Sajeev v. State of Kerala
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 998; [2023] 15 S.C.R. 241
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice 307, Justice And 326/120b Ipc and S.55(A), Justice (H), Justice 1860 – Ss. 302, Justice 307 and 326/120b – – Conspiracy of Alcohol Poisoning – A1, Justice Kingpin of the Illicit Liquor Business Alongwith A3, Justice A10, Justice And the Consumption of the Same Resulted in The
- Decided
- 9 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1134/2011
- Sections
- 55, 57, 302, 120B, 34, 57A, 307, 326, 57(1), 313, 5, 6
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 15 S.C.R. 241 : 2023 INSC 998
CASE DETAILS
SAJEEV
v.
STATE OF KERALA
(Criminal Appeal No. 1134 of 2011)
NOVEMBER 09, 2023
[ABHAY S. OKA AND SANJAY KAROL, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the conviction and sentence of the accused-A10 and A11 u/ss. 302, 307, and 326/120B IPC and s.55(a), (h),
(i) and s. 57 (A)(1)(ii) of the Abkari Act by the courts below is sustainable in law.
Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302, 307 and 326/120B – Akbari Act – ss. 57(A)(1)(ii) and 55 – Conspiracy of alcohol poisoning – A1, kingpin of the illicit liquor business alongwith A3, A10, and A11 hatched a conspiracy to mix methyl alcohol with spirit to sell the same for an unlawful gain through the outlet operated by A1, and the consumption of the same resulted in the death of 7 innocent people, blindness in 11 people, and injuries to 40 people – Conviction qua A1 upheld right up to this Court – Conviction of the accused-A10 and A11 u/ss. 302, 307 and 326/120 B and s. 55(a), (h), (i) and s. 57 (A)(1)(ii) of the Abkari Act and sentenced to imprisonment for life for the offence u/s. 302 and s. 57(A)(1)(ii), along with other sentences, by the courts below – Interference with:
Held: Not called for – Relationship between A10 and A11, and their relationship with A1; and the role played by each one of them in hatching a conspiracy, if any, supply of Biosole and subsequent malice in the supply and sale of illicit liquor established – Cause of death of the deceased persons was poisoning caused by methyl alcohol, so also the persons sufferred injuries on their body parts as a result of such consumption – Prosecution succeeded in establishing the offence of criminal conspiracy of A10 and A11 with A1 – Accused failed to justify the incriminating 242 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
circumstances appearing against them – Offence u/s. 57(A)(1)(ii) of mixing noxious substance likely to endanger human life, attributable to them – Also, in res gestae ss. 6 and 8 of the Evidence Act applicable – Furthermore, there is evidence relating to the transport, bottling and sale of methyl alcohol – Accused persons have been established to be in conspiracy for common objectives throughout – Conviction of A10 and A11 u/s. 55(a), (h) and (i) upheld – Thus, the involvement of the accused persons in the sale and mixing of methyl alcohol with spirit as part of the conspiracy, resulting in deaths and injuries to many innocent persons proved – Conviction of A10 and A11 u/ss. 302, 307, 326 and 120B IPC and 57(A)(1)(ii) of the Abkari Act, by the courts below upheld. [Para 16, 37, 41, 42, 45, 46, 48-50] Criminal Law – Concurrent convictions – Interference – When warranted:
Held: It is when the finding is perverse; finding is based or built on inadmissible evidence; and the courts below have not considered or wrongly discarded vital pieces of evidence that would tilt the balance in favor of the accused. [Para 51] Penal Code, 1860 – s. 120B – Criminal conspiracy – Necessary ingredients to constitute a criminal conspiracy – Elucidated. [Para 35] Supreme Court Rules, 2013 – Order XX, r. 5, sub rules 2 and 3 – Criminal Appeals – Suggestion for amendment of sub-rule 3:
