Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1014; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1355
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice Pankaj Mithal
- Decided
- 18 Dec 2024
- Case number
- TRANSFER PETITION (CIVIL) No. 278/2023
- Sections
- 25, 13, 200, 13(1), 13B(1), 13B, 506, 340, 482, 498A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1355 : 2024 INSC 1014 Rinku Baheti v.
Sandesh Sharda (Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 278 of 2023)
19 December 2024 [B.V. Nagarathna* and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the petitioner-wife is entitled to the transfer of the divorce petition; and whether this Court, upon the application filed by the respondent-husband, can exercise its powers u/Art. 142(1) of the Constitution to grant a decree of divorce to the parties on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art. 142(1) – Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 – ss.13, 13B – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – s.25 – Transfer petition – Transfer of divorce petition – Dissolution of marriage – Irretrievable breakdown of marriage – Permanent alimony – Second marriage of both the parties – Husbandrespondent, a citizen of USA – Parties had brief period of relationship of three months, thereafter marital discord resulting in multiple litigations – Criminal complaints by the wife-petitioner against the husband, alleging offences of cruelty, outraging of modesty, rape, cheating, along with the complaint against her father-in-law – Issuance of ‘Look Out Circular’ against the husband, leading to his arrest at the airport – Husband released on bail after one month of police custody – Husband filed three divorce petitions within a span of 34 days before the Family Court, out of which, the first was dismissed as withdrawn; second filed by both parties was dismissed for being pre-mature and the third is pending adjudication – Transfer petition by the wife before this Court seeking transfer of the third divorce petition – During pendency, application u/Art.142(1) by the husband seeking dissolution of marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage – Wife also filed application before the Transferee Court for fixation of alimony:
*Author 1356 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: Hardly any cordiality or meaningful marital relationship emerged from the marriage of the parties – Submission of the wife that she intends to continue her marital relationship with the husband cannot be accepted – Events stated deterred the husband from continuing with his marital relationship with the wife – It is difficult to fathom as to how the wife can reasonably expect her spouse to continue in a cordial marital relationship with her, when she has filed a criminal case against him, got a “Look Out Circular” issued against him, and even got him arrested – On one hand, petitioner sought the dismissal of application u/Art.142(1) on the ground that she wishes to continue the marriage, while in the same breath, she has demanded a huge sum of money as permanent alimony equalling the share received by the respondent’s ex-wife – Petitioner’s criminal complaint, among other things, has left incurable scar on the relationship between the parties – No chance for the parties to reconcile their differences and lead a normal married life hereinafter – Marriage has completely failed and also no child born out of the wedlock – Thus, fit case to exercise discretion u/ Art.142(1), as such the application u/Art.142(1) is allowed and the marriage between the petitioner and the respondent is dissolved on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage – As regards, permanent alimony the wife sought equalisation of status not just with the respondent-husband but also with the ex-wife of the respondent, which cannot be an acceptable approach – Petitioner cannot simply claim an amount equal to what the ex-wife of the respondent had received or on the basis of the income of the respondent – Court has to not just consider the income of the respondent-husband, but also bear in mind other factors such as the income of the petitioner-wife, her reasonable needs, her residential rights, and other similar factors – Thus, her entitlement to maintenance has to be decided based on the factors applicable to her – Also duration of marriage, a relevant factor to be taken into consideration which was hardly three to four months – In the petition seeking divorce by mutual consent, respondent agreed to pay sum of Rs.8 crores towards full and final settlement of all claims of the petitioner – Family Court assessed Rs.10 crores as the quantum of permanent alimony, which is accepted – Additional amount of Rs.2 crores is liable to be paid to the petitioner to enable her to acquire another flat – Thus, sum of Rs.12 crores to be paid as permanent alimony to the petitioner by the respondent as a full and final settlement of all her claims on the respondent and his family – Also Rs. Three Lakhs to be paid as litigation expenses. [Paras 9.10, 9.11, 9.13-9.16, 11-13, 14.7-14.10, 15] [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1357Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 – Fixation of Maintenance/Alimony – Factors for computing maintenance:
