Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 716; [2024] 10 S.C.R. 154
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice Cji, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice * J.]
- Decided
- 23 Sept 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2161/2024
- Sections
- 15, 67B, 30, 482, 15(1), 15(2), 15(3), 2(1), 14(1), 19, 2, 21
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 154 : 2024 INSC 716 Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr.
v.
S. Harish & Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 2161-2162 of 2024)
23 September 2024 [Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI, J.B. Pardiwala,* J.] Issue for Consideration What is the scope of Section 15 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO); what is the underlying distinction between sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) respectively of the POCSO; whether, mere viewing, possessing or storing of any child pornographic material is punishable under the POCSO; what is the true scope of Section 67B of the IT Act; what is the scope of Section 30 of the POCSO; what are the foundational facts necessary for invoking the statutory presumption of culpable mental state in respect of Section 15 of the POCSO; whether, the statutory presumption contained in Section 30 of the POCSO can be invoked only at the stage of trial by the Special Court alone established under the POCSO; whether it is permissible for the High Court in a quashing petition filed under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. to resort to the statutory presumption of culpable mental state contained in Section 30 of the POCSO.
Headnotes† Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – Scope – Interpretation – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 – Mere viewing, possessing or storing of any child pornographic material, if punishable under the POCSO:
Held: Yes – Any activity of viewing, distributing or displaying etc., of any child pornographic material by a person over the internet without any actual or physical possession or storage of such material in any device or in any form or manner would amount to ‘possession’ in terms of Section 15 of the POCSO, provided the said person exercised an invariable degree of control over such material, by virtue of the doctrine of constructive possession (possession beyond physical control, having the power and intention to control the contraband) – s.15 provides for three distinct offences that penalize * Author [2024] 10 S.C.R. 155Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. either the storage or the possession of any child pornographic material when done with any particular intention specified under sub-section(s) (1), (2) or (3) respectively – It is in an inchoate offence which penalizes the mere storage or possession of any pornographic material involving a child when done with a specific intent as prescribed, without requiring any actual transmission, dissemination etc. – 2019 Amendment Act made three different forms of storage or possession of child pornography a punishable offence u/s.15, unlike the unamended s.15, which criminalized only the storage of child pornography for a commercial purpose – s.15(1) penalizes the failure to delete, destroy or report any child pornographic material found to be stored or in possession of any person with an intention to share or transmit the same – The mensrea or the intention required under this provision is to be gathered from the actus reus itself i.e., from the manner in which such material is stored or possessed and the circumstances in which the same was not deleted, destroyed or reported – s.15(2) penalizes both the actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution of any child pornography as-well as the facilitation of any of the said acts – The mens rea is to be gathered from the manner in which the pornographic material was found to be stored or in possession and any other material apart from such possession or storage indicative of any facilitation or actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution of such material – Further, s.15(3) penalizes the storage or possession of any child pornographic material when done for any commercial purpose wherein there must be some additional material or attending circumstances that may sufficiently indicate that the said storage or possession was done with the intent to derive any gain or benefit however, to constitute an offence under sub-section (3) there is no requirement to establish that such gain or benefit had been actually realized – Sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) of Section 15 constitute independent and distinct offences with distinction between the varying degree of culpable mens-rea required under the three sub-sections – The three offences cannot co-exist simultaneously in the same set of facts. [Paras 73, 76, 86, 114, 118, 222] Information Technology Act, 2000 – s.67B – Scope:
Held: s.67B is a comprehensive provision designed to address and penalize the various electronic forms of exploitation and abuse of children online – It not only punishes the electronic dissemination of child pornographic material, but also the creation, possession, 156 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports propagation and consumption of such material as-well as the different types of direct and indirect acts of online sexual denigration and exploitation of the vulnerable age of children – s.67B ought to be interpreted in a purposive manner that suppresses the mischief and advances the remedy and ensures that the legislative intent of penalizing the various forms of cyber-offences relating to children and the use of obscene/pornographic material through electronic means is not defeated by a narrow construction. [Paras 151, 153, 222] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – “Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child” – Inchoate Crime/Offence – ‘Actus Reus’; ‘Mens Rea’ – If there is any requirement for an actual transmission of any child pornographic material in order to fall within the ambit of s.15: Held: No – s.15 is in the nature and form of an inchoate offence wherein it is the intention which is being punished and not the commission of any criminal act in the traditional sense – What is sought to be penalized under Section 15 is the storage or possession of any child pornographic material when done with a particular intention or purpose as stipulated in sub-section(s) (1),
(2) or (3), as the case may be. [Paras 81, 86] Criminal jurisprudence – Doctrine of Inchoate Crimes – Concept and aim – Discussed.
Interpretation of Statutes – Aid of marginal note – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – “Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child” – Interpretation with the aid of marginal note when there is no contradiction between marginal note and the substantive parts: Held: In the absence of any inherent conflict or contradiction between the marginal note and the substantive parts of a particular provision, the marginal note may be used to aid in the interpretation of the provision – s.15 along with the marginal note indicates, that it punishes only the storage of pornographic material involving a child when done with a specific intent prescribed thereunder and that there is no requirement for any actual transmission – Thus, s.15 is in the nature and form of an inchoate offence which penalizes the mere storage or possession of any pornographic material involving a child when stored with a specific intent prescribed thereunder, without requiring any actual transmission, dissemination etc. [Para 86] [2024] 10 S.C.R. 157Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. Criminal jurisprudence – Inchoate Crimes – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – Child pornographic material – “Possession” – Doctrine of constructive possession – “actus-reus”:
Held: Under inchoate crimes possession is sought to be punished – Constructive possession extends the concept of possession beyond physical control to situations where an individual has the power and intention to control the contraband, even if it is not in their immediate physical possession – For establishing constructive possession both the power to control the material in question and the knowledge of exercise of such control are required – Wherever a person indulges in any activity such as viewing, distributing or displaying etc. pertaining to any child pornographic material without actually possessing or storing it in any device or in any form or manner, such act would still tantamount to ‘possession’ in terms of Section 15 of the POCSO, if he exercised an invariable degree of control over such material, applying the doctrine of constructive possession – Thus, in terms of the Doctrine of Constructive Possession, any form of intangible or constructive possession of any child pornographic material will also amount to “possession” under Section 15 of the POCSO – There is no requirement of a physical or tangible “storage” or “possession” of such material in Section 15 – Thus, where any child pornographic material is in the constructive possession of an accused, the failure or omission to report the same would constitute the requisite actus-reus for the purposes of Section 15 sub-section
(1) of POCSO. [Paras 114, 117, 118, 122] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15(1), (2), (3) – ‘mens rea’ required under – Distinction between: Held: Section 15 sub-section (1) requires the existence of the requisite mens rea or intention due to which the child pornographic material was not deleted, destroyed or reported whereas, Section 15 sub-section (2) requires the existence of the requisite mens rea or intention which propelled or led the person accused to not only store or possess the said material but also to take some additional steps towards either the actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution or the facilitation of the same – In contrast, Section 15 sub-section (3) requires the existence of the requisite mens rea or intention due to which the person accused not only stored or possessed the child pornographic material but also compelled him to take some additional steps either for any gain or benefit or 158 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in lieu or expectation of some form of gain or benefit – Distinction further explained through examples. [Para 95] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 – ‘Possession’ added to make s.15 more stringent to deter the dissemination and use of child pornography: Held: Word “possession” was originally absent in the unamended Section 15 and the legislature specifically added it in the amended Section 15 – Hence, now both the storage or the possession of any child pornographic material would be liable to be punished when done with any of the specified intention thereunder. [Para 112] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – ‘storage’; ‘possession’ of child pornographic material – To constitute offence u/s.15, ‘storage’ and ‘possession’ not to continue to be there at the time of registration of FIR: Held: Section 15 does not fixate any particularly time-frame – What is simpliciter required to constitute an offence under Section 15 of the POCSO is the establishment of ‘storage’ or ‘possession’ of any child pornographic material with the specified intention under sub-section(s) (1), (2) or (3), at any relevant point of time – Thus, an offence can be made out under Section 15 even if the said ‘storage’ or ‘possession’ no longer exists at the time of registration of the FIR, if it is established that the person accused had ‘stored’ or ‘possessed’ of any child pornographic material with the specified intention at any particular point of time even if it is anterior in time. [Para 124] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – Information Technology Act, 2000 – s.67B – Ingredients necessary to constitute offences under – Divergent views of different High Courts – Discussed.
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 vis-àvis Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 – Statement of Object and Reasons – Discussed. Information Technology Act, 2000 – ss.67, 67A, 67B – Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008 – History of amendment traced.
Interpretation of Statutes – Information Technology Act, 2000 – Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008 – ss.67, 67A vis-à-vis s.67B – Purposive interpretation:
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 159Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. Held: A conjoint reading of Section(s) 67 and 67A vis-a-vis 67B would reveal that unlike the former which penalizes only the publication or transmission of any obscene material or pornographic material,scope and ambit of Section 67B is much wider as it recognizes and penalizes five different forms/categories of actus reus – s.67B not only punishes the electronic dissemination of child pornographic material, but also the creation, possession, propagation and consumption of such material as well as the different types of direct and indirect acts of online sexual denigration and exploitation of the children – ss.67, 67A, s.67B being a complete code, ought to be interpreted in a purposive manner that suppresses the mischief and advances the remedy and ensures that the legislative intent of penalizing the various forms of cyberoffences relating to children and the use of obscene/pornographic material through electronic means is not defeated by a narrow construction. [Paras 150, 153] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 – ss.15, 2(1)(d), 2(1)(da) – “child”; “child pornography” – Pornographic material must prima facie appear to involve a Child – “Subjective satisfaction” criteria – “Subjective satisfaction” criteria, as existing in various countries discussed:
Held: Any visual depiction of a sexually explicit act which any ordinary person of a prudent mind would reasonably believe to prima facie depict a child or appear to involve a child, would be deemed as ‘child pornography’ – Courts are only required to form a prima facie opinion to arrive at the subjective satisfaction that the material appears to depict a child from the perspective of any ordinary prudent person for any offence under the POCSO that relates to child pornographic material, such as Section 15 – Such satisfaction may be arrived at from any authoritative opinion such as a forensic science laboratory (FSL) report of such material or from any expert opinion or by the assessment of such material by the courts themselves – Practical difficulties in conclusively establishing the age of an individual in a pornographic material through objective means or criteria resulting in absurd consequences, enumerated. [Paras 131, 222] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 – ss.15, 2(1)(da), 2(1)(d) – “but appear to depict a 160 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports child” – Purport of s.2(1)(da) – Section 2(1)(da) is a departure from the existing objective criterion of determination of age in terms of Section 2(1)(d):
Held: Neither Section 15 of the POCSO nor Section 2(1)(da) can be interpreted or invoked in isolation from the other – Section 2(1)
(da) of the POCSO, made a conscious departure from the already existing objective criterion of determination of age in terms of Section 2(1)(d) which is generally applicable to the POCSO, as the legislature was alive to inherent difficulty posed by such criteria – Section 2(1)(da) of the POCSO was inserted to explicitly define and delineate what type of visual depictions would be considered ‘child pornography’ to remove any ambiguity that existed earlier and more importantly, to mitigate the tendency of the courts to refer and apply the objective criteria of age determination prescribed under Section 2(1)(d) of the POCSO, even when dealing with matters involving child pornography – Thus, the legislature in addition to explaining the contour of visual depiction in Section 2(1)(da) of the POCSO, also specifically added the words “but appear to depict a child” in the end – If the courts while dealing with any matter involving child pornography, continue to refer and rely on Section 2(1)(d) of the POCSO, then the same will frustrate the intention behind Section 2(1)(da), rendering the words “but appear to depict a child” otiose and nugatory – The true purport of Section 2(1)(da) of the POCSO is to ensure that for offences pertaining to child pornography, it is Section 2(1)(da) that is given due regard and not Section 2(1)(d) – Thus, it is the definition of ‘child pornography’ which is of relevance while considering whether Section 15 of the POCSO can be invoked or not. [Paras 139-143] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – ss.2(1) (d), 2(1)(da)– Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 – “child”; “child pornography” – Whether the individual involved is a ‘child’ or not – Determination – “but appear to depict a child”:
Held: Under s.2(1)(d), an objective criterion is prescribed based on the age of the individual in question which involves ascertaining and establishing whether he or she is under eighteen years of age, if so, such person would be considered a ‘child’ for the purposes of any offence in respect of such child that is punishable under the POCSO – Further, under the unamended Section 15, there was only one criteria for ascertaining whether the material in [2024] 10 S.C.R. 161Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. question can be regarded as ‘child pornography’ or not, which was by establishing that the material depicts or involves a person who is under the age of eighteen years – “child pornography” was specifically defined after the 2019 Amendment Act meaning any visual depiction of a child involved in any sexually explicit conduct wherein the expression ‘visual depiction’ is inclusive in nature – Further, “but appear to depict a child” lays down the test or criteria for ascertaining, whether any of the mentioned visual depiction is a ‘child pornography’ or not, by prescribing a prima facie subjective satisfaction that the material appears to depict a child – The use of the comma before the words “but appear to depict a child” is significant which is used both as a disjunctive and a conjunctive to the words preceding it – It has been used as a disjunctive to stress, that the subjective criteria that the material in question appears to depict a child is not inextricably linked or limited to just one category of visual depictions i.e., the last category being “image created, adapted, or modified” – At the same time, it has been used as a conjunctive in relation to all types of visual depictions that have been illustrated in the said provision, to clearly indicate, that this subjective criterion applies to the entire provision i.e., to all types of visual depictions mentioned therein or in other words to ‘child pornography’. [Paras 126-130] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.30 – Culpable mental state under – Presumption mandatory yet, rebuttable:
Held: The statutory presumption of culpable mental state on the part of the accused as envisaged under Section 30 of the POCSO can be made applicable provided the prosecution is able to establish the foundational facts necessary to constitute a particular offence under the POCSO that may have been alleged against the accused – Such presumption can be rebutted by the accused either by discrediting the prosecution’s case or by leading evidence to prove the contrary, beyond a reasonable doubt – The standard prescribed for rebutting the said statutory presumption of culpable mental state is beyond a reasonable doubt. [Paras 156, 222] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.30 – Statutory presumption of culpable mental state under – Reasons therefor, stated – Principle of Foundational Facts: Held: Statutory presumption of culpable mental state is in view of the exigency posed by the difficulty that exists in establishing certain 162 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports types of offences such as inchoate offences due to its clandestine nature – Such presumptions are in essence an exception to the cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence that the act does not make a person guilty unless the mind is also guilty – Before the statutory presumption of culpable mental state could be validly invoked, the prosecution must first establish certain foundational facts beyond a reasonable doubt – Initial burden always lies on the prosecution – Thus, the establishment of foundational facts by the prosecution is a prerequisite for triggering the statutory presumption for shifting the onus on the accused to prove the contrary – It is a delicate balance struck between the practical need for such presumption in law and the cardinal principles of criminal jurisprudence to ensure that the presumption does not cross or transgress the fine line that demarcates presumption of ‘culpable mental state’ from the ‘presumption of guilt’ itself – Even if the prosecution establishes such foundational facts and the presumption is raised against the accused, he can rebut the same either by discrediting prosecution’s case as improbable or absurd or could lead evidence to prove his defence, in order to rebut the presumption, however the said presumption under Section 30 of the POCSO will be said to have been rebutted only where the accused by way of his defence establishes a fact contrary to the presumption and proves the same beyond a reasonable doubt. [Paras 166, 171, 172, 174] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15(1), (2), (3) – Statutory presumption of culpable mental state for offence u/s.15 – Necessary foundational facts to be established for invocation thereof:
Held: For the purpose of sub-section (1), the foundational facts that the prosecution may have to first establish is the storage or possession of any child pornographic material and that the person accused had failed to delete, destroy or report the same – In order to invoke the statutory presumption of culpable mental state for an offence under sub-section (2), the prosecution would be required to first establish the storage or possession of any child pornographic material, and also any other fact to indicate either the actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution of any such material or any form of an overt act such as preparation or setup done for the facilitation of the transmission, propagation, display or distribution of such material, whereafter it shall be presumed by the court that the said act was done with the intent of transmitting, displaying, propagating or distributing such material and that the [2024] 10 S.C.R. 163Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. said act(s) had not been done for the purpose of either reporting or for use as evidence – Further, for the purpose of sub-section
(3) the prosecution must establish the storage or possession of such material and further prove any fact that might indicate that the same had been done to derive some form of gain or benefit or the expectation of some gain or benefit. [Para 222] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.30 – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.482 – Presumption u/s.30, if can be resorted to in a quashing proceeding – Two videos depicting children involved in a sexual activity were recovered from the mobile phone of respondent no.1accused – FIR alleged offences u/ss.14(1) of the POCSO and 67B of the IT Act, however, in the chargesheet, the offence u/s.14(1) of the POCSO was substituted and instead offence u/s.15(1) of the POCSO was alleged – Criminal proceedings quashed by High Court – Correctness:
Held: There is no bar for the High Court to invoke the statutory presumption at the stage of deciding the quashing petition in respect to any offence to which such a presumption is applicable – The statutory presumption envisaged under Section 30 of the POCSO is applicable and can be invoked in any proceeding which involves an offence under the said Act that requires a culpable mental state, irrespective of the court where such proceeding is taking place – Once the investigation is over and chargesheet is filed, the FIR pales into insignificance – Child pornographic material that was recovered from the personal mobile phone of the accused which was regularly in use by him, which prima facie establishes the storage or possession of child pornographic material – Further, since the aforesaid child pornographic material was found to have been stored in the said personal mobile phone since 2016 and 2019, prima facie there was a failure on his part to delete, destroy or report such material – High Court failed to advert to Section 15 of the POCSO especially when the chargesheet had already been filed at the time of passing of the Impugned Order and erred in quashing the criminal proceedings – In view of the statutory presumption of culpable mental state being attracted, any defence of the accused such as the absence of knowledge or intention would be a matter of trial – Absence of culpable mental state has to be established before the trial court by leading cogent evidence in that regard, such defences should not be looked into at this stage – Impugned judgment set aside, criminal proceedings restored. [Paras 185, 193, 201, 203, 221, 261] 164 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.482 – Duty of High Court – Quashing of criminal proceedings, when justified – Discussed.
