Pawan Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 1012; [2023] 15 S.C.R. 261
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice 2023 [sanjay Kishan Kaul and Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice A Liberal Approach Should Be Undertaken –
- Decided
- 21 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3548/2023
- Sections
- 302, 34, 307, 313, 391, 2, 7A, 7, 64, 25, 16
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 15 S.C.R. 261 : 2023 INSC 1012
CASE DETAILS
PAWAN KUMAR
v.
STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
(Criminal Appeal No. 3548 of 2023)
NOVEMBER 21, 2023
[SANJAY KISHAN KAUL AND SUDHANSHU DHULIA,JJ]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: The question which arise for determination is whether the appellant was a juvenile at the time of commission of offence. Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Rules, 2007 – r. 12(3)(b) – Benefit of juvenility – Procedure to be followed in determination of age – When exact assessment of the age cannot be done: Held: Age of a juvenile has to be determined on the basis of the date of the alleged commission of the crime – In a case of juvenility where two views are possible, a liberal approach should be undertaken – Furthermore, as per sub-rule (3)(b) of r. 12, in the case exact assessment of the age cannot be done, the Court or the Board or, the committee for the reasons to be recorded by them, may, if considered necessary give benefit to the child or juvenile by considering his/her age on lower side within the margin of one year – On facts, as regards the appellant involved in a crime u/s. 302, 307/34 IPC there were some conflicting aspects as to the age of the appellant, the margin of age was so thin – As per r. 12, the school certificates are given more importance than a Panchayat Register, as such the School leaving certificate of the first school attended by the appellant would be a certificate liable to be considered and is a valid proof of evidence for determination of the age of the appellant, whereby his age was less than 16 years when the offence was committed – Second certificate is the medical report, Bone Ossification Test which shows that he was about 19 years of age, which is not entirely accurate – Even if the medical report which shows the age of the appellant as 19 years is taken 262 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
to be correct even then an exact assessment of age was not possible – Considering the conflicting reports and documents, as per sub rule 3(b) of r. 12, the Court ought to have given the appellant a benefit of one year – Thus, the report of the Additional Sessions Judge is accepted and it is declared that the appellant was a juvenile on the date of the commission of crime – Since the appellant has been detained beyond the maximum period, he is directed to be released forthwith – Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 – ss. 15, 16. [Para 26, 30-34]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Pratap Singh v. State of Jharkhand and Another [2005] 1 Scr 1019 : (2005) 3 SCC 551; Satya Deo alias Bhoorey v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2020] 12 SCR 128 : (2020) 10 SCC 555; Hariram v. State of Rajasthan and Another [2009] 7 SCR 623 : (2009) 13 SCC 211; Shah Nawaz v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another (2011) 13 SCC 751: [2011] 9 SCR 859; Vinod Katara v. State of U.P. 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1204; Arnit Das v. State of Bihar [2000] 1 Suppl. SCR 69 : (2000) 5 SCC 488; Mukarrab and Others v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2016] 8 SCR 557 : (2017) 2 SCC 210; Ashwani Kumar Saxena v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2012] 10 SCR 540 : (2012) 9 SCC 750; Rishipal Singh Solanki v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2022) 8 SCC 602 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
3548 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 07.05.2019 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in CRLA No.106 of 2000. Appearances:
Ms. Vanshaja Shukla, Rishad Murtaza, Ms. Ankeeta Appanna, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ardhendumouli Kumar Prasad, AAG, Rohit K. Singh, Aviral Saxena, Pritam Bishwas, Ashish Madan, Ms. Ananya Sahu, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.
Leave granted.
2. The appellant before this Court has been convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki in Sessions Trial No.85 of 1996 for offences under Sections 302 and 307 read with Section 34 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 and has been sentenced to life imprisonment under Section 302/34 and rigorous imprisonment for 7 years under Section 307/34 with default stipulations. The conviction and sentence of the appellant was upheld in appeal by the High Court, in its order dated 07.05.2019.
3. There were four accused in the case, which were Gaya Prasad Mishra, Gulab Chandra, Pawan Kumar and Babadeen. The accused Babadeen passed away during the trial and his case stood abated and the remaining three were convicted for the offences as stated above. The said conviction has been upheld by the High Court of Judicature of Allahabad (Lucknow Bench). Meanwhile, as far as Gaya Prasad Mishra and Gulab Chandra are concerned, who are the father and brother of the present appellant respectively, they were released prematurely after remaining in jail for more than 19 years, under the remission policy of the State. Consequently, they have not filed any petition before this Court.
