Seemant Kumar Singh v. Mahesh Ps & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 272; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 587
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Krishna Murari, Justice The High Court Made Adverse Remarks Against the Appellants, Justice Who Had No Lis in the Proceedings – Further
- Decided
- 21 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 872/2023
- Sections
- 7, 439
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
SEEMANT KUMAR SINGH
v.
MAHESH PS & ORS.
(Criminal Appeal No. 872 of 2023)
MARCH 21, 2023
[KRISHNA MURARI AND AHSANUDDIN AMANULLAH, JJ.] Bail – Adverse remarks – Expunction of – During the pendency of bail proceedings of respondent no.1, the High Court made adverse remarks against the appellants, who had no lis in the proceedings – Further, the High Court issued direction for seeking reports against appellant no.2 during the bail proceedings – On appeal, held – Remarks made by High Court against appellant no.2 are unreasonable and without justification as appellant no.2 has no personal involvement in the case – No evidence against appellant no.2 has been analysed and no opportunity has been given to him to explain himself – Also, appellant no.3 is not a party to the bail proceedings, it was unreasonable to pass adverse remarks – Further, the direction issued by the high Court to seek reports against the appellant no.2 during bail proceedings of respondent no .1 is liable to be set aside as no opportunity of hearing was given to appellant no .2 and the High Court must have confined itself to the issues relevant to it for the purposes of deciding the bail of respondent no.1 – Adverse remarks passed by the High Court against the appellants expunged and order of High Court quashed.
Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD:1. As far as the Appellant No.2 is concerned, the remarks made by the High Court against him seem to be unreasonable and without justification. The Appellant No.2 is merely a government employee of the department that is conducting the investigation and has no personal involvement with the case. The Appellant No. 2 is not an accused and has nothing to do with the transaction of the crime, let alone the bail proceedings. No evidence against him has been analyzed by the court and no opportunity has been given to him to explain himself, however, scathing and egregious remarks have still been passed [2023] 3 S.C.R. 587 A B C D E F G H 588 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
against him. In such a scenario, this Court finds that the remarks passed by the High Court to be unfair and not in the interest of justice. [Para 18][594-A-B]
2. In so far as the Appellant No. 3 is concerned, even though he is an accused in the alleged crime, however, what must not be forgotten is the fact that he does not have any lis in the bail proceedings, as the same was exclusive to Respondent No.1. In such a scenario, where Appellant No.3 was not party to the ongoing bail proceedings, this Court finds it to be extremely unreasonable for the High Court to pass such adverse remarks against him. When no allegations were made against Appellant No.3, and the presumption of innocence is still functional in the favor of the Appellant No.3, this Court finds it to be a gross abuse of the process of law to pass such adverse remarks against him, as such remarks do not just cause injury to his reputation, but also has the potential to cause great prejudice to his actual trial. [Paras 19, 20][594-C-F]
3. The High Court during the bail proceedings of a third party are manifestly arbitrary and unjust, and the High Court must have confined itself to the issues relevant to it for the purposes of deciding the bail of the Respondent No.1. A court of bail, especially in cases where the bail is sought for by a third party, is not a court that has all the relevant information to pass an order on the merits of an unconnected party, and such an order, if passed, has the potential to cause great harm to the said party without them being afforded an actual and meaningful opportunity to defend themselves. It is a well settled principle of law that any party, when being accused of an illegal act, must be given an opportunity be fairly heard. This opportunity to be meaningfully heard however has not been afforded to the Appellant No.2. [Para 25][596-E-G] Niranjan Patnaik v. Sashibhusan Kar (1986) 2 SCC 569 : [1986] 2 SCR 470; State of M.P. v. Nandlal Jaiswal (1986) 4 SCC 566 : [1987] 1 SCR 1; Election Commission of India v. M. R. Vijaybhaskar (2021) 9 SCC 770; RBI v. Cooperative Bank Deposit A/C HR.
Sha (2010) 15 SCC 85 : [2010] 9 SCR 1107; State Represented by Inspector of Police v. M. Murugesan & A B C D E F G H Anr. (2020) 15 SCC 251 : [2020] 2 SCR 553; State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar and Others (2011) 14 SCC 770 : [2011] 15 SCR 540 – relied on.
Case law reference [1986] 2 SCR 470 relied on Para 15 [1987] 1 SCR 1 relied on Para 15 (2021) 9 SCC 770 relied on Para 17 [2010] 9 SCR 1107 relied on Para 22 [2020] 2 SCR 553 relied on Para 23 [2011] 15 SCR 540 relied on Para 24 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
872 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 07.07.2022 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in CRLP No. 4909 of 2022.
With Criminal Appeal Nos. 873 and 874 of 2023.
Nikhil Goel, A.A.G., Ranjit Kumar, Amit Kumar, Sr. Advs., Avijit Mani Tripathi, Shaurya Sahay, Mrs. Rekha Bakshi, Shubhranshu Padhi, Vishal Banshal, Ms. Rajeshwari Shankar, Niroop Sukrithy, Ovias Moh., Ms. Anand Sanjay M. Nuli, Suraj Kaushik, Dharm Singh, S. Shiva Swaroop, M/s. Nuli & Nuli, Advs. for the Appellant.
K.M. Nataraj, ASG, Raghavendra S. Srivatsa, Venkita Subramoniam T. R., Likhi Chand Bonsle, Ms. Komal Mundhar, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
KRISHNA MURARI, J.
Leave granted.
