Hari Babu Thota v. *
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 1056; [2023] 16 S.C.R. 917
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice 2016 – Ss.29a, Justice Small and Medium Enterprises – Appellant-Resolution
- Decided
- 29 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4422/2023
- Sections
- 29A, 240A, 29, 240, 7, 11
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 16 S.C.R. 917 : 2023 INSC 1056
CASE DETAILS
HARI BABU THOTA
v.* (Civil Appeal No. 4422 of 2023)
NOVEMBER 29, 2023
[SANJAY KISHAN KAUL AND SUDHANSHU DHULIA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the resolution applicant was disqualified under the primary conditions as specified u/s.29A of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 and; whether the corporate debtor not having an MSME status at the time of commencement of CIRP proceedings would disqualify the Resolution applicant u/s.29A of the Code as benefit of s.240A would not be available.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – ss.29A, 240A – Persons not eligible to be resolution applicant – Application of the Code to micro, small and medium enterprises – Appellant-Resolution Professional presented plan as propounded by the promoters and approved by the Committee of Creditors – Application dismissed by NCLT holding that the promoters could not have presented the plan – Order upheld by NCLAT relying on its earlier order in Digamber Anand Rao Pingle v. Shrikant Madanlal Zawar & Ors. – Sustainability:
Held: s.29A was added as an amendment by Act 8 of 2018 with effect from 23.11.2017 – The objective was to cure the mischiefs of the persons who may be responsible for the financial situation of the company against trying to submit a plan and take over the company – On facts, there is no per say disqualification u/s.29A – s.240A also was introduced as an Amendment in 2018 effective from 06.06.2018 – It begins with a “notwithstanding clause” – Clauses (c) and (h) of s.29-A which apply to the promoters and exempts them to apply for a plan is not applicable qua any micro, small and medium enterprises – The objective obviously was to due to the nature of business carried out by such entities – Excluding such industries from disqualification u/s.29A (c) and (h) is because qua such industries other resolution applicants * Ed. Note: There was no respondent. Amicus Curiae was appointed in the matter. 918 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
may not be forthcoming which thus, would inevitably lead not to resolution but to liquidation – The submission that while interpreting s.240A, the reason for carving out an exception in micro, small and medium industries is set out on the date of application for making the bid as the crucial date and that while for some other aspects the initiation of the CIRP proceedings would be the cut off date, the same would not apply in the case of s.240A, in view of the statement by the Minister himself, accepted – Law laid down in Digambar Anand Rao Pigle case by the Tribunal is not the correct position in law and the cut off date will be the date of submission of resolution plan – Even on this count, the plan submitted in question will not incur the disqualification – Impugned orders of the NCLT and NCLAT set aside. [Paras 6, 10, 14, 17, 20-23 and 25]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Digamber Anand Rao Pingle v. Shrikant Madanlal Zawar & Ors. Decision of National Company Law Appellate Tribunal in Comp. App. (AT) (Ins.) No.43-43A/2021 – not the correct position in law.
India Private Limited v. Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors, (2019) 2 SCC 1 : [2018] 12 SCR 362; Swiss Ribbons Private Limited and Anr. v. Union of India & Ors, (2019) 4 SCC 17 : [2019] 3 SCR 535 – referred to. Insolvency Law Committee Report 2018 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 4422 of 2023. From the Judgment and Order dated 02.06.2023 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, Chennai Bench in Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No.110 of 2023.
Appearances:
Bishwaji Dubey, Ld. Amicus Curiae, Adhitya Srinivasan, Nikhil Saran, Advs.
Ms. Pritha Srikumar Iyer, Arun Srikumar, Ms. Neha Mathem, Shubhansh Thakur, Advs. for the Appellant.
Praveen Kumar Jha, S. Thennavan, Bholle Taguru Phanendra, N. Sakthivel, Chembugari Abheeshna, Sunil Fernandes, Zeeshan Diwan, Ms. Priyansha Indira Sharma, Faraz Ahmed, Praveen Kumar Jha, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, J.
