Modi Rubber Limited v. Continental Carbon India Ltd.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 246; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 1026
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.R. Shah, Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, Justice 1985 – Ss.18, Justice 19 – Approval of A Scheme By the Bifr Under the 1985 Act
- Decided
- 17 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 375/2017
- Sections
- 18, 22, 22A, 3, 19, 18(8), 32, 18(4), 19(1), 18(1), 18(2), 18(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 1026 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
MODI RUBBER LIMITED
v.
CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD.
(Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017)
MARCH 17, 2023
[M. R. SHAH AND SUDHANSHU DHULIA, JJ.] Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 – ss.18, 19 – Approval of a scheme by the BIFR under the 1985 Act, unsecured creditor if has the option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues – Held: No – Rehabilitation scheme u/s.18 shall bind all the creditors including the unsecured creditors and the unsecured creditors have to accept the scaled down value of its dues provided under the rehabilitation scheme – To make the company viable, the concerned persons including the unsecured creditors have to sacrifice to some extent otherwise the revival efforts shall fail – Looking to the object and purpose of the SICA, 1985 and the provisions of ss.18 and 19, the word “creditors” shall have to be construed in a broad manner and is not required to be construed narrowly – Creditors include unsecured creditors – Thus, if the scheme binds the creditors, including other creditors like financial institutions etc., who may have a better claim than the unsecured creditors, there is no reason to treat the unsecured creditors separately and not to treat them as creditors – Minority creditors and that too some unsecured creditors cannot be permitted to stall the rehabilitation of the sick company by not accepting the scaled down value of its dues – View taken by the Delhi High Court in Continental Carbon India Ltd. case that on approval of a scheme by the BIFR, the unsecured creditor has an option not to accept the scaling down value of its dues and to wait till the rehabilitation scheme of the sick company has worked itself out with an option to recover the debt with interest post such rehabilitation, is erroneous and contrary to the scheme of SICA, 1985 and is set aside. Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 – Scheme of the Act – Discussed – Constitution of India – Article 39. Constitution of India – Article 300A – Plea of the unsecured creditors that to compel them to accept the scaled down value of its [2023] 3 S.C.R. 1026 A B C D E F G H dues would be violative of Article 300A – Held: Has no substance – Scaling down the value of the dues is under the rehabilitation scheme prepared u/s.18 of the SICA, which has a binding effect on all the creditors – It cannot be said to be violative of Article 300A – Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 – s.18. Disposing of the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 The SICA, 1985 basically and predominantly is a remedial and ameliorative enactment, insofar as it empowers a quasi-judicial Body - BIFR to take appropriate measures for revival and rehabilitation of the potentially viable sick industrial companies as quickly as possible and also to salvage the productive assets and realise the amounts due to the banks and financial institutions, to the extent possible, from the non-viable sick industrial companies through liquidation of those companies. The primary concern of the Board would be the revival of the sick company and to save the sick company from winding up. That is why with a view to see that there is no impediment in framing the rehabilitation scheme and to get out the sick company from sickness. Section 22 provides for suspension of legal proceedings, contracts etc. On a bare reading of Section 22 and Section 22A of SICA, it appears that these two provisions primarily ensure that the scheme prepared by BIFR does not get frustrated because of certain other legal proceedings and to prevent untimely and unwarranted disposal of the assets of the sick industrial company. These sections clearly state certain restrictions which will impact upon the implementation of the scheme as well as on the assets of the company. [Paras 11.6, 11.8][1054-G; 1058-B-C] Tata Motors Limited vs. Pharmaceutical Products of India Limited and Anr. (2008) 7 SCC 619 : [2008] 9 SCR 267; Raheja Universal Limited vs. NRC Limited and Ors. (2012) 4 SCC 148 : [2012] 3 SCR 388; NGEF Ltd. vs. Chandra Developers (P) Ltd. (2005) 8 SCC 219 : [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 747 – relied on.
1.2 Under Section 18 of the SICA, 1985, it is the operating agency to prepare a scheme with respect to the sick company providing for any one or more of the measures mentioned in MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA
LTD.
