Vahitha v. State of Tamil Nadu
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 151; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 942
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dinesh Maheshwari, Justice Bela M. Trivedi Penal Code
- Decided
- 22 Feb 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 762/2012
- Sections
- 302, 313, 106, 300, 2
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 942 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.[2023] 3 S.C.R. 942
VAHITHA
v.
STATE OF TAMIL NADU
(Criminal Appeal No. 762 of 2012)
FEBRUARY 22, 2023
[DINESH MAHESHWARI AND BELA M. TRIVEDI, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 – Conviction under – Strangulation of child – Prosecution case that appellant strangulated her five year old child to death while PW-1 (mother-in-law of appellant) had gone out of the house – As per the FIR, when PW-1 came back to the house, she saw the appellant tie the outer end of her saree tightly around the neck of the child – During her testimony PW-1 stated that she found the appellant sitting silently next to the deceased child when she came back to the house – Upon hearing PW-1 shout; daughters of PW-1 i.e. PW-2 and PW-3 also arrived at the scene of occurrence – Two independent witnesses PW-4 and PW-5 (landlord and neighbour of PW-1) also testified that they saw the appellant next to the body of the deceased child – According to post-mortem report, cause of death of child was asphyxia due to strangulation – However, PW-6- father of appellant deposed that appellant was with him at his village and that he accompanied her back to in-laws place after receiving information about death of child – Trial Court convicted appellant u/s. 302 and rejected plea of alibi – High Court affirmed findings of trial Court and held that appellant was last person to be seen with child, hence onus was on appellant to explain how death occurred – On appeal, held: Plea of alibi rejected – No evidence adduced to prove that appellant was not present at time and place of incident; two independent witnesses testified that they saw the appellant near the body of the deceased child; appellant arrested on the same day of the incident at bus stand – Although, there were discrepancies in versions of PW-2 between the complaint and her assertions before the Court such discrepancies are normal and natural or the result of her want of proper comprehension – Trial Court rightly analysed matter and observed that PW-1 was deposing from memory one year from incident hence discrepancies would not result in rejection of her testimony – Further, saree recovered from appellant had blood stains A B C D E F G H – Motive of appellant to not live in matrimonial house and thus committing offence cannot be ruled out looking to fact that she was living with her parents and was only forced to come to in-laws place for the upbringing of the child – Further, the appellant has not given any explanation in her statement u/s. 313 CrPC apart from denying the circumstances put to her – Burden u/s. 106 of the Evidence Act operates heavily against appellant – Alternative submission that case would be of culpable homicide not amounting to murder rejected.
Dismissing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1. The Trial Court and the High Court have examined the evidence on record and have rejected this plea of alibi with reference to the significant features of the case that there is no corroborative evidence on record, to the assertion made by PW-6, that on 20.06.2007, he took his daughter back to his village Kolakkudi. The accused-appellant did not adduce any evidence to prove that she was not present at her mother-inlaw’s place, at the time and place of incident. Apart from the fact that PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 consistently maintained their versions that the appellant was available at the time and place of incident, two independent witnesses, PW-4, landlord of PW-1 and PW-5, neighbour of PW-1 testified that they saw the appellant sitting with or near the body of the deceased child immediately after, and at the place of, the incident. Although there appears to be no reason to discard the testimonies of PW2 and PW-3 but even if for the sake of argument their testimonies are left aside for being directly related witnesses who might not be favourably disposed towards the appellant, there appears no reason to disbelieve and discard the testimonies of PW-4 and PW-5. Nothing even remotely has been shown as to why PW-4 and PW-5 would be interested in testifying about the presence of appellant around the time, and at the place of incident. [Para 15.1][981-B-D]
2. Apart from the foregoing, fact of the matter also remains that the appellant was arrested on 21.06.2007 i.e., the very day of the incident, albeit nine hours after the incident, at the bus stand. However, when the theory propounded by PW-6 that the appellant had travelled to his village with him on 20.06.2007 and VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU A B C D E F G H 944 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
then travelled back to her mother-in-law’s place on 21.06.2007 is discarded, all other facts taken together lead to the logical conclusion that the plea of alibi is required to be rejected. [Para 15.2][981-E-F]
3. Another major factor highlighted and elaborated by the appellant relates to certain discrepancies appearing in the versions of PW-1, as stated in the complaint made to the police compared with her assertions before the Court. No doubt, there had been some such discrepancies in the matter which, at the first blush, give rise to certain doubts as to whether the testimony of PW-1 could be believed or not. However, a close look at the record makes it clear that the discrepancies, said to be of contradictions in the versions given by PW-1, could only be considered to be normal and natural or being the result of her want of proper comprehension. [Para 16][981-G-H; 982-A]
4. PW-1 is none other than mother-in-law of the appellant and the grand-mother of the victim child. The first discrepancy in the matter is that, as per the version in the complaint, she left her house in the morning to buy idli without taking money, but in her deposition, she stated that appellant gave her Rs. 100 and asked her to get idli. Another major discrepancy surfaces when it is noticed that in the complaint, she asserted that the appellant ran away from the scene of occurrence but in her deposition, she stated that the appellant was taken to the police station. Thirdly, what she saw and did upon reaching the house after visiting the market is also stated differently in the complaint and in the deposition. The question is as to whether her testimony and the prosecution case be rejected altogether because of these discrepancies. [Para 16.1][982-B-C]
