Commissioner of Customs (Imports), Mumbai v. M/S Ganpati Overseas Through Its Proprietor Shri Yashpal Sharma & Anr.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 881; [2023] 13 S.C.R. 172
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice 1962 – 14 – Customs Valuation (Determination of Price of Imported Goods) Rules, Justice 1988 – R. 4
- Decided
- 6 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4735/2009
- Sections
- 108, 130, 135, 14, 28(1), 112, 124, 14(1), 114A, 132, 193, 228
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 13 S.C.R. 172 : 2023 INSC 881
CASE DETAILS
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI
v.
M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR SHRI
YASHPAL SHARMA & ANR.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 4735-4736 of 2009)
OCTOBER 06, 2023
[B. V. NAGARATHNA AND UJJAL BHUYAN, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the tribunal was justified in holding that enhancement of value of the imported goods and the penalties imposed by the Commissioner of Customs on the noticee-respondents could not be sustained and consequently in setting aside the same.
Customs Act, 1962 – 14 – Customs Valuation (Determination of Price of Imported Goods) Rules, 1988 – r. 4, 8, 5, 6 and 7 – Transaction value of imported goods – Determination of – Allegations of underinvoicing of price and thereby evasion of customs duty by the respondents – Initiation of proceedings on the basis of the price declared by the foreign supplier in the first set of export declarations filed before the Hong Kong customs authority – Discrepancies noticed in the price mentioned in the export declarations and the price of the goods as per the import invoices – Filing of second set of export declarations albeit imposition of penalty for mis-declaration of price at the initial stage, which stood paid by the foreign supplier – Department after rejecting the price declared as per the import invoices, invoked r. 8 straightaway instead of going through rr. 5, 6 and 7 thereof sequentially – Correctness: Held: If transaction value of imported goods cannot be determined, the value shall be determined by proceeding sequentially through rr. 5 to 8 – Where the value of imported goods cannot be determined under the provisions of any of the rr 5 to 7A, the value shall be determined using reasonable means as provided in r. 8-the residual method – Furthermore, transaction value can be rejected if the invoice price is not found to be correct but it is for the department to prove that the invoice price is incorrect – On facts, both the department as well as the adjudicating authority were not justified in rejecting the import invoice price of the goods as not correct and enhancing the price by straightaway invoking r. 8 when there was no evidence before them to do so – Thus, the tribunal was justified in setting aside the order passed by the adjudicating authority – No error or infirmity in the impugned judgment of passed by the tribunal. [Paras 34.1, 37, 40.2, 41,42] Customs Act, 1962 – Initiation of proceeding alleging underinvoicing of price of goods imported from foreign country and thereby evading customs duty by the noticee – Reliance upon the unattested photocopies of the first set of export declarations filed by the foreign supplier before the customs authority showing great discrepancy in the price mentioned in the export declarations and the price of the goods as per the import invoices – Justification:
Held: Export declarations relied upon by the Department and earlier by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence were unattested photocopies – Since those documents were used as a piece of evidence against the noticee, it was necessary that those documents were required to have been proved – Unattested photocopies of the relied upon documents without anyone proving or owning up the veracity of the same would not have any evidentiary value – Very substratum of these documents was subsequently removed when the foreign supplier filed a second set of export declarations before the Hong Kong customs authority showing lower price matching the price of the goods declared in the import invoices – Foreign supplier had paid the penalty for mis declaration of price at the initial stage – There can be no justifiable reason for the department to harp upon the price of the goods as per the initial export declarations by placing reliance on the unattested photocopies of the first set of export declarations to prove underinvoicing for the purpose of evading customs duty – Tribunal rightly held that the value shown in the first set of export declarations could not form any reliable basis for enhancement of the value. [Paras 16, 17] Customs Act, 1962 – s. 108 – Power to summon persons to give evidence and produce documents – Admissibility in evidence of the statement recorded u/s. 108:
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI
OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.174 Held: Customs officer is not a police officer, and the person summoned and who makes a statement u/s. 108 is not an accused – However, a statement made by a person u/s.108 before the concerned customs officer is admissible in evidence and can be used against such a person – Object underlying s. 108 is to elicit the truth from the person who is being examined regarding the incident of customs infringement, thus customs officer must ensure the truthfulness of the statement so recorded – If the statement recorded is not correct, then, the very utility of recording such a statement would get lost – It is axiomatic that when a statement is admissible as a piece of evidence, the same has to conform to minimum judicial standards – Statement recorded under duress or coercion cannot be used against the person making the statement and the adjudicating authority is to find the same – On facts, statement of director of the supplier firm and proprietor of the importer, recorded u/s. 108 wherein both admitted under valuation – Tribunal noted the factum of retraction of the statement and thus, refused to give credence to such statement – Approach of the tribunal is justified. [Paras 18, 20, 28]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Commissioner of Customs, Calcutta v. South India Television (P) Ltd. (2007) 6 SCC 373 : [2007] 8 SCR 95; Rabindra Chandra Paul v. Commissioner of Customs, (2007) 3 SCC 93 : [2007] 3 SCR 319 – relied on.
