Eva Agro Feeds Private Limited v. Punjab National Bank and Anr.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 809; [2023] 13 S.C.R. 861
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice 2023 [b. V. Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 6 Sept 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7906/2021
- Sections
- 29A, 62, 9, 60, 61, 5(24), 5, 5(18), 34, 33, 35, 36
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 13 S.C.R. 861 : 2023 INSC 809
CASE DETAILS
EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED
v.
PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.
(Civil Appeal No.7906 of 2021)
SEPTEMBER 06, 2023
[B. V. NAGARATHNA AND UJJAL BHUYAN, JJ. ]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Appellate Tribunal whether justified in upholding the decision of the Liquidator to cancel the auction sale without assigning any reasons.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Auction sale cancelled by Liquidator without assigning any reasons – Appellant submitted its bid dtd.16.07.21 to Respondent No.2-Liquidator in respect of the assets of the corporate debtor (in liquidation) – On 20.07.21, appellant received an E-auction certificate from certifying that it had won the auction of the subject property– On 21.07.21, the appellant received an email from Respondent No.2 simply informing that he had cancelled the E-auction u/Clause 3(k) of the Disclaimer Clause in the E-Auction Process Information Document and that a fresh E-auction would be conducted– Appellant filed application before the Tribunal– Tribunal directed the respondent No.2 vide order dtd. 12.08.21 to send a communication to the appellant requiring him to deposit the balance sale consideration– Letter issued to the appellant, entire sum was deposited – Sale certificate issued in favour of the appellant – Respondent No.1-financial creditor filed appeal against order dtd. 12.08.21– Appellate Tribunal set aside the said order and reversed the steps taken pursuant thereto, liberty given to the Respondent No.2 to initiate fresh process of auction – He issued sale notice dtd. 24.12.2021 for E-auction sale of the subject property – Auction scheduled stayed:
Held: No reasons were assigned by the Liquidator for cancellation of the E-auction – While the highest bidder has no indefeasible right 862 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
to demand acceptance of his bid, the Liquidator if he does not want to accept the bid of the highest bidder has to apply his mind to the relevant factors – Such application of mind must be visible or manifest in the rejection order itself – It is incomprehensible that an administrative authority can take a decision without disclosing the reasons for taking a decision affecting the rights of parties – Further, while it is true that para 1(11A), stating that where the Liquidator rejects the highest bid in an auction process, he shall intimate the reasons for such rejection to the highest bidder and mention it in the next progress report, came to be inserted in Schedule 1 to the Regulations w.e.f 30.09.21, it does not imply that an auction sale or the highest bid prior to the aforesaid date could be cancelled by the Liquidator exercising unfettered discretion and without furnishing any reason – Furthermore, in the present case, even after cancelling the highest bid of the appellant, in the subsequent sale notice dtd. 24.12.21, Respondent No.2 again fixed the reserve price of the subject property at Rs.10 crores which was the reserve price in the previous round of auction sale and which was also the bid value of the appellant – There was no rationale or justification in rejecting the bid of the appellant and going for another round of auction at the same reserve price – Merely because the Liquidator has the discretion of carrying out multiple auction it does not necessarily imply that he would abandon or cancel a valid auction fetching a reasonable price and opt for another round of auction process with the expectation of a better price – There can be no absolute or unfettered discretion on the part of the Liquidator to cancel an auction which is otherwise valid – Tribunal rightly held that there were no objective materials before the Liquidator to cancel the auction process and to opt for another round of auction – Appellate Tribunal not justified in setting aside the order of the Tribunal dtd.12.08.2021 – Impugned order set aside, order dtd.12.08.2021 restored – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016– Regulation 33; Schedule 1, Para 1(11A)– Auction– National Company Law Tribunal Rules, 2016– Administrative Law – Principles of natural justice. [Paras 20.1, 29, 34.1, 41, 42 and 51] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – ss.5(24), 29A – ‘related party’ suffering ineligibility u/s.29A – Intervenor argued that one ‘VKG’, the director and principal shareholder of the appellant was also one of the promotor director and principal shareholder of the corporate debtor and therefore, a ‘related party’ of the corporate debtor and as such was not eligible; rather debarred from participating in the auction of the subject property of the corporate debtor:
Held: The disqualification sought to be attached to the appellant is without any substance as the related party had ceased to be in the helm of affairs of the corporate debtor more than a decade ago – He was not in charge of the company or an influential member of the company i.e., the corporate debtor when the appellant had made its bid pursuant to the auction sale notice. [Para 50] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 – Schedule 1, Para 1(11A) – Plea of the intervenor that since para 1(11A) was inserted in Schedule I vide notifi cation dtd.30.09.2021 w.e.f 30.09.2021 and this provision is prospective thus, it cannot be applied to auctions conducted prior to 30.09.2021, including the auction in question – Therefore, there was no requirement for the Liquidator to give reasons for cancellation of the bid of the appellant:
Held: Plea not accepted – Furnishing of reasons is an important aspect rather a check on the arbitrary exercise of power – It presupposes application of mind to the relevant factors and consideration by the concerned authority before passing an order – Absence of reasons may be a good reason to draw inference that the decision making process was arbitrary – Therefore, what para 1(11A) has done is to give statutory recognition to the requirement for furnishing reasons, if the Liquidator wishes to reject the bid of the highest bidder – Furnishing of reasons, which is an integral facet of the principles of natural justice, is embedded in a provision or action, whereby the highest bid is rejected by the Liquidator – Thus, what para 1(11A) has done is to give statutory recognition to this well-established principle – It has made explicit what was implicit. [Para 29] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Powers and duties of the Liquidator – Discussed – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016.
EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB
NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.
864 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
S.N. Mukherjee versus Union of India (1990) 4 SCC 594: [1990] 1 Suppl. SCR 44; State of Orissa versus Dhaniram Luhar (2004) 5 SCC 568: [2004] 2 SCR 68; East Coast Railway versus Mahadev Appa Rao (2010) 7 SCC 678: [2010] 7 SCR 908; Kranti Associates (P) Ltd. Versus Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496: [2010] 10 SCR 1070; Valji Khimji and Company Versus Official Liquidator of Hindustan Nitro Product (Gujarat) Limited and Others (2008) 9 SCC 299: [2008] 12 SCR 1; K. Kumara Gupta Versus Sri Markendaya and Sri Omkareswara Swamy Temple and Ors (2022) 5 SCC 710 – relied on.
Swiss Ribbons Private Limited and Another versus Union of India and Others (2019) 4 SCC 17: [2019] 3 SCR 535; Phoenix ARC Private Limited versus Spade Financial Services Limited (2021) 3 SCC 475; Arcelor Mittal (India) (P) Ltd. V. Satish Kumar Gupta (2019) 2 SCC 1: [2018] 12 SCR 362; Arun Kumar Jagatramka Versus Jindal Steel and Power Limited and Another (2021) 7 SCC 474: [2021] 3 SCR 114 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.7906 of 2021.
From the Judgment and Order dated 30.11.2021 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (Principal Bench) at New Delhi in Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No.757 of 2021.
Appearances:
Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Sr. Adv., Parag Maini, Varun Lamba, Raghav Chadha, Ms. Nishtha Kumar, Ms. Ira Mahajan, Advs. for the Appellant. Siddharth Bhatnagar, Sr. Adv., Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Achuni, Dinesh Sharma, Sumit Sharma, Krishnaraj Thaker, Ms. Pallavi Langar, Rahul Arya, Ashish Choudhury, Ms. Pracheta Kar, Aditya Sidhra, Nadeem Afroz, Rohit Amit Sthalekar, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
UJJAL BHUYAN, J.
Application (I. A. No.14220 of 2022) for intervention is allowed.
2. This appeal has been preferred under Section 62 of The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Code’) against the order dated 30.11.2021 passed by the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (briefly ‘the Appellate Tribunal’ hereinafter) allowing the appeal of Punjab National Bank i.e. Respondent No.1 being Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No.757 of 2021. The aforesaid appeal was filed by the Punjab National Bank against the order dated 12.08.2021 passed by the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata Bench, Kolkata (briefly the ‘Tribunal’ hereinafter) in I.A. (IB) No.663/ KB/2021 in CP (IB) 440/KB/2018.
3. At the outset, it would be necessary to advert to the relevant facts:-
(i) One Huvepharma Sea (Pune) Private Limited filed an application under Section 9 of the Code against M/s. Amrit Feeds Limited i.e. corporate debtor before the Tribunal. The same was registered as CP(IB) No.440/KB/2018. The Tribunal passed an order dated 22.10.2019 admitting the application filed under Section 9 of the Code as a result of which corporate insolvency resolution process of the corporate debtor commenced.
(ii) On 19.02.2021, the Tribunal passed an order for liquidation of the corporate debtor. Respondent No.2 was appointed as the Liquidator to oversee the corporate insolvency resolution process.
(iii) Respondent No.2 by an e-mail dated 07.06.2021 forwarded a sale notice dated 02.06.2021 for sale of the assets of the corporate debtor. 23.06.2021 was the date fixed by Respondent No.2 for auction sale of the assets of the corporate debtor. It appears that the aforesaid auction sale did not materialize. Thereafter by way of an e-mail dated 29.06.2021, Respondent No.2 forwarded a EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB
NATIONAL BANK AND ANR.
866 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
similar notice dated 28.06.2021 for auction sale of the assets of the corporate debtor scheduled on 20.07.2021.
(iv) It is stated that the appellant i.e., Eva Agro Feeds Private Limited was incorporated on 09.07.2021 under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013.
(v) Appellant submitted its bid dated 16.07.2021 to Respondent No.2 on 17.07.2021 in respect of the assets of the corporate debtor (in liquidation). The assets put up for auction were lands admeasuring 1,05,250.40 sqft at Plot No.56, Khata Nos.27, 26, 29, 36, 36 (Old) and 362/363 (New), Mouza - Deoria, Pargana Bhuli, Tehsil - Chunar, District - Mirzapur, Uttar Pradesh with building, plant and machinery and other fixed assets thereon on a lump sum basis as mentioned at serial No.3 of the sale notice.
(vi) In terms of the sale notice, appellant paid the earnest money deposit (EMD) of Rs.1 crore in respect of the subject property. While the last date/time for submission of bid was 20.07.2021 at 14:30 hours, appellant had submitted its bid on 19.07.2021 for a sum of Rs.10 crores which was equivalent to the reserve price as notified in the bid which ended at 14:30 hours on 20.07.2021.
