Joseph Shine v. Union of India
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 87; [2023] 4 S.C.R. 585
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 5 Judges: Justice K.M. Joseph, Justice Ajay Rastogi, Justice Aniruddha Bose, Justice Hrishikesh Roy, Justice C.T. Ravikumar Judgments/Orders – Clarification of – Army Act, Justice 1950 – Ss. 45, Justice 63 – Air Force Act, Justice 1950 – Ss.45, Justice 65 – Navy Act, Justice 1957 – Ss.54(2)
- Decided
- 31 Jan 2023
- Case number
- MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION No. 2204/2020
- Sections
- 497, 45, 63, 69, 70, 198
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 585[2023] 4 S.C.R. 585
JOSEPH SHINE
v.
UNION OF INDIA
(Miscellaneous Application No. 2204 of 2020)
JANUARY 31, 2023
[K. M. JOSEPH, AJAY RASTOGI, ANIRUDDHA BOSE, HRISHIKESH ROY AND C. T. RAVIKUMAR, JJ.] Judgments/Orders – Clarification of – Army Act, 1950 – ss. 45, 63 – Air Force Act, 1950 – ss.45, 65 – Navy Act, 1957 – ss.54(2), 74 – Union of India (UOI) sought clarification of the judgment of Supreme Court in Joseph Shine v. Union of India reported as [2018] 11 SCR 765 – Held: In Joseph Shine case, the scheme of the Acts in the context of Article 33 of the Constitution did not fall for the consideration – Said judgment was not concerned with the effect and operation of the relevant provisions of the Acts in question – Court was neither called upon nor it ventured to pronounce on the effect of ss.45 and 63 of the 1950 Act or the corresponding provisions in other Acts or any other provisions of the Acts – Further, it is not as if this Court approved of adultery – It was found that adultery may be a moral wrong (per Hon’ble Indu Malhotra, J.) – It will continue to be a ground for securing dissolution of marriage and has also been described as a civil wrong – Constitution of India – Article 33 – Armed Forces.
Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2019) 3 SCC 39 :
[2018] 11 SCR 765 – clarified.
Supertech Limited v. Emerald Court Owner Resident Welfare Association and Others Miscellaneous Application No. 1572 of 2021 in Civil Appeal No. 5041 of 2021; Delhi Administration v. Gurdip Singh Uban and Others (2000) 7 SCC 296 : [2000] 2 Suppl. SCR 496 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2018] 11 SCR 765 clarified Para 3, 24 [2000] 2 Suppl. SCR 496 referred to Para 18 A B C D E F G H 586 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
Miscellaneous Application No.2204 of 2020 : In Writ Petition (Criminal) No.194 of 2017.
From the Judgment and Order dated 27.09.2018 in W. P. (Crl.) No.194 of 2017 of the Supreme Court of India.
With Miscellaneous Application No.1702 of 2021 in Writ Petition (Criminal) No.194 of 2017.
Mrs. Madhavi Divan, Sanjay Jain, A.S.Gs., Mr. R Balasubramaniam, Sr. Adv., Sarvesh Singh, Sachin Sharma, Mohd Akhil, Balendu Shekhar, Kanu Agarwal, Mrs. Deepabali Dutta, Mayank Pandey, Anandh Venkataramani, Mrs. Vijayalakshmi Venkataramani, Vinayak Mehrotra, Ms. Mansi Sood, Chitvan Singhal, Ms. Sonali Jain, Abhishek Kumar Pandey, Raman Yadav, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Ms. Nidhi Khanna, Ms. Aishwarya Nabh, Aanorita Deb, Shubham Saigal, Aishani Narain, Kaleeswaram Raj, Nishe Rajen Shonker, Ms. Thulasi K Raj, Advs. for the Petitioner.
K. Parameshwar, Ms. Arti Gupta, Ms. Kanti, Ms. Anannya Ghosh, Dushyant Manocha, Ms. Mrinalini Mishra, Ms. Chitra Vats, Ms. Doel Bose, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Order of the Court was passed by
K. M. JOSEPH, J.
MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. 2204 OF 2020
IN
WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) NO. 194 OF 2017
(1) Applications for intervention and impleadment are allowed.
(2) This miscellaneous application is filed by the Union of India seeking the following clarification:
“(a) That persons subject to Army Act, Navy Act and Air Force Act, by virtue of Article 33 of the Constitution of India, being a distinct class, any promiscuous or adulterous acts by such persons should be allowed to be governed by the provisions of Sections 45 or 63 of the Army Act, Sections 45 or 65 of the Air Force Act and Sections 54(2) or 74 of the Navy Act being special legislation and A B C D E F G H considering the requirements of discipline and proper discharge of their duty.”
(3) The applicant is seeking clarification of the judgment of this Court reported in Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2019) 3 SCC 39. It must be noticed that the applicant was the sole respondent in the said case.
(4) The reasons which have driven the applicant to seek the clarification are as follows:
It is the case of the applicant that this Court has undoubtedly proceeded to find Section 497 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’ for brevity) as unconstitutional as it offended Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution of India. However, it is the case of the applicant that officers of the Armed forces are subject to statutory provisions, viz., Army Act, 1950, Navy Act, 1957 and the Air Force Act, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Acts’).