A B C D E F G H 1028 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Section 18, which include:- (i) the financial reconstruction of the sick industrial company; (ii) such other preventive, ameliorative and remedial measures as may be appropriate. The operating agency is defined under Section 3(i) and it means any public financial institution, State-level institution, scheduled bank or any other person as may be specified by general or special order as its agency by the Board. No other persons including the unsecured creditors comes into picture like preparing the scheme under Section 18. Section 18 of the SICA does not provide that at the time of preparing of the scheme under Section 18 or when it is sanctioned by the Board, the unsecured creditors are required to be heard. The only provision for the consent required is Section 19 and the agency/person, who is required to give the financial assistance, its consent is required. Once the rehabilitation scheme / scheme under Section 18 prepared by the operating agency is sanctioned by the BIFR, which may include the scaling down the value of dues of the unsecured creditors, the same shall bind all, otherwise the rehabilitation scheme shall not be workable at all and the object and purpose of enactment of the SICA, 1985 will be frustrated. If some persons / unsecured creditors and/or even the labourers are permitted to get out of the purview of the scheme and thereafter permitting such or some of the unsecured creditors to wait till the scheme for rehabilitation of the sick company has worked itself out, in that case, the scheme shall not be workable at all. To make the company viable, the concerned persons including the unsecured creditors have to sacrifice to some extent otherwise the revival efforts shall fail. At this stage, it is required to be noted that if a sick company is ordered to be wind up, in that case, the unsecured creditors otherwise may not get anything. However, on the other hand on sanctioning the rehabilitation scheme under Section 18, the unsecured creditors may get part of their dues /debts, which otherwise, they may not get. At this stage, it is required to be noted that as per Section 18(8) of SICA, 1985, which has been substituted by Act 12 of 1994, on and from the date of the coming into operation of the sanctioned scheme or any provision thereof, the scheme or such provision shall be binding on the sick industrial company and the transferee company or, as the case may be, the other company and also on A B C D E F G H the shareholders, creditors and guarantors and even the employees of the said companies. [Paras 11.14, 11.14.1, 11.14.2][1064-B-H; 1065-A-B] 1.3 The intention of the legislature is very clear. Creditors includes unsecured creditors. The submission on behalf of the unsecured creditors that the word “creditors” is not defined like IBC, 2016 and therefore, the scheme shall not bind the unsecured creditors, cannot be accepted. Looking to the object and purpose of the SICA, 1985 and the provisions of Sections 18 and 19 of the SICA, 1985, the word “creditors” shall have to be construed in a broad manner and is not required to be construed narrowly, otherwise, the object and purpose of rehabilitation scheme shall be frustrated. If the scheme binds the creditors, including other creditors like financial institutions etc., who may have a better claim than the unsecured creditors, there is no reason to treat the unsecured creditors separately and not to treat them as creditors. Therefore, even as per Section 18(8), the scheme shall bind all the creditors and guarantors and even the employees of the sick company, for whose revival the scheme is sanctioned. If the submission on behalf of the unsecured creditors, which has been accepted by the High Court in the case of Continental Carbon India Ltd. that an unsecured creditor can opt out of the scheme sanctioned by the BIFR under the SICA, 1985 and is allowed not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and may wait till the scheme for rehabilitation of the sick company has worked itself out, with an option to recover the debt post such rehabilitation is accepted / allowed, in that case, the minority creditors may frustrate the rehabilitation scheme, which may frustrate the object and purpose of enactment of SICA, 1985. Thus, minority creditors and that too some unsecured creditors cannot be permitted to stall the rehabilitation of the sick company by not 51 accepting the scaled down value of its dues. Unless and until there is a sacrifice by all concerned, including the creditors, financial institutions, unsecured creditors, labourers, there shall not be any revival of the sick industrial company / company. [Para 11.15, 11.16][1065-B-F] 1.4 Now, so far as the submission on behalf of the unsecured creditors that the unsecured creditors should have an option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and to wait till the MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA
LTD.
A B C D E F G H 1030 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
scheme for rehabilitation of the sick company has worked itself out, with an option to recover the debt post such rehabilitation is concerned, the same has no substance and cannot be accepted. It is required to be noted that in a given case, because of the scaling down of the value of the dues of the creditors, the company survives. The company has survived in view of the rehabilitation scheme because of the sacrifice/scaling down the value of the dues of the creditors including the financial institutions. How such a benefit can be permitted to be given to the unsecured creditors, who does not accept the scaled down value of its dues. Such an unsecured creditor cannot be permitted to take the benefit of the revival scheme, which is at the cost of other creditors including the financial institutions and even the labourers. [Para 12][1066- C-E] 1.5 Now, so far as the view taken by the High Court that the unsecured creditor had an option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and can wait till the scheme for rehabilitation of the company has worked itself out with an option to recover the debt with interest post such rehabilitation is accepted, in a given case, the sick company, which has been able to revive because of the scaling down the value of the dues, may again become sick, if the entire dues of the unsecured creditors are to be paid thereafter. It may again lead to becoming such a revived company again as a sick company. If such a thing is permitted, in that case, it will again frustrate the object and purpose of enactment of the SICA, 1985. [Para 13][1066-F-H] 1.6 Scaling down the value of the dues is under the rehabilitation scheme prepared under Section 18 of the SICA, which has a binding effect on all the creditors. Therefore, the same cannot be said to be violative of Article 300A of the Constitution of India. The law permits framing of the scheme taking into consideration and to provide the measures contemplated under Section 18, therefore, the rehabilitation scheme which provides for scaling down the value of dues of the creditors /unsecured creditors and even that of the labourers cannot be said to be violative of Article 300A of the Constitution of India as submitted on behalf of the unsecured creditors. [Para 14][1067-B-C] A B C D E F G H 1.7 The view taken by the High Court of Delhi in Continental Carbon India Ltd. that on approval of a scheme by the BIFR under the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985, the unsecured creditors has an option not to accept the scaling down value of its dues and to wait till the rehabilitation scheme of the sick company has worked itself out with an option to recover the debt with interest post such rehabilitation is erroneous and contrary to the scheme of SICA, 1985 and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside and is accordingly quashed and set aside. The rehabilitation scheme under Section 18 of the SICA, 1985 shall bind all the creditors including the unsecured creditors and the unsecured creditors have to accept the scaled down value of its dues provided under the rehabilitation scheme. The impugned judgment and order passed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court relying upon the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Continental Carbon India Ltd. is quashed and set aside. [Paras 15, 16][1067-D-F; 1068-A] Navnit R. Kamani vs. R.R. Kamani (1988) 4 SCC 387;
Kanpur Fertilizers and Cement Limited vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Anr. (2018) 17 SCC 309 – referred to.
