Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1024; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1946
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 19 Dec 2024
- Case number
- No. 5556/2024
- Sections
- 138, 141, 139, 1948, 7, 313, 401, 397, 255(2), 4, 6, 143A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1946 : 2024 INSC 1024 Bijoy Kumar Moni v.
Paresh Manna & Anr.
(Criminal Appeal No. 5556 of 2024)
20 December 2024 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The dishonoured cheque in question was signed by respondentaccused, in his capacity as Director and Authorised Signatory of the Company Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd., on the account maintained by the Company with Standard Chartered Bank. By the impugned order, the High Court acquitted respondent-accused of offence punishable u/s.138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 holding that in absence of the company being arraigned as an accused, the complaint against the respondent-accused was not maintainable; whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned order is the question for determination.
Headnotes† Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – ss.138, 139 and 141 – Dishonour of Cheque – Cheque issued on behalf of company by its authorised signatory – Whether prosecution could not proceed against such authorised signatory, unless the company was arraigned as an accused – Whether prosecution could proceed against the accused in his personal capacity – Whether benefit of exception embodied in doctrine of lex non cogit ad impossibilia could be extended to the complainant: Held:1. Although it can be understood that the complainant had no occasion to believe that the cheque was drawn upon the bank account of Shilabati Hospital as the debt was one which was taken by the accused in his personal capacity, yet a bare perusal of the cheque shows that the cheque was signed by the accused in the capacity of the Director of the Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. as the same bears both the stamp of the director as well as the hospital – In case of a cheque issued on behalf of a company by its authorised signatory, prosecution cannot proceed against the such authorised signatory or other post-holders of the company as described under *Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1947Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. Section 141 of the NI Act, unless the company who is the drawer of the cheque is arraigned as an accused in the complaint case filed before the magistrate – Further, vicarious liability can only be affixed against the directors, authorised signatories, etc. of the company after the company is held liable for the commission of offence under Section 138. [Paras 49, 50]
2.1. It is the case of the complainant that the cheque was issued in discharge of the personal liability of the accused towards the complainant, and hence there was no occasion for it to implead the company as an accused – However, even if the cheque might have been issued for the discharge of personal liability of the accused towards the complainant, had the company Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. been arraigned as an accused in the complaint case before the Trial Court, it would have remained open to the complainant to establish with the aid of the presumption under Section 139 that the cheque issued by the company was in discharge of a legally enforceable debt – However, in the absence of the drawer of the cheque having been arraigned as an accused, it was rightly held by the High Court that no prosecution could have proceeded against the accused in his personal capacity – The only way by which the accused could be held liable was under Section 141 of the NI Act, however the same could not have been done in the absence of the company being arraigned as an accused. [Paras 51, 55]
2.2. As specified in a three-Judge Bench decision in Aneeta Hada, the only exception to the above general rule is embodied in the doctrine of lex non cogit ad impossibilia which means that the law doesn’t compel the impossible – Thus, it is only in those cases where the impleadment of the company is not possible due to some legal impediment that this general rule can be exempted – In the facts on hand, it cannot be said that there was any legal difficulty in impleading Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. as an accused in the complaint case filed by the complainant – Thus, even the benefit of the exception cannot be extended to the complainant in the present case. [Para 56]
3. It is the drawer Company which must be first held to be the principal offender under Section 138 of the NI Act before culpability can be extended, through a deeming fiction, to the other Directors or persons in-charge of and responsible to the Company for the conduct of its business – In the absence of the liability of the drawer Company, there would naturally be no requirement to hold the other persons vicariously liable for the offence committed under Section 1948 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 138 of the NI Act – It is only the drawer of the cheque who can be held liable for an offence under Section 138 of the NI Act – An authorised signatory acting on behalf of the principal cannot be said to be the “drawer” of the cheque “on an account maintained by him with a banker” under Section 138. [Paras 62, 66]
4.1. In the case on hand, the accused was prosecuted in his individual capacity and not in his capacity of being the Director of the Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. Although it is undisputed that the accused signed the cheque in question, yet as the cheque was drawn not on an account maintained by him with a Banker but was issued on an account maintained by the hospital, the requirement of Section 138 of the Act cannot be said to have been complied with. [Para 69]
4.2. It would have been altogether a different situation if the accused was prosecuted in his capacity as a Director of the Shilabati Hospital – In such a scenario, the cheque drawn by him on an account maintained by the Company would have satisfied the requirement of Section 138 of the Act but as the accused has been proceeded against for an offence under Section 138 of the Act in his individual capacity and inasmuch as the cheque dishonoured for insufficiency of funds was drawn on the account maintained by the Company, namely, Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd., and not by the accused herein, no offence could be said to have been committed under Section 138 of the Act – The High Court rightly held that in the absence of the principal offender having been arraigned as an accused, prosecution for the commission of an offence under Section 138 of the NI Act could not have proceeded against the accused. [Para 70]