Surjit Singh Chhabra v. Union of India, 1997 (89) ELT-646; K.I. Pavunny v. Assistant Collector (1997) 3 SCC 721 : [1997] 1 SCR 797; State of Punjab v. Barkat Ram [1962] 3 SCR 338; Ramesh Chandra Mehta v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1970 SC 940 : [1969] SCR 461; Collector of Customs, Madras v. D. Bhoormall (1974) 2 SCC 544 : [1974] 3 SCR 833; Naresh J. Sukhawani v. Union of India AIR 1996 SC 522 : [1995] 4 Suppl. SCR 778; K.I. Pavunny v. Assistant Collector (1997) 3 SCC 721 : [1997] 1 SCR 797; Union of India v. Padam Narain Aggarwal, AIR 2009 SC 254 : [2008] 14 SCR 179; Eicher Tractors Limited v. Commissioner of Customs (2001) 1 SCC 315 : [2000] 4 Suppl. SCR 597 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 4735-4736 of 2009.
From the Judgment and Order dated 27.06.2008 of the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Bench at Mumbai in Appeal No.C/1347 & 1374 of 2002.
Appearances:
Balbir Singh, ASG, Arijit Prasad, Sr. Adv., Rupesh Kumar, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Ms. Rukmini Bobde, Aniruddh Sharma II, Ishaan Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant.
V. Lakshmikumaran, Ms. Apeksha Mehta, Ms. Neha Choudhary, Ms. Charanya Lakshmikumaran, Ms. Falguni Gupta, Ms. Umang Motiyani, M. P. Devanath, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
UJJAL BHUYAN, J.
1. Since both the appeals arise out of the common judgment and final order dated 27.06.2008 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Bench at Mumbai with parties also being the same, the two appeals were heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment and order.
2. The appeals have been filed by the Commissioner of Customs (Imports), Mumbai under Section 130-E of the Customs Act, 1962 against the common judgment and final order dated 27.06.2008 passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West Zonal Bench at Mumbai (briefly the ‘CESTAT’ or ‘the Tribunal’ hereinafter) in Appeal Nos. C/1347 and 1374 of 2002.
3. The issue that arises in the two appeals is whether the CESTAT was justified in holding that enhancement of value of the imported goods and the penalties imposed by the Commissioner of Customs (Adjudication-1), COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI
OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.176 Mumbai on the respondents could not be sustained and consequently in setting aside the same?
4. A brief recital of facts would be in order.
4.1. Show cause notice dated 17.12.1999 was issued to the respondents by the Additional Director General, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, New Delhi. It was mentioned therein that secret information was received by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence that M/s Ganpati Overseas had imported tuners from Hong Kong at grossly under invoiced prices, thereby evading huge customs duty. The information revealed that the firm M/s Ganpati Overseas was owned by one Mr. Yashpal Sharma; the Hong Kong based supplier M/s Arise Enterprises was owned by his relative Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma; the imported goods were cleared from Air Cargo Complex, Sahar, Mumbai and that M/s National Shipping Agency, Mumbai had acted as the Customs House Agent.
4.2. Upon receipt of such information, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence carried out investigation wherefrom it could be gathered that M/s Ganpati Overseas had imported twenty consignments during the years 1997-98 and 1998-99. It was found that M/s Ganpati Overseas had imported mainly tuners from M/s Arise Enterprises, Hong Kong and had also imported about three-four consignments of saw filters alongwith the tuners. Directorate of Revenue Intelligence obtained information from the Consulate General of India at Hong Kong that M/s Arise Enterprises, Hong Kong belonged to one Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma who alongwith his wife Mrs. Kusum Sharma were the directors. When Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma visited India in March, 1999, his statement was recorded on 08.03.1999 under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 (referred to as the ‘Customs Act’ hereinafter). In his statement, Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma stated that M/s Ganpati Overseas belonged to Mr. Yashpal Sharma who was his co-brother. He stated that M/s Ganpati Overseas was in the business of importing electronic goods since 1997-98. He had supplied tuners and saw filters to M/s Ganpati Overseas through his firm M/s Arise Enterprises from Hong Kong.
