Naveen @ Ajay v. The State of Madhya Pradesh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 936; [2023] 14 S.C.R. 977
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha
- Decided
- 19 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 489/2019
- Sections
- 302, 293, 5, 6, 174, 396, 294, 313, 45
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 14 S.C.R. 977 : 2023 INSC 936
CASE DETAILS
NAVEEN @ AJAY v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 489-490 of 2019)
OCTOBER 19, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI, PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA AND PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether appellant was afforded a fair trial; whether he was deprived of his valuable legal rights.
Penal Code, 1860 – s. 302 – Appellant was convicted and sentenced for committing rape and murder of 3 months old girl child – His death sentence was confirmed by the High Court – Appellant contended that the entire trial was completed within a span of 15 days and appellant was not afforded a fair trial – Propriety:
Held: The Order-sheet would clearly indicate that the trial was conducted in a hurried manner without providing ample and proper opportunity to the defence counsel, who was engaged through legal aid, to prepare himself effectively – It is also to be noted that copies of DNA Report, FSL Report and Viscera Report were not submitted along with the charge-sheet and were presented before the Court during the course of trial – When the reports were challenged by the accused before the High Court, it was brushed aside by observing that even if the authors of the reports were not called for evidence, in terms of Section 293 Cr.P.C., the reports are not open to question as the defence had an opportunity to cross-examine the authors of the reports during the trial – High Court was not correct in saying that the defence had an opportunity to cross-examine the experts – Accused, who was in jail and defended by a counsel from legal aid, was compelled by the Trial Court to produce defence witness of his own in one day – It was impossible for the accused himself to produce doctors, the authors of the Reports (Ex.P-72), in one day because 978 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
the said experts are government servants and could not have attended the Court at the request of an accused in jail – There was no opportunity, in the real sense, to the appellant to cross-examine the experts – Therefore, the Judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court and affirmed by the High Court is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the trial court for de novo trial by affording proper opportunity to the appellant to defend himself. [Paras 8, 10, 21, 22] Criminal Trial – Fair Trial – Definition of:
Held: There can be no analytical, all-comprehensive or exhaustive definition of the concept of a fair trial, and it may have to be determined in seemingly infinite variety of actual situations with the ultimate object in mind viz. whether something that was done or said either before or at the trial deprived the quality of fairness to a degree where a miscarriage of justice has resulted – Each one has an inbuilt right to be dealt with fairly in a criminal trial – Denial of a fair trial is as much injustice to the accused as is to the victim and the society – Fair trial obviously would mean a trial before an impartial judge, a fair prosecutor, and the atmosphere of judicial calm – Fair trial means a trial in which bias or prejudice for or against the accused, the witnesses, or the cause which is being tried is eliminated – It is inherent in the concept of due process of law, that condemnation should be rendered only after the trial in which the hearing is a real one, not sham or a mere farce and pretence – Since fair hearing requires an opportunity to preserve the process, it may be vitiated and violated by an overhasty, stage-managed, tailored and partisan trial – It is thus settled that a hasty trial in which proper and sufficient opportunity has not been provided to the accused to defend himself/herself would vitiate the trial as being meaningless & stage-managed – It is in violation of the principle of judicial calm. [Para 16] Principle/Doctrine – Judicial Calm – Discussed. [Paras 16, 17]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Bashira vs. State of U.P. AIR 1968 SC 1313 : [1969] SCR 32; Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh & Anr. Vs. State of Gujarat & Ors (2004) 4 SCC 158 : [2004] 3 SCR 1050; Anokhilal vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2019) 20 SCC 196: Rahul v. State of Delhi, Ministry of Home Affairs & Anr (2023) 1 SCC 83; Manoj & Ors. Vs. State of M.P (2023) 2 SCC 353: Anil @ Anthony Arikswamy Joseph Vs. State of Maharashtra (2014) 4 SCC 69 : [2014] 3 SCR 34 – relied on.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
489-490 of 2019.
From the Judgment and Order dated 24.12.2018 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Indore in CRR No. 3 of 2018 and CRLA No.3830 of 2018.
Appearances:
B H Marlapalle, Sr. Adv., Bhavesh Seth, Avinish Kumar Saurab, Harini Raghupathy, Rajat Mittal, Advs. for the Appellant.
Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Ms. Smriti Razdan, Ms. Maitreyee Jagat Joshi, Pulkit Agarwal, Astik Gupta, Ms. Akanksha Tomar, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J.