Held: No fixed formula for calculating maintenance amount – Should be based on a balanced consideration of various factors – Factors are illustrative but are not limited or exhaustive – Serious reservations with the tendency of parties seeking maintenance or alimony as an equalisation of wealth with the other party – Law of maintenance aimed at empowering the destitute and achieving social justice and dignity of the individual – Wife entitled to be maintained as far as possible in a manner similar to what she was accustomed to in her matrimonial home while the parties were together – However, once the parties separated, it cannot be expected of the husband to maintain her as per his present status all his life – Wife cannot simply claim an amount equal to what the ex-wife of the husband had received or on the basis of the income of the husband. [Paras 14.3, 14.5, 14.7] Constitution of India – Art. 142(1) – Exercise of jurisdiction under – Cases of marital disputes – Grant of divorce on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown of marriage – Power of: Held: Art.142 empowers the Supreme Court to exercise its jurisdiction to pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it – Expression “such order as is necessary for doing complete justice” has a wide amplitude and scope and empowers the Supreme Court to make any order as may be necessary for doing complete justice in a case before it – Supreme Court would look into equitable consideration while passing such orders given the facts and circumstances of a case, so as to further the cause of justice – Power to grant a decree of divorce u/Art.142(1) is exercisable by the Courts when, in the opinion of this Court there is complete and irretrievable breakdown of marriage – Irretrievable breakdown is to be determined in each case, that the marriage has “completely failed” and there is no possibility of the parties cohabiting together as husband and wife, and that the continuation of the formal legal relationship of marriage is unjustified lacking in substance and content – Family Court is bound by fault-divorce provisions of HMA, has to appreciate evidence, however this Court while dealing with an application u/Art.142(1) can depart from such procedure by acting as a problem solver and balancing out the 1358 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports equities between the conflicting claims – Court is not required to look deep into the veracity of the detailed allegations made by the parties against each other to find as to who is at fault, but to take a holistic view on the relationship between the parties – Grant of divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage is on the basis of exercise of discretion for doing complete justice between the parties because there is no possibility of the parties cohabiting together and continuing their marital relationship – Divorce u/Art.142(1) cannot be sought as a matter of right. [Paras 6.1, 7, 8.11-8.15] Judicial deprecation – Marital dispute – Abuse of process of law – Criminal proceedings between spouses and their impact on marital ties:
Held: Provisions in the criminal law are for the protection and empowerment of women but sometimes are used by certain women more for purposes that they are never meant for – In recent times, the invocation of ss.498A, 376, 377, 506 IPC as a combined package in most of the complaints related to matrimonial disputes is a practice condemned by this Court on several occasions – Wife and her family tend to use a criminal complaint with all the serious offences as a platform for negotiation and as a mechanism and a tool to get the husband and his family to comply with their demands, which are mostly monetary in nature – It is done in a fit of rage after a marital dispute, while at times it is a planned strategy in other cases – Unfortunately, it is not just the parties who are involved in this abuse of the process of law – Furthermore, Police personnel sometimes jump into action in selective cases and arrest the husband or even their relatives including aged and bedridden parents and grand-parents of the husband – Trial courts are hesitant in granting bail to the accused persons being swayed by the “gravity of the offences” mentioned in the FIR – Collective effect of this chain of events is often overlooked by the actual individual players involved, minor disputes between husband and wife tend to snowball into ugly prodigious battles of ego and reputation, eventually leading to the relationship turning sour to the extent that there remains no possibility of a reconciliation or cohabitation – Women to be careful about the fact that these strict provisions of law in their hands are beneficial legislations for their welfare and not means to chastise, threaten, domineer or extort from their husbands. [Para 10] [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1359Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda Case Law Cited Naveen Kohli v. Neelu Kohli [2006] 3 SCR 53 : (2006) 4 SCC 558; Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan [2023] 5 SCR 165 : (2016) 16 SCC 352 – followed.
Rajnesh v. Neha [2020] 13 SCR 1093 : (2021) 2 SCC 324; Delma Lubna Coelho v. Edmond Clint Fernandes [2023] 4 SCR 473 : (2023) 18 SCC 447; Nirmal Singh Panesar v. Paramjit Kaur Panesar @ Ajinder Kaur Panesar [2023] 13 SCR 832 : (2025) 3 SCC 790; Rakesh Raman v. Kavita [2023] 3 SCR 552 : (2023) 17 SCC 433; Vikas Kanaujia v. Sarita [2024] 7 SCR 933 : (2025) 3 SCC 748; Prakashchandra Joshi v. Kuntal Prakashchandra Joshi @ Kuntal Visanji Shah [2024] 1 SCR 697 : (2025) 3 SCC 784; R. Srinivas Kumar v. R. Shametha [2019] 12 SCR 873 : (2019) 9 SCC 409; Munish Kakkar v. Nidhi Kakkar [2019] 15 SCR 169 : (2020) 14 SCC 657; N. Rajendran v. S. Valli [2022] 16 SCR 498 : (2025) 3 SCC 801; K. Srinivas Rao v. D.A. Deepa [2013] 2 SCR 126 : (2013) 5 SCC 226; Anil Kumar Jain v. Maya Jain [2009] 14 SCR 90 : (2009) 10 SCC 415; Achin Gupta v. State of Haryana & Anr. [2024] 6 SCR 129 : (2025) 3 SCC 756; Preeti Gupta v. State of Jharkhand [2010] 9 SCR 1168 : (2010) 7 SCC 667; Dolly Rani v. Manish Kumar Chanchal [2024] 5 SCR 510 : (2025) 2 SCC 587; Shakti v. Anita, Civil Appeal No. 7427/2023, MANU/ SCOR/139017/2023; Kiran Jyot Maini v. Anish Pramod Patel [2024] 7 SCR 942 : 2024 SCC Online SC 1724; Vinny Paramvir Parmar v. Paramvir Parmar [2011] 9 SCR 371 : (2011) 13 SCC 112; Vishwanath Agrawal v. Sarla Vishwanath Agrawal [2012] 7 SCR 607 : (2012) 7 SCC 288 – referred to.