4.3. Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma admitted that the rate of tuners per piece as shown in the invoices by M/s Arise Enterprises did not reflect the actual price. He had deliberately mentioned lower price with the intention of saving customs duty in respect of the goods imported by his co-brother, Mr. Yashpal Sharma. The actual price of the tuners was quite high. The differential amount i.e. the difference between the actual price and the declared price was retained in India which he used to collect from Mr. Yashpal Sharma.
4.4. Mr. Yashpal Sharma was also summoned whereafter his statement was recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act on 15.03.1999. Apart from narrating the factum of importing the goods by showing prices much lesser than the actual price meant to evade customs duty, he stated that the amount of payment disclosed in the import documents were sent by him to Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma through the banking channel, whereas, the balance differential amount used to be handed over to Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma on his visits to India.
4.5. It was mentioned that price of tuners so imported as per the sales vouchers was in the range of Rs. 40-60 per piece but the actual market value of these tuners was in the range of Rs. 200-325 per piece. In this manner, the respondents had evaded customs duty amounting to a total of around rupees twenty five to thirty lakhs approximately.
4.6. Mr. Yashpal Sharma was arrested on 15.03.1999 under Section 135 of the Customs Act. He was enlarged on bail on 30.03.1999 by the Additional Sessions Judge, Patiala House, New Delhi subject to the condition that a sum of rupees ten lakhs should be deposited in the office of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence on 30.03.1999 and a further sum of rupees twenty lakhs should be so deposited within a period of forty-five days. Both the amounts were accordingly deposited.
4.7. From a scrutiny of the relevant materials including export declarations, it was found that the price of tuner as per the export declarations filed by the exporter before the Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department was Hong Kong $67.67 per piece which was much higher as compared to the price declared in the invoice by M/s Ganpati Overseas before the Indian customs authority at the time of importation of the goods. In this connection, the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence prepared two charts; as per chart-I, M/s Ganpati Overseas had evaded customs duty to the extent of Rs. 1,07,41,419.00 on import of nineteen consignments. Likewise, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence prepared chart-II which dealt with importation of 3200 pieces of tuners which were made in Taiwan. It was noted that the COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.178 value of the goods declared before the customs authority was Hong Kong $19200 whereas the actual value was Hong Kong $211468.07 as per export declaration before the Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department. Thus, according to the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, M/s Ganpati Overseas had evaded customs duty to the tune of Rs. 8,67,762.00. The price of goods as shown in the import documents by M/s Ganpati Overseas was found to be much less than the real price of the goods, i.e., at the price at which those were supplied from Hong Kong. Therefore, the import valuation was rejected in terms of Section 14 of the Customs Act and the Customs Valuation (Determination of Price of Imported Goods) Rules, 1988 (briefly, the ‘Customs Valuation Rules’ hereinafter).
4.8. The show cause notice proposed that the value of imported goods should be determined under Rule 8 of the Customs Valuation Rules on the basis of the value given in the export declarations obtained from the Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department. Alleging that respondents had wilfully misdeclared and suppressed the correct value of the imported goods with an intent to evade duties of customs, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence invoked the extended period of limitation as per the proviso to Section 28(1) of the Customs Act. It was mentioned that M/s Ganpati Overseas was liable to pay the differential customs duty of Rs. 1,07,41,419.00 leviable on the import of tuners, saw filters etc. as per chart-I and Rs. 8,67,762.00 as per chart-II, the total amount being Rs. 1,16,09,181.00. Respondents were therefore called upon to show cause as to why the aforesaid amount of customs duty should not be demanded and recovered from them and also as to why the imported goods should not be confiscated under Sections 111(d) and 111(m) of the Customs Act, besides appropriation of the amount of Rs. 30 lakhs already deposited. Respondents were further called upon to show cause as to why penalty under Section 112(a) of the Customs Act should not be imposed upon them and as to why interest should not be levied on the evaded customs duty.
4.9. The noticees were directed to submit their reply to the Commissioner of Customs, Air Cargo Complex, Sahar Airport, Mumbai within the stipulated time. It was mentioned that the show cause notice was issued under Section 124 of the Customs Act read with the proviso to Section 28(1) of the aforesaid Act.
