Moturu Nalini Kanth v. Gainedi Kaliprasad (Dead, Through LRs.)
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 1004; [2023] 16 S.C.R. 644
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice C.T. Ravikumar, Justice Who As Per His Claim Had Adopted Him, Justice ‘gk’. Evidence Act, Justice 1872 – Ss.68, Justice 69 – Legal Requirements to Prove A Will – Suit Was Fi Led By the Appellant, Justice Through His Guardian
- Decided
- 20 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2435/2010
- Sections
- 69, 68, 63, 16, 11, 71
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 16 S.C.R. 644 : 2023 INSC 1004
CASE DETAILS
MOTURU NALINI KANTH
v.
GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD, THROUGH LRS.)
(Civil Appeal No. 2435 of 2010)
NOVEMBER 20, 2023
[C.T. RAVIKUMAR AND SANJAY KUMAR, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Suit filed by the appellant (then a minor) through his guardian claiming right and title over the properties of late ‘V’, who as per his claim had adopted him, under a registered Will. Trial Court decreed the suit. High Court whether justified in allowing the appeal filed by V’s grandson, ‘GK’.
Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.68, 69 – Legal requirements to prove a Will – Suit was filed by the appellant, through his guardian, for declaration of his title to the suit properties belonging to late ‘V’ and for recovery of their possession from V’s grandson-‘GK’ (who was her grandson through her deceased daughter) – It was his case that he was adopted by ‘V’ by a registered Adoption Deed – Appellant was the son of V’s brother’s son – As per him ‘V’ had executed registered Will bequeathing all her properties to him and canceled her earlier Will, executed in favour of ‘GK’ – Trial Court held in favour of the appellant – Decision reversed by High Court:
Held: For the purposes of s.69, it is not enough to merely examine a random witness who asserts that he saw the attesting witness affix his signature in the Will – The very purpose and objective of insisting upon examination of at least one attesting witness to the Will would be entirely lost if such requirement is whittled down to just having a stray witness depose that he saw the attesting witness sign the Will – Neither of the attesting witnesses to the Will were examined before the Trial Court, in compliance with s.68 – Therefore, s.69 could have been made use of to prove the Will but no witness was examined who was familiar with the signature of either of the attesting witnesses and who could vouch for the same or produce an admitted signature before the Trial Court – Will not proved in accordance with law and has no legal consequence – Disowning of her own grandson by ‘V’ under Will is a suspicious circumstance that remained unexplained – Too many suspicious circumstances surrounding the Will make it very difficult to accept and act upon the same, even if it had been proved as per law – Further, adoption of the appellant is not proved in accordance with law despite the registration of Adoption Deed – On facts, the very adoption, itself, is not believable, given the multitude of suspicious circumstances surrounding it – Therefore, appellant cannot be treated as V’s heir by adoption thus, not entitled to claim any right or share in her properties – Findings of the High Court to that effect, albeit for reasons altogether different, do not warrant interference – Judgment of the High Court confirmed – Indian Succession Act, 1925 – s.63 – Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 – s.16. [Paras 30, 32, 55] Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 – ss.16, 11 – Presumption u/s.16 in favour of a registered document relating to adoption, rebuttable – Appellant claimed a half-share in V’s properties relying on the adoption ceremony and the registered Adoption Deed:
Held: The presumption is rebuttable – On facts, the adoption ceremony and the Adoption Deed are shrouded with equally suspicious circumstances – As the Adoption Deed was registered, the presumption u/s.16 attached to it and it was for ‘GK’ (V’s grandson) to rebut that presumption, who did so more than sufficiently – Mere registration of the Adoption Deed did not absolve the person asserting such adoption from proving that fact by cogent evidence and the person contesting it from adducing evidence to the contrary – It is in this respect that various suspicious circumstances attached to the adoption ceremony of assume significance – The actual ‘giving and taking’ of the child in adoption, is an essential requisite u/s.11(vi) however, there is no convincing evidence of that ‘act’ also in the case on hand – There are no pictures of the actual ‘giving and taking’ of the child in adoption. [Paras 35, 46 and 50] MOTURU NALINI KANTH v. GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD,
THROUGH LRS.)
