Ms. X v. The State of Maharashtra and Another
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 252; [2023] 2 S.C.R. 1112
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice A.S. Bopanna, Justice Hima Kohli Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice 1973 – Ss. 437, Justice 438 and 439 – Penal Code, Justice 1860 – Ss. 354, Justice 354-B, Justice Against the Respondent No.2-Accused, Justice Who Lured Her Under the Garb of Assignments, Justice Raped Her in A Hotel Room Where She Was Staying – Initially, Justice The Fir Was Registered U/Ss. 354, Justice 354-B and 506 of the Ipc, Justice And Later, Justice On the Supplementary Statement of the Appellant Being Recorded, Justice The Offence U/S.376 Was Added to the Fir – the High Court Granted
- Decided
- 17 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 822/2023
- Sections
- 376, 375, 164, 438, 437(3), 438(2), 437(5), 31, 439(2), 41, 2, 439
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 1112 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
MS. X v.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER
(Criminal Appeals Nos. 822-823 of 2023)
MARCH 17, 2023
[A. S. BOPANNA AND HIMA KOHLI, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss. 437,438 and 439 – Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 354,354-B, 376 and 506 – Anticipatory bail – Cancellation of – A complaint filed by the appellantprosecutrix, against the respondent No.2-accused, who lured her under the garb of offering some modelling assignments, raped her in a hotel room where she was staying – Initially, the FIR was registered u/ss. 354, 354-B and 506 of the IPC, and later, on the supplementary statement of the appellant being recorded, the offence u/s.376 was added to the FIR – The High Court granted anticipatory bail to the respondent No. 2 on the grounds that the appellant had improved her statement – On appeal, held: The nature and gravity of the alleged offence and the financial stature, position and standing of the accused vis-à-vis the appellant was disregarded and ignored by the High Court – There was sufficient material in the FIR that would prima facie attract the provision of s. 376, IPC – Despite the appellant having filed an application for intervention in the petition for anticipatory bail moved by the Respondent No.2 before the High Court, she was not afforded a hearing – There is no other witness except for the appellant herself, High Court should have granted opportunity of hearing – Grant of anticipatory bail cannot be sustained – Order of the High Court quashed and set aside.
Disposing of the appeals, the Court Held: 1. The nature and gravity of the alleged offence has been disregarded. So has the financial stature, position and standing of the accused vis-à-vis the appellant/prosecutrix been ignored. The High Court has granted anticipatory bail in favour of the respondent No. 2/accused in a brief order of three paragraphs, having been swayed by the “star variations in the narration of the prosecutrix” implying thereby that what was [2023] 2 S.C.R. 1112 A B C D E F G H originally recorded in the FIR, did not make out an offence of rape, as defined in Section 375 IPC, which is an erroneous assumption. Even if the first Supplementary statement of the appellant/prosecutrix recorded in the evening hours of 6th August, 2022, the date on which the FIR had been registered against the respondent No.2/accused in the first half of the same day, her second Supplementary statement recorded on 6th September, 2022 and the Medico-Legal Report of the doctor who had examined the appellant/prosecutrix on 8th August, 2022, are kept aside for a moment, this Court finds that there was still sufficient material in the FIR that would prima facie attract the provision of Section 376, IPC. In this Court’s opinion, these factors ought to have dissuaded the High Court from exercising its discretion in favour of the respondent No.2/accused for granting him anticipatory bail. [Para 22][1131-E-G; 1132-A-B]
2. Another reason that has weighed with this Court for interfering in the impugned orders is that despite the appellant/ prosecutrix having filed an application for intervention in the petition for anticipatory bail moved by the respondent No.2/ accused before the High Court, she was not afforded a hearing. At least a perusal of the second impugned order does not reflect the said position. No doubt, the State was present and was represented in the said proceedings, but the right of the prosecutrix could not have been whittled down for this reason alone. In a crime of this nature where ordinarily, there is no other witness except for the prosecutrix herself, it was all the more incumbent for the High Court to have lent its ear to the appellant. Such an approach tantamounts to failure to recognize the right of the prosecutrix to participate in the criminal proceedings that would include a right to oppose the application for anticipatory bail moved by the accused. The appellant/prosecutrix having been denied a meaningful hearing when the first impugned order of anticipatory bail granted in favour of the respondent No. 2/accused was confirmed by the second impugned order, is an additional factor that has prevailed with this Court to interfere in the impugned orders. [Paras 23, 25][1132-B-D; 1133-F-G] MS. X v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER A B C D E F G H 1114 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Sushila Aggarwal and Others v. State (NCT of Delhi)
and Another (2020) 5 SCC 1 : [2020] 2 SCR 1 – followed.