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.15 – Ignorance of law vis-à-vis incognizance of law – Ignorance of law, when can be used as a valid defence – Plea of the accused that he was unaware that storing of child-pornography was a punishable offence under Section 15 of POCSO along with the bona-fide belief that such storage was not an offence: Held: Rejected – For a plea of ignorance of law, the ignorance or mistake of law must be such which legitimately gives rise to a bona-fide belief of the existence of a right or a claim, and the said person commits any act on the strength of such right or claim – Even if a person is unaware that the possession or storage of such material is punishable, it by no stretch can be considered to give rise to any right or assertion as there exists no such right to either store or possess such material, and thus it is not a valid defence – No person of an ordinary prudent mind with the same degree of oblivion or unawareness as to the law, more particularly Section 15 of POCSO could as a natural corollary be led to a belief of existence of a right to store or possess any child pornographic material – The ignorance or unawareness must have a reasonable nexus with the right or assertion claimed i.e., the ignorance or unawareness must be such which could legitimately and reasonably give rise to a corresponding right or claim and the existence of which must be bona-fidely believed – Thus, even if the accused was unaware about Section 15 of POCSO, this by itself does not give rise to a corresponding legitimate or reasonable ground to believe that there was any right to store or possess child pornographic material – As such the four-prong test for a valid defence is not fulfilled and the defence of ignorance of law by the accused fails – Even otherwise, one must be mindful to the fact that such a plea is not a statutory defence with any legal backing, but rather a by-product of the doctrine of equity – Unawareness or incognizance of law should not be conflated with ignorance of law. [Paras 212, 214, 217] Suggestions by Court – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – Suggestions made to Ministry of Women and Child Development, Union of India:
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 165Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. Held: The term “child pornography” is a misnomer that fails to capture the full extent of the crime – Each case of what is traditionally termed “child pornography” involves the actual abuse of a child, the use of the term “child pornography” trivializes the crime, as pornography is often seen as a consensual act between adults – It undermines the victimization because the term suggests a correlation to pornography- conduct that may be legal, whose subject is voluntarily participating in, and whose subject is capable of consenting to the conduct – The term “child sexual exploitation and abuse material”(“CSEAM”) more accurately reflects the reality that these images and videos are not merely pornographic but are records of incidents, where a child has either been sexually exploited and abused or where any abuse of children has been portrayed through any self-generated visual depiction – CSEAM rightly places the emphasis on the exploitation and abuse of the child, highlighting the criminal nature of the act and the need for a serious and robust response – Courts forbidden from using the term “child pornography” and instead the term CSEAM should be used in judicial orders and judgements of all courts across the country – Parliament should consider to amend the POCSO for substituting the term “child pornography” with “child sexual exploitation and abuse material” (CSEAM) – Further, though, there is a tangible difference between the act of viewing CSEAM and the act of engaging in sexual abuse of children, yet the latter desire is always inherent in the former – Need for and importance of positive age-appropriate sex education emphasized – Implementation of comprehensive sex education programs – Impact of CSEAM on victims; need for legal, social, therapeutic support to the victims and rehabilitation programs for the offenders, stated – These services should include psychological counselling, therapeutic interventions and educational support to address the underlying issues and promote healthy development – For those involved in viewing or distributing child pornography, CBT has proven effective in addressing the cognitive distortions that fuel such behaviour – Raising awareness about the realities of child sexual exploitative material and its consequences through public campaigns can help reduce its prevalence – Identifying at-risk individuals early and implementing intervention strategies for youth with problematic sexual behaviours (PSB) involves several steps and requires a coordinated effort among various stakeholders, including schools, educators, healthcare providers, law enforcement, and child welfare services – Union of India may consider constituting an Expert 166 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Committee for devising a comprehensive program or mechanism for health and sex education, as well as raising awareness about the POCSO among children – Obligation of the appropriate government and the commission under Section(s) 43 and 44 of the POCSO does not end at just spreading awareness about the provisions of the POCSO – Their efforts must go beyond just the textual wording of the said provisions and to earnestly take into account the pragmatic necessities for curtailing the issue of child abuse, exploitation and addiction to pornography – Collective responsibility of the society u/s.19, 20 of the POCSO, specified – Parliament to consider amending Section 15(1) of POCSO to make it more convenient for the general public to report by way of an online portal, any instance of storage or possession of CSEAM to the specified authorities for the purpose of the said provision. [Paras 227-229, 248, 260] Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – Information Technology Act, 2000 – ss.2(w), 79 – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Rules, 2020 – Role and obligations of “intermediaries”:
Held:Significance of role of “intermediaries” as defined under Section 2(w) of the IT Act in checking the proliferation of child pornography; obligation on the intermediaries under Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Rules, 2020, enumerated – Social media intermediaries in addition to reporting the commission or the likely apprehension of commission of any offence under POCSO to the National Centre for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) are also obligated to report the same to authorities specified under Section 19 of POCSO – Courts to refrain from showing any leniency or leeway in offences under Section 21 of the POCSO, particularly to schools/educational institutions, special homes, children’s homes, shelter homes, hostels, remand homes, jails, etc. who fail to discharge their obligation of reporting the commission or the apprehension of commission of any offence or instance of child abuse or exploitation under the POCSO – Section(s) 19, 20 and 21 of the POCSO are mandatory in nature, and there can be no dilution of the salutary object and purport of these provisions – In view of the the mandatory character of Sections 19 and 20 of the POCSO read with Rule 11 of the POCSO Rules, an intermediary cannot claim exemption from the liability under Section 79 of the IT Act for any third-party information, data, or communication link made available or hosted by it, unless due diligence is conducted [2024] 10 S.C.R. 167Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. by it and compliance is made of these provisions of the POCSO – Such due diligence includes not only removal of child pornographic content but also making an immediate report of such content to the concerned police units in the manner specified under the POCSO Act and the Rules thereunder. [Paras 254-256, 258-260] Words and Phrases – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.2(da) – “child pornography”;
‘Possession’, ‘Constructive Possession’; ‘Immediate Control’ u/s.15 – Concept.
Case Law Cited Chandi Kumar Das Karmarkar v. Abanidhar Roy AIR (1965) SC 585; Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P. [1979] 2 SCR 641 : (1979) 2 SCC 409 - held inapplicable.
Independent Thought v. Union of India & Anr. [2017] 13 SCR 821 : (2017) INSC 1030; Attorney General for India v. Satish [2021] 10 SCR 955 : (2021) INSC 762; Eera through Dr. Manjula Krippendorf v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) & Anr. [2017] 7 SCR 924 : (2017) INSC 658; Nawabuddin v. State of Uttarakhand [2022] 1 SCR 1083 : (2022) INSC 162; Sharat Babu Digumarti v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi [2016] 8 SCR 1015 : (2017) 2 SCC 18; State of M.P. v. Harsh Gupta (1998) 8 SCC 630; Prakash Nath Khanna v. CIT [2004] 2 SCR 434 : (2004) 9 SCC 686; R. Kalyani v. Janak C. Mehta & Ors. [2008] 14 SCR 1249 : (2009) 1 SCC 516; Rathis Babu Unnikrishnan v. The State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) & Anr. [2022] 4 SCR 989 : (2022) INSC 480; R.P. Kapur v. State of Punjab AIR (1960) SC 866; State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal (1992) AIR SC 604; S.M. Datta v. State of Gujarat [2001] Supp. 2 SCR 140 :(2001) 7 SCC 659; National Spot Exchange Ltd. v. Anil Kohli, Resolution Professional for Dunar Foods Ltd. [2021] 7 SCR 1024 : (2022) 11 SCC 761; M. Siddiq v. Mahant Suresh Das (2020) 1 SCC 1; Shankar Kisanrao Khade v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 6 SCR 949 : (2013) 5 SCC 546; State of Maharashtra & Anr. v. Maroti [2022] 8 SCR 821 : (2023) 4 SCC 298 – relied on.
Bhanabhai Khalpabhai v. Collector of Customs [1994] 2 SCR 348 : (1994) Supp. (2) SCC 143; Devchand Kalyan Tandel v. State of Gujarat [1996] Supp. 4 SCR 382 : (1996) 6 SCC 255; State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh [1999] 3 SCR 977 : (1999) 6 SCC 172; Seema Silk Sarees v. Directorate of Enforcement [2008] 8 SCR 201 : (2008) 5 SCC 580; Noor Aga v. State of Punjab & Anr. [2008] 168 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 10 SCR 379 : (2008) 16 SCC 417; Bhola Singh v. State of Punjab [2011] 2 SCR 642 : (2011) 11 SCC 653; Baldev Singh v. State of Haryana [2015] 12 SCR 969 : (2015) 7 SCC 554 – referred to. Nupur Ghatge v. State of Madhya Pradesh (MCRC No. 52596 of 2020); P.G. Sam Infant Jones v. State represented by Inspector of Police (2021) SCC OnLine Mad 2241; Ajin Surendran v. State of Kerala & Anr. (2022) KER 7207; Manuel Benny v. State of Kerala (2022) KER 9730; Lakshya v. State of Maharashtra & Anr. (Criminal Writ Petition No. 479 of 2022); Shantheeshlal T. v. State of Kerala (2024) KER 35968; Akash Vijay v. State of Kerala (2024) KER 42626; Akhil Johny v. State of Kerala (2024) KER 53767; Inayathulla N (1) v. State (2024) KHC 26513; Inayathulla N (2) v. State (2024) KHC 28204 – referred to.
U.S. v. Tucker 150 F. Supp. 2d 1263 (D. Utah. 2001); U.S. v. Romm 455 F. 3d. 990 (9th Cir., 2006); Regina v. Michael Land (1997) EWCA Crim J1010-15; John Leadbetter v. Her Majesty’s Advocate (2020) HCJAC 51; United States v. Katz 178 F.3rd 368 (5 th Cir. 1999); Commonwealth v. Robert (829 A.2d. 127) – referred to. Books and Periodicals cited 50th Report of the Standing Committee on Information Technology on the ‘Information Technology (Amendment) Bill, 2007; Eva J. Klain, Heather J Davies, Molly A. Hicks Et. Al., Child Pornography: The Criminal Justice-System Response, 8 (Penn State University Press, 2001); Philip Jenkins, Beyond Tolerance: Child Pornography on the Internet (New York University Press, 2003); Burgess, Ann W. & C.R. Hartman, Child Abuse Aspects of Child Pornography, 7 PSYCHIATRIC ANNALS, 248 (1987); Audrey Rogers, The Dignity Harm of Child Pornography – From Producers to Possessors, in Carissa Byrne Hessick (Eds.), Refining Child Pornography Law – Crime, Language and Social Consequences (University of Michigan Press, 2016); Tali Gal, Child Victims and Restorative Justice – A Needs Rights Model, 17 (Oxford University Press, 2011); Jonah R. Rimmer, Child Sexual Exploitation, (Oxford Research Encyclopaedia Criminology, 2024); Mary Graw Leary, The Language of Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation, in Carissa Byrne Hessick (Eds.), Refining Child Pornography Law – Crime, Language and Social Consequences (University of Michigan Press, 2016); Danijela Frangež, Anton Toni Klančnik, Mojca Žagar Karer Et. Al., The Importance of Terminology Related to Child Sexual [2024] 10 S.C.R. 169Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. Exploitation, 66(4) REV. ZA. KRIM. KRIMINOL. 291 (2015); Kathryn C. Seigfried Spellar & Virginia Soldino, Child Sexual Exploitation: Introduction to a Global Problem, in Thomas J. Holt & Adam M. Bossler (Eds.); The Palgrave Handbook of International Cybercrime and Cyberdeviance, (Palgrave Macmillian, Cham, 2020); Vaughn I. Rickert & Owen Ryan, Is the Internet the Source, 40 J. ADOLESC. HEALTH 104 (2007); Dr. Ethel Quayle, Assessment issues with young people who engage in problematic sexual behaviour through the Internet, in M.C. Calder (Ed.), New Developments with young people who sexually abuse (Russel House Publishing, Lyme Regis, UK, 2007); Matthew L Long, Laurence A. Alison & Michelle A McManus, Child pornography and likelihood of contact abuse: a comparison between contact child sexual offenders and noncontact offenders, 25(4) SEX ABUSE, 370 (2013); Dr. Ethel Quayle Et. Al., The role of sexual images in online and offline sexual bheaviour with minors, 17(6) CURR. PSYCHIATRY REP. 1 (2019); Melissa Hamilton, The Child Pornography Crusade and Its Net- Widening Effect, 33 CARDOZO L. REV. 1694 (2012); Esposito & Lesli C., Regulating the Internet: The Battle Against Child Pornography, 30 CASEW. RES. J. INT’L. L. 5 (1998); Jason S. Carrol Et Al., Generation XXX, Pornography Acceptance and Use Among Emerging Adults, 23 J. ADOLESCENT RES. 6 (2008); Clare McGlynn & Dr. Hannah Bows, Possessing Extreme Pornography: policing, prosecutions and the need for reform, 83(6) J. CRIM. LAW., 473 (2019); Dr. Ethel Quayle, Lars Loof and Tink Palmer, Child Pornography and Sexual Exploitation of Children Online, 64 (ECPAT International, 2008); Michael C. Seto, Kailey Roche, Nicole C Rodrigues Et. Al., Evaluating Child Sexual Abuse Perpetration Prevention Efforts: A Systematic Review, 33 J. CHILD SEX. ABUS. 22 (2024); Paul G. Cassel, James Marsh & Jeremy M. Christiansen, The Case for Full Restitution for Child Pornography Victims, 82 GEO. WASH. L. REV. 61 (2013); Padminin Iyer & Peter Aggleton, Seventy years of sex education – A Critical Review, 74(1) HEALTH EDUC. J. 3 (2015); Udaan Adolescent Education Program by the Centre for Catalyzing Change in Jharkhand in India; Cortney Lollar, Child Pornography and the Restitution Revolution, 103 J. CRIM. L. & CRIMINOLOGY 343 (2013); Jagdish Khubchandani, Jeffrey Clark & Raman Kumar, Beyond Controversies: Sexuality Education for Adolescents in India, 3(3) J. FAMILY MED. PRIM. CARE. 175 (2014) – referred to.
170 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012; Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019; Information Technology Act, 2000; Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008; Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Rules, 2020. List of Keywords Section 15 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012; Section 67B of the Information Technology Act, 2000; POCSO; Child pornography; Child; Pornographic content; Child pornographic material; Child sexual exploitation; Child sexual abuse; Exploitation and abuse of children; Use of obscene/ pornographic material through electronic means; Online sexual denigration and exploitation of children; Cyber-offences relating to children; Videos showing children involved in a sexual activity; Statutory presumption of culpable mental state; Quashing; Storage or possession; Mere storage or possession; Intangible possession; Constructive possession; “Deleted, destroyed, reported”; Failure or omission to report; Transmission; Propagation; Display or distribution; Foundational facts; Marginal note; Commercial purpose; Inchoate offence; Mens-rea; Culpable mens-rea; Requisite mens rea; Intention; Actus reus; Purposive interpretation; “Subjective satisfaction” criteria; Ignorance of Law; Incognizance of Law; Suggestions by Court; Due diligence; Intermediaries; “Child Sexual Exploitation and Abuse Material”(CSEAM).
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 2161- 2162 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.01.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in CRLOP No. 37 of 2024 and CRLMP No. 79 of 2024 Appearances for Parties H.S. Phoolka, Sr. Adv., Jagjit Singh Chhabra, Bhuwan Ribhu, Ms. Rachna Tyagi, Saksham Maheshwari, Ms. Shashi, Ms. Taruna Panwar, Ms. Tanvi Chaudhry, Advs. for the Appellants.