5.1. The requirement of Section 138 of the NI Act is that for fastening criminal liability on the accused, the cheque which was dishonoured for insufficiency of funds etc., must have been drawn on an account maintained by the accused – The mere fact that the cheque signed by the accused in his capacity as a “Director” of the Company would in the normal course be honoured by the Bank to which it was presented does not satisfy the statutory requirement of Section 138 of the Act. [Para 71]
5.2. Section 138 of the Act exposes the person who has drawn the cheque and which has been returned for insufficiency of funds to criminal liability – The provision, therefore, must be construed strictly – However, such a strict construction should not result [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1949Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. in defeating the very purpose for which the provision has been enacted – At the same time, the statutory provisions creating penal liability cannot be stretched too far to embrace the persons and situations patently excluded from its purview as discernible from clear and unequivocal language used in the provision. [Para 72]
5.3. Section 138 of the NI Act clearly postulates that the cheque returned for insufficiency of funds should have been drawn by a person on an account maintained by him – It will amount to doing violence to the language of the statute if Section 138 of the Act is interpreted to mean that even if a person draws a cheque on an account not maintained by him, he shall be liable if the cheque is returned for insufficiency of funds – Such an interpretation will lead to absurd and wholly unintended results. [Para 73]
5.4. However, the peculiar factual situation of the present case and the plight of the complainant is not lost upon us – The option of bringing civil action against the accused or the hospital will be of no avail to the complainant as the claims are hopelessly time barred – Further, it is also not open for the complainant to initiate proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act afresh by impleading Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. as an accused as the time period prescribed for issuance of statutory notice under Section 138 has long expired. [Para 74]
5.5. It is trite law that an act may constitute an offence under more than one statute – The encashment of the cheque for an amount of Rs 7,00,000/- issued by the complainant in favour of the accused [i.e. amount borrowed by him from the complainant] stood proved during the course of the trial – Further, the conduct of the accused in not replying to the statutory notice of dishonour of cheque issued by the lawyer for the complainant and in not taking the plea of the cheque having been drawn on the account of the company in his capacity as a Director during the course of trial undoubtedly raises questions as regards his dishonest intention in not repaying the amount borrowed by him from the complainant. [Para 75]
5.6. In such circumstances, although it is not possible to hold the accused liable for the offence under Section 138 of the NI Act, yet the possibility of him having committed the offence of cheating cannot be ruled out – Prima facie, the mens rea (guilty mind) of the accused speaks for itself – It is left open to the complainant to approach the jurisdictional police station and lodge an appropriate 1950 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports FIR against the accused – If the complainant lodges an FIR, the concerned police officer in-charge of the police station shall investigate the same in accordance with law. [Paras 76, 77] Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – s.138 – Penal provision – Has to be strictly construed:
Held: Section 138 of the NI Act being penal in nature has to be strictly construed and advertence to the object behind its enactment can only be made to supplement the language employed in the text of the statute and not to supplant it or render it overly broad and susceptible to misuse. [Para 68] Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – ss.138 and 141 – Scope – Liability and vicarious liability:
Held: It is only the drawer of the cheque who can be held liable under Section 138 – Section 141 is an exception to this scheme of the NI Act and provides for vicarious liability of persons other than the drawer of the cheque in cases where the drawer of the cheque under Section 138 is a corporate person. [Para 39] Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – ss.7 and 138 – Expression “on an account maintained by him with a banker” used in s.138 – Meaning of:
Held: The expression describes the relationship between the account holder and the banker – This relationship is fundamental to the application of Section 138 – The act of maintaining an account is exclusively tied to the account holder and does not extend to any third party whom the account holder may authorize to manage the account on its behalf – Therefore, any delegation of authority to manage the account does not alter the intrinsic relationship existing between the account holder and the banker as envisaged under the NI Act. [Para 45] Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – ss.7, 138 and 141 – Whether authorized signatory of a company falls within the ambit of the expression “drawer”:
Held: Corporate persons like companies, which are mere legal entities and have no soul, mind or limb to work physically, discharge their functions through some human agency recognised under the law to work – Therefore, if some function is discharged by [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1951Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. such human agency for and on behalf of the company it would be an act of the company and not attributable to such human agent – One such instance of discharge of functions could be the authority to manage the bank accounts of the company, issue and sign cheques on its behalf, etc. which may be delegated to an authorised signatory – However, such authorisation would not render the authorised signatory as the maker of those cheques – It is the company alone which would continue to be the maker of these cheques, and thus also the drawer within the meaning of Section 7 of the NI Act – The authorised signatory is merely the physical limb that signs and makes the cheque on behalf of the company’s incorporeal personality – The company, for all purposes, continues to remain the drawer of the cheques. [Paras 45, 46] Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – Cheque drawn upon a joint account – Liability upon account holders of a joint account – Discussed:
