Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v. State of Gujarat
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 987; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1072
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Aravind Kumar, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 17 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5412/2024
- Sections
- 29, 302, 8, 106, 27, 53, 9, 5, 6, 3, 364, 377
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1072 : 2024 INSC 987 Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v.
State of Gujarat (Criminal Appeal No(s). 5412-5413 of 2024)
17 December 2024 [B.R. Gavai, Aravind Kumar and K.V. Viswanathan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the correctness of the order of conviction and death sentence to the appellant for offences punishable u/ss.302, 364 and 377 IPC and ss. 4 and 6 of the POCSO, for committing murder and brutal sexual assault of the 4 year old boy.
Headnotes† Penal Code – ss.302, 364, 377 – Protection of Children from Sexual offences Act, 2012 – ss.4, 5, 6, 29 – Murder, kidnapping and sexual assault – Case of brutal sexual assault and murder of four year old boy – Trial court convicted and sentenced the appellant to death for offences punishable u/ss.302, 364 and 377 IPC and ss.4 and 6 of the POCSO – High Court confirmed the conviction and sentence of death – Correctness:
Held: Time lag between the accused being last seen with the deceased and the sighting of the dead body lying was extremely short and accused was to offer a plausible explanation as to how he parted company with the deceased and the explanation offered must be satisfactory, which he failed to do so, that itself provides an additional link in the chain of circumstances – Presence of the accused at the scene of crime in the background of the evidence of last seen, is clear link in the chain of circumstances which point to the guilt of the accused – Injury on the private parts of the accused for which no other explanation offered, conduct of the appellant in pointing out where the apparel of the deceased was hidden, matching of blood group considered, all considered as an additional link in the chain of circumstances – Thus, circumstantial evidence pointing to the guilt of the appellant exist – Injury on the * Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1073Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v. State of Gujarat prepuce of the penis of the accused along with the matching of the blood group coupled with other circumstantial evidence clearly constitute foundational facts for raising presumption u/s. 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act – Appellant did not rebut the presumption by adducing proof to the contrary – Thus, the circumstances fully established, the circumstances so established consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and are not explainable by any other hypothesis; the circumstances are conclusive in nature and the chain of circumstance is so complete as to point to the conclusion that the appellant is guilty of the offences charged – Conviction as imposed by the courts below upheld – Instant case is not a case where possibility of reformation is completely ruled out – Even though the case falls short of the rarest of rare category, in view of the nature of the crime, a sentence of life imprisonment which normally works out for 14 years would be grossly disproportionate and inadequate – Sentence of imprisonment for a prescribed period without remission would alone be proportionate to the crime and also not jeopardize the public confidence in the efficacy of the legal system – Sentence of imprisonment for a period of twentyfive years without remission would be ‘a just desert’ – Thus, the sentence of death for the offence u/s.302 set aside, substituting the same with that of rigorous imprisonment for a period of 25 years without remission – Sentence imposed for offences u/ss. 364 and 6 of the POCSO Act to run concurrently – Considering the socio-economic condition of the accused, the fine imposed set aside – Evidence Act, 1872 – Sentencing – Death sentence – Remission. [Paras 13-37, 39-42] Case Law Cited Swami Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93 : (2008) 13 SCC 767; Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; State of Rajasthan v. Kashiram [2006] Supp. 8 SCR 501 : (2006) 12 SCC 254; Pappu v. State of UP [2022] 2 SCR 13 : (2022) 10 SCC 321 – relied on.
A.N. Venkatesh and another v. State of Karnataka (2005) 7 SCC 22 714; Prakash Chand v. State (Delhi Admn.) [1979] 2 SCR 330 : (1979) 3 SCC 90; Prakash v. State of Karnataka [2014] 5 SCR 1074 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 242 : (2014) 12 SCC 133; Veerendra v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2022] 4 SCR 225 : (2022) 8 SCC 668; Nawas Alias Mulanavas v. State of Kerala [2024] 3 SCR 913 : (2024) SCC OnLine SC 315 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
List of Keywords Murder; Kidnapping; Sexual assault; Brutal sexual assault; Death sentence; Rejection of parole; Golden principles of circumstantial evidence; Facts consistent with hypothesis of guilt; Complete chain of evidence; Last seen; Time lag between accused last seen and sighting of dead body; Additional link in the chain of circumstances; Presence of accused; Chain of circumstances; Matching of blood group; Injury on prepuce of penis of accused; Presumption; Rebutting the presumption by adducing proof; Possibility of reformation; Rarest of rare category; Sentence of life imprisonment; Disproportionate and inadequate sentence; Remission; Just desert; Socio-economic condition.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
5412-5413 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 03.04.2019 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in CRLCC No. 2 and CRLA No. 1207 of 2018 With Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 9162 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Ms. Uttara Babbar, Sr. Adv., Ms. Manasa Ramakrishna, Bhavesh Seth, Manan Bansal, Ms. Rayana Mukherjee, Ms. Maitreyi Misra, Ms. Veera Mahuli, Nisarg P. Khatri, Arunava Mukherjee, Ramesh Kumar Sahu, Dr. Nirmal Chopra, Advs. for the Appellant. Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Ms. Neha Singh, Rishi Yadav, Advs. for the Respondent.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1075Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v. State of Gujarat Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. Wednesday, 13th April 2016 dawned normally for the family of Pravingiri Gosai (PW-9), a farmer, who also alternated as the temple priest at Piludara village under the Vedaj Police Station, Bharuch District in the State of Gujarat. However, by dusk the situation had turned macabre for them, when their four-year old child was found murdered in the village outskirts.