Ms. Swarupama Chaturvedi, Sr. Adv., Prashant S. Kenjale, Amol Nirmalkumar Suryawanshi, Ms. Srishty Pandey, Ashutosh Chaturvedi, M/s. Juristrust Law Offices, Abhaid Parikh, Ms. Katyayani Anand, Ms. Saumya Kapoor, Aayush Shivam, D. Kumanan, Sheikh F. Kalia, Advs. for the Respondents.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 171Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.:
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts: - INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX........................................................................... 4 B. IMPUGNED ORDER....................................................................... 10 C. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES................................................ 16 i. Submissions on behalf of the Appellants............................. 16 ii. Submissions on behalf of the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR).................................... 18 iii. Submissions on behalf of the respondent no. 1 / the Sole Accused................................................................................... 20 iv. Submissions on behalf of the respondent nos. 2 & 3 / the State......................................................................................... 22 D. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION.................................................... 24 E. ANALYSIS........................................................................................ 25 i. Relevant Statutory Scheme and Provisions....................... 25 a. Legislative History and Scheme of the POCSO................ 25 b. Relevant Provisions of the IT Act....................................... 38 ii. Scope of Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act................................................................................. 40 a. Contradictory Views of different High Courts on the subject.. 40 b. Three distinct offences punishable under Section 15 of the POCSO.......................................................................... 55 I. Concept of an Inchoate Crime – The ‘Actus Reus’ and ‘Mens Rea’ required under Section 15................. 60 II. Concept of ‘Possession’, ‘Constructive Possession’ and ‘Immediate Control’ under Section 15 of the POCSO........................................................................ 78 c. Pornographic Material must prima facie appear to involve a Child................................................................................... 86 d. Scope of Section 67B of the IT Act.................................... 95 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
172 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports iii. Presumption of Culpable Mental State under Section 30 of the POCSO.......................................................................... 108 a. Concept of Statutory Presumption and Principle of Foundational Facts............................................................ 110 b. Foundational Facts required under Section 15 of the POCSO............................................................................... 126 c. Whether the Presumption under Section 30 of the POCSO can be resorted to in a Quashing Proceeding?................ 130 iv. Whether the case at hand was one fit for the High Court to quash?................................................................................ 141 a. Plea of Ignorance of Law: Ignorance of Law viz-a-viz Incognizance of Law.......................................................... 147 v. Summary of our conclusion.................................................. 161 F. FEW MEANINGFUL SUGGESTIONS............................................. 167 i. The Lingering Impact of Child Pornography on the Victimization & Abuse of Children....................................... 167 a. Obligation to report under Section(s) 19 & 20 respectively of the POCSO and Role of the Society and all Stakeholders... 180 ii. Suggestions to the Union of India and to the courts......... 195 G. FINAL ORDER................................................................................. 198
1. Since the issues raised in both the captioned appeals are same and the challenge is also to a self-same judgment and order passed by the High Court those were taken up for hearing analogously and are being disposed of by this common judgment and order.
2. The present appeals arise out of the final judgment and order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Madras dated 11.01.2024 in Criminal Original Petition (Crl. O.P.) No. 37 of 2024 (“Impugned Order”) filed by the respondent no. 1 (accused) herein under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, the “Cr.P.C.”) by which the High Court allowed the petition and thereby quashed the chargesheet dated 19.09.2023 filed for the offences punishable under Section 67B of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (for short, the “IT Act”) and Section 15(1) of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (for short, the “POCSO”) arising out of the FIR No. 03 of 2020, P.S. Ambattur, Chennai. As a consequence, the criminal proceedings in Special Sessions Case No. 170 of 2023 stood terminated.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 173Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
3. It may be necessary to clarify that the appellant no. 1 herein, ‘Just Rights for Children Alliance’ is a collation comprising of five different NGOs that work in unison against child trafficking, sexual exploitation and other allied causes. Whereas the appellant no. 2 is a child rights organization working towards protecting children from exploitation and one of the partner NGOs to the aforesaid collation. The appellants herein were not a party to the proceedings before the High Court. However, having regard to the serious issue of public importance involved in the matter they sought leave of this Court to challenge the impugned judgment of the High Court. The respondent nos. 2 & 3 are the State of Tamil Nadu and the Inspector of Police, All-Women’s Police Station Ambattur, Chennai, respectively.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
4. On 29.01.2020, the All-Women’s Police Station Ambattur, Chennai, Tamil Nadu i.e., the respondent no. 3 herein, received a letter from the Additional Deputy Commissioner of Police (Crime against women and children Branch) wherein it was mentioned that as per the Cyber Tipline Report of the National Crimes Record Bureau (NCRB), the respondent no. 1 herein is an active consumer of pornography and has allegedly downloaded pornographic material involving children in his mobile phone.
5. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid letter an FIR was registered against the respondent no. 1 herein on the very same day i.e., 29.01.2020 at the All-Women’s Police Station Ambattur, Chennai, Tamil Nadu as Crime No. 03 of 2020 for the offence punishable under Section(s) 67B of the IT Act and 14(1) of the POCSO. The relevant portion of the FIR reads as under: - “Today on 29.01.2020 at 12.00 noon, I, the Inspector of W28, All Women Police Station was on duty, received letter RC. No. 03/ADC CWC/West/Camp/2020 dated 28.01.2020 from Thirumathi S. Megalina, Additional Deputy Commissioner of Police, Prevention of Crimes against Women and Children Division, Chennai, West Zone.
On perusal of the same, 4 References were mentioned therein viz.
Ref: 1. DO.Lr.No.05/ADGP-CWC/NCMEC/2020
2. C. No.30/COP/CO/2020 174 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
3. R.C. No. 228 VIII/DC CWC/Genl/2020 (CTR No. 49303278)
4. RC No. 68 /Japu – ii/NCMEC/2020 As per the notice issued in CTR No. 49303278 by National Crime Record Bureau, it is seen that Harris, resident of Door No.2, 1st Main Road, VPC Nagar, Kallikuppam, Ambattur, Mobile No. 99406 87836, has for the past more than two years, been watching child pornographic films. Details have also been obtained with regard to child pornographic films which were made by using children who have been exploited, children who have gone missing, and by collecting information from centres which deal with missing children, and details have been provided with regard to the persons who have downloaded such child pornographic films. When those notices were perused, it was seen that the above said person had downloaded those films through Old Site ID-KALLI/OLD/ Chm ID-CHM2307, with a view to indulge in sexual activities, and these films were made at the address ‘Gopalsamy, No.2, Gangai Amman Kovil 3rd Main Road, Kallikuppam, Ambattur’ by exploiting children in this area. Since this bad activity is a crime against good social order, it was directed to take appropriate action against the said person, and therefore, Crime No. 03/2020 U/S 67B IT ACT r/w 14(1) POCSO Act 2012 was registered, and the original FIR has been sent to the concerned Court of learned Judicial Magistrate, and copies have been sent to the concerned superior officers of police without any delay, and investigation has been taken up.
13. Action Taken: Since the above information reveals commission of offence(s) u/s as mentioned at Item No. 2, registered the case and took up the investigation.
FIR read over to the complainant/Informant, admitted to be correctly recorded and a copy given to the Complainant/ Informant free of cost.”
6. During the course of the investigation, the mobile phone belonging to the respondent no. 1 was seized and sent to the Forensic Science [2024] 10 S.C.R. 175Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. Laboratory for analysis. The respondent no. 1 was also questioned whether he had ever viewed any pornographic content, to which the respondent no. 1 admitted that he used to regularly view pornography while he was in college.
7. As per the Computer Forensic Analysis Report dated 22.08.2020 it was found that the mobile phone of the respondent no. 1 contained two video files relating to child pornography depicting two underage boys involved in sexual activity with an adult woman. The Computer Forensic Analysis Report further stated that more than hundred other pornographic video files were downloaded and stored in the said mobile phone. The relevant portion of the said Computer Forensic Analysis Report reads as under: - “COMPUTER FORENSIC ANALYSIS REPORT Received from : The Sessions Judge, Mahalir Neethi Mandram, (Fast Track Mahila Court) Tiruvallur.
Crime No. & P.S. : 03/2020 of Ambattur AWPS Organization Report No. : CF/52/2020 Case received Date : 28.02.2020 Case received through : WHC 43450, Tmt. Poornima Seals status : Correct & Intact Nature of crime : 67(B) IT Act and 14(1) of POCSO Act 2012 Tools used : UFED 4 PC.
Report date : 22.08.2020 Head of the Division : A. Visalakshi, M.Sc, PGDCA Examiner : S. Hemalatha, M.Sc., (FS), M.Sc., (CS)
RECEIVED DEVICE DESCRIPTION
One (1) sealed cloth-lined paper parcel marked, “PI No. 5/2020. Cr. No. 3/2020, Ambattur AWPS …” containing the following item:
Marked as Name of the Item received Details of the Item Packing / Labelling details 176 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 1 Mobile phone
SIM 1
Memory Card Battery Make: MOTO Model: XT 1804
IMEI1: 356477088126073
IMEI2: 356477088126081
Airtel 4G 128K
ICCID:
8991000902533662473U Strontium 16 GB Inbuilt Kept in a plastic box marked, “PI No:
05/2020”.
Objective The above item was examined with a view to find if there is any facility of viewing video files using YouTube application and the details. And also to find if any media files pertaining to pornography were found accessed/downloaded/saved.
EXAMINATION
Mobile Phone : [MOTO] The internal memory of the mobile phone was acquired using file system extraction and examined using the forensic software tool “UFED 4 PC”. The retrieved details such as contacts, call logs, SMS messages and media files are generated as a report and the report (in pdf) is copied on to a Compact Disc marked as “CF 52/20”. Selected pages from the report are given as Annexure-I. Some of the findings from the report are as follows: - [...] [...] Above findings indicated that the mobile phone was found to be equipped with the facility of viewing videos through YouTube Application.
4. (a) Video files pertaining to pornography (more than 100 Nos.) were found downloaded and stored in different paths, the details of the same are given as Annexure – II. [...]
(b) Some of the vide files pertaining to pornographic nature were found stored under the path “Motorola GSM_XT1806 MotoG5SPlus.zip/sdcard/ProgramData/ Android/Language/.fr/Videos/wat up pono”. [...] [2024] 10 S.C.R. 177Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
(c) Under the same path two video files which could be accounted for Child Pornography content were found stored. In the videos boys (under-teen) were found involved in sexual activity with a adult woman/girl. The details of the same are pasted below: - S. No. File Info Additional File Info
1. Name: VID-20190614-WA0006.
mp4 Path: Motorola GSM_XT1806 MotoG5SPlus.zip/sdcard/ ProgramData/Android/Language/.
fr/Videos/wat up pono/ VID- 20190614-WA0006.mp4 Size (bytes): 11256288 Modified:
6/14/2019 15:44 (UTC +5:30)
2. Name: Unmayal sollungal Ennodu sellungal with Vadivel Balaji in AIE 4-8-2012 – Youtube.3GP Path: Media/Internal shared storage/trending/adhu idu/Unmayal sollungal Ennodu sellungal with Vadivel Balaji in AIE 4-8-2012 – Youtube.3GP Size (bytes): 20467994 Modified:
9/5/2016 23:12 (UTC +5:30)
[...] Memory Card: [Strontium 16 GB] The memory card was acquired and examined using the forensic software tool “UFED 4 PC”. The retrieved details such as document, image and video files are generated as a report and the report (in pdf) is copied on to a Compact Disc marked as “CF 52/20”. The full report is given as Annexure-III.
On perusing the medial files, multiple video snapshot images and video files were found related to pornography. The representative samples of the same are copied onto the CD mentioned earlier under a specified folder. [...]”
8. Upon completion of the investigation, chargesheet dated 19.09.2023 was filed against the respondent no. 1 for the offences punishable under Section(s) 67B of the IT Act and 15(1) of the POCSO 178 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports respectively. It may not be out of place to state at this stage, that although the FIR was registered for the offence punishable under Section 14(1) of the POCSO yet in light of the materials collected in the course of the investigation and the findings recorded in the Computer Forensic Analysis Report, the chargesheet was ultimately filed for the offence punishable under Section 15(1) of the POCSO. The relevant portion reads as under: - “Final Report Before the Hon’ble Mahila Fast Track Mahila Court, Tiruvallur Police Final Report under 173(i) W28 Ambattur All Women Police Station Crim no- 3/2020 U/s 67(B) IT ACT & 14 (1) of POCSO ACT 2012 @67 (B) IT ACT 15(1) of POCSO ACT 2012. [...] Nature of the case Mrs. Megallina, Additional Deputy Commissioner of Police, Women and Child Crime Branch, Chennai, West Zone LETTER RC.NO. 03/ADC CWC/West/Camp/2020 Dated:
28.01.2020 in that mentioned Ref: 1. Do. Lr. No. 05/ ADGP- CWC/ camp/ NCMEC/ 2020, 2. C.No.30/ COP/ CO/ 2020, 3. R.CNO. 228 VIII/ DC CWC/ Genl/ 2020 (CTR No.
49303278), 4. RC.No. 68/ japu- ii/ NCMEC/ 2020 as per the detail, Haris residing at 1st Main Road, Door No.03, VPC Nagar, Kallikuppam, Ambattur has reported to NCRB (National Crime Record Bureau) that he had seen child pornography on his mobile phone number 99406 87836 for more than two years at CTR No. 49303278 has been obtained and a report on child exploitation and missing persons and details of those who have downloaded child pornography against children banned by the data collection system has been obtained. Aforesaid person OLD Size ID- KALLI 4/OLD Chm Id- CHM2307 Downloaded from the address No.2 Gopalsamy, 3rd Main Road, Gangaiyamman Temple, Ampathur, Kallikuppam, with the malicious intention of viewing children’s pornographic films for sexual purposes. As this evil act is considered to be a crime of disturbance of social morals, after being instructed to [2024] 10 S.C.R. 179Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. take appropriate action against the said person, the All Women Police Station registered a case in CRIME NO.
03/20 U/ S 67B IT ACT r/ w 14(1) POCSO Act 2012 and the copy of the same was sent to the concerned court and the copies to the higher police officers without delay for investigation. [...] In the investigation conducted so far, crime scene no. 2, VPC Nagar to Main Road Kallikuppam Ambattur, Chennai is within the jurisdiction of Ambattur All Women Police Station. On 28.01.2000 Additional Deputy Commissioner, Women and Child Prevention Division, Chennai West Zone gone through the case received from (NCMEC) According to the National Center for Exploited Children in this case accused Harish AGE 24/S/o. Santhanam No. 2 VPC Nagar First Main Road Kallikuppam Ampathur Chennai has been using his phone number ( 99406 87836) for more than two years from his mobile phone number OLD Size ID- KALLI 4/OLD Chm Id- CHM2307 Downloaded from the address No.2 Gopalsamy, 3rd Main Road, Gangaiyamman Temple, Ampathur, Kallikuppam, with the malicious intention of viewing children’s pornographic films for sexual purposes As this evil act is considered to be a crime of disturbance of social morals, as per CTR NO 49303278 a report of the crime has been received by NCRB.
Therefore, the accused in this case is considered to have committed an offense of disturbing public morals and therefore has committed a cognizable offense under Section 67 (B) IT ACT & 15 (1) of the POCSO Act 2012. [...]”
B. IMPUGNED ORDER
9. Aggrieved by the aforesaid, the respondent no. 1 went before the High Court of Judicature at Madras by way of a quashing petition being the Criminal Original Petition (Crl. O.P.) No. 37 of 2024 for the purposes of getting the aforesaid chargesheet and the criminal proceedings arising therefrom quashed.
10. The impugned judgment of the High Court is in three-parts. In other words, the High Court quashed the criminal proceedings essentially on three grounds: - 180 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(i) First, the High Court was of the view that to constitute an offence under Section 14(1) of POCSO, a child must have been used by the person accused for pornographic purposes. It observed that although the two videos depicting children engaged in a sexual activity were found to have been downloaded and stored in the mobile phone belonging to the respondent no. 1, and assuming that the accused had watched the same yet the same would not constitute an offence under Section 14(1) of the POCSO. The relevant observations read as under: - “9. To make out an offence under Section 14(1) of Protection of Child from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, a child or children must have been used for pornography purposes. This would mean that the accused person should have used the child for pornographic purposes.
Even assuming that the accused person had watched child pornography video, that strictly will not fall within the scope of Section 14(1) of Protection of Child from Sexual Offences Act, 2012. Since he has not used a child or children for pornographic purposes, at the best, it can only be construed as a moral decay on the part of the accused person.”
(ii) Secondly, the High Court held that, to constitute an offence under Section 67B of the IT Act, the person accused must have published, transmitted or created material depicting children in sexually explicit act or conduct. It held that although the respondent no. 1 had admitted that he was addicted to watching pornography, yet mere watching or downloading of child pornography without any transmission or publication of the same does not fall within the purview of Section 67B of the IT Act. The relevant portion reads as under: - “6. This Court enquired the petitioner and he stated that his date of birth is 13.11.1995 and that he has an elder brother. After a lot of persuasion, the petitioner admitted that during his teens, he had the habit of watching pornography. However, the petitioner made it clear that he had never watched child pornography.
That apart, he also stated that he had never attempted to publish or transmit any of the pornographic [2024] 10 S.C.R. 181Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. materials to others. He had merely downloaded the same and he had watched pornography in privacy.
xxx xxx xxx
10. In order to constitute an offence under Section 67-B of Information Technology Act, 2000, the accused person must have published, transmitted, created material depicting children in sexual explicit act or conduct. A careful reading of this provision does not make watching a child pornography, per se, an offence under Section 67-B of Information Technology Act, 2000. Even though Section 67-B of Information Technology Act, 2000, has been widely worded, it does not cover a case where a person has merely downloaded in his electronic gadget, a child pornography and he has watched the same without doing anything more.”