5. The Trial Court has rightly analysed the matter and has rightly observed that when PW-1, sixty-five years of age, was deposing before the Court from her memory after one year from the incident, such discrepancies would not result in rejection of her testimony altogether. The relevant features emanating from her assertions in the complaint as also in the statement are that she had gone out to purchase eatables in the morning while leaving the victim child with the appellant; and after coming back, A B C D E F G H found the child dead, with the appellant being with the child. As to whether she had gone to the market after being given money by the appellant or without taking money, in our view, cannot override entire of her testimony as also the testimonies of other witnesses. Further, the said witness PW-1 seems to have obviously lost the track of facts when she asserted in her deposition that the appellant was taken to the police station after the incident. It has clearly been established on record that the appellant was arrested in the late afternoon at the bus stand and it has nowhere been shown if she was taken to the police station immediately after the incident. A suggestion made in that regard to the official witness PW-10 has also been specifically denied by her. The said discrepancy in the version of PW-1 is also of no relevance and the concurrent findings of the two Courts cannot be displaced on that count. Even the version given in the complaint as if PW-1 saw the appellant strangling her child seems to be an overt assertion immediately after the incident. The other witnesses who had reached the scene of crime including the independent witnesses PW-4 and PW-5 have consistently maintained that the appellant was available with the dead body of the child at the place of, and immediately after, the incident. [Para 16.2][982-D-H; 983-A]
6. Taking an overall view of the matter, this Court does not find any reason that entire prosecution case be disbelieved and discarded because PW-1 has not projected the case in a consistent manner. Apart from the private witnesses, all the relevant facts have been duly established in the testimonies of the official witnesses too. The discrepancies as noticed in the present case, at the most, could be said to be of minor contradictions or inconsistencies or embellishments of trivial nature; and are reasonably referable to the reasons recounted by this Court in Bharwada Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai for which, the minor discrepancies do occur in evidence and excessive importance cannot be attached to them [Para 16.3][983-B-C]
7. The submission that the assertion about the appellant having strangled the victim, by pressing her saree around the neck, does not correlate with the post-mortem examination is also untenable. As noticed, the medical officers have clearly VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU A B C D E F G H 946 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
established that the child suffered strangulation with a wound measuring 20 cm in length and 2 cm in breadth around the neck and with thyroid cartilage bone having been fractured. PW8 also opined that if outer end of the saree was twisted and put around the neck and the person was strangled, there was a chance of such a wound. The saree in question had been duly recovered from the appellant and was said to be carrying blood stains. [Para 17][983-D-E]
8. In the given set of facts and circumstances, the motive as suggested by the prosecution, i.e., the desire of the appellant not to live in her matrimonial house and, on being forced to do so only because of the child, she being not interested in the existence of the child, though presents a somewhat difficult proposition but, at the same time, cannot be ruled out altogether, particularly looking to the fact that, until 18.06.2007, the appellant was living with her parents and she was forced to come to Perambalur for the purpose of upbringing of the child with the family of her husband. [Para 18][983-F]
9. Another submission made on behalf of the appellant, that her husband has not been examined by the prosecution, does not take her case any further. Her husband was not shown to be in the country at the time of incident and he was not a direct witness in relation to the material facts to be established by the prosecution. Other way round, if at all the appellant considered him to be a material witness, nothing prevented her from making a prayer to the Court for his examination and nothing prevented her from making specific submissions in that regard during her examination under Section 313 CrPC. [Para 19][983-G-H; 984- A]
10. As regards the statement under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant has not given any explanation whatsoever and has not made any statement except denying the circumstances put to her. In the facts of the present case, when the prosecution evidence categorically established the fact that the victim child was last seen alive with the appellant only; she was required to explain the circumstances leading to the demise of the child. Upon her failure to do so and failure to give the explanation with regard to the circumstances under which death may have taken place, A B C D E F G H burden of Section 106 of the Evidence Act operates heavily against the appellant, as noticeable from the decisions above referred, particularly in the cases of Satpal and Sabitri Samantaray . [Para 20][984-B-C]
11. The submissions made in the alternative that in the given set of circumstances, the present case could only be of culpable homicide not amounting to murder has only been noted to be rejected. Even if it be taken that there was a quarrel of the appellant with her mother-in-law (PW-1) in the morning of the date of incident because the appellant wanted to go the place of her father, it cannot be said that such a quarrel would make it a case of grave and sudden provocation. The circumstances as proved on record, and the manner of commission of crime, make it clear that the present case cannot be brought under any of the Exceptions of Section 300 IPC; and conviction and sentencing of the appellant under Section 302 IPC cannot be faulted. [Para 22][984-E-F] Pappu v. The State of Uttar Pradesh (2022) 10 SCC 321; Mekala Sivaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2022)
8 SCC 253; Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra (1984) 4 SCC 116 : [1985] 1 SCR 88;
Hanumant v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1952 SC 343 : [1952] SCR 1091; Shyamal Ghosh v. State of West Bengal (2012) 7 SCC 646 : [2012] 10 SCR 95;
Bharwada Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai v. State of Gujarat (1983) 3 SCC 217 : [1983] 3 SCR 280; Gangadhar Behera v. State of Orissa (2002) 8 SCC 381 : [2002] 3 Suppl. SCR 183; Gangabhavani v. Rayapati Venkat Reddy (2013) 15 SCC 298 : [2013] 14 SCR 155;
Ramnaresh v. State of Chhattisgarh (2012) 4 SCC 257 : [2012] 3 SCR 630; Satpal v. State of Haryana (2018)
6 SCC 610; Satye Singh and Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand (2022) 5 SCC 438; Sabitri Samantaray v.
