Shramjeevi Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. v. Dinesh Joshi & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 275; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 1069
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Dipankar Datta National Green Tribunal Act, Justice A Man-Made Lake/Reservoir in Mandsaur, Justice Who Had Obtained Sanctions From the Nagar Palika Parishad And
- Decided
- 22 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5328/2016
- Sections
- 19, 22, 196, 195, 50
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 1069[2023] 3 S.C.R. 1069
SHRAMJEEVI COOPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY LTD.
v.
DINESH JOSHI & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 5328-5329 of 2016)
MARCH 22, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.] National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 –s.19 – Procedure and Powers of Tribunal –Held: NGT though not bound by the Code of Civil Procedure, is nevertheless bound by principles of natural justice – It is a judicial tribunal exclusively tasked with the duty of deciding environmental disputes and causes – In the present case, the NGT had to take into consideration that the nature of its directions meant that all those living or owning land near the Teliya Talab, a man-made lake/reservoir in Mandsaur, who had obtained sanctions from the Nagar Palika Parishad and the Town and Country Planning Department were condemned unheard–Also, the judgments of the courts in favour of the appellant-Society reveal that the 1.4 hectares owned by it for which conversion (from agricultural to non-agricultural use) was sanctioned, was sought to be cancelled on the ground that the land fell within the submergence area – The history of the previous litigation which the NGT was seized with reveals that the land forming part of Khasra No. 1248, owned by the Society was directly in issue in a litigation to which the State was a party, and in which it lost – That decree was affirmed by all the courts –However, NGT chose to ignore this fact–Thus, in C.A. No. 5328-29/2016, the Society’s rights, title, and interest in respect of the land purchased by it for which construction permission was granted and in respect of which the decree was ultimately confirmed by the High Court shall not be disturbed or affected, in any manner –In all other appeals, the NGT shall consider the question of precise boundaries of the talab, after considering the report of a committee in the pending proceedings– Further directions issued–Principles of Natural Justice.
Doctrines/Principles –Principle of finality– Held: Parties are bound by the principle of finality which results in a decree by a competent court, acquiring a final and binding nature, especially A B C D E F G H 1070 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
where it is confirmed concurrently and upheld by the highest court of the land – Also, subsequent changes in law, cannot divest parties of the benefit derived by them in a litigation that attained finality, through a decree.
Pradeep Kumar Maskara v. State of West Bengal (2015)
2 SCC 653 : [2014] 13 SCR 540; Lekh Raj v. Ranjit Singh (2018) 12 SCC 750 : [2017] 7 SCR 542;
Ibrahimpatnam Taluk Vyavasaya Coolie Sangham v. K.
Suresh Reddy (2003) 7 SCC 667 : [2003] Supp 2 SCR 698 State of Andhra Pradesh v. T. Yadagiri Reddy (2008)
16 SCC 299 : [2008] 16 SCR 792; Sulochana Chandrakant Galande v. Pune Municipal Transport (2010) 8 SCC 467 : [2010] 9 SCR 476 – relied on.
Case Law Reference [2014] 13 SCR 540 relied on Para 12 [2017] 7 SCR 542 relied on Para 12 [2003] Supp 2 SCR 698 relied on Para 13 [2008] 16 SCR 792 relied on Para 13 [2010] 9 SCR 476 relied on Para 13 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 5328- 5329 of 2016.
From the Judgment and Order dated 17.02.2016 of the National Green Tribunal, Central Zonal Bench at Bhopal in O.A. No.100 of 2015 and dated 19.04.2016 in Review Application No.03 of 2016. With Civil Appeal Nos.1877 of 2023, 409-410, 407-408, 2370-2371 of 2021 And 10239 of 2018.
Brijender Chahar, A.N.S. Nadkarni, P.C. Sen, Ms. Meenakshi Arora, Sr. Advs., Sumeer Sodhi, Prannoy Joe Sebastian, Pulkit Agarwal, Azmat Hayat Amanullah, Ms. Pragati Neekhra, Vijay Assudani, Himanshu Shekhar Tripathi, Ambuj Dixit, Ms. Ankeeta A., Chandratanay Chaube, Advs. for the Appellant.
P.V. Yogeshwaran, A.A.G., Ms. Ankita Chaudhary, D.A.G., Aakash Nandolia, Mrinal Gopal Elker, Sunny Choudhary, Nishan Awanat, A B C D E F G H Nishant Awana, Yasharth Kant, Rahul Kaushik, Arjun Garg, Gopal Jha, Raghvendra Shukla, Shreyash Bhardwaj, Mishra Saurabh, Pulkit Agarwal, Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Vikas Bansal, Astik Gupta, Rajul Shrivastav, Mohit D. Ram, Ms. Monisha Handa, Anubhav Sharma, K. Krishna Kumar, Pai Amit, Ms. Komal Mundhra, Saurabh Agrawal, Abhiyudaya Vats, Ms. Pankhuri Bhardwaj, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.
