Naresh @ Nehru v. State of Haryana
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 889; [2023] 13 S.C.R. 771
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Ipc Based On the Statement of Pw-9, Justice As An Eyewitness to the Crime
- Decided
- 9 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1786/2023
- Sections
- 302, 149, 65, 25, 26, 307, 313, 65B, 161, 27, 3, 141
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 13 S.C.R. 771 : 2023 INSC 889
CASE DETAILS
NARESH @ NEHRU v.
STATE OF HARYANA
(Criminal Appeal No. 1786 of 2023)
OCTOBER 09, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND ARAVIND KUMAR, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Conviction of the appellants for offences punishable u/s.302 r/w s.149, IPC based on the statement of PW-9, as an eyewitness to the crime, if justified.
Evidence – Of eyewitness – When not to be relied upon:
Held: Evidence of the eye-witness should be of very sterling quality and calibre and it should not only instil confidence in the court to accept the same but it should also be a version of such nature that can be accepted at its face value – In the present case, testimony of PW-9 (cousin of the deceased) was shrouded with inconsistencies and he had not named the appellants in the FIR – Contradictions in PW-9’s statement were glaring – Prosecution failed to prove the guilt of the appellants beyond reasonable doubt – Non-consideration of the lacuna in the prosecution case in proper perspective by the Trial Court and the High Court resulted in miscarriage of justice – Conviction of the appellants unsustainable – Judgment of Courts below set aside – Appellants acquitted of the offences alleged. [Paras 9.1- 9.3, 10 and 11] Evidence – CCTV footage – Reliance placed to convict the appellants and co-accused persons, if proper:
Held: Said evidence could not have been relied upon as it was infested with serious doubts and the very manner in which it came into existence itself raised a serious doubt not only about its source but also about the presence of the appellants at the scene of crime – PW-8 who made a video from his mobile phone of the CCTV footage on 22.04.2016 claimed to SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.772 have handed over the recorded CD (Ex.P.3) to the police on 01.06.2016 – However, the video (CD) was not forwarded by the police to the Forensic Science Laboratory – PW-8 claims to have downloaded the video from his mobile phone and transferred to his laptop and then prepared CD (Ex.P.3) – Neither laptop nor mobile phone was produced by prosecution or had been seized by the police during the course of investigation – Trial court’s conclusion is based on inconsistent evidence and there is lack of clarity in the evidence of PW.8 – He identified his signature on the certificate Ex. P-L (furnished as required u/s.65-B, Evidence Act) which was prepared by police official who was not examined – Further, Ex.P.3 was played in the trial court and the Sessions Judge recorded that from the video clips the faces of assailants and complainants were not decipherable – PW-8 admitted in his cross-examination that certificate Ex.PL was prepared by a police official, and he had affixed his signature to Ex.PL – He also admitted that faces of the assailants were not visible and identifiable and the registration numbers of the motorcycles were also not visible – Investigating Officer (PW-15) also admitted in his cross-examination that faces of the accused are not identifiable from the video – The said video according to PW-8 was taken from the CCTV camera located in the house of ‘D’ who was never cited as a witness by the prosecution – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.65-B. [Paras 9.4, 9.5] Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.25, 26 – Confessional statement of the accused and co-accused were recorded when they were in police custody: Held: Such confessional statements would become inadmissible having regard to the provisions of ss.25, 26 – s.25 makes it clear that no confession made to a police officer shall be proved as against a person accused of any offence – Likewise, s.26 states that any such statement is inadmissible if given while in police custody. [Para 9.6] Penal Code, 1860 – s.149:
Held: In order to attract s.149, it must be shown by the prosecution that the incriminating act was done to accomplish the common object by such unlawful assembly – It must be within the knowledge of the other members as one likely to be committed in furtherance of the common object – Even if no overt act is imputed to the accused, the presence of the accused as part of the unlawful assembly is sufficient for conviction – Inference of a common object has to be drawn from various factors such as the weapons with which the members were armed, their movements, the acts of violence committed by them, and the end result – In the present case, High Court held that every member had inhibited the common intention to accomplish the unlawful object – On facts, the motive alleged was a quarrel that ensued between one ‘R’ and ‘N’ with ‘A’ (the deceased) and ‘S’ on the day of Dulhandi and ‘R’ was said to have threatened to kill ‘A’ – This factor clearly discloses that the appellants herein were not involved in the fight that occurred on the day of Dulhandi and as such no motive could be attributed to the appellants – Prosecution failed to prove that the appellants shared a common object with other members of the alleged unlawful assembly – There is no evidence to connect the appellants with the deceased or the co-accused – No overt act was attributed to the appellants – PW-9 admitted in his cross-examination that none of the accused except ‘P’ had caused injury to the deceased and there was only a single shot fired from the pistol. [Para 10]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Rai Sandeep @ Deepu alias Deepu v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2012) 8 SCC 21 : [2012] 6 SCR 1153; Mehboob Ali & Another v. State of Rajasthan (2016) 14 SCC 640 : [2015] 10 SCR 553; Indra Dalal v. State of Haryana (2015) 11 SCC 31 : [2015] 7 SCR 1083; Roy Fernandes v. State of Goa and Others (2012) 3 SCC 221: [2012] 1 SCR 477 – relied on.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
1786 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 09.01.2020 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRAD No.1063 of 2017.