646 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Ashutosh Samanta (Dead) by LRs. And others vs. SM. Ranjan Bala Dasi and others (2023) SCC OnLine SC 255; Ved Mitra Verma vs. Dharam Deo Verma (2014) 15 SCC 578 – distinguished.
Janki Narayan Bhoir vs. Narayan Namdeo Kadam (2003) 2 SCC 91: [2002] 5 Suppl. SCR 175; Ramesh Verma (Dead) through LRs . vs. Lajesh Saxena (Dead) by LRs . and another (2017) 1 SCC 257; H. Venkatachala Iyengar vs. B.N. Thimmajamma and others AIR 1959 SC 443: [1959] Suppl. SCR 426; Jagdish Chand Sharma vs. Narain Singh Saini through LRs. and others (2015) 8 SCC 615: [2015] 6 SCR 397; Bhagat Ram and another vs. Suresh and others (2003) 12 SCC 35: [2003] 6 Suppl. SCR 216; Benga Behera and another vs. Braja Kishore Nanda and others (2007) 9 SCC 728: [2007] 6 SCR 853 – relied on.
Lalitaben Jayantilal Popat vs. Pragnaben Jamnadas Kataria and others (2008) 15 SCC 365: [2008] 17 SCR 1500; Apoline D’ Souza vs. John D’ Souza (2007) 7 SCC 225: [2007] 6 SCR 1103; Naresh Charan Das Gupta vs. Paresh Charan Das Gupta AIR 1955 SC 363: [1955] SCR 1035; Bhagavathiammal vs. Marimuthu Ammal and others 2010 (2) Madras Weekly Notes (Civil) 704; G. Vasu vs. Syed Yaseen Sifuddin Quadri AIR 1987 Andhra Pradesh 139; Bharat Barrel & Drum Manufacturing Company vs. Amin Chand Payrelal (1999) 3 SCC 35: [1999] 1 SCR 704; Laxmibai (Dead) through LRs. and another vs. Bhagwantbuva (Dead) through LRs . And others (2013) 4 SCC 97: [2013] 1 SCR 632; Kishori Lal vs. Mst. Chaltibai AIR 1959 SC 504: [1959] Suppl. SCR 698; Jai Singh vs. Shakuntala (2002) 3 SCC 634; Mst. Deu and others vs. Laxmi Narayan and others (1998) 8 SCC 701; Lakshman Singh Kothari vs. Rup Kanwar (Smt) alias Rup Kanwar Bai AIR 1961 SC 1378: [1962] SCR 477; M. Vanaja vs. M. Sarla Devi (Dead) (2020) 5 SCC 307 – referred to.
Govinda vs. Chimabai and others AIR 1968 Mysore 309; Padmalav Achariya and another vs. Srimatyia Fakira Debya and others AIR 1931 Privy Council 81; Dhanno wd/o Balbir Singh vs. Tuhi Ram (Died) represented by his LRs.AIR 1996 P & H – referred to..
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.2435 of 2010. From the Judgment and Order dated 11.12.2006 of the High Court of A. P. at Hyderabad in AS No.2695 of 1989.
Appearances:
Basant R., Sr. Adv., Y. Raja Gopala Rao, Akshay Sahay, Ms. Y. Vismai Rao, Y. Ramesh, Dhuli Gopi Krishna, Aarsh Thakkar, Sharat Gopal, Advs. for the Appellant.
Thomas P. Joseph, Sr. Adv., M/s Devasa & Co., Shekhar G. Devasa, Manish Tiwari, Thasmitha Muthanna, Tinny Thomas, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SANJAY KUMAR, J.
1. Moturu Nalini Kanth, then a minor, claimed absolute right and title over the properties of late Venkubayamma under registered Will Deed dated 03.05.1982. It was also claimed that he was adopted by her, as evidenced by registered Adoption Deed dated 20.04.1982. Nalini Kanth was not even a year old at that time, as he was born on 10.07.1981. O.S. No. 113 of 1983 was filed by Nalini Kanth, through his guardian, for declaratory and consequential reliefs in respect of Venkubayamma’s properties. The learned Principal Subordinate Judge, Srikakulam, held in his favour, vide judgment dated 30.09.1989, and decreed the suit. However, in appeal, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh held against Nalini Kanth, vide judgment dated 11.12.2006, and allowed Appeal Suit No. 2695 of 1989 filed by Gainedi Kaliprasad, Venkubayamma’s grandson through her deceased daughter, Varalaxmi. Hence, this appeal by Nalini Kanth.