3. The appellant herein stood trial for the offences of kidnapping, sexual assault and murder of the said child and was convicted and sentenced to death by the Trial Court. The High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad, by the judgment dated 03.04.2019 in R/Criminal Confirmation Case No. 2 of 2018 with R/Criminal Appeal No. 1207 of 2018, confirmed the conviction and sentence of death imposed on him for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 364, and 377 of the Indian Penal Code (for short ‘IPC’) and Sections 4 and 6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual offences Act, 2012 (for short ‘POCSO Act’). The appellant is before us in appeal by way of special leave.
Brief Facts:
4. Pravingiri Gosai (PW-9) and his wife Artiben (PW-13.2) left their house at 06:00 a.m. in the morning of 13.04.2016 to get fodder for their cattle leaving their two small children Rohit @ Shital, aged about four years, the deceased and Rajeshwari, aged three months, along with PW-9’s mother at home. When they returned at 11.00 a.m., PW-9’s mother and children were at home. PW-9 left again to install a Dish TV in the village and returned at around 1 O’clock. He noticed that Rohit was not at home and when he inquired from his wife Arti, she replied that Rohit was playing near the temple and had not been seen since long. The desperate father continued his inquiries when PW-10 Jyotsnaben, his sister-in-law, who lived in the neighborhood told him that when Rohit was playing near the temple about 12:30 PM, the appellant who belonged to their village 1076 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports took the deceased and when she inquired from the appellant as to where he was taking the deceased, the appellant in spite of being dissuaded from doing so, told her that he will buy the child ice-cream and return in a while.
5. Since Rohit had not returned, PW-9 continued his search in the village when he met the appellant under a jamun tree behind the Pir Dargah at the bank of the lake at about 2 O’clock. When PW-9 inquired about his son with the appellant, the appellant told him that he gave the deceased ice-cream to eat and sent him home. PW-9 went home and when Rohit was not there, he came back to the lake, the appellant was not found. PW-13.2 Artiben, the mother of the deceased also carried out the search carried out and after receiving information from PW-11 Manoj Kumar Parmar that the deceased was taken by the appellant, she along with her sister-in-law PW-10, and daughter went to the appellant’s house. The appellant’s mother was there and the appellant was not there. They left a message with the appellant’s mother that the appellant may be told to send their son (deceased) back home.
6. PW-9 continued his inquiries and search when he received a call from Manoj Kumar Parmar (PW-11) who asked PW-9 to come to the bank of the lake behind the Pir Dargah. When PW-9 reached the spot, he found the dead body of his son lying naked near the bushes.
7. PW-9 lodged a complaint around 06:45 at the Vedaj Police Station which resulted in registration of an FIR and the subsequent proceedings. After the inquest, the body of the deceased was sent for postmortem to BKS Medical College Vadodara. The postmortem report reveals that death was due to asphyxia due to throttling. A number of injuries were found on the body of the deceased which are as follows:
“The following injuries were observed during the external examination of the dead body.
(1) Multiple scratch abrasions of size varying from 0.1 cm x 0.5 cm to 1.5 cm x 0.1 cm with underlying contusions of size varying from 1 cm x 1 cm to 2.5 cm x 2 cm present over perianal region. Perianal skin swollen, reddish in colour. Anal orifice dilated, roomy diameter of anal orifice is 2.5 cm. Part of rectum protruded out through anal orifice. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1077Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v. State of Gujarat
(2) A bite mark in form of pressure abrasion of size 4 cm x 3.5 cm present over right cheek, 3 cm above right angle of mandible and 4 cm right to midline.