With Criminal Appeal Nos.1787-1788 of 2023.
Appearances:
Siddharth Mittal, Prabhat Kumar, Vaibhav Tomar, Mrs. Shilpa G Mittal, Soumik Ghosal, Vikas Walia, Syed M Shoeb, Ms. Drishti Harpalani, Gaurav Singh, Advs. for the Appellant.
NARESH @ NEHRU v. STATE OF HARYANA SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.774 Mrs. Manisha Aggarwal Narain, AAG, Samar Vijay Singh, Keshav Mittal, Ms. Sabarni Som, Sandeep Singh Somaria, Shivangi G., Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
ARAVIND KUMAR, J.
1. Judgment dated 09-01-2020 rendered in Criminal Appeal Nos.1063 of 2017, 997 & 1043 of 2017 by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Judicature at Chandigarh is under challenge in these appeals, whereunder the accused Nos.4, 5 and 6 (appellants herein) who were convicted for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code (for short ‘IPC’) by the Sessions Court came to be affirmed.
GIST OF PROSECUTION CASE:
2. On 22-04-2016, ASI Ram Kishan while on patrolling duty at 75 feet road, had received a telephonic information that in the village Maheshwari certain persons had fired a gun-shot at a boy and upon reaching there, statement of Mohit @ Kala came to be recorded which was to the effect that at about 6.40 pm his cousins Ajay and Suraj were talking in front of the house of Ex. Sarpanch Karan Singh and they were near the house of Dharmender and he (Mohit) saw Ajay and Suraj running towards the house of Dharmender as they were being chased by three youngsters on a bullet motorcycle. It was also stated by Mohit @ Kala that bullet motorcycle was being driven by Ravi, Shoaib Khan was the pillion rider and one unknown person was sitting behind them. It was further stated that two more motorcycles having two riders each, with batons in their hands were following the Bullet motorcycle. It was also alleged that unknown person sitting on the Bullet motorcycle got down and fired at Ajay with countrymade revolver, which hit his head and Ajay fell in front of the house of Dharmender. Suraj hid in Dharmender’s house and on raising the alarm the assailants sped away on their motorcycles towards Bhiwadi; it is also stated by Mohit @ Kala that injured Ajay was shifted to the hospital; it is further stated that Ravi was studying in his school and was his junior and he used to bully and threaten all. Mohit also stated that Ajay and Suraj had a fight with Ravi on the day of ‘Dulhandi’ and he had threatened to kill them and Ravi along with his companions had fired at Ajay with intend to kill him. Based on the said statement FIR under Sections 148, 149, 307 of IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act came to be registered and on the death of Ajay (on 23-04-2016) Section 302 of IPC was substituted in place of Section 307 IPC and accused persons were apprehended; on the disclosure statement of first accused (Pawan) country made pistol was recovered and as per the statement of accused No.2 (Dharmender) wooden stick was recovered apart from four motorcycles. One of the accused-Shoaib was produced before the Juvenile Justice Board and Ravi was tried by the Children’s Court under the provisions of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. The charge was framed against six accused persons and in all 18 witnesses were examined on behalf of the prosecution. The statements of the accused under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short ‘Cr.P.C.’) came to be recorded and the accused having denied the incriminating material appearing in evidence against them, had pleaded not guilty. After hearing the learned advocates appearing for the accused persons and the public prosecutor and on appreciation of the evidence laid before the court, the learned Sessions Judge by judgment dated 06-10-2017 convicted the accused persons for the offences already noticed hereinabove and said order of conviction and sentence imposed came to be affirmed by the High Court under the impugned order vide judgment dated 09-01-2020. Hence, these appeals have been preferred by accused Nos.4 to 6.
3. We have heard Mr. Siddharth Mittal and Mr. Vikas Walia, learned Advocates appearing for the accused-appellants in Criminal Appeal Nos.1786 of 2023 and 1787-1788 of 2023 respectively, and Ms. Manisha Aggarwal Narain, learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the State of Haryana, Respondent.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS:
4. Mr. Siddharth Mittal, learned counsel for the appellant appearing for Naresh @ Nehru Accused No.4, contends that the trial court and High Court had committed an error in convicting him without considering the statement of Mohit @ Kala (PW-9) in proper perspective whereunder he had not named the appellant and the CCTV footage did not conform to Section 65 B of the Indian Evidence Act which even otherwise did not reflect A-4’s NARESH @ NEHRU v. STATE OF HARYANA [ARAVIND KUMAR, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.776 of presence. He also contends that no Test Identification Parade (TIP ‘for short’) was conducted, and PW-9 had only identified this accused (A-4) in the court. Mr. Mittal learned counsel would also contend that said witness (PW-9) was shocked or perplexed when his statement came to be recorded as admitted by him and reliance could not have been placed on said evidence for convicting the appellant. He would further contend that A-4 had no common object to share with the main accused, Pawan (PW-1), who is said to have fired at Ajay (deceased). Mr. Mittal, learned counsel would also contend that PW-9 was an interested witness as he was a close relative of the deceased, and various discrepancies, including the improvement in his statement made before court, ought to have been the ground to summarily brush aside his testimony. Mr. Mittal, learned advocate would point out that discrepancies in PW-9’s statement had clearly surfaced which was evident from his admission of not informing the police about the Splendor vehicle being driven by the appellant and this fact was conveniently ignored by the courts below. Mr. Mittal, learned counsel would also contend that CCTV footage relied upon by prosecution was recorded on a mobile phone by PW-8 and converted into a CD, which was not in conformity with Section 65B of the Evidence Act and it was allegedly recorded on 26.04.2016 but handed over to the police on 01.06.2016 and during this interregnum period the possibility of said recording being tampered could not have been ruled out. Even otherwise the face of the assailants was not identifiable in the CCTV footage as found by the trial court itself and, therefore, no inference could have been drawn to implicate the appellant(A-4).