(vii) On 20.07.2021, appellant received an E-auction certificate from Respondent No.2 certifying that it had won the auction for the assets of the corporate debtor put up for auction sale (referred to hereinafter as the ‘subject property’). On 21.07.2021, appellant by way of an e-mail requested Respondent No.2 to issue allotment letter in respect of the subject property. It is stated that on 21.07.2021 itself appellant received an e-mail of the aforesaid date from Respondent No.2 informing that Respondent No.2 had cancelled the E-auction held on 20.07.2021 under Clause 3(k)
of the Disclaimer Clause in the E-Auction Process Information Document. The appellant was further informed that a fresh E-auction would be conducted for the subject property.
(viii) Aggrieved by the same, appellant filed an application before the Tribunal under Section 60 and related provisions of the Code read with The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 as well as under Rule 11 of the National Company Law Tribunal Rules, 2016 which was registered as I.A. (IB) No.663/KB/2021 in CP (IB) 440/ KB/2018. Tribunal vide order dated 12.08.2021 disposed of the said application by directing the Liquidator i.e. respondent No.2 to send a communication to the appellant requiring him to deposit the balance sale consideration within the time specified in the E-auction notice.
(ix) According to the appellant, Respondent No.2 complied with the order of the Tribunal and issued a letter to the appellant to deposit the balance consideration money. Pursuant to the said letter, appellant deposited the entire sum on 10.09.2021 following which Respondent No.2 issued a sale certificate dated 15.09.2021 in respect of the subject property in favour of the appellant.
(x) While the Liquidator accepted the order of the Tribunal, one of the financial creditors i.e. Punjab National Bank (Respondent No.1) filed an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal under Section 61 of the Code against the order dated 12.08.2021 passed by the Tribunal. The appeal was contested by the appellant. However, by the impugned order dated 30.11.2021, Appellate Tribunal allowed the appeal and set aside the order dated 12.08.2021 passed by the Tribunal. Consequently, the steps taken pursuant to the said order were also reversed. Liquidator was given liberty to initiate fresh process of auction in accordance with the provisions of the Code read with The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016 (briefly the ‘Regulations’ hereinafter).
(xi) Aggrieved, the auction purchaser as the appellant has preferred the present appeal.
4. This court by order dated 10.01.2022 had issued notice and passed an interim order staying the subsequent auction which was scheduled on 17.01.2022.
5. Respondent No.1 - Punjab National Bank in its counter affidavit at the outset pleaded that the appeal deserves to be dismissed at the threshold EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 868 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
and that the impugned order of the Appellate Tribunal upholding the decision of the Liquidator to cancel the auction sale is fully justified. Appellant was the sole bidder and quoted exactly the reserve price. Reasoning given by the Appellate Tribunal in paragraphs 11 to 22 of the impugned order are just and proper and calls for no interference. In this connection, Respondent No.1 has referred to Clause 3 (k) of the auction sale notice which says that the Liquidator has the absolute right to accept or reject any or all the bids or adjourn/postpone/cancel the E-auction or withdraw any asset/property or portion thereof from the E-auction at any stage without assigning any reason. Reliance has also been placed on Clause 5 (m) of the auction sale notice as per which the bidder with the highest offer/bid does not get any right to demand acceptance of its bid. It is in the above context that Respondent No.1 has contended that the Liquidator was well within his rights to cancel the auction sale, which decision has been rightly affirmed by the Appellate Tribunal.
5.1. According to Respondent No.1, it is a settled position that any auction sale, before completion, can always be cancelled. Tribunal had overlooked the provisions contained in Clause-13 of the Regulations which makes it clear that auction sale shall stand completed only on payment of full amount and not at the stage when the highest bidder is invited to provide balance sale consideration within 90 days from the date of demand. Tribunal relied upon Clause 12 of the Regulations as per which, on the closure of auction, the highest bidder shall be invited to provide the balance sale consideration within 90 days of the date of demand; first proviso mentions that payments made after 30 days would attract interest of 12% with the second proviso clarifying that the sale would be cancelled if the payment is not received within 90 days. According to Respondent No.1, Tribunal by placing reliance on Clause 12 mis-directed itself in directing the Liquidator to send a communication to the appellant for depositing the balance sale consideration within the time specified in the E-auction notice.
5.2. There is no express bar or prohibition either under the Code or under the Regulations restraining the Liquidator from cancelling an auction sale even after declaration of the highest bidder but before completion of sale as understood under Clause 13 of the Regulations. In the absence of such express bar or prohibition and when the auction sale was yet to be concluded, Liquidator was well within his rights in cancelling the auction sale with the intent to have another round of auction sale. Tribunal had erred in interfering with such action of the Liquidator.
5.3. Appellant had accepted the terms and conditions of the auction sale notice while participating in the auction sale, including Clause 3 (k). Therefore, it was not open to the appellant to question the decision of the Liquidator to cancel the auction sale.
