Commissioner of Income Tax 7 v. M/S Paville Projects Pvt. Ltd.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 325; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 310
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.R. Shah, Justice 2023 [m. R. Shah and A. S. Bopanna Jj.] Income Tax Act
- Decided
- 6 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6126/2021
- Sections
- 263, 143(3), 263(1), 55(1), 50A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 310 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 7
v.
M/S PAVILLE PROJECTS PVT. LTD.
(Civil Appeal No. 6126 of 2021)
APRIL 06, 2023
[M. R. SHAH AND A. S. BOPANNA JJ.] Income Tax Act, 1961 – s.263 – Exercise of jurisdiction under – Respondent filed its income tax return for the AY 2007-08, wherein it showed sale of the property / building for an amount of Rs.33 Crores – According to the assessee, property was sold to discharge encumbrances from the sale proceeds to pay off the shareholders and therefore, the said discharge of encumbrances was “cost of improvement” – Assessment accepted by AO u/s. 143(3) – However, the Commissioner invoked jurisdiction u/s. 263 of the IT Act and held that the assessment order passed u/s.143(3) of the IT Act was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of the revenue – Commissioner set aside the assessment order passed by the AO – ITAT concluded that the Commissioner wrongly invoked the jurisdiction u/s. 263 of the IT Act and upheld the allowability of the Assessee’s claim – Appeal against the ITAT’s order was dismissed by the High Court – On appeal, held: Applying the law laid down in the case of Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. and on perusal of the the assessment order as well as the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax, the Court is of the opinion that the assessment order was not only erroneous but prejudicial to the interest of the Revenue also – In the facts and circumstances of the case, it cannot be said that the Commissioner exercised the jurisdiction u/s. 263 not vested in it – High Court committed a serious error – Impugned Judgment and order passed by the High Court set aside and that the order passed by the Commissioner passed in exercise of powers u/s. 263 of the Income Tax Act is restored.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1. It is true that in Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd., on interpretation of Section 263 of the Income Tax Act, it is observed and held that in order to exercise the jurisdiction under Section 263(1) of the Income tax Act, the Commissioner has to be satisfied [2023] 3 S.C.R. 310 A B C D E F G H of twin conditions, namely, (i) the order of the Assessing Officer sought to be revised is erroneous; and (ii) it is prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. It is further observed that if one of them is absent, recourse cannot be had to Section 263(1) of the Act. [Para 7.1][318-E-F]
2. Even as observed in the case of Malabar Industrial Co.
Ltd. that the scheme of the Act is to levy and collect tax in accordance with the provisions of the Act and this task is entrusted to the Revenue. It is further observed that if due to an erroneous order of the Income Tax Officer, the Revenue is losing tax lawfully payable by a person, it will certainly be prejudicial to the interests of the Revenue. However, only in a case where two views are possible and the Assessing Officer has adopted one view, such a decision, which might be plausible and it has resulted in loss of Revenue, such an order is not revisable under Section 263 [Para 7.2][320-A-C]
3. Having gone through the assessment order as well as the order passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax, we are also of the opinion that the assessment order was not only erroneous but prejudicial to the interest of the Revenue also. In the facts and circumstances of the case, it cannot be said that the Commissioner exercised the jurisdiction under Section 263 not vested in it. [Para 7.3][320-D-E] Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. Vs. CIT (2000) 2 SCC 718 : [2000] 1 SCR 744 : (2000) 243 ITR 83 (SC) – relied on.
CIT Vs. Smt. Shakuntala Kantilal (1991) 190 ITR 56 (Bombay); Chemosyn Ltd. Vs. ACIT (2012) (25)
Taxxman.com 325 (Bombay) – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2000] 1 SCR 744 relied on Paras 3.4, 7.2, 7.3 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6126 of 2021.
From the Judgment and Order dated 18.09.2017 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in ITA No.78 of 2015.
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 7 v. M/S PAVILLE
PROJECTS PVT. LTD.
A B C D E F G H 312 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Balbir Singh, ASG, Piyush Beriwal, Ms. Chinmayee Chandra, Shyam Gopal, Shyam, Manish, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Advs. for the Appellant.
Firoze Andhyarujina, Sr. Adv., Maneck Andhyarujina, Neerav B. Merchant, Rajesh Kumar, Vinod Kumar, Advs. for the Respondent. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
M. R. SHAH, J.
1. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order dated 18.09.2017 passed by the High Court of Judicature, at Bombay in ITA No.78 of 2015 by which the High Court has dismissed the said appeal preferred by the Revenue, the Revenue has preferred the present Appeal.
2. The relevant assessment order concerning the present appeal is Assessment Year 2007-08.
3. The respondent assessee was engaged in manufacture and export of garments, shoes etc. It filed its income tax return for the AY 2007-08 wherein it showed sale of the property / building “Paville House” for an amount of Rs.33 Crores. That, the building “Paville House” was constructed by the assessee on the piece of land which was purchased in the year 1972. The said house of the company was duly reflected in the balance sheet of the company.