Held: A company vis-à-vis its authorised signatory stands on a completely different footing as compared to account holders of a joint account – In the former, it is only the company which holds an account with the banker, whereas in the latter, each joint account holder can be said to hold an account with the banker – Thus, while in the case of a cheque drawn on the account of the company the authorised signatory cannot be held to be the drawer, in the case of a cheque drawn upon a joint account, each account holder affixing his signature to the cheque may be said to have drawn such a cheque. [Para 47] Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – s.138 – “any debt or other liability” appearing in s.138 of the Act – Scope of:
Held: Section 138 of the NI Act does not envisage that only those cases where a cheque issued towards the discharge of the personal liability of the drawer towards the payee gets dishonoured would come within the ambit of the provision – The expression “of any debt or other liability” appearing in Section 138 when read with the Explanation to the provision is wide enough to bring any debt or liability which is legally enforceable within its fold – Thus, the requirement under the provision is that the debt or any other liability has to be legally enforceable and the emphasis is not on the existence of such debt or other liability between the drawer and the payee – Even those cases where a person assumes the 1952 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports responsibility of discharging the debt of some other person, and in furtherance thereof draws a cheque on an account maintained by him, which subsequently gets dishonoured upon being presented before the drawee, would be covered by Section 138 if the payee is able to establish that there was some sort of an arrangement by way of which the debt was assumed by the drawer. [Para 52] Case Law Cited P.J. Agro Tech Ltd. and Others v. Water Base Ltd. [2010] 9 SCR 119 : (2010) 12 SCC 146; Jugesh Sehgal v. Shamsher Singh Gogi [2009] 10 SCR 857 : (2009) 14 SCC 683; Shri Gurudatta Sugars Marketing (P) Ltd. v. Prithviraj Sayajirao Deshmukh and Others [2024] 7 SCR 1211 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1800; N. Harihara Krishnan v. J. Thomas [2017] 9 SCR 324 : (2018) 13 SCC 663; Aparna A. Shah v. Sheth Developers (P) Ltd. [2013] 7 SCR 69 : (2013) 8 SCC 71; Anil Sachar and Another v. Shree Nath Spinners Private Limited and Others [2011] 9 SCR 328 : (2011) 13 SCC 148; ICDS Ltd. v. Beena Shabeer and Another [2002] Supp. 1 SCR 488 : (2002) 6 SCC 426; Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels and Tours Private Limited [2012] 5 SCR 503 : (2012) 5 SCC 661; Anil Gupta v. Star India Private Limited and Another [2014] 8 SCR 183 : (2014) 10 SCC 373; Ashok Shewakramani and Others v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Another (2023) 8 SCC 473; NEPC Micon Limited and Others v. Magma Leasing Limited [1999] 2 SCR 932 : (1999) 4 SCC 253 – relied on.
Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Pennar Peterson Securities Ltd. and Others [2000] 1 SCR 1120 : (2000) 2 SCC 745; Himanshu v. B. Shivamurthy and Another [2019] 1 SCR 991 : (2019) 3 SCC 797; Mainuddin Abdul Sattar Shaikh v. Vijay D. Salvi [2015] 6 SCR 1033 : (2015) 9 SCC 622; Raghu Lakshminarayanan v. Fine Tubes [2007] 4 SCR 885 : (2007) 5 SCC 103 – referred to. P.N. Salim v. P.J. Thomas & Another, 2004 SCC Online Ker 269; Hashmikant M. Seth v. State of Gujarat & Anr., 2004 SCC Online Guj 300 – approved.
P. Sarvana Kumar v. S.P. Vijaya Kumar, 2022 SCC Online Mad 1387 – disapproved.
List of Acts Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1953Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. List of Keywords Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881; Dishonour of Cheque; Vicarious liability; Company; Section 141 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881; Section 139 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881; Any debt or other liability; Debt; Drawer of the cheque; Account maintained by him; Authorised signatory; Accused in his personal capacity; Doctrine of lex non cogit ad impossibilia; Cheque drawn upon a joint account.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5556 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 19.03.2024 of the High Court at Calcutta in CRR No. 887 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Uddyam Mukherjee, Swapnil Pattanayak, Agnibha Chatterjee, Advs. for the Appellant.
Gaurav Kejriwal, Abhijit Sengupta, Navneet Singh, Kunal Chatterji, Ms. Maitrayee Banerjee, Rohit Bansal, Ms. Mrinalini Mukherjee, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment/Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, the present judgment is divided into the following parts:
INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ............................................................. 2 i. Proceedings before the Trial Court ............................. 6 ii. Proceedings before the Sessions Court ..................... 11 iii. Proceedings before the High Court ............................. 16 *Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
1954 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT / COMPLAINANT .................................................................. C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT / ACCUSED ........................................................................... D. ANALYSIS .......................................................................... 22 i. Section 138 of the NI Act .............................................. 22 ii. Whether authorized signatory of a company falls within the ambit of the expression “drawer”? ............................ iii. Meaning of the expression “on an account maintained by him” used in Section 138 of the NI Act ........................ iv. Scope of the expression “any debt or other liability” appearing in Section 138 of the NI Act ........................... v. Section 141 of the NI Act ............................................. 48 E. CONCLUSION ................................................................... 55
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order dated 19.03.2024 passed by the High Court at Calcutta in Criminal Revision No. 887 of 2019 by which the High Court allowed the criminal revision application preferred by the respondent herein (original accused) and thereby quashed and set aside the judgment and order of conviction passed by the Trial Court and affirmed by the Sessions Court for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (for short, the “NI Act”).
3. For the sake of convenience, the appellant herein shall be referred to as the complainant and the respondent herein shall be referred to as the accused.