2. Nalini Kanth’s prayer in O.S. No. 113 of 1983 before the learned Principal Subordinate Judge, Srikakulam, filed through his guardian, was for declaration of his title to the suit properties that had belonged to MOTURU NALINI KANTH v. GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD,
THROUGH LRS.)
648 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Venkubayamma and for recovery of their possession from Kaliprasad, defendant No.1. His case was that he was adopted by Venkubayamma on 18.04.1982 at Sri Sri Raghunadha Swamy Temple at Bhapur in Berhampur City, Ganjam District, Orissa (presently, Odisha). It was claimed that the Adoption Deed (Ex. A9) was executed on 20.04.1982 and it was registered on the same day. It was signed by his natural parents who gave him in adoption and also by his adoptive mother. Thereafter, Venkubayamma executed registered Will Deed dated 03.05.1982 (Ex. A10) in a sound state of mind bequeathing all her properties to him. Thereby, Venkubayamma also canceled her earlier Will Deed dated 26.05.1981 (Ex. A19), executed in favour of Kaliprasad, her grandson. Under Ex. A10 Will, Venkubayamma appointed Pasupuleti Anasuya (PW 1) as the executor of the Will and also as the guardian of Nalini Kanth, in the event she died during his minority. In fact, Venkubayamma died just two months later, on 26.07.1982. Defendants No. 2 to 12 in the suit were Venkubayamma’s tenants. As disputes arose between Pasupuleti Anasuya, Nalini Kanth’s guardian, and Kaliprasad as to who was entitled to receive the rents, the suit in O.S. No. 113 of 1983 came to be filed by her on his behalf.
3. The suit was contested by Kaliprasad. He challenged the Adoption Deed as well as the Will Deed, under which Nalini Kanth claimed rights. He alleged that Venkubayamma was a resident of Srikakulam and was very old in 1982. According to him, she was senile and was not in a position to exercise free will and consciousness. He asserted that the adoption was not true, valid or binding on him. He contended that Ex. A10 Will was invalid as it was not properly attested. He claimed that Venkubayamma had brought him up and got his marriage performed and that she had always treated him as her sole heir and successor.
4. The Trial Court settled the following issues for consideration: ‘1.Whether the plaintiff is the adopted son of Venkubayamma and the Adoption Deed dated 19.04.1982 (sic) is true?
2. Whether the registered Will dated 03.05.1982 executed by late Venkubayamma is true and valid?
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the possession of the suit properties?
4. To what relief?’
5. PWs 1 to 15 were examined for the plaintiff, Nalini Kanth, by his guardian. Ex. A1 to A25 were marked on his behalf. Kaliprasad examined himself as DW 1. He also examined DWs 2 and 3 but did not adduce any documentary evidence. Exs. C1 & C2 and Exs. X1 & X2 were also made part of the record. Ex C1 is the affidavit dated 16.09.1982 of Balaga Sivanarayana Rao, stating that he had scribed Ex. A10 Will Deed. It was attested by B. Prasada Rao, Advocate. Ex. C2 is stated to be the affidavit dated 16.09.1982 of Pydi Appala Suranna, an attesting witness to Ex. A10 Will Deed. It was attested by K. V. Ramanayya, Advocate. Exs. X1 and X2, as per the version of Nalini Kanth’s guardian, are the thumb marks of Venkubayamma but this is disputed by Kaliprasad.
6. At this stage, we may note that the contesting parties are all related to Venkubayamma. Kaliprasad, as stated earlier, is the son of her predeceased daughter, Varalaxmi. Nalini Kanth is the son of her brother’s son, viz., P. Panduranga Rao. Pasupuleti Anasuya, the guardian, is P. Panduranga Rao’s elder sister and the paternal aunt of Nalini Kanth.