5.4. Respondent No.1 has also alleged that the appellant had made incorrect statements in the appeal and did not bring on record relevant documents. It is stated that Respondent No.2 in his written submission before the Tribunal had stated that he was informed by way of e-mail dated 05.08.2021 by Kapila Krishi Udyog Pvt. Ltd. that the promoters of the appellant were also the founder promoters of the corporate debtor. On receipt of such e-mail, Liquidator verified the record and found that one of the present directors of the appellant, Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia was a director of the corporate debtor from its inception i.e. 22.09.1994 to 13.01.2009. Liquidator had submitted that later on it had received letter dated 05.08.2021 from Sugna Feeds Pvt. Ltd. expressing its intention to participate in the auction sale of the subject property. It was contended that Sugna Feeds Pvt. Ltd. is a well-established player in the poultry feeds sector, whereas appellant was incorporated only on 09.07.2021 i.e. after issuance of the E-auction sale notice.
5.5. Appellant while submitting its bid vide application dated 16.07.2021 had accepted the terms and conditions of the auction process shared by the Liquidator which contained paragraph-7. Paragraph-7 is specific: it mentions that applicant would adhere to the terms and conditions of the E-Auction Process Information Document as shared by the Liquidator.
6. Mr. Sunil Mohan Acharya- Liquidator of the corporate debtor i.e., Respondent No.2 has filed counter affidavit. He was appointed as Liquidator of the corporate debtor by the Tribunal vide order dated 19.02.2021. According to him, the admitted debts of the corporate debtor are Rs.530 Crores of which claims of financial creditors are Rs.371 Crores.
6.1. By an E-auction notice dated 02.06.2021, the assets of the corporate debtor being, inter alia, poultry feed farms at Lucknow (Lot EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 870 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
No.2) and Mirzapur (Lot No.3) were put up for auction with reserve prices of Rs.11.30 crores and Rs. 12.69 crores respectively. By an e-mail dated 07.06.2021, respondent No. 2 had forwarded the E-auction notice to the prospective bidders, including to the appellant. However, as no bids were received in respect of any of the assets of the corporate debtor, reserve prices were reduced by 25% as provided in the Regulations, whereafter Lot No.2 and Lot No.3-subject property, with revised reserve prices of Rs.8.50 crores and Rs. 10.00 crores respectively were again put up for auction vide E-auction notice dated 28.06.2021. By an e-mail dated 29.06.2021, the E-auction notice along with E-Auction Process Information Document were sent to the prospective bidders, including the appellant.
6.2. Before the date of auction on 20.07.2021, earnest money deposit (EMD) was paid by the appellant and another intending bidder both for Lot No.2 and the subject property. Five minutes before the scheduled closure of bidding time there was a spurt of counter bids for Lot No.2 by the appellant and the other bidder, taking the price from Rs.8.50 crores to Rs.14.79 crores. The pattern of bidding in respect of Lot No.2 and the fact that the same two entities had submitted EMD for the subject property, but the bid being ultimately made only by the appellant led Respondent No.2 to believe that higher bids could be received for the subject property on further re-auction.
6.3. According to Respondent No.2, the subject property had a cost of Rs.17.30 crores and written down book value of Rs.8.59 crores as compared to Lot No.2, which had cost of Rs.9.28 crores and written down book value of only Rs.2.45 crores. However, Lot No.2 was sold for Rs.14.39 crores as against its reserve price of Rs.8.50 crores. Respondent No.2 therefore expected a price higher than Rs.10 crores for the subject property as Lot No.2 despite having a substantially lower worth as per the available record had fetched bids higher than Rs.10 crores.
6.4. For the aforesaid reasons and to maximise the value of the subject property which would enure to the benefit of all stakeholders, Respondent No.2 thought it prudent to explore the possibility of further price enhancement in respect of the subject property and therefore decided to cancel the auction for the subject property.
6.5. In support of the above averments, Respondent No.2 has referred to certain terms and conditions in the E-auction notice and the E-Auction Process Information Document. Clause 3(f) binds the applicant to accept the terms of the disclaimer, which forms an integral part of the E-Auction Process Information Document. Clause 3 (k) says that the Liquidator has the absolute right to accept or reject any or all bids or adjourn/postpone/cancel the E-auction or withdraw any asset/property or portion thereof from the E-auction at any stage without assigning any reason thereof. As per Clause 5 (m), the bidder with the highest offer/bid does not get any right to demand acceptance of his bid. Clause 5 (n) provides for intimation to be sent to the successful bidder via e-mail. Date of sending the mail would be considered as the date of receipt of the intimation. As per Clause 2 (h), on the close of the auction, the highest bidder shall be invited to provide balance sale consideration within 90 days of the date of such demand. Clause 2 (i) makes it clear that on payment of the full amount, the sale shall stand completed. The Liquidator shall then execute certificate of sale or sale deed to transfer such assets and thereafter the assets shall be delivered to the highest bidder in the manner specified in terms of the sale.
6.6. Respondent No.2 has contended that while submitting its bid for the subject property, the appellant was well aware of the terms and conditions governing the sale by auction. Appellant expressly accepted the aforesaid terms and conditions while submitting its application dated 16.07.2021 for participating in the auction bid process. According to him, on expiry of the time to submit bids on 20.07.2021, an auto generated e-mail from the web portal of ‘eauctioneer.com’ was sent to the appellant stating that the bid submitted by it was the highest.