(3) Multiple laceration of size varying from 0.5 cm x 0.2 cm to 1 cm x 0.2 cm x tissue deep with underlying contusions of size varying from 1 cm x 0.5 cm to 1.5 cm x 1 cm present over inner aspects of both lips.
(4) Multiple crescentic shaped abrasions of size varying from 0.5 cm x 0.1 cm to 1.2 cm x 0.1 cm in an area of 5 cm x 3 cm present over left side of neck, 3.5 cm left to midline and 2 cm below chin.
(5) Two abrasions of size 1.5 cm x 0.5 cm and 0.5 cm x 0.2 cm present over right side of the neck, 1.5 cm below chin and 2 cm, 3 cm right to midline respectively.
(6) Multiple scratch abrasions of size varying from 8.5 cm x 0.5 cm to 2.5 cm x 0.5 cm present in an area of 20 cm x 9 cm, over back of right thigh.
Note: All abrasions and contusions are reddish in colour. Margins of all lacerated wounds are irregular and contused with red clotted blood over it.
All of the above mentioned injuries were antemortem in origin.”
It will be clear from the above that the deceased was also subjected to penetrative sexual assault through the anus. PW-8 Dr. Kalpesh Kumar who led the postmortem team has categorically opined that the cause of death was asphyxia due to throttling. In view of this, there is no iota of doubt that the deceased had a homicidal death. The only question that arises is as to whether there is any evidence against the appellant to convict him for the offences charged.
8. The appellant was arrested (at about 20:45 hrs. to 21:26 hrs.) on 14.04.2016 and his medical examination revealed that there were injury marks on his genitals as spoken to by PW-7 Dr. Kamlesh Kumar.
9. The prosecution attempts to rely on the discovery panchnama (Exh.18) to reinforce their case that it was pursuant to the appellant’s statement that the place of occurrence was discovered. PW-4 1078 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Bharat Kumar and PW-5 Arjun Sinh were examined in support of the said purported discovery panchnama. This document, however, is seriously disputed by the defence. According to the defence, the panchnama (Exh.9) of the place of the occurrence was already drawn on 14.04.2016 between 16:00 hrs and 18:30 hrs and by the time the discovery panchnama (Exh.18) was drawn at around 09:00 a.m. on 15.04.2016, the place of occurrence was already known to the prosecution.
10. It is also the case of the prosecution that as part of the same transaction when the place of occurrence was discovered and after the said panchnama was drawn at around 09:00 a.m. on 15.04.2016, the accused voluntarily expressed willingness to show the place where he had thrown the clothes of the victim and in pursuance thereof the recovery panchnama (Exh.21) was drawn up between 09:15 hours and 09:45 hrs on 15.04.2016 and a light pink coloured Tshirt and a red coloured leggings were recovered The prosecution has examined PW-6 Maheshbhai in support of the recoveries. The defence has strongly objected to the admissibility of the recoveries on the ground that no statement of the accused was recorded on this aspect and that what is available is merely a purported recovery carried out. We have considered this aspect in the later part of the judgment coupled with the applicability of Section 8 of the Evidence Act to see if the conduct of the accused in leading to the place where the clothes of the deceased were found would be admissible in evidence.
11. We have heard Ms. Uttara Babbar, learned senior counsel for the appellant, appearing pro bono, who presented the case comprehensively and filed detailed written submissions. We have also heard Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, learned counsel for the State who in ably advancing the State’s case, left no stone unturned in countering the submissions of the learned senior counsel for the appellant. Detailed written submissions were also filed by her. We have perused the records including the records of the trial court.
12. The case rests on circumstantial evidence. We are conscious of the five golden principles repeatedly reiterated by this Court which are to be borne in mind in cases involved with circumstantial evidence. In the leading case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116, it was held as under:- [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1079Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v. State of Gujarat “153. A close analysis of this decision would show that the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to be fully established: “(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances concerned “must or should” and not “may be” established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal distinction between “may be proved” and “must be or should be proved” as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC 793 : 1973 SCC (Cri) 1033 : 1973 Crl LJ 1783] where the observations were made:
“Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance between ‘may be’ and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
Approaching the case at hand with the above principles in mind, we find the following.
