Joseph v. The State of Kerala & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 843; [2023] 12 S.C.R. 505
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice To Prematurely Release Him, Justice Having Been in Custody-Actual Imprisonment for Over 26 Years, Justice And Served A Sentence of Over 35 Years of Remission Earned, Justice For Off Ence Punishable U/Ss. 302 and 392 Ipc
- Decided
- 21 Sept 2023
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) No. 520/2022
- Sections
- 302, 376, 102(2), 433, 7717, 99, 77, 432, 72
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 12 S.C.R. 505 : 2023 INSC 843
CASE DETAILS
JOSEPH
v.
THE STATE OF KERALA & ORS.
(Writ Petition (Criminal) No(s). 520 of 2022)
SEPTEMBER 21, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the writ petition filed by the petitioner seeking appropriate direction to the State Government, to prematurely release him, having been in custody-actual imprisonment for over 26 years, and served a sentence of over 35 years including over 8 years of remission earned, for offence punishable u/ss. 302 and 392 IPC, should be allowed.
Premature release – Convict served over 26 years in actual imprisonment and served 35 years of sentence including 8 years of remission earned for offences punishable u/ss. 302 and 392 – Case rejected for premature release thrice by the State Government – Writ petition seeking direction to the State Government to prematurely release him:
Held: Inflexible guidelines can result in the real danger of overlooking the reformative potential of each individual convict – Grouping types of convicts, based on the offences they were found to have committed, as a starting point, may be justified, however, prison laws in India read with Arts. 72 and 161 encapsulate a strong underlying reformative purpose – Insistence of guidelines, and denial to consider the real impact of prison good behavior, and other relevant factors results in violation of Art. 14 – Excluding the relief of premature release to prisoners who have served extremely long periods of incarceration, not only crushes their spirit, and instils despair, but signifies society’s resolve to be harsh and unforgiving – Idea of rewarding, a prisoner for good conduct is entirely negated – r. 376 of the 2014 Rules 506 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
prescribes that prisoners shall be granted remission for keeping peace and good behaviour in jail – Redirecting the petitioner who has already undergone over 26 years of incarceration and over 35 years of punishment with remission, to undergo, again, consideration before the Advisory Board, and thereafter, State Government for premature release, would be cruel – Petitioner has earned over 8 years of remission, thus demonstrates good conduct in jail – Discussions of the Jail Advisory Board are also positive and shows that he is a reformed inmate – Thus, in the interest of justice, issuance of direction to release the petitioner – Kerala Prison Rules, 1958 – Kerala Prisons and Correctional Services (Management) Rules, 2014 – rr 462 to 468. [Paras 33-35] Remission – Grant of remission – Scope of:
Held: Blanket exclusion of certain offences, from the scope of grant of remission, by way of an executive policy, is arbitrary and against the ideals of reformation that run through the criminal justice system – Penological goal is of reformation and rehabilitation rather than retribution – Impact of applying such an executive instruction/guideline would be that any progress made by a long-term convict would leave them feeling hopeless, and condemned to an indefinite period of incarceration. [Para 28] Remission – Remission policy – Application of:
Held: Remission policy prevailing on the date of conviction, is to be applied in a given case, and if a more liberal policy exists on the day of consideration, then the latter would apply. [Para 19] Administrative law – Discretion conferred widely by plenary statute or statutory rules:
Held: Cannot be lightly fettered. [Para 29]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
State of Haryana v. Jagdish [2010] 3 SCR 716; Maru Ram, v. Union of India [1981] 1 SCR 1196; General Officer Commanding-in-Chief v. Subhash Chandra Yadav [1988] 3 SCR 62; State of Haryana v. Mahender Singh [2007] 11 SCR 932; State v. H. Nilofer Nisha (2020) 14 SCC 161:[2020] 1 SCR 456; Ramdas Athawale v. Union of India [2010] 3 SCR 1059; Union of India v. V. Sriharan [2015] 14 SCR 613; Swamy Shraddananda (2) @ Mural Manohar Mishra v. State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Ratan Singh [1976] Supp. 1 SCR 552; Rajan v. The Home Secretary, Home Department of Tamil Nadu [2019] 6 SCR 1035; State of Haryana v. Raj Kumar (2021) 9 SCC 292; Rajo v. State of Bihar Judgment dated 25.08.2023 in Writ Petition (Crl.) No. 252/2023; State of Haryana v. Mohinder Singh [2000] 1 SCR 698; Sangeet v. State of Haryana [2012] 13 SCR 85; Ram Chander v. State of Chhattisgarh [2022] 4 SCR 1103; U.P. State Road Transport Corporation & Anr v. Mohd. Ismail & Ors. [1991] 2 SCR 274; Chairman, All India Railway Rec. Board & Ors. v. K. Shyam Kumar & Ors. [2010] 6 SCR 291 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Writ Petition (Criminal)
No.520 of 2022 (Under Article 32 of The Constitution of India)
Appearances:
Adolf Mathew, Sanjay Jain, Advs. for the Petitioner.
Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv., Harshad V Hameed, Dileep Poolakkot, Subhash Chandran K.R., Mrs. Ashly Harshad, Advs. for the Respondents. JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.
1. The petitioner, currently serving a life imprisonment sentence for a crime committed in 1996, punishable under Sections 302 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code (hereafter “IPC”) approaches this court seeking to enforce his right under Article 32 of the Constitution of India. He seeks appropriate direction to the state government, to prematurely release him, having been in custody (i.e., actual imprisonment) for over 26 years, and served a sentence of over 35 years (including over 8 years of remission earned). JOSEPH v. THE STATE OF KERALA 508 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
Facts and background
2. It was alleged that on 16.09.1994, the petitioner had gone to his sister-in-law’s (the deceased victim) place of work, and on the false pretext that her mother was seriously ill and had been admitted to the hospital, taken her away with the permission of the in-charge of the convent where she worked. The prosecution case was that he had her walk along the railway line and at a desolate place, allegedly raped and robbed her of the ornaments she was wearing, before laying her on the tracks to be runover by a passing train.
3. The petitioner was arrested on 09.10.1994 in connection with the case and remained in custody till the trial court1 acquitted him of all charges on 23.03.1996. The High Court2 reversed the acquittal, and convicted the petitioner by its judgment dated 06.01.1998 for the offences punishable under Section 302, 376 and 392 IPC. The High Court sentenced him to life imprisonment for the offence under Section 302, and rigorous imprisonment of 7 years on each count of Section 376 and 392 IPC, which were to run concurrently. This court3, however, on 27.04.2000 set aside the conviction under Section 376 IPC and confirmed the conviction and sentence under Sections 302 and 392 IPC only.
4. Pursuant to an order of this court, the respondent-state filed an affidavit indicating the computation of his period of sentence undergone, the status of his plea for remission to be granted, as well as filed the state’s various remission policies (as amended from time to time). The petitioner completed 1 year 5 months and 10 days of custody as an undertrial, before his acquittal by the trial court. After his conviction by the High Court, he surrendered to the sentence on 28.01.1998, and remained in custody thereafter. On 13.08.2010, he completed 14 years of actual imprisonment (including the time spent as an undertrial). And on 13.08.2016, he completed 20 years of actual imprisonment. The custody certificate produced in his writ petition, confirms that he completed actual imprisonment of 25 years 9 months and 26 days on 07.06.2022, (i.e., he completed 25 years actual 1 By judgment dated 23.03.1996 passed by the Sessions Court, Thrissur in S.C. No. 73/1995.
2 By judgment dated 06.01.1998 passed by the Kerala High Court in Crl. A. No. 511/1996.
3 By judgment dated 27.04.2000 passed by this Court in Crl. A. No. 656/1998. imprisonment on 13.08.2021). However, in terms of the state’s counter affidavit, as on 31.01.2023, he completed 25 years 10 months 3 days of actual imprisonment and has earned 8 years 4 months and 16 days in remission. Regardless of the arithmetical inconsistencies, it is not contested that he has completed over 26 years of actual imprisonment.