7. Deposing as PW 1, Pasupuleti Anasuya stated as follows:
Venkubayamma had extended an invitation to attend the adoption of Nalini Kanth. Ex. A1 is the invitation. The adoption took place at Raghunadha Swamy Temple, Berhampur, at 10 am on 18.04.1982 and all their relations and friends attended the ceremony. All the customary rituals for adoption took place and the natural parents physically handed over the child to Venkubayamma but she, herself, was not present when the child was physically handed over. Exs. A2 to A4 photographs were taken at that time. Exs. A5 to A7 are the negatives thereof. Ex. A8 cash receipt was issued by the photographer, Sunkara Papa Rao. The Adoption Deed dated 20.04.1982 is Ex. A9. Venkubayamma executed a registered Will on 03.05.1982 and it is Ex. A10. She was in a sound and disposing state of mind till her death. Venkubayamma gave necessary instructions to the scribe for writing Ex. A10 Will and she went with her to the Sub-Registrar’s office. In her cross-examination, PW1 admitted that she was not there in any of the photos (Exs. A2 to A4). She denied the suggestion that Venkubayamma was not at all present in those photographs and that she never adopted Nalini Kanth by executing Ex. A9 Adoption Deed. MOTURU NALINI KANTH v. GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD, THROUGH LRS.) [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 650 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
8. P. Panduranga Rao, the natural father of Nalini Kanth, deposed as PW 2. He stated that Venkubayamma was his father’s sister and that he, along with his wife, gave their second son, Nalini Kanth, in adoption to her. He said that the adoption ceremony took place on 18.04.1982 and Ex. A1 was the invitation printed on that occasion. He also spoke of Exs. A2 to A4 photographs and asserted that the child was handed over by him and his wife to Venkubayamma in adoption. He admitted his signature in the Adoption Deed (Ex. A9). In his cross-examination, PW 2 admitted that Venkubayamma brought up Kaliprasad from childhood, got him educated and performed his marriage. He also admitted that none of the relatives of Venkubayamma residing at Srikakulam attended the adoption ceremony. He also stated that Kaliprasad was residing in the house of Venkubayamma at the time of Nalini Kanth’s adoption in 1982.
9. PW 3 is one of the attestors of Ex. A9 Adoption Deed and he is the brother of PWs 1 and 2. According to him, the other attesting witness to the document as well as the scribe thereof had expired. He stated that all the rituals had taken place at the time of adoption and the ceremonies were conducted at Raghunadha Swamy Temple at Berhampur at 10 am. He also spoke of Exs. A2 to A4 photographs being taken at that time. He further stated that the adoption was registered at Berhampur on 20.04.1982. PW 4 is the photographer who took Exs. A2 to A4 photographs, which were marked along with Exs. A5 to A7 negatives and Ex. A8 receipt by PW 1.
10. PW 5, an Advocate, was examined to identify Venkubayamma in the photographs, as he claimed to be a distant relative. He stated that the woman in Ex. A3 photograph, wearing spectacles, was Venkubayamma and that she was also seen in Ex. A2 photograph. He stated that in Ex. A4 photograph, she was seen holding a child in her lap. He stated in his crossexamination that Kaliprasad was with Venkubayamma since ten years.
11. PW 6 is the document-writer who scribed Ex. A10 Will Deed. He said that he knew Pydi Appala Suranna, one of the attestors thereto, but he was no more. He stated that he did not know the other attestor. He claimed that he had known Venkubayamma for about 5 or 6 years. He admitted that Ex. C1 was in his handwriting and bore his signature. He also admitted that Ex. C2 was in his handwriting and claimed that Pydi Appala Suranna had signed therein. He said that he was not present when Venkubayamma signed Ex. A10 Will. Thereupon, he was cross-examined by the plaintiff’s counsel. In the course of such cross-examination, he stated that he wrote Ex. C1 affidavit at the dictation of the plaintiff’s counsel at his house. He further stated that he did not see who exactly signed in Ex. A10 Will Deed. A woman was stated to be sitting at a distance but he did not know if she was Venkubayamma and whether she signed the document. He stated that the prior Will of Venkubayamma dated 26.05.1981 (Ex. A19) was also written by him and Venkubayamma had signed the same in his presence. He further stated that he told the plaintiff’s counsel that, as he did not see Venkubayamma signing the Will, he would not sign the affidavit. However, the plaintiff’s counsel persuaded him to sign it, saying that he need not worry about it and that there would be no consequences. He claimed that some lady from Berhampur who was a relation of Venkubayamma brought the earlier Will to him and he mentioned the date of the said Will in Ex. A10 Will. In his cross-examination by the defence, PW 6 stated that while he was in the Registrar’s office attending to some work, a lady from Berhampur came to him and on that day, the document was written. He further stated that he knew Venkubayamma but she did not come to him on that day. The woman who came from Berhampur gave all the information to write the document and the recital in the Will that the plaintiff’s adoption took place in the house of his natural parents in Chandramanipeta of Berhampur town was made only on the instructions given by the woman. The other particulars mentioned in the Will were also stated to have been given by the same woman. After the writing of the document, according to PW 6, Venkubayamma and the witnesses did not come to him and he did not go to them. He stated that they took the written Will saying that Venkubayamma could herself read the document. He further stated that Pydi Appala Suranna, one of the attestors, also did not sign before him. He also said that he could not say whether the signature in Ex. A10 was that of Pydi Appala Suranna. In his further cross-examination by the plaintiff’s counsel, PW 6 denied the suggestion that he was told that the adoption took place at Raghunadha Swamy Temple and the other formal ceremonies were performed at the natural parents’ house but he omitted to write that the adoption took place at the temple.
