Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 865; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 2375
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 12 Nov 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2845/2015
- Sections
- 52, 54, 53A, 16, 96, 29
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 2375 : 2024 INSC 865 Shyam Kumar Inani v.
Vinod Agrawal & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 2845 of 2015)
12 November 2024 [Vikram Nath* and Prashant Kumar Mishra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Appellants are entitled to specific performance of an Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990. Whether the Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990 executed by one Sushila Devi was valid and enforceable; whether such execution could be proved by a General Power of Attorney holder; whether the plea of pardanashin status, illiteracy and old age affected the validity of the sale; whether the suit was barred by limitation under Article 54 of the Limitation Act; whether plaintiffs were in possession and whether consideration had been paid; whether plaintiffs were always ready and willing to perform their part of the contract; whether the subsequent sale deeds executed during pendency of suit were protected under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act and whether they violated the doctrine of lis pendens; and whether the High Court rightly reversed concurrent findings of the Trial Court.
Headnotes† Sale of Immovable Property – Specific Performance – Validity of Agreement to Sell, Proof, Possession, Limitation, and Appellate Interference – The appellant-plaintiffs sought specific performance based on an Agreement to Sell with full consideration paid and possession of 23.98 acres of disputed agricultural land obtained from Sushila Devi, who passed away in 1992 – The Trial Court decreed the suit, validating the agreement, but the High Court reversed the decision, raising concerns over under-valuation, vagueness of the agreement, absence of direct testimony by all plaintiffs, lack of boundary specifications, bar of limitation, and pardanashin status of the executant – The High Court also questioned the credibility of the Power of Attorney holder's testimony:
*Author 2376 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: Supreme Court restored the Trial Court's decree, concluding that the Agreement to Sell was valid and enforceable under the Contract Act and Specific Relief Act – It held that procedural and substantive requirements were satisfied, with no conclusive proof of fraud – The Court emphasized that the burden of proving fraud lies on the defendant – The absence of boundary descriptions was not fatal to enforceability where the property was clearly identifiable and plaintiffs were in possession – It was further held that not every plaintiff must depose if a Power of Attorney holder with firsthand knowledge proves execution. [Paras 1, 2, 37] Inference of fraud must be clearly established – The defendants alleged that the Agreement to Sell was procured through fraudulent means, citing undervaluation, vague boundaries, and Sushila Devi's alleged incapacity:
Held: The Supreme Court emphasized that fraud must be strictly pleaded and proved – The burden to proof lies squarely on the party alleging it – Defendants failed to produce any direct or circumstantial evidence showing deception, coercion, or concealment by the plaintiffs – Allegation of fraud was unsubstantiated – No material produced to prove fraud or misrepresentation – The Supreme Court noted that the Trial Court correctly found the transaction to be genuine and voluntary, and the High Court erred in accepting a speculative charge of fraud. [Para 35.1] Specific Relief – Validity – Proof of Execution by Power of Attorney Holder – The Power of Attorney holder, M.K. Maheshwari, had personal involvement in the transaction, which was corroborated by an attesting witness and handwriting expert – The High Court made misplaced adverse inference from non-examination of other plaintiffs:
Held: Valid execution established – The Court relied on Man Kaur v. Hartar Singh Sangha, (2010) 10 SCC 512 to affirm that a Power of Attorney holder with personal knowledge may validly depose – The Court distinguished the decision in Vidyadhar Vishnupant Ratnaparkhi v. Manikrao Babarao Deshmukh, (1999) 3 SCC 573, to argue adverse inference for non-examination of plaintiffs, on facts as the Power of Attorney holder had firsthand knowledge and testified credibly – The Supreme Court distinguished Janki Vashdeo v. IndusInd Bank, (2005) 2 SCC 217 and Rajesh [2024] 11 S.C.R. 2377Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors. Kumar v. Anand Kumar, (2024) SCC OnLine SC 981, cited to challenge validity of POA evidence, on the ground that POA holder in this case had direct knowledge and personal involvement. [Paras 25–29, 34.4- 34.5 35.2] Limitation – Article 54 – Second part applicable – No fixed time for performance – Cause of action arose upon refusal – The agreement did not fix a time for registration – After Sushila Devi’s death, mutation was denied in 1994 – Suit filed in 1995 was within limitation:
