition proceedings vide letters dated 30.10.1976, 01.11.1976, 30.12.1976, 17.01.1977, 07.02.1977, 24.02.1977 and 10.03.1977. However, the respondents never apprised the OSD that there was a litigation pending between them and the state government regarding the nature and ownership of one parcel of the Nangli Kota lands bearing Survey no. 229. This, according to Ms. Dave, was a willful concealment of facts on part of the respondents.
d) On 28.04.1977, the OSD sent a letter to the State Government recommending for the issuance of a notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act for acquisition of the Nangli Kota lands. e) The State Government, on 16.06.1977 issued a notification under Section 52(1) which was published in the official gazette on 23.06.1977. The learned counsel has submitted that since the said notice showed the names of all the seven sons of late Ram Narain, the notification under Section 52(1) was valid as per the provisions of the RUI Act.
f) The learned counsel relied on this Court’s judgment in Pratap v. State of Rajasthan, reported in (1996) 3 SCC 1 to submit that after the issuance of the notification under Section 52(1), the land vested completely in the State Government free from all encumbrances, as per sub-sections (1) and (4) of Section 52. g) Further, the respondents were aware of the proposed acquisition proceedings and appeared before the OSD who heard them at every stage of the proceedings. This is substantiated by the fact that the respondents sought time on multiple occasions to produce proof of their ownership of the Nangli Kota lands. The respondents also had the benefit of legal expertise and guidance all throughout the acquisition proceedings which is evident from the power of attorney or vakalatnama placed on record on behalf of the respondents. Therefore, it could not be said that the respondents being laymen had no proper knowledge of the legal implications involved in the acquisition process. h) The learned counsel relied on this Court’s judgment in Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition CMDA v. J. Sivaprakasam and Ors., reported in (2011) 1 SCC 330 to submit that there was no requirement on the part of the acquiring authority to [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1009Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
prove actual service of notice of proposal to acquire land, on the person whose land is sought to be acquired. The purpose of notice is to make the owner(s) or interested parties aware about the proposed acquisition and therefore, such knowledge can also be inferred by way of implied or constructive notice. i) The notification issued under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act contained names of all the seven sons of late Ram Narain and the same was issued after the respondents had appeared before the OSD. Therefore, the purpose of issuing the notice under Section 52(2) notice was achieved when all the interested parties appeared before the OSD and no individual service of notice or pasting of the notice at a conspicuous place of the locality was required. The learned senior counsel submitted that the High Court erred in holding the notice to be invalid taking a hyper technical view.
j) There is a presumption as per illustration (e) of Section 114 of the Evidence Act, 1872 that the notification under Section 52(1) was in conformity with the provisions of the RUI Act. Such presumption has not been dislodged by the respondents as no specific plea has been taken by them in respect of: (a) lack of power/authority of the person issuing the notification; and (b) that the procedure prescribed has not been followed in entirety, that is, no notice at all was issued to and served on any of the owners. Moreover, once the respondents participated regularly in the acquisition proceedings before the OSD and also handed over the possession of the lands proposed to be acquired on 23.10.1980, no question of argument of non-compliance of the provisions of the RUI Act could have been accepted.
k) Further, the respondents filed a writ petition before the High Court in the year 1998. There was an inordinate delay of 21 years in challenging the acquisition proceedings which were initiated in the year 1976. The High Court erred in holding that the delay in approaching the court could be at best 5 to 6 years on the reasoning that the State Government issued and published the notification in the gazette to acquire the Nangli Kota lands on 03.09.1992. The appellant clarified that although the respondents were seeking to challenge the notification dated 16.06.1997 yet, the acquisition proceedings had begun 1010 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in the year 1976. The subject land was handed over to the appellant on 15.01.1981. Therefore, taking the year 1976 to be the point of cause of action, the appellant submitted that the respondents approached the High Court 21 years after vesting of the said lands in the State Government. The learned senior counsel made an additional submission that once the land stood vested in the State and the possession was handed over to the appellant, the appellant could be said to have acquired ownership of the land.
l) The Nangli Kota lands were acquired in the year 1977 for the purpose of a residential scheme. The general public would have been the beneficiary. However, the protracted litigation and inordinate delay frustrated the very purpose for which the land was even though the subject land has been in the possession of the appellant and lying vacant for almost 50 years. m) As regards the issue of quantum of compensation raised by the appellant, the learned counsel submitted that sub-section
(3) of Section 53 provided for methods of determination of compensation. One of the methods provided therein was that compensation can be determined by way of an agreement between the State Government and the person to be compensated. Section 53(4) provided that where no such agreement could be reached, the State Government shall have to refer the case to the Collector for determination of the amount of compensation to be paid.
n) In the case of Nangli Kota lands, the amount towards compensation to be paid to the respondents was decided as per the statement of acceptance dated 06.06.1980 and a draft agreement under Section 53(3) duly signed and submitted on a stamp paper, by the seven sons of late Ram Narain. The said agreement stipulated that the respondents shall accept an amount of Rs. 90,000/- in lieu of the 5 bighas of the land. The respondents also agreed to hand over vacant and peaceful possession of the subject lands to the State Government or any other person specified in their behalf. The appellant submitted that the State Government agreed to the amount of compensation as proposed in the draft agreement and eventually paid the said amount in the court and therefore, whether the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1011Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
draft agreement was signed or not by the State Government was of no significance.