State of Odisha 2022 SCC OnLine SC 673 – relied on.
Krishna Mochi v. State of Bihar (2002) 6 SCC 81 :
[2002] 3 SCR 1; Leela Ram v. State of Haryana (1999)
9 SCC 525 : [1999] 3 Suppl. SCR 435; State of VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU A B C D E F G H 948 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Rajasthan v. Kashi Ram (2006) 12 SCC 254 : [2006] 8 Suppl. SCR 501; State of Haryana v. Bhagirath (1999)
5 SCC 96 : [1999] 3 SCR 529; State of Rajasthan v.
Kalki (1981) 2 SCC 752 : [1981] 3 SCR 504 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1985] 1 SCR 88 relied on Para 8.6 [2012] 10 SCR 95 relied on Para 8.6 [2012] 3 SCR 630 relied on Para 8.6 [1952] SCR 1091 relied on Para 12.1 [1983] 3 SCR 280 relied on Para 9.1 [2002] 3 SCR 1 referred to Para 9.1 [1999] 3 Suppl. SCR 435 referred to Para 9.1 [2006] 8 Suppl. SCR 501 referred to Para 9.2 [2002] 3 Suppl. SCR 183 relied on Para 9.4 [1999] 3 SCR 529 referred to Para 9.4 [2013] 14 SCR 155 relied on Para 9.5 [1981] 3 SCR 504 referred to Para 9.5 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.762 of 2012.
From the Judgment and Order dated 09.03.2010 of the High Court of Madras in CRLP No.01 of 2010.
Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, Ms. Vandana Tiwari, Anurag Rana, Advs. for the Appellant.
Dr. Joseph Aristotle S., Ms. Nupur Sharma, Shobhit Dwivedi, Sanjeev Kumar Mahara, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.
1. This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 09.03.2010 in Criminal Appeal No. 1 of 2010, whereby the High Court of Judicature at Madras has dismissed the appeal against A B C D E F G H the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 15.10.2009, as passed by the Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Perambalur in Sessions Case No. 9 of 2008, holding the appellant guilty of the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 18601 and awarding her the punishment of imprisonment for life and fine of Rs. 2,000/- with default stipulations.
2. In a brief outline, it could be noticed that in this case, the appellant has been convicted of the offence of murder of her five-yearold child in the house of her mother-in-law at Perambalur in the morning of 21.06.2007. According to the prosecution case, the appellant’s husband was living abroad for earning livelihood and the appellant was mostly living with her father at Kolakkudi. However, on being forced to live with her mother-in-law for the purpose of upbringing and education of the child, she found the child to be an obstacle in her desire to live separate and hence, strangulated the child to death when her mother-in-law had gone out of the house. It was alleged that the appellant was last seen with the child and after having killed the child, when her mother-in-law and other witnesses reached the scene of crime, she ran away and was apprehended in the late afternoon at Perambalur New Bus Stand. As per the post-mortem report, the cause of death of the child was asphyxia because of strangulation. In the trial, all but one prosecution witnesses supported the accusations against the appellant. Only the father of the appellant deposed to the contrary and asserted that at the relevant point of time, the appellant was with him at Kolakkudi and he accompanied her to Perambalur after receiving information about death of the child. After appreciation of evidence, the Trial Court, in its judgment dated 15.10.2009, rejected the plea of alibi taken on behalf of the accusedappellant and held proved that the victim child died of asphyxia because of strangulation and was last seen alive with the appellant, who failed to explain the circumstances in which the child died. Hence, the appellant was convicted of the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC and was sentenced accordingly. In appeal, the High Court concurred with the findings of the Trial Court while holding that the ingredients establishing culpability of the appellant were clearly established on record.
2.1. In this appeal, the concurrent findings of the two Courts have been questioned essentially with reference to certain discrepancies in the version of the prosecution witnesses and on the ground that the 1 ‘IPC’, for short.
VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 950 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
prosecution has failed to establish a chain of cogent circumstances which could lead to the only hypothesis that the appellant had killed her own child. These submissions have been countered with reference to the evidence of the prosecution and findings of the two Courts.