Held: Perusal of sub-Rules 2 & 3 of r. 5 shows that physical copies of the original records are to be called for, in criminal appeals involving sentence of life or the death penalty – It is suggested that sub-rule 3 be amended to insert the words ‘soft copy’ before the words ‘original records’, resulting in e-copies of the Original Records being requisitioned – This would facilitate a much quicker availability of such records to the court as also further a more environmentally conscious approach – Such requisition of the soft copy of the record be extended to cases where leave is granted against an order of acquittal or conviction – Also, soft copy of the records, once received be provided to the counsel appearing for the parties. [Para 58] Judicial deprecation – Practice of depositions of material witnesses not being placed on record – Effect:
Held: Such practice often cause repeated adjournments, which goes to the root of pendency and delay in disposing of appeals – Thus, a suggestion to amend sub rule 3 of rule 5 of Order XX of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 by inserting the words ‘soft copy’ before the words original records resulting in e-copies of the original records being requisitioned, at a quicker pace – Supreme Court Rules, 2013 – Order XX, r. 5, sub rules 2 and 3. [Para 56]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Ramanarayan Popli v. CBI (2003) SCC (Crl.) 869; P.K. Narayanan v. State of Kerala (1995) 1 SCC 142; Mohd. Naushad v. State (NCT of Delhi) 2023 SCC Online SC 784; Hari and Anr. v. State of UP. 2021 SCC Online SC 1131; Koli Lakhmanbhai Chanabhai v. State of Gujarat (1999) 8 SCC 624; State through Superintendent of Police v. Nalini & Ors. (1999) 5 SCC 253: 1999 ( 3 ) SC 1; Yakub Abdul Razak Memon v. State of Maharashtra (2013) 13 SCC 1: 2013 (15 ) SCR 1; Arvind Singh v. State of Maharashtra (2021) 11 SCC 1; State of Haryana v. Krishan (2017) 8 SCC 204: [2017] 7 SCR 251; Phula Singh v. State of Himachal Pradesh AIR 2014 SC 1256: [2014] 3 SCR 551; Indrakunwar v. State of Chhattisgarh 2023 SCC Online 1364; Chandran v. State of Kerala (2011) 5 SCC 161: [2011] 8 SCR 273; P.N. Krishna Lal v. Govt. of Kerala 1995 Supp (2) SCC 187: [1994] 5 Suppl. SCR 526; Mekala Sivaiah v. State of A.P. (2022) 8 SCC 253; Ravasaheb and Ors. v. State of Karnataka (2023) 5 SCC 391 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
1134 of 2011.
From the Judgment and Order dated 23.07.2010 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in CRLA No.792 of 2004.
With Criminal Appeal No.567 of 2015.
SAJEEV v. STATE OF KERALA 244 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
Appearances:
R Basant, Sr. Adv., Renjith B. Marar, Ms. Lakshmi N. Kaimal, Santhosh M. J., Harsh Vardhan Shah Shyam, Arun Poomulli, Davesh Kumar Sharma, Vishnu Pazhanganat, Ms. Ashu Jain, M Gireesh Kumar, Ankur Kulkarni, Sharath S Janarathanan, Vijay Kumar, Gaurav Agrawal, Advs. for the Appellant.
Jayanth Muth Raj, Sr. Adv., Harshad V. Hameed, Dileep Poolakkot, Subhash Chandran K.R., Mrs. Ashly Harshad, Advs. for the Respondent. JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SANJAY KAROL, J.
1. The present appeals arise from the final judgment and order dated 23.07.2010 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in Criminal Appeal No.72 of 2004, which confirmed the judgment and order dated 02.04.2004 passed by Sessions Judge, Kollam in Sessions Case No.1308 of 2003 vide which the present Appellants, two in number, namely,(i) Sajeev (Accused No. 10) and (ii) Roy (Accused No.11) were convicted under Sections 302, 307 and 326 read with Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter ‘IPC’), Section 55(a), (h), (i) and Section 57 (A) (1) (ii) of the Abkari Act. They were awarded imprisonment for life for the offence under Section 302 and Section 57(A)(1)(ii), along with other sentences, ordered to run concurrently.
2. The incident in question relates to alcohol poisoning, resulting in the death of 7 innocent people, blindness in 11 people, and more than 40 people sustaining injuries.