MOTURU NALINI KANTH v. GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD, THROUGH LRS.) [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 652 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
12. PW 7 is the purohit who is stated to have performed the adoption ceremonies. He stated that his native place was Berhampur and he was doing pourohityam since about 12 years. He stated that he was the purohit for the family of P. Panduranga Rao (PW 2). He further stated that he knew Venkubayamma as she used to visit her parents’ house. He stated that he had performed pourohityam at the time of the adoption. He claimed that the adoption ceremony took place in Raghunadha Swamy Temple and datta homam was also performed. He further claimed that after the datta homam, the child was physically handed over to the adoptive mother by the parents and photos were taken on that occasion. He identified himself along with the adoptive mother, the natural parents and the child in Ex. A2 and Ex. A3 photographs. He further stated that after the official adoption was over at the temple, they worshipped their personal deity at home. PW 7 stated in his cross-examination that he used to see Venkubayamma once or twice a year at her parents’ house in Chandramanipeta. He was questioned about certain ceremonies in the context of adoption and stated that he had not performed the same. He denied the suggestion that the woman in Exs. A2 to A4 photographs was not Venkubayamma. He, however, stated that Raghunadha Swamy Temple was in Chandramanipeta and Ramalingeshwara and Mukteshwara Temples were in Bhapur.
13. PW 8 is the Advocate who attested Ex. C1 affidavit. PW9 is the Sub-Registrar at Chodavaram who registered Ex. A19 Will. He stated in his cross-examination that he did not know Venkubayamma personally and that the identifying witnesses told him that the executant was Venkubayamma. He said that the executant also stated her name to him. PW 10 was a Director of the Finger Prints Bureau at Madras. His evidence was that the thumb prints in the Adoption Deed and the Will Deed were identical to the thumb print of Venkubayamma in the Sub-Registrar’s record pertaining to Ex. A19 Will. PW 11 was from the Registration Department at Kurnool and spoke of Venkubayamma affixing her thumb print in Ex. A10 Will in his presence. However, in his cross-examination, PW 11 admitted that he did not know her personally and relied only on the identifying witnesses. He also could not say what the age of the said executant was, due to lapse of time. PW 12, an Advocate at Srikakulam, stated that he knew Venkubayamma, who was a client of his father and, thereafter, himself. He further stated that he could identify her and claimed that the woman, wearing glasses and holding a child, in Exs. A2 and A3 photographs, was Venkubayamma. He admitted in his cross-examination that, though Venkubayamma was about 70 years of age in 1970, she did not appear to be of that age in the photographs. He did not know when she died but stated that she died by 1985.