6.7. Thereafter, by an e-mail dated 21.07.2021, Respondent No.2 informed the appellant about cancellation of E-auction held on 20.07.2021 under Clause 3(k) of the E-Auction Process Information Document. Appellant was advised to collect the EMD as a fresh E-auction sale was to be conducted.
6.8. Respondent No.2 has mentioned that he had received an e-mail dated 10.09.2021 from one Mr. Amit Ghidia alleging that the directors of the appellant were also the founder promoters of M/s. Amrit Feeds Limited, the corporate debtor. On receipt of such e-mail, Respondent No.2 carried out inspection and upon verification came to know that one of the present directors of the appellant, Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia was a director and the EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 872 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
principal shareholder of the corporate debtor during the period 22.09.1994 to 13.08.2019. Respondent No.2 has also mentioned that appellant was incorporated only in July, 2021.
6.9. Referring to the proceeding before the Tribunal instituted by the appellant, he submits that the application filed by the appellant against cancellation of the E-auction was taken up for hearing on 29.07.2021 and concluded on the same day without giving any opportunity to Respondent No.2 to file reply. However, the parties were permitted to file written submissions which were duly filed by Respondent No.2.
6.10. By order dated 12.08.2021, Tribunal allowed the application of the appellant and directed Respondent No.2 to send a communication to the appellant for depositing the balance sale consideration within the time specified in the E-auction notice.
6.11. Punjab National Bank i.e., Respondent No.1, a financial creditor of the corporate debtor, having claims of Rs.136,61,93,948/- assailed the order dated 12.08.2021 before the Appellate Tribunal. In such proceedings, Respondent No.2 supported the stand of Respondent No.1. Appellate Tribunal by order dated 30.11.2021 allowed the appeal of Punjab National Bank and directed Respondent No.2 to initiate a fresh process of auction in accordance with the provisions of the Code and the Regulations.
6.12. It is stated that after the order dated 30.11.2021 was passed by the Appellate Tribunal, Respondent No.2 had sent an e-mail dated 02.12.2021 calling upon the appellant to comply with the order of the Appellate Tribunal and to handover peaceful possession of the subject property. As there was no response from the appellant, Respondent No.2 made several calls to Navneet Kumar Ghidia, Director of Eva Agro Feeds Pvt. Ltd. on his mobile phone but the calls went unanswered. Appellant did not allow even the representative of Respondent No.2 to enter into the subject property. That apart, representative of Respondent No.2 had informed him that the appellant was wrongfully removing materials and equipments from the subject property.
6.13. It is further stated that subsequent to cancellation of the E-auction sale of the subject property, Respondent No.2 had received a letter dated 05.08.2021 from Sugna Feeds Pvt. Ltd., a well-established player in the poultry feeds sector, expressing its intention to participate in the auction of the subject property. It is stated that in addition to the above, respondent No.2 had received an e-mail dated 20.08.2021 from IFFCO KISAN Delhi, a subsidiary company of Indian Farmers Fertilisers Cooperative (IFFCO) expressing its interest in the assets of the corporate debtor.
6.14. In the above circumstances, Respondent No.2 has contended that cancellation of E-auction was justified and was done in the best interest of the stakeholders of the corporate debtor.
7. Appellant has filed rejoinder affidavit to the counter affidavit of Respondent No.1.
7.1. While reiterating its contentions, appellant has stated that the adjudicating authority i.e., the Tribunal had rightly set aside the decision of the Liquidator (Respondent No.2). Respondent No.2 after issuing the certificate certifying that appellant had won the auction of the subject property, cancelled the E-auction without giving any justification or reason for such cancellation. Referring to Clause 3 (a) of the E-Auction Process Information Document, appellant has contended that the said clause is contrary to the Regulations. In the facts and circumstances of the case, Respondent No.2 could not have cancelled the auction. Such act of cancellation of E-auction was wholly illegal and arbitrary. In this connection, reliance has been placed upon para 1(12) of Schedule I to the Regulations. Appellant was the highest and sole bidder in the second round of auction and its bid amount matched the reserve price as mentioned in the sale notice. Reserve price in the first round of auction was fixed at Rs.12,69,00,000/-. However, as the auction sale did not materialise, Respondent No.2 in the second round reduced the reserve price in order to get bidders to at least match the reserve price. This was done successfully by the appellant whereafter appellant was informed that it had won the bid. Action of Respondent No.2 in cancelling the E-auction after e-mailing the appellant that it had won the bid is a clear case of abuse of the process.
7.2. Respondent No.2 vide public notice dated 24.12.2021 scheduled fresh E-auction on 17.01.2022 again fixing the reserve price in relation to the subject property at Rs.10 crores which was the same amount as the reserve price in the second round of bidding and which was the bid amount of the appellant EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 874 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
7.3. Respondent No.1 has misinterpreted Clause 3 (k) to mean that since full amount was not paid, it was entitled to invoke the said clause and cancel the bid. Such a contention is wholly untenable having regard to the overall scheme of the Regulations. No reasons were assigned by the Liquidator while cancelling the auction process. The order cancelling the auction being devoid of any reasons does not indicate application of mind by the Liquidator.