3. The prosecution case emerging from the record, as also set out by the Courts below, is as follows:
i. On 04.04.2003, at about 7 PM, A1, A3, A10, and A11 hatched a conspiracy to mix methyl alcohol with spirit to sell the same for an unlawful gain through the outlet operated by A1. In furtherance of this conspiracy, A10 and A11 brought 21 cans (each of 5L) containing methyl alcohol labeled as ‘Biosole’ in the Maruti car owned by A10 to the residence of A1 and A3 on 05.04.2003.
ii. Thereafter, A2, A7, and A8 brought spirit to the residence of A1 and A3 in the Ambassador car owned by A2. Methyl Alcohol supplied by A10 and A11 was mixed with this spirit by A1 and A3 and sold through A1’s outlet. A4, A5, A6, A9 and A12 assisted A1 in this sale.
iii. Seven persons, including A4 and A12, died after consuming the spurious liquor on 09.04.2003 – 10.04.2003. PWs 1 – 9 and 11 -12 also fell ill after consuming the said liquor. PW70, DYSP, received information about the incident and commenced the investigation with PW67, Addl. Sub-Inspector, Anchalummode Police Station. After recording statements, PW67 registered FIR (Ex.P186) under Sections 302, 307 read with Section 34 of IPC and Section 57A of the Abkari Act.
iv. The prosecution examined 76 witnesses and marked Exhibits P1 to P259 along with material objects (hereinafter ‘MO’)MO 1 to MO 29. The defence did not adduce oral evidence. After carefully considering the evidence produced, the Trial Court convicted the accused persons in the manner discussed above.
4. The Trial Court, after elaborate consideration, vide common judgment dated 02.04.2004, convicted the accused persons facing trial for different offences and awarded sentences therefor. Accused No.1, 2, 5-9, 10 and 11 preferred appeals from the Trial Court to the High Court. The High Court confirmed the judgment of the Trial Court against these accused persons. The picture emerging is depicted in the chart below: No. Name Trial Court High Court Crime Punishment Awarded -
1. A1 – Thampi IPC – S.302 and 120B Imprisonment for life (302) and RI for 10 years (120B); Rs.50,000 fine Conviction affirmed for all offences IPC - S.307 RI for 7 years; Rs. 50,000 fine IPC – S.326 RI for 7 years; Rs. 50,000 fine SAJEEV v. STATE OF KERALA [SANJAY KAROL, J.] 246 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
Abkari Act – S.57 (A) (1)
(ii)
Imprisonment for life; Rs.
50,000 fine Abkari Act – S.55(a), (h)
and (i)
R.I. for 7 years;
Rs.7,00,000 fine
2. A2 – Saji @ Parippally Saji Abkari Act – S.55(a)(i)
R.I. for 10 years; Rs.
2,00,000 fine Conviction affirmed for all offences
3. A3 – Shobhana @ Maya Abkari Act – S.55(a)
R.I. for 1 year; Rs.
1,00,000 fine No appeal preferred
4. A4 – Shaji @ Jinu Shaji Died
5. A5 – Rajesh @ Bai Abkari Act – S.55(a)(i)
R.I. for 10 years; Rs.
2,00,000 fine Conviction affirmed for all offences
6. A6 - Hussain
7. A7 – Sony
8. A8 – Vipin B.
Nair
9. A9 – Santhosh
10. A10 - Sajeev A11 - Roy
IPC – S.302
and 120B Imprisonment for life (302) and RI for 5 years (120B); Rs.25,000 fine Conviction affirmed for all offences IPC - S.307 RI for 5 years; Rs. 25,000 fine IPC – S.326 RI for 5 years; Rs. 25,000 fine Abkari Act – S.57 (A) (1)
(ii)
Imprisonment for life; Rs.
25,000 fine
11. Abkari Act – S.55(a), (h)
and (i)
R.I. for 5 years;
Rs.5,00,000 fine
12. A12 – Prasanthan Died during Trial
5. Accused No.1 had filed SLP (Crl.)mDiary No.2018/2016 against the order of the High Court, which came to be dismissed by this Court vide order dated 29.01.2016. Therefore, the conviction qua A1 stands affirmed. No other accused preferred appeal to this Court.