14. PW 13 is the Advocate who attested Ex. C2 affidavit. He admitted in his cross-examination that he previously did not know Pydi Appala Suranna, the deponent thereto. PW 14 was an invitee to the adoption ceremony at Berhampur. He claimed to be in Ex. A4 photograph. However, in his crossexamination, he admitted that Venkubayamma must have been about 65 to 70 years old but the lady in Ex. A4 photograph was about 45 years of age. He also admitted that he was only acquainted with PW 2, the natural father of the adopted child, and that he had no relationship or friendship either with Venkubayamma or her husband and except by way of PW 2’s introduction that she was Venkubayamma, he had no other source of information. PW 15 was an identifying witness in Ex. A10 Will. According to him, Pydi Appala Suranna and a person, whose name he did not know, attested Ex. A10 Will on the Sub-Registrar’s Office verandah. He claimed he was present when the attestors and the scribe signed on Ex. A10. He said that he could identify Venkubayamma and claimed that she was the third person, wearing spectacles, in Ex. A2 photograph. He identified her as the woman sitting, wearing glasses, with a baby in her lap, in Ex. A3. He also identified her in Ex. A4. He asserted that he knew Venkubayamma for the last 10 years but he did not know any other details or when she died.
15. Kaliprasad deposed as DW 1. He stated that Venkubayamma was his mother’s mother and asserted that she never adopted any boy during her lifetime. He asserted that Venkubayamma only had one daughter and he was the son of that daughter. He claimed to be the sole heir to the properties of late Venkubayamma. He claimed that since childhood, he was brought up in Venkubayamma’s house and that his marriage was performed by her in February, 1982. According to him, Venkubayamma was between 75 to 80 years of age at the time of her death. He said that she told him about a Will in his favour after his marriage but he had not seen the document. He denied that she had adopted a boy. According to him, she went to Srikakulam till the second week of July, 1982, and after that, she wanted to go to her relations’ houses at Vizianagaram, Berhampur and Khurda Road. He further stated that, by the time he attained the age of discretion, Venkubayamma’s hair had MOTURU NALINI KANTH v. GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD, THROUGH LRS.) [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 654 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
turned grey and asserted that it was false that Exs. A2 to A4 photographs were of Venkubayamma. He stated that she used to write letters to him whenever she was in camp and he was, therefore, acquainted with her signature and handwriting. He stated that Ex. A9 Adoption Deed did not bear the signature of Venkubayamma. He further stated that Exs. X1 and X2 were not the thumb marks of Venkubayamma. He denied the suggestion that Venkubayamma had adopted Nalini Kanth and had executed a Will, whereby he would be entitled to her properties.
16. In his cross-examination, Kaliprasad stated that he did not have any photograph of Venkubayamma. He denied the suggestion that she used to apply hair dye. He also denied that the woman in Exs. A2 and A3 photographs was Venkubayamma. According to him, Venkubayamma used to write letters to him while he was at Hyderabad and she was in the habit of signing in English using disjointed letters. He admitted that some of her letters were signed in Telugu but a few were signed in English. He asserted that the signatures in Ex. A10 were not that of Venkubayamma and denied that the thumb marks (Exs. X1 and X2) were of Venkubayamma.
17. As already noted supra, the Trial Court held in favour of Nalini Kanth but, in appeal, the High Court reversed that decision. In essence, this case would turn upon the validity of Ex. A10 Will. Further, the validity of Ex. A9 Adoption Deed would also require examination. In the event Ex. A10 Will is found to be valid, Nalini Kanth would be the sole heir thereunder, but if it is held to be invalid and Ex. A9 Adoption Deed is found to be valid, he would be an heir, as an adopted son, along with Kaliprasad, the grandson. He would then be entitled to a half-share in the suit properties.
18. First and foremost, we may note the essential legal requirements to prove a Will. Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (for brevity, ‘the Succession Act’), prescribes the mode and method of proving a Will and, to the extent relevant, it reads as under: - “63. Execution of unprivileged Wills. - Every testator, not being a soldier employed in an expedition or engaged in actual warfare, or an airman so employed or engaged, or a mariner at sea, shall execute his Will according to the following rules: - (a). …….
(b). …….
(c). The Will shall be attested by two or more witnesses, each of whom has seen the testator sign or affix his mark to the Will or has seen some other person sign the Will, in the presence and by the direction of the testator, or has received from the testator a personal acknowledgement of his signature or mark, or the signature of such other person; and each of the witnesses shall sign the Will in the presence of the testator, but it shall not be necessary that more than one witness be present at the same time, and no particular form of attestation shall be necessary.”