5. M/s Ganpati Overseas through its lawyer replied to the aforesaid show cause notice on 20.05.2000. While denying all the allegations in totality, it was mentioned that the Commissioner of Customs vide his letter dated 07.04.2000 had rejected the request of M/s Ganpati Overseas for supply of certain documents sought for, on the ground that those documents were not relied upon. It was submitted that those documents might have relevance while preparing the defence and that absence of those documents would handicap the noticees in putting forth a proper defence. While reiterating the request for such documents, the noticees submitted what they called an interim reply.
5.1. It was mentioned that Mr. Yashpal Sharma was the proprietor of the noticee firm which was engaged in the business of import of tuners etc. during the years 1997-98 and 1998-99. The imports were made from M/s. Arise Enterprises, Hong Kong. At the time of clearance, the bills of entry were filed through the Customs House Agent and the imported goods were cleared after proper assessment by the customs authority on payment of due customs duty. Those goods were subsequently sold in the local market. In all, twenty consignments were imported. The noticees thereafter described and furnished the details of two types of tuners which were imported over a period of about nine months consisting of twenty consignments.
5.2. The noticees adverted to the allegations made in the show cause notice that the price declared by the noticees was not correct and was on the lower side, as proved by the statements of Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma and Mr. Yashpal Sharma recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act as well as by the export declarations filed by M/s Arise Enterprises before the Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department. It was pointed out that the two statements of Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma and Mr. Yashpal Sharma could not be termed as voluntary under any circumstances. Those inculpatory statements were obtained through coercion and under duress. It was pointed out that the statement of Mr. Yashpal Sharma was structured in such a manner as to tally entirely with the statement of Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma. That apart, statement of Mr. Yashpal Sharma was contradictory to his own statement made before the Additional Sessions Judge where he had stated that there was no under valuation or under invoicing of the goods imported. Therefore, it was contended that both the statements were not at COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.180 all reliable. Further, Mr. Yashpal Sharma vide letter dated 25.08.1999 had retracted the statement made by him under Section 108 of the Customs Act.
5.3. Regarding the export declarations filed by M/s Arise Enterprises before the Hong Kong customs authority, it was submitted that it was not known as to when these declarations were forwarded by the Consulate General of India, Hong Kong to the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, New Delhi. The copies relied upon by the department were unattested and photocopies, thus unreliable. That apart, when the noticees contacted M/s Arise Enterprises, Hong Kong, it was acknowledged that due to error on the part of the staff, value of the goods was incorrectly shown in the export declarations. The mistake was subsequently rectified whereafter M/s Arise Enterprises lodged a second set of declarations before the Hong Kong customs authority and paid the penalty which was levied.
5.4. It was stated that the noticees were informed by the Hong Kong supplier that the tuners, saw filters etc. were being offered to them on stock clearance basis at lower prices. It was for this reason that the goods were sold to the noticees at lower prices, details of which were mentioned in paragraph 11 of the reply.
5.5. After saying so, it was pointed out that different prices in export declarations and in import invoices did not necessarily mean that the price shown in the export declarations was correct and that the one declared in the import invoices was incorrect.
5.6. The reply also touched upon the method of valuation as well as the valuation of the goods by the customs authority in India. After adverting to various provisions of the Customs Valuation Rules, it was asserted that the price at which the goods of the respondents were assessed and cleared was more or less correct. It was pointed out that the department could not adduce any single piece of evidence to arrive at the so called correct value of the goods. No value of identical or similar goods could be produced. No evidence of market value was adduced. No attempt to find out the price per unit was made for a comparison. That apart, no incriminating document or material was produced to establish under valuation. There was no evidence as to how remittances over and above the invoice price were made. One and only ‘evidence’ relied upon by the department was the initial value shown in the export declarations which was declared to be incorrect by the supplier itself and later on rectified. Thus, there was no mis-declaration either in respect of description of the goods or value of the goods. No question of confiscation under Sections 111(d) and 111(m) of the Customs Act was made out. That apart, the goods were not prohibited ones, the import of which would warrant confiscation. In any view of the matter, the goods on being cleared by the customs authority were sold by the noticees much before the issuance of the show cause notice. Therefore, there cannot be any confiscation of such goods. In so far deposit of Rs. 30 lakhs by Mr. Yashpal Sharma is concerned, the same was to fulfil the bail condition imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge. Since there was no short payment of customs duty, question of appropriation of the aforesaid amount did not arise; neither any penalty was imposable nor interest leviable. M/s Ganpati Overseas, therefore, requested the Commissioner to drop the proceedings.