4. Since these proceedings arise from a private complaint, the respondent no. 2, that is, the State of West Bengal, although represented by Mr. Kunal Chatterji, has no role to play.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1955Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
5. The facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarised as under: a. The case of the complainant is plain and simple. According to him, for the purpose of operating his trade loan account, he would frequently visit the U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch and it is during one such visit sometime in the month of January, 2006 that he came to be introduced to the accused by one Ashoke Mondal who was the Manager of the said branch. Thereafter, the accused maintained amicable relations with the complainant through telephonic conversations.
b. In February 2006, the accused was in need of some financial assistance and in such circumstances, he approached the complainant with a request that a particular amount may be lent to him with a promise to repay on demand.
c. Accordingly, the complainant issued a bearer cheque for an amount of Rs.7,00,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakh only)
which indisputably was encashed by the accused.
d. Upon the complainant requesting the accused to repay the amount referred to above, he issued a cheque dated 28.04.2006 drawn on the Standard Chartered Bank, N.S. Road, Kolkata for the amount of Rs.8,45,000/- (Rupees Eight lakh forty five thousand only). It is the case of the complainant that Rs. 7,00,000/- was lent by him by way of a bearer cheque and Rs. 1,45,000/- was subsequently lent in cash. That is how the accused issued a cheque of Rs. 8,45,000/- for the purpose of discharging his debt towards the complainant.
e. However, the said cheque was signed by him in his capacity as a Director of Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. and was drawn upon the bank account maintained in the name of the hospital.
f. There is a stamp of Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd. on the cheque and beneath the signature of the accused there is a stamp of the Director.
g. It is not in dispute that the cheque in question came to be dishonoured for want of sufficient funds.
1956 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports h. In such circumstances, the complainant issued a statutory notice to the accused under Section 138 of the NI Act dated 14.08.2006 calling upon him to make the payment within 15 days of the receipt of the notice.
6. The statutory notice referred to above is reproduced herein below: “ DATE: 14/8/2006 To Sri Paresh Manna C/o SHILABATI HOSPITAL PVT. LTD.
P.O. CHATAL, Distt. Peschim Midnapur Dear Sir, Under the instructions of my client Sri Bijay Kumar Moni son of Sri Mursrimohan Nond, resident of Raghunathpur, P.O./P.S. Raghunathpur, Distt. Purulia. I do hereby serve you this notice to the following effect.
That my client had been introduced to you by Sri Achoke Mondal, Branch Manager United Bank of India, Raghunathpur Branch some time in the month of February, 2008.
That my client was also informed by Sri Ashok Mondal that you are contemplating to start a -Nursing Home with huge investment at Raghunathpur.
That taking advantage of the said introduction by Sri Ashok Mandal you - approached my client for a sum of Rs. 8,45,000/- (eight lakhs forty five thousand) only to be repaid within a very short period.
That my client very innocently acceded to your request and arranged to handover a sum of Rs. 8,45,000/- (eight lakh forty five thousand) out of the said sum of Rs. 7,00,000/- (Seven lakhs) was given to you by my client through cheque No. 951764 on his trade loan A/C maintained with U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch on 28.02.06 and the rest amount was paid by my client to you in cash.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1957Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. That you in discharge of your existing legal debts and outstanding liabilities had issued A/C. payee cheque No.997309 in favour of my client on 28.04.06 for Rs.
8,45,000/- (eight lakhs forty five thousand) against your account maintained in standard chartered Bank, 19, N.S. Road, Kolkata-700001. That as per your instruction my client had presented the said cheque for encashment through his banker, U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch on 22.07.06.
That my client had received back the cheque refused by you with the bank unpaid issue memo dated 27.07.06 that the same has returned due to insufficient fund.
That as per instruction of my client I am sending this demand notice to you with the intimation that you must pay back to my client the sum of 8,45,000/- (eight lakhs forty-five thousand) within 15 days from the date of receipt of the notice, failing which my client will be constrained to take recourse to law without any further intimation.
Thanking you, Yours faithfully, Sd/- Arun Kumar Moni Advocate Dt. 14-08-06”
7. It is not in dispute that the accused upon receipt of the above notice failed to give any appropriate reply to the complainant.
8. In such circumstances, the complainant was left with no other option but to file a private complaint in the Court of the A.C.J.M. at Raghunathpur, District Purulia for the offence punishable under Section 138 of the NI Act which came to be registered as Complaint Case No. 39 of 2006.
i. Proceedings before the Trial Court
9. As the facts of this case are little peculiar, we deem it necessary to reproduce the entire complaint as under:
“In the Court of the A.C.J.M. at Raghunathpur, District Purulia.
Complaint Case No. 39 of 2006.
1958 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Bijoy Kumar Moni son of Sri Murari Mohan Moni, resident of Raghunathpur, P.O. & P.S. Raghunathpur, Dist. Purulia. …Complainant -Versus- Paresh Manna son of not known c/o. Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd., P.O. Chatal, P.S. Ghatal, District East Midnapur. …Accused Person Offence committed: U/s. 138 of Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881.
Date of occurrence: Since August, 2006 onwards.
Name of witnesses:
1. Sri Ashoke Mondal s/o. Naba Kumar Mondal, Manager of U.B.I Raghunathpur Branch, Dist. Purulia.
2. Sanjoy Ganguly s/o. Late Dhirendranath Ganguly.
3. Shyamapada Kumbhakar, s/o. Late Gopal Chandra Kumbhakar both of Raghunathpur, P.O. & P.S.
Raghunathpur, Dist. Purulia.
The humble petition on behalf of the complainant Most respectfully showeth:
1. That the complainant hails from a very respectable family of Raghunathpun, District Purulia and he has been engaged in construction enterprise and considering his credibility and goodwill the local U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch has provided him with a trade loan account bearing A/C No. 9.
2. That the complainant in operating his trade loan account has very often visits to the U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch and thus a close tie grew up with the Branch Manager, Sri Ashoke Mondal.