Kotak Mahindra Finance Ltd. vs. Mafatlal Industries Ltd. (2004) 5 Bom. CR 792 (Bom.); Nasik People’s Co-operative Bank Ltd. vs. Datar Switchgear and Anr., 2007 SCC Online Del 2067(DB); Oman International Bank S.A.O.G. vs. Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, (2010) 169 DLT 618 (DB);
International Finance Corporation, Washington vs.
Bihar Sponge & Iron Ltd. & Ors. AIR 2010 Del 142 (DB); Union of India vs. Cimmco Ltd. and Ors. 2014 SCC OnLine Del 909 – referred to.
Case Law Reference (1988) 4 SCC 387 referred to para 5 [2008] 9 SCR 267 relied on para 5 [2012] 3 SCR 388 relied on para 5 & 6 (2018) 17 SCC 309 referred to para 6 [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 747 relied on para 11 MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA
LTD.
A B C D E F G H 1032 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.375 of 2017.
From the Judgment and Order dated 31.07.2012 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in WP No.4854 of 2011.
With Civil appeal nos.377, 379 of 2017, transfer petition (c) no.543 of 2016 and civil appeal no.1755 of 2023.
Jayant Bhushan, Chander Uday Singh, Santosh Paul, Sr. Advs., Atishi Dipankar, A.K. Jain, Amartya Bhushan, Keta Paul, Tushar Bhushan, Ms. Uttara Babbar, Ms. Shipra Jain, Amjid Maqbool, Ms. Viddusshi, Zubin Mammen John, Aman Jha, Ms. Riya Kalra, E.R. Kumar, D.P. Mohanty, Aditya Sharma, Maithreya Shetty, Vedant Mishra for M/ s. Parekh & Co., Atul Shanker Mathur, Shubhankar for M/s. Khaitan & Co., Advs. for the Appellant.
Balbir Singh, ASG, Nalin Kohli, Sr. AAG, A.K. Shrivastava, Gopal Jain, Arijit Prasad, Sr. Advs., P. S. Sudheer, Rishi Maheshwari, Ms. Anne Mathew, Bharat Sood, Ms. Shruti Jose, Kamal Kant, P. N. Puri, Akshat Shrivastava, Satvic Mathur, Amar Gupta, Pranav Tanwar, Divyam Agarwal, Deepak Goel, Arun Aggarwal, Ms. Anshika Agarwal, B. Krishna Prasad, M/s. Mitter & Mitter Co., Upender Thakur, Yatin Grover, Ms. Nandini Tomar, A. V. Rangam, Buddy A. Ranganadhan, M. Yogesh Kanna, Ms. Aparna Bhat, Ms. Karishma Maria, Ms. Nimisha Menon, Aastik Dhingra, Shuvodeep Roy, Shahshank Bajpai, Ms. Gargi Khanna, Manish Pushkarna, Prashant Singh, Shyam Gopal, Ms. Preeti Rani, G.S. Makker, Prashant Singh II, Raj Bahadur Yadav, M.K. Maroria, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
M. R. SHAH, J.
1. As common question of law and facts arise in these group of appeals, they are being disposed of by this common judgment and order. Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017 - (To be treated as the lead matter)
2. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi passed in Writ Petition (C) No. 4854 of 2011 by which the Division Bench of the A B C D E F G H High Court has allowed the said writ petition preferred by the respondent No. 1 herein – Continental Carbon India Ltd. (unsecured creditor) and has held that the original writ petitioner is an unsecured creditor and has the option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and may wait till the scheme of rehabilitation of the appellant company [company before the BIFR under Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as “SICA”)] has worked itself out with an option to recover its debt post such rehabilitation, the original respondent No. 1 – Modi Rubber Ltd. has preferred the present Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017.