7.4. Appellant has asserted that the Liquidator i.e. Respondent No.2 had accepted the decision of the Tribunal by not filing any appeal against the order dated 12.8.2021. Therefore, it is not open to the Liquidator to contest the claim of the appellant.
8. As noticed above, one Mr. Harish Bagla has filed an application seeking intervention which we have allowed.
9. In addition to narrating the facts and commenting thereupon, the intervenor has averred that the principal person in control of the appellant is one Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia who is a director and principal shareholder of the appellant. Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia was also one of the promoter directors and principal shareholders of the corporate debtor. Sale of any asset of the corporate debtor could not have been conducted in favour of a related party of the corporate debtor in view of the specific bar under Section 29A of the Code. As a matter of fact, Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia is also the maternal uncle of the intervenor who is the ex-managing director of the corporate debtor. Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia therefore comes within the meaning of ‘related party’ as defined under Sections 5(24) and 5(24A) of the Code. Therefore, the auction sale in favour of the appellant is bad in law and cannot be sustained.
9.1. This aspect was also brought to the notice of Respondent No.2 i.e. the Liquidator.
9.2. It is stated that the intervenor had filed an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal being Company Appeal (AD) (Insolvency) No.789 of 2021. In the said appeal, an interim order was passed on 27.09.2021 directing the parties to maintain status quo. Before the appeal of the intervenor could be heard, the Appellate Tribunal had passed the order dated 30.11.2021 allowing the appeal of Respondent No.1 by setting aside the order of the Tribunal dated 12.08.2021. Therefore, when the appeal of the intervenor came up for hearing before the Appellate Tribunal, the same was disposed of vide order dated 09.12.2021 as having been rendered infructuous. When the intervenor came to know that the appellant has filed the present appeal, it had filed the intervention application.
10. We have heard Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, learned senior counsel for the appellant; Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam, learned counsel for Respondent No.1; Mr. Krishnaraj Thakker, learned counsel for Respondent No.2; and Mr. Siddharth Bhatnagar, learned senior counsel for the intervenor - Mr. Harish Bagla.
11. Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, learned senior counsel for the appellant at the outset submits that Appellate Tribunal fell in complete error in setting aside the order of the Tribunal and restoring the order of the Liquidator. Adverting to the order of the Liquidator cancelling the auction sale, he submits that the same is devoid of any reasons. Such an order is not only arbitrary but is non est in the eye of law. There could not have been any occasion for the Liquidator to go for a fresh auction keeping the reserve price at the same amount of Rs.10 crores which was the bid offered by the appellant and accepted by the Liquidator. In fact, Liquidator had declared that the appellant had won the bid. Tribunal had rightly appreciated the grievance of the appellant and interfered with the aforesaid order of the Liquidator. Liquidator did not challenge the order of the Tribunal dated 12.08.2021, rather Liquidator had complied with the same by accepting the balance sale consideration from the appellant and issuing the sale certificate. Since Liquidator had accepted the order of the Tribunal, it was not open for him to support Respondent No.1 or the order of the Appellate Tribunal in the appeal filed by the appellant. He has also pointed out that at the time of auction, Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia was no longer connected with the corporate debtor having retired from the said company way back in the year 2011. Therefore, he cannot come within the ambit of the expression ‘related party’ as defined under the Code. He submits that the present is a fit case for setting aside the order of the Appellate Tribunal and restoring the order of the Tribunal which as a matter of fact has been complied with by the Liquidator.
EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 876 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
12. Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam, learned counsel for Respondent No.1 submits that appellant has failed to point out any particular provision either in the Code or in the Regulations prohibiting the Liquidator from cancelling the auction sale after declaring the highest bidder but before completion of sale. Power of cancellation is available to the Liquidator under Clause 3(k) of the auction notice. Such a power could be exercised by the Liquidator without assigning any reason. While bidding, the appellant had unconditionally accepted all the clauses of the auction notice, including Clause 3(k). Therefore, the Tribunal was not justified in interfering with such a decision of the Liquidator and further directing the Liquidator to conclude the auction sale process. Before completion of sale, highest bidder has no vested right for confirmation of sale in his favour. Insofar as the maintainability of the appeal before the Appellate Tribunal is concerned, he submits that there is no bar or prohibition restraining a financial creditor from preferring an appeal against an order of the Tribunal since the financial creditor is certainly an aggrieved person and has substantial interest in the auction sale of the subject property of the corporate debtor. That apart, under para 1(11) of Schedule I to the Regulations, the Liquidator has the discretion to conduct multiple rounds of auction to maximize realization in the sale of assets and to promote the best interest of the financial creditors. He submits that reliance on para 1(13) of Schedule I to the Regulations by learned senior counsel for the appellant is misplaced inasmuch as a sale can be said to have been completed only on payment of the full amount and not on declaration of a bidder as the highest bidder who in any case has no vested right to claim confirmation of sale. He submits that appellant is in no way prejudiced by the next round of auction which was scheduled on 17.01.2022 but could not proceed because of the restraint imposed by this Court. Appellant can certainly participate in the next round of auction.