4. The appellant before this Court apart from challenging the impugned order on merits has also raised a claim of being a juvenile at the time of the alleged commission of the crime (dated 01.12.1995), a plea which has been dismissed by the Trial Court and the High Court.
5. Before us, the learned counsel for the appellant, Ms. Vanshaja Shukla has submitted that the plea of juvenility may be considered first as the claim of the appellant indeed was that at the time of the incident, he was a juvenile and his plea of juvenility had not been considered in the true letter and spirit of the applicable law. Consequently, before going through the case on its merits, we have heard the counsel for the appellant at length on the plea of juvenility.
PAWAN KUMAR v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
264 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
6. We must state at the very outset that the appellant has been raising the claim of juvenility right since the time of his trial, although belatedly. The trial court as well as the appellate court after an enquiry have found that the appellant was not juvenile at the time of the incident. Since this plea was raised before this Court as well, this court had asked for a report from the concerned Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki and consequently a report was filed on an earlier occasion before this Court, to which we shall refer in a while. However, the last report (dated 28.09.2022) filed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki differs from the earlier findings, and the claim of the appellant being a juvenile at the time of the commission of crime has been accepted. We shall be referring to this report later.
7. The facts of this case must also be stated here. On 01.12.1995, while the father and brother of the Complainant-Guru Prasad Mishra were irrigating their land, water flushed towards the adjacent field belonging to one Gaya Prasad Mishra. The present appellant, who is the son of Gaya Prasad Mishra reported this to his father and shortly thereafter Gaya Prasad Mishra along with his two sons, Gulab Chandra and Pawan Kumar (the present appellant), and one ‘Babadeen’ came to the spot armed with “lathis” and started assaulting the father and brother of the complainant. After hearing the ‘hue and cry’, the complainant along with some village persons reached the spot and he was also assaulted by the accused persons. This incident resulted in grievous injuries on all and ultimately in the death of one Ganga Prasad, brother of the complainant. An FIR as Crime No.86 of 1995 was then filed in Subeha Police Station in Barabanki District, under Sections 307, 504 and 323 IPC against the four named accused as mentioned above. As the brother of the complainant (Ganga Prasad) died the same day, Section 302 was added in the FIR.
8. Undoubtedly, the appellant belongs to the aggressor group and had attacked the deceased and caused injuries and ultimately the death of one of the injured persons. It is also true that some of the assailants, including the present appellant, were armed with “lathis”. We have placed these facts on record to show the nature of the incident. The accused have committed a heinous crime. Yet they are not hardened criminals. It is also not a premeditated cold-blooded murder.
9. While having his statement recorded under Section 313 of CrPC the age of the appellant was recorded as 18 years and upon further inquiry the appellant claimed that he was less than 16 years of age at the time of the commission of the offence, i.e., on 01.12.1995. At the relevant time, Juvenile Justice Act, 1986 was in force where a juvenile in case of a boy, was one who had not completed sixteen years of age. This age however, was increased to eighteen years by the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 as we shall see later. A formal plea of juvenility was raised at the stage of trial. In support of his plea, the appellant produced the Scholar Register of the National Inter College, Barabanki which recorded his D.O.B. as 05.07.1980 which meant that on the date when the offence was committed, the appellant would be 15 years, 6 months, and 26 days old. However, during cross-examination the clerk of National Inter College who had produced the Scholar Register, admitted that the entry was made on the basis of a transfer certificate issued by Purva Madhyamik Vidhyalaya (hereafter referred to as High School, Kamela), which was not placed on record. Further, the Gram Panchayat Officer was examined who produced the Family Register of the appellant where D.O.B. of the appellant was recorded as 1975. The day and month of his birth were not mentioned in this Family Register. In any case, as per the Family Register of the Gram Panchayat, the appellant would be around 20 years of age at the time of the commission of the offence.