Civil Appeal No. 377 of 2017 2.1 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi passed in Writ Petition (C) No. 8154 of 2010 by which the Division Bench of the High Court has dismissed the said writ petition preferred by the appellant herein confirming the orders passed by BIFR and AAIFR taking the view that the appellant herein, on obtaining the decree in its favour has to stand in the queue alongwith other unsecured creditors, who were to be given 54 paisa in a rupee as per the scheme of revival sanctioned under the SICA, the original writ petitioner – OCL India Ltd. (unsecured creditor) has preferred the present Civil Appeal No. 377 of 2017. Civil Appeal No. 379 of 2017 2.2 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi dated 02.03.2016 passed in Writ Petition (C) No. 832 of 2016 by which the Division Bench of the High Court has doubted the correctness of the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Delhi in the case of Continental Carbon India Ltd. Vs. Modi Rubber Ltd., 2012 (131) DRJ 294 (DB), which is the subject matter of Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017 before this Court and has referred the matter to the Larger Bench, the original respondent – TVS Sewing Needles Ltd. has preferred the present Civil Appeal No. 379 of 2017.
TRANSFER PETITION (C) NO. 543 OF 2016
2.3 Present Transfer Petition has been preferred by the petitioner – TVS Sewing Needles Ltd. to transfer the pending Writ Petition (C) No. 832 of 2016 pending before the Delhi High Court, which is also the subject matter of Civil Appeal No. 379 of 2017 as the issue involved in MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1034 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
the writ petition is the same arising in Civil appeal No. 375 of 2017 as the correctness of the said decision, which is the subject matter of Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017 is doubted in Writ Petition (C) No. 832 of 2016. Civil Appeal No. 1755 of 2023 (@ SLP (C) No. 4282 of 2020) Leave granted.
2.4 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh Bench at Gwalior passed in Civil Revision No. 96 of 2018 by which the High Court has dismissed the said revision application relying upon the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Continental Carbon India Ltd. (supra), which is the subject matter of Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017, the original revisionist – M/s. Titagarh Wagons Limited, the judgment debtor has preferred the present appeal.
3. Following question of law arise in the present group of appeals:- Whether on approval of a scheme by the BIFR under the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘SICA’), an unsecured creditor has the option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues, and to wait till the scheme for rehabilitation of the respondent – Company has worked itself out, with an option to recover the debt with interest post such rehabilitation?
4. For the sake of convenience Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017 is treated as the lead matter. The facts leading to the Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017 are as under:- 4.1 That the scheme of rehabilitation of the respondent – company was approved on 08.04.2008 under the SICA. The dues of the unsecured creditors was dealt with in para 5.1.3 of the sanctioned scheme, under which the payment to the unsecured creditors was to be made as under:- “5.1.3. UNSECURED PRESSING CREDITOR (RS. 7390.20
LACS)
Pressing creditors have been identified as under:- A B C D E F G H The above creditors shall accept their outstanding dues as per one of the following three options:
a) To accept 30% of the principal outstanding as full and final payment. The payment shall be made within 3 months of the sanction of the scheme by the BIFR. Or b) To accept 40% of the principal outstanding as full the final payment. The payment shall be made in 3 equal annual installments from the cut off date (i.e. 31.3.2008). The first installment shall be payable within 3 months of the sanction of the Scheme by the BIFR c) To accept 50% of the principal outstanding as full and final payment. The payment shall be made in one go at the end of 3rd year from the sanction of the Scheme by the BIFR. Raw-material Suppliers: MRL has already entered into Memorandum of Understanding with 30 Suppliers out of total 36 Pressing Raw Material suppliers They have accepted for payment as per option (a). Discussions with others are underway by the company management.
Acceptances: MRL has already received acceptance from PNB about their Hundi acceptances settlement as per option (a). Efforts are being made to settle with other banks namely Federal Bank, Dhanlakshmi Bank, etc in respect of Hundi Acceptances. The negotiations are at advance stage.”
4.2 Clause 5.1.4 provides for payment to other unsecured creditors as under:- “5.1.4 OTHER unsecured creditors (Rs. 1840.42 lacs)
To accept 20% of the principal outstanding as full and final payment. The payment shall be made at the end of 3rd year from the sanction of the Scheme by the BIFR.”
4.3 That the respondent herein was an unsecured creditor – a carbon black supplier, who did not accept the amount offered under the rehabilitation scheme sanctioned under SICA. According to the original writ petitioner – respondent No. 1 herein, the debts recovered in the scheme due to it were much less than the actual debts. Therefore, MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1036 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
aggrieved by the rehabilitation scheme, the respondent No. 1– unsecured creditor preferred an appeal before the AAIFR to the extent it provided a dispensation for payment of unsecured creditors.
4.4 The AAIFR dismissed the appeal vide order dated 23.06.2011. The order passed by the AAIFR was the subject matter of writ petition before the High Court.