3. That sometime in the month of January, 2006 the complainant along with witness No. 2 had met the Branch Manager, U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch and there he noticed the accused present in his chamber. Sri Ashoke Mondal introduced the accused to the complainant saying that the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1959Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. latter is an established personality in construction work at Raghunathpur and is a solvent party having trade loan A/C in his Branch. Sri Mondal also informed the complainant that he knows the accused personally and he is the owner of a renowned nursing home styled “Shilabati” Hospital Pvt. Ltd. of Ghatal, East Midnapur. Sri Mondal also apprised the complainant that the accused is contemplating to start a nursing home Project at Raghunathpur with huge investments.
4. That the complainant innocently believed all the narration of Sri Mondal. Accused also taking advantage of such introduction grew familiar with the complainant and also apprised him in details his contemplated project at Raghunathpur and sought for complainant’s co-operation in as much as he is a man of the locality. The Complainant was greatly impressed by the talking of the accused and assured to cooperate with him in all respect.
5. That the accused thereafter kept close contact with the complainant and over phone from Ghatal. On 28.02.2006 the complainant along with witnesses Nos. 2 and 3 had come to the U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch and there the accused met him and informed that he is in dire need of Rs. 7,00,000/- (Seven Lacs) only for a couple of months for incidental expenses relating to his contemplated project. Complainant innocently believed the accused and issued a cheque No. 951764 on his trade loan A/C for Rs. 7,00,000/- in favour of the accused on 28.02.06.
6. That the accused withdrew the sum of Rs. 7,00,000/and shortly thereafter the accused again approached the complainant for another sum of Rs. 1,45,000/- (One Lac forty five thousand) in presence of the witnesses Nos. 2 and 3. Complainant was hesitant to accede to such request of the accused but latter due to repeatedly insistence the complainant arranged for the sum on the promise of the accused to repay the entire sum very shortly.
7. That the complainant accordingly paid Rs. 1,45,000/- to the accused in presence of Witnesses Nos. 2 and 3 in the early part of March, 2006.
1960 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
8. That the accused thereafter started avoiding the complainant. However, on 28.04.2006 the accused in discharge of his existing debt and liabilities issued in favour of the complainant at Raghunathpur a cheque bearing No. 997309 for Rs. 8,45,000/- (Eight Lac forty five thousand) on his A/C maintained in Chartered Bank, N.S. Road Kolkata. However the accused while handing over the said cheque requested the complainant not to present the same for encashment before third week of July, 2006.
9. That the complainant as per the instructions of the accused presented the Cheque No. 997309 dated 28.4.2006 for encashment on 22.07.2006 through his Banker U.B.I. Raghunathpur Branch. The said cheque bounced and the complainant received back the cheque along with unpaid item nemo, of standard chartered Bank dated 27.7.06 through his Banker on 03.08.2006 with the note “Insufficient funds.
10. That the complainant thereupon through his Lawyer Sri Arun Kumar Moni of Raghunathpur Court had issued a demand notice to the accused dated 14.08.2006. It was sent under registered Post with A/D on 16.08.2006 and it was duly received on behalf of the accused on 19.08.2006 as per the endorsement appearing on the A/D card.
11. That the accused even inspite of the receipt of the demand notice failed to pay Rs. 8,45,000/- to the Complainant. However he kept on giving false and frivolous excuses to the complainant over phone and through Sri Ashok Mondal Branch Manager, Raghunathpur U.B.I.
Branch that he would repay the sum soon.
12. That the accused had with fraudulent intention prevailed! Accused had upon the complainant with the tacit support of Sri Ashoke Mondal to part with Rs. 8,45,000/- (Eight Lac forty five thousand) and he also with malafide intention issued the cheque knowing fully well that the same would never get cleared.
13. That the accused has thus committed an offence U/s. 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 and is liable to be prosecuted and punished in accordance with law. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1961Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr.
14. That the complainant is filing the Cheque No. 997309 along with unpaid item memo. issued by the Bank, Postal receipt A/D card and office copy of the demand notice. It is therefore most respectfully prayed that your Honour will be pleased to take cognisance of the offence and issue process against the accused to stand his trial in the court of law in accordance with law.
AND
For this act of kindness, your petitioner as in duty bound shall ever pray.
Affidavit Sd/-illegible 28/8/2023”
10. During the trial, the complainant entered the box and led oral evidence. He was cross examined by the defence counsel appearing for the accused. It appears that the accused also examined himself and as his witness the Branch Manager was also examined.
11. In the further statement of the accused recorded under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short “the Cr.P.C.”), the Trial Court put a specific question:
“11; P.W.1 Sri Bijoy Kr Moni, has stated in his examinationin-chief that, since thereafter you started avoiding the complainant. However, on 28/04/06 you in discharge of your existing debts and liabilities issued a cheque bearing No. 997309 for Rs. 8,45,000/- on your account maintained in chartered Bank. N.S Road. Kolkata. Do you have anything to say about this statement?”
12. To the aforesaid Question No. 11, the accused replied that he had issued the cheque as a security towards a loan transaction.
13. The Question No. 21 in the further statement of the accused reads thus:
“21) Qus:- P.W.1 Sri Bijoy Kumar Moni, further stated during in his evidence that, you have prevailed upon the complainant by gaining his confidence took Rs.8,45,000/- 1962 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and thereafter issued cheque no. 997309 to him with the knowledge that there is no sufficient fund in the account. What do you have to say about his statement?”