List of Acts Hindu Marriage Act, 1955; Information Technology Act, 2000; Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007; Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Penal Code, 1860; Constitution of India. List of Keywords Transfer petition; Transfer of divorce petition; Decree of divorce; Irretrievable breakdown of marriage; Dissolution of marriage; Maintenance/Permanent alimony; Second marriage; Husband, citizen of USA; Marital discord; Multiple litigations; Criminal complaints; ‘Look Out Circular’; Police custody; Three divorce petitions; Family 1360 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Court; Permanent alimony equalling share received by husband’s exwife; Hindu marriage, a sacrament; Sacred institution; Irreconcilable status; Rupees twelve crores as permanent alimony to wife; Rupees three lakhs as litigation expenses to wife; Abuse of process of law; Protection and empowerment of women; Possibility of reconciliation or cohabitation; Beneficial legislations; Balancing the equities. Case Arising From CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 278 of 2023 Petition Filed under Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Appearances for Parties N.K. Modi, Sr. Adv., Ms. Ishita M. Puranik, Jigisha Agarwal, Praveen Swarup, Ms. Anindita Mitra, Advs. for the Petitioner. Mrs. Meenakshi Arora, Sr. Adv., Satish L. Maneshinde, Priyank Upadhyay, Mrs. Shivali Sharma, Anupam Shukla, Abhinav Sharma, Ms. Anandini Fernandes, Anadi Kumar Taylor, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Nagarathna, J.
This transfer petition has been filed by the petitioner-wife under Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short “CPC”), seeking the following reliefs:
“a) Grant transfer of Divorce Petition case filed under section 13 (1) of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 bearing RCS(HM) No. 1379 of 2022 titled as Sandesh Sharda Versus Rinku Baheti pending in the Hon’ble Court of Ld. Principal Judge, Family Courts District Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh to the Court of Ld. Principal Judge, Family Courts, District Pune, Maharashtra; and b) Pass such other order(s) or directions as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case, to meet the ends of the justice.”
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1361Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda
2. The question for consideration before us is not just whether the petitioner is entitled to the aforesaid relief, but also whether this Court, upon the application filed by the respondent-husband, can exercise its powers under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India to grant a decree of divorce to the parties herein on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. If yes, then on what terms. In the above backdrop, we have heard the application in the first instance. Factual background:
3. Briefly stated, the facts of the case as narrated in the application filed by the respondent/applicant are that the petitioner-wife and the respondent-husband got married on 31.07.2021 as per Hindu rites and rituals at Pune. It was a second marriage for both the parties. The respondent had obtained a decree of divorce from his first wife on 09.11.2020. The said marriage had subsisted for almost two decades and he has two children from his first marriage. The respondent is a citizen of the United States of America (USA) and is engaged in the business of Information Technology consultancy services in USA. The petitioner is a post-graduate who has a degree in Finance and further has studied Naturopathy and Yogic Sciences. The parties met through a matrimonial portal in May 2020 and decided to tie the knot after a few months.
3.1 The petitioner and the respondent started having marital discord, largely over the issue of respondent’s continued involvement with his children, ex-wife and ailing father. The respondent husband is stated to have mooted the idea of separation by mutual consent, which was not acceptable to the petitioner. The respondent even submitted a complaint at Police Station Habibganj and filed a complaint dated 22.07.2022 before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bhopal under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter “CrPC), alleging that as a result of constant fights between the parties, the petitioner has been subjecting the respondent to mental cruelty by threatening him with dire consequences like taking her own life and filing false criminal cases against the respondent and his family. Thus, the respondent had sought appropriate action against the petitioner and an impartial investigation in future if the petitioner took any untoward step.
1362 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 3.2 Thereafter, on 01.08.2022, the respondent filed a divorce petition bearing RCS(HM) No.1146/2022 before the Family Court, Bhopal, under Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (hereinafter “HMA”). But the same was dismissed as withdrawn by order dated 16.08.2022. Just before withdrawing the said divorce petition, the parties filed a second petition for divorce by mutual consent under Section 13B(1) of HMA, bearing RCS(HM) No. 1215/2022, on 13.08.2022 before the Family Court at Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh. The petitioner has alleged that the respondent had fraudulently obtained her signatures on this second divorce petition. Be that as it may, the said petition was also dismissed vide order dated 29.08.2022, on the ground that the parties had not completed the statutorily mandated period of separation of one year as per Section 13B(1) of the HMA.
3.3 Subsequently, on 14.09.2022, the respondent filed a third divorce petition bearing RCS(HM) No. 1379 of 2022 under Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA before the Principal Judge, Family Court, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, seeking divorce from the petitioner on the ground of cruelty. The said petition has been contested by the petitioner and is also the subject matter of the present transfer petition before this Court.
3.4 Subsequently, the petitioner also filed two criminal cases–
(i) FIR No.586 of 2022 dated 12.12.2022 before the Police Station Yerwada, District Pune, for offences punishable under Sections 360, 427, 452, 454 and 457 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, “IPC”) which was filed against an employee of respondent’s company;
(ii) FIR No. 588 of 2022 dated 15.12.2022 before the Police Station Yerwada, District Pune, for offences punishable under Sections 354, 376, 377, 420, 498A, 503, 506, 509 of the IPC and Sections 66 and 67 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (“IT Act, 2000”, for short) which was filed against the respondent and the respondent’s father. Interestingly, the second FIR dated 15.12.2022 was filed by the petitioner on the same day when she was scheduled to appear before the Family Court in the divorce case filed by the respondent-husband. Pursuant to the second FIR, a Look Out [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1363Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda Circular (LOC) dated 19.12.2022 was issued from the Bureau of Investigation against the respondent and consequently, the respondent was arrested on 25.12.2022 from the international airport at Mumbai while he was leaving for USA. He was finally released on regular bail by the Additional Sessions Judge, Pune by order dated 21.01.2023, resulting in the respondent spending almost a month in custody.