3. Having regard to the submissions made and the questions arising for determination, we may take note of the relevant factual and background aspects as follows:
3.1. In this case, the First Information Report2, bearing No. 328 of 2007 was registered at Perambalur Police Station at around 9.00 a.m. on 21.06.2007 on the information furnished by PW-1 Basheera, motherin-law of the appellant, about killing of the victim child by her own mother, that is, the appellant. The relevant contents of the FIR, said to have been scribed by PW-10 Subbulakshmi, SI, Perambalur, read as under:3 - “…As my grand daughter is 5 years old, my son had spoken from Riyat to Kolakkudi and said that she has to go to Perambalur and stay in my house and educate the child. Hence, Vahida was brought by her father on 18.6.07 along with grand daughter Farhana and dropped in my house at Perambalur. For two days after her arrival she did not properly have the food and also did not speak to me properly and my daughter-in-law Vahida picked up quarrel with me and was telling me that she is going to Kolakkudi. As I had warned her not to go to Kolakkudi, she was telling that only because of this child, I could not live peacefully. My husband is suspecting me. You are also not allowing me to go to Kolakkudi. Only if I finish off this child, I shall live peacefully. I, my daughter Mumtaz, my 2nd daughter-in-law Asha, and the Kamala, my neighbour together had warned her on the night of 20.6.2007. On 21.06.2007 at about 8.00 A.M. I said that I will go and get idli for the child. She said that I could not educate my child here and she wanted to go to Kolakkudi. Hence, there was a quarrel picked up between me and my daughter-in-law Vaheetha. I told her let us see and went to get the idli. By that time, my daughter Mumtaz and my daughter-in-law Asha came to see me. I being left the home for buying idli without taking money went along with them came to house to take the money. By that time my daughter-in-law Vaheetha, was tying the neck of my grand daughter Farhana who 2 ‘FIR’, for short.
3 The extractions in this judgment are from the translated copies placed on record. A B C D E F G H is aged five years with the outer end of a saree (mundanai) portion of her saree and was holding it tight. After seeing this I shouted why are you killing my grandchild. Besides, holding my grandchild’s neck with the saree and killing her, she had pushed us and ran away through the entrance. The neighbours Kamala and Jayaraman came running there, after hearing my scream. I touched the child. She was dead…”
3.2. After registration of the FIR (Ex.P10), PW-12 Thiru G. Ayyanar, the first Investigating Officer4 reached the place of occurrence, photographs of the dead body (Ex. P11) were taken; the rough sketch (Ex. P12) and inquest report (Ex. P13) were prepared; and the dead body was sent for post-mortem examination. As per the post-mortem report (Ex. P5), there was a wound around the neck of the victim child measuring 20 cm in length and 2 cm in breadth; and victim died due to asphyxia because of strangulation.
3.3. According to the first IO, PW-12 Thiru G. Ayyanar, the appellant was arrested at about 5.00 p.m. near a ladies washroom at the Perambalur New Bus Stand, i.e., approximately nine hours after the occurrence. It was alleged that after her arrest, the appellant identified the saree by which the child was strangulated; that the saree allegedly carrying blood-stains was seized in the presence of attesting witnesses; and that following her arrest, the appellant made a confessional statement that was recorded by PW-12 in the presence of witnesses. Later on, the investigation was taken over by PW-14 D. Sivasubramanian, who filed the charge-sheet for the offence under Section 302 IPC against the appellant. After committal, and upon denial of charge by the appellant, the case was tried as Sessions Case No. 9 of 2008 by the Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Perambalur.
4. In trial, a total of fourteen witnesses were examined by the prosecution. The first witness PW-1 Basheera, mother-in-law of the appellant and the informant, was examined as the key witness related with the occurrence. Four other witnesses, PW-2 Mumtaz, daughter of PW-1; PW-3 Asha Begum, other daughter-in-law of PW-1; PW-4 Sharfunisha, landlord of PW-1; and PW-5 Thiru-Jothi, neighbour of PW- 1 were claimed to be the witnesses who reached the scene of crime immediately after the occurrence. PW-8 Dr. Saravanan and PW-13 Dr. 4 ‘IO’, for short.
VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 952 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Karthikeyan A. testified respectively to the post-mortem report and the report with respect to the thyroid cartilage bone of the victim child. PW- 9 Devaraj, Village Administrative Officer and PW-7 Sadiq Ali were examined as attesting witnesses related with the process of investigation. PW-10 Subbulakshmi had recorded the statement of PW-1 and scribed the FIR whereas PW-11 Mohammed Munwar Khan was the photographer who had taken photographs at the scene of occurrence. As noticed, PW-12 Thiru G. Ayyanar carried out the initial investigation whereas PW-14 D. Sivasubramanian, SI, Perambalur completed the investigation and filed charge-sheet. Apart from these witnesses who supported the prosecution case, there had been another witness PW-6 Jamal Mohammed, father of the appellant, who stated to the contrary and asserted that the appellant was with him at his village Kolakkudi. In other words, this witness supported the appellant’s plea of alibi.
5. Though elaboration of the entire prosecution evidence is not necessary for the purpose of the present appeal, but having regard to the contentions urged, we may take note of the relevant part of depositions, particularly in reference to certain inconsistencies/ discrepancies in the assertions of the prosecution witnesses as also in reference to the appellant’s plea of alibi.