6. Accused Nos.10 and 11 have filed instant separate appeals by special leave against the final judgment and order of the High Court of Kerala, upholding their conviction, which were registered as Criminal Appeal No.1154 of 2011 and Criminal Appeal No.567 of 2015.
7. The question which arises for consideration before this Court is whether the conviction and sentence imposed by the Trial Court and High Court on A10 and A11 are sustainable in law or not.
Trial Court and High Court Findings
8. The Trial Court in Sessions Case No.1308 of 2003, after a detailed consideration of the voluminous evidence, gave the following findings while convicting A10 and A11:
i. Given the testimonies of the injured persons and family members of the deceased and the doctors who proved the post-mortem reports, the Trial Court held the prosecution to have proved beyond all reasonable doubt that the cause of death and the persons suffering injuries (except PW21) were only due to the consumption of spurious liquor mixed with methyl alcohol.
ii. There is overwhelming evidence on record that A1 ran an illicit liquor business.
iii. Reliance was placed on Ramanarayan Popli v. CBI1 and P.K. Narayanan v. State of Kerala2 to bring home the charge of conspiracy and from the material testimonies of PW23, PW24, PW11 and PW18, it is evident that on 04.04.2003, all three, i.e., A1, A10 and A11, hatched a conspiracy and in furtherance thereof, 21 cans containing methyl alcohol (Biosole) were delivered at the house of A1. Further, on consideration of witnesses,PW25 to 35 and PW76, the Trial Court adduced that it can be safely held that 21 cans of Biosole transported to the house of A1 and 1 (2003) SCC (Crl.) 869
2 (1995) 1 SCC 142
SAJEEV v. STATE OF KERALA [SANJAY KAROL, J.] 248 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
A3 contained methyl alcohol. It was also observed that A11 was running the firm RR Distributors which supplied the methyl alcohol, on behalf of his brother. Reliance was also placed on the forensic examination conducted by PW44 in which it was opined that the 21 cans recovered by PW76 (IO) from the residence of A1, MO15 series and MO31 series (Biosole cans produced by PW27) are cast from the same mould.
iv. The recovery of burnt plastic materials from the paramba (lawn) of the house of A11, wherein methyl alcohol was detected, cannot be connected with the occurrence.
9. The High Court observed that the testimony of PW11establishes A10 and A11 having delivered Biosole at the residence of A1 in 21 cans in a maruti car in furtherance of the conspiracy hatched with A1. Also, records of RR Distributors, an enterprise of A11, were falsified by making specific entries with an endeavor to conceal the delivery of 21 cans of Biosole to A1. Further, the Court found that on an overall perusal of the materials on record, it cannot be said that there was any serious infirmity or illegality in the investigation. In view of the above findings, vide the impugned judgment, the conviction and sentence handed down to A10 and A11 were confirmed.
Submissions on behalf of accused persons
10. Learned senior counsel and learned counsel for both these convicts (Appellants) submit that by no stretch of imagination can the act of conspiracy be attributable towards them.
11. Assuming hypothetically, these convicts can be said to have supplied spirit, which is ethanol, as an independent business transaction. Even then, the factum of mixing and illegally selling the end product is not attributable to them,more so, in the absence of any element of conspiracy established beyond a reasonable doubt; hence, there is no question of conviction under the penal laws of the land.
12. In so far as Section 57(1)(a) of the Abkari Act is concerned, it was submitted the same is not applicable, for they have neither sold nor mixed the banned product.
Submissions on behalf of the State of Kerala
13. On behalf of the State of Kerala, learned senior counsel has submitted that the prosecution has placed sufficient evidence on record to bring home the charge of conspiracy against A10 and A11. A10 is a close associate of A11 and together, in a conspiracy, they sold methyl alcohol to A1, with full knowledge of the material being sold illegally and the purpose of its purchase.
Submissions on behalf of Amicus Curiae
14. Learned Counsel, Mr. Gaurav Aggarwal, was appointed by this Court as an Amicus Curiae vide order dated 20.07.2023 to assist the Court. The Amicus Curiae has submitted his submissions in four parts, placing on record: (a) the relevant testimonies; (b) the relevant exhibits; (c) the relevant portion of the testimonies; and (d) a chart indicating the role played by A10 and A11.