Held: Suit not time-barred – The second part of Article 54 applied – Section 54 prescribes that when no date is fixed for performance, the limitation period begins when the plaintiff has notice that performance is refused – The Court rejected the High Court’s view that the limitation began immediately upon execution or death of the executant – The agreement was consistently acted upon and the plaintiffs had performed their part by paying full consideration and remaining in possession. [Para 30] Pardanashin Status – No pleading or proof – Age/illiteracy – No seclusion – Voluntary execution – High Court assuming Sushila Devi to be a pardanashin lady, applied higher evidentiary threshold to the Agreement to Sell:
Held: Sushila Devi not entitled to pardanashin protection – Presumption of undue influence not applicable – Burden of proof not discharged by defendants – The Supreme Court found no pleading or credible evidence to support such status – It distinguished Mst. Kharbuja Kuer v. Jangbahadur Rai, AIR 1963 SC 1203, relied on by respondents to invoke stricter scrutiny in transactions involving pardanashin women, on facts, as Sushila Devi’s status was not analogous due to the absence of seclusion or concealment – It also distinguished Krishna Mohan Kul v. Pratima Maity, (2004) 9 SCC 468 relied on to suggest incapacity due age and infirmity, on facts – Unlike the 100-year-old bedridden woman in that case, Sushila Devi was active and voluntarily executed the agreement. [Paras 34.2–34.3] Possession and Title – Possession since 1990 – Title deeds handed over – Part performance under Section 53A TPA – Evidence supported by documents and conduct – The plaintiffs 2378 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports had been in settled possession of the suit land since 1990, following execution of the Agreement to Sell – They produced documentary proof including the original sale deed, Rin Pustika, and land revenue receipts have paid land revenue, indicating de facto and de jure control – The defendants failed to rebut the evidence of possession and title handover – It also distinguished Thiruvengadam Pillai v. Navaneethammal, (2008) 4 SCC 530, cited to argue execution defects, as the plaintiffs were in possession, stamp duty and evidentiary support were both satisfied in present case:
Held: Plaintiffs' continuous possession supported by documentary evidence established part performance – The Court found that possession pursuant to a lawful agreement, coupled with part payment and willingness to perform, attracted protection under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act. [Paras 31–32, 34.1, 34.6-34.8] Readiness and Willingness – Full consideration paid – Continuous willingness – Delay attributable to defendants – The plaintiffs paid the full consideration under the Agreement to Sell at the outset and remained ready and willing to execute the formal sale deed – The delay was due to the inaction of defendants – The plaintiffs’ consistent conduct and attempts to seek mutation and performance were evident:
Held: Plaintiffs complied with Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act. [Paras 20.4, 21.4] Lis Pendens – Section 52 TPA – Sale during pendency – Violation of injunction – Purchasers not bona fide – Doctrine to prevent frustration of judicial process – On 18.01.2001, while the suit for specific performance was pending and after an injunction was granted on 04.12.2000, the defendants executed four sale deeds in favour of third parties:
Held: Sale deeds executed during pendency and in violation of injunction were void – Doctrine of lis pendens squarely applied – Purchasers could not claim protection under bona fide doctrine due to notice of pending suit and injunction – The Court distinguished Thomson Press (India) Ltd. v. Nanak Builders and Investors Pvt. Ltd., (2013) 5 SCC 397 and Yogesh Goel v. Govind Narayan, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 169, which were cited by the defendants to [2024] 11 S.C.R. 2379Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors. support protection of pendente lite purchasers – In those cases, the purchasers had either no notice or the dispute lacked injunction orders at the time of sale – In contrast, here the purchasers had clear notice of the pending suit and express injunctive restraint. [Paras 33, 34.6-34.8] No enforceability bar due to vagueness – Boundaries identifiable – Undervaluation not conclusive of mala fides – The defendants also contended that the Agreement to Sell was vague and lacked specific demarcation of boundaries, and that the consideration was below market rate:
Held: Agreement not invalid for lack of precise boundaries or lowerthan-market consideration – No mala fides established – The Court clarified that minor imprecision in boundary description does not affect enforceability where the property can otherwise be identified with certainty – Further, undervaluation alone does not establish fraud or invalidate the contract when possession, consideration, and intention to perform are established. [Paras 34.6] Case Law Cited Thiruvengadam Pillai v. Navaneethammal [2008] 3 SCR 23 : (2008) 4 SCC 530; Mst. Kharbuja Kuer v. Jangbahadur Rai & Ors. [1963] Supp. 1 SCR 456 : AIR 1963 SC 1203; Vidyadhar Vishnupant Ratnaparkhi v. Manikrao Babarao Deshmukh and Ors. [1999] 1 SCR 1168 : (1999) 3 SCC 573; Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani & Anr. v. Indusind Bank Ltd. and Anr. [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 681 : (2005) 2 SCC 217; Rajesh Kumar v. Anand Kumar [2024] 5 SCR 612 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 981; Thomson Press (India) Ltd. v. Nank Builders & Investors (P) Ltd. [2013] 2 SCR 74 : (2013) 5 SCC 397 – distinguished.