19. In turn, Sections 68 and 69 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (for brevity, ‘the Evidence Act’), read as under:
‘68. Proof of execution of document required by law to be attested. - If a document is required by law to be attested, it shall not be used as evidence until one attesting witness at least has been called for the purpose of proving its execution, if there be an attesting witness alive, and subject to the process of the Court and capable of giving evidence: Provided that it shall not be necessary to call an attesting witness in proof of the execution of any document, not being a Will, which has been registered in accordance with the provisions of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), unless its execution by the person by whom it purports to have been executed is specifically denied. Section 69. Proof where no attesting witness found. – If no such attesting witness can be found, or if the document purports to have been executed in the United Kingdom, it must be proved that the attestation of one attesting witness at least is in his handwriting, and that the signature of the person executing the document is in the handwriting of that person.’
20. Trite to state, mere registration of a Will does not attach to it a stamp of validity and it must still be proved in terms of the above legal mandate. In Janki Narayan Bhoir vs. Narayan Namdeo Kadam1, this Court held that the requirements in clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Section 63 of
1 (2003) 2 SCC 91
MOTURU NALINI KANTH v. GAINEDI KALIPRASAD (DEAD, THROUGH LRS.) [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 656 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
the Succession Act have to be complied with to prove a Will and the most important point is that the Will has to be attested by two or more witnesses and each of these witnesses must have seen the testator sign or affix his mark to the Will or must have seen some other person sign the Will in the presence of and by the direction of the testator or must have received from the testator a personal acknowledgment of his signature or mark or of the signature or mark of such other person and each of the witnesses has to sign the Will in the presence of the testator. It was further held that, a person propounding a Will has got to prove that it was duly and validly executed and that cannot be done by simply proving that the signature on the Will was that of the testator, as the propounder must also prove that the attestations were made properly, as required by Section 63(c) of the Succession Act. These principles were affirmed in Lalitaben Jayantilal Popat vs. Pragnaben Jamnadas Kataria and others2.
21. More recently, in Ramesh Verma (Dead) through LRs. vs. Lajesh Saxena (Dead) by LRs. and another3, this Court observed that a Will, like any other document, is to be proved in terms of the provisions of the Evidence Act. It was held that the propounder of the Will is called upon to show by satisfactory evidence that the Will was signed by the testator, that the testator at the relevant time was in a sound and disposing state of mind, that he understood the nature and effect of the disposition and put his signature to the document of his own free will and the document shall not be used as evidence until one attesting witness at least has been called for the purpose of proving its execution. It was noted that this is the mandate of Section 68 of the Evidence Act and the position would remain the same even when the opposite party does not deny the execution of the Will.
22. Long ago, in H. Venkatachala Iyengar vs. B.N. Thimmajamma and others4, a 3-Judge Bench of this Court noted that there is an important feature which distinguishes Wills from other documents as, unlike other documents, a Will speaks from the death of the testator and, therefore, when it is propounded or produced before a Court, the testator who has already departed from the world cannot say whether it is his Will or not.
2 (2008) 15 SCC 365
3 (2017) 1 SCC 257
4 AIR 1959 SC 443
It was held that the onus on the propounder to prove the Will can be taken to be discharged on proof of the essential facts, such as, that the Will was signed by the testator; that the testator at the relevant time was in a sound and disposing state of mind; that he understood the nature and effect of the dispositions; and that he put his signature to the document of his own free will. It was, however, noted by the Bench that there may be cases in which the execution of the Will is surrounded by suspicious circumstances and the same would naturally tend to make the initial onus very heavy and unless it is satisfactorily discharged, Courts would be reluctant to treat the document as the last Will of the testator.
23. Again, in Jagdish Chand Sharma vs. Narain Singh Saini (Dead) through LRs. and others5, this Court held as under:
‘57. A will as an instrument of testamentary disposition of property being a legally acknowledged mode of bequeathing a testator’s acquisitions during his lifetime, to be acted upon only on his/her demise, it is no longer res integra, that it carries with it an overwhelming element of sanctity. As understandably, the testator/testatrix, as the case may be, at the time of testing the document for its validity, would not be available, stringent requisites for the proof thereof have been statutorily enjoined to rule out the possibility of any manipulation. This is more so, as many a times, the manner of dispensation is in stark departure from the prescribed canons of devolution of property to the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased. The rigour of Section 63(c) of the Act and Section 68 of the 1872 Act is thus befitting the underlying exigency to secure against any self-serving intervention contrary to the last wishes of the executor.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.