4.5 By the impugned judgment and order, the Division Bench of the High Court has allowed the writ petition and has set aside the order passe by the AAIFR dated 23.06.2011 by holding that the respondent No. 1 – original writ petitioner as an unsecured creditor has the option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and wait till the scheme of rehabilitation of the respondent company has worked itself out with an option to recover its debt post such rehabilitation. Holding so, the Division Bench was of the view that the contract inter se the parties arrived at whereafter the company has become sick, cannot be compulsorily overridden by the provisions of the SICA if the creditor is willing to wait till such time as the company is financially rehabilitated to claim its dues. The High Court is of the opinion that there would be only suspension of legal proceedings as envisaged under Section 22 of the SICA and the enforcement of the remedy remains suspended and that is why even in computing period of limitation, the period is excluded as per sub-section (5) of Section 22 of the SICA. The impugned judgment and order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court is the subject matter of present Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017.
5. Shri Jayant Bhushan, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant - Modi Rubber Limited in Civil Appeal No. 375 of 2017 while assailing the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court has submitted as under:-
(i) That in the instant case, notwithstanding the mandatory provisions of Section 18(8) of SICA read with Section 32 of SICA, the High Court by the impugned judgment and order has allowed the unsecured creditor to stay outside the rigours of the scheme sanctioned under Section 18(4) of SICA read with Section 32 of SICA, thus, putting at naught the very purpose, rationale and scheme of SICA;
(ii) The schemes whether under the Companies Act or under specific insolvency legislations like, SICA are binding on all A B C D E F G H the creditors including the decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders covered by the scheme. No creditor including decree holders etc. covered by a scheme can opt out of the scheme once the statutory requirements are complied with. It is submitted that even the binding effect of a scheme is based on the statutory provisions. It is submitted that under such statutory provisions enabling framing and sanction of schemes and their binding effect is founded upon larger public interest. Reliance is placed upon the decision of this Court in the case of Navnit R. Kamani Vs. R.R. Kamani, (1988) 4 SCC 387. It is submitted that once the rehabilitation scheme is sanctioned under the statutory provisions of the SICA, the concerned insolvent companies can lead a debt free future life and can use this as a second chance / fresh start to succeed;
(iii) That no creditor including the decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders can claim super priority of their claims specially when the prescribed entities mentioned in Section 19(1) may be required to take severe cuts to help revive sick companies, the other creditors including the decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders cannot claim to have better rights;
(iv) Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has taken us to the object and purpose of SICA, 1985. He has also taken us to the procedure to be followed under the SICA while considering and/or sanctioning the rehabilitation scheme under Section 18(4) read with Section 32 of SICA. It is submitted that SICA has done away with classification of creditors and shareholders, separate meetings of classes of creditors and shareholders. It submitted that done away with the vexed distinctions in law between composition, arrangements, reconstruction etc. The SICA has also done away with individual notices to and separate meetings of unsecured creditors and shareholders. It is submitted that SICA treats all creditors including decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders as one class so as to avoid giving veto power to the minority MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1038 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
creditors in value. It is further submitted that the rehabilitation scheme under SICA discharges debt by operation of law. It is submitted that SICA, 1985 was not a consent based regime rather it was an operation by law based regime;
(v) It is further submitted by learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant that in case of insolvent company, from practical and commercial point of view, there is in effect, no scaling down of debt of ordinary creditors – unsecured creditors as the real market value of debts owed to the ordinary creditors including the decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders covered by the scheme is nothing. The nominal value of debt may appear to have been scaled down, however, in reality, the unsecured creditors normally do not get anything;
(vi) It is submitted that subsequently, legislatures in response to societal and economic changes have enacted separate insolvency legislations providing a mandatory system to reorganize business which shielded the insolvent companies with automatic stay against recovery of the debts. It is submitted that invocation of insolvency legislations are usually involuntary. It is submitted that the Parliaments of different countries recognized the need to have separate insolvency legislations as the fallout of insolvency and eventual winding up leading to dissolution of companies was having serious economic and social implications for the society at large;
(vii) It is further submitted that the commercial laws have two types of laws, one, mandatory laws and second, permissive opting out laws. Insolvency/bankruptcy laws are mandatory laws and not permissive opting out laws. Insolvency/ bankruptcy laws provides a mandatory system wherein creditors’ bargain take place within a common collection pool;
(viii) It is further submitted that a sanctioned scheme whether under Companies Act or under specific insolvency laws like SICA or IBC, 2013 is to operate as a discharge of debt A B C D E F G H / liability owed by the insolvent company to all creditors including decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders. All creditors are entitled to collect the amount of debt as provided in the scheme and not the full amount of debt. It is submitted that a decree or an award does not confer any superior right to a creditor holding such a decree or an award. Decree holders or award holders do not form a separate class;
(ix) On the scheme of SICA, more particularly, the rehabilitation scheme, it is submitted as under :a) Section 18(1) deals with the measures that a scheme with respect to a sick industrial company can provide for. The scheme under section 18(1)(a) and 18(2)(h)
can provide for “financial reconstruction of the sick industrial company” Section 18(1)(e) enable a scheme to provide for such other preventive, ameliorative and remedial measures as may be appropriate”. Financial reconstruction would normally entail reduction / sacrifice of portion of debts as otherwise, no financial reconstruction of a financially distressed company would be possible. Section 18(1)(f) is the residuary clause dealing with incidental, consequential or supplemental measures that may be necessary or expedient in connection with or for the purposes of the measures specified in clauses (a) to
(e) of Section 18(1). Section 18(2) delineates various aspects that the scheme may provide for to fully and effectively carry out reconstruction, amalgamation or other measures mentioned therein.
