M/S Godrej Sara Lee Ltd v. The Excise and Taxation Officer-Cum-Assessing Authority & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 92; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 871
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Dipankar Datta Haryana Value Added Tax Act, Justice 2003 : Ss. 33 and 34 – Revision – As Regards, Justice Tax Liability On Mosquito Repellant Manufactured By the Appellant
- Decided
- 1 Feb 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5393/2010
- Sections
- 33, 34, 2, 7, 15, 57, 49
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 871[2023] 3 S.C.R. 871 M/S GODREJ SARA LEE LTD.
v.
THE EXCISE AND TAXATION OFFICER-CUM-ASSESSING
AUTHORITY & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No.5393 of 2010)
FEBRUARY 01, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.] Haryana Value Added Tax Act, 2003 : ss. 33 and 34 – Revision – As regards, tax liability on mosquito repellant manufactured by the appellant, the Revisional Authority suo moto called for the assessment records of appellant as found that the Assessing Authority erred in levying tax on mosquito repellant @ 4% instead of 10 % – It issued show cause notices and passed final revisional order enhancing the liability of the appellant to tax @10% instead of 4% – Writ petition thereagainst – High Court relegated the appellant to the alternative remedy of appeal u/s. 33, which it had not pursued – Justification of – Held: Mere availability of an alternative remedy of appeal or revision, which the party invoking the jurisdiction of the High Court u/Art. 226 has not pursued, would not oust the jurisdiction of the High Court and render a writ petition “not maintainable” – Availability of an alternative remedy does not operate as an absolute bar to the “maintainability” of a writ petition – Rule, which requires a party to pursue the alternative remedy provided by a statute, is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion rather than a rule of law – Hence, dismissal of a writ petition by a High Court on the ground that the petitioner has not availed the alternative remedy without examining whether an exceptional case has been made out for such entertainment would not be proper – Moreover, a jurisdictional issue raised in the writ petition questioning the very competence of the Revisional Authority to exercise suo motu power, was a pure question of law – Thus, the High Court erred in dismissing the writ petition – Constitution of India - Art.226.
s.34 – Revisional jurisdiction – Orders of the Revisional Authority seeking to revise the orders of the Assessing Authority pertaining to the Assessment Years – Held : Sine qua non for exercise A B C D E F G H 872 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
of power u/s. 34 is the satisfaction of the Revisional Authority that an order has been made by a taxing authority in any proceeding prejudicial to the interests of the State, the legality or propriety of which appears to him to be prima facie vulnerable.
Constitution of India : Art.226 – Writ – “entertainability” and “maintainability” – Difference between – Discussed.
Art. 226 – Writ – Entertainability of, when effective and efficacious alternative remedy available – Discussed.”
Judicial discipline: Principle of judicial discipline – Adherence to the decision of higher authorities – Unless the discipline of adhering to decisions made by the higher authorities is maintained, there would be utter chaos in administration of tax laws apart from undue harassment to assesse – On facts, nothing on record to justify either illegality or procedural/moral impropriety in the proceedings before the Assessing Authority or the orders passed by him, as such – To brand the order of the Assessing Authority as illegal, the same appears to be not only unjustified but also demonstrates thorough lack of understanding of the principle regulating exercise of suo motu revisional power by a quasi-judicial authority apart from being in breach of the principle of judicial discipline, while confronted with orders passed by a superior tribunal/Court – It is not the Assessing Authority’s orders but those passed by the Revisional Authority, which suffer from a patent illegality.