These appeals would call in question, the impugned Judgment of conviction and sentence dated 24.12.2018 passed by the High Court of Judicature of Madhya Pradesh at Indore in Criminal Reference No. 03 of 2018 and Criminal Appeal No. 3830 of 2018 upholding the conviction of the appellant under Sections 363, 366-A, 376(A), 376(2)(i), 376(2)(j), 376(2) (k), 376(2)(m), 302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code1, and Section 5(m), 5(i) read with Section 6 of Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act 20122, and confirming the sentence of death imposed on the appellant by the Fifth Additional Sessions Judge, Indore (MP) in Sessions Trial No. 87 1 (for short, ‘IPC’)
2 (for short, ‘POCSO’)
NAVEEN @ AJAY v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH 980 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
of 2018 arising out of Crime No. 50 of 2018 dated 20.04.2018, registered at P.S. Sarafa, Indore, Madhya Pradesh.
2. The appellant has been convicted and sentenced for committing rape and murder of 3 months old girl child. The appellant was tried for the afore-mentioned offences on the allegation that complainant-Sunil and his wife were engaged in the business of selling balloons and they were residing at Rajawada, Indore (MP). On 20.04.2018, complainant-Sunil along with his family members were sleeping at a platform near Rajawada, at about 03:00 a.m., his daughter (deceased) aged about three months and four days started weeping on which her mother Sonubai fed milk, thereafter, the deceased slept. At about 05:00 a.m. when complainant-Sunil and his family members woke up, they did not find the deceased at the place where she was sleeping. Despite search, they could not find her. Thereafter, Sunil lodged a missing report of his daughter at Police Station, Sarafa, Indore registered as Crime No. 50 of 2018 (Ex.P-7). At about 13.27 hours, one Mr. Deepak Jain (PW-5) informed the Police Station MG Road, Indore (MP) that one dead body of a girl of about three months old has been found at Shreenath Palace Society, Indore. MERG intimation was recorded under Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19733. On coming to know about the discovery of a dead body, Sunil went to the spot and identified the deceased as his daughter. Postmortem of the dead body was conducted, and the Report thereof was submitted by Dr. Poonam Mathur (PW-20) vide Ex. P-53. After completing the investigation including collection of evidence from CCTV footage, recovery of incriminating articles, chemical analysis report etc., the charge-sheet was filed on 27.04.2018. The DNA report was produced later during the trial.
3. On the basis of evidence brought on record during the course of trial, wherein the prosecution examined 29 witnesses and also proved 78 documents including expert opinion/chemical report/FSL report, the Trial Court convicted the appellant for the subject offences against which the appellant preferred appeal before the High Court. The Sessions Court also sent reference to the High Court under Section 396 Cr.P.C. for confirmation of death sentence. The High Court has confirmed the death sentence and 3 (for short, ‘Cr.P.C.)
resultantly the Criminal Appeal preferred by the appellant has also been dismissed by the impugned Judgment.
4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. They have advanced lengthy arguments and have taken us through the entire evidence on record. However, considering the nature of the order, we propose to pass, we are not referring to the details of the evidence on record.
5. At the outset, learned senior counsel Mr. B.H. Marlappalle assisted by Mr. Rajat Mittal, Advocate-on-Record for the appellant argued that the entire trial for such serious offences has been completed within a span of 15 days i.e. from 27th April, 2018 (when the charge-sheet was filed) to 12th May, 2018 (when the Judgment was delivered by the Sessions Court). Referring to the order-sheet recorded by the trial court from 27th April, 2018 to 12th May, 2018, learned senior counsel would submit that the appellant has not been afforded a fair trial depriving him of his valuable legal rights. It is also argued that the DNA report (Ex.P-72) has not been proved in accordance with law. The forensic experts were not examined during the trial, nor the report was put to the accused for admission or otherwise.
6. Per contra learned counsel for the respondent-State, while supporting the impugned Judgment of the High Court, would submit that the appellant having not raised any objection regarding hasty completion of trial or denial of a fair trial, it is not open for the appellant to argue, at this stage, that the trial has not been conducted properly and fairly. He would submit that in view of clinching evidence against the appellant which are scientific in nature, the Sessions Court and the High Court as well, have not committed any illegality in convicting and sentencing the appellant.
7. To appreciate the arguments regarding denial of fair trial, we have gone through the complete order-sheet recorded by the trial court from 27th April, 2018 to 12th May, 2018. The gist whereof is reproduced hereunder: - 27.04.2018 Charge-sheet filed.
Cognizance taken.
Charge-sheet supplied to the accused. He requested for appointment of an advocate through legal aid.
NAVEEN @ AJAY v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J.] 982 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
Advocate from legal aid appointed on the same day.
The case was posted on the same day, after some time, for arguments on charge.
Later on, the case was posted for next day for hearing arguments on charge.
28.04.2018 Arguments on charge heard, charges framed.
Accused was asked as to whether he admits any documents as required under Section 294 of Cr.P.C. to which the accused refused to admit any document.
District Public Prosecution Officer was directed to submit trial program today itself.
Prosecution submitted trial program for examining 34 witnesses. 01.05.2018 PW Nos. 1 to 4 examined.