3.5 Just a few days later, the chain of litigation between the parties reached the doors of this Court, when the petitioner filed the present transfer petition before this Court, seeking the transfer of divorce petition bearing No.RCS(HM) No.1379 of 2022, titled “Sandesh Sharda versus Rinku Baheti”, pending before the Court of Principal Judge, Family Court, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, to the Court of the Principal Judge, Family Court, District Pune, Maharashtra. This court, vide order dated 09.02.2023, issued notice in the matter and granted interim stay on the aforesaid divorce proceedings pending before the Family Court. 3.6 During the pendency of the present transfer petition, the respondent has filed the interlocutory application bearing IA No. 149439/2023 before this Court under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, seeking dissolution of marriage between the parties on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage amidst the multiple litigations pending between the parties. The relief sought by the respondent is as follows:
“a. Allow the present application thereby exercising the powers conferred by Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India thereby dissolving the marriage of the parties and granting a decree of divorce; and/or b. Pass any such other and further order(s) that this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
3.7 It is averred in the said application by the respondent that he had every intention to spend a good future with the petitioner but he has not been able to meet the illicit demands of the petitioner, both monetary and non-monetary. It is alleged that soon after the marriage, the petitioner had started demanding unrealistic sums of money from the respondent without providing any reasons for the same. The petitioner would misbehave with 1364 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the respondent, his family, his staff, and not cooperate with the fact that the respondent had to take care of his octogenarian father and his children from his first marriage. It was also stated by the respondent that he had proposed the idea of an amicable separation to the petitioner but she created an even more hostile environment and threatened to implicate the respondent and his family in false criminal cases. Thus, the parties allegedly started living separately from February-March of 2022. It is stated that the petitioner asked for a sum of Rs.8 crores in lieu of filing for divorce by mutual consent, but upon the dismissal of the petition by the Trial Court, the petitioner’s demand increased to Rs.25 crores, along with threats of criminal complaints. This was all followed by the FIRs filed by the petitioner and the arrest of the respondent, thereby fracturing the relations between the parties beyond repair. Therefore, the respondent has prayed for a decree of divorce before this Court to be passed in this transfer petition by exercising jurisdiction under Article 142(1) of the Constitution.
3.8 The petitioner herein filed her reply to the application filed by the respondent under Article 142(1) of the Constitution and opposed the relief prayed by the respondent. The petitioner stated that there is no irretrievable breakdown of marriage between the parties and the respondent is seeking to abuse the extraordinary power of this Court under Article 142(1) of the Constitution to escape the process of law under the HMA. The petitioner further stated that she had been constantly discriminated against by her husband and in-laws since the time she got married to the respondent, and it was under the pressure of the respondent’s ex-wife and children that he was attempting to seek divorce. The respondent had constantly tried to stall the process of taking the petitioner to USA with him, thus trying to systematically remove her from his life. 3.9 The father-in-law of the petitioner had also filed a complaint being Case No.838/B-121/2022-23 under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 before the SDM, Kolar, Bhopal, for eviction of the petitioner from the matrimonial home at Pune where she was residing. Thus, the petitioner sought the dismissal of the application filed by the respondent on the aforesaid grounds.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1365Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda 3.10 By order dated 12.09.2023, this Court observed that it was just and necessary that the application under Article 142(1) filed by the respondent has to be considered in a larger canvas and not just on the question of whether there is an irretrievable breakdown of marriage in the instant case. Thus, it was directed that the case being RCS (HM) No.1379/2022 titled as “Sandesh Sharda vs. Rinku Baheti” pending on the file of the Court of Principal Judge, Family Courts, District Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh be transferred to the Principal Judge, Family Court, District Pune, Maharashtra, only for the limited purpose of determining the quantum of alimony or maintenance as well as other rights which the petitioner-wife would be entitled to, in the event the application filed by the respondent-husband for divorce in the main transfer petition is to be allowed. The Transferee Court at Pune was directed to consider the case of the respective parties and record the evidence, if any, and submit a report in the form of an order to this Court for the purpose of considering the application filed by the respondent under Article 142(1) of the Constitution.
3.11 In compliance with the aforesaid order of this Court, both the parties appeared before the Transferee Court, i.e., Family Court, Pune. The petitioner-wife filed an application before that court for fixation of alimony commensurate to the assets of the respondent-husband and further sought monthly maintenance and residence rights in the matrimonial house at Pune. The petitioner averred before the Family Court, Pune that the respondent divorced his first wife and gave her 50% of his net worth, which was around Rs.500 crores, in addition to a house in USA, and therefore, the petitioner may be paid permanent alimony in the same manner as was given to the first wife and as per the status of the respondent.
3.12 The respondent denied the claims made by the petitioner in her application for fixation of alimony and stated that the present marriage between the parties was for a short duration of only three months, during which no marital assets were created, unlike his previous marriage where his ex-wife had contributed to building the assets of the respondent and thus she was entitled to a stake in those assets. He stated that on the contrary, the criminal cases filed by the petitioner herein 1366 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports have led to a further loss of his business. Thus, the respondent prayed for the permanent alimony to be fixed in the range of Rs.20 lakhs to 40 lakhs.