1. Special leave granted in SLP (C) No. 12945/2018. In all these appeals, all respondents were served and had entered appearance. The original applicant before the National Green Tribunal (hereafter ‘NGT’) too had been served; an affidavit was filed on his behalf. He was however, not represented on the date of hearing. With consent of counsel for the parties, all appeals were heard finally.
2. These appeals, under Section 22 of the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 (hereafter ‘NGT Act’) and appeals by special leave1, question various orders2 of the National Green Tribunal which directed that the Nagar Palika Parishad, Mandsaur (hereafter ‘Parishad’), should desist from granting sanction to develop and construct properties in the vicinity of the “Teliya Talab” (hereafter ‘talab’), a man-made lake or reservoir in the city of Mandsaur.
3. The original applicant, Dinesh Joshi, preferred an application before the Central Bench of NGT, seeking directions for protection and conservation of the talab, alleging that construction permissions had been granted by the authorities, i.e., the Parishad and the State, to various private parties, and allowed construction upon a water body, resulting in depletion of the lake’s area, thus reducing availability of surface water. It was also further alleged that untreated domestic waste and industrial effluents were being discharged or dumped into the talab. The Parishad and the Town and Country Planning Department (hereafter ‘TCD’) filed replies, upon being issued notices.
4. The NGT, by its order dated 17.02.2016 (referred to hereafter as ‘the main order’) took note of the Parishad’s reply, as well as that of 1 Against order dated 10.7.2018 in WP No. 3484/2018 (PIL) of the Madhya Pradesh High Court 2 Dated 17.02.2016 in OA No. 100/2015; dated 19.04.2016 in RA No. 3/2016; dated 21.09.2020 in OA No. 17/2018; dated 18.11.2020 in RA No. 8 & 9/2020 and order dated 25.11.2020 in MA Nos. 9, 11 & 14/2020 SHRAMJEEVI COOPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY LTD. v.
DINESH JOSHI & ORS.
A B C D E F G H 1072 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
the TCD and relied on a ‘revenue trace map’ to say that the “Maximum Water Line” (hereafter ‘MWL’) had been shown and the land over which construction permission was given, i.e., Khasra. No. 1238, fell within the “Full Water Line” (hereafter ‘FWL’) as well as the MWL. It was observed that if the water was allowed to reach the maximum level, the lands would be submerged, as according to the NGT, they fell within the catchment area.
5. The appellants (except the appellant in the appeal by special leave) preferred review petitions, pointing to the fact that they had been given permission by the Parishad much earlier, and also drawing to the notice of the NGT that a Development Plan had been finally sanctioned in 2003, in terms of which a green area abutted the talab, beyond which a public road had been sanctioned and built, and further that their lands lay beyond this road. It was argued that in these circumstances, the NGT should review its order, as they were not heard before the main order was made.
6. The appellant in C.A. No. 5328-29/2016 (hereafter called ‘the society’) additionally urged that the lands owned by it were allotted a long time earlier to it, and that its use for construction of residential units to its members (who were workers, belonging to the poorer segments of society) became a subject matter of a previous litigation, whereby the state authorities had cancelled the conversion certificate, on the ground that the lands fell in the submergence area. The society filed a suit, which was decreed by the trial court3; the state’s appeal was dismissed4 and its second appeal before the Madhya Pradesh High Court, met the same fate, i.e., dismissal5. It was also pointed out that the special leave petition filed by the State too, was dismissed6 by this court.
7. The NGT, however, dismissed all the review petitions before it, by the impugned orders. On the basis of certain representations and letters, the Collector, District Mandsaur constituted a committee of seven officials from the revenue department for the purposes of investigating and submitting the latest report with respect to the boundaries of the 3 By order dated 24.12.1994 passed by the Civil Judge First Class, Mandsaur in CS No. 524A/88 4 By order dated 18.05.2001 passed by the Additional District Judge in RCA No. 80A/ 5 By order dated 23.06.2011 of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in SA No. 415/2001 6 By order dated 08.02.2016 in SLP (CC) No. 2066/2016 A B C D E F G H talab. Based upon the report received, the Collector issued an order on 06.06.2017. The material portion of that order reads as follows: “the aforesaid investigation team got the demarcation done vide the Land Record District Mandsaur Letter Number 1316/ MP/2016 dated 18-05-2016 and from team comprising 21 officers/employees on 04-06-2016 and 06-06-2016 and punching, report and map were submitted. As per the Panchnama, and Report and for clarifying of the facts/ removal of errors mentioned in the application concerned with the Applicant regarding MWL of Telia Talab, situated at Kaba Mandsaur the Demarcation team notified the MWL limits of Telia talab to the employees of Municipal Council and Water Resources at the spot and permanent boundary signs were established, which are mentioned in the map with Green ink. After MWL signs, the colonies are not in submerged area.
The survey numbers mentioned above the green ink of the map are recognised beyond the limits of MWL. After marking MWL signs, the permission of construction can be granted. I examined the case and minutely perused the aforesaid investigation report, Panchnama, and map submitted by the Committee constituted by this Court. Being consented (sic satisfied) with the report of investigation team and as per the Mandsaur Development Scheme 2001, the MWL. (Maximum Water Level) Limit signs which are mentioned in Green ink and the demarcation map of MWL limits of Telia Talab in the report of Investigation Team, as the colonies situated outside the Signs are not submerged and hence, construction permission can be given to the colonies situated outside the signs. This map shall be a part of this order.”