Prasanta Kumar Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee And Another (2010) 14 SCC 496 : [2010] 12 SCR 1165; Masroor v.
State of Uttar Pradesh and Another (2009) 14 SCC 286 : [2009] 6 SCR 1030; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v.
Rajesh Ranjan Alias Pappu Yadav and Another (2004)
7 SCC 528; Myakala Dharmarajam and Others v. State of Telangana and Another (2020) 2 SCC 743; Pradeep Ram v. State of Jharkhand and Another (2019) 17 SCC 326 : [2019] 8 SCR 824 – relied on.
State of U.P. through CBI v. Amarmani Tripathi (2005)
8 SCC 21 : [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 454; Prahlad Singh Bhat v. NCT, Delhi and Another (2001) 4 SCC 280 :
[2001] 2 SCR 684; Ram Govind Upadhyay v.
Sudarshan Singh and Others (2009) 14 SCC 286 :
[2009] 6 SCR 1030; State of Maharashtra v. Ritesh (2001) 4 SCC 224 : [2001] 2 SCR 438; Panchanan Mishra v. Digambar Mishra and Others (2005) 3 SCC 143 : [2005] 1 SCR 484; Vijay Kumar v. Narendra and Others (2002) 9 SCC 364; Anwari Begum v. Sher Mohammad and Another (2005) 7 SCC 326 : [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 287; Neeru Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh And Another (2014) 16 SCC 508 : [2014] 12 SCR 453;
Anil Kumar Yadav v. State (NCT Of Delhi) And Another (2018) 12 SCC 129 : [2017] 11 SCR 195; Mahipal v Rajesh Kumar Alias Polia and Another (2020) 2 SCC 118 : [2019] 14 SCR 529; Supreme Bhiwandi Wada Manor Infrastructure Private Limited v. State of Maharashtra And Another (2021) 8 SCC 753; Jagjeet Singh And Others v. Ashish Mishra Alias Monu And Another (2022) 9 SCC 321 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2010] 12 SCR 1165 relied on Para 8 [2009] 6 SCR 1030 relied on Para 13 [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 454 referred to Para 12 A B C D E F G H [2001] 2 SCR 684 referred to Para 12 [2009] 6 SCR 1030 referred to Para 12 [2001] 2 SCR 438 referred to Para 12 [2005] 1 SCR 484 referred to Para 13 [2005] 3 Suppl. SCR 287 referred to Para 13 [2014] 12 SCR 453 referred to Para 13 [2017] 11 SCR 195 referred to Para 13 [2019] 14 SCR 529 referred to Para 13 [2020] 2 SCR 1 followed Para 15 [2019] 8 SCR 824 relied on Para 19 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 822-823 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 21.09.2022 and 07.10.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in ABA No. 2594 of 2022. R. Basant, Sr. Adv., Subodh Kr. Pathak, Abhijeet Chatterjee, Shahsi Ranjan, Pawan Kumar Sharma, Gautam Barua, Akash Swami, Ravi P. Wadhwani, Advs. for the Appellant.
Sanjay K Hedge, Sr. Adv., Dharmendra Kumar Sinha, Akhilesh Singh, Ms. Neetu Singh, Arun Adhlakha, Nitin Lonkar, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Amit Singh, Lokesh Dutt Sharma, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
HIMA KOHLI, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The appellant/prosecutrix, who claims to have been exposed to the horrors of the notorious casting couch syndrome, at the hands of the respondent No.2/accused herein, is aggrieved by the orders dated 21st September, 20221 and 07th October, 20222, passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in exercise of its Criminal Appellate jurisdiction 1 First Impugned Order:
2 Second Impugned Order MS. X v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER A B C D E F G H 1116 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
allowing the anticipatory bail application3 filed by the respondent No. 2/accused in connection with FIR4 filed by her with the MIDC Police Station, Mumbai. Initially, the FIR was registered under Sections 354, 354-B and 506 of the Indian Penal Code5. Subsequently, on the supplementary statement of the appellant/prosecutrix being recorded, offence under Section 376 was added to the subject FIR. By the first impugned order, the High Court granted pre-arrest bail to the respondent No. 2/accused as an interim measure subject to certain conditions and on 7th October 2022, confirmed the said order.