3.13 The Family Court, Pune, after a detailed analysis of the material on record, submitted its report dated 22.03.2024 to this Court. The learned Judge of the Family Court at Pune concluded that after taking into consideration the status and standard of living of the respondent-husband; the income and expenditure of the petitioner-wife; as well as the fact that the petitioner-wife has her own house where she can live, permanent alimony of Rs.2 lakhs per month was just and reasonable and if a lumpsum amount is to be granted, an amount of Rs.10 crores would be just and proper.
Mediation Proceedings:
4. Pending consideration of the application filed under Article 142(1) of the Constitution, this Court made further attempts to encourage the parties to reach an amicable settlement inter se. By order dated 22.04.2024, the matter was referred to the Supreme Court Mediation Centre. But after a few mediation sessions, the respondent submitted through Video Conferencing Facility (VC) before us that he was not interested in pursuing a mediated settlement before the Supreme Court Mediation Centre and the same was recorded in the order dated 13.05.2024. However, the parties agreed to attempt a mediated settlement of the dispute between them before a retired Judge of this Court. Consequently, Mr. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Retired Judge, Supreme Court of India, was appointed as a mediator in the matter by the aforesaid order. The Hon’ble mediator held multiple meetings with the parties, in their presence and through VC, and submitted a Confidential Report dated 19.07.2024, by which he reported that the parties have not been able to reach a mutually agreeable settlement. The same has been perused by this Court. Upon further interaction with the petitioner and the respondent by this Court on 10.09.2024, it was categorically stated by the respondent while appearing through VC before us that he does not intend to engage in any further discussion with the petitioner.
4.1 In light of the above facts and circumstances, this Court heard learned senior counsel for the respective parties on IA No. 149439/2023 filed by the respondent-husband under Article [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1367Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda 142(1) of the Constitution of India, seeking a decree of divorce from the petitioner-wife on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. Depending upon the fate of the said application, this Court shall consider the original prayer made in the transfer petition by the petitioner-wife before this Court, i.e., whether the present transfer petition ought to be allowed or not. Submissions:
5. On the averments made by the parties against each other in the captioned transfer petition, the application under Article 142(1), the application for fixation of alimony and the corresponding replies filed to those pleadings, learned counsel for the petitioner and respondent made detailed submissions at the bar.
5.1 The crux of the submissions made by the learned senior counsel Ms. Meenakshi Arora on behalf of the respondent-husband was that in light of the numerous litigations pending between the parties, including the criminal complaints filed by the petitioner that went to the extent of Look Out Circular (LOC) being issued against the respondent herein and he also being arrested and being in custody for almost a month, the relationship between the parties has fractured beyond repair. The petitioner has gone to the extent of alleging falsely not just against the respondent, but his ailing father and his son who resides in USA as well as the employees of the respondent’s company in the present dispute. It was submitted that the petitioner’s unwarranted criminal complaints and actions have made a serious dent on the reputation of the respondent which has adversely affected both his personal life as well as his business.
5.2 It was further submitted that even though the parties resided together only for a brief period of three months and the petitioner is financially equipped and educated enough to maintain herself, the respondent is not shying away from his responsibility to reasonably provide for the future of the petitioner in case of a separation but the petitioner has been making unreasonable monetary demands that cannot be accepted by the respondent. The petitioner is also said to have usurped the flat belonging to the respondent and his father, despite herself having sufficient educational qualifications, various fixed deposits, a property worth Rs.90 lakhs and rental income from that property. 1368 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 5.3 Thus, the learned counsel for the respondent contended that the cumulative impact of the ill-intended acts of the petitioner has been that the relationship between the parties has irretrievably broken down that cannot be cemented together again and therefore respondent intends to put an end to the mental, physical, emotional and financial harassment caused to him by the petitioner and consequently requests this Court to exercise its power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution and grant a decree of divorce and a reasonable permanent alimony to the petitioner.
5.4 Per contra, learned senior counsel for the petitioner Sri N.K. Modi contended that the application of the respondent under Article 142(1) of the Constitution is wholly misconceived. That the exercise of power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution is extraordinary and wide and ought not be used in cases where the underlying facts are in dispute and have to be factually determined after a fair trial. It was submitted that the parties have happily lived together after marriage. Contrary to what is being averred by the respondent, it was submitted that the parties have remained in touch and lived together after marriage for a period of almost thirteen months, i.e., from 31.07.2021 to 31.08.2022, when the petitioner left for Kota. Thus, the petitioner contends that the respondent was in touch with the petitioner throughout and was maintaining cordial relations and is seeking a divorce only on paper so as to satisfy his son and his father. It was further submitted that the petitioner is opposed to a decree of divorce, as that would leave her with societal stigma of being divorced twice. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that there is still a fair chance of reconciliation between the parties as she wants to remain married. Therefore, he prayed for the dismissal of the application filed by the respondent herein. 5.5 It was also submitted that in case this Court decides to grant a decree of divorce by exercising jurisdiction under Article 142(1), then the petitioner may be permitted to continue her residence in the matrimonial home at Pune, which is in the name of the father of the respondent and be further granted a permanent alimony equitable to the amount given to the first wife of the respondent. The petitioner’s prayer is based on the contention that the respondent is a powerful man of means and position, [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1369Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda who is not having any other financial burdens since he has divorced his first wife, his two children are settled in USA and his 85-year old father is a wealthy person with multiple sources of income, on the other hand, the petitioner is a lady with limited resources available for her survival, who is running from pillar to post for justice and has been abandoned by her own parents because of the ongoing marital dispute. Therefore, the interest and welfare of the petitioner may be borne in mind by this Court was the submission of learned senior counsel for the petitioner. Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India:
6. Before considering the facts and issues involved in the case, it is pertinent to refer to Article 142 of the Constitution of India, which reads as follows:
“142. Enforcement of decrees and orders of the Supreme Court and orders as to discovery, etc.—(1) The Supreme Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it, and any decree so passed or order so made shall be enforceable throughout the territory of India in such manner as may be prescribed by or under any law made by Parliament and, until provision in that behalf is so made, in such manner as the President may by order prescribe.