Our View
15. The Courts below have held A1 to be the kingpin of the illicit liquor business. The conviction qua A1 has come to be confirmed right up to this Court. Hence, the issues requiring consideration are: (a) the relationship between A10 & A11, and their relationship with A1; and (b) the role played by each one of them in hatching a conspiracy, if any, supply of Biosole and subsequent malice in the supply and sale of illicit liquor.
16. Undisputedly, the cause of death of the deceased is poisoning caused by methyl alcohol. So also the persons suffering injuries on their body parts as a result of such consumption.
17. Against this backdrop, we now proceed to examine the case of the prosecution with respect to A10 and A11, as has unfurled through the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses.
18. PW11, Rajesh in his testimony, has deposed that he knew A1 for having worked with him as a mason. On 05.04.2003, he was present at the residence of A1, for doing such work. At that time, A10 (whom he had also seen earlier) and A11 arrived at the residence at around 7 PM in an ash-coloured maruti car. From the car, 3-4 cardboard boxes were taken out. Also, A3 and A4 brought 3 cans of 35L each, which were filled up with SAJEEV v. STATE OF KERALA [SANJAY KAROL, J.] 250 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
the contents of the cans taken out from the cardboard boxes taken out by A3 and A4 from the car. After this process was over, PW11 assisted A4, in carrying the cans to the property of Kamalamma. Further, A10 and A11 received cash from the residence of A1 and left. Pertinently, PW11 was one of the injured as a result of the incident and has identified A10 and A11 in Court. He correctly identifies the big vessel in which the cans were emptied, marked as MO14 series; the cans from the cardboard box, marked as MO15 series (21 in number) and the maruti car of A10, marked as MO16. Nothing material or significant is brought out in the cross-examination part of his testimony, rendering his version to be doubtful in any manner.
19. PW18, Vincent is a neighbor of A1. Even though this witness turned hostile, for not remembering having seen A10 and A11, yet, pertinently, he identified the car (MO16) of A10 in which the methyl alcohol was brought at the residence of A1 by the appellants. It is the settled law that the testimony of a hostile witness can be accepted to the extent that the version is found to be dependable on careful scrutiny thereof. Testimony of such a witness can be relied upon and cannot be treated as being washed off the record. [Refer: Mohd. Naushad v. State (NCT of Delhi)3 (3-Judge Bench); Hari and Anr. v. State of UP.4 (3-Judge Bench) and Koli Lakhmanbhai Chanabhai v. State of Gujarat5 (2-Judge Bench)]
20. PW23, Vinod is an acquaintance of A1. He testified being privy to the process of procuring the spirit and converting it into arrack and seeing A10 and A11 at the residence of A1 multiple times. Further, he corroborates the version of PW11 to the effect that both A10 and A11 brought cardboard boxes at the residence of A1 on 05.04.2003. Also, out of these cardboard boxes, cans containing spirit, resembling the MO15 series were emptied into huge cans. Also, he correctly identified all the accused present in the Court.
21. PW24, Saros, a friend of A1, fully corroborates the version of PW11 and PW23, with respect to the visit of A10 and A11 to the residence of A1 and delivery of M015 series cans, which were poured into 3 larger cans containing methanol, measuring 35L each.
3 2023 SCC Online SC 784 4 2021 SCC Online SC 1131
5 (1999) 8 SCC 624
22. From a conjoint reading of the testimonies of the above witnesses, what comes to be established is that: (a) A10 and A11 were known to A1;
(b) A10 and A11 visited the residence of A1 on 05.04.2003, in the presence of other accused persons/independent persons; and (c) some material which is alleged to be methyl alcohol was supplied in 21 cans, which were emptied into 3 cans of 35L each and stored at the residence of A1. Keeping this in mind, we proceed to examine the next set of witnesses.
23. PW25 Sheeja, in her testimony, states that she provided her pharmacy license to A11, which enabled him to start his firm RR Distributors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.