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 It is axiomatic that the High Courts (bearing in mind the facts of each particular case) have a discretion whether to entertain a writ petition or not. One of the self-imposed restrictions on the exercise of power under Article 226 that has evolved through judicial precedents is that the high courts should normally not entertain a writ petition, where an effective and efficacious alternative remedy is available. It must be remembered that mere availability of an alternative remedy of appeal or revision, which the party invoking the jurisdiction of the high court under Article 226 has not pursued, would not oust the jurisdiction of the high court and render a writ petition “not maintainable”. Availability of an alternative remedy does not operate as an absolute bar to the “maintainability” of a writ petition A B C D E F G H and bar to the “maintainability” of a writ petition and that the rule, which requires a party to pursue the alternative remedy provided by a statute, is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion rather than a rule of law. Though elementary, it needs to be restated that “entertainability” and “maintainability” of a writ petition are distinct concepts. The fine but real distinction between the two ought not to be lost sight of. The objection as to “maintainability” goes to the root of the matter and if such objection were found to be of substance, the courts would be rendered incapable of even receiving the lis for adjudication. On the other hand, the question of “entertainability” is entirely within the realm of discretion of the High Courts, writ remedy being discretionary. A writ petition despite being maintainable may not be entertained by a High Court for very many reasons or relief could even be refused to the petitioner, despite setting up a sound legal point, if grant of the claimed relief would not further public interest. Hence, dismissal of a writ petition by a High Court on the ground that the petitioner has not availed the alternative remedy without, however, examining whether an exceptional case has been made out for such entertainment would not be proper. [Para 4][878-H; 879-A-F]
1.2. The appellant had claimed before the High Court that the suo motu revisional power could not have been exercised by the Revisional Authority in view of the existing facts and circumstances leading to the only conclusion that the assessment orders were legally correct and that the final orders impugned in the writ petition were passed upon assuming a jurisdiction which the Revisional Authority did not possess. In fine, the orders impugned were passed wholly without jurisdiction. Since a jurisdictional issue was raised by the appellant in the writ petition questioning the very competence of the Revisional Authority to exercise suo motu power, being a pure question of law, the plea raised in the writ petition did deserve a consideration on merits and the appellant’s writ petition ought not to have been thrown out at the threshold. [Para 9][881-B-D]
1.3. Ordering a remand is an available option. However, having regard to the lapse of time (almost a life term of fourteen M/S GODREJ SARA LEE LTD. v. THE EXCISE AND TAXATION
OFFICER-CUM-ASSESSING AUTHORITY
A B C D E F G H 874 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
years) since the orders impugned in the writ petition were made, it would not be in the best interests of justice to remit the matter to the High Court. Since prior to reserving judgment on this appeal, the parties were heard on the merits of the jurisdictional issue that the appellant had raised before the High Court, it is time to rule on the jurisdiction of the Revisional Authority. [Para 13][882-F]
1.4. Suo motu power of revision could be exercised by the Revisional Authority for the purposes of satisfying himself as to the legality or propriety of any order made in any proceeding which is prejudicial to the interests of the State. The first proviso, however, imposed a restriction on exercise of such suo motu power, if an issue had been settled, inter alia, by an appellate authority. Thus, the sine qua non for exercise of power under section 34 is the satisfaction of the Revisional Authority that an order has been made by a taxing authority in any proceeding prejudicial to the interests of the State, the legality or propriety of which appears to him to be prima facie vulnerable. Nevertheless, such power cannot be exercised if the issue involved is pending before or has been settled by an appellate authority. It cannot be disputed that the tribunal is comprehended within the meaning of ‘appellate authority’ as defined in section 2(b) of the VAT Act. [Para 27][888- D-F]
1.5. While deciding the present appeal, the Court is primarily concerned with the issue of assumption of jurisdiction by the Revisional Authority on the face of the unchallenged order of the tribunal dated 21st November, 2001, and not with the merits of the decision either given by the tribunal or by the Revisional Authority. What stares at the face of the respondents is that the said decision of the tribunal, quoted in the order of the Assessing Authority, has attained finality. Once the issue stands finally concluded, the decision binds the State, a fortiori, the Revisional Authority. The decision of the tribunal may not be acceptable to the Revisional Authority, but that cannot furnish any ground to such authority to perceive that it is either not bound by the same or that it need not be followed. The first proviso, in such a case, gets activated and would operate as a bar to the exercise of powers by the Revisional Authority. [Para 33][889-F-H; 890-A] A B C D E F G H