14. To the aforesaid question, the answer of the accused was that the cheque was issued by the company as a security towards some mortgage.
15. Upon appreciation of the oral as well as documentary evidence, the Trial Court vide Judgment and Order dated 19.07.2017 held the accused guilty of the offence punishable under Section 138 of the NI Act. The operative part of the order passed by the Trial Court reads thus: “That the convict Paresh Manna is sentenced to suffer simple Imprisonment for one year. The convict is further sentenced to pay compensation amounting to Rs.
10,00,000 (Ten lakhs only) to the complainant namely Bijoy Kumar Moni within two months from the date of this order, in default of payment of which the convict is liable to further suffer rigorous imprisonment for two months.” ii. Proceedings before the Sessions Court
16. The accused, aggrieved by the order of conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court, went in appeal before the Sessions Court. The Sessions Court affirmed the findings recorded by the Trial Court and dismissed the appeal vide Judgment and Order dated 22.02.2019. The operative part of the order passed by the Sessions Court reads thus:
“Accordingly it is ordered that the Criminal appeal no 03/17 be and the same is dismissed on contest.
The impugned judgment and order of conviction dt.
19.07.17 passed by Ld. Judicial Magistrate, 1” Court, Raghunathpur in C.Case no. 39/06 (TR No. 315/06) is hereby affirmed.
The stay of operation of judgment and order of conviction dt. 19.07.17 is thus vacated.
The appellant is directed to surrender before the Trial Court to serve out the sentence as directed within a month from the date of delivery of judgment.”
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1963Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr.
17. At this stage, we may also reproduce some of the findings recorded by the Sessions Court:
“In the case in hand before the Trial Court according to the ocular version of DW 1, the appellant himself, he tried to convince that he did not take any money in his personal capacity. Now we find the clear picture about the transaction in respect of cheque no. 951764 from evidence of DW 2, the manager of UBI, Raghunathpur branch, the banker of the respondent/complainant, who was brought by the accused/ appellant to adduce evidence on his behalf. In course of the ocular evidence the original cheque no. 951764 dt. 28.02.06 amounting to Rs. 7,00,000/- was identified and proved by DW 2 and he admitted at the time of cross examination that on 28.02.06 the sum of Rs. 7,00,000/- was debited to the accused/ appellant.
Throughout the trial the accused/appellant did not place any document or did not adduce any evidence that he, being the Director of Shilabati Hospital Private Ltd., had joint account with the company and that was operated by him for any transaction with that company. Being questioned about getting the confidence of the respondent/complainant to get the entire amount of Rs. 8,45,000/- and subsequent issuance of cheque bearing no. 997309 in discharging the liability of repayment, the accused/appellant took the plea that the said cheque was issued from the company as security of mortgage. But again to the utter surprise in course of trial no document of any mortgage was produced by him to establish the fact that the cheque bearing no. 997309 was issued in discharging the liability as security and the company was liable also for that ground. The appellant tried to shift the onus upon the respondent/ complainant, but he could not succeed to that effect. In my considered opinion I am constrained to take into account the plea of the accused that the company was also the accused of that case ad thus the ruling relied upon by the accused/ appellant do not render any support to the contention of him.
In this regard I would like to refer the observation of Hon’ble Apex Court as reported in 2010 AIR SCW 4616 and as 1964 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports relied upon by the side of respondent. It has been observed by Hon’ble Apex Court that: “Negotiable Instruments Act (26 of 1881), S. 138- Dishonour of cheque Complaint- Tenable only against drawer of cheque-Cheque drawn by employee of appellant-company on his personal account- Even if it be for discharging dues of appellant- company and its Directors-Appellant-company and its Directors cannot be made liable under 5. 138.”
From a bare reading of S.138 of NI Act the first and foremost ingredient is that the person who is to be made liable should be the drawer of the cheque and should have drawn the cheque on an account maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of money to another person from out of that account for discharging whole or part, of any debt or any liability.
At the time of his examination u/s 313 Cr.P.C when the memory of the appellant was shattered by putting question about issuance of cheque bearing no. 997309 amounting to Rs. 8,45,000/- from his account maintained at Chattered Bank, NS Road, Kolkata, he admitted about such issuance of cheque but placed another story about such issuance of that cheque as loan security. As I have already held, throughout the trial the accused/ appellant never bothered to prove anything to substantiate his proposition that there was any agreement between him and the complainant/ respondent about his taking loan for any purpose or that he received the amount vide cheque no. 951764 on behalf of the company i.e.
Shilabati Nursing Home Private Ltd.
In this regard I would like to refer to the observation of Hon’ble Apex Court as reported in 2015 AIR SCW 4015 and as relied upon by the side of respondent. It has been observed by Hon’ble Apex Court that: “Negotiable Instruments Act (26 of 1881), S. 138- Dishonour of cheque- Liability Cheque drawn by respondent in his personal capacity and not by company of which he is Managing Director Company is not liable even if it is for discharging dues of company Respondent being drawer of cheque is alone liable for offence under S. 138,” “Presumptions are [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1965Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. devices by use of which the Courts are enabled and entitled to pronounce on an issue notwithstanding that there is no evidence or insufficient evidence. Under the Evidence Act all presumptions must come under one or the other class of the three classes mentioned in the Act, namely, (1) ‘may presume (rebuttable), (2) ‘shall presume (rebuttable) and (3) ‘conclusive presumptions’ (irrebuttable). The term ‘presumptions’ is used to designate inference, affirmative or dis-affirmative of the existence of a fact, conveniently called the ‘presumed fact drawn by a judicial tribunal, by a process of probable reasoning from some matter of fact, either judicially noticed or admitted or established by legal evidence to the satisfaction of the tribunal. Presumptions literally means ‘taking as true without examination or proof....” (2009) 2 SCC 513.