6. Reply of the respondents was found to be not acceptable. Therefore, the case was taken up for adjudication. Accordingly, the case was transferred to Commissioner of Customs (Adjudication-1), New Customs House, Mumbai for the purpose of adjudication. During the adjudication process, personal hearing was afforded to the respondents.
6.1. Adjudicating authority noted that the customs department had alleged under valuation of the goods in question resulting in evasion of customs duty to the tune of Rs. 1,16,09,181.00. To prove under valuation, the department had relied upon the price mentioned in the export declarations filed by the supplier before the Hong Kong customs authority in respect of nineteen consignments. The price so declared was considered as the correct transaction value. In respect of one more consignment where export declaration was not available, department had proposed enhancement of the price of the goods on the basis of the other export declarations. Adjudicating authority did not accept the contention of the respondents that the price mentioned in the export declarations filed before the Hong Kong customs authority could not be accepted. Distinguishing the facts of the two cases relied upon by the respondents, the adjudicating authority took the view that even if the copies of the export declarations available with the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence were not attested or were xerox copies, it would not make those copies unreliable or unauthentic. Therefore, taking into account the fact that the supplier M/s Arise Enterprises had acknowledged COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.182 that those declarations were filed by them, which was not denied by the respondents, the adjudicating authority held that there was no reason to doubt the veracity of the export declarations even if those were unattested and were mainly xerox copies. Accordingly, the adjudicating authority held that the information obtained was correct and genuine.
6.2. On the contention that statements of Mr. Yashpal Sharma and Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma were not voluntary and therefore could not be relied upon, adjudicating authority held that both of them in their statements recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act had admitted to having under-invoiced the price of the goods and had voluntarily paid Rs. 30 lakhs towards payment of evaded customs duty during the investigation. They had also explained in their statements the modus operandi adopted by them and the manner of transfer of the differential amount. Therefore, the adjudicating authority opined that he had no reason to accept the plea of the respondents that the statements of Mr. Yashpal Sharma and Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma were not voluntary and should not be relied upon. This plea was taken only as an afterthought.
6.3. Contention of the respondents that the declared price was correct when compared with contemporaneous imports was also not accepted by the adjudicating authority as the invoices of the contemporaneous imports did not reveal the specification, quality etc., of the products.
6.4. Adjudicating authority also rejected the contention of the respondents that the supplier M/s Arise Enterprises had purchased the goods in question on stock clearance basis at a lower price and for this reason it could sell the goods to M/s Ganpati Overseas at a lower price. According to the adjudicating authority, this was again an afterthought and an invented argument as the noticees had not declared that the goods were purchased in stock lot. Neither invoices nor export declarations as well as the bills of entry or any other document on record suggested that the subject goods were purchased in stock lot at a price lower than the normal one. Rather, such a plea would support the allegation of the department that the invoice price was not a normal price and coupled with the fact that the parties were relatives, had rendered the invoice price unacceptable for assessment in terms of Section 14(1) of the Customs Act read with Rule 2(2) of the Customs Valuation Rules. Since neither the transaction value of similar goods nor contemporary prices etc. were available, resort to Rules 5, 6 and 7 for determining the assessable value of the goods was not possible. Therefore, Rule 8 of the Customs Valuation Rules was correctly applied.
6.5. Holding that the export declarations reflected the true transaction value which was misdeclared by the importer to evade customs duty, the adjudicating authority vide the order-in-original dated 17.06.2002 held that the proviso to Section 28(1) of the Customs Act was applicable. Consequently, M/s Ganpati Overseas was held liable to pay the differential customs duty of Rs. 1,16,09,181.00 alongwith interest forthwith. For misdeclaration and under valuation, the goods in question were held liable for confiscation under Sections 111(d) and 111(m) of the Customs Act. However, as the said goods were not available having been cleared no order for confiscation was passed. Further, equivalent amount of differential customs duty was imposed on M/s Ganpati Overseas as a penalty under Section 114A of the Customs Act and in addition, penalty of rupees five lakhs was imposed on Mr. Yashpal Sharma under Section 112(a) of the Customs Act.
7. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order-in-original of the adjudicating authority, respondents preferred appeals before the CESTAT which were registered as Appeal Nos. C/1347 and 1374 of 2002.