1. Shree Aashraya Infra-Con Limited went into CIRP under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 [for short “the Code”] and the appellant before us was appointed as the Resolution Professional. The Resolution Professional presented a plan before the National Company Law Tribunal, Bengaluru as propounded by the promoters and approved by the Committee of Creditors [COC] but in terms of the order dated 28.02.2023, the application was dismissed on the ground that the promoters could not have presented the plan. It is the say of the appellant before us that this has far reaching consequences for him and his role as the Resolution Professional as:
a) the appellant is ineligible to continue as a Resolution Professional; b) the applicant is ineligible to be considered as Board is liquidator of the corporate debtor;
c) the case of the appellant is required to be referred to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) for further action in accordance with law on the ground that the appellant had erred in putting up a plan that was not in consonance with law for consideration of the adjudicating authority.
2. Since there was really no representation on behalf of the other side, we appointed Mr. Bishwajit Dubey, learned counsel as Amicus in the matter.
3. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant/Resolution Professional and the learned Amicus not only because it would affect the professional abilities of the appellant but because certain issues required
HARI BABU THOTA
920 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
adjudication by us, more so, in view of the impugned order relying on an earlier order of the National Company Law Appellant Tribunal in Digamber Anand Rao Pingle v. Shrikant Madanlal Zawar & Ors.1
4. There are two aspects to be examined out of the contours of the submissions:
Firstly: Whether the resolution applicant was disqualified under the primary conditions as specified under Section 29 A of the Code; and Secondly: Whether the corporate debtor not having an MSME status at the time of commencement of CIRP proceedings would disqualify the Resolution applicant under Section 29A of the Code as benefit of Section 240A would not be available.
It is the say of learned Amicus that if the MSME certificate is obtained prior to the presentation of the plan such disqualification would not be incurred and benefit of the provision would be available.
5. Learned counsel for parties have taken us through Section 29A of the said Code. It has been pointed out that other sub-Clauses except Clauses (c),
(g) and (h) which apply to promoters and guarantors are generic in nature. We reproduce the relevant provisions as under:
29A. Persons not eligible to be resolution applicant- (C) at the time of submission of the resolution plan has an account, or an account of a corporate debtor under the management or control of such person or of whom such person is a promoter, classified as non-performing asset in accordance with the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India issued under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (10 of 1949) or the guidelines of a financial sector regulator issued under any other law for the time being in force, and at least a period of one year has lapsed from the date of such classification till the date of commencement of the corporate insolvency resolution process of the corporate debtor:
1 Comp. App. (AT) (Ins.) No.43-43A/2021 Provided that the person shall be eligible to submit a resolution plan if such person makes payment of all overdue amounts with interest thereon and charges relating to non-performing asset accounts before submission of resolution plan:
Provided further that nothing in this clause shall apply to a resolution applicant where such applicant is a financial entity and is not a related party to the corporate debtor.
Explanation I – For the purposes of this proviso, the expression “related party” shall not include a financial entity, regulated by a financial sector regulator, if it is a financial creditor of the corporate debtor and is a related party of the corporate debtor solely on account of conversion or substitution of debt into equity shares or instruments convertible into equity shares or completion of such transactions as may be prescribed, prior to the insolvency commencement date.
Explanation II -For the purposes of this clause, where a resolution applicant has an account, or an account of a corporate debtor under the management or control of such person or of whom such person is a promoter, classified as non-performing asset and such account was acquired pursuant to a prior resolution plan approved under this Code, then, the provisions of this clause shall not apply to such resolution applicant for a period of three years from the date of approval of such resolution plan by the Adjudicating Authority under this Code.
(g) has been a promoter or in the management or control of a corporate debtor in which a preferential transaction, undervalued transaction, extortionate credit transaction or fraudulent transaction has taken place and in respect of which an order has been made by the Adjudicating Authority under this Code:
Provided that this clause shall not apply if a preferential transaction, undervalued transaction, extortionate credit transaction or fraudulent transaction has taken place prior to the acquisition of the corporate debtor by the resolution applicant pursuant to a resolution plan approved under this Code or pursuant to a scheme or plan approved by a financial sector regulator or a court, and such resolution applicant has not otherwise contributed to the preferential
HARI BABU THOTA
[SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, J.] 922 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
transaction, undervalued transaction, extortionate credit transaction or fraudulent transaction.