12.1. In the above context, he submits that Tribunal was not justified in interfering with the decision of the Liquidator and therefore, Appellate Tribunal rightly set aside the said order of the Tribunal and in restoring the order of the Liquidator. He has referred to Clause 3 (k) of the auction notice which confers discretion upon the Liquidator to cancel the E-auction at any stage without assigning any reason. Adverting to the facts of the present case, he submits that the appellant was the sole bidder and his bid amount was exactly the same as the reserve price. It was in that context that the Liquidator decided to cancel the auction with a view to have another round of auction to fetch a better price. There was nothing wrong or illegal in the exercise of such discretion by the Liquidator.
13. Mr. Krishnaraj Thakker, learned counsel for Respondent No.2 has also adopted and reiterated the above submissions made by learned counsel for Respondent No.1. Additionally, he submits that Liquidator had received an e-mail dated 10.09.2021 from one Mr. Amit Ghidia informing him that the promoter of the appellant was also the founder promoter of the corporate debtor. Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia who is one of the directors of the appellant was also a director and principal shareholder of the corporate debtor. Recent incorporation of the appellant in the month of July 2021 also raised suspicion about the nature of the appellant and its intentions.
13.1. Appellant while submitting its bid had accepted the terms and conditions of the auction process. Therefore, it is not open to the appellant to question the exercise of discretion by the Liquidator, which is one of the terms and conditions of the auction.
13.2. In so far issuance of e-mail to the appellant declaring it as the winner of the auction process is concerned, he submits that on expiry of the time for placing of bids, an auto generated e-mail from the e-auction website “www.eauctioneer.com” was sent to the appellant stating that the bid submitted by it was the highest. It was an auto-generated e-mail and cannot be construed to be the E-auction certificate. In so far acceptance of the balance sale consideration and issuance of sale certificate is concerned, he submits that the same was done as per the direction of the Tribunal.
13.3. In the course of the hearing, he submitted that there were two assets of the corporate debtor; one at Lucknow (Lot No. 2) and the other at Mirzapur (Lot No.3). Since the assets at Lot No.2 fetched Rs.4.79 crores more than the reserve price, Liquidator believed that the subject property could fetch a higher amount than the reserve price of Rs.10 crores. Keeping this in mind, he had cancelled the E-auction process.
13.4. On the submission that Liquidator did not assail the decision of the Tribunal and therefore had accepted the same, his contention is that in all the proceedings Liquidator had contested the case projected by the appellant. Now that the appeal of Respondent No.1 has been allowed by the Appellate EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 878 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
Tribunal, Liquidator is bound by the same. He submits that decision of the Liquidator to cancel the auction was vindicated when post cancellation of auction, Liquidator received letter dated 05.08.2021 from Sugna Feeds Private Limited expressing its intention to participate in the auction of the subject property. Sugna Feeds Private Limited is a well-established player in the poultry sector whereas appellant was incorporated after issuance of the E-auction sale notice.
14. Mr. Siddharth Bhatnagar, learned senior counsel appearing for the intervenor highlighted the issue of ‘related party’. According to him, appellant should have been disqualified from participating in the E-auction by reason of being a ‘related party’. Promoter director of the appellant, Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia, is the maternal uncle of Mr. Harish Bagla, the intervener. Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia is one of the directors of the appellant. He was also one of the promoter directors and original subscribers to the Memorandum and Articles of Association of the corporate debtor. Elaborating further, he submits that mother of the intervenor Smt. Chanda Bagla is the sister of Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia. Intervenor has a significant stake in the corporate debtor having held about fifty-three per cent of the paid-up share-capital of the corporate debtor. Liquidator, therefore, should have cancelled the auction sale notice only on the ground that appellant is a ‘related party’ to the corporate debtor. Referring to the e-mail dated 10.09.2021, he submits that Mr. Amit Ghidia, son of Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia had brought to the notice of the Liquidator that Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia is the maternal uncle of the intervenor. By virtue of such relationship, appellant would attract disqualification under Section 29A read with Section 5(24) and Section 5(24A) of the Code.
15. Referring to the above contentions, Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, learned senior counsel for the appellant submits that it was because of the activities of persons like the intervenor that the corporate debtor has landed in the present situation. Therefore, it is not open to such persons to talk about getting proper valuation of the auctioned assets of the corporate debtor. In so far allegation of ‘related party’ is concerned, he submits that the same is no bar at all and cannot be held as a disqualification for the appellant inasmuch as Mr. Vijay Kumar Ghidia had ceased to be a director of the corporate debtor way back in the year 2011. To attract disqualification under Section 29A, the relationship has to be proximate. In this connection, he has placed reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of Swiss Ribbons Private Limited and Another versus Union of India and Others1.
16. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received due consideration of the Court.
17. As we have noted above after initiation of the corporate insolvency resolution process, Liquidator i.e. Respondent No.2 had issued sale notice dated 02.06.2021 for sale of the subject property of the corporate debtor. The reserve price of the subject property was fixed at Rs.12.69 crores, whereas EMD was fixed at Rs.1,26,19,000.00. E-auction was scheduled on 23.06.2021 between 14.00 to 14.30 hrs. This E-auction did not fructify in the absence of any bidders. Thereafter, Respondent No. 2 issued second sale notice dated 28.06.2021 for auction sale amongst others of the subject property. This time the reserve price was scaled down to Rs.10 crores and correspondingly, the EMD was fixed at Rs.1 crore. Last date for deposit of EMD was 19.07.2021 and the date and time of bid was fixed as 20.07.2021 at 14.30 hrs. It was mentioned therein that the E-auction sale would be subject to the terms and conditions prescribed in E-Auction Process Information Document available at the website of the second Respondent.