In view of this contradiction, a bone ossification test was conducted under the supervision of the Chief Medical Officer of District Hospital, Barabanki where the age of the appellant was recorded as approximately 19 years. Thus, by order dated 21.08.1999 it was concluded by the Trial Court that the benefit of juvenility cannot be extended to the appellant and he was directed to face the trial.
10. The appellant filed a Criminal Revision before the High Court against the said order dated 21.08.1999 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki. The High Court dismissed his criminal revision on 16.09.1999. At the stage of filing the criminal revision the trial was almost complete and the High Court did not consider it appropriate to interfere with the trial at such a belated stage.
PAWAN KUMAR v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
[SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 266 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
11. The Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki continued with the trial, where all the accused persons (except Babadeen), including the appellant were convicted for offences under sections 302/34 and 307/34 of the IPC for which they were sentenced to life imprisonment and 7 years of rigorous imprisonment, respectively. One of the co-accused, Babadeen died on 12.12.1998 during the trial and proceedings against him stood abated by order dated 04.01.1999 passed by the Trial Court.
12. Against the order of conviction dated 11.02.2000 passed by the Trial Court all the accused filed their appeal before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (Lucknow Bench). During the pendency of the appeal, the appellant filed a Criminal Miscellaneous Application under Section 391 of the CrPC for placing additional evidence on record regarding his juvenility. Accordingly, the appellant produced Transfer Certificate dated 05.07.1995 issued by High School, Kamela based on which the Scholar Register of National Inter College, Barabanki which had recorded the age of the appellant as 05.07.1980. Nevertheless, the High Court vide its order dated 07.05.2019, dismissed the Criminal Appeal of all the three accused, including the plea of juvenility raised by the appellant. The High Court also noted that the State Government had meanwhile remitted the sentence of the other two co-accused as both had undergone more than 19 years of imprisonment. However, the appellant was directed to surrender and to carry out his sentence. While rejecting the plea of juvenility, the reasons given by the High Court are as follows:
“20...It is undisputed that juvenility can be examined at any stage, if raised by the accused person. In the present case, appellant no. 3 has raised the point of his juvenility before the trial court, which was dealt with after examining the court witnesses and evidences placed by means of parivar register, radiological report, C.M.O. report and the scholar register of Rashtriya Inter College and rejected by the court below vide order dated 21.08.1999. As no good ground has been taken in the present appeal of juvenility of appellant no. 3. It is also relevant to mention here that aforesaid order dated 21st August, 1999 was challenged by the appellant no. 3 in Criminal Revision No. 271 of 1999, which was also dismissed by this Court vide order dated 16.09.1999”.
The appellant had mostly remained on bail during the period of trial and appeal, but consequent to the decision of the High Court, he surrendered on 29.07.2019 and since then he has been in jail. By now he has served a sentence of about 4 ½ years.
13. The specific grievance of the appellant in the present case is that the Trial Court had not accepted the veracity of the Scholar Register of National Inter College, Barabanki because it was based on a Transfer Certificate issued by High School, Kamela which was not on record. However, when the appellant had placed the same on record, in his application under Section 391 of CrPC, the same ought to have been considered.
14. This Court passed order dated 08.10.2021 and directed the Trial Court to submit a fresh report on the plea of juvenility raised by the appellant, after appreciating the additional evidence. The order dated 08.10.2021 of this Court reads as under: - “…Learned counsel for the petitioner submits by reference to additional documents that CM No.96164/2012 was filed under Section 391 of the Cr.P.C for taking on record additional documents in the form of transfer certificate showing the date of birth of the applicant as 05.07.1980. She has also filed a document regarding listing of the applications as on 29.01.2020 before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench to show such application as pending as on 01.11.2012 for disposal. It is thus, her submission that the application seeking to bring on record additional documents in support of the plea of juvenility was never dealt with.
Our attention has been invited at para 20 of the impugned order which recognizes that plea of juvenility was raised before the trial Court and was rejected by the order dated 21.08.1999. It has been observed that no ground has been taken in the appeal of juvenility of appellant No.3 possibly because a Criminal Revision was filed against the order dated 21.08.1999 being Criminal Revision No.271/1999 which was also dismissed by the High Court on 16.09.1999.
It is correct that in the grounds of appeal before the High Court no plea of juvenility was raised. The plea of the petitioner is predicated PAWAN KUMAR v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
[SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 268 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
only on CM No.96164/2012 filed seeking to raise the plea of juvenility based on the additional grounds.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we are of the view that the additional documents brought on record ought to have been examined and they require examination as to whether the petitioner can raise the plea of juvenility.