2. The present three Appeals are directed against the interim order dated 07.07.2022 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru, (hereinafter referred to as “High Court”) in Criminal Petition No. 4909 of 2022, whereby adverse remarks were made by the Ld. Single Judge of the High Court against the Appellants, and a direction was issued to the CBI, mandating them to investigate the past records of one of the Appellants.
SEEMANT KUMAR SINGH v. MAHESH PS & ORS.
A B C D E F G H 590 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
3. The Appellant in SLP (CRL.) No. 6253 of 2022 (hereinafter referred to as Appellant No. 1), is the State of Karnataka and the Appellant in SLP No. 6572 of 2022, one Mr. Seemant Kumar (hereinafter referred to as Appellant No. 2), is a senior IPS officer with 26 years of service, and is currently the Additional Director General of Police, Anti- Corruption Bureau. The Appellant in SLP (Crl) 6573 of 2022, one Mr. J. Manjunath (hereinafter referred to as Appellant No. 3), is the District Collector for the city of Bangalore. The Respondent Mahesh PS (hereinafter referred to as Respondent No.1) .
4. Briefly, the facts relevant for the present appeals are that during the pendency of bail proceedings of Respondent No.1, who is a police officer alleged to have taken a bribe, the High Court vide impugned interim order dated 07.07.2022 made adverse remarks against the Appellants, who had no lis in the above-mentioned bail proceedings.
5. On 20.05.2022, an FIR was registered under Section 7(a) of the Prevention Of Corruption Act against the Respondent No.1 herein, for allegedly demanding a bribe from the informant. The respondent no.1 was subsequently taken into custody.
6. The respondent No.1 then filed a bail application under Section 439 Cr.PC in the High Court. Notice was issued by the High Court in the said case, and on 22.06.2022, during the bail proceedings, the High Court issued an oral summons against the Appellants herein seeking their appearance in court. It is important to note that the Appellant 1 and Appellant 2 are not arraigned as accused persons in the said case and have no connection with the bail proceedings.
7. During the same bail proceedings, on 04.07.2022, the High Court made adverse remarks against the Appellants herein. These remarks made by the High Court were widely reported in the media and caused injury to the reputation of the Appellants.
8. Subsequently, on 07.07.2022, the High Court while making further adverse remarks against the Appellants, also directed the CBI to place a report of the past investigations conducted against the Appellant No. 2, without giving an opportunity to the Appellant No.2 to be heard.
9. It is however important to note that Appellant No.3 stands on a slightly different footing from the other Appellants, in so far as that the Appellant No.3, after the initial investigation, was arrayed as an Accused in the abovementioned case. In the same breath however, it must also A B C D E F G H be kept in mind that the Appellant No.3, even though is an accused in the said alleged crime, was not a party to the abovementioned bail proceedings in the High Court.
10. Through the present Appeals filed before this court, the Appellants seek for the remarks made by the High Court against them to be expunged.
QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO THE PRESENT
APPEALS
11. At the very outset, we would like to clarify that in the present appeals, we are only concerned with the adverse remarks made by the High Court against the appellants and the subsequent directions issued to the counsel of CBI against the Appellant No.2. The substantive prayer for bail sought for by the respondent No.1 is not being entertained by this court at the present, and the proceedings for the same are ongoing in the High Court.
12. In the aftermath of the aforesaid proceedings, this court is now tasked with answering two questions in the present Appeals. I. Whether the adverse remarks made by the High Court against the appellants during the bail proceedings of the respondent No. 1 is liable to be expunged?
II. Whether the direction issued by the High Court to seek for reports against the Appellant No.2 during the bail proceedings of the respondent no.1 is liable to be set aside?
ANALYSIS
ISSUE I-Whether the adverse remarks made by the High Court during the bail proceedings of the respondent No.1 is liable to be expunged?
13. The High Court, on 04.07.2022 and 07.07.2022, on two separate occasions, during the bail proceedings of the Respondent No.1, made adverse remarks against the Appellants herein, which is said to have caused great harm to their reputation. Due to the proceedings being broadcasted on the High Court’s YouTube channel, the said comments have received wide publicity, and several media and news outlets have picked up on those comments and reported the same.
SEEMANT KUMAR SINGH v. MAHESH PS & ORS.
[KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 592 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
14. It is to be noted that bail proceedings, unlike a full criminal trial, are burdened with the task of only forming a prima facie view on the merits of the case. In such a circumstance when the evidence is not fully analyzed, and a presumption of innocence is still operational in favour of the accused, the courts must then be extremely cautious in passing adverse remarks against the accused. This becomes especially important in cases where the party against whom the remarks are passed do not have a lis in the said proceedings, for such comments, especially if passed by constitutional courts, can cause great injury to the reputation of the parties at the receiving end of such remarks. This burden of caution on the courts has been held in a catena of judgments by this Court.
15. In the case of Niranjan Patnaik v. Sashibhusan Kar1, this Court, while examining certain remarks made by a High Court stated that the courts, while passing adverse remarks, must be extremely careful and must resort to passing such remarks only if it is necessary to come to fair conclusion in order to meet the ends of justice. The relevant paragraph of the said judgment is being extracted herein: “In expressing their opinions, Judges and Magistrates must be guided by consideration of justice, fair play and restraint, (…) the judges should not normally depart from sobriety, moderation and reserve and harsh or disparaging remarks are not to be made against the parties or authorities unless it is really necessary for the decision of the case as integral part thereof”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.