FACTS OF THE CASE
3. The facts of the case as are relevant for deciding the present appeals are briefly stated:- 3.1 The appellant/prosecutrix is a Model by profession. She filed a complaint with P.S. MIDC, Mumbai against the respondent No. 2/accused in the late hours of 5th August, 2022, when she dialled ‘100’ to call the police alleging that the respondent No.2/accused, a businessman, who lured her under the garb of offering her some modelling assignments and then forced himself upon her and raped her in a hotel room where she was staying.
3.2 The relevant portion of the appellant’s statement recorded in the early hours of 06th August, 2022 at the MIDC Police Station, Mumbai is extracted hereinbelow :- “……Thereafter we discussed about our work, thereafter Jignesh told me that he wants to talk with me some personal therefore he told me to go in room. Then as Jignesh is going to give me job therefore at about 11.15 pm in the night I took him in the hotel room. Then I asked him water but he refused. Then he told me that, “xxx tu jo field me kaam kart i hai, wo field me to tumhe pata hai kya kya karna padta hai” (xxx you know that, what things needs to do in the field you are working), at that time I told him to speak clearly. Then he told me that, “xxx kuchh pane ke liye kuchh khona padata hai” (xxx one has to sacrifice something to get something). At that time I told him, that I have cleared you about the same on very first day. At that time he told 3 Anticipatory Bail Application No. 2594 of 2022 4 CR FIR No. 915 of 2022 registered on 06th August, 2022 5 For short ‘the IPC’ A B C D E F G H me that, you have to compromise with me, I have good contacts. At that time I clearly refused him. Thereafter he got up from bed and pushed me on bed and he touched my breast and backside. Then I started shouting and then he held my neck and threatened to kill me and then he opened his shirt buttons and he tried to open my clothes. In between my maxi was torn near the neck and breast and then he took out his private part with his hand and he started doing intimacy with me and then I pushed him forcibly and went out from the room and then I got down to the reception from staircase and called the police on 100 number’’ 3.3 Thereafter, in the evening of 06th August, 2022 itself, a supplementary statement of the appellant/prosecutrix was recorded, relevant portion whereof is as under :- “……Then he got up from the bed and pushed me on the bed by pushing me hard. This time he touched my chest and my rear and lifted my dress which I was wearing. As I screamed and begged him not to do this to me, he grabbed me by the throat and threatened to kill me. At that time my whole body was shivering, I was completely scared, I had no idea. He then unbuttoned his shirt, removed his pants and tried to remove my clothes. There was a tussle between us and my maxi was torn near my neck and near my chest. During the tussle, he pulled my knicker down and pulled out his private part with his hand and tried to insert in my private part. Then I pushed him hard and I opened the door and ran outside, then he told, “if you say something about this by going outside then I will kill you and your family.” He was giving such threat then also I came out from the room……”
3.4 It is the case of the appellant/prosecutrix that to favour the respondent No. 2/accused, the police had intentionally removed a vital portion of her statement while recording the FIR and had only mentioned the offences under Sections 354, 354-B and 506 IPC; that the police deliberately did not take the appellant/prosecutrix for a medical examination even on her alleging commission of rape by the respondent No.2/accused; that though the police came to the Hotel on a call being made by the appellant/prosecutrix at around 11:00 p.m. on 5th August, 2022 and had taken her and the respondent No. 2/accused to the Police Station, she was made to wait from 11:30 p.m. till 05:00 a.m. on 6th August, 2022 and during that period, she was being constantly pressurized MS. X v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER [HIMA KOHLI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1118 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
to settle the matter with the respondent No. 2/accused; that when the appellant/prosecutrix did not agree for any settlement, the police was compelled to register the FIR but even then, they had watered down the offences to favour the respondent No. 2/accused.
SEQUENCE OF EVENTS :
4. On 6th August, 2022 itself, at noon time, the police produced the respondent No. 2/accused before the Court of the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate6, XXII Court, Andheri, Mumbai and sought his judicial custody which was allowed by the learned ACMM upto 20th August, 2022. Contemporaneously, the respondent No.2/accused filed an application for bail7 in the Court of the learned ACMM which was opposed by the Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the State on the ground that the offence is non- bailable; the statement of the prosecutrix was yet to be recorded under S. 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure8, the investigation was still in progress; and if released, the respondent No.2/accused may tamper with the evidence. However, the said application was allowed by the learned ACMM vide order dated 06th August, 2022.