(iii) Lastly, the High Court in light of its aforesaid discussion and by placing reliance on Section 292 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, the “IPC”) took the view that although the pornographic content was found to have been downloaded and stored in the mobile phone of the respondent no. 1 yet in the absence of any material to show that the respondent no. 1 had transmitted or published the same, no offence whatsoever could be said to have been made out either under the POCSO, IT Act or the IPC and thus quashed the criminal proceedings. The relevant observations read as under: - “8. This Court had the advantage of going through the entire CD file. The mobile phone that was seized from the petitioner did contain pornographic materials. However, for the purposes of this case, only two videos were identified as child pornography. Those two videos contain boys (under teen) involved in sexual activity with an adult woman/girl. Admittedly, those two videos were downloaded and available in the mobile phone belonging to the petitioner and it was neither published nor transmitted to others and it was within the private domain of the petitioner.
xxx xxx xxx 182 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
11. The Kerala High Court had an occasion to deal with the scope of Section 292 IPC. That was a case where a person was caught watching porn videos and a First Information Report came to be registered against him. While dealing with this issue, the Kerala High Court held that, watching an obscene photo or obscene video by a person by itself will not constitute an offence under Section 292 IPC. This is in view of the fact that this act is done by the concerned person in privacy without affecting or influencing anyone else. The moment the accused person tries to circulate or distribute or publicly exhibits obscene photos or videos, then the ingredients of the offence starts kicking in.
11. Thus, the High Court vide its impugned judgment and order dated 11.01.2024 allowed the petition and thereby quashed the criminal proceedings in Spl. S.C. No. 170 of 2023 on the ground that no offence could be said to have been made out against the respondent no. 1 either under Section 14(1) of the POCSO or Section 67B of the IT Act. The operative portion of the Impugned Order reads as under: - “12. In the considered view of this Court, the materials that have been placed before this Court does not make out an offence against the petitioner under Section 67-B of Information Technology Act, 2000 and Section 14(1) of Protection of Child from Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
xxx xxx xxx
18. In the light of the above discussion, the continuation of the proceedings against the petitioner will amount to abuse of process of Court. That apart, it will be a stumbling block for the petitioner’s career in future. Therefore, this Court is inclined to quash the proceedings in Spl.S.C.No.170 of 2023 on the file of the Sessions Judge, Mahila Neethi Mandram (Fast Track Court), Tiruvallur District.
Accordingly, this Criminal Original Petition stands allowed and the proceedings in Spl.S.C.No.170 of 2023 on the file of the Sessions Judge, Mahila Neethi Mandram (Fast Track Court), Tiruvallur District, is hereby quashed. Consequently, connected criminal miscellaneous petition is closed.”
(Emphasis supplied)
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 183Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
12. From the aforesaid it could be said that the High Court laid down three propositions of law which are as follows: i. Mere possession or storage of any pornographic material is not an offence under the POCSO. We are mindful of the fact that, whilst endorsing the aforesaid proposition of law, the High Court in its impugned Order either consciously did not deem it necessary to refer to Section 15 of the POCSO or inadvertently failed to refer to Section 15 of the POCSO. Nevertheless, in either case that may be, the aforesaid proposition of law found favour with the High Court.
ii. Section 67B of the IT Act only makes the act of transmission, publication or creation of material depicting children in sexually explicit manner an offence. Mere watching or downloading of child pornography in private domain is not punishable under the same.
iii. In the absence of any material to indicate any transmission or publication of pornographic content involving child, no offence could be said to have been committed under the POCSO or the IT Act, and the criminal proceedings would be liable to be quashed. In other words, to attract the provisions of the POCSO or the IT Act it is not sufficient to merely establish storage or possession of child pornography and that transmission or publication of the same is also required to be established. In the absence of the same the criminal proceedings are liable to be quashed.
13. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellants being aggrieved with the Impugned Order passed by the High Court have come up before this Court with the present appeal.
C. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
i. Submissions on behalf of the Appellants.
14. Mr. H.S. Phoolka, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants submitted that the interpretation of the relevant provisions of POCSO by the High Court for the purpose of holding that mere storage or possession of any child pornographic material does not amount to an offence, poses a significant threat to the well-being of children and may result in proliferation of child pornography, posing a significant threat to the very social fabric of the society at large. 184 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports In support of his submissions, Mr. Phoolka relied on the Convention on Cybercrime and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989.
15. He further submitted that the chargesheet filed by the investigating agency specifically records that, as per the information received from the National Commission for Missing and Exploited Children, USA (NC-MEC), the accused had been watching child pornographic videos for the past two years.
16. He further contended that the High Court erroneously proceeded under Section 14(1) of the POCSO, which deals with the use of children for pornographic purposes, without giving due consideration to Section 15(1) of the Act.
17. He further submitted that Section 15(1) explicitly penalizes the downloading and failure to delete child pornography. In the present case, the respondent’s stance that he had received two files containing child pornography via WhatsApp is falsified by the NC-MEC report. Furthermore, there is nothing on record to substantiate that the videos were received on WhatsApp.
18. It was further argued that the High Court committed a serious error in quashing the criminal proceedings without addressing itself on Section 15 of the POCSO. He submitted that the impugned judgment poses a significant threat to child welfare and is contrary to several national and international commitments.
19. He further submitted that the High Court also failed to distinguish between adult pornography and child pornography, as Sections 67 and 67A of the IT Act deal with adult pornography, while Section 67B was specifically introduced in 2009 to provide more stringent punishment for collecting, downloading, or watching child pornographic material.
20. He further submitted that in view of Section 30 of the POCSO the High Court was legally obliged to presume the existence of a culpable mental state on the part of the accused for having committed any offence under the Act that requires such a mental state.
21. In the last, Mr. Phoolka submitted that a conjoint reading of Section 67B of the IT Act, Section 15, and Section 30 of the POCSO leaves no manner of doubt as regards the culpability of persons in possession of child pornography.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 185Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. ii. Submissions on behalf of the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR).
22. Ms. Swarupama Chaturvedi, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR), submitted that there was a serious lapse on the part of the State in failing to register the FIR for the offence punishable under Section 15 of the POCSO, 2012, as the possession of pornographic material involving a child in any form by itself is an offence under Section 15(1) of the Act. It was also argued that the State as a Prosecuting agency failed in its duty to bring it to the notice of the High Court that chargesheet was ultimately filed for the offence under Section 15(1) of the POCSO & not Section 14.
23. She further submitted that the accused had downloaded pornographic material involving a child onto his mobile phone, retained possession of it, and failed to take any steps to delete the same for two years, as mandated under Section 19 of the POCSO, 2012.
24. She contended that the High Court failed to appreciate the mandate of Section 30, which raises a presumption of a culpable mental state on the part of the accused for any offence under the Act that necessitates such a mental state. The provision, therefore, shifts the burden of proving the absence of a culpable mental state onto the accused.
25. She would further submit that Section 19 of the POCSO imposes mandatory reporting of an offence under the Act if there was an apprehension that such offence is likely to be committed or knowledge that such an offence has been committed. It was pointed out that the failure to discharge this obligation by itself is punishable under Section 21 of the POCSO. She pointed out that the social media platforms claim to report such instances to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC), a US-based NGO, which then reports them to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB). However, Section 19 mandates reporting such cases to the Special Juvenile Police Unit (SJPU) or the Special Police. Therefore, reporting to an NGO cannot absolve the social media platforms of its liability under Section 21 of the POCSO.
26. In the last, it was submitted that the issue as regards the plight of minors involved or used in child pornography is a matter of serious 186 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports concern for one and all. She prayed for issuance of appropriate directions. She submitted that in an age when children require internet access for educational purposes, it has become imperative to provide them with a safe online environment in accordance with Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC).
iii. Submissions on behalf of the respondent no. 1 / the Sole Accused.
27. Mr. Prashant S. Kenjale, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent no. 1 / the accused, submitted that the FIR was lodged for the offence under Section 14(1) of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act, and thus, no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned order.
28. He further submitted that the date of the receipt of the videos recovered from the mobile phone of the respondent no. 1 phone is 14.06.2019, at which point the 2019 amendment to Section 15 was not yet in force.
29. He further contended that the two files found from the Respondent’s phone were named (a.) VID-20190614-WA005.mp4 and (b.) VID- 20190823-WA0020.mp4. The use of “WA” in the file names indicates that they were automatically downloaded by WhatsApp, which has an auto-download feature, as shown in a research study. He would submit that in such circumstances, the said videos had been automatically downloaded onto his phone and that the respondent no. 1 was unaware of their existence. He argued that the forensic evidence clearly indicates both the creation and modification date as 14.06.2019, thereby indicating that the files were never accessed.
30. He further submitted that the mere possession of the aforesaid videos does not constitute an offence under Section 15(1) of the POCSO, as the respondent never had any intention to share or distribute them. He also argued that even if it is assumed that the respondent no. 1 had watched the said videos once and then failed to delete it, he cannot be charged under Section 15(1) of the POCSO, as he was unaware of its presence due to the government’s failure to publicize the law.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 187Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
31. He submitted that ignorance of law on the part of the respondent no. 1 was accompanied by a bona fide belief, and as such it would not constitute an offence under Section(s) 15 of the POCSO and 67B of the IT Act. In support of this argument, he placed reliance on the decisions of this Court in Chandi Kumar Das Karmarkar v. Abanidhar Roy, reported in AIR 1965 SC 585, and Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P., reported in (1979) 2 SCC 409. iv. Submissions on behalf of the respondent nos. 2 & 3 / the State.
32. Mr. D. Kumanan, the learned Counsel appearing for the State, submitted that the High Court, whilst passing the Impugned Order proceeded on an erroneous footing that an offence under Section 14 of the POCSO had been alleged against the accused, eventhough both the chargesheet as-well as the quashing petition clearly mentioned that the indictment against the accused was under Section 15(1) of the POCSO.
33. He further submitted that the High Court in its Impugned Order failed to look into Section 67B of the IT Act. The High Court whilst quashing the criminal proceedings neither discussed nor gave any due consideration to Section 67B, eventhough chargesheet had been filed for an offence under it.
34. It was submitted that both Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act had been enacted with the salutary object of curtailing child abuse by penalizing any form of use of child pornography, including watching of such pornographic content in order to tackle the larger problem of creation and dissemination of such material by the perpetrators.
35. He submitted that more than hundred pornographic videos were found stored in the mobile phone of the respondent no. 1 / accused herein. Furthermore, the accused had himself admitted before the High Court that he along with his friends would regularly watch such pornographic material. In such circumstances it was argued that the accused had stored such material in his phone with the intention of sharing it with his friends.
36. It was further submitted that the marginal note of Section 15 of the POCSO i.e. “Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child” is self-explanatory and that sub-section (1) of the 188 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports said provision punishes the storage or possession of any such pornographic material when done with an intention to share or transmit it. Reliance was placed on Section 30 of the POCSO to argue that the said provision specifically provides for presumption of a culpable mental state on part of the accused for any offence under the Act which requires such mental state, and as such the onus was on the accused to prove that he had no intention to share the material that was found stored in his phone, which was also overlooked by the High Court.
37. In the last, it was submitted that once the chargesheet and the other materials on record prima-facie disclosed the commission of an offence, more particularly the pornographic videos that were found stored in the mobile phone of the accused, it was not proper for the High Court to exercise its inherent powers under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C to quash the criminal proceedings.
D. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
38. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the following questions of law fall for our consideration: - I. What is the scope of Section 15 of the POCSO? In other words, what is the underlying distinction between sub-section(s) (1),
(2) and (3) respectively of the POCSO?
II. Whether, mere viewing, possessing or storing of any child pornographic material is punishable under the POCSO?
III. What is the true scope of Section 67B of the IT Act? IV. What is the scope of Section 30 of the POCSO? In, other words, what are the foundational facts necessary for invoking the statutory presumption of culpable mental state in respect of Section 15 of the POCSO?
V. Whether, the statutory presumption contained in Section 30 of the POCSO can be invoked only at the stage of trial by the Special Court alone established under the POCSO? In other words, whether it is permissible for the High Court in a quashing petition filed under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. to resort to the statutory presumption of culpable mental state contained in Section 30 of the POCSO?
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 189Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
E. ANALYSIS
i. Relevant Statutory Scheme and Provisions.
a. Legislative History and Scheme of the POCSO.
39. Before adverting to the rival submissions canvassed on either side, it would be apposite to first look into the statutory scheme and refer to the relevant provisions of the POCSO.
40. As the long title, ‘Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012’ suggests, the POCSO was enacted by the Parliament to address the urgent need for a comprehensive law to protect children from sexual abuse and exploitation.
41. Sexual exploitation of children is a pervasive and deeply rooted issue that has plagued the societies worldwide and has been a matter of serious concern in India. Prior to the enactment of the POCSO, India lacked a specific legal framework dedicated to dealing with sexual offenses against children. While the provisions related to sexual offenses existed in the IPC, they were not adequately tailored to address the unique vulnerabilities and the needs of children.
42. The inadequacy of the existing laws to effectively deal and combat with the sexual abuse of children was starkly evident. The IPC, though equipped to handle sexual offences, did not explicitly recognize the various forms of sexual abuse that children might face. Under the IPC there was no distinction between an adult and a child victim for the purposes of the offences punishable under the Code nor did it account for the specific psychological and developmental needs of such child victims. Moreover, the procedural laws were not childfriendly, often resulting in secondary victimization during the legal process. The increasing incidence of child sexual abuse in India and the growing awareness of the long-term psychological impact on the victims underscored the need for a dedicated law. The POCSO was introduced to fill this gap and provide a robust legal mechanism to safeguard children from sexual crimes and protect them from offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography.
43. The Statement of Objects and Reasons for the enactment of the POCSO makes it abundantly clear that since the sexual offences against children were not adequately addressed by the existing laws and a large number of such offences were neither specifically 190 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports provided for nor were they adequately penalized, the POCSO has been enacted to protect the children from the offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography and to provide for establishment of Special Courts for trial of such offences and for matters connected therewith and incidental thereto.
44. It further states that the POCSO is a ‘self-contained comprehensive legislation’ for the purpose of enforcing the rights of all children to safety, security and protection from sexual abuse and exploitation countered through commensurate penalties as an effective deterrence for sexual offences and pornography and has been enacted keeping in mind Articles 15 and 39 of the Constitution respectively and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Children. The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the POCSO reads as under: - “STATEMENT OF OBJECTS AND REASONS Article 15 of the Constitution, inter alia, confers upon the State powers to make special provision for children. Further, Article 39, inter alia, provides that the State shall in particular direct its policy towards securing that the tender age of children are not abused and their childhood and youth are protected against exploitation and they are given facilities to develop in a healthy manner and in conditions of freedom and dignity.
The United Nations Convention on Rights of Children, ratified by India on 11th December,1992, requires the State Parties to undertake all appropriate National, By-lateral and Multi lateral measures to prevent (a) the inducement or coercion of a child to engage in any unlawful sexual activity; (b) the exploitative use of children in prostitution or other unlawful sexual practices; and (c) the exploitative use of children in pornographic performances and materials. The data collected by the National Crime Records Bureau shows that there has been increase in cases of sexual offences against children. This is corroborated by the ‘study on child abuse: India 2007’ conducted by the Ministry of Women and Child Department. Moreover, sexual offences against children are not adequately addressed by the extent laws. A large number of such offences are neither [2024] 10 S.C.R. 191Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. specifically provided for nor are they adequately penalized. The interests of the child, both as a victim as well as a witness, need to be protected. It is felt that offences against children need to be defined explicitly and countered through commensurate penalties as an effective deterrence.
It is, therefore, proposed to enact a self-contained comprehensive legislation inter-alia to provide for protection of children from the sexual offences and pornography with due regard for safeguarding the interest and well being of the child at every stage of the Judicial process, incorporating child friendly procedures for reporting, recording of evidence, investigation and trial of offences and provision for establishment of Special Courts for speedy trial of such offences.
(Emphasis supplied)
45. The primary legislative intent behind the enactment of the POCSO was to create a comprehensive legal framework that would not only punish offenders but also provide a child-friendly system for the recording of evidence, investigation, and trial of offenses. The POCSO was designed to cover all forms of sexual abuse against children, including sexual harassment, child pornography, and aggravated sexual assault, among others. It aimed to ensure the safety and dignity of child victims during the legal process, with specific provisions that mandate in-camera trials, the presence of a trusted adult during the proceedings, and the prohibition of aggressive questioning of child victims.