(2) Subject to the provisions of any law made in this behalf by Parliament, the Supreme Court shall, as respects the whole of the territory of India, have all and every power to make any order for the purpose of securing the attendance of any person, the discovery or production of any documents, or the investigation or punishment of any contempt of itself.”
(underlining by us)
6.1 The aforesaid Article empowers the Supreme Court to exercise its jurisdiction to pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it and any decree so passed or order so made shall be enforceable throughout the territory of India in such 1370 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports manner as may be prescribed by or under any law made by Parliament and until provision in that behalf is so made, in such manner as the President may by order prescribe. The expression “such order as is necessary for doing complete justice” has a wide amplitude and scope and empowers the Supreme Court to make any order as may be necessary for doing complete justice in a case before it. Thus, the object of exercising such power is ultimately to do complete justice between the parties. Usually, when the Supreme Court moulds the relief while ensuring that no injustice is caused, power is exercised under Article 142(1) for doing complete justice in the matter. Sometimes, while laying down the law in a matter, a direction could be issued by granting relief in a particular way in that particular case so as to safeguard the interest of the parties. The Supreme Court would also look into equitable consideration while passing such orders given the facts and circumstances of a case, so as to further the cause of justice. 6.2 In Shilpa Sailesh vs. Varun Sreenivasan, (2023) 5 SCR 165 (“Shilpa Sailesh”), a Constitution Bench of this Court speaking through Sanjiv Khanna, J. (as the present Chief Justice of India then was) observed in paragraph 19 as under:
“19. Exercise of jurisdiction under Article 142(1)
of the Constitution of India by this Court in such cases is clearly permissible to do ‘complete justice’ to a ‘cause or matter’. We should accept that this Court can pass an order or decree which a family court, trial court or High Court can pass. As per Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, a decree passed or an order made by this Court is executable throughout the territory of India. Power of this Court under Articles 136 and 142(1) of the Constitution of India will certainly embrace and enswathe this power to do ‘complete justice’, even when the main case/ proceeding is pending before the family court, the trial court or another judicial forum. A question or issue of lack of subject-matter jurisdiction does not arise. Settlements in matrimonial matters invariably end multiple legal proceedings, including criminal proceedings in different courts and at diverse [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1371Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda locations. Necessarily, in such cases, the parties have to move separate applications in multiple courts, including the jurisdictional High Court, for appropriate relief and closure, and disposal and/or dismissal of cases. This puts burden on the courts in the form of listing, paper work, compliance with formalities, verification etc. Parallelly, parties have to bear the cost, appear before several forums/courts and the final orders get delayed causing anxiety and apprehension. In this sense, when this Court exercises the power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, it assists and aids the cause of justice.”
Shilpa Sailesh:
7. The issue regarding invocation of the extraordinary powers of this Court under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India in cases of marital disputes is no more res-integra and has been settled by a Constitution Bench of this Court in the case of Shilpa Sailesh. The power to grant a decree of divorce under Article 142(1) of the Constitution is exercisable by the Courts when, in the opinion of this Court there is complete and irretrievable breakdown of marriage, in spite of the other spouse opposing such prayer. Three substantial questions of law were formulated for consideration in Shilpa Sailesh. The third question was:
“Whether this Court can grant divorce in exercise of power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India when there is complete and irretrievable breakdown of marriage in spite of the other spouses opposing the prayer?”
Learned senior counsel for both the parties have placed reliance on the said judgment of this Court, although citing different parts and paragraphs.
7.1 Learned senior counsel for the respondent has drawn our attention to the following paragraph of the judgment in Shilpa Sailesh:
“33. Having said so, we wish to clearly state that grant of divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage by this Court is not a matter 1372 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of right, but a discretion which is to be exercised with great care and caution, keeping in mind several factors ensuring that ‘complete justice’ is done to both parties. It is obvious that this Court should be fully convinced and satisfied that the marriage is totally unworkable, emotionally dead and beyond salvation and, therefore, dissolution of marriage is the right solution and the only way forward. That the marriage has irretrievably broken down is to be factually determined and firmly established. For this, several factors are to be considered such as the period of time the parties had cohabited after marriage; when the parties had last cohabited; the nature of allegations made by the parties against each other and their family members; the orders passed in the legal proceedings from time to time, cumulative impact on the personal relationship; whether, and how many attempts were made to settle the disputes by intervention of the court or through mediation, and when the last attempt was made, etc. The period of separation should be sufficiently long, and anything above six years or more will be a relevant factor. But these facts have to be evaluated keeping in view the economic and social status of the parties, including their educational qualifications, whether the parties have any children, their age, educational qualification, and whether the other spouse and children are dependent, in which event how and in what manner the party seeking divorce intends to take care and provide for the spouse or the children. Question of custody and welfare of minor children, provision for fair and adequate alimony for the wife, and economic rights of the children and other pending matters, if any, are relevant considerations. We would not like to codify the factors so as to curtail exercise of jurisdiction under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, which is situation specific. Some of the factors mentioned can be taken as illustrative, and worthy of consideration.”