b) The words financial reconstruction provided in section 18(1) (a) are of widest amplitude. Under this subsection the BIFR can reorganize, modify, vary, reduce, defer the dues of creditors.
c) Section 18(3)(a) provides for publication of draft scheme in daily newspapers for suggestions and objections. Section 18(3)(b) specifically provides that BIFR may modify draft scheme in the light of MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1040 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
suggestions and objections received from creditors, amongst others, of sick company.
d) Section 18(8) of SICA provides that a sanctioned scheme shall be binding on the sick industrial company, shareholders, creditors, guarantors and employees of the company.
e) Section 19(1) deals with financial assistance, sacrifices to he provided by central and state governments, scheduled banks or other bank, public financial institutions, state level institution or any institution or other authority. Section 19(2) provides that only in the case of above mentioned prescribed entities that their consent is imperative as they may be required to give financial assistance. This subsection requires the consent to be given within a span of 60 days from the date of circulation of scheme or within such further period not exceeding 60 days, as allowed by BIFR. It is imperative that the consent is given within the prescribed period of 60 days or within such further period not exceeding 60 days, as allowed by BIFR. Otherwise, this sub-section mandatorily provides that the consent will be deemed to have been given.
f) Section 32 of the SICA provides that the provisions of the scheme framed under the SICA, i.e., the sanctioned scheme, shall override all other laws except the Foreign Exchange Regulations Act, 1973 and the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulations) Act, 1976. The section states that a scheme framed under the SICA will override also the memorandum and articles of association of a sick industrial company or any other instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act.
g) After amendments made in SICA in 1994 (w.e.f.
1.2.1994), in particular, in section 18(1)(a), 18(3)(a), 18(8) it becomes amply clear that BIFR has the power to scale down/ vary the dues of the creditors including A B C D E F G H decree holders/ arbitration award holders/industrial award holders.
(x) It is further submitted that as such in the case of winding up, the ordinary creditors including decree holders etc. normally do not get anything. Thus, when the BIFR scales down the dues owed to the creditors including the unsecured creditors, in effect, there is no confiscation of property. Rather, if the sick company becomes healthy, the unsecured creditors including decree holders / arbitration award holders / industrial award holders can do business with the healthy company.
(xi) It is further submitted that Section 22(1) does not provide for any period of the implementation of scheme. The protective umbrella of Section 22 is not terminable on networth becoming positive. The scheme is binding on all covered and creditors including decree holders etc., who cannot have the option of opting out.
(xii) It is further submitted that Section 22(5) of SICA dealing with exclusion of limitation period cannot be relied upon to argue that it indicates that the dues of the creditors can be deferred to a period when the company’s networth becomes positive or when the scheme is fully implemented. It is submitted that if such an argument is accepted, no creditor will like to give financial assistance or make sacrifices. The resultant effect may be that the company whose networth has turned positive with the assistance of financial assistance and sacrifices may again become sick making the whole effort of taking a company out of sickness futile.
(xiii) It is submitted that such a submission / argument would be against the foundational principle of SICA and, in general, other insolvency legislations that their purpose is to rescue the sick companies from the throes of their inevitable death / liquidation and are not mechanisms for recovery of debts of creditors.
(xiv) Now, so far as the submission on behalf of the respondents that the scaling down/reduction/waiver of dues of creditors is violative of Article 300A of the Constitution of India is MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1042 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
concerned, it is submitted that Article 300A of the Constitution of India shall have no application to a rehabilitation scheme sanctioned by BIFR under the framework of SICA. It is submitted that there is no deprivation of and/or confiscation of property when the dues owed to a creditor other than prescribed entities under Section 19(1) of SICA, is unilaterally reduced after complying with the procedure stated in Section 18(3)(a) including publication of draft rehabilitation scheme inviting objections and suggestions, as the same is done by authority of law i.e., SICA. It is submitted that SICA has been enacted to secure the principles specified in Article 39(a) and (b). It is submitted that in reality, there is no real property or interest in favour of creditors which get affected. In the case of winding up of a sick industrial company whose networth is eroded, the ordinary creditors including decree holders do not normally get anything.