8. The report submitted to the Collector and order made by him became the subject matter of controversy before the NGT. An application (No. 17/2018), objecting to the correction of the submergence area and the MWL, was filed by the applicant who moved the earlier O.A. No. 100/2015. The applicant’s grievance was that the NGT had prohibited any construction in the water bound area and within limits of the MWL and FWL of the talab. The argument made out was that the map prepared subsequently and taken on record by the Collector’s order dated 06.06.2017, could not be sustained. The Madhya Pradesh Pollution SHRAMJEEVI COOPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY LTD. v.
DINESH JOSHI & ORS. [S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.] A B C D E F G H 1074 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Control Board in its reply stated that the alteration of the boundaries of the talab did not fall within its jurisdiction. It was stated, however, that the Board had issued notice to the Parishad from time to time to comply with provisions of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974 (hereafter ‘Water Act’). This was recorded by the NGT in its order. It was further recorded that the Collector’s team had inspected the area and found that 10 colonies were existing within 3 kilometres from the talab, and further that untreated sewage water was being discharged in it. By its order dated 21.09.2020 (hereafter ‘second order’) the NGT severely chastised the State, the Parishad, and district revenue authorities, and directed them to immediately proceed to demarcate the water body and the area which was previously within the area of the water body, to ensure that it was not reduced in any manner. The NGT also prohibited grant of permission for construction without the demarcation of the area of the water bodies, and up to the MWL. It further directed that the entire Khasra No. 1238 should be protected and that the water body should not be disturbed.
Contentions of counsel for the parties
9. Ms. Meenakshi Arora, learned senior counsel appearing for the society, argued that the NGT’s impugned orders are erroneous on two counts. Firstly, that it did not consider or deal with the fact that the portions of KhasraNo.1238 was purchased by the society over four decades ago, with the hard-earned money of its members, who were lowly paid workers. They had faced litigation for over two and a half decades, when the conversion certificate issued to them, was cancelled on the ground that the lands fell within the submergence area (Doobkshetra). The society was constrained to file a suit for perpetual injunction, where the state was impleaded; the state relied on the deposition of an engineer from its irrigation department, who reiterated its stand. However, he was unable to point to any document or material in support of the state’s argument that the land fell within the submergence area. The state’s appeal was rejected; the first appellate court noted the state’s stand, which was contradictory, i.e., that the lands fell in the submergence area, and at the same time, that they were required for some construction. The state’s second appeal, and special leave petition were also rejected.
10. Ms. Arora urged, as the second limb of her submissions, that the doctrine of finality of judgement and res judicata applied to the A B C D E F G H facts of this case. The principle plays a vital role as it is based on a sound firm principle of public policy. The doctrine of finality has evolved with the objective of preventing unnecessary litigation under the colour and pretence of law. It also ensures an end to litigation, in public interest. The state, and all its agencies were bound by the decree of the courts, which had been confirmed up to this court. Learned counsel submitted that the order dismissing the special leave petition also held that the judgment of the High Court was justified.
11. Mr. A.N.S. Nadkarni and Mr. P.C. Sen, learned senior counsels, Mr. Sumeer Sodhi, Ms. Pragati Neekhra, Mr. Amit Pai, and other counsel, appeared for other appellants. Mr. Brijendra Chahar, learned senior counsel, and Mr. Yogeshwaran, learned Additional Advocate General (AAG) for Madhya Pradesh, appeared for the TCD and the Parishad respectively; and Mr. Saurabh Mishra, AAG, appeared for the state of Madhya Pradesh. They supported the submissions on behalf of the society, and urged that the NGT fell into serious error in not considering that the TCD had published the Development/Master Plan in 2001, which was finally approved on 12.05.2003. This forms the basis for development of Mandsaur. The existence of the talab, its boundaries, and the extent of its catchment area, were made known. No one objected to the plan, which designated a green area immediately adjoining the talab, after which a road was permitted. The development of residences and colonies was beyond this road. These facts were known to the general public. In this background, the applicant before the NGT persuaded it to issue orders based on a “trace” map, which had not been finalised.
12. Learned counsel submitted that after much inter-departmental correspondence between the Sub-Divisional Officer of Mandsaur, the Parishad and the Water Resources Department, as well as the Collector, finally a letter was addressed by the Sub-Divisional Officer, to the Collector, on 31.01.2022, which disclosed that the map shown to the NGT, based on which, it made its orders was “not originally a map, but a proposed map to depict a situation if the FTL of Teliya Talab were to be increased by one feet and which only bore the signature of Shri. L.N. Badgotia, the Sub-Divisional Officer of the Water Resources Department. This Map does not bear the signatures of any authorized Revenue Officer. The Map that was presented by Shri Santosh Rathore along with his request letter is in two pages and SHRAMJEEVI COOPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY LTD. v.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.