(underlining by us)
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1373Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda 7.2 On the contrary, learned senior counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the following paragraph of the judgment, wherein the Court answered the question, whether, this Court can grant divorce in exercise of power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India when there is complete and irretrievable breakdown of marriage in spite of the other spouse opposing the prayer:
“42. …This question is also answered in the affirmative, inter alia, holding that this Court, in exercise of power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, has the discretion to dissolve the marriage on the ground of its irretrievable breakdown. This discretionary power is to be exercised to do ‘complete justice’ to the parties, wherein this Court is satisfied that the facts established show that the marriage has completely failed and there is no possibility that the parties will cohabit together, and continuation of the formal legal relationship is unjustified. The Court, as a court of equity, is required to also balance the circumstances and the background in which the party opposing the dissolution is placed.”
(underlining by us)
7.3 The petitioner has further relied on the following part from the Shilpa Sailesh judgment to bring our attention to the caution that needs to be exercised in granting a decree of divorce without undergoing trial:
“41. Lastly, we must express our opinion on whether a party can directly canvass before this Court the ground of irretrievable breakdown by filing a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. In Poonam v. Sumit Tanwar, a two judges’ bench of this Court has rightly held that any such attempt must be spurned and not accepted, as the parties should not be permitted to file a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India, or for that matter under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before the High Court, and seek divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of 1374 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports marriage. The reason is that the remedy of a person aggrieved by the decision of the competent judicial forum is to approach the superior tribunal/ forum for redressal of his/her grievance. The parties should not be permitted to circumvent the procedure by resorting to the writ jurisdiction under Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution of India, as the case may be…”
7.4 Our attention was further drawn to the following part of the aforesaid judgment to highlight the relevance of the facts of the case while exercising the power under Article 142(1): “20. However, there is a difference between existence of a power, and exercise of that power in a given case. Existence of power is generally a matter of law, whereas exercise of power is a mixed question of law and facts. Even when the power to pass a decree of divorce by mutual consent exists and can be exercised by this Court under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, when and in which of the cases the power should be exercised to do ‘complete justice’ in a ‘cause or matter’ is an issue that has to be determined independent of existence of the power. This discretion has to be exercised on the basis of the factual matrix in the particular case, evaluated on objective criteria and factors, without ignoring the objective of the statutory provisions.”
Other orders/judgments on irretrievable breakdown of marriage:
8. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has further placed reliance on a few recent judgments of this Court, wherein the exercise of the power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution for granting a decree of divorce on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown of marriage was denied by this Court. Reliance is placed on a recent judgment of this Court in Delma Lubna Coelho vs. Edmond Clint Fernandes, (2023) 4 SCR 473, wherein the decree of divorce was denied by observing that the parties had stayed together for only forty days and it takes time to settle down in a marriage. Further reliance is placed on Nirmal Singh Panesar vs. Paramjit Kaur Panesar @ Ajinder Kaur Panesar, (2023) 13 SCR 832, wherein the exercise [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1375Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda of power under Article 142(1) was refused by this Court to dissolve the marriage of an octogenarian couple, on the ground that the 82year old wife is still ready and willing to take care of her husband and does not wish to leave him alone at this stage of his life and does not want to die with the stigma of being a divorcee. There have been other similar judgments cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner, but the same are not being mentioned here because those rulings were prior to the final settlement of the law on irretrievable breakdown of marriage by the Constitution Bench of this Court in Shilpa Sailesh.
8.1 The exercise of power by this Court under Article 142(1) to grant a decree of divorce and the factors to be considered while doing so have varied with facts and circumstances of each case. In the case of Rakesh Raman vs. Kavita, (2023) 3 SCR 552, it was observed as follows:
“15. The multiple Court battles between them and the repeated failures in mediation and conciliation is at least testimony of this fact that no bond now survive between the couple, it is indeed a marriage which has broken down irretrievably.
x x x x
16. … Irretrievable breakdown of a marriage may not be a ground for dissolution of marriage, under the Hindu Marriage Act, but cruelty is. A marriage can be dissolved by a decree of divorce, inter alia, on the ground when the other party “has, after the solemnization of the marriage treated the petitioner with cruelty”. In our considered opinion, a marital relationship which has only become more bitter and acrimonious over the years, does nothing but inflicts cruelty on both the sides. To keep the façade of this broken marriage alive would be doing injustice to both the parties. A marriage which has broken down irretrievably, in our opinion spells cruelty to both the parties, as in such a relationship each party is treating the other with cruelty. It is therefore a ground for dissolution of marriage under Section 13 (1) (ia) of the Act.”
1376 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports In light of the above observations, this Court had granted a decree of divorce and dissolved the marriage between the parties in that case.