Krishna Mohan Kul v. Pratima Maity and Ors. [2003] Supp. 3 SCR 496 : (2004) 9 SCC 468; Yogesh Goyanka v. Govind [2024] 7 SCR 668 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 169 – referred to.
Man kaur v. Hartar Singh Sangha [2010] 12 SCR 515 : (2010) 10 SCC 512; Pawan Kumar Gupta v. Rochiram Nagdeo [1999] 2 SCR 767 : AIR 1999 SC 1823 – relied on.
List of Acts Specific Relief Act, 1963; Limitation Act, 1963; Contract Act, 1872. 2380 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Agreement to Sell; Specific performance; Limitation; Power of Attorney; Possession; Pardanashin; Bonafide purchasers; Violation of injunction.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2845 of 2015 From the Judgment and Order dated 15.03.2012 of the High Court of M.P at Jabalpur in FA No. 372 of 2001 With Civil Appeal No(s). 2846, 2850, 2847, 2848 and 2852 of 2015 Appearances for Parties P. S. Patwalia, Rahul Sripat, Sr. Advs., Santosh Kumar, Madhurendra Sharma, Rajiv R. Mishra, Ms. Suruchi Yadav, Yadav Narender Singh, Advs. for the Appellant.
Sudhanshu Shashikumar Choudhari, Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad, Sunil Kumar, Sr. Advs., Harshvardhan Jha, Mrs. Yugandhara Pawar Jha, Ms. Srishti Mishra, Aman Pathak, Ms. Shuchi Bharti, Ms. Tunika Sharma, Akshat Shrivastava, Satvic Mathur, Divyakant Lahoti, Kumar Vinayakam Gupta, Ms. Praveena Bisht, Ms. Vindhya Mehra, Kartik Lahoti, Adith Menon, Ms. Samridhi Bhatt, Ms. Shreya Gokel, Ms. Anushka Awasthi, Rohan Thawani, Ms. Vandana Sehgal, Ms. S. Ambica, Advs. for the Respondents.
Shree Prakash Sinha, Rakesh Mishra, Ms. Mohua Sinha, Nawalendra Kumar, Ms. Shwetam, Rishabh Kumar, Shekhar Kumar, Anoop Kashyap, Advs. for the Interveners.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. The six appellants are the plaintiffs in a suit for specific performance of a contract. The Trial Court decreed the suit. However, the High Court, on first appeal, allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the Trial Court and dismissed the suit. Aggrieved, the present appeals by the plaintiffs.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 2381Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors.
2. The dispute relates to 23.98 acres of Khasra Nos.546, 547 and 548 situate in village Godar Mau, Tehsil Huzur, District Bhopal. It is an admitted position between the parties that a larger area measuring 27.56 acres of the aforesaid three khasra numbers was purchased by one Sushila Bai, wife of late Chandra Mal Aggarwal, vide registered sale deed dated 29.04.1966 executed by erstwhile owner Vijay Chhatti for a sale consideration of Rs.7,000/-. Based on the said instrument, the name of Sushila Bai was mutated in land revenue records.