5. Aggrieved by the casual approach allegedly adopted by the investigating team, the appellant/prosecutrix approached the Deputy Commissioner of Police of the area, which as per her, activated the police and on 7th August, 2022, they called her for recording her further statement. Based on the said statement, the offence under Section 376 IPC was added in the FIR . Thus, the FIR was registered under Sections 376, 354, 354-B, 506 and 506(2), IPC. On the same day, the investigating officer addressed a letter to the appellant/prosecutrix requesting her to present herself for her medical examination on 8th August, 2022. Accompanied by a lady Police Officer the appellant/prosecutrix was taken to the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai Hospital on 08th August, 2022 where the doctor conducted her medical examination and recorded the following :- “As per history given by the survivor 25 yrs. Female were at hotel Silver INN at Marol Andheri West. Survivor met Jignesh Mehta 48 yrs. Male around time 11.15 pm. 5.8.2022.
6 For short ‘ACMM’ 7 Bail Application No.2279/BA/2022 8 For short ‘CrPC’.
A B C D E F G H Jignesh touched survivor on her private parts, breast, abdomen he held survivor’s neck and threatened that he will kill her removed own clothes and survivor’s clothes forcefully and inserted his genitalia penis in the vulvo once. After that survivor pushed Jignesh and ran away from room. There was history of sexual assault physical assault verbal assault….”
5.1. Dissatisfied with the manner in which the Investigating Officer was conducting the investigation, the appellant/prosecutrix states that she submitted an application dated 10.08.2022 to the Additional Commissioner of Police, West Region imploring him to ensure that the investigation is carried out properly and the respondent No. 2/accused is arrested.
5.2. On 10th August, 2022, the police moved an application before the learned ACMM for cancellation of the bail granted to the respondent No. 2/accused having regard to the fact that the provision of Section 376 IPC has been added to the subject FIR vide application dated 8th August, 2022. The said application was allowed and vide order dated 23rd August, 2022, the learned ACMM cancelled the bail granted to the respondent/accused on 6th April, 2022.
5.3. On 06th September, 2022, the Supplementary Statement of the appellant/prosecutrix was recorded by the police wherein she stated as follows :- “…..I straightaway refused to oblige him but he got up from the bed and forcefully pushed me onto the bed. He touched my chest and posterior inappropriately and pulled up posterior the gown worn by me. I screamed and requested him to not to do such things with me but he held me by my neck and threatened to kill me. At that time out of grave fear I was completely petrified and was unable to think anything. Thereafter he removed his shirt buttons, removed his pants and tried to disrobe me. In the ensuing scuffle my gown tore near my neck and breasts.
During the struggle he pulled down my nickers, pulled out his member and penetrated it inside my private part…….”
5.4. On 17th September, 2022, the respondent No.2/accused filed an application9 under Section 438 Cr.P.C. seeking anticipatory bail in 9 Anticipatory Bail Application No. 1367 of 2022 MS. X v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER [HIMA KOHLI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1120 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
respect of the subject FIR before the court of the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Borivali Division, Dindoshi (Borivali Division), Goregoan, Mumbai. After noting the submissions made by the respondent No.2/ accused, counsel for the State and counsel for the appellant/prosecutrix who had moved an intervention application in the matter, the learned Additional Sessions Judge rejected the anticipatory bail application of the respondent No. 2/accused with the following observations :- “12 It is pertinent to note that in the application filed under section 438 of Cr.P.C. the applicant has averred several facts which appear to be aptly unusual and strange. Though the applicant has contended that he is the victim of honey-trap which was arranged by the victim with her friends, in Para. No. 8 of the application the applicant has contended that he is lifetime member of the Club Emerald, where he used to go for recreation and fitness. In Para. No. 14 of the application whatever is stated prima-facie does not appear to be acceptable in ordinary human behavioral pattern. Despite the applicant is claiming himself to be reputed businessman who used to visit the Club as lifetime member, he has stated in Para. No. 14 that in the said room of the hotel he was invited by the prosecutrix and she started kissing him on his neck and cheek and even rubbing her hand on the body of the applicant and when the applicant stopped her, prosecutrix became more aggressive and suddenly demanded Rs. 15,00,000/- from the applicant.