8.2 The aforementioned position has since then been followed by this Court in several cases while exercising power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution. For instance, in a recent judgment delivered by a co-ordinate bench of this Court in Vikas Kanaujia vs. Sarita, (2024) 7 SCR 933, this Court granted the decree of divorce on account of irretrievable breakdown of marriage in light of the overall facts and circumstances of the case, even though the wife therein had submitted that she was willing to live with the husband believing in the sanctity of marriage.
8.3 Similarly, in the case of Prakashchandra Joshi vs. Kuntal Prakashchandra Joshi @ Kuntal Visanji Shah, (2024) 1 SCR 697, a co-ordinate bench of this Court observed that it was a case of irretrievable breakdown of marriage as there was no possibility of the couple staying together and used the powers under Article 142(1) to dissolve the marriage between the parties, despite the fact that the wife in that case chose not to appear in the proceedings before this court and was proceeded ex-parte.
8.4 Another co-ordinate bench of this Court in the case of Vineet Taneja vs. Ritu Johari, vide order dated 22.07.2024 passed in M.A. No.2009 of 2023 in SLP (C) No.3667 of 2023, MANU/ SCOR/93862/2024, granted a decree of dissolution of marriage taking into consideration the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage between the parties, on the miscellaneous application filed by the wife seeking dissolution of the marriage in exercise of powers under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India and the husband had vehemently opposed the application.
8.5 The aforesaid decisions have followed the proposition of law confirmed by the constitution bench in the case of Shilpa Sailesh. However, even before the said judgment, this Court had not hesitated from dissolving the marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown where the relationship between the parties had deteriorated to a level that no reconciliation appeared [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1377Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda possible and where such a dissolution was necessary to do complete justice between the parties in exercise of power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, even though one of the spouses had opposed such a prayer or had shown interest in continuing with the marital bond.
8.6 Earlier, a two-judge bench of this Court, in the case of R. Srinivas Kumar vs. R. Shametha, (2019) 12 SCR 873, dealt with the submission of the wife that unless there is a consent by both the parties, even in exercise of powers under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India, the marriage cannot be dissolved on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, by making the following observations:
“6. Now so far as submission on behalf of the respondent wife that unless there is a consent by both the parties, even in exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India the marriage cannot be dissolved on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage is concerned, the aforesaid has no substance. If both the parties to the marriage agree for separation permanently and/or consent for divorce, in that case, certainly both the parties can move the competent court for a decree of divorce by mutual consent. Only in a case where one of the parties do not agree and give consent, only then the powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India are required to be invoked to do the substantial justice between the parties, considering the facts and circumstances of the case. However, at the same time, the interest of the wife is also required to be protected financially so that she may not have to suffer financially in future and she may not have to depend upon others.”
(underlining by us)
8.7 Another observation of this court on the same issue, in Munish Kakkar vs. Nidhi Kakkar, (2019) 15 SCR 169, reads as under:
1378 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “18. No doubt there is no consent of the respondent. But there is also, in real terms, no willingness of the parties, including of the respondent to live together. There are only bitter memories and angst against each other. This angst has got extended in the case of the respondent to somehow not permit the appellant to get a decree of divorce and “live his life”, forgetting that both parties would be able to live their lives in a better manner, separately, as both parties suffer from an obsession with legal proceedings, as reflected from the submissions before us.”
8.8 The aforesaid judgments and observations were also followed by this court in the case of N. Rajendran vs. S. Valli, (2022) 16 SCR 498, and it was held that it would be in the interest of justice and to do complete justice to the parties that an order should be passed dissolving the marriage between the parties. 8.9 In the case of K. Srinivas Rao vs. D.A. Deepa, (2013) 2 SCR 126, the wife had made scurrilous, vulgar and defamatory statements against the husband in her complaint to the women’s cell of the police. This Court speaking through Ranjana Desai, J. held that such statements cannot be explained away by stating that it was made because the wife was anxious to go back to the husband as the same is not the way to win the husband back. It was held that the wife had caused mental cruelty to the husband and the marriage had irretrievably broken down. In light of the fact that the husband was not willing to reside with the wife, even if the court refuses a decree of divorce to the husband, there are hardly any chances of the wife leading a happy life with the husband because a lot of bitterness had been created by the conduct of the wife. Thus, this Court accordingly granted a decree of divorce.
8.10 In the case of Anil Kumar Jain vs. Maya Jain, (2009) 14 SCR 90, this court held that the stand of the wife that she wants to live separately from her husband but is not agreeable to a mutual divorce was not acceptable and found it a fit case for exercise of the powers vested in the court under Article 142(1) [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1379Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda of the Constitution. Thus, the court accepted the petition for grant of mutual divorce under Section 13B of the HMA. 8.11 Therefore, there now remains no doubt that this Court has the power to grant a decree of divorce on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown of marriage by invoking its powers under Article 142(1) of the Constitution. But what constitutes an irretrievable breakdown has to be determined in each case by undertaking a factual analysis of the case and using judicial discretion in light of several non-exhaustive factors laid down by this Court in the judgment of Shilpa Sailesh. This Court has to reach the conclusion that the marriage has “completely failed” and there is no possibility of the parties cohabiting together as husband and wife, and that the continuation of the formal legal relationship of marriage is unjustified lacking in substance and content.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.