3. The appellants filed separate suits for specific performance in May, 1995 against the legal heirs of Sushila Devi.
4. It would be relevant to mention here that in the plaint, defendant nos.1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 were the other legal heirs of late Sushila Devi. We have mentioned the name of Kailash Aggarwal separately as he had a distinct role to play in the entire transaction. The sequence of events which would be discussed and pleaded upon at a later stage will reflect upon the role of Kailash Aggarwal. However, needless to say that Kailash Aggarwal was the eldest son of Sushila Devi. All the plaints are more or less identically worded, as such, we are not giving any specific details of the separate suit schedule property for each of the plaint, but we have generally dealt with the plaint allegations. Briefly stated the plaint allegations are as follows: a) Sushila Devi was the owner of the suit schedule property. She entered into an Agreement to Sell on 30.08.1990 with each of the appellants separately after receiving the entire sale consideration. The appellants had taken over actual possession, having paid the entire sale consideration, the suit schedule property was agricultural land and cultivated by the appellants. b) Details of the land covered and the sale consideration with respect to six Agreement to Sell are as follows:
S.
NO.
Khasra No.
Area Consideration Name of Purchaser
1. 548 3.48 acres Rs.58,000/- Bharat Kumar Lathi
2. 547 3.50 acres Rs.70,000/- Shyam Kumar Inani 2382 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3. 547 4.0 acres Rs. 80,000/- Suryakanta Maheshwari w/o KD Maheshwari
4. 547 4.0 acres Rs. 80,000/- Ram Kumar Inani
5. 546 4.50 acres Rs. 90,000/- Sangeeta Maheshwari d/o K.D. Maheshwari
6. 546 4.50 acres Rs. 90,000/- K.D. Maheshwari c) The defendants are the legal heirs of Sushila Devi and Agreement to Sell was binding upon them, but they declined to fulfil their legal obligation by executing the sale deed in favour of the appellants and had instead applied for mutation for the suit schedule property which had been allowed by the revenue authority.
d) As the entire sale consideration had been paid as per the contents of the Agreement to Sell, the appellants were put into possession also. The original title deed of 1966 in favour of Sushila Devi was also handed over to the appellants. The witnesses to the Agreement to Sell were Dipesh Chandra Patni PW-2 and one Mr. Sharma. As the entire sale consideration had been paid, the time was not the essence of contract and the same was also incorporated in the Agreement to Sell in clause
6. Smt. Sushila Devi executed a registered General Power of Attorney in favour of M.K. Maheshwari on 04.09.1990. She died on 25.12.1992 leaving behind the respondent nos. 1, 2, 3, 9 and 10 as her legal heirs and representatives.
e) The legal heirs applied for mutation of their names over the suit schedule property to which objections were filed by the appellants. However, they were unsuccessful, and the Tehsildar directed for mutation of the names of the legal heirs by order dated 23.02.1999.
f) The appellants, vide notice dated 28.04.1994 called upon the legal heirs of Sushila Devi to execute the sale deed. However, the same was not honoured.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 2383Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors. g) The appellants instituted six separate Civil Suits, each seeking a decree for specific performance of an Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990, against the legal heirs of Sushila Devi, compelling them to execute the sale deed in accordance with the said agreement. In these suits, the following reliefs were similarly claimed:
(i) A decree directing the defendants to specifically perform their obligations under the Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990 by registering a sale deed for the agricultural land under the respective khasra numbers in favour of the appellants. Alternatively, a direction was sought for the court itself to execute a legal sale deed for the disputed property in favour of the appellants.
(ii) An award of costs of the suit in favour of the appellants and against the defendants, along with any other reliefs deemed appropriate by the court.
(iii) A permanent injunction restraining defendants no. 1 to 5 from alienating, altering or placing any encumbrances on the said property, and from transferring the suit property to any third party or governmental authority.
(iv) A declaration that the subsequent transfer of the suit property, effected on 18.01.2001, was void and not binding on the appellants.
h) Further, it was brought on record, by way of amendment to the plaint that the defendant numbers 1 to 5 on the basis of the mutation order passed on 23.02.1999 was likely to alienate the suit schedule property in favour of third party and, later on, by a further amendment, it was brought on record that defendant nos. 2 to 5 by four separate sale deeds actually alienated the suit schedule property in favour of newly added dependent nos. 7 to 10 on 18.01.2001. State of Madhya Pradesh was also made a party to the suit as defendant no. 6. Trial Court passed an interim injunction order on 04.12.2000 putting a restraint on the alienation of the property in suit.
i) Despite there being an injunction order restraining the defendants from alienating the suit schedule property, the appellants were 2384 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports always ready and willing to perform their part of the contract which only required registration of the sale deed as the entire sale consideration had already been paid. A prayer for specific performance of the contract was made based on such plaint averments.