13. Considering the grounds set up in the application, it is apparent that the applicant has not disputed that at the time of the incident, he was with the victim in the room of the said hotel. Even if the contents in the supplementary statement are overlooked, averments in the FIR prima-facie made out the case under section 376 of IPC. I am, therefore of the view that, in view of the gravity of the offence and nature of punishment in the light of aforesaid allegations, no prima-facie case is made out by the applicant for granting bail under section 438 of Cr.P.C…..”
IMPUGNED ORDERS:
6. The respondent No. 2/accused then approached the High Court seeking anticipatory bail10. By the first impugned order dated 10 Anticipatory Bail Application No. 2594 of 2022 A B C D E F G H 21st September, 2022, interim protection was granted to the respondent No. 2/accused with the following order :- “1. Heard Iearned counsel for the applicant and learned A.P.P. for the State.
2. On 06/08/2022, C.R.No.915 of 2022 came to be registered with MIDC Police Station, on the complaint filed by the prosecutrix, who is a model by profession and she reported to the police station that her modesty was outraged by the applicant. This resulted in invocation of Sections 354, 354-B, 506 IPC.
On the very same day, i.e. on 06/10/2022, the prosecutrix got her supplementary statement recorded and this time, she elaborated the incident by taking it further and stated that after inappropriately touching her, she was pushed on the bed and an attempt was made to commit forcible sexual intercourse. In the scuffle that took place, she alleged that her apparel, which she was wearing was torn and she pushed him out of the door, but while leaving the room, he threatened her that she should not disclose the incident to any one. She came to reception and made a phone call.
After one month i.e. on 06/09/2022, there is further improvement in the version of the prosecutrix, where she states that there was penetrative sexual assault and the other narration that she pushed him and rang the reception remain same.
3. The applicant was released on bail on an earlier occasion, when the subject C.R. invoked Sections 354, 354-B and 506 of I.P.C., but on the supplementary statement being recorded, Section 376 has been added to the subject C.R. and the applicant is apprehending his arrest, since the earlier order operating in his favour, has been cancelled. Looking to the star variations in the narration of the prosecutrix, without judging it’s truthfulness, at this stage, these variations itself persuade me to protect the applicant by way of an interim order.
Subject to his co- operation in the investigation and the material that would come up before the Investigating Officer, further course of action as to whether his custodial interrogation is necessary, would be ascertained. Hence, the following order:
MS. X v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER [HIMA KOHLI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1122 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
:ORDER:
(a) In the event of arrest in connection with C.R.No.915 of 2022 registered with MIDC Police Station, applicant-Jignesh Jashwantrai Mehta shall be released on bail on furnishing P.R. Bond to the extent of Rs.25,000/- with one or two sureties in the like amount.
(b) The applicant shall report to the concerned police station from 27th to 30th September, 2022 between 2.00 p.m. to, 5.00 p.m.
(c) The applicant shall not directly or indirectly make any inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing the facts to Court or any Police Officer and shall not tamper with evidence. List the application on 07/10/2022.”
6.1. On coming to know of the passing of the aforesaid order, the appellant/prosecutrix filed an application for intervention11 before the High Court. By the second impugned order dated 7th October 2022, the Bail application moved by the respondent No.2/accused was allowed with the following order :- “2. Considering the improvement in the version of the prosecutrix and that too coming after a period of more than one month, the applicant was protected by interim order he was directed to report to the Investigating Officer. Accordingly, he has reported to the Investigating Officer, his medical is conducted and the mobile phone is seized.
3. In the wake of the above, since the applicant has rendered his co- operation in the investigation, order dated 21/09/2022 is made absolute.”
7. Aggrieved by the aforesaid two orders, the appellant/prosecutrix has preferred the present appeals wherein notice was issued on 18th November, 2022. Appearance was entered on behalf of the respondent No. 1 – State and the respondent No. 2/accused before the next date of hearing and time was granted to file counter affidavits. Counter affidavits have been filed by the counsel for the respondent No. 1/State and the respondent No. 2/accused.
11 Intervention Application No.17150 of 2022 in Anticipatory Bail Application No.2594 of 2022 dated 06.10.2022 A B C D E F G H
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED BY THE LEARNED
COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES:
A. COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT/PROSECUTRIX
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.