7.1. CESTAT opined that export declarations filed by the foreign supplier before the Hong Kong customs authority could not be relied upon for the purpose of enhancement of value. This was for more than one reason. Firstly, those declarations were unattested photocopies. Secondly, the supplier had filed another set of declarations indicating the price as shown in the invoices of the imports. Thirdly, for filing incorrect declarations which had to be subsequently replaced by another set of declarations, the foreign supplier had paid penalty before the Hong Kong customs authority. Fourthly, no investigation was carried out by the customs authority with the Hong Kong customs authority revealing anything to the contrary. On that basis, CESTAT held that the price shown in the initial export declarations could not form the basis for enhancing the value of the goods.
7.2. CESTAT noted that nothing incriminating was recovered from the importers in the form of text messages etc. CESTAT also recorded that there was no evidence of contemporary imports which had higher value. COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.184 The foreign supplier had given explanation in respect of the price initially declared in the export declarations, which explanation was not discarded.
7.3. According to CESTAT, value in the export declaration may be relied upon for ascertainment of assessable value under the Customs Valuation Rules and not for determining the price at which the goods are ordinarily sold at the time and place of importation. CESTAT referred to and relied upon the decision of this Court in Commissioner of Customs, Calcutta Vs. South India Television (P) Ltd., (2007) 6 SCC 373 wherein this court held that the burden lies upon the department to prove under valuation by evidence or information about comparable imports and if the charge of under valuation is not supported by such evidence or information, the benefit of doubt has to be given to the importer. On the basis of the aforesaid decision, CESTAT recorded that there was not only no contrary evidence of contemporaneous import but even the foreign supplier had satisfactorily explained that the price initially shown in the export declarations was incorrect which was subsequently amended and accepted by the Hong Kong customs authority.
7.4. As regards the statements of Mr. Yashpal Sharma and Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma, the Tribunal observed that these statements were retracted at the earliest available opportunity. Decisions relied upon by the appellant, viz., Surjit Singh Chhabra Vs. Union of India, 1997 (89) ELT-646 and in K.I. Pavunny Vs. Assistant Collector, (1997) 3 SCC 721 did not advance the case of the department. Tribunal observed that in the said decisions, this court has held that the inculpatory portion of confessional statement of accused, even if retracted, could be relied upon to base conviction if it is found to be voluntary and truthful; however, this Court sounded a note of caution that prudence and practice would require that such confessional statement should be corroborated by other evidence adduced by the prosecution. Statement of Mr. Yashpal Sharma that the actual market value of the tuners was in the range of Rs.200.00 and Rs.325.00 per piece which would make the market price thereof in excess of Rs.700.00 after adding normal profit could not be taken to be voluntary and true for the reason that tuners were supplied to the respondents at negotiated price of four different rates i.e. HK$ 4.00, 4.50, 5.50 and 6.00. In that view of the matter, Tribunal was of the view that the loaded value proposed by the department would not be correct since the proposed Free on Board (FoB) price would be about Rs.372.00 per piece and CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) value would be Rs. 454.00 per piece and the landing cost would be Rs.660.00 per piece after adding customs duty.
7.5. CESTAT also noted that the importers i.e. respondents had produced invoices of contemporaneous imports by M/s Bharat Electronics and M/s K.S. International to show price comparable with the price declared by them in respect of the goods in question.
7.6. In the above backdrop, CESTAT vide the judgment and order dated 27.06.2008 held that enhancement of the value of the imported goods as well as the penalties imposed could not be sustained. Accordingly, those were set aside and appeals filed by the respondents were allowed.
8. It is this order of CESTAT which has been impugned in the two appeals before us.
9. This court vide the order dated 24.07.2009 had issued notice. Thereafter, the appeals were admitted on 10.12.2010.
10. Respondents have filed counter affidavit through Mr. Yashpal Sharma. After narrating the facts, respondents have supported the judgment and order passed by the CESTAT while controverting all the contentions raised by the appellant. Respondents have, therefore, sought for dismissal of the appeals.
11. Mr. Rupesh Kumar, learned counsel for the appellant has assailed the judgment and order of CESTAT. He has asserted that the appellant was justified in determining the value of the imported goods under Rule 8 of the Customs Valuation Rules on the basis of the declared value of the goods mentioned in the export declarations filed by the supplier which were obtained from the Hong Kong customs authority. The invoices presented by the respondents before the customs authority did not represent genuine and actual transaction.