5. A brief written statement was filed by the respondent State of Madhya Pradesh-defendant number 6 (respondent no.8) to the effect that the suit schedule property fell in urban area (Nagariya Kshetra) under the Nagar Bhumi Seema Adhiniyam and as per the requirements of the said Act, it was only after the enforcement of the new Master Plan, that the actual area of land which the owner would be entitled to possess, would be determined. As such, the defendant would not have any right to sell the property, nor would the plaintiff have any right to buy these properties. The plaintiff is, thus, not entitled to any relief.
6. Defendant nos. 2, 3 and 4, namely Vinod Aggarwal, Jagdish Aggarwal and Usha Aggarwal, three of the legal heirs of Sushila Devi filed a joint written statement. They denied the contents of the plaint except to the extent that Sushila Devi was the owner of the suit schedule property. It was further stated that she had never executed any Agreement to Sell. It was, thus, claimed that the suit deserves to be dismissed.
7. The subsequent purchasers, under the sale deed dated 18.01.2001, filed a separate written statement denying the plaint allegations. They also denied that any Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990 was executed by Sushila Devi. No specific answer has been given as to whether the sale deed dated 18.01.2001 in their favour was executed in violation of the injunction order. They also took the plea that the Agreement to Sell required compulsory registration and also payment of sufficient stamp duty which was not done, as such, the same was not admissible in evidence.
8. It was further stated in their written statement that the sale consideration mentioned in the Agreement to Sell was much below the prevailing market rate which indicated mala fide on the part of the appellants. A plea was also raised to the effect that the suit scheduled property was owned by a HUF and as such the Agreement to Sell having been executed only by Sushila Devi without the consent or confirmation of the other members of HUF, the Agreement to Sell was void. On such averments, the defendant nos. 7 to 10 stated that the suit was liable to be dismissed.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 2385Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors.
9. The Trial Court, on the pleadings of the parties, framed the following issues as stated in paragraph 8 of the judgment along with its findings on each issue. The same are reproduced hereunder:
“ Issues Finding
1. Whether an Agreement was executed on 30.08.90 with the plaintiff by the mother of the defendants late Sushilabai for the sale of the disputed land situated in Godar Mau Khasra No.548 area 3.49 acres?
Sushilabai had executed an agreement dated 30.08.90 for the sale of disputed land with the plaintiff.
2. Whether the plaintiff making full payment of the Agreement to late Sushilabai obtained the possession of the disputed property on 30.08.90 itself?
All the amount of the bai was paid by the plaintiff to Sushila bai and the possession of the disputed property has been obtained.
3(a) Whether the plaintiff has been always ready to comply with the Agreement?
In compliance with the agreement the plaintif has been willing and ready to fulfil.
3(b) Whether the defendants have refused to comply with the agreement?
The Defendants have refused to comply with the Agreement.
4. Whether the dispute being of agricultural land, the State of M.P.
is necessary party?
Proved
5. Whether the Defendant No.2 to 5 had sold the disputed land to Deft.
No.7 to 10 even there being order of prohibition during the course of trial?
Yes
6. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get 4 sale deeds dated 18.01.2001 to be declared null and void?
All four sale-deeds dt.18.01.2001 concerning up to the extent of the disputed land the plaintiff is entitled to get declared null and void.
7. Relief and expenses As per last para of the judgment & Decree issued.”
2386 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
10. The parties led both oral and documentary evidence in support of their respective cases. The Trial Court, vide judgment dated 14.05.2001, decreed all the suits as contained in paragraph 45 of the judgment. The operative part of the judgment of the Trial Court is reproduced hereunder:
“…..
1. The disputed land situated in Godar Mau in respect of Khasra No.548 area 3.48 acres which was sold by registered sale-deed dated 18.01.2001 b Usha Aggarwal to Md. Shakir Khan, Vinod Aggarwal to Irfan Khan, Sangita Aggarwal to Ashok Jaiswal and Jagdish Aggarwal in favour of Tomo has been executed, the lands of this Khasra No. to that extent of about 4 sale deeds are declared null and void.
2. That in favour of the plaintiff defendants No.1 to 5 may get executed the sale deed within a period of two months of the disputed land Khasra No.548 area 3.48 acres.