Circumstance No. 1: The appellant last seen with the deceased
13. It is the consistent case of the prosecution that the deceased child Rohit @ Shital was barely four years old and was playing near his 1080 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports house when the accused took him from there under the pretext of getting him ice-cream. PW-10 Jyotsnaben, who was the aunt of the deceased and who lived nearby, clearly deposed that on the day of the incident when she was cooking near the front side of the house, the appellant came to her and asked for water. Thereafter, while leaving, the accused took the victim. When she asked the appellant where he was taking the victim, the appellant replied that he was taking the victim to get ice-cream and he will send him after that. When PW-10 told him not to do so, the appellant stated that he would send him back after getting the child ice-cream, and so saying took the child with him.
14. It is undisputed that the family of the deceased knew the appellant and his family. PW-10 further deposed that when after a long time the deceased did not return, she informed the same to her sister-inlaw PW-13.2 Artiben. PW-10 maintained her narration in the cross where it also emerges that she searched for child at the ice-cream shop of Kabo and Yogesh in the village and was told that the victim had not been there.
15. The deposition of PW-10 Jyotsnaben is fully corroborated by the evidence given by PW-11 Manoj Kumar. PW-11 states that he was running a garment shop at Piludara village; that on the day of the incident, the appellant Shambhu passed by his shop at about 12 O’clock; that Pravingiri’s son was with the appellant; that on being asked the appellant informed that he was going to the shop of Kaliya to get ice-cream. PW-11 also stated that when the appellant was passing by the shop along with victim, PW-12 Somabhai Ranchhodbhai, Ranjitbhai Fatesang and Raysangbhai Manorbhai were also present. The defence contends that PW-12 did not support the case of the prosecution and was declared hostile. This aspect of the matter does not detract from the clinching evidence of the evidence of aunt of the deceased - PW-10 Jyotsnaben which we find very natural or the evidence of PW-11 Manoj Kumar who had no reason to falsely depose to the said fact. The only suggestion given to PW-11 is that he was deposing because he was friend of the father of the deceased. We are not persuaded to discredit the testimony of PW-11 on this score.
16. Apart from PW-10 and PW-11, PW-13.1 Sursangbhai also speaks about the appellant taking the deceased and the appellant stating [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1081Sambhubhai Raisangbhai Padhiyar v. State of Gujarat that he was going to get the child ice-cream. PW-13.1 states that thereafter he went inside the house and left for the farm. It was strongly contended by the defence that in the cross-examination, he had deposed that he had not seen the appellant passing by the shop along with the deceased. The portion of the cross-examination has to be read in the context of the earlier statements occurring therein. They are as follows:
“It is not true that Manojbhai’s shop is located at the distance of half kilometer from my house. It is true that Manojbhai’s shop is in the market it is true that Manojbhai runs business of ice cream and other goods. Kaliya’s shop is located in the other market. I had reached Manojbhai’s shop at about 1 o’clock. It is true that the market was open and there was movement of people. It is true that I had not seen Shambhu passing by the shop along with the son of Pravin. Pravin bhai Maharaj is my friend. I do not know his family members.”
It will be seen that PW-13.1 states that he reached Manojbhai’s shop at about 1 O’clock and that market was open and there was movement of people and thereafter the statement occurs that he had not seen appellant passing by along with the son of Pravingiri. Mrs. Swati Ghildiyal, learned counsel for the State, in her written submissions, has furnished the portion as in Gujarati which was also read to us and translated at the time of the oral hearing. According to the learned counsel for the State, the particular sentence only meant that PW-13.1, did not see the appellant leaving or going away from the shop and that this was only because he had gone into his house prior to that. We are inclined to accept the meaning as it comes out from the Gujarati version. The small discrepancies insofar as the timings are concerned are only natural as the witnesses were deposing nearly two years after the incident. They are not material discrepancies.
17. Hence, it is undisputed that between 12:00 and 01:00 PM, the appellant went to the neighborhood of the house of the deceased and partook water from the aunt PW-10, engaged in a conversation with her and in spite of being dissuaded, took the deceased child under the pretext of buying him ice-cream. The time lag between the accused being last seen and the sighting of the dead body lying 1082 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports is also extremely short. PW-11 Manoj Kumar states that at about 5 O’clock in the evening when they were searching for the victim and when they were near the boundary wall of the lake near the Dargah, some persons informed them that a dead body was lying in the acacia bushes behind the Dargah.
18. The incident has clearly occurred between 12:00 noon and 05:00 PM on 13.04.2016. The timing is also corroborated by the doctor PW-8 who did the postmortem on 14.04.2016 between 03:35 PM and 04:45 PM and he further deposed that death would have occurred 24 to 36 hours before the postmortem. There are some important aspects which require to be noticed here and that is what brings out the clinching nature of the case against the appellant.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.