o) The appellant submitted that the Registrar, Board of Revenue, Ajmer vide its letter dated 22.03.1980 addressed to the appellant Trust had instructed that in view of the pending litigation with respect to the ownership of the Nangli Kota land before the revenue authorities, the amount towards compensation need not be deposited in court. Therefore, the payment towards compensation got delayed till the year 1997. The appellant thereafter, had addressed a letter dated 02.12.1980 to the Tehsildar, Alwar informing that the Nangli Kota land had already been vested with the State Government with the issuance of the notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act and asked the Tehsildar, Alwar vide letter dated 05.01.1981 that the issue as regards the ownership of the said land, once decided, should be informed to the appellant immediately.
p) The State Government had moved an application before the court of sub-divisional officer, Alwar seeking correction of entries with respect to one of the parcels of the Nangli Kota lands and had asked for a declaration of the same as “sivaichak land” (barren land) to be recorded in the name of the State Government. The court of sub-divisional officer rejected the said application and declared the concerned land to be an “abadi” land whose ownership was to remain with the respondents. Thereafter, on appeal, the Revenue Appellate Authority heard the matter ex parte and declared the said land to be “sivaichak” land,to be recorded in the name of the State Government. In pursuance of this order, the mutation of the lands was done in the name of the State Government. The State Government mutated the Nangli Kota lands in favour of the appellant Trust on 15.06.1981. The respondents filed a second appeal before the Board of Revenue, Ajmer against the aforesaid order but did not make the appellant a party to the litigation. The Board of Revenue allowed the second appeal on 30.12.1983 and ordered for the transfer of the land in the name of the respondents. On 20.03.1985, the relevant entries were mutated in the revenue records which transferred the Nangli Kota land from the Department Urban Improvement Trust, Alwar to the seven sons and two daughters of late Ram Narain.
1012 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports q) On 31.12.1985, the appellant filed a writ petition before the High Court against the order of the Board of Revenue, Ajmer dated 30.12.1983 on the ground that the said order affected the rights of the appellant, without being joined as a party before the Board of Revenue. A single judge of the High Court dismissed the writ petition on 30.08.2011 which was upheld by a division bench on 01.12.2014. The appellant has had filed a SLP before this Court, which is pending adjudication.
r) The appellant clarified the revenue entries and status of possession of both the parcels of lands forming part of the Nangli Kota lands as under:
• The lands bearing Khasra no. 229 as well as Khasra no. 229/287 situated in Village Nangli Kota, were mutated in favour of the appellant Trust on 15.06.1981.
• The order of Board of Revenue dated 30.12.1983 led to the mutation of only Khasra no. 229 in favour of the seven sons and two daughters of late Ram Narain. The appellant asserted that the names of the two daughters never figured in any ownership documents of the said land before and was also never mentioned by the seven sons of late Ram Narain, who regularly appeared before the OSD in the acquisition proceedings.
• The land bearing Khasra no. 229 was again mutated in favour of the appellant Trust and till date continues to remain recorded in favour of and possession of the appellant Trust.
s) It was submitted that in the case of compulsory acquisition, there is no provision in the RUI Act which provides that the landowners may decline to hand over the possession of the land being acquired if the compensation amount had not been paid to them and in any circumstances, the landowners cannot refuse to hand over the possession of the land being acquired. t) As regards the delay in payment of compensation, it was submitted that the same was caused due to the parallel proceedings pending before the Revenue Authorities which were deliberately suppressed by the respondents. The appellant had issued a notice dated 06.11.1997 asking the respondents to [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1013Urban Improvement Trust v.
Smt. Vidhya Devi and Ors.
collect the compensation amount but the respondents for the reasons best known to them did not collect it.
u) In such circumstances, the appellant had to make a reference before the District Judge, Alwar to disburse the compensation amount to the respondents. Accordingly,an amount of Rs. 2,72,212.32/- that is, compensation amount of Rs. 90,000/along with 12% interest from 15.01.1981 to 15.12.1997 was deposited with the court.
v) A notice was sent to the respondents to appear before the Land Acquisition officer, Urban Improvement Trust, Alwar in order to receive compensation. The cheque deposited in the court of the District Judge, Alwar has not been collected by the respondents till date, which shows the malafide of the respondents to back out from a concluded acquisition and/or to receive more compensation than was initially agreed upon. w) Upon receipt of notice from the reference court, the respondents challenged the acquisition proceedings before the High Court on the ground that since no award was passed within a period of two years, the acquisition proceedings stood lapsed. A single judge of the High Court dismissed the writ petition on the ground that the addition of Section 60A(4) specifically barred the respondents from challenging the validity of the acquisition proceedings on the ground that no amount of compensation was tendered and paid in accordance with Section 17(3A) of the Land Acquisition Act.
x) The respondents filed an appeal before the division bench of the High Court and the same was allowed vide the impugned judgment dated 29.10.2009. The acquisition proceedings and the notification dated 16.06.1997 issued under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act came to be quashed.
43. As regards the Moongaska land, Ms. Dave submitted as follows: a) The Urban Development Department, Jaipur had issued a notice dated 01.07.1976 under Section 52(2) of the RUI Act duly published in the gazette for the purpose of acquiring the Moongaska land and in response to the said notice, the respondents had appeared before the OSD and had prayed for time to place on record the proof of their ownership and also 1014 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the representations in respect of the acquisition proceedings. Thereafter, the OSD sent a letter to the State Government for issuance of notification under Section 52(1) of the RUI Act for acquisition of the Moongaska land. The State Government issued a notification under Section 52(1) on 16.06.1977 which was published in the official gazette on 23.06.1977 and showed names of all the owners of the Moongaska land as per the provisions of the RUI Act.
b) In terms of sub-sections (1) and (4) of Section 52 of the RUI Act, the land vested absolutely in the State Government free from all encumbrances. The appellant relied on this Court’s judgment in Pratap v. State of Rajasthan, (1996) 3 SCC 1 to substantiate this assertion.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.