5.1. PW-1 Basheera has been the key witness for the prosecution. In her testimony, she stated that her son Abdul Raheem had married the appellant; that a female child was born to the appellant after the marriage; and that Abdul Raheem was sending all the money earned by him to the appellant. She further stated that Abdul Raheem had called her to say that his daughter should be admitted in a school in Perambalur and he would send her money for that purpose; and subsequently, on 18.06.2007, PW-6 Jamal Mohammed, father of the appellant, dropped the appellant and the child to the house of PW-1 with request to educate the child in Perambalur since Abdul Raheem was allegedly not sending the appellant any money. She stated that on the morning of 21.06.2007, the appellant gave her Rs. 100 and asked her to buy idli; that when she came back to the house, the appellant was sitting silently next to the child; and that upon asking, the appellant told her that she had killed the child. During cross-examination, this witness stated that she went to the police station with the appellant immediately after the occurrence. The relevant parts of her statement read as under: - A B C D E F G H “……About 10 months ago, 18th day of 6th month, my daughterin-law’s father Jamal Mohammed had brought his daughter, the margin accused and our grand child to my house at Perambalur. My daughter-in-law’s father was telling his daughter, the margin accused, that on the next day, 19th he would be leaving to his village and she has to take care of everything. The margin accused told her father that she would take care. On the next day 19th, the accused’s father went back to his village. On the next day to that, on 20th Wednesday we cooked and had our food and were available in the house of my daughter Mumtaz. ….. I am residing separately after 4 or 5 houses from her house. (the witness repeats the same.) I told the margin accused to come to my house along with her daughter and we would admit the grand daughter in school. The accused said OK for the same and on that day Wednesday, night, I, the accused and the grand daughter Farhana three of us went to the house wherein I am staying as a tenant for our sleep. In the morning of the next day, at about 6.00 A.M. I went to get the society milk. … I bought the milk and made tea and gave to her. Thereafter I told her that I would get meat. For that the margin accused said that no need of getting meat, and gave me Rs.100/and asked me to get idli. It would be around 7.00 A.M. I came to Farmers’ market. It took some time. By that time I got the change for Rs.100/- and got the idli and came back to home. On the same day, i.e. 21st at 6.00 A.M. my son Abdul Raheem had called my daughter Mumtaz from abroad. The said information was given to me by my daughter Mumtaz on the way to home after getting the idli, as the house of my daughter Mumtaz is situated on the way….. I bought the idli and went to my house. The tea which was kept by me in a glass was there as it is. That tea was kept by me for my grand daughter. It was there as it is. By that time the accused Vahida was sitting near my grand daughter who was lying there. I told the details given by Mumtaz to me and asked her to wake up grand daughter and give her the tea. For that the accused was sitting quiet. When I was telling the accused about the admission of my granddaughter into school and she has to talk to my son Abdul Raheem over phone, the accused asked me where is the police station. I asked the accused, “What I am telling you. What you are asking me.” For that the margin accused said that she had killed her daughter. I told her, “none of the mother VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 954 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
who gave birth to a child will kill the child. You are telling lie”. For that the margin accused said that really she had killed her child. When I was telling the accused that she is telling lie once again, my daughter Mumtaz and my middle daughter-in-law Asha Begum both of them came into my house. Again I told the accused “You are telling lie.” And asked her to wake up the child. But again the accused said that she had killed the child, I shook the head of my grand daughter. There was blood out of my grand daughter’s nose. My grand daughter Farhana was dead. When I saw that my grand daughter was dead and came out shouting, as said by me earlier, my daughter Mumtaz, my middle daughter-in-law Asha begum came there. The people also gathered. I had giddiness. They took me to the neighbouring house and made me to sit there. Anwar Basha had made phone call. Police authorities came to our house. They called me to the police station and asked me. I told them all that had transpired. The police authorities recorded the same. I had affixed my left thumb impression in the same. That was shown to me. When the witness was shown the complaint dated 21.6.2007 and asked about the same, as the witness had accepted the same the above said complaint had been marked as Ex.P1. ….. The accused told me that she had put the saree outer end of a saree (mundanai) around her neck and murdered her. When the police authorities examined me I deposed what had happened.