11.1. The price declared in the invoice was much lower than the value declared in the export declarations filed in Hong Kong. Since it did not reflect the correct transaction value, the value appearing in the import invoices did not fulfil the criteria of Section 14(1) of the Customs Act and Rule 4 of the Customs Valuation Rules as per which the transaction value of the imported goods is the price actually paid or payable when sold for export to India. COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.186
11.2. He submits that the export declarations filed by the foreign supplier before the Hong Kong customs authority was not the sole basis for increasing the value of the subject goods. There were sufficient materials on record to prove under valuation. Both Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma, director of the supplier firm and Mr. Yashpal Sharma, proprietor of the importer, in their statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act had admitted under valuation. In his statement, Mr. Yashpal Sharma had stated that the supplier M/s Arise Enterprises, Hong Kong belonged to his co-brother Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma. Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma used to send the goods on his own and that he had never sent any written or oral order for supply. As and when M/s Arise Enterprises would dispatch the goods, Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma would inform Mr. Yashpal Sharma over telephone to whom the goods were to be sold, in what quantity and at what price. Thereafter, he used to sell the goods at the settled price and receive the payments. He had stated that he was not aware of the actual price of the goods imported from Hong Kong. The amount of payment as per the import documents were sent by him to Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma through banking channel and the balance amount he used to handover to Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma whenever he visited India.
11.3. Learned counsel has highlighted the fact that the supplier in Hong Kong and the importer in India were related parties. Therefore, the contention that the foreign supplier had filed another set of export declarations wherein the price shown in the invoices matched with that shown in the import documents in India was an afterthought to frustrate the proceedings initiated by the customs authority.
11.4. He further submits that where the importer like the respondents had not laid any basis for acceptance of the invoice price as transaction value, then the authorities would be legally justified to initiate fixation of price under Rule 5 onwards under the Customs Valuation Rules. According to him, the department had to take recourse to Rule 8 of the aforesaid Rules straightaway instead of proceeding through Rules 5, 6 and 7 as neither transaction value of similar goods nor contemporary prices were available. Therefore, the adjudicating authority had rightly invoked Rule 8 while assessing the transaction value to determine the short levy of customs duty and for imposing penalty. CESTAT was not at all justified in interfering with such a reasoned order of the adjudicating authority. In these circumstances, he seeks setting aside of the order of the CESTAT dated 27.06.2008.
12. Per contra, Mr. V. Lakshmikumaran, learned counsel for the respondents has supported the order of CESTAT and submits that the appeals of the department wholly lacks merit and therefore should be dismissed.
12.1. He submits that the Tribunal was fully justified in holding that the price declared in the import invoice was correct. The foreign supplier had withdrawn the original export declarations earlier submitted before the Hong Kong customs authority and thereafter had filed another set of declarations where the declared price matched the price shown by the respondents in the import invoices. The subsequent declarations were accepted by the Hong Kong customs authority following which penalty was levied which was paid by the supplier.
12.2. Mr. Lakshmikumaran, learned counsel submits that the export declarations relied upon by the appellant were only photocopies which were neither signed nor attested. As such, those export declarations did not have any evidentiary value. He has asserted that the price reflected in the import invoices was the sole consideration for sale which satisfied the definition of transaction value as per Rule 4 of the Customs Valuation Rules.
12.3. According to Mr. V. Lakshmikumaran, there were no evidence before the customs authority to prove under valuation. Statements of Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma and Mr. Yashpal Sharma could not be relied upon to prove under valuation for more than one reason. Firstly, when the two statements were recorded there was no evidence available with the customs department to prove under valuation. Secondly, both the statements were almost identical and matched each other which would indicate that those were dictated ones. Therefore, it is clearly evident that those were obtained under coercion and undue pressure. Thirdly, the two statements were retracted at the first available opportunity. Fourthly, the Additional Sessions Judge, New Delhi while granting bail to Mr. Yashpal Sharma had recorded in his order dated 26.05.1999 that the statement made was under coercion and pressure and therefore, the same could not be termed as a voluntary statement. In the circumstances, Tribunal was fully justified in not giving any credence to the above two statements.
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.188
12.4. He further submits that though the appellant had placed much emphasis on the fact that the parties are related and that filing of the second set of export declarations was an afterthought, the same is totally irrelevant. On the contrary, it is on record that the second set of export declarations were accepted by the Hong Kong customs authority by imposing penalty which was paid by the Hong Kong supplier.