(xv) It is submitted that the High Court has interpreted the provisions of SICA by juxtaposing them with the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 in a way which is contrary to the general principle that no person can stay out of insolvency regime. The High Court has by its interpretation allowed the creditors to stay out of the insolvency regime, which is impermissible. The High Court has failed to appreciate the full import of various provisions of Sections 18(3)(a), 18(4), 18(8), 19(1), 19(2) etc. The purpose of SICA is to expeditiously rehabilitate a sick company by framing and sanctioning a scheme of rehabilitation and the timeline fixed to complete the process is 90 days. The Parliament in its wisdom provided for public notice rather than individual notices as the same was neither practical nor of commercial utility.
(xvi) It is submitted that in the case of Tata Motors Limited Vs. Pharmaceutical Products of India Limited and Anr., (2008) 7 SCC 619, it is specifically observed and held by this Court that the provisions of a special Act will override the provisions of a general act. It is observed that SICA is a special statute and is a self-contained code. The A B C D E F G H Companies Act, 1956 is a general act. Therefore, wherever any inconsistency is seen between the provisions of the two Acts, SICA would prevail. It is further submitted that in the said decision, it is also further observed that the SICA has been enacted to secure the principles specified in Article 39 of the Constitution. It seeks to give effect to the larger public interest and it should be given primacy because of its higher public purpose.
(xvii) It is further submitted that in the case of Raheja Universal Limited Vs. NRC Limited and Ors., (2012) 4 SCC 148 taking into consideration the object and purpose and nature of SICA and its provisions, it is observed and held by this Court that the matters connected with sanctioning and implementation of rehabilitation / restructuring scheme from the date of its presentation or date of its coming into effect, whichever is earlier, fall exclusively within the jurisdiction of BIFR. It is further observed that in such a case of creditors’ demand, even if not made part of the scheme, would not merely for that reasons stand executed from BIFR’s jurisdiction, which extends to making changes in instruments, documents etc., which create rights and liabilities vis-à-vis sick industrial company and its properties. It is observed that any other view would defeat the very purpose of SICA. It is submitted that it is further observed and held in the said decision that the SICA is a special law vis-à-vis Transfer of Property Act, which is a general law.
(xviii) It is further submitted by the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant – Modi Rubber Ltd. that even subsequently, the Division Bench of the High Court has doubted the correctness of the present impugned decision by observing that prima facie the view taken in Modi Rubber Ltd. (supra) is not in sync with the view taken by the various Division Benches of the High Court, which have been distinguished by the Division Bench in Modi Rubber Ltd. (supra) with a simple observation that the point therein was on a slightly different question. It is submitted that in the case of Singer India Ltd. (supra) while not agreeing with the view taken in the case of Modi Rubber Ltd.
MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1044 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
(supra), it is observed that there is no distinction between secured and unsecured creditors except those creditors, who have given financial assistance under a scheme to a sick company. In other words, every creditor stand on a same footing with respect to the power of the Board to sanction a scheme. It is further observed that those creditors, which have to provide financial assistance would form a subcategory and their consent alone would be necessary with respect to the financial assistance to be provided.
(xix) Making above submissions and relying upon the above decisions, it prayed to allow the present appeals and set aside the impugned judgment and order taking the view that an unsecured creditor has the option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and wait till the scheme of rehabilitation of the appellant company has worked itself out with an option to recover its debt post such rehabilitation.
6. Shri C.U. Singh, learned Senior Advocate, appearing on behalf of the appellant / petitioner in Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 4282 of 2020 has vehemently submitted that the Hon’ble Madhya Pradesh High Court has erred in treating the judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of Continental Carbon India Ltd. (supra) as a binding precedent and even the said judgment was contrary to the several earlier and later judgments of the Delhi High Court and, therefore, the Madhya Pradesh High Court ought to have independently examined the issue.
6.1 It is further submitted by Shri C.U. Singh, learned Senior Advocate that the sanction accorded by the BIFR under section 18(4) is under section 18(7) treated as conclusive evidence that all requirements relating to reconstruction or amalgamation or any other measure specified therein have been complied with, and a certified copy thereof shall in all legal proceedings be admitted as evidence. Further, on and from the date of sanction, the scheme and every provision thereof shall be binding on the sick industrial company, and, inter alia, its shareholders, creditors, guarantors, and employees, in terms of section 18(8) of SICA. Reliance is placed on the decisions of this Court as well as the decision of the Bombay and Delhi High Court in the case of :
(i) Raheja Universal Limited Vs. NRC Limited and Ors., (2012) 4 SCC 148;
A B C D E F G H
(ii) Kanpur Fertilizers and Cement Limited Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Anr., (2018) 17 SCC 309;
(iii) Kotak Mahindra Finance Ltd. Vs. Mafatlal Industries Ltd., (2004) 5 Bom. CR 792 (Bom.);
(iv) Nasik People’s Co-operative Bank Ltd. Vs. Datar Switchgear and Anr., 2007 SCC Online Del 2067(DB);
(v) Oman International Bank S.A.O.G. Vs. Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, (2010) 169 DLT 618 (DB);
(vi) International Finance Corporation, Washington Vs.