1.6. The Revisional Authority might have been justified in exercising suo motu power to revise the order of the Assessing Authority had the decision of the Tribunal been set aside or its operation stayed by a competent Court. So long it is not disputed that the tribunal’s decision, having regard to the framework of classification of products/tax liability then existing, continues to remain operative and such framework too continues to remain operative when the impugned revisional orders were made, the Revisional Authority was left with no other choice but to follow the decision of the tribunal without any reservation. Unless the discipline of adhering to decisions made by the higher authorities is maintained, there would be utter chaos in administration of tax laws apart from undue harassment to assesses. [Para 34][890-B- D] 1.7 The submission that suo motu power of revision, on the terms of section 34, could have been exercised only if the orders sought to be revised suffered from any illegality or impropriety, is accepted. [Para 36][890-F-G] 1.8 A decision may be questioned as suffering from an illegality if its maker fails to understand the law that regulates his decision making power correctly or if he fails to give effect to any law that holds the field and binds the parties. On the other hand, having regard to the purpose section 34 seeks to serve, to take exception to a decision on the ground of lack of propriety of any proceedings or order passed in such proceedings, it essentially ought to relate to a procedural impropriety. It is incumbent for the accuser to show that the decision maker has failed to observe the standard procedures applicable in case of exercise of his power. Additionally, to impeach an order on the ground of moral impropriety, it has to be shown that the weight of facts together with the applicable law overwhelmingly points to one course of action but the decision has surprisingly gone the other way, giving reason to suspect misbehaviour or misconduct in the sphere of activity of the decision maker warranting a revision. [Para 37][890-G-H; 891-A-B]
1.9. There is nothing on record to justify either illegality or (procedural/moral) impropriety in the proceedings before the Assessing Authority or the orders passed by him, as such. The M/S GODREJ SARA LEE LTD. v. THE EXCISE AND TAXATION
OFFICER-CUM-ASSESSING AUTHORITY
A B C D E F G H 876 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Assessing Authority was bound by the order of the tribunal and elected to follow it having no other option. Such decision of the tribunal was even binding on the Revisional Authority. In such circumstances, to brand the orders of the Assessing Authority as suffering from illegality and impropriety appears to be not only unjustified but also demonstrates thorough lack of understanding of the principle regulating exercise of suo motu revisional power by a quasi-judicial authority apart from being in breach of the principle of judicial discipline, while confronted with orders passed by a superior tribunal/Court. It is not the Assessing Authority’s orders but those passed by the Revisional Authority, which suffer from a patent illegality. [Para 38][891-C-E] 1.10 The impugned final revisional orders dated 2nd March, 2009 for the Assessment Years 2003-04 and 2004-05 is invalidated. [Para 39][891-E] Titagarh Paper Mills vs. Orissa State Electricity Board & Anr. (1975) 2 SCC 436 – held inapplicable.
Sonic Electrochem vs. S.T.O.(1998) 6 SCC 397 : [1998] 3 SCR 1102 – distinguished.
Union of India and Ors. Vs. Kamlakshi Finance Corporation Ltd. 1992 SUPP (1) SCC 443 – relied on.
Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. vs. State of Orissa (1983)
2 SCC 433 : [1983] 2 SCR 743; State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Mohd. Nooh [1958] SCR 595; Whirlpool Corporation vs. Registrar of Trade Marks, Mumbai and Others (1998) 8 SCC 1 : [1998] 2 Suppl. SCR 359;
Assistant Commissioner of State Tax vs. M/s. Commercial Steel Limited 2021 SCC OnLine SC 884; State of Uttar Pradesh & ors. vs. Indian Hume Pipe Co. Ltd. (1977) 2 SCC 724 : [1977] 3 SCR 120; Union of India vs. State of Haryana (2000) 10 SCC 482 – referred to.
Case Law Reference (1975) 2 SCC 436 held inapplicable Para 10 [1958] SCR 595 referred to Para 5 [1998] 2 Suppl. SCR 359 referred to Para 6 A B C D E F G H [1977] 3 SCR 120 referred to Para 8 (2000) 10 SCC 482 referred to Para 8 [1998] 3 SCR 1102 distinguished Para 20 [1983] 2 SCR 743 referred to Para 11 1992 SUPP (1) SCC 443 relied on Para 22 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.5393 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 12.10.2009 of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in WP No.9191 of 2009. V. Lakshmikumaran, Rajiv Tyagi, Ms. Apeksha Mehta, Charanya Lakshmikumaran, Rohit Gupta, Pranav Mundra, Ms. Falguni Gupta, Advs. for the Appellant.