12.5. Asserting that there was no under valuation of the imported goods, learned counsel submits that valuation of imported goods is governed by the Customs Valuation Rules and not by price declaration made by the supplier in another country. Appellant was not justified in by-passing Rules 5, 6 and 7 of the Customs Valuation Rules while determining the transaction value and straightaway invoking Rule 8. Customs department had not made any effort to gather evidence to determine transaction value of identical or similar goods imported contemporaneously. In this connection, learned counsel has relied upon the decision of this court in Rabindra Chandra Paul Vs. Commissioner of Customs, (2007) 3 SCC 93 and in the case of South India Television (P) Ltd. (supra). He, therefore, submits that there was no error or infirmity in the view taken by CESTAT. Consequently, the appeals are liable to the dismissed.
13. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the court.
14. Before we deal with the rival contentions, it would be relevant to have a brief recap of the factual narrative. Based on an intelligence input received by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence that M/s Ganpati Overseas had imported tuners etc. from Hong Kong at grossly under invoiced prices thereby evading huge customs duty, a show cause notice dated 17.12.1999 was issued to the respondents. As per the show cause notice, M/s Ganpati Overseas had imported twenty consignments of tuners and saw filters from M/s Arise Enterprises, Hong Kong during the years 1997-1998 and 1998-1999. Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma and his wife Mrs. Kusum Sharma were the directors of M/s Arise Enterprises, whereas, Mr. Yashpal Sharma was the proprietor of M/s Ganpati Overseas. Mr. Yashpal Sharma and Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma were co-brothers.
14.1. Statements of Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma and Mr. Yashpal Sharma were recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act. In their respective statements which virtually complimented each other, they admitted that the price of goods as per the export declarations filed by the foreign supplier before the Hong Kong customs authority reflected the actual price. On import, the price was kept intentionally low to avoid paying due customs duty. Actual price of the goods was quite high. The difference between the actual price and the declared price was retained in India, which Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma used to collect from Mr. Yashpal Sharma whenever he visited India. However, the two statements were subsequently retracted on the ground that those were obtained under coercion and duress.
14.2. Mr. Yashpal Sharma was arrested on 15.03.1999 under Section 135 of the Customs Act. He was enlarged on bail on 30.03.1999 by the Additional Sessions Judge, Patiala House, New Delhi conditional upon depositing Rs.30 lakhs, which he deposited. In his bail order, the Additional Sessions Judge recorded that the statement made by Mr. Yashpal Sharma under Section 108 of the Customs Act was forcibly taken, and, therefore, could not be relied upon.
14.3. It has come on record that the foreign supplier had admitted before the Hong Kong customs authority that price of the goods declared in the initial export declarations was not correct because of mistake committed by the staff. It thereafter submitted a second set of export declarations where the price of the goods declared matched the price of the goods at the time of import in India. This was accepted by the Hong Kong customs authority but on payment of penalty which was paid by the supplier.
14.4. Be that as it may, the show cause notice proposed levy of higher customs duty with interest; confiscation of the imported goods; and imposition of penalty.
14.5. Respondents submitted their reply denying all the allegations. The show cause notice was adjudicated upon by the Commissioner of Customs (Adjudication-1), Mumbai. In his order-in-original dated 17.06.2002 the adjudicating authority accepted the price mentioned in the initial export declarations filed by the supplier before the Hong Kong customs authority in respect of nineteen consignments. In respect of one consignment where export declaration was not available, adjudicating authority accepted the price mentioned in respect of the nineteen consignments. Adjudicating authority brushed aside the objection raised by the respondents that copies of COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORTS), MUMBAI v. M/S GANPATI OVERSEAS THR. ITS PROP. SHRI YASHPAL SHARMA [UJJAL BHUYAN, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.190 the export declarations available with the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence were not attested and were simply xerox copies. Adjudicating authority took the view that merely because the copies of the export declarations were not attested or were xerox copies, those would not become unreliable or unauthentic. According to the adjudicating authority, the supplier had acknowledged those export declarations. Therefore, he held that information obtained by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence based on the export declarations was correct and genuine.
14.6. He also rejected the objection of the respondents that statements of Mr. Yashpal Sharma and Mr. Suresh Chandra Sharma were not voluntary and therefore could not be relied upon. According to the adjudicating authority, both the two persons had admitted to under invoicing of the price and this was buttressed by the fact that Mr. Yashpal Sharma had voluntarily paid Rs.30 lakhs towards the evaded customs duty during the investigation stage. Such objection was therefore held to be only an afterthought.
14.7. Further contention of the respondents that the declared price is correct when compared with the contemporaneous imports was not accepted by the adjudicating authority on the ground that invoices of contemporaneous imports did not reveal the specification, quality, etc. of the products.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.