46. The POCSO is a manifestation of the unique scheme formed by Article(s) 15 and 39 respectively of the Constitution and the obligation cast by the United Nations Convention on Rights of Children that was ratified by India. Article 15 more particularly sub-article (3) read with Article 39(f) of the Constitution i) enables the State to make special provisions for children AND ii) at the same time obligates the State to direct its policy towards ensuring that the tender and vulnerable age of children is not exploited or abused and to secure a dignified and healthy childhood and youth, free from any moral or material abandonment or exploitation. The UN Convention on Rights of Children prescribes a set of standards that have to be ensured 192 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports by all State parties including India to secure the best interest of the child and to specifically undertake preventive measures against any form of exploitation of children such as prostitution, unlawful sexual activity or pornographic performances and depictions. The POCSO is a legislative manifestation towards realization of these constitutional provisions, by providing a specialized framework to combat and prevent any and all forms of sexual abuse and exploitation as stated in its long Preamble. The relevant portion of the long Preamble of the POCSO reads as under: - “An Act to protect children from offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography and provide for establishment of Special Courts for trial of such offences and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. Whereas clause (3) of article 15 of the Constitution, inter alia, empowers the State to make special provisions for children;
And whereas, the Government of India has acceded on the 11th December, 1992 to the Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted by the General Assembly of the United Nations, which has prescribed a set of standards to be followed by all State parties in securing the best interests of the child;
And whereas it is necessary for the proper development of the child that his or her right to privacy and confidentiality be protected and respected by every person by all means and through all stages of a judicial process involving the child;
And whereas it is imperative that the law operates in a manner that the best interest and well being of the child are regarded as being of paramount importance at every stage, to ensure the healthy physical, emotional, intellectual and social development of the child;
And whereas the State parties to the Convention on the Rights of the Child are required to undertake all appropriate national, bilateral and multilateral measures to prevent – [2024] 10 S.C.R. 193Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
(a) the inducement or coercion of a child to engage in any unlawful sexual activity;
(b) the exploitative use of children in prostitution or other unlawful sexual practices;
(c) the exploitative use of children in pornographic performances and materials;
And whereas sexual exploitation and sexual abuse of children are heinous crimes and need to be effectively addressed.”
47. Section 2(1) sub-clause (d) of the POCSO defines the term “child” to mean any person below the age of eighteen years. Thus, the definition of the term “child” used under the POCSO is denuded of any gender i.e., the term is both gender neutral and gender fluid and as such will include any person who is below the age of 18-years. The relevant provision reads as under: - “2. Definitions. –
(1) In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires, –
(d) “child” means any person below the age of eighteen years;”
48. Section 2(1)(da) defines the term “child pornography” to mean and include any visual depiction of a child involved in any sexually explicit conduct such as photograph, video, image generated digitally or by a computer which is indistinguishable from an actual child i.e., any self-generated image of an actual child or any other image that has been created, adapted or modified, that appears to depict a child. The relevant provision reads as under: - “2. Definitions. –
(1) In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires, –
(da) “child pornography” means any visual depiction of sexually explicit conduct involving a child which include photograph, video, digital or computer generated image indistinguishable from an actual child and image created, adapted, or modified, but appear to depict a child;”
194 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
49. Section 15 of the POCSO delineates and provides when the storage or possession of pornographic material involving a child shall be a punishable offence under the POCSO and further prescribes the punishment for such storage or possession of pornographic material involving a child. The relevant provision reads as under: - “15. Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child. –
(1) Any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child, but fails to delete or destroy or report the same to the designated authority, as may be prescribed, with an intention to share or transmit child pornography, shall be liable to fine not less than five thousand rupees and in the event of second or subsequent offence, with fine which shall not be less than ten thousand rupees.
(2) Any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child for transmitting or propagating or displaying or distributing in any manner at any time except for the purpose of reporting, as may be prescribed, or for use as evidence in court, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.
(3) Any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child for commercial purpose shall be punished on the first conviction with imprisonment of either description which shall not be less than three years which may extend to five years, or with fine, or with both and in the event of second or subsequent conviction, with imprisonment of either description which shall not be less than five years which may extend to seven years and shall also be liable to fine.”
50. It would be worthwhile to note that Section 15 of the POCSO had undergone a significant change by virtue of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 (for short, the “2019 Amendment Act”), whereby several key changes were introduced. We shall discuss the said provision viz-à-viz the unamended provision of Section 15 along with the object and purpose behind the 2019 Amendment Act in more detail in the latter part of this judgment. [2024] 10 S.C.R. 195Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
51. Section 30 of the POCSO provides for the presumption of culpable mental state and provides that where any offence under the POCSO requires a culpable mental state on the part of the accused, the existence of such mental state on the part of the accused shall be presumed by the Special Court, and that it shall be open for the accused to rebut this presumption. In other words, the accused can prove that he had no such mental state with respect to any offence under the Act. The relevant provision reads as under: - “30. Presumption of culpable mental state. –
(1) In any prosecution for any offence under this Act which requires a culpable mental state on the part of the accused, the Special Court shall presume the existence of such mental state but it shall be a defence for the accused to prove the fact that he had no such mental state with respect to the act charged as an offence in that prosecution.
(2) For the purposes of this section, a fact is said to be proved only when the Special Court believes it to exist beyond reasonable doubt and not merely when its existence is established by a preponderance of probability. Explanation. – In this section, “culpable mental state” includes intention, motive, knowledge of a fact and the belief in, or reason to believe, a fact.”
52. This Court in its decision in Independent Thought v. Union of India & Anr. reported in 2017 INSC 1030 held that the preamble to the POCSO recognizes and mandates that the Act and its provisions ought to operate and be interpreted in a manner that would be in the best interest and well-being of the child. It should i) ensure that the sexual exploitation and abuse of children are addressed effectively and ii) induce a healthy physical, emotional, intellectual and social development of the child. The relevant observations read as under: - “42. [...] The Preamble to the POCSO Act also recognizes that it is imperative that the law should operate “in a manner that the best interest and well being of the child are regarded as being of paramount importance at every stage, to ensure the healthy, physical, emotional, intellectual and social development of the child”. Finally, 196 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the Preamble also provides that “sexual exploitation and sexual abuse of children are heinous crimes and need to be effectively addressed”. [...]”
(Emphasis supplied)
53. In Attorney General for India v. Satish reported in 2021 INSC 762 this Court had the occasion to examine the entire legislative scheme of the POCSO. It held that each provision of the POCSO should be construed viz-a-viz the other provisions of the Act and with reference to the context or background with which the legislation was enacted, so as to make the Act and its provisions more meaningful and effective. This Court further emphasized that, while construing the provisions of the POCSO, the impact of sexual assault and exploitation on the children should not be ignored and further the courts should avoid a narrow or pedantic interpretation that would the defeat the statute; rather, where the intention of the legislature cannot be given effect to or cannot be realized, a meaningful construction of the statute should be adopted to bring about a more effective result. The relevant observations read as under: - “33. [...] As per the rule of construction contained in the maxim “Ut Res Magis Valeat Quam Pereat”, the construction of a rule should give effect to the rule rather than destroying it. Any narrow and pedantic interpretation of the provision which would defeat the object of the provision, cannot be accepted. It is also needless to say that where the intention of the Legislature cannot be given effect to, the courts would accept the bolder construction for the purpose of bringing about an effective result. [...] xxx xxx xxx
37. [...] However, it is equally settled legal position that the clauses of a statute should be construed with reference to the context vis-a-vis the other provisions so as to make a consistent enactment of the whole Statute relating to the subject matter. The Court can not be oblivious to the fact that the impact of traumatic sexual assault committed on children of tender age could endure during their whole life, and may also have an adverse effect on their mental state. The suffering of the victims in certain cases may be immeasurable. Therefore, considering the objects of the [2024] 10 S.C.R. 197Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. POCSO Act, its provisions, more particularly pertaining to the sexual assault, sexual harassment etc. have to be construed vis-a-vis the other provisions, so as to make the objects of the Act more meaningful and effective.”
(Emphasis supplied)
54. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat in his concurring opinion in Attorney General for India (supra) further observed that the POCSO and its nuanced provisions were designed keeping in mind the need to protect the autonomy and dignity of children. It was enacted to criminalize those acts and behaviour that have the propensity to harass, discomfit or demean minors, and as such it is the duty of the courts to ensure that the provisions of the POCSO are not interpreted in a manner that would undermine its purpose or the pressing needs of the times. The relevant observations read as under: - “11. The limitations in law in dealing with acts that undermined the dignity and autonomy of women and children, ranging from behaviour that is now termed “stalking” to pornography, or physical contact, and associated acts, which were not the subject matter of any penal law, were recognized and appropriate legislative measures adopted, in other countries. These have been alluded to in Trivedi, J’s judgment, in detail. These laws contain nuanced provisions criminalizing behaviour that involve unwanted physical contact of different types and hues, have the propensity to harass and discomfit women and minors (including minors of either sex), or demean them.
xxx xxx xxx
33. In the end, I cannot resist quoting Benjamin Cardozo that “the great tides and currents which engulf the rest of men do not turn aside in their course and pass the judges by.” It is, therefore, no part of any judge’s duty to strain the plain words of a statute, beyond recognition and to the point of its destruction, thereby denying the cry of the times that children desperately need the assurance of a law designed to protect their autonomy and dignity, as POCSO does.”
(Emphasis supplied)
198 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
55. Similarly in Eera through Dr. Manjula Krippendorf v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) & Anr. reported in 2017 INSC 658, this Court observed that the POCSO had been brought with the purpose of protecting the children from sexual exploitation and harassment. It had been designed to secure the well-being and the best interests of the child with the protection of the child’s dignity being the backbone of the legislation. The dignity, protection and interest form the bedrock of the POCSO. The relevant observations read as under: - “18. The purpose of referring to the Statement of Objects and Reasons and the Preamble of the POCSO Act is to appreciate that the very purpose of bringing a legislation of the present nature is to protect the children from the sexual assault, harassment and exploitation, and to secure the best interest of the child. On an avid and diligent discernment of the preamble, it is manifest that it recognizes the necessity of the right to privacy and confidentiality of a child to be protected and respected by every person by all means and through all stages of a judicial process involving the child. Best interest and well being are regarded as being of paramount importance at every stage to ensure the healthy physical, emotional, intellectual and social development of the child. There is also a stipulation that sexual exploitation and sexual abuse are heinous offences and need to be effectively addressed. The statement of objects and reasons provides regard being had to the constitutional mandate, to direct its policy towards securing that the tender age of children is not abused and their childhood is protected against exploitation and they are given facilities to develop in a healthy manner and in conditions of freedom and dignity. There is also a mention which is quite significant that interest of the child, both as a victim as well as a witness, needs to be protected. The stress is on providing child-friendly procedure. Dignity of the child has been laid immense emphasis in the scheme of legislation.
Protection and interest occupy the seminal place in the text of the POCSO Act.
xxx xxx xxx [2024] 10 S.C.R. 199Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
63. [...] The POCSO Act, as I have indicated earlier, comprehensively deals with various facets that are likely to offend the physical identity and mental condition of a child. The legislature has dealt with sexual assault, sexual harassment and abuse with due regard to safeguard the interest and well being of the children at every stage of judicial proceeding in an extremely detailed manner. The procedure is child friendly and the atmosphere as commanded by the provisions of the POSCO Act has to be congenial. The protection of the dignity of the child is the spine of the legislation. [...]”
(Emphasis supplied)
56. In Nawabuddin v. State of Uttarakhand reported in 2022 INSC 162 this Court held that any act of sexual assault, exploitation or harassment of the children should be dealt with in a stringent manner and that no leniency should be shown when dealing with an offence under the POCSO in view of the object that is sought to be achieved by the Act. The relevant observations read as under: - “10. Keeping in mind the aforesaid objects and to achieve what has been provided under Article 15 and 39 of the Constitution to protect children from the offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment, the POCSO Act, 2012 has been enacted. Any act of sexual assault or sexual harassment to the children should be viewed very seriously and all such offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment on the children have to be dealt with in a stringent manner and no leniency should be shown to a person who has committed the offence under the POCSO Act. By awarding a suitable punishment commensurate with the act of sexual assault, sexual harassment, a message must be conveyed to the society at large that, if anybody commits any offence under the POCSO Act of sexual assault, sexual harassment or use of children for pornographic purposes they shall be punished suitably and no leniency shall be shown to them. Cases of sexual assault or sexual harassment on the children are instances of perverse lust for sex where even innocent children are not spared in pursuit of such debased sexual pleasure.”
(Emphasis supplied)
200 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports b. Relevant Provisions of the IT Act.
57. For better and effective adjudication of the issues involved in the case at hand, it would be apposite to refer to the IT Act which also contains several provisions, more particularly Section(s) 67, 67A and 67B respectively, that penalize the use, transmission and publication of obscene materials including child pornography. These provisions together encompass and collectively form the umbrella scheme of comprehensive penal provisions contained in the IT Act in this regard.
58. Section 67 of the IT Act is the principal provision that criminalizes the publication or transmission of “obscene material” in any electronic form and constitutes an offence. Section 67A of the IT Act, is a more aggravated offence, prescribing enhanced punishment than the preceding provision. It does so by further amplifying the scope of ‘obscene material’ by stipulating that any obscene material that contains or depicts any sexually explicit act or conduct, when published or transmitted shall be punishable under the said provision.
59. Section 67B of the IT Act specifically deals with child pornographic materials. It provides for an even more severe form of offence by bringing within its ambit those obscene materials in any electronic form that depict a child in any sexually explicit act or conduct and by further expanding the scope of ‘actus reus’ which is punishable under the provision to include not just publication or transmission but also the browsing, creation, collection, online facilitation or enticement of children into any sexual act or conduct etc. The said provision reads as under: - “67B. Punishment for publishing or transmitting of material depicting children in sexually explicit act, etc., in electronic form. — Whoever —
(a) publishes or transmits or causes to be published or transmitted material in any electronic form which depicts children engaged in sexually explicit act or conduct; or
(b) creates text or digital images, collects, seeks, browses, downloads, advertises, promotes, exchanges or distributes material in any electronic form depicting children in obscene or indecent or sexually explicit manner; or
(c) cultivates, entices or induces children to online relationship with one or more children for and on sexually [2024] 10 S.C.R. 201Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. explicit act or in a manner that may offend a reasonable adult on the computer resources; or
(d) facilitates abusing children online; or
(e) records in any electronic form own abuse or that of others pertaining to sexually explicit act with children, shall be punished on first conviction with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to five years and with a fine which may extend to ten lakh rupees and in the event of second or subsequent conviction with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years and also with fine which may extend to ten lakh rupees:
Provided that provisions of Section 67, Section 67-A and this section does not extend to any book, pamphlet, paper, writing, drawing, painting, representation or figure in electronic form—
(i) the publication of which is proved to be justified as being for the public good on the ground that such book, pamphlet, paper, writing, drawing, painting, representation or figure is in the interest of science, literature, art or learning or other objects of general concern; or
(ii) which is kept or used for bona fide heritage or religious purposes.
Explanation. — For the purpose of this section, “children” means a person who has not completed the age of 18 years.”
ii. Scope of Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act.
60. In the case at hand, we are concerned with the interpretation of Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act, more particularly the scope of these two provisions and what would constitute an offence under each of them. In other words, what exactly has been made punishable under Section(s) 15 of the POCSO and 67B of the IT Act respectively and what are the necessary ingredients or elements to establish or make out an offence under it.
202 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports a. Contradictory Views of different High Courts on the subject.
61. Before proceeding with the analysis of the aforesaid two provisions, it would be appropriate to refer to the decisions of various High Courts and the cleavage of opinion that have been expressed as regards the scope of Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act.
62. In Nupur Ghatge v. State of Madhya Pradesh (MCRC No. 52596 of 2020), the accused therein was alleged to have uploaded child pornographic videos and photographs on his social media account, and thus, a case was registered against him under Section 67B of the IT Act. The Gwalior Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court held that Section 67B penalizes various forms of acts including the act of watching or transmitting any child pornographic material in electronic form. It further held that any defence of the accused as to the absence of any involvement in transmission or sharing of such material or the mental state of the accused cannot be looked into at the stage of quashing under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. The relevant observations read as under: - “From the whats-app chats filed by the applicant, it appears that the applicant himself was involved in porn activities, therefore, the provision of Section 67B of the Act, 2000 would be applicable as Section 67-B of the Act, 2000 also includes records in any electronic form own abuse or that of others pertaining to sexually explicit act with children. xxx xxx xxx The burden is on the applicant to prove his defence which cannot be decided by this Court in exercise of powers under Section 482 of CrPC.”
63. In P.G. Sam Infant Jones v. State represented by Inspector of Police reported in 2021 SCC OnLine Mad 2241 the accused therein was alleged to have browsed, downloaded and transmitted child pornographic material through his e-mail and social media account. Accordingly, a case was registered against him for the offences under Section 15(1) of POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act, whereupon the accused therein preferred an anticipatory bail application before the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court. The Madras High Court observed that while viewing of pornography in private domain may not be an offence in view of an individual’s [2024] 10 S.C.R. 203Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. right to expression and privacy, child pornography falls outside the ambit of such individual rights and stands on a different footing. It held that Section 67B penalizes various kinds of acts pertaining to child pornography including the act of viewing such material. The relevant observations read as under: - 3.The case of the prosecution is that on 27.06.2020 at 17.38:51 hours, the petitioner browsed, downloaded and transmitted child pornographic material by using Airtel Sim bearing No.9787973370 through his e-mail and Facebook Account.
xxx xxx xxx
5. Viewing pornography privately will not constitute an offence. Offence is an act that is forbidden by law and made punishable. That is the definition found in Section 40 of IPC. As on date, there is no provision prohibiting such private acts. There are some who even elevate it as falling within one’s right to free expression and privacy. But child pornography falls outside this circle of freedom. Section 67-B of the Information Technology Act, 2000 penalises every kind of act pertaining to child pornography. [...] Therefore, even viewing child pornography constitutes an offence.