Alok Sangwan, Sr. Adv., Sumit Sharma, Anurag Kulharia, Sandeep, Apoorv Yadav, Vipul Dahiya, Rajat Sangwan, Samar Vijay Singh, Kamal Mohan Gupta, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1. This appeal, by special leave, registers a challenge to an order dated 12th October, 2009 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh (hereafter ‘the High Court’, for short) dismissing Civil Writ Petition No.9191 of 2009 presented by the appellant and relegating it to the remedy of an appeal under section 33 of the Haryana Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (hereafter ‘the VAT Act’, for short).
2. Two questions emerge for decision on this appeal. First, whether the High Court was justified in declining interference on the ground of availability of an alternative remedy of appeal to the appellant under section 33 of the VAT Act, which it had not pursued. Should the answer to the first question be in the negative, we would next be required to decide whether to remit the writ petition to the High Court for hearing it on merits or to examine the correctness or otherwise of the orders impugned before the High Court.
3. It appears on a perusal of the order under challenge in this appeal that the appellant had questioned the jurisdiction of the Deputy Excise and Taxation Commissioner (ST)-cum-Revisional Authority, M/S GODREJ SARA LEE LTD. v. THE EXCISE AND TAXATION
OFFICER-CUM-ASSESSING AUTHORITY
A B C D E F G H 878 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Kurukshetra (hereafter ‘the Revisional Authority’, for short) to reopen proceedings, in exercise of suo motu revisional power conferred by section 34 of the VAT Act, and to pass final orders holding that the two assessment orders, both dated 28th February, 2007 passed by the ETOcum-Assessing Authority, Kurukshetra (hereafter ‘the Assessing Authority’, for short) for the assessment years 2003-04 and 2004-05 suffered from illegality and impropriety as delineated therein, viz. that the Assessing Authority erred in levying tax on mosquito repellant (a product manufactured by the appellant) @ 4% instead of 10%. Keeping in view the objection raised by counsel for the respondents that without exhausting the remedy of appeal provided by section 33 of the VAT Act “it would not be permissible to entertain this petition” and upon consideration of the decision of this Court reported in (1975) 2 SCC 436 (Titagarh Paper Mills vs. Orissa State Electricity Board & Anr.) based on which it was contended on their behalf that where any right or liberty arises under a particular Act then the remedy available under that Act has to be availed, the High Court was of the opinion that there can be no presumption that the appellate authority would not be able to grant relief sought in the writ petition; hence, the writ petition was dismissed and the appellants were relegated to the appellate remedy.
4. Before answering the questions, we feel the urge to say a few words on the exercise of writ powers conferred by Article 226 of the Constitution having come across certain orders passed by the high courts holding writ petitions as “not maintainable” merely because the alternative remedy provided by the relevant statutes has not been pursued by the parties desirous of invocation of the writ jurisdiction. The power to issue prerogative writs under Article 226 is plenary in nature. Any limitation on the exercise of such power must be traceable in the Constitution itself. Profitable reference in this regard may be made to Article 329 and ordainments of other similarly worded articles in the Constitution. Article 226 does not, in terms, impose any limitation or restraint on the exercise of power to issue writs. While it is true that exercise of writ powers despite availability of a remedy under the very statute which has been invoked and has given rise to the action impugned in the writ petition ought not to be made in a routine manner, yet, the mere fact that the petitioner before the high court, in a given case, has not pursued the alternative remedy available to him/it cannot mechanically be construed as a ground for its dismissal. It is axiomatic that the high courts (bearing in mind the facts of each particular case) have a discretion whether to A B C D E F G H entertain a writ petition or not. One of the self-imposed restrictions on the exercise of power under Article 226 that has evolved through judicial precedents is that the high courts should normally not entertain a writ petition, where an effective and efficacious alternative remedy is available. At the same time, it must be remembered that mere availability of an alternative remedy of appeal or revision, which the party invoking the jurisdiction of the high court under Article 226 has not pursued, would not oust the jurisdiction of the high court and render a writ petition “not maintainable”. In a long line of decisions, this Court has made it clear that availability of an alternative remedy does not operate as an absolute bar to the “maintainability” of a writ petition and that the rule, which requires a party to pursue the alternative remedy provided by a statute, is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion rather than a rule of law. Though elementary, it needs to be restated that “entertainability” and “maintainability” of a writ petition are distinct concepts. The fine but real distinction between the two ought not to be lost sight of. The objection as to “maintainability” goes to the root of the matter and if such objection were found to be of substance, the courts would be rendered incapable of even receiving the lis for adjudication. On the other hand, the question of “entertainability” is entirely within the realm of discretion of the high courts, writ remedy being discretionary. A writ petition despite being maintainable may not be entertained by a high court for very many reasons or relief could even be refused to the petitioner, despite setting up a sound legal point, if grant of the claimed relief would not further public interest. Hence, dismissal of a writ petition by a high court on the ground that the petitioner has not availed the alternative remedy without, however, examining whether an exceptional case has been made out for such entertainment would not be proper.