Cross Examination: On the date of the death of my grand daughter, at about 8.30 A.M. the police authorities came to our house. After the police authorities came, seeing that the child was dead, the police authorities brought me and the margin accused, my daughterin-law to the police station. I had deposed the same particulars that I had deposed in the chief examination, in the police station also. If anyone call loudly in front of my house, it would be heard by the persons in the house of my daughter Mumtaz. My son Shamsudeen and his wife Asha Begum both were staying in a house in some other street. When I bought idli and came back, Asha Begum and Shamsudeen were not available in the house of my daughter Mumtaz……. If it is said that as we did not take any steps to admit our grand daughter in the school, on 20th morning the father of the accused had left our grand daughter Farhana in our house and left for Kollakudi village, it is incorrect. When I saw the child was dead and when I came out of the house and A B C D E F G H shouted at about 10 or 15 feet distance, Mumtaz and Asha Begum were coming. The name of my house owner is Majid. I was residing in a portion of the portico which was covered with asbestos sheet. It has only one door. As the place wherein I resided is a portico, there are no windows. When I got the idli and came back, the door of the house was closed tight. I had knocked it strongly and opened. …. It is incorrect to state that I had not deposed during the police investigation that on the next day at 6.00 A.M. I went to get the society milk and brought the milk. It is incorrect to state that I had not deposed during the police investigation that after making the tea and giving it to my daughter-in-law the margin accused gave me Rs.100/- to get idli and that I went to the farmer’s market to get the idli and when I got the idli and was coming back, through my daughter Mumtaz she said that Abdul Raheem spoke to my daughter Mumtaz over phone. It is incorrect to state that as deposed during my chief examination, I did not mention in the complaint statement as well as during the police investigation, that when I came back the tea which had been kept for my grand daughter was as it is, and that when I asked the accused, why she did not wake up granddaughter and give her the tea, she was sitting quiet, and that when I asked again the accused said that she had killed the child. … My eldest son Jamal Mohammed and my another son Shamsudeen, alone were sending money to be from abroad. It is incorrect to state that as Abdul Raheem did not take care of me, after his marriage, I am angry with him. It is incorrect to state that in the event that my son Abdul Raheem and the accused did not take care of me, they had handed over my grand daughter Farhana to me. If it is said that on account of this anger, I and my daughter Mumtaz colluded and murdered my grand daughter, it is false. If it is said that Shamudeen who came from abroad had given the money and by using his influence, had used me and made a false case to be filed against the accused, all of them are wrong. If it is said that after hearing the news of the child’s death, the accused who came to Perambalur at 5.00 P.M. from Kollakudi Village, was taken by all of us and handed over to the police, all are incorrect.”
5.2. The testimony of PW-2 Mumtaz, daughter of PW-1, assumes relevance in view of her close connectivity with the occurrence, as asserted by PW-1. The relevant parts of her statement read as under: - VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 956 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
“…..The name of the daughter of the margin accused is Farhana. The child died on the 21st day of June, 2007. Two days earlier, the accused and her daughter stayed at Perambur as guests. My mother is residing separately in a house which is away slightly from my house. By that time, along with my mother, the margin accused and her daughter were staying when they came to Perambalur. The accused and her daughter were residing in my mother’s house separately. On the date of incident, between 7.30 to 8.00 A.M. my mother went to get idli. When my mother got idli and went home, my mother shouted. People gathered there. We went to that place. I saw that the accused’s daughter was dead…..When I asked margin accused, she said that she had killed the child. (The witness once again said this). At about 7.00 A.M. on that day, my younger brother Abdul Raheem had called me over phone and said that Vahida i.e. the margin accused should not go anywhere and that the accused’s daughter has to be admitted in the school. My younger brother Abdul Raheem told me over phone that I have to tell the accused to admit the school in Perambalur and to stay along with my mother. When my mother got idli and came back, I told the details as said by my younger brother, Abdul Raheem over phone. My younger brother told me over phone to bring the margin accused and keep her in my house and before I could do the same, the incident had taken place. When I saw, Farhana was dead with the blood coming out of the nose and mouth. When the police authorities examined me, I deposed the above details. That is all.
Cross Examination: After my mother got idli she shouted within 5 minutes. By that time 20 or 30 persons gathered there. Immediately, between 9.30 and 9.45 A.M. the police authorities came there. When I went and saw and asked the accused, the accused was silent and this had been deposed by me in the chief examination and the same had not been deposed during the investigation by the police authorities. I did not depose during the investigation by the police authorities about the phone call from Abdul Raheem at 7.00 A.M. on that day, and the details of conversation and also about my informing the same to my mother, as I had deposed in my chief examination…. After the marriage the accused and her husband did not have smooth relationship with my mother. In these circumstances, if it is said that the accused had left her daughter A B C D E F G H for educating her in my mother’s house and on 20th she went to Kolakkudi Village they are all false. The reason for the death of the child who had been left as such is me and my mother, they are all false.”
5.3. PW-3 Asha Begum, the other daughter-in-law of PW-1, also allegedly reached the scene of occurrence at the relevant point of time. She allegedly asked the appellant as to why she killed the child but the appellant did not answer. During her cross-examination, this witness mentioned that she was not speaking to the appellant for four years prior to the occurrence. The relevant parts of her statement read as under: - “….The margin accused had a daughter by name Farhana. She died on 21.6.2007. On the date of incident, the accused, her daughter were staying in the house, wherein Basheera was staying, along with P.W.1 Basheera. After my mother-in-law got the idli, when she shouted, I and my sister-in-law Mumtaz went to the house of my mother-in-law. My mother-in-law was residing in a house 5 houses away from my house. When I went there and saw, the child of the accused was instable. One nurse came and saw the child and confirmed that the child was dead. My sisterin-law Mumtaz had said accused “Why did you do like this. If you do not like the child, you would have left her with me” and she was beating on her head. I also asked the accused “You are an educated woman. Isn’t it? Why did you kill the child” and shouted at her. The accused did not speak anything. When the police authorities examined me, I deposed the above said particulars. If it is asked who is the cause for the death of Farhana, her mother is the sole reason. That is all.