3.1 It appears that there had been litigation between shareholders of the Company being family members. Litigations in the Company Law Board and the High Court culminated in arbitration. In the arbitration proceedings, an interim award was passed whereby an amicable settlement termed as “family settlement” was recorded between the parties. As per the interim award, three shareholders viz. (1) Asha, (2) Nandita and (3) Nikhil were paid Rs.10.35 Crores each. According to the assessee, “Paville House” was sold to discharge encumbrances from the sale proceeds to pay off the shareholders and therefore, the said discharge of encumbrances was “cost of improvement”. As observed hereinabove, “Paville House” was sold for an amount of Rs.33 Crores. The assessee showed gains arising therefrom amounting to Rs.1,21,16,695/- as “long term capital gains” in the computation of their income for AY 2007-08. The working computation of capital gains was accepted by the AO, whereby the cost of removing encumbrances A B C D E F G H claimed (Rs.10.33 Crores paid to three shareholders pursuant to the interim award) was taken as “cost of improvement” and the deduction was claimed to remove encumbrances on computation of capital gains. On the balance amount capital gain tax was offered and paid. The assessment was completed on 15.12.2019 by the AO under Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act (for short “IT Act”) accepting the “long term capital gains” as per sheet attached in computation of income. 3.2 However, a notice dated 24.10.2011 was issued by the Commissioner of Income Tax-7 under Section 263 of the IT Act to show cause as to why the assessment order should not be set aside under Section 263 of the IT Act. The Commissioner vide its order dated 24.11.2011 held that the assessment order passed under Section 143(3) of the IT Act was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of the revenue on the issue relating to deduction of Rs.31.05 Crores claimed by the assessee as cost of improvement while computing long term capital gains. The claim of the assessee that the said payment was made by them towards settlement of litigation, which according to the assessee amounted to discharge of encumbrances and required to be considered as cost of improvement, was not accepted by the Commissioner as according to him it did not fall under the definition of “cost of improvement” contained in Section 55(1)(b) of the IT Act. According to the Commissioner, the expenses claimed by the assessee neither constituted expenditure that is capital in nature nor resulted in any additions or alterations that provide an enhanced value of an enduring nature to the capital asset. The Commissioner also held that the payment as contended, was not made by the assessee to remove encumbrances.
3.3 The Commissioner also held that provisions of sections 50A and 55(1)(b) of the IT Act have not been complied with and the assessment order is not framed in consonance with the provisions of the IT Act and thus the assessment order was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of the revenue. Consequently, the Commissioner set aside the assessment order passed by the AO with a direction to the AO to recompute the capital gains of the assessee in consonance with the provisions of the IT Act as discussed in the order.
3.4 The assessee approached the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short “ITAT”) by way of filing ITA No.16/MUM/2012 against the order passed by the Commissioner, passed under Section 263 of the IT Act. The ITAT relying upon the decision of this Court in the case of COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 7 v. M/S PAVILLE PROJECTS PVT. LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 314 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. Vs. CIT [(2000) 2 SCC 718 : (2000) 243 ITR 83 (SC)] concluded that the Commissioner wrongly invoked the jurisdiction under Section 263 of the IT Act. The ITAT also observed that there was no error on facts declared. The ITAT held that every loss of revenue as a consequence of AO’s order cannot be treated as prejudicial to the interest of the revenue, when two views were possible and AO took a view which CIT did not agree with. The ITAT also upheld the allowability of the assessee’s claim of deduction of payment made to the shareholders relying upon the decision of the Bombay High Court in CIT Vs. Smt. Shakuntala Kantilal [(1991) 190 ITR 56 (Bombay)]. The ITAT relying on the Tribunal’s order (Bombay Bench) in Chemosyn Ltd. Vs. ACIT [2012 (25) Taxxman.com 325 (Bombay)] held that the CIT’s observation of expenditure incurred for payment of shareholders not being deductible as incorrect. 3.5 The Department’s appeal against the ITAT’s order has been dismissed by the High Court by the impugned judgment and order wherein the High Court has confirmed the ITAT’s findings. The High Court agreed with the findings recorded by the ITAT that the claim for deduction of Rs.31.05 Crores was for ending the litigation and the litigation ended only when the building was sold and the payment was made as per the direction of the Company Law Board as well as the interim arbitral award and therefore, the same was deductible under Section 55(1)(b) of the IT Act, as allowed by the AO.
3.6 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court dismissing the appeal preferred by the Revenue and confirming the order passed by the ITAT by which the ITAT set aside the order passed by the Commissioner passed under Section 263 of the IT Act, the Revenue has filed the present appeal.
4. Shri Balbir Singh, learned ASG appearing on behalf of the Revenue has vehemently submitted that the High Court has materially erred in dismissing the appeal preferred by the Revenue and confirming the order passed by the ITAT by which the ITAT set aside the order passed by the Commissioner passed in exercise of powers under Section 263 of the IT Act.
4.1 It is submitted that the High Court has not at all appreciated the fact that the view taken by the AO in allowing the expenses of Rs.31.05 Crores while computing the capital gain from sale of the land was erroneous and not as per the law as payments made to shareholders A B C D E F G H are neither expenses nor the said payments have any relation to the asset under consideration. It is further submitted that the High Court has also not properly appreciated that the claim of the assessee that amount of Rs.31.05 Crores paid by it in lieu of settlement of litigation would amount to discharge of encumbrances and therefore, requires to be considered as cost of improvement on the said property is bad in law. It is submitted that payment of Rs.31.05 Crores paid to the shareholders did not lead to acquisition of any interest in the asset already acquired by the assessee. It is submitted that the rights already enjoyed by the assessee on the said property were absolute. It is submitted that therefore the assessment order passed by the AO was erroneous, bad in law and prejudicial to the interest of the revenue and therefore, the same was rightly set aside by the Commissioner under Section 263 of the IT Act, which ought not to have been set aside by the ITAT.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.