(Emphasis supplied)
64. In Ajin Surendran v. State of Kerala & Anr. reported in 2022 KER 7207 child pornographic videos were found stored in the mobile phone of the accused therein. The High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam observed that Section 15 of POCSO gets attracted when any person stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child, with an intention to share or transmit it, whereas Section 67B of the IT Act gets attracted when a person browses or downloads any such material in any electronic form. Accordingly, it held that in view of the videos that were found stored in the accused’s mobile phone, prima-facie both of the aforesaid provisions are said to be squarely attracted, and thus the power under Section 482 cannot be invoked for quashing the criminal proceedings. The relevant observations read as under: - 204 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports “3. I have gone through the first information statement as well as the final report. It would show that the mobile phone belongs to the petitioner and the sim card was examined and it was found that in the memory card, pornographic video of children were stored. Section 15 of POCSO Act gets attracted when any person stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child, with an intention to share or transmit child pornography. Section 67B(b) of the IT Act gets attracted when a person among other things, browses or downloads material in any electronic form depicting children in obscene or indecent or sexually explicit manner. Thus, both the sections are squarely attracted. When prima facie case is made out, power under Section 482 cannot be invoked.”
(Emphasis supplied)
65. In Manuel Benny v. State of Kerala reported in 2022 KER 9730 it was found that the accused person therein had downloaded and stored pornographic videos depicting children in a sexually explicit manner in his mobile phone from a messaging app; ‘Telegram’ for private viewing. Accordingly, a case was registered against the accused therein under Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act. When the final report came to be filed, the offence under Section 15 of the POCSO was dropped, and chargesheet was filed only for the offence under Section 67B of the IT Act. The accused preferred a quashing petition before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam on the ground that even if the materials in the chargesheet were taken at their face value, no ingredients were made out to constitute the offence under Section 67B of the IT Act. A learned Single Judge of the High Court whilst quashing the criminal proceedings held that in order to attract the offence under Section 67B of the IT Act, the pornographic material in question must be voluntarily downloaded. It held that there should be an intention on the part of the accused to download any pornographic content in order to view it so as to constitute an offence under Section 67B of the IT Act. The learned Single Judge further observed that as per the FSL report, the child pornographic videos had been accessed through the messaging app ‘Telegram’ wherein there is a possibility of automatic download of videos. Since there was no material to show that the accused therein had voluntarily downloaded or browsed the pornographic material in [2024] 10 S.C.R. 205Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. question, no prima facie offence had been made out under Section 67B of the IT Act, and thus the High Court quashed the criminal proceedings. The relevant observations read as under: - “5. A perusal of the final report would show that the only allegation against the petitioner is that he downloaded and enjoyed material depicting children in obscene, indecent and sexually explicit manner from the application called ‘Telegram’. In order to attract the offence under Section 67B of the IT Act, the videos or material has to be voluntarily downloaded into any device. In other words, there should be intention on the part of the petitioner to download the material in order to view it. The definite case of the petitioner is that he did not download any offensive material. Even in Annexure A3 FSL report it is seen that the path of those images is from Android backup and the child pornographic videos were accessed through ‘Telegram’. The learned Additional DGP submitted that the contents transmitted in the ‘Telegram’ can be automatically downloaded in the mobile phone by default. Hence, it cannot be said that the petitioner has intentionally downloaded the material, considering the features of the ‘Telegram’ App.
Since there is no material to show that the petitioner has browsed or downloaded child pornographic material, the offence under Section 67B of the IT Act is not attracted. Hence, no purpose will be served in proceedings with the matter further. Accordingly, the Crl.M.C is allowed. All further proceedings pursuant to Annexure A2 final report in Crime No.531/2020 of Melukavu Police Station now pending as C.C.No.257/2021 on the files of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Erattupetta stands hereby quashed.”
(Emphasis supplied)
66. In Lakshya v. State of Maharashtra & Anr. (Criminal Writ Petition No. 479 of 2022), the accused therein had viewed and stored a child pornographic video in his mobile, which he subsequently showed to his other friends and co-accused therein. On the basis of the aforesaid, a case was registered against the accused persons under Section(s) 15(1) and (3) of the POCSO along with Section 67B of the 206 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports IT Act. The accused preferred a discharge application which came to be rejected by the Trial Court whereafter the accused therein went in appeal before the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Nagpur Bench. The learned Single Judge of the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the rejection of the discharge application by the Trial Court. The High Court held that merely because the accused therein was not the creator of the pornographic material in question it cannot be said that no offence had been made out. It held that the act of the accused to store and forward the pornographic material and the failure on his part to delete or report the same would squarely fall within the ambit of Section(s) 15(1) and (2) of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act. However, the High Court chose not to advert to the offence under Section 15(3) of the POCSO that was contained in the chargesheet as a prima facie case had already been established against the accused therein for the other offences with which they were charged. The relevant observation reads as under: - “8. With the assistance of the learned Advocate for the accused and the learned APP for the State, I have gone through the provisions of Section 67-B of the I. T. Act and Section 15 of the POCSO Act. The main allegation against the accused is that they stored, forwarded and shared with each other porn video. Even if it is assumed for the sake of argument that they are not creators of the porn video, in my view, the benefit of discharge cannot be granted to them. [...]
9. In my view, perusal of Section 15 of the POCSO Act in entirety would show that the act of the accused persons to store, forward and possess pornographic material involving a child is squarely covered under Section 15(1) and (2) of the POCSO Act. They failed to delete or destroy or report the same to the designated authority. As per the case of the prosecution, they stored, possessed and circulated the said porn video. Therefore, in my view, at this stage, it is very difficult for the accused to come out of the tentacles of Section 15(1) and (2) of the POCSO Act.
10. Section 67-B of the I.T. Act provides a punishment for publishing or transmitting the material depicting children in Sexually explicit act, etc., in an electronic form. If the [2024] 10 S.C.R. 207Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. basic ingredient of Section 67-B, prima facie, are applied to the facts of the case on hand, it would show beyond doubt that the act of the accused is squarely covered within the ambit of Section 67-B of the I. T. Act. In my view, in the teeth of the allegations against the accused and the material collected during the course of investigation and compiled in the charge-sheet, it would be very difficult to accept the contention of the accused persons. It is true that the applicants are young. They are students. They are from reputed family. However, while deciding the discharge application this could not be the consideration. If this submission is accepted on this ground then this would be nothing short of showing misplaced sympathy to the persons who are prima facie accused of the commission of offence.”
(Emphasis supplied)
67. In Shantheeshlal T. v. State of Kerala reported in 2024 KER 35968, during investigation certain pornographic videos involving a child had been recovered from the device of the accused thereunder. Accordingly, chargesheet was submitted against the accused therein for the offences punishable under Section(s) 15(1) of the POCSO and 67B of the IT Act. The accused thereunder preferred a quashing petition before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, wherein the learned Single Judge quashed the aforesaid chargesheet and the criminal proceedings taking the view as under: -
(i) First, the learned Single Judge held that in order to attract the provision of Section 15(1) of the POCSO there must be a storage or possession of child pornographic material and further such material should be shown to have been shared or transmitted by the person accused. Mere possession or storage of pornographic material by itself is not an offence under Section 15(1) of the POCSO unless it is shown that the accused person had indeed shared or transmitted such material. In other words, to constitute an offence under Section 15(1) there must be an actual act of transmission or sharing of the pornographic material depicting a child in a sexually explicit act or conduct that was found to be stored or in possession of the accused. The relevant observation reads as under: - 208 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports “9. Reading the provision, it is emphatically clear that storing or possessing pornographic materials in any form involving a child and failure to delete or destroy or report the same to the designated authority, as may be prescribed, with an intention to share or transmit child pornography, shall be an offence. So mere storing or possessing pornographic material is not an offence under Section 15(1) of POCSO Act, if the said storing or possession is without any intention to share or transmit the same. Therefore, mere storing or possessing pornographic materials by itself is not an offence. Thus, in order to attract an offence under Section 15(1) of the POCSO Act, the stored or possessed pornographic materials should be shared or transmitted. In the instant case, there is no material available to hold that the accused either shared or transmitted pornographic materials, though storing of the same was detected.
Therefore, the offence under Section 15(1) of the POCSO Act is not made out in the instant case.”
(Emphasis supplied)
(ii) Secondly, it observed that, even for the purposes of Section 67B of the IT Act there must be some material to show that the accused person had either browsed, downloaded, published, transmitted or created any material in electronic form depicting a child in a sexually explicit act or conduct. To constitute an offence under Section 67B of the IT Act the accused person must have intentionally either downloaded, browsed, recorded or transmitted a pornographic material involving a child. In the absence of any material to show or establish specific intention on the part of the accused to share or transmit the pornographic material found, no offence could be said to have been made out under Section 67B of the IT Act. Any accidental or automatic download of such material will not fall within the purview of the said provision. The relevant observations read as under: - “11. Publishing, transmitting or causing any material in electronic form which depicts children engaged in sexually explicit act or conduct or creation of text or digital images etc. are the ingredients under Section 67B of the IT Act also. xxx xxx xxx [2024] 10 S.C.R. 209Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
13. Therefore, going by the decision, automatic or accidental downloading of children engaged in sexually explicit act or conduct is not an offence under Section 67B, once the specific intention to do so is not established, by the materials which form part of the prosecution records.
14. In the present case, the materials collected during investigation would show that some pornographic messages, which would depict children engaged in sexually explicit act or conduct were found in the devise of the accused. But there are no materials to show that the petitioner intentionally downloaded or browsed or recorded the same. More particularly there are no materials to show that the petitioner had either shared, transmitted or published the same in any manner.
15. Thus, the materials available do not suggest the ingredients to find prima facie, commission of offence under Section 67B of the IT Act.”
(Emphasis supplied)
As besides the recovery of the pornographic material from the device of the accused there was nothing to show that he had either shared or transmitted or intentionally downloaded the same in the first place. In such circumstances, the learned Single Judge held that no prima facie offence had been made out either under Section(s) 15(1) of the POCSO or 67B of the IT Act and thus, proceeded to quash the criminal proceedings.
68. Similarly, in Akash Vijay v. State of Kerala reported in 2024 KER 42626, the Kerala High Court placing reliance on the decision of Shantheeshlal T (supra) held that mere storage or possession of any pornographic material involving a child will not constitute an offence under Section(s) 15 of the POCSO or 67B of the IT Act in the absence of any material to show that the accused person either intentionally downloaded or browsed the said material or that he shared or transmitted the same. The relevant observations read as under: - “6. On perusal of the prosecution records, no materials collected during investigation to show that the petitioner intentionally downloaded or browsed or recorded the 210 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports same and there are no materials available to show that the petitioner had either shared, transmitted or published the video, in any manner. The allegation is confined to that of presence of porn video in the mobile phone of the accused alone.
xxx xxx xxx
8. Reading the facts of this case, the same is similar to the facts dealt in Shantheeshlal T.’s case (supra).
Therefore, applying the same ratio, this Crl.M.C. is liable to be allowed.”
(Emphasis supplied)
69. In Akhil Johny v. State of Kerala reported in 2024 KER 53767, the learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court held that where the allegations are limited only to the presence of pornographic material involving a child in the mobile phone or hard disk of the accused, no offence could be said to have been made out under Section(s) 15 of the POCSO or 67B of the IT Act and as such the criminal proceedings would be liable to be quashed. The relevant observations read as under: - “6. On perusal of the prosecution records, no materials collected during investigation to show that the petitioner intentionally downloaded or browsed or recorded the same and there are no materials available to show that the petitioner had either shared, transmitted or published the video, in any manner. The allegation is confined to that of presence of porn video in the mobile phone of the accused alone. xxx xxx xxx
8. Reading the facts of this case, the same is similar to the facts dealt in Shantheeshlal T.’s case (supra). Therefore, applying the same ratio, this Crl.M.C. is liable to be allowed.”
(Emphasis supplied)
70. In Inayathulla N (1) v. State reported in 2024 KHC 26513, the accused therein was charged for browsing a website and viewing pornographic materials involving a child. Accordingly, a case was registered against him under Section(s) 67B of the IT Act. A learned Single Judge of the High Court of Karnataka held that the soul and [2024] 10 S.C.R. 211Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. essence of Section 67B lies in the act of publication or transmission of any material depicting a child in any sexually explicit conduct, and that mere browsing or watching of such material would not attract the aforesaid provision. It further held that in such cases even investigation should not be permitted to be continued and thus, proceeded to quash the criminal proceedings. The relevant observations read as under: - “7. [...] Section 67B of the IT Act punishes those persons who would publish, transmit the material depicting children in sexually explicit acts in electronic form. The soul of the provision is publishing or transmitting of material depicting children in sexually explicit act.
8. The allegation against the petitioner is that he has watched a pornographic website. This, in the considered view of the Court, would not become publishing or transmitting of material, as is necessary under Section 67B of the IT Act. At best, as contended, the petitioner could be a porn addict, who has watched pornographic material. Nothing beyond this, is alleged against the petitioner. If the facts are pitted against the ingredients necessary to drive home Section 67B of the IT Act, what would unmistakably emerge is, further proceedings cannot be permitted to be continued, as it would become an abuse of process of law. [...]
9. The Apex Court in the afore laid postulates holds that even if the facts that forms the complaint is accepted as true, it would not make out any offence. In such cases, even investigation should not be permitted to be continued. Therefore, the impugned proceedings cannot be permitted to be continued, as it does not make out an offence under Section 67B of the IT Act.”
(Emphasis supplied)
71. We are conscious of the fact that the aforesaid decision of Inayathulla N (1) (supra) was subsequently taken in review by the learned Single Judge of the Karnataka High Court under the nomenclature “recall” upon realising that Section 67B of the IT Act had been misinterpreted more particularly the failure to advert to sub-section (b) of the said provision which criminalizes the browsing of child pornographic sites. 212 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Consequently, in Inayathulla N (2) v. State reported in 2024 KHC 28204 the learned Single Judge set aside its earlier order in Inayathulla N (1) (supra) by observing that although Section 67B sub-section (a) of the IT Act may not apply in the absence of any transmission or publication of any child pornography, yet sub-section (b) of the said provision would indeed be applicable where the allegations involve browsing or viewing of any child pornographic material. It is relevant to note that although the court was apprised of the fact that even Section 15 of the POCSO was being contemplated to be added in the chargesheet, yet the High Court in view of the limited question before it did not deem it necessary to go into the applicability of the said provision at that stage. The relevant observations read as under: - “5. This Court accepting the facts had allowed the petition in terms of its order dated 10-07-2024. [...] After release of the order, the State appears to have noticed the short assistance rendered by it, as also the fact that the cyber tipline/2nd respondent was not heard in the matter. The further fact is that the State has filed an application before the Court to bring in Section 15 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offices Act, 2012 (‘POCSO Act’ for short). [...] By a separate order passed on 19-07-2024, the I.A. filed by the State stood answered and the order dated 10-07- 2024, by accepting the reasons indicated in the affidavit was recalled and the matter was restored to file.
xxx xxx xxx
8. [...] The reliance placed by the petitioner is on Section 67B(a) of the Act which was relied on and proceedings quashed. What becomes applicable to the case at hand is Section 67B(b). Section 67B(b) open up prosecution against a person who creates text or digital images, collects, seeks, browses, downloads, advertises, promotes, exchanges or distributes material in any electronic form depicting children in obscene or indecent or sexually explicit manner. It is not in dispute that the petitioner, in the case at hand, has browsed child pornographic material for about 50 minutes. Browsing child pornographic material makes it an offence under Section 67B(b) of the Act.”
(Emphasis supplied)
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 213Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
72. Thus, it appears from the aforesaid that there are divergent views expressed by different High Courts of the country as regards the ingredients necessary to constitute an offence under Section 15 of the POCSO and Section 67B of the IT Act. The Kerala High Court has taken the view that mere possession or viewing of pornographic material involving a child will not fall within the ambit of Section 15 of the POCSO, rather what the provision criminalizes is the actual act of transmission or sharing of the said material. It has held that where the allegations are confined only to the possession of pornographic material and there is nothing to indicate the actual transmission of the same, the criminal proceedings shall be liable to be quashed. Whereas, the Bombay High Court appears to have taken the view that under Section 15(1) of the POCSO, what is penalized is the storage of child pornography and resultant failure to delete or report the same while under Section 15(2), it is the storage and consequent transmission of child pornography. Similarly, with respect to Section 67B, both the Karnataka High Court and the Kerala High Court have held that what is criminalized is the intentional browsing or transmission of child pornography, and not the mere possession of such material.
b. Three distinct offences punishable under Section 15 of the POCSO.
73. Prior to the 2019 Amendment Act, Section 15 of the POCSO as originally enacted, stipulated that any person who stores any pornographic material involving a child for commercial purposes shall be punishable under the said provision. Thus, under the erstwhile Section 15 of the POCSO only one act was criminalized; in other words, only the storage of child pornography for a commercial purpose was made a punishable offence. Storage of such material for any other purpose was outside the scope and purview of the said provision. The said provision as it then stood, reads as under: - “15. Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child. – Any person, who stores, for commercial purposes any pornographic material in any form involving a child shall be punished with imprisonment of either description which may extent to three years or with fine or with both.”