Cross-examination: I had deposed the facts which had been said by me in the chief examination, during the police investigation also. On the date of incident, my husband came from abroad for his holidays. I and the margin accused are not speaking with each other for the past four years. Two days before the death of Farhana, the accused came with her child to our house. After she came, she asked my husband that the husband of the margin accused Abdul Raheem is not sending money to her and that he is also not calling her over phone, and that she wanted to educate her child Farhana. My husband asked the margin accused keeping silent for all these years, now you have come here. Thereafter, the VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 958 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
accused took the child and went to the house of my mother-inlaw. I did not say the details of my sister-in-law Mumtaz, asking the accused after seeing the dead body of the child, during the police investigation. It is incorrect to state that the accused is not the cause for the death of Farhana and that as there is no contact between me and the accused for the past four years, I am adducing false evidence against the accused. As the accused did not come to us, there is no contact between us.”
5.4. PW-4 Sharfunisha, the landlord of PW-1, deposed that when she came back to her house, she saw the child with the appellant. The witness also claimed that she heard the appellant admit that she had killed the child. The relevant parts of her statement could also be reproduced as under: - “… P.W.1 Basheera is residing in a portion of our house. At the time of the incident, the margin accused came as a guest to Basheera’s house. Only then I came to know her. Before that, I do not know the margin accused. The margin accused came with her child to the house of Basheera and stayed there. On 21.6.2007, the child of the accused was dead. I came to send my child to school by bus went near to Perambalur Farmers market and came back to my house, after sending my child. People were talking there that the accused had killed her child. When I saw that child, the margin accused was there. She said the crowd that she had killed her child by straggling with her saree outer end of a saree (mundanai) around her neck. I was there at that time. When the police authorities examined me I deposed the above particulars. Cross Examination: Basheera is residing in our house as a tenant with the monthly rent of Rs.350/- for the past two years. It is incorrect to state that I did not depose during the police investigation that I went to send my child to school and after sending my child, when I came back, I saw the crowd in my house. I did not tell the police authorities that the accused had said the crowd that she straggled the child with her saree outer end of a saree (mundanai). It is incorrect to state that I do not know the accused and that I had not seen the accused on the date of the death of her child. It is incorrect to state that as Basheera is our tenant, I am adducing false evidence.”
A B C D E F G H
5.5. PW-5 Thiru-Jothi, neighbour of PW-1, testified to have seen the appellant for ten minutes, when the appellant was sitting near the body of the deceased child. Her deposition could also be usefully reproduced as under: - “My name is Jothi. My father’s name is Veerasamy. I am residing at Perambalur. Witness Basheera is residing in the house next to our house. About 4 or 5 months ago, one day on the date of death of the child, I had seen the accused for 10 minutes. The margin accused’s child had passed away on that day. Only on the date of the death of the accused’s child, I had seen the margin accused when she was sitting near the dead body of the child in the house wherein witness Basheera was staying. By that time, it would be around 8 or 8.15 A.M. P.W.1 Basheera was crying and said the mother who gave birth to the child itself had murdered the child. I told her to go to the police station and not to do anything else. I told this at the time of police investigation.
Cross-examination: It is incorrect to state that I had not deposed the details as mentioned in the chief examination, during the police investigation. It is incorrect to state that I am adducing false evidence.”
5.6. As noticed, the prosecution examined two medical officers as regards post-mortem examination of the dead body of the victim child who testified to the injuries noticed on the dead body and as regards the cause of death. PW-8 Dr. Saravanan testified that there was a wound measuring 20 cm in length and 2 cm in breadth around the neck; and the thyroid cartilage bone was fractured, which was consistent with strangulation. He also opined that if outer end of a saree was twisted, put around the neck and strangled, there was a chance of such wound to the child. During cross-examination, he deposed that the wound would be more than 2 cm if a saree was tied around the neck. However, in reexamination, he clarified that the wound could be less than 2 cm if the saree was completely twisted in small measurement. PW-13 Dr. Karthikeyan A. has been the doctor who gave the report in respect of the thyroid cartilage bone. As per his examination, the fracture of the thyroid bone was ante-mortem and there was a chance that it was caused due to strangling. However, during cross-examination, he stated that if the neck is strangled using a saree, there is a less likelihood of marks. The fact that the victim child died due to asphyxia because of strangulation VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 960 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
is as such not a matter of dispute and hence, we need not elaborate on these testimonies.