To disprove the presumption, the accused should bring on record such facts and circumstances, upon consideration of which, the Court may either believe that the consideration and the debt did not exist or there non existence was so probable that a prudent man would under the circumstances of the case, act upon the plea that they did not exist. Something which is probable has to be brought on record for getting the burden of proof shifted to the complainant.
In the present case in hand the appellant at the time of adducing evidence as DW 1, denied the fact of taking the cheque amount of Rs. 7,00,000/- and liquid cash of Rs. 1,45,000/- totaling Rs. 8,45,000/- In his personal capacity, but by producing D.W 2, the branch manager of UBI, Raghunathpur branch, he tilted the entire case in support of the prosecution/complainant as because said DW 2 admitted on going through the documents (Exbt.
C and Exbt. D) that on 28.02.06 a sum of Rs. 7,00,000/was debited to the appellant and that was the case of the complainant/ respondent that on 28.02.06 he issued the cheque bearing no. 951764 amounting to Rs. 7,00,000/in favour of the appellant. During the course of trial the appellant/ accused failed to shift the burden of proof upon the respondent/ complainant that he was falsely implicated 1966 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and the company was the essential party to face the trial also and thus I am of the view that the rulings relied upon by the appellant do not render any help and support to succeed with his contention.
After perusal of the evidence on record and the entire judgment, I am constrained to hold that ld. Trial Court was wrong thereby observing the appellant guilty for the commission of offence u/s 138 of NI Act, rather going through the entire judgment, I find that Id. Trial Court meticulously described the finding for holding the appellant guilty for commission of the offence and rightly passed the order of conviction, and thus I find that this Appellate Court has no scope to make any interference with the order of conviction.
Upon my above observation the criminal appeal fails & is hereby dismissed.
C.F. paid is found correct.”
iii. Proceedings before the High Court
18. The accused being dissatisfied with the dismissal of his appeal by the Sessions Court invoked the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 401 read with Section 397 of the Cr.P.C.
19. The High Court allowed the revision application and acquitted the accused on the ground that the offence as alleged could be said to have been committed by the company, that is Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd., which is a separate legal entity. It further observed that as the cheque was drawn by the accused for and on behalf of the company in his capacity as one of the Directors, he could have been held vicariously liable for the alleged offence in terms of Section 141 of the NI Act, but only if the company was made an accused and held guilty. According to the High Court, as the company was not arraigned as an accused person, the accused as a Director of the said company could not be held vicariously liable for the offence.
20. The High Court placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Himanshu v. B. Shivamurthy and Another reported in (2019) 3 SCC 797 and held that in the absence of the company being [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1967Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. arraigned as an accused, the complaint against the accused could not be held to be maintainable. It observed that although the complainant was entitled to the benefit of the presumption under Section 139 of the NI Act as the accused had failed in rebutting the presumption cast upon him, yet in the absence of compliance with the requirements necessary for the applicability of vicarious liability as provided under Section 141, the accused could not have been convicted as a sole accused in the absence of the company being arraigned as an accused and convicted as the principal offender first. The observations made by the High Court are reproduced hereinbelow:
“27. The Company is neither a party nor was any notice served upon the Company of which the petitioner as director issued the cheque.
28. The petitioner is the sole accused/opposite party in the complaint case, having signed the cheque as Director of the company, for and on its behalf.
xxx xxx xxx
30. The facts in the present case is very similar to the case, in Himanshu vs. B. Shivamurthy & Anr. (Supra).
xxx xxx xxx
31. In the present case:a) The company has not been made an accused nor was any notice served upon the company, though the cheque was issued on behalf of the company.
b) The petitioner has been made an accused as the person, who signed and issued the cheque.
32. Therefore, in the absence of the company being arraigned as an accused, a complaint against the petitioner is not maintainable Himanshu vs. B. Shivamurthy & Anr. (supra).
xxx xxx xxx
37. In the present case the presumption is clearly in favour of the complainant and the petitioner has not been able to rebut the said presumption under Section 139 N.I. Act. 1968 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports But there is no compliance under Section 141 N.I. Act and as such the proceedings in the present case is clearly not maintainable.”
21. In view of the aforesaid, the High Court set aside the order of the Sessions Court which had upheld the order of conviction passed by the Trial Court. The operative part of the impugned order passed by the High Court is extracted hereinbelow:
“40. The Judgment and Order dated February 22, 2019 passed by the Court of the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Raghunathpur at Purulia, in connection with Criminal Appeal No. 03 of 2017 thereby affirming the Judgment and Order dated July 19, 2017 passed by the Learned Magistrate, 1 Court, Raghunathpur, Purulia in C. Case No. 39 of 2006 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 thereby convicting the petitioner under Section 255(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 for Commission of offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and sentencing the petitioner to suffer simple imprisonment for one year and to pay compensation of Rs. 10 lakhs to the Opposite Party no.2 within two months from the date of the Order, in default, to suffer rigorous imprisonment of further two months, is hereby set aside/quashed.”