We thus, refer the matter to the trial Court for recording evidence on the basis of the certificates sought to be produced by the petitioner as a transfer certificate and submit a report to this Court….”
15. Accordingly, the First Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki in compliance of the order of this Court had submitted a Report dated 28.02.2022. According to this report, the D.O.B of the appellant should be taken as recorded in the Family Register, which is 1975 and therefore at the time of the commission of the offence he was not a juvenile. The Trial Court had examined the entry of the Scholar Register of the National Inter College, Barabanki where the D.O.B of the appellant was 05.07.1980. The D.O.B entered in the Scholar Register was based on a Transfer Certificate dated 05.07.1995 issued by High School, Kamela which had also been placed on record by the appellant, however, the original records of High School, Kamela were not produced and the evidence of the Family Register and bone ossification test was also against the appellant. By comparing these evidences, the Trial Court declared the D.O.B of the appellant to be 1975 and consequently, the report of the Additional Sessions Judge dated 28.02.2022 declared that the appellant was not a juvenile on the date of the commission of the alleged offence.
16. The report dated 28.02.2022 was examined by this Court and it was felt that the Trial Court did not examine the Transfer Certificate of the appellant, which was placed before it. Hence, the issue was again remitted back to the Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki on 15.07.2022 by this Court for fresh consideration on the aspect of juvenility and another report was directed to be filed. The Order of this Court dated 15.07.2022 is as follows:
“We have perused the report of the First Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki dated 28.02.2022 but that report does not analyze the transfer certificate which is the document sought to be relied upon by the petitioner as an additional document before the High Court for which an application had been filed before it. That is what is required to be considered.
Undisputedly, the other documents do not go in favour of the petitioner and show the age as more than 16 years.
It appears that the District Judge has not analysed the document or its veracity which is what is required to be considered.
We have thus, no option but to remit the matter back to the District Judge, Barabanki to appreciate the purport of our order and carry out the enquiry in that behalf and then submit a report to us. Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the original document is in the possession of the petitioner and will be filed with an affidavit before the District Judge.
The enquiry report to be submitted within a period of three months from the date of the receipt of this order.
List on the enquiry report being received.”
17. In compliance of the said order the Additional Sessions Judge, Barabanki filed a fresh report dated 28.09.2022. In this report the D.O.B has been determined as 05.07.1980. If this report is accepted then the appellant was 15 years, 4 months, and 26 days old at the time of commission of the crime which occurred on 01.12.1995. The relevant observation of the report is given as under:
“18. In the end, it is humbly submitted that the date of birth of Pawan Kumar, right from the first school where he was admitted, up to the last school where he has studied, as per the relevant documents of each school has remained the same i.e., 05.07.1980 (Annexure-1) which has been issued by the Principal of Pre-secondary School Kamela, mentioning his date of birth as 05.07.1980, matches with the date of birth of Pawan Kumar as has been mentioned in the relevant registers/ documents of each and every school, where the petitioner has studied at different stages of his education”.
PAWAN KUMAR v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
[SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 270 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
18. On behalf of the appellant, we have heard ld. counsel Ms. Vanshaja Shukla and learned senior counsel Mr. Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad, Additional Advocate General (AAG) for the State of Uttar Pradesh. Before we deal with the submissions made by both sides, it would be prudent to examine some of the relevant statutory provisions.
19. The age of a juvenile has to be determined on the basis of the date of the alleged commission of the crime. The present incident which involved the appellant in a crime inter alia under Section 302 IPC was allegedly committed on 01.12.1995. At the relevant point of time, the Act which was in force for juvenile offenders was known as Juvenile Justice Act, 1986. In the said Act, Section 2(h) defined juvenile as follows:
“(h) “juvenile” means a boy who has not attained the age of sixteen years or a girl who has not attained the age of eighteen years” In the case of the present appellant, the relevant age apparently was 16 years. In order to be a juvenile, he should not have attained the age of 16 years. Till the time the sessions court finally convicted the appellant, inter alia, under Section 302 of the IPC, the above provision of law was in force. The Trial court’s decision is of 11.02.2000.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.