5.7. As regards the police personnel related with this matter, PW- 10Subbulakshmi, Sub-Inspector of Perambalur, recorded the statement of PW-1 and scribed the FIR. She deposed that at around 9:00 am, PW- 1 came to the police station to file a complaint. During cross-examination, she clarified that PW-1 had not deposed in her original complaint that she had come out of her house and shouted after realising that the child was dead and had not brought the appellant to the police station immediately after the occurrence. She also denied the suggestions in the cross-examination that she visited the place of occurrence at 8:00 a.m. and brought the witnesses as also the appellant with her to the police station. The relevant extracts from the testimony of PW-10 are as under:- “…On 21.6.2007 at 9:00 A.M. when I was on duty, Basheera, wife of Mohammed Kasim, aged 65 years, residing at No. 230/ 48D, Cross Street, Renga Nagar, Perambalur, came to the station and had deposed the complaint and I recorded the same in writing. After deposing the complaint, I had read out the statement to Basheera. As she said that it was as deposed by her, and as she said that she did not know to sign, I had obtained her left thumb impression in the complaint… Cross Examination:…In the complaint that had been deposed to me it had not been indicated that after the incident was over, the margin accused was brought by the complainant Basheera to the Perambalur Police Station. When Basheera deposed, Anwar Basha was with her.… The witness Basheera did not depose in the complaint that after seeing that the child was dead, Basheera came out of the house, and shouted and thereafter the witnesses Mumtaz and Asha Begum came there. Basheera did not depose in the complaint that she went to get the society milk at 6:00 A.M. She did not depose in the complaint that when she bought the milk and came on the way she met her daughter Mumtaz at her house and talked to her. The witness Basheera did not depose in the complaint that after coming to house, the accused had given Rupees one hundred for getting idli and that she had taken the same and went to the farmer’s market to get idli. The witness Basheera did not depose in the complaint that after she came to the house, the house door was locked and she had knocked the A B C D E F G H door and opened the same. If it is said that after coming to know of the incident, I went to the place of incident at 8.00 A.M. itself and I had brought the witnesses, Basheera, Mumtaz and Asha Begum to the police station, they are all incorrect. If it is said that at that time, I had taken the margin accused along with the above said witnesses, it is also incorrect…”
5.8. PW-12 Thiru G. Ayyanar was the first IO in the case. He stated to have received the FIR at 10:15 a.m. on 21.06.2007 and commenced the investigation. For the purpose, he went to the place of incident and examined a few witnesses; prepared the mahazar; and seized the articles like mat and pillow. He also stated to have arrested the appellant at Perambalur New Bus Stand and having recorded her confessional statement in the presence of witnesses. He further stated to have seized the saree said to have been used in the offence. The relevant parts of his testimony read as under:
“…On the same day at about 17.00 hours, I had arrested the accused Vahida in the Perambalur New Bus Stand. I had examined the margin accused and recorded her confession statement before the witnesses Devaraj and Parameswaran. The margin accused said in her confession statement that she had killed the child by strangling her neck with the saree which she was wearing. The admitted portion of the confession statement had already been marked as Ex. P9. As per the confession statement, the saree which she was wearing was seized by me with the assistance of the lady police under the mahazar. The mahazar for the same was the one shown to me. That had already been marked as Ex. P8. The saree which was seized by me is the one shown to me. That had already been marked as M.O.3. …. Cross-Examination: In Ex.P8 Mahazar, it had been indicated that through the Sub-Inspector, Subbulakshmi the accused was given the alternate saree. The accused who was arrested at 5.00 P.M. on that day, was kept by me till 6.45 P.M. in the Perambalur New Bus Stand only. In the last portion of the confession statement, it had not been mentioned that the sub-inspector Subbulakshmi was sent to get the alternate saree. It had been indicated that the lady police had been sent and the alternate saree was brought… The evening newspapers which are published in Perambalur would come at 5.00 P.M. If it is said that in the Maalai Malar newspaper VAHITHA v. STATE OF TAMIL NADU [DINESH MAHESHWARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 962 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
dated 21.6.2007, which had been circulated at 5.00 P.M. on that day, it was indicated that the accused of this case had been arrested, I do not know of the same. I did not give such a news. If it is said that in the same newspaper, the news stating that the police authorities are conducting the investigation to witness Basheera, I do not know of the same. The witnesses Basheera and Mumtaz had deposed that after the incident was over, the margin accused ran from the house. If it is said that in the circulation of Dinakaran and Dinamalar newspapers, it had been indicated that after the incident was concluded, the mother of the child was lying down near the child, I do not know of the same. It is incorrect to state that after the death of the child the margin accused had ran away from the house and that we had published the news falsely stating that the margin accused was lying near the deceased child. It is incorrect to state that the witnesses Basheera, Mumtaz and Ashabegum had deposed during my investigation that they had seen that the child was dead. It is incorrect to state that on 20.6.2007 itself, the margin accused had left her female child to the witness Basheera, and she went to Kolakkudi Village on the same day. It is incorrect to state that on 21.6.07, the accused who was in Kolakkudi village had the information that her child was dead and that she came to Perambalur by bus and when she got down, I had arrested her….”
5.9. PW-14 D. Sivasubramanian had been the other police officer who carried out the later part of investigation, recorded the statements of other witnesses and then filed the charge-sheet. For the present purpose, we need not elaborate on the testimony of this witness or the other witnesses who had been a part of the investigation including the photographer and the attesting witnesses.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.