17.1. As it appears, appellant was the sole bidder and its bid value was Rs.10 crores which was equivalent to the reserve price.
18. Pausing here for a moment, we may advert to the Bid Application Form. As per Clause-7 of the Bid Application Form, the applicant i.e. the bidder was required to adhere to the terms and conditions mentioned in the E-Auction Process Information Document. Clause-9 provided that the applicant would participate in the E-auction for the sale of assets on as is where is basis, as is what is basis, whatever there is basis and no recourse basis. Further, if selected as the highest bidder, the bid amount would be unconditionally binding on the applicant. Clause-12 made it clear that the applicant would at all time adhere to the provisions of the Code and the Regulations.
1 (2019) 4 SCC 17
EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 880 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
19. The E-Auction Process Information Document was issued by the Liquidator i.e. Respondent No.2 for regulating the E-auction of the subject property of the corporate debtor. As per Clause 2 (g), unless specified otherwise, EMD of the successful bidder would be retained towards part of the sale consideration and EMD of unsuccessful bidder would be refunded, which would not bear any interest. Clause 2 (h) says that in accordance with para 1(12) of Schedule I to the Regulations, on the closure of the auction, the highest bidder would be invited to provide balance sale consideration within 90 days of the date of such demand. As per proviso (i) of Clause 2(h), payments made after 30 days would attract interest at the rate of 12 per cent and as per proviso (ii) of Clause 2(h), the sale shall be cancelled if the payment is not received within 90 days. Clause 2 (i) says that on payment of the full amount, the sale would stand completed and the Liquidator would execute the certificate of sale or sale deed to transfer such assets which would be delivered to him in the manner specified in the terms of sale. As per Clause 2(m), the information provided in the E-Auction Process Information Document should be read together with the provisions of the Code and the Regulations. In the event of a conflict between the E-Auction Process Information Document and the Code or the Regulations, provisions of the Code or the Regulations, as the case may be, would prevail. Mandate of Clause 2(r) is that the successful bidder would have to take over possession of the movable assets being sold under the E-auction within 15 days from the date of the complete payment to the Liquidator without any damage to the premises where the assets were kept.
19.1. Clause 3 of the E-Auction Process Information Document deals with disclaimer. While Clause 3 (a) says that the said document has been issued by the Liquidator for general information purposes only; sub-clause
(b) clarifies that the said document is not a statutory document; it has not been approved or registered with any regulatory or statutory authority of Government of India or any State Government. Further, nothing relating to the E-Auction Process Information Document should be construed as legal, financial, accounting, regulatory or tax advice by the Liquidator. Clause 3
(f) declares that by procuring a copy of the E-Auction Process Information Document, the recipient accepted the terms of the disclaimer, which forms an integral part of the E-Auction Process Information Document. As per Clause 3(i), E-Auction Process Information Document is neither an agreement nor an offer by the Liquidator to the prospective bidders or any other person. Objective of the E-Auction Process Information Document is to provide interested parties with information that may be useful to them in making their bids. Clause 3(k) declares that the Liquidator has absolute right to accept or reject any or all bids or adjourn/postpone/cancel the E-auction or withdraw any asset/property or portion thereof from the E-auction at any stage without assigning any reason thereof. As per Clause 5(m), the highest bid on the E-auction shall supersede all the previous bids of the respective bidders. However, the bidder of the highest offer/bid does not get any right to demand acceptance of his bid.
20. On 21.07.2021, appellant received a congratulatory e-mail from the second respondent i.e., the Liquidator. The language of this e-mail is quite important. Appellant was informed that it had won the auction for the subject property. The winning bidders’ order had been prepared and the item was listed on the appellant’s web page. If the appellant had any queries, it was advised to contact the auction administrator. When the appellant requested Respondent No.2 for issuance of allotment letter in respect of the subject property, it received an e-mail from the Respondent No.2 on 21.07.2021 itself at 17:56 pm. Appellant was informed that in terms of Clause 3 (k) of the E-Auction Process Information Document, he had cancelled the E-auction held on 20.07.2021. Appellant was informed that the Liquidator would come up with a fresh E-auction for sale of the subject property.
20.1. From the aforesaid, we find that no reasons were assigned by the Liquidator for cancellation of the E-auction held on 20.07.2021. Appellant was simply informed that the E-auction was cancelled in terms of Clause 3(k) of the E-Auction Process Information Document. Clause 3
(k) as discussed above only declares that the Liquidator has absolute right to accept or reject any or all bids or adjourn/postpone/cancel the E-auction etc., at any stage without assigning any reason therefor. We will advert to this clause a little later.
21. To complete the narrative, we may mention that aggrieved by such cancellation, appellant had filed an application under Section 60 of the Code before the Tribunal assailing such cancellation. Issue before the Tribunal was whether the Liquidator was justified in cancelling the E-auction. Tribunal noted that the Liquidator had cancelled the auction without assigning any EVA AGRO FEEDS PRIVATE LIMITED v. PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANR. [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] 882 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.