214 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
74. Over a period of time, the legislature realized that despite the enactment of POCSO, there had been an increase rather than a decline in the number of cases pertaining to child sexual abuse. The legislature noted that some of the provisions of the POCSO were not proving to be effective in addressing the various forms of sexual degradation, abuse and exploitation of children in the country. The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act, 2019 earmarked a significant step by the legislature in response to the aforesaid problem, by introducing several new offences and further making the existing offences more stringent with enhanced punishments, as a form of deterrence to sexual predators and to combat the sexual exploitation of children in order to safeguard a secure and dignified environment for them. The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the 2019 Amendment Act read as under: - “STATEMENT OF OBJECTS AND REASONS “1. The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (the said Act) has been enacted to protect children from offences of sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography and provide for establishment of Special Courts for trial of such offences and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.
2. The said Act is gender neutral and regards the best interests and welfare of the child as a matter of paramount importance at every stage so as to ensure the healthy physical, emotional, intellectual and social development of the child.
3. However, in the recent past incidences of child sexual abuse cases demonstrating the inhumane mind-set of the abusers, who have been barbaric in their approach towards young victims, is rising in the country. Children are becoming easy prey because of their tender age, physical vulnerabilities and inexperience of life and society. The unequal balance of power leading to the gruesome act may also detriment the mind of the child to believe that might is right and reported studies establish that children who have been victims of sexual violence in their childhood become more abusive later in their life. The report of the National Crime Records Bureau for the year 2016 indicate [2024] 10 S.C.R. 215Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. increase in the number of cases registered under the said Act from 44.7 per cent. in 2013 over 2012 and 178.6 per cent. in 2014 over 2013 and no decline in the number of cases thereafter.
4. The Supreme Court, in the matter of Machhi Singh vs. State of Punjab [1983 (3) SCC 470], held that when the community feels that for the sake of self-preservation the killer has to be killed, the community may well withdraw the protection by sanctioning the death penalty. But the community will not do so in every case. It may do so in rarest of rare cases when its collective conscience is so shocked that it will expect the holders of the judicial power centre to inflict death penalty irrespective of their personal opinion as regards desirability or otherwise of retaining death penalty. The same analogy has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in the matter of Devender Pal Singh vs. State (NCT of Delhi)[AIR 2002 SC 1661] wherein it was held that when the collective conscience of the community is so shocked, the court must award death sentence.
5. In the above backdrop, as there is a strong need to take stringent measures to deter the rising trend of child sex abuse in the country, the proposed amendments to the said Act make provisions for enhancement of punishments for various offences so as to deter the perpetrators and ensure safety, security and dignified childhood for a child. It also empowers the Central Government to make rules for the manner of deleting or destroying or reporting about pornographic material in any form involving a child to the designated authority.
6. The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (Amendment) Bill, 2019, for the aforementioned purpose, which was introduced and pending consideration and passing in the Lok Sabha, lapsed on the dissolution of the Sixteenth Lok Sabha. Hence, the present Bill.
7. The Bill seeks to achieve the above objectives. NEW DELHI; The 12th July, 2019.”
(Emphasis supplied)
216 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
75. Pursuant to the aforesaid 2019 Amendment Act, a slew of amendments were brought within the POCSO, which inter alia included i) the insertion of Section 2(da) by which “child pornography” came to be defined under the Act AND ii) the amendment of Section 15 of the Act whereby now three distinct offences are made punishable under the said provision. Again, at the cost of repetition, the amended Section 15 of the POCSO is reproduced hereunder: - “15. Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child. –
(1) Any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child, but fails to delete or destroy or report the same to the designated authority, as may be prescribed, with an intention to share or transmit child pornography, shall be liable to fine not less than five thousand rupees and in the event of second or subsequent offence, with fine which shall not be less than ten thousand rupees.
(2) Any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child for transmitting or propagating or displaying or distributing in any manner at any time except for the purpose of reporting, as may be prescribed, or for use as evidence in court, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.
(3) Any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child for commercial purpose shall be punished on the first conviction with imprisonment of either description which shall not be less than three years which may extend to five years, or with fine, or with both and in the event of second or subsequent conviction, with imprisonment of either description which shall not be less than five years which may extend to seven years and shall also be liable to fine.”
(Emphasis supplied)
76. A bare perusal of the aforesaid provision makes it abundantly clear that Section 15 of the POCSO is in three parts. The legislature by virtue of the 2019 Amendment Act has now made three different forms [2024] 10 S.C.R. 217Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. of storage or possession of child pornography a punishable offence under the said provision, unlike the erstwhile provision, which had criminalized only one form of storage of child pornography.
77. Section 15 sub-section (1) of the POCSO now provides that any person who either stores or possesses any pornographic material involving a child and fails to either delete, destroy or report the same with the intention to share or transmit such material, shall be liable to fine of not less than rupees five thousand for the first offence, and a fine of not less than rupees ten thousand for any subsequent offence.
78. On the other hand, Section 15 sub-section (2) of the POCSO provides that any person who either stores or possesses any pornographic material involving a child for transmitting, displaying, propagating, or distributing the same in any manner except for either reporting it or for using it as evidence shall be punishable with either imprisonment extending upto three-years or with fine or both.
79. Whereas, Section 15 sub-section (3) of the POCSO stipulates that any person who either stores or possesses any pornographic material involving a child for commercial purpose shall be punishable with imprisonment of not less than three-years, which may extend upto five-years, or with fine, or both for the first offence, and for any subsequent offence, he shall be punishable with imprisonment not less than five-years, that may extend upto seven-years and along with fine.
I. Concept of an Inchoate Crime – The ‘Actus Reus’ and ‘Mens Rea’ required under Section 15.
80. Before proceeding further to discuss the scope of Section 15 of the POCSO and the ingredients necessary to constitute an offence thereunder, it would be apposite to first understand the true purpose and the nature of the said penal provision.
81. A plain reading of Section 15 of the POCSO and the marginal note appended thereto would reveal that the common theme permeating across sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) respectively is that there is no requirement whatsoever for an actual transmission of any child pornographic material in order to fall within the ambit of the said provision. What is sought to be penalized under Section 15 of the POCSO is the storage or possession of any child pornographic material when done with a particular intention or purpose as stipulated 218 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in sub-section(s) (1), (2) or (3), as the case may be. Thus, the bare textual reading of the said provision makes it clear that it is the intention which is being punished and not the commission of any criminal act in the traditional sense. This in the criminal jurisprudence is known as an ‘Inchoate Crime’ or ‘Inchoate Offence’.
82. Inchoate crimes are defined as criminal acts that are committed in preparation for a further offence. The term “inchoate” itself means “undeveloped” or “incomplete.”
83. The Doctrine of Inchoate Crimes is a cornerstone of criminal jurisprudence. It is aimed at addressing the legal culpability of those who engage in a conduct that is preparatory to the commission of any substantive offence. Inchoate crimes, are often referred to and described as an incomplete or preliminary offence, that capture the essence of criminal intent and the preparatory actions that precede the commission of a criminal act. It underscores the principle that the law does not merely respond to offences already committed but also intervenes when a crime is in the process of being committed, thus thereby protecting public order and safety. Inchoate crimes represent a critical aspect of criminal law, embodying the legal system’s proactive and deterrent approach to crime itself.
84. The primary rationale for the existence of inchoate crimes within the legal framework is the prevention of harm by intervening at an early stage i.e before the potential damage is caused. It recognizes that though certain actions do not result in an offence, nonetheless those actions pose a sufficient threat to society to warrant legal intervention. The jurisprudence surrounding inchoate crimes has evolved as a balance struck between i) the need for early intervention on the one hand with ii) the cardinal principle of criminal law that no one should be punished merely for their thoughts or intentions on the other, by criminalizing only those actions of an individual that demonstrate a clear movement towards the commission of a criminal offense. It is deeply rooted in the preventive or deterrent nature or approach of a particular law by criminalizing those conduct, actions or intentions that pose a significant risk of harm. An inchoate offence requires towing a delicate balance between the need for prevention of potential threat to the society and the risk of undoing the sacrosanct fundamental principle of ‘actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea’ in order to ensure that the law remains a powerful tool [2024] 10 S.C.R. 219Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. in the maintenance of public order. This inherent tension between respecting the autonomy of an individual’s thought and state of mind with the societal interest and safety is often balanced and resolved by carefully shaping and defining the point at which any particular action or preparatory step becomes sufficiently proximate to the commission of an offence. In other words, the law would only intervene at the point where an individual has acquired the means to commit a further offence, and will not punish the mere thought of committing an offence in the absence of any overt steps towards the same. Thus, the critical or central component of any inchoate crime is the preliminary or preparatory actus reus that sufficiently reflects the essence or existence of a criminal intent.
85. Offence pertaining to the possession of any contraband is a prime example and one of the facets of an inchoate crime, as they involve the possession of items that are prohibited by law due to their inherent dangerousness or their use in the commission of further criminal offences. The criminalization of possession as an inchoate crime is predicated on the idea that possession is not an innocuous act but a preparatory step towards more significant criminal conduct. This is because, first, it allows intervention at an early stage, before the contraband can be used to cause harm. Secondly, it acts as a deterrent by penalizing individuals who engage in activities that are likely to lead to more serious offenses. Thirdly, it reflects the societal interest in preventing the accumulation and availability of dangerous items that have no legitimate purpose except for the further perpetuation of a more severe offence and harm to society at large.
86. The POCSO as outlined in its Statement of Object and Reasons was specifically designed to provide commensurate penalties to serve as a deterrent against the sexual abuse and exploitation of children. Additionally, the Statement of Objects and Reasons accompanying the 2019 Amendment Act which inter-alia amended Section 15 of the Act to provide for three distinct offences punishable under it, explicitly emphasizes that the said amendments had been introduced in order to implement stringent measures aimed at addressing and deterring the alarming increase in child sexual abuse. The plain reading of sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) respectively of Section 15 of the POCSO along with the marginal note appended to it which reads “Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child” indicates, that the said provision punishes only the storage of 220 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports pornographic material involving a child when done with a specific intent prescribed thereunder and that there is no requirement for any actual transmission. It is trite to say that, in the absence of any inherent conflict or contradiction between the marginal note and the substantive parts of a particular provision, the marginal note may be used to aid in the interpretation of the provision. Thus, the aforesaid leaves no manner of doubt in the mind of this Court, that the provision of Section 15 of the POCSO is in the nature and form of an inchoate offence which penalizes the mere storage or possession of any pornographic material involving a child when stored with a specific intent prescribed thereunder, without requiring any actual transmission, dissemination etc.
87. Under Section 15 sub-section (1), where a person either stores or possesses any child pornography and does not delete or report the same, in order to share or transmit the same, he will be liable under the said provision. The use of the words “with an intention to share or transmit child pornography ” in the said provision makes it clear that no actual sharing or transmission is required to occur, rather what is required is only the intention to share or transmit because of which the said material was neither deleted, destroyed, or reported. In other words, the actus reus that is penalized under Section 15 sub-section (1) is the failure to delete, destroy or report any child pornography that was stored or in possession of any person with an intention to share or transmit the same. Had the intent of the legislature been otherwise, it would have clearly used the words “transmits” or “shares” instead.
88. Similarly, Section 15 sub-section (2) penalizes the storage or possession of any child pornographic material when done for the purpose of either transmitting, propagating, displaying or distributing the same in any manner. The use of the words “for transmitting or propagating or displaying or distributing in any manner at any time” clearly suggests that again no actual act of transmission, propagation, display or distribution is required to take place. Had the intent of the legislature been otherwise, it would have explicitly stated “any person, who stores or possesses pornographic material in any form involving a child and transmits or propagates or displays or distributes in any manner at any time”. The use of the words “for transmitting or propagating or displaying or distributing in any manner” in Section 15 sub-section (2) makes it crystal clear that the said provision [2024] 10 S.C.R. 221Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. deals with two kinds of actus reus being (I) first, the storage or possession of a pornographic material involving a child when done with an intention to either transmit it or to propagate it or to display or distribute it though no actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution might have occurred OR (II) secondly, the storage or possession of a pornographic material involving a child which was actually transmitted, propagated, displayed or distributed in any form or manner. In other words, the actus reus that is required under Section 15 sub-section (2) is that a pornographic material involving a child must be found to have been stored or in possession with an intention to either transmit it or to propagate it or to display or distribute it or the same must have been transmitted, propagated, displayed or distributed in any form or manner.
89. The underlying difference in the actus reus under Section 15 subsection(s) (1) and (2) is that in the former the storage or possession of any such material is due to the omission to delete, destroy or report the same whereas in the latter, the storage or possession of any such material is in order to facilitate the transmission, propagation, display or distribution of the same. To further put the distinction into perspective, the actus reus under sub-section (1) must be such that indicates that the child pornographic material found in storage or possession was only due to an omission to delete or destroy. Whereas under sub-section (2) it must be shown that such material had been stored or in possession for a reason more than just mere omission i.e., for the reason of transmitting, propagating, displaying or distributing the same. The use of the words “any manner ” in subsection (2) makes it clear that apart from the storage or possession of such pornographic material, there must be something more to show either (I) the actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution of such material OR (II) the facilitation of any transmission, propagation, display or distribution of such material, such as any form of preparation or setup done that would enable that person to transmit it or to display it. Thus, Section 15 sub-section (2) of the POCSO would cover both the actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution of any child pornography as-well as the facilitation of any of the abovementioned acts.
90. On the other hand, the mens rea which is required to constitute an offence under Section 15(1) is the intent to share or transmit a pornographic material involving a child, and the said intention is 222 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to be gathered or gauged from the actus reus itself i.e., by culling out the manner in which there was an omission to delete, destroy or report such a material or the reason behind the same. This is evinced from the construction of the expression “but fails to delete or destroy or report the same to the designated authority, as may be prescribed, with an intention to share or transmit child pornography” which makes it clear that the scope of discerning the intent to share or transmit has been both limited AND tied to only the omission to delete, destroy or report i.e., the actus reus. The expression “with an intention to share or transmit ” cannot be singled out and construed devoid of its context. Thus, it is the manner in which along with the attending circumstances attributable to the failure to delete, destroy or report that must sufficiently be indicative of the intent to share or transmit any material.
91. In Section 15 sub-section (1) of the POCSO the legislature by qualifying and linking the expression “intent to share or transmit ” to the omission to delete, destroy or report, has in its wisdom made the intention or mens rea under the said provision a matter of inference, to be ascertained from the actus reus itself. The degree of probability for inferring such intention would largely depend upon the manner in which the actus reus i.e., how the omission took place. It is for the courts to ascertain whether the manner in which the material was found in storage or possession, the attending circumstances to the omission and the conduct of the person accused sufficiently refutes or displaces the inference of an intention to share or transmit or not.
92. The underlying reason behind tying the inference of intention to the omission alone is because the legislature was alive to the practical difficulty that exists in establishing an intention to share or transmit any child pornographic material from just the mere possession of such material. In offences pertaining to or involving the possession of any contraband, it is too uphill a task for the courts to peer through and look into the mind of the person accused and then cull out the intention of that person behind possessing or storing such material. Thus, in such cases instead of directly establishing the intention from the mental state of the person accused, it is established indirectly by inferring it from the manner in which the contraband was found to have been stored or in possession. Here again due to the infeasibility or difficulty in cogently establishing an inference of intention often due to the lack of any material and the very private and clandestine nature [2024] 10 S.C.R. 223Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. of the offence, the courts instead try to look for some material or circumstances that might displace the inference of such an intention, and wherever there is nothing to show the same, the courts may without hesitation proceed to infer the existence of such an intention.
93. Whereas, under Section 15 sub-section (2) the mens rea is to be gathered from the manner in which the pornographic material was found to be stored or in possession and any other material apart from such possession or storage that would be indicative of any facilitation or actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution of such material. Thus, wherever in addition to the storage or possession of any child pornographic material, there exists any material or attending circumstances that would either show or indicate the facilitation or actual commission of any of the acts enumerated in Section 15 subsection (2) of the POCSO, the said provision would get attracted in place of Section 15 sub-section (1). We say so because, the presence of such additional material may demonstrate that the intention of the person accused has gone beyond the contours of Section 15 sub-section (1). It evinces a more significant manifestation of the intention of the person accused, which moved from what is required in sub-section (1) to a much higher degree of intention that is required under sub-section (2). In other words, the existence of such additional material strengthens the inference of that intention which is required and made punishable under Section 15 sub-section (2).
94. Section 15 sub-section (3) penalizes the storage or possession of any child pornographic material when done for any commercial purpose. The term ‘commercial purpose’ refers to and encompasses any activity or transaction that is carried out or undertaken as a means of any commercial enterprise i.e., with the object or intention of any gain, irrespective of whether it was in monetary terms or not. Thus, to constitute an offence under this provision, the requirement is that the storage or possession of any child pornography must be in lieu of any monetary gain or for receiving any other valuable consideration. Again, the words “any commercial purpose” indicate that the storage or possession must be with an intention to generate or acquire any monetary gain or any other form of valuable consideration, irrespective and regardless of whether such monetary gain or valuable consideration is actually generated or acquired. Thus, it is immaterial whether any monetary gain or any other benefit was actually realized or not. To establish an offence under Section 15 sub- 224 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports section (3), besides the storage or possession of the pornographic material involving a child, there must be some additional material or attending circumstances that may sufficiently indicate that the said storage or possession was done with the intent of any form of gain or benefit. As soon as there is any material to indicate that the storage or possession of any child pornographic material was done in lieu or in expectation of some form of gain or benefit, it would constitute an offence under Section 15 sub-section (3) of the POCSO notwithstanding whether such gain was actually realized.