3. In respect of the above land, the expenses are to be incurred on getting the registered sale deed by the plaintiff.
4. The cost of this suit of the plaintiff will be borne by the defendants and the defendants will bear their own expenses.
….”
11. RCS No.47A/01 and one more were decided on 14.05.2001 and thereafter by a separate judgment dated 05.10.2001, four other suits were decreed, details whereof are given in the table below: S.No. Civil Suit No.
Party Name Decided on.
1. RCS No.
22-A/97 Bharat Kumar Lathi vs.
Kaliash Agarwal & 9 others.
(Pankaj Maheshwari – Power of attorney Holder)
14.05.2001 [2024] 11 S.C.R. 2387Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors.
2. RCS No.
23-A/97 Shyam Kumar Inani Vs.
Kailash Agarwal & 9 ors.
Filed through self (KDM Power of attorney prosecuted later)
14.05.2001
3. RCS
45-A/01 Smt. Suryakanta vs. Kailash Agarwal and ors.
(KDM Power of attorney)
05.10.2001
4. RCS
46-A/01 Raj Kumar Inani Vs. Kailash Agarwal & ors.
(KDM Power of attorney)
05.10.2001
5. RCS
47-A/01 Sangeeta Maheshwari Vs.
Kailash Agarwal & ors.
(KDM Power of Attorney)
05.10.2001
6. RCS
48-A/01 K.D. Maheshwari vs. Kailash Agarwal and ors.
(KDM Power of Attorney)
Filed through self 05.10.2001
12. Aggrieved by the aforesaid two judgments, the defendants filed an appeal under section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 before the High Court. The High Court, by the impugned judgment, has allowed all the six appeals and after setting aside the judgment of the Trial Court dismissed the suits. Aggrieved, the plaintiffs are in appeal before this Court.
13. Before proceeding further, briefly, the evidence led by the appellantplaintiffs and the defendant-respondents may be noticed. The appellants examined either the plaintiff or his Power of Attorney holder as PW-1. Further, the attesting witness to the Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990, Dipesh Patni was examined as PW-2 and Mahesh Kumar Maheshwari was examined as PW-3, who was said to have been Power of Attorney holder of Sushila Devi, vide registered deed of Attorney dated 04.09.1990. R.K. Pathik was examined as PW-4 as Handwriting Expert (HWE).
14. On behalf of the defendants, Mohd. Shakir Khan was examined as DW-1. One of the legal heirs of Sushila Devi, namely Vinod Kumar 2388 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Aggarwal, was examined as DW-2, and Naveen Chandra Deshpande was examined as DW-3 as Handwriting Expert (HWE). On behalf of the plaintiffs, the Power of Attorneys of the respective plaintiffs were filed and exhibited. The Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990 was also filed and duly proved as Exhibit-P/2. The original documents handed over by Sushila Devi to her Power of Attorney holder Mahesh Kumar Maheshwari were also filed which included loan book, Ex.-P/3, Original Sale deed dated 29.04.1966, Ex.-P/4, and the Power of Attorney in favour of Mahesh Kumar Maheshwari, Ex.-P/5
15. Further, the defendants filed documents relating to the sale deed in favour of the defendants 7 to 10 along with supporting documents like loan book etc. which were marked as Exhibits - D/1 to D/6. The list of documents with brief description filed by the plaintiffs as also the defendants in one of the suits is given hereunder: - “Documents filed by the Plaintiffs Exhibit P-1 Sale agreement dated 30.8.1990 Exhibit P-2 Registered General Power of Attorney dated 4.9.1990 executed by Smt. Sushila Devi in favour Shri M.K. Maheshwari Exhibit P-3 Legal notice dated 28.04.1994 Exhibit P-4 Postal Receipt Exhibit P-5 Sale-deed dated 29.4.1966 executed by Vijay Chhatti in favour of Smt. Sushila Devi in respect of Khasra Nos. 546, 547 and 548 area 9.3, 15.5 and 3.3 acres, total are 27.56 acres situated in Godarmau, Tahsil Huzur District Bhopal Exhibit P-6 Rin Pustika issued in favour Smt. Sushila Devi Exhibit P-7 Registered Power of Attorney dated 20.04.1995 executed by Shri Ramkumar Inani (Plaintiff) in favour of Shri K.D. Maheshwari.