22. The complainant being dissatisfied with the judgment and order passed by the High Court acquitting the accused of the alleged offence, has come up before this Court with the present appeal. B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT /
COMPLAINANT
23. Mr. Uddyam Mukherjee, the learned counsel appearing for the complainant, vehemently submitted that the High Court committed an egregious error in acquitting the accused on the ground that he could not have been held vicariously liable for the offence said to have been committed by the company in the absence of the company being prosecuted and punished.
24. According to the learned counsel, the transaction in question was between the accused and the complainant. The company was not at [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1969Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. all in picture. He submitted that there is nothing on record to indicate that the accused had borrowed the amount for the company or on behalf of the company.
25. He submitted that although the cheque in question might have been issued by the accused containing a stamp of the hospital on it and signed by him in his capacity as a Director of the company, yet the said cheque was issued in discharge of his personal debt.
26. He further submitted that even before the Trial Court, it was not the defence of the accused that he had issued the cheque to discharge the debt of the company. He led no evidence worth the name in this regard. On the contrary, his defence was that the cheque was issued by way of a security towards a loan transaction and the same had been misused by the complainant.
27. In such circumstances, referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being merit in his appeal, the same be allowed and the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court be set aside. C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT /
ACCUSED
28. On the other hand, Mr. Gaurav Kejriwal the learned counsel appearing for the accused, while opposing this appeal, submitted that no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned order.
29. According to him, it is well-settled that if the accused is to be held vicariously liable for the offence alleged to have been committed by the company, then in the absence of company being prosecuted, no vicarious liability can be fastened on the Director of the company who is said to have drawn the cheque in question. He submitted that there is no possibility of any doubt arising as regards whether the cheque in question was drawn upon the account maintained by the company as the cheque was duly stamped with the stamp of the company. It was the responsibility of the complainant to exercise due diligence and issue a statutory notice to the drawer of the cheque, that is Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd.
30. He would submit that all throughout the defence of his client was that the cheque was issued by way of security towards a loan transaction and not in discharge of any legally enforceable debt. 1970 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
31. In such circumstances, referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being no merit in the appeal the same may be dismissed.
D. ANALYSIS
32. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned order.
i. Section 138 of the NI Act
33. Section 138 of the NI Act is contained in the Chapter XVII which was inserted vide Section 4 of the Banking, Public Financial Institutions and Negotiable Instruments Laws (Amendment) Act, 1988. Chapter XVII of the NI Act, which consists of Sections 138 to 147, inter alia provides for penalties in case of dishonour of certain cheques for insufficiency of funds in the accounts. Paragraph (xi) of the Statement of the Objects and Reasons specifies the legislative intent behind introduction of Chapter XVII to the NI Act in the following words: “(xi) to enhance the acceptability of cheques in settlement of liabilities by making the drawer liable for penalties in case of bouncing of cheques due to insufficiency of funds in the accounts or for the reason that it exceeds the arrangements made by the drawer, with adequate safeguards to prevent harassment of honest drawers.”
34. Section 138 of the NI Act reads as under:
“138. Dishonour of cheque for insufficiency, etc., of funds in the account.— Where any cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of money to another person from out of that account for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability, is returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit of that account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement made with that bank, such person shall be deemed to have committed an offence and shall, without prejudice to any other provision of this Act, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may be [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1971Bijoy Kumar Moni v. Paresh Manna & Anr. extended to two years’, or with fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque, or with both:
Provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply unless—
(a) the cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier;
(b) the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque, as the case may be, makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice; in writing, to the drawer of the cheque, within thirty days of the receipt of information by him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid; and
(c) the drawer of such cheque fails to make the payment of the said amount of money to the payee or, as the case may be, to the holder in due course of the cheque, within fifteen days of the receipt of the said notice.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, “debt of other liability” means a legally enforceable debt or other liability.”
35. This Court in Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Pennar Peterson Securities Ltd. and Others reported in (2000) 2 SCC 745 explained the ingredients which are to be satisfied for making out a case under Section 138 of the NI Act in the following manner:
“10. On a reading of the provisions of Section 138 of the NI Act it is clear that the ingredients which are to be satisfied for making out a case under the provision are:
(i) a person must have drawn a cheque on an account maintained by him in a bank for payment of a certain amount of money to another person from out of that account for the discharge of any debt or other liability;
(ii) that cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier;
(iii) that cheque is returned by the bank unpaid, either because the amount of money standing to the credit of 1972 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement made with the bank;
(iv)the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice in writing, to the drawer of the cheque, within 15 days of the receipt of information by him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid;
(v) the drawer of such cheque fails to make payment of the said amount of money to the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque within 15 days of the receipt of the said notice.”
36. In the case on hand, the cheque in question came to be signed by the accused, in his capacity as the Director and Authorised Signatory of the Company Shilabati Hospital Pvt. Ltd., on the account maintained by the Company with the Standard Chartered Bank. Hence, the question that falls for our determination is whether the accused could be said to be covered by the expression “account maintained by him” as it appears in Section 138 of the NI Act. In other words, could it be said that the accused was “maintaining” the bank account upon which the dishonoured cheque had been drawn.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.