5. He would contend that the alleged motive attributed to the accused persons is due to a quarrel that had ensued between the deceased, Suraj, Ravi, and Nabbu on the day of Dulhandi and there was no evidence placed on record by prosecution to suggest any common object had been shared by the appellants with other accused persons. He would contend that appellant has not been alleged to have been armed with any weapon, so no inference could have been drawn about the common object to commit the offence. He would submit that the reasoning adopted by the courts below to convict the accused by overlooking the fact that TIP had not been conducted and only on the ground of PW-9 having known the remaining accused by face before the incident was erroneous, though the testimony of PW-9 would suggest that accused persons were not previously known to him and his admission in evidence that came to know about them only when they were arrested and their names were published in the newspaper. The nondisclosure of the names of the accused persons at the first instance creates reasonable doubts as to the appellant’s identity. The learned counsel for the appellant (A-4) would also contend that there was unexplained delay in recording PW-9’s statement, namely it was recorded at 11:30 p.m., despite the incident having taken place at 6:30 p.m. and PW-9 was present during this period. The alleged confessional statement of the appellant is of no value in the light of Section 25 of the Evidence Act and said statement does not indicate any common object having been shared by the appellant with other assailants. Hence, he prays for his appeal being allowed and the appellant (A-4) being acquitted.
6. Mr. Vikas Walia, learned counsel appearing for the appellants, namely, Irshad and Sonu Kumar (accused numbers 5 and 6 respectively) in Criminal Appeal Nos.1787-1788 of 2023, contends that courts below had erred in not considering the fact that a person liable for being punished for the offence of being a member of an unlawful assembly under Section 149 IPC would be necessary to prove that such persons had acted in pursuance of a common object. He would further contend that prosecution had failed to prove that appellants were aware of Pawan’s (Accused No.1) possessing the pistol and he had the intention/object to kill Ajay and such intention could not be inferred. He would contend that appellants’ involvement in the unlawful assembly and sharing a common object to kill Ajay could not be inferred in the circumstances of the case, particularly when there was no evidence to support the stand of the prosecution that appellants were aware of pistol being in possession of Pawan (A-1).
7. He would further contend that the prosecution failed to prove that the members of the unlawful assembly had assembled to accomplish the common object of killing Ajay, as attributed to them. There was no evidence suggesting a sharing of common object between the accused. The CCTV footage, which was relied upon by the prosecution, does not inspire confidence to accept the story of the prosecution, since, faces appearing in the video was not clear and this itself would be a good ground to allow appeals and set aside the conviction of the appellants. NARESH @ NEHRU v. STATE OF HARYANA [ARAVIND KUMAR, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.778 He would also contend that appellants were not residents of the village where the incident took place and there is no whisper in the statement of PW-9 recorded under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. on this aspect. Hence, he prays for appeal preferred by A-5, and A-6 be allowed by setting aside the impugned judgment.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION:
8. Having heard the learned counsels appearing for the parties and on perusal of the judgments of the courts below, it would emerge therefrom, that conviction of all the accused is based on the testimony of PW-9 and recovery of the motor-cycles and the motive for the crime attributed by PW-9 in his statement recorded on the date of incident. In this background, we have perused the judgments of the courts below by bestowing our anxious consideration to the rival contentions raised at the Bar.
9. At the outset, it requires to be noticed that motive that has been attributed against the accused persons for the killing of Ajay was, he (Ajay) and Suraj had a fight with Ravi on the day of Dulhandi, where Ravi had threatened to kill them and in furtherance of said threat, he is said to have come along with other co-accused, and a person sitting on the bullet motorcycle had fired at Ajay from the pistol, while Ravi was driving the Bullet motorcycle. PW-9 had also deposed that Ajay was in the company of Suraj, who ran alongside the deceased and hid himself in Dharmender’s house. However, the police did not record the statement of Suraj, and he was not even cited as a witness on behalf of the prosecution. This would be the first gap in the prosecution story or a defective investigation.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.