(5) Our attention is further drawn to Article 33 of the Constitution which reads as follows:
“33. Power of Parliament to modify the rights conferred by this Part in their application to Forces, etc.— Parliament may, by law, determine to what extent any of the rights conferred by this Part shall, in their application to,—
(a) the members of the Armed Forces; or (b)the members of the Forces charged with the maintenance of public order; or (c)persons employed in any bureau or other organisation established by the State for purposes of intelligence or counter intelligence; or (d)person employed in, or in connection with, the telecommunication systems set up for the purposes of any Force, bureau or organisation referred to in clauses (a)to (c), be restricted or abrogated so as to ensure the proper discharge of their duties and the maintenance of discipline among them.”
(6) It is the case of the applicant that the impression has been generated and is sought to be perpetuated that in the light of the judgment JOSEPH SHINE v. UNION OF INDIA [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 588 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
of which the clarification is sought, nothing more would survive even if a case is made otherwise under relevant provisions of the Acts in question.
(7) Ms. Madhvi Divan, learned Additional Solicitor General, who appears on behalf of the applicant, drew our attention, as an illustration, to the following provisions of the Army Act, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1950 Act’ for brevity).
Chapter VI deals with offences thereunder. Our attention is drawn to Section 45:
“45. Unbecoming conduct. Any officer, junior commissioned officer or warrant officer who behaves in a manner unbecoming his position and the character expected of him shall, on conviction by court-martial, if he is an officer, be liable to be cashiered or to suffer such less punishment as is in this Act mentioned; and, if he is a junior commissioned officer or a warrant officer, be liable to be dismissed or to suffer such less punishment as is in this Act mentioned.”
(8) She further draws our attention to Section 63:
“63. Violation of good order and discipline. Any person subject to this Act who is guilty of any act or omission which, though not specified in this Act, is prejudicial to good order and military discipline shall, on conviction by court- martial, be liable to suffer imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years or such less punishment as is in this Act mentioned.”
(9) Finally, she drew our attention to Section 69:
69.Civil offences. Subject to the provisions of section 70, any person subject to this Act who at any place in or beyond India commits any civil offence shall be deemed to be guilty of an offence against this Act and, if charged therewith under this section, shall be liable to be tried by a court-martial and, on conviction, be punishable as follows, that is to say,-
(a) if the offence is one which would be punishable under any law in force in India with death or with transportation, he shall be liable to suffer any punishment, other than whipping, assigned for the offence, by the aforesaid law and such less punishment as is in this Act mentioned; and A B C D E F G H
(b) in any other case, he shall be liable to suffer any punishment, other than whipping, assigned for the offence by the law in force in India, or imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years, or such less punishment as is in this Act mentioned.
(10) She would immediately point out that in the light of the judgment of this Court in Joseph Shine (supra), since Section 497 IPC has been struck down as unconstitutional and it being a civil offence within the meaning of Section 69 of the 1950 Act, it may not be open to the authorities to proceed against an officer under Section 69. However, it is the further case that it will not preclude the authorities from invoking Section 45 and/or Section 63 of the 1950 Act. There are similar provisions also in the Navy Act and in the Air Force Act.
It is her submission that the words adulterous acts would bear the meaning which is assigned to it in the dictionary. So also the word promiscuous. They need not be found integrally connected with Section 497 IPC as such.
(11) The members of Armed Forces, according to her, are a class apart. She also drew our attention to the objects and reasons of the 1950 Act. It is pointed out that the law was enacted to provide for an exhaustive Code. It is a complete Code. It provides for self-regulation. According to her, the decision of this Court in Joseph Shine (supra) must be viewed in the context of the institution of Marriage. It was not rendered in the context of a workplace. Expanding further, learned Additional Solicitor General would point out that the setting in which the Armed Forces operate makes it a unique workplace. Discipline among the members of the Force is a matter which is indispensable. Discipline would indeed be impaired, according to her, if the high moral ground to be occupied by the officers is diluted. The obstacle for the authorities invoking Sections 45 and 63 of the 1950 Act as also the corresponding provisions in the other two Acts will ultimately result in a situation where, in the sensitive Forces, which the Armed Forces are, it would engender and breed rank indiscipline. The Forces which act as one and proceed on the existence of a sense of brotherhood would face breakdown of their morale. This was not what was in contemplation of this Court when it pronounced Section 497 IPC as unconstitutional. Section 497 IPC has been struck down on the basis that it offended Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution. The Court it is contended was distressed by the resort to values of a bygone era [the Victorian era] and the considerations which JOSEPH SHINE v. UNION OF INDIA [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 590 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
persuaded this Court to hold Section 497 IPC as unconstitutional are not germane for the purposes of deciding on the validity or the legality of actions taken under Sections 45 and 63 of the 1950 Act. She, in fact, did point out that there was an element of discord even in the matter of right of privacy which has been advocated in the judgment of one of the learned Judges whereas it has not been so evidenced in the judgment of another Judge. There is a command structure in the Armed Forces which it is indispensable to maintain. Such command structure would be disturbed. She would, in this regard, ask us to focus attention on the words ‘unbecoming conduct’ in Section 45 of the 1950 Act. She would submit that in a case where the officer is charged with what is unbecoming conduct and it consists of an act of adultery, nothing can stand in the way of the authorities taking action.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.