Exhibit P-8 Judgment and decree dated 14.05.2001 passed by learned Second Additional District Judge, Bhopal in Civil Suit no.22-A/1994 [Bharat Kumar Lathi vs.
Kailash Agrawal] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 2389Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors. Exhibit P-9 Judgment and decree dated 14.05.2001 passed by Second Additional District Judge, Bhopal in Civil Suit No.23-A /1997 [Shyam Kumar Inani vs.
Kailash Agrawal] Exhibit P-9A Evidence of Vinod Kumar Agrawal in Civil Suit No.23-A/1997 [Shyam Kumar Inani vs. Kailash Agrawal] Exhibit P-10 Report of Handwriting Expert Shri R.K. Pathik Documents filed by the Defendants Exhibit D-1 Bhu Adhikar Evam Rin Pustika issued in favour of Kailash, Vinod and Jagdish Exhibit D-2 Rin Pustika issued in favour of Irfan Khan Exhibit D-3 Rin Pustika issued in favour of Modh. Shakir Exhibit D-4 Rin Pustika issued in favour of Mr. Tommy Exhibit D-5 Rin Pustika issued in favour of Ashok Jaiswal Exhibit D-6(c) Order sheets of Ceiling Case passed by Additional Collector/Competent Authority Exhibit D-7 Covering letter dated 28.08.2001 together with opinion of Shri N.C. Deshpande (Handwriting Expert)
Exhibit D-8 to D-20 Copies of specimen signature of Smt. Sushila Bai
16. We have mentioned this list only for the purpose of showing as to what were the documents generally filed by the parties. Most of the documents were common for all the six suits. The difference in different suits could be of numbering of the documents as exhibits but, more or less, they are one and the same.
17. We may now briefly refer to the discussion and analysis made by the Trial Court including the documents relied upon by it while decreeing the suit. The Trial Court thoroughly analysed the claims of both the parties, particularly focusing on the Agreement to Sell dated 2390 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 30.08.1990 and the subsequent conduct of the parties. Following findings were recorded by the Trial Court:
17.1. The Trial Court found that the appellants had paid the entire sale consideration at the time of the agreement, and the possession of the disputed land was handed over by Sushila Devi to the plaintiff-appellants. The appellants remained in possession of the land since 30.08.1990, using it for agricultural purposes. The Trial Court also noted that after Sushila Devi’s death on 17.12.1992, the appellants had repeatedly requested the defendants, as legal heirs, to execute the sale deed in their favour, which the defendants failed to do. This refusal constituted the cause of action for filing the suit for specific performance.
17.2. The Trial Court relied on the Power of Attorney holder, Pankaj Maheshwari, as a key witness. He testified to his personal knowledge of the facts, the execution of the agreement, and the possession handed over to the plaintiff. Notably, Pankaj Maheshwari also presented crucial documents, including the original loan book, the registered sale deed of 1966, and the Power of Attorney, all of which were duly exhibited before the Trial Court. The agreement was witnessed by Dipesh Chandra Patni and one Mr. Sharma. Dipesh Chandra Patni was examined as plaintiff’s witness supporting the appellants’ case.
17.3. The defendants, despite alleging fraud and forgery regarding the execution of the agreement and Power of Attorney, failed to appear or provide any rebuttal evidence. The Trial Court emphasized that the burden of proving fraud lay with the defendants, who did not present any credible evidence to support their claims. The Trial Court held that the defendants’ absence and failure to present any substantial challenge to the appellants’ evidence effectively confirmed the validity of the agreement.
17.4. Further, the Trial Court addressed the sale of the disputed property by the defendants to subsequent purchasers, Defendant Nos. 7 to 10, during the pendency of the trial. It noted that a prohibition order had been passed restraining such a transfer, yet the defendants proceeded with the sale in violation of the Court’s directive. As a result, the four sale [2024] 11 S.C.R. 2391Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors. deeds dated 18.01.2001 were declared null and void.
17.5. In its final findings, the Trial Court ruled that the appellants had been ready and willing to perform their obligations under the agreement. The suit was found to be within the period of limitation, as the cause of action arose when the legal heirs of Sushila Devi refused to execute the sale deed after her death.
17.6. The Trial Court directed that Defendant Nos. 1 to 5 must execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff within two months and further declared the sale deeds executed in favour of Defendant Nos. 7 to 10 as null and void.