Bihar Sponge & Iron Ltd. & Ors., AIR 2010 Del 142 (DB); and
(vii) Union of India Vs. Cimmco Ltd. and Ors. reported in 2014 SCC OnLine Del 909.
6.2 Shri C.U. Singh, learned Senior Advocate has further submitted that the judgment in the case of Continental Carbon India Ltd. (supra) has made a complete departure from all prior decisions as to the scope and effect and Sections 18 and 22 of SICA and the effect thereof would be to completely negate the purpose for which a Scheme has been framed by BIFR. It is submitted that it is no longer res integra that the provisions of SICA did not envisage any prior consent being obtained from unsecured creditors, yet dues of such unsecured creditors could be completely or partially written off under a revival scheme framed under section 18 of SICA.
6.3 It is further submitted that under Section 18 of SICA, the operating agency prepares a scheme with respect to the sick company and the scheme can provide any of the measures specified in Section 18(1) and 18(2). The provisions of 18(1) and 18(2) are extremely broad and there is power to provide for such incidental and consequential measures as are necessary. Specifically, Section 18(2)(f) and (m) provide:
(f) the reduction of the interest or rights which the shareholders have in the sick industrial company to such extent as the Board considers necessary in the interests of the reconstruction, revival or rehabilitation of the sick industrial company or for the maintenance of the business of the sick industrial company; MODI RUBBER LIMITED v. CONTINENTAL CARBON INDIA LTD. [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 1046 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
(m) such incidental, consequential and supplemental matters as may be necessary to secure that the reconstruction or amalgamation or other measures mentioned in the scheme are fully and effectively carried out.
6.4 It is further submitted that the draft Scheme is examined by the Board and then published in daily newspapers for suggestions and objections [Section 18(3)(a)]. Thereafter, the Board makes such modifications as considered necessary in light of the suggestions and objections received [Section 18:31(b)]. Thereafter the scheme is sanctioned by the Board [Section 18(4)].
6.5 It is submitted that SICA being a special statute, the provisions thereof, shall prevail over the general law for recovery of money in respect of price of goods sold and delivered. SICA provides for a special mechanism for revival of a company declared sick, and the fate of such a scheme cannot be upset by the refusal of one creditor, secured or unsecured, to adhere to the provisions of the scheme.
6.6 It is submitted that the scheme framed by the BIFR in terms of the provisions of SICA is binding on all creditors of the sick company and it is not open to any creditor to contend that the scheme framed shall not bind such creditor irrespective of whether such consent of such unsecured creditor was not taken prior to sanction of the scheme. The provisions of SICA do not provide for the creditors’ consent white framing of the scheme under Section 18 or its implementation. In section 19(2), the scheme under Section 19(1) is required to be circulated to every person providing financial assistance “for his consent”. However, the scheme under Section 18 envisages no such “consent.
6.7 Further, the Scheme under Section 18 remains binding even after revival of the company. Here, it is necessary to contrast the provisions of Section 22, which provide that legal proceedings, contracts, etc., in respect of a sick company against whom an inquiry is pending under Section 16, or a scheme is under preparation or implementation, etc., shall remain suspended in terms of a declaration of the Board under Section 22(3), and would revive upon the declaration ceasing to have effect [Section 22(4)]. However, the scheme under Section 18 does not lose its finality/efficacy upon revival of the company. 6.8 It is further submitted that SICA, being a special Act, the provisions thereof and the scheme sanctioned thereunder, would prevail A B C D E F G H over any other obligation that may have arisen against a sick company under any other law for the time being in force. Section 32 of SICA clearly provides that a scheme framed by the BIFR shall prevail and have effect over any other law for the time being in force notwithstanding the same.
6.9 It is submitted that the entire purpose of formulating a scheme under SICA is to rehabilitate the sick company. If the sick company is wound up, then the unsecured creditors would get nothing. Hence is the very scheme that ensures that all creditors get some of their property, albeit to a reduced extent.
7. Shri P.S. Sudheer, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent – Continental Carbon India Ltd. – unsecured creditor has vehemently submitted that the Hon’ble High Court after examining various provisions of the SICA, 1985 and various judgments has answered the question and has held that the unsecured creditor has the option not to accept the scaled down value of its dues and may wait till the scheme of rehabilitation of the sick company has worked itself out with the option to recover its debt post such rehabilitation, which is not required to be interfered with by this Court.
7.1 It is submitted that there is no provision under the SICA to compel an unsecured creditor to accept the scaled down value of its dues. In absence of any such provision, the unsecured creditor – respondent cannot be compelled to accept a lesser amount, which would tantamount to taking the right to property in the goods without appropriate consideration and would be violative of Article 300A of the Constitution of India.
7.2 It is submitted that the scheme under the SICA, 1985 provides for preparation and sanction of the scheme for rehabilitation under Section
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.