(h) has executed a guarantee in favour of a creditor in respect of a corporate debtor against which an application for insolvency resolution made by such creditor has been admitted under this Code and such guarantee has been invoked by the creditor and remains unpaid in full or part:”
6. We may note that the aforesaid section was added as an amendment by Act 8 of 2018 with effect from 23.11.2017. The objective was to cure the mischiefs of the persons who may be responsible for the financial situation of the company against trying to submit a plan and take over the company. If we turn to Clause (c), it provides a time frame i.e. a period of one year should elapse from the date of classification as a non-performing asset (NPA). In the factual scenario, it is stated that there are no bank dues/outstanding which would at all invite a concept of NPA much less the period of one year.
7. Insofar as Clause (g) is concerned, it is pointed out that only one preferential transaction was identified by the appellant but no order was passed by the adjudicating authority as on the date of the impugned order.
8. It is similarly stated that Clause (h) again has no factual application in the given scenario.
9. In effect, what is stated is that these aforesaid Clauses are specific to the promoters and thus, the promoter of the company was not disqualified per say under Section 29A as to dis-entitle him from presenting the plan. This issue is stated to have been noted even in the impugned judgment in para 3 as raised but there is no finding in the impugned order in this behalf. The impugned order has been based only on the issue of Section 240A of the said Code.
10. The aforesaid discussion thus, shows that as per the factual scenario on record, there is no per say disqualification under Section 29A and we could have left the matter at that. However, we proceed further as it is pointed out that the plea based on Section 240A needs the opinion of this Court as there are a number of such cases arising and the orders earlier passed are being followed.
11. In this behalf learned Amicus has drawn our attention to the judgment of this Court in Arcelormittal India Private Limited v. Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors.2. The discussion in this behalf is contained in paras 46, 47 and 57 which are reproduced as under:
46. According to us, it is clear that the opening words of Section 29-A furnish a clue as to the time at which clause (c) is to operate. The opening words of Section 29-A state: “a person shall not be eligible to submit a resolution plan...”. It is clear therefore that the stage of ineligibility attaches when the resolution plan is submitted by a resolution applicant. The contrary view expressed by Shri Rohatgi is obviously incorrect, as the date of commencement of the corporate insolvency resolution process is only relevant for the purpose of calculating whether one year has lapsed from the date of classification of a person as a non-performing asset. Further, the expression used is “has”, which as Dr. Singhvi has correctly argued, is in praesenti. This is to be contrasted with the expression “has been”, which is used in Clauses (d) and (g), which refers to an anterior point of time. Consequently, the amendment of 2018 introducing the words “at the time of submission of the resolution plan” is clarificatory, as this was always the correct interpretation as to the point of time at which the disqualification in clause (c) of Section 29-A will attach. In fact, the amendment was made pursuant to the Insolvency Law Committee Report of March, 2018. That Report clearly stated:
“In relation to applicability of Section 29-A (c), the Committee also discussed that it must be clarified that the disqualification pursuant to Section 29-A(c) shall be applicable if such NPA accounts are held by the resolution applicant or its connected persons at the time of submission of the resolution plan to the RP.”
47. The ingredients of clause (c) are that, the ineligibility to submit a resolution plan attaches if any person, as is referred to in the opening lines of Section 29-A, either itself has an account, or is a promoter of, or in the management or control of, a corporate debtor which has an account, which account has been classified as a non-performing asset,
2 (2019) 2 SCC 1
HARI BABU THOTA
[SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, J.] 924 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
for a period of at least one year from the date of such classification till the date of commencement of the corporate insolvency resolution process. For the purpose of applying this sub-section, any one of three things, which are disjunctive, needs to be established. The corporate debtor may be under the management of the person referred to in Section 29-A, the corporate debtor may be a person under the control of such person, or the corporate debtor may be a person of whom such person is a promoter.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.