18. Now, we briefly refer to the reasoning and findings of the High Court in allowing the appeal.
18.1. The High Court first scrutinized the Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990, emphasizing that it was not registered, and the sale consideration appeared to be significantly below the market rate prevailing at the time of the alleged transaction. The High Court found this to be an indicator of potential mala fides on the part of the plaintiff-appellants.
18.2. Furthermore, the High Court noted that the agreement lacked specific details concerning the boundaries of the disputed land, leading to ambiguity about the property that was to be conveyed.
18.3. On the issue of possession, the High Court observed that while the appellants claimed to have been put in possession of the land by Sushila Devi, there was no substantial evidence to corroborate this assertion.
18.4. The High Court found that the appellants had failed to convincingly establish their possession of the land in question, which significantly weakened their case for specific performance.
18.5. In addition, the High Court placed significant weight on the fact that the appellants did not enter the witness box to testify in support of their claims. Instead, the appellants relied on their Power of Attorney holder, Pankaj Maheshwari, to provide testimony. The High Court emphasized that while a Power of Attorney holder may testify regarding facts within their personal knowledge, critical facts regarding the execution of the 2392 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Agreement to Sell could only be testified to by the appellants themselves. The failure of the appellants to take the witness stand led the High Court to draw an adverse inference under the established legal principle that the best evidence should be produced, especially when a party to the agreement is alive and capable of testifying.
18.6. The High Court further examined the issue of fraud and misrepresentation, which had been raised by the defendants. It found that the entire transaction was shrouded in suspicion, given the low consideration, the alleged absence of clear possession by the plaintiffs, and the fact that the legal heirs of Sushila Devi were unaware of the agreement. The High Court concluded that the burden of proving the validity of the agreement rested on the appellants, particularly in light of the defence of fraud, but the appellants had failed to discharge this burden satisfactorily.
18.7. On the issue of limitation, the High Court disagreed with the Trial Court’s finding. The High Court held that the suit was barred by limitation under Article 54 of the Limitation Act, 1963. It found that the cause of action for filing the suit arose immediately after the death of Sushila Devi in 1992, yet the suit was filed only in 1995. Given that no specific time was stipulated in the agreement for the execution of the sale deed, the High Court concluded that the suit was not filed within the prescribed period of three years from the date of Sushila Devi’s death or the time when the right to sue first accrued. Based on these findings, the High Court concluded that the plaintiffs had failed to prove their case for specific performance of the Agreement to Sell, and the sale deeds executed in favour of Defendant Nos. 7 to 10 were not liable to be declared null and void. The High also recorded a finding that the vendor Sushila Devi was entitled to the benefits admissible to a Pardanashin lady and relied upon the judgments in the case of MST. Kharbuja Kuer vs. Jangbahadur Rai & Ors.1 and Krishna Mohan Kul.2 The High Court, thus, allowed the appeal, set aside the decree passed by the Trial Court, and dismissed the suits filed by the plaintiffs. 1 AIR 1963 SC 1203 (para 6)
2 (2004) 9 SCC 468
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 2393Shyam Kumar Inani v. Vinod Agrawal & Ors.
19. We have heard Shri P.S. Patwalia and Shri Rahul Sripat, learned senior counsels appearing for the appellants, Shri Sunil Kumar, Shri Sudhanshu Shashikumr Choudhari and Shri Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad, learned senior advocates appearing for different respondents in different appeals and Shri Shekhar Kumar, advocate for the intervenor.
20. Briefly summarised, the arguments advanced on behalf of the appellants by learned senior counsel are to the following effect:
20.1. The Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990 executed by Sushila Devi was duly proved and it was valid and binding on the legal representatives of late Sushila Devi. Our attention has been drawn to the oral evidence as well as documentary evidence led by the plaintiffs in support of the said Agreement to Sell. The same would be dealt with at an appropriate stage.
20.2. It was next submitted that the defence taken by the respondents regarding plea of fraud and misrepresentation with respect to Agreement to Sell dated 30.08.1990, would be required to be established by the defendants as the onus of proof in this regard laid on the defendants. The High Court, in the impugned judgment, erred to shift the burden on the plaintiff-appellants, even though the High Court had specifically recorded that the defendants had failed to lead any evidence in respect of misrepresentation and fraud.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.