95. Thus, while Section 15 sub-section (1) requires the existence of the requisite mens rea or intention due to which the child pornographic material was not deleted, destroyed or reported, Section 15 subsection (2) requires the existence of the requisite mens rea or intention which propelled or led the person accused to not only store or possess the said material but also to take some additional steps towards either the actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution or the facilitation of the same. In contrast, Section 15 sub-section (3) requires the existence of the requisite mens rea or intention due to which the person accused not only stored or possessed the child pornographic material but also compelled him to take some additional steps either for any gain or benefit or in lieu or expectation of some form of gain or benefit.
96. For the sake of clarity, it would be apposite to give few illustrations as a guiding example to further demonstrate the fine but pertinent distinction that exists between sub-section (1), (2) and (3) of Section 15 of the POCSO.
97. For illustration; say certain child pornographic material was found stored in the personal mobile phone of ‘A’ and the same was neither deleted, destroyed nor reported. Here though there is possession or storage of child pornographic material but since there is nothing to show any facilitation of transmission, propagation, display or distribution of the said material, this would attract the provision of Section 15(1). At the same time, since the material in question was found in the personal mobile of ‘A’ the same is indicative that the omission to either delete, destroy or report in all likelihood was due to the intent to share or transmit. Here the manner in which the omission has occurred is sufficiently indicative of the intent to share or transmit, as there is nothing apart to show that the omission was [2024] 10 S.C.R. 225Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. attributable to any other reason but the intent to share or transmit, and thus it would constitute an offence under Section 15(1) of the
POCSO.
98. Conversely, say for example certain child pornographic material was found stored in a broken mobile phone of ‘A’ and the said material had never been deleted, destroyed or reported. Now again, there is nothing to show that there was either any actual transmission, propagation, display or distribution nor anything to show that something apart from and in addition to the storage or possession had been done by ‘A’ for facilitation of the transmission, propagation, display or distribution of such material. This would again attract the provision of Section 15(1) instead of 15(2) of the POCSO. However, since the material was found in a broken phone, it is likely that the failure to delete, destroy or report the same was attributable to the inability of ‘A’ to operate the broken mobile rather than the intent to share or transmit, thus, no offence would be made out under Section 15(1) of the POCSO. This is because, the manner in which the omission has occurred is not sufficiently indicative of the intent to share or transmit. Thus, no offence could be said to have been constituted under Section 15 sub-section (1) of the POCSO.
99. Take for instance, certain child pornographic material was found stored in the mobile phone of ‘A’ but this time, the said material had found its way in the device due to an automatic download of media of which ‘A’ had no knowledge whatsoever. Here although there is possession or storage of such material, yet the omission to delete, destroy or report is clearly shown and established by ‘A’ that it was due to lack of knowledge about the existence of such material on his parts. Here the manner in which the omission has occurred is not sufficiently indicative of the intent to share or transmit, thus no offence could be said to have been made out under Section 15(1) of the POCSO.
100. Take a case where certain child pornographic material was found stored in the mobile phone of ‘A’ but this time in addition to the aforesaid material few chats were also recovered wherein ‘A’ told his friend ‘B’ that he had some child pornographic material which he could share with him. Here, since there is additional material to show that ‘A’ had taken some overt steps in order to propagate the said material, he would be liable under Section 15(2) of the POCSO. 226 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
101. For another illustration, say for example, again certain child pornographic material was found stored in the mobile phone of ‘A’ but this time ‘A’ creates a chat group consisting of several of his friends, and sends a message therein stating that he has some child pornographic material which he would forward on the group. Here, since there is additional material to show that ‘A’ had taken some overt steps in order to distribute the said material, he would be liable under Section 15(2) of the POCSO.
102. Conversely, say ‘A’ who has certain child pornographic material in his phone, again creates a group consisting of several of his friends, but this time he sends a message stating that he has some child pornographic material which he would send in exchange of some amount of money. Here, since there is additional material to show that ‘A’ had taken some overt steps in respect of the said material for some monetary gain, he would now be liable under Section 15(3) of the POCSO instead.
103. We may at the cost of repetition clarify that there may be situations where the possession or storage of the pornographic material is found to be in a such a manner that the same by itself would be indicative of an intention to either transmit, display, propagate or distribute such material or that it was done in lieu or expectation of any gain. In such cases the storage or possession of child pornographic material itself would sufficiently be indicative of the requisite intention either under Section 15 sub-section(s) (2) or (3) as the case may be, and there would be no requirement to adduce any additional material as long as the manner of storage or possession of such material or the attending circumstances itself is sufficiently indicative of such intention.
104. For illustration; say certain child pornographic material was found stored in five to six television devices in a hotel run by ‘A’. Here, because the pornographic material has been found to be stored in multiple devices that too at a place which has easy access for the public, the same would be indicative that the ‘A’ was using the hotel and the television devices therein as a means for facilitating display of such pornographic material, and thus, would be punishable under Section 15 sub-section (2) of the POCSO.
105. For another illustration say again certain child pornographic material were found stored in five to six television devices in a hotel run by [2024] 10 S.C.R. 227Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. ‘A’, but this time some price was mentioned onto the pornographic material itself. Here, because some amount of money was found to be mentioned on the material itself and the said material was stored in a place with easy public access, the same would be indicative that the ‘A’ was using the hotel and the television devices therein as a means for facilitating display of such pornographic material in lieu of monetary gain, thus, would be punishable under Section 15 sub-section (3) of the POCSO.
106. The aforesaid illustrations have been provided only as a guiding example to highlight the distinction between sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) of Section 15 of the POCSO. These illustrations should not be mechanically applied or construed by any court in any proceeding while dealing with any matter involving Section 15 of the POCSO devoid of the context in which these illustrations have been given and without applying its mind as to whether the necessary ingredients have been established or not in the individual facts and circumstances of the matter. Any matter involving Section 15 sub-section (1), (2) or
(3) of the POCSO, must be dealt with independent of the illustrations narrated above and stricto-sensu in accordance with only the ratio of this decision.
107. Lastly, we must also caution the police and the courts to be mindful of the fact that wherever in a given case a particular sub-section of Section 15 is found to be applicable, the other two remaining sub-sections of the said provision will cease to be applicable. Section 15 sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) respectively of the POCSO are independent and distinct offences. The three offences cannot coexist simultaneously in the same set of facts. They are distinct from each other and are not intertwined that they cannot survive without each other. This is because, the underlying distinction between Section 15 sub-section(s) (1), (2) and (3) respectively lies in the different degree of culpable mens rea that is required under each of the three provisions. The inception of the requisite culpable mens rea begins and takes shape from the intention specified under sub-section (1), then gradually continues to transform into the intention stipulated under sub-section (2) and finally culminates into the intention prescribed under sub-section (3). Under Section 15 sub-section (1) of the POCSO, the requisite intention therein is still in fieri i.e., in process of developing and culminating into either the intention under sub-section(s) (2) or 228 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports (3). Whenever, the said intention ultimately crystalizes into the intention either under sub-section(s) (2) or (3), the other provisions would automatically become inapplicable.
108. Yet one another important aspect, that the police and the courts should be mindful of is that while examining any matter involving the storage or possession of any child pornography, it finds that particular sub-section of Section 15 is not attracted, it must not jump to the conclusion that no offence at all is made out under Section 15 of the POCSO. The police at the time of investigation and the courts at the time of taking cognizance, should keep this aforesaid aspect in mind. In other words, both should try to ascertain that if offence is not made out in one particular sub-section, whether the same is made out in the other two sub-sections or not.
II. Concept of ‘Possession’, ‘Constructive Possession’ and ‘Immediate Control’ under Section 15 of the POCSO.
109. During the course of hearing, our attention was also drawn to a recent news article that reported how on social media, links to view child pornography were being circulated and sold for anywhere between Rs. 40 to Rs. 5,000. The news report indicates, how social media platforms are rife with child sexual abuse, and gave certain insight about the modus operandi of the distribution of such material on these platforms. It explained how the sellers and distributors of child pornographic material rather than sharing any downloads to such material, would ingeniously only share links to such material instead in lieu of money, so as to circumvent the penal provisions of the POCSO and IT Act, which criminalized only the storage of such material. By indefinitely forwarding links, they completely bypass the requirement of first storing such material onto any device, and similarly those who view such material also only use the links, without ever downloading such material onto their device.
110. As earlier mentioned, prior to the 2019 Amendment Act, Section 15 of the POCSO only criminalized the storage of any child pornographic material for any commercial purpose. Thereafter, the legislature in view of the increasing number of child sexual abuse cases, amended Section 15 of the POCSO, to recognize and criminalize three distinct forms or manner of storage of child pornographic material, as has been discussed in the preceding parts of this judgment. [2024] 10 S.C.R. 229Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
111. One another subtle but significant change that was made to all three sub-sections of Section 15 was the inclusion of the word “possession” in addition to storage, which was earlier not there in the erstwhile provision of Section 15 of the POCSO.
112. Thus, while the word “possession” was originally absent in the unamended Section 15 of the POCSO, the legislature in its wisdom, specifically added the said word in the amended Section 15, whereby now both the storage or the possession of any child pornographic material would be liable to be punished when done with any of the specified intention thereunder.
113. We believe that the change referred to above was not made inadvertently or lightly, but rather was done specifically with the intention of making the provisions of Section 15 of the POCSO more stringent to effectively deter the dissemination and use of child pornography.
114. An important aspect of the jurisprudence on possession as an inchoate crime is the doctrine of constructive possession. Constructive possession extends the concept of possession beyond physical control to situations where an individual has the power and intention to control the contraband, even if it is not in their immediate physical possession. This doctrine is particularly relevant in cases where contraband is found in a location that is not directly under the physical control of the accused, but where the accused has access to and control over the area where the contraband is found.
115. In U.S. v. Tucker reported in 150 F. Supp. 2d 1263 (D. Utah. 2001), the U.S. District Court, Utah, explained and elaborated on the doctrine of constructive possession. In the said case, the defendant therein used to routinely view child pornography, but he never used to keep it stored in his computer, and would often delete any such material and its traces from its computer after he was finished viewing them. When charged with the offence of possession of child pornographic material, he challenged the same, contending that since no material had been stored in his disk, he cannot be said to be in possession of any child pornography. The court held that wherever a person exercises some form or manner of immediate control over any particular material, both tangible or intangible, such material would be said to be in his constructive possession. It observed that the control of a person over such material can be ascertained by seeing whether 230 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports he could manipulate, alter, modify or destroy such material or not, if the answer to any of the above is in an affirmative, such material would be deemed to be in his conscious or constructive possession.
116. Similarly in U.S. v. Romm reported in 455 F. 3d. 990 (9 th Cir., 2006), the defendant therein admitted to viewing images of child pornography on the Internet. He would save them to disk, view them for about 5 minutes, then delete them. The Court held that a person can be said to possess child pornography even without downloading or storing it, if he or she seeks it out and exercises dominion or control over it. It observed that this dominion or control may be evident by factors such as when viewing the images on the screen, did the person have the ability to print them, save them, forward them or delete them. If he did, then he can be said to have knowingly exercised custody or control over those images and thus, consequently in possession of the same.
117. Thus, for establishing constructive possession both the power to control the material in question and the knowledge of exercise of such control are required. The doctrine of constructive possession, is a crucial development in the criminal jurisprudence, especially pertaining to inchoate crimes where possession is sought to be punished, as it ensures that no person can evade liability by simply distancing themselves from the physical possession of contraband while retaining the ability to control it.
118. We are of the considered view, that wherever a person indulges in any activity such as viewing, distributing or displaying etc. pertaining to any child pornographic material without actually possessing or storing it in any device or in any form or manner, such act would still tantamount to ‘possession’ in terms of Section 15 of the POCSO, if he exercised an invariable degree of control over such material, applying the aforesaid doctrine of constructive possession.
119. Say for instance, ‘A’ routinely watches child pornography over the internet, but never downloads or stores the same in his mobile. Here ‘A’ would still be said to be in possession of such material, as while watching he exercises a considerable degree of control over such material including but not limited to sharing, deleting, enlarging such material, changing the volume etc. Furthermore, since he himself on his own volition is viewing such material, he is said to have knowledge of having control over such material.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 231Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
120. Conversely, say ‘A’ is sent an unknown link by ‘B’, which upon clicking opened a child pornographic video on the phone of ‘A’. Here although ‘A’ at the time of opening the link had control over the said link, yet he cannot be said to have a knowledge of that control over such material as he at that relevant point of time was unaware as to what would open from the said link; thus ‘A’ cannot be said to be in possession. We say so, because, ‘A’ had no information as to what the link pertained to, in order to have knowledge of control over such material, a person requires reasonable information such as what is involved in the material in question, what is the purpose of such material, etc. Without such information no person can decide whether he wants to view it, or delete it or further forward it i.e., he cannot effectively exercise the control that he has, without a certain degree of knowledge.
121. However, in the aforementioned illustration, if ‘A’ rather than closing the link in a reasonable time, continues to view such material he would be deemed to be in possession of such material. This is because, after a reasonable window of time, he would be said to have sufficient information about such material to have knowledge for the effective exercise of his control over such material.
122. Thus, we are of the considered view that any form of intangible or constructive possession of any child pornographic material will also amount to “possession” under Section 15 of the POCSO in terms of the Doctrine of Constructive Possession. There is no requirement of a physical or tangible “storage” or “possession” of such material in Section 15 of the POCSO. We may clarify with a view to obviate any confusion that, where any child pornographic material is in the constructive possession of an accused, there the failure or omission to report the same would constitute the requisite actus-reus for the purposes of Section 15 sub-section
(1) of POCSO.
123. For instance, say, ‘A’ is sent an unknown link by ‘B’, which upon clicking opened a child pornographic video on the phone of ‘A’. Now if ‘A’ immediately closes the link, although once the link is closed ‘A’ is no longer in constructive possession of the child pornography, this by itself does not mean that ‘A’ has destroyed or deleted the said material by merely closing the link. ‘A’ will only be absolved of 232 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports any liability if he after closing the link further reports the same to the specified authorities. Thus, when it comes to constructive possession of an accused, it is the failure or omission to report that constitutes the requisite actus-reus for the purposes of Section 15 sub-section
(1) of POCSO.
124. At this juncture we may also address ourselves on another pertinent aspect for constituting an offence under Section 15 of the POCSO. The term ‘storage’ and ‘possession’ that has been used in the said provision does not require that such ‘storage’ or ‘possession’ must continue to be there at the time of registration of an FIR or any criminal proceeding. The provision of Section 15 is not fixated any particularly time-frame. What is simpliciter required to constitute an offence under Section 15 of the POCSO is the establishment of ‘storage’ or ‘possession’ of any child pornographic material with the specified intention under sub-section(s) (1), (2) or (3), at any relevant point of time. Even, if the said ‘storage’ or ‘possession’ no longer exists at the time of registration of the FIR, nonetheless an offence can be made out under Section 15 if it is established that the person accused had ‘stored’ or ‘possessed’ of any child pornographic material with the specified intention at any particular point of time even if it is anterior in time. We say so because, any other view aside from the above, in our opinion would lead to a chilling effect with drastic consequences, whereby the provisions of the POCSO may be defeated by a devious person. If for instance, a person immediately after storing and watching child pornography in his mobile phone deletes the same before an FIR could be registered, could it be said that the said person is not liable under Section 15, because at the time of registration of the FIR, such material no longer existed on the device of the person accused? The answer to the aforesaid, must be an emphatic “no”. Thus, we clarify that there is no requirement under Section 15 of the POCSO that ‘storage’ or ‘possession’ must continue to exist at the time of initiation of the criminal proceeding, and no such requirement can be read into the said provision. An offence can be made out under Section 15 if it is established that the person accused had ‘stored’ or ‘possessed’ of any child pornographic material with the specified intention at any particular point of time even if it was before such initiation or registration of criminal proceedings.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 233Just Rights for Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors. c. Pornographic Material must prima facie appear to involve a Child.
125. At this stage, we may explain one another crucial aspect concerning Section 15 of the POCSO, more particularly the criteria for determining whether the material in question involves or depicts a ‘child’, or in other words whether such material can be considered a ‘child pornography’ or not. The determination of whether the individual involved is a ‘child’ or not, in terms of the POCSO is a crucial foundational element for constituting various offences under the Act.
126. Section 2(1)(d) of the POCSO stipulates that the term ‘child’ means and refers to any person who is below the age of eighteen years. Thus, under the POCSO more particularly Section 2(1)(d) an objective criterion has been prescribed by the legislature for determining whether a person is a ‘child’ or not for the purposes of any offence under the Act. The said criteria is based on the age of the individual in question, and involves ascertaining and establishing whether he or she is under eighteen years of age, if so, such person would be considered a ‘child’ for the purposes of any offence in respect of such child that is punishable under the POCSO.
127. Earlier under the POCSO, there was no specific definition of ‘child pornography’. Thus, under the erstwhile Section 15 of the POCSO, there was only one criteria for ascertaining whether the material in question can be regarded as ‘child pornography’ or not, which was by establishing that the material depicts or involves a person who is under the age of eighteen years.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.