5. A little after the dawn of the Constitution, a Constitution Bench of this Court in its decision reported in 1958 SCR 595 (State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Mohd. Nooh) had the occasion to observe as follows: “10. In the next place it must be borne in mind that there is no rule, with regard to certiorari as there is with mandamus, that it will lie only where there is no other equally effective remedy. It is well established that, provided the requisite grounds exist, certiorari will lie although a right of appeal has been conferred by statute, (Halsbury’s Laws of England, 3rd Edn., Vol. 11, p. 130 and the cases cited there). The fact that the aggrieved party has another and adequate remedy may be taken into consideration by the M/S GODREJ SARA LEE LTD. v. THE EXCISE AND TAXATION OFFICER-CUM-ASSESSING AUTHORITY [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 880 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
superior court in arriving at a conclusion as to whether it should, in exercise of its discretion, issue a writ of certiorari to quash the proceedings and decisions of inferior courts subordinate to it and ordinarily the superior court will decline to interfere until the aggrieved party has exhausted his other statutory remedies, if any. But this rule requiring the exhaustion of statutory remedies before the writ will be granted is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion rather than a rule of law and instances are numerous where a writ of certiorari has been issued in spite of the fact that the aggrieved party had other adequate legal remedies. ***”
6. At the end of the last century, this Court in paragraph 15 of the its decision reported in (1998) 8 SCC 1 (Whirlpool Corporation vs. Registrar of Trade Marks, Mumbai and Others) carved out the exceptions on the existence whereof a Writ Court would be justified in entertaining a writ petition despite the party approaching it not having availed the alternative remedy provided by the statute. The same read as under:
(i) where the writ petition seeks enforcement of any of the fundamental rights;
(ii) where there is violation of principles of natural justice;
(iii) where the order or the proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction; or
(iv) where the vires of an Act is challenged.
7. Not too long ago, this Court in its decision reported in 2021 SCC OnLine SC 884 (Assistant Commissioner of State Tax vs. M/s. Commercial Steel Limited) has reiterated the same principles in paragraph 11.
8. That apart, we may also usefully refer to the decisions of this Court reported in (1977) 2 SCC 724 (State of Uttar Pradesh & ors. vs. Indian Hume Pipe Co. Ltd.) and (2000) 10 SCC 482 (Union of India vs. State of Haryana). What appears on a plain reading of the former decision is that whether a certain item falls within an entry in a sales tax statute, raises a pure question of law and if investigation into facts is unnecessary, the high court could entertain a writ petition in its discretion even though the alternative remedy was not availed of; and, unless exercise of discretion is shown to be unreasonable or perverse, this Court would not interfere. In the latter decision, this Court found the issue A B C D E F G H raised by the appellant to be pristinely legal requiring determination by the high court without putting the appellant through the mill of statutory appeals in the hierarchy. What follows from the said decisions is that where the controversy is a purely legal one and it does not involve disputed questions of fact but only questions of law, then it should be decided by the high court instead of dismissing the writ petition on the ground of an alternative remedy being available.
9. Now, reverting to the facts of this appeal, we find that the appellant had claimed before the High Court that the suo motu revisional power could not have been exercised by the Revisional Authority in view of the existing facts and circumstances leading to the only conclusion that the assessment orders were legally correct and that the final orders impugned in the writ petition were passed upon assuming a jurisdiction which the Revisional Authority did not possess. In fine, the orders impugned were passed wholly without jurisdiction. Since a jurisdictional issue was raised by the appellant in the writ petition questioning the very competence of the Revisional Authority to exercise suo motu power, being a pure question of law, we are of the considered view that the plea raised in the writ petition did deserve a consideration on merits and the appellant’s writ petition ought not to have been thrown out at the threshold.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.