The prosecution was directed to keep its remaining witnesses present (summons not issued).
02.05.2018 PW Nos. 5 to 10 examined.
The prosecution was directed to keep its remaining witnesses present (summons not issued).
03.05.2018 PW Nos. 11 to 15 examined.
Two witnesses discharged without examination.
The prosecution was directed to keep its remaining witnesses present (summons not issued).
04.05.2018 PW Nos. 16 to 20 examined.
FSL report received from State Forensic Science Laboratory, Sagar, Viscera Report of deceased received from the Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Jhumarghat, Rau, Indore and DNA report received from the State Forensic Science Laboratory, Government of M.P. produced by the prosecution.
The prosecution was directed to keep its remaining witnesses present through summons tomorrow.
05.05.2018 PW Nos. 21 to 25 examined.
No other witnesses were presented.
Remaining Witnesses were directed to be called through summons.
Witness-Sunil was directed to be called from the District Jail, Dhar through production warrant (this witness was never examined).
The case fixed for 07.05.2023 for remaining witnesses.
07.05.2018 PW No. 26 examined.
The prosecution was directed to keep its remaining witnesses present tomorrow.
08.05.2018 PW Nos. 27 to 29 examined.
The prosecution closed its evidence.
The case was posted for accused examination under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. tomorrow.
09.05.2018 The accused examined under Section 313 of Cr.P.C.
The accused requested to provide an opportunity to produce defence witness on his behalf.
He was directed to keep the defence witness present tomorrow. NAVEEN @ AJAY v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J.] 984 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
10.05.2018 Defence witness was not present.
Defence closed.
Parties were directed for final arguments today itself (after recess).
Final arguments heard.
The case was posted for Judgment on 12.05.2018.
12.05.2018 Judgment pronounced.
The accused and his advocate heard on the question of sentence. The case posted after some time for hearing the accused on sentence (order-sheet does not record that copy of the Judgement supplied to the accused).
After some time, sentence pronounced.
Copy of the Judgment provided to the accused.
8. A close reading and scrutiny of the order-sheet recorded by the Trial Court, as stated above in brief, would manifest that the accused was not provided an opportunity to engage a counsel of his choice and instead his submission was recorded that he desires to be defended by a counsel appointed through legal aid. From the very beginning, the trial proceeded on day-to-day basis except on Saturday and Sunday and all the witnesses examined by the prosecution were produced without issuing summons. One witness-Sunil was directed to be produced from District Jail, Dhar through production warrant. However, this witness was never examined nor there is any indication that this witness has been given up. It is this witness (Sunil) who was named as a suspect in the FIR. Non-examination of this witness has therefore left a crucial gap in the prosecution case. It is significant to note that the FSL report, Viscera report and DNA report were not submitted along with the charge-sheet. The same were presented before the Trial Court on 04.05.2018. The accused was never asked as to whether he admits the documents, as required under Section 294 of Cr.P.C.. Neither any witnesses were called to prove these reports. After the prosecution case was closed on 08.05.2018, the accused examination was conducted on the very next day i.e. on 09.05.2018 and thereafter on the next day i.e. on 10.05.2018, the case was fixed for examination of defence witness. It requires special notice that the accused was in jail and was not defended by a counsel of his choice but by a legal aid counsel. He was not in a position to present the witness himself, yet he was directed to keep his witnesses present on the next day i.e. on 10.05.2018. On this date, he could not produce his witnesses, therefore, his defence was closed, and the case was posted for final arguments after recess.
9. In a case of this nature, the trial was conducted on day-to-day basis and the order-sheet does not record that copies of statement of witnesses were supplied to the accused or his counsel, it is not known as to whether the defence counsel was supplied all the requisite material basing which he could have advanced his final arguments.
10. The Order-sheet would thus clearly indicate that the trial was conducted in a hurried manner without providing ample and proper opportunity to the defence counsel, who was engaged through legal aid, to prepare himself effectively. It is also to be noted that copies of DNA Report, FSL Report and Viscera Report were presented before the Court during the course of trial on 04.05.2018.
11. In the matter of Bashira vs. State of U.P.4, almost similar situation, like in the present case arose, when the trial was conducted in 13 days. Dealing with submissions made by the accused counsel apropos lack of sufficient opportunity to defend the accused, this Court held in paragraph 8 and 9 as follows: - “8. There is nothing on the record to show that, after his appointment as counsel for the appellant, Sri Shukla was given sufficient time to prepare the defence. The order- sheet maintained by the Judge seems to indicate that, as soon as the counsel was appointed, the charge was read out to the accused and, after his plea had been recorded, examination of witnesses began. The counsel, of course, did his best
4 AIR 1968 SC 1313
NAVEEN @ AJAY v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J.] 986 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.