5. In the course of hearing, it was pointed out that the petitioner’s case had been considered by the Advisory Committee/Jail Advisory Board under prevailing Rules4 on nine occasions of which three times, the Board had recommended his premature release. However, the state government had rejected his request on all three occasions. Pursuant to a direction by this court, the State has placed on record each of the Minutes of the Meeting/ Reports of the Advisory Boards, containing recommendations (positive and negative) relating to the petitioner, and the rejection orders passed by the State on the three occasions wherein the Board recommended release. These are summarized below:
ADVISORY COMMITTEE/JAIL ADVISORY BOARD Date & Statutory provisions/Rules applied Consideration of petitioner’s case and reasoning 10.08.2011 [1958 Rules] Petitioner’s case unanimously rejected as it was a case of premediated murder.
27.08.2013 [1958 Rules] Based on the police report and manner of commission of offence, the three official members opposed recommendation, while the three non-official members recommended release.
Committee rejected proposal.
30.06.2014 [Both 1958 and 2014 Rules] Listed under separate heading ‘cases of prisoners who have been convicted for offences against women but are not premediated and thus coming under purview of government directions’. The District Probation officer recommended release, while the police opposed. Recorded that he is hard working, disciplined, and reformed and hence, Petitioner’s case was deferred to the next meeting given that he had completed over 17 years of imprisonment.
4 Kerala Prison Rules, 1958 (hereafter ‘1958 Rules’) and Kerala Prisons and Correctional Services (Management) Rules, 2014 (hereafter ‘2014 Rules’).
JOSEPH v. THE STATE OF KERALA [S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.] 510 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
29.09.2015 [2014 Rules] Same observations/conclusions as last date of consideration; petitioner’s case was unanimously directed to be considered afresh after receiving detailed reports from the probation officer and police and the case was deferred for consideration till November 2015.
08.01.2016 [2014 Rules] Petitioner’s case rejected on the ground that the police report did not recommend release.
10.01.2017 [2014 Rules] Police report did not recommend release, while the reports of the probation officer and jail superintendent respectively, supported release. After a detailed discussion of the police report, charges levelled, and his life inside and outside prison – probation officer and non-official members supported release. Thereafter, the Board unanimously recommended the petitioner’s case for premature release.
13.08.2019 [2014 Rules] District Probation officer recommended premature release, while the police report again recommended against release.
Considering his life on parole, character in prison, and period undergone, case was deferred for consideration in next meeting.
26.02.2020 [2014 Rules] Considering the long term imprisonment undergone, age of convict, character in prison, family background and situation, Petitioner’s case unanimously recommended for release.
07.03.2022 [2014 Rules] Petitioner’s case was discussed in detail. District Judge on the Board, pointed out that the Supreme Court had directed that persons who had committed murder of women and children and those convicted under NDPS need not be considered for release. The Chairman also opined that those convicted for murder of women and children, and murder with rape, ought not to be recommended. However, a non-official member pointed out that he had undergone over 24 years of actual imprisonment, had been considered by the Board 5 times and 2 times been recommended for release, and may be given special consideration for release on humanitarian grounds.
Given his age and long incarceration, the Petitioner’s case was thereafter recommended unanimously for premature release.
STATE GOVERNMENT DECISION
Date of decision Government’s decision relating to the petitioner 06.07.2019 Pursuant to Advisory Board’s recommendation dated 10.01.2017, Petitioner’s case (along with the other three convicts) was rejected without assigning any reasons.
22.04.2021 Pursuant to Advisory Board’s recommendation dated 26.02.2020, file relating to all 20 persons recommended for release, returned for further action.
01.09.2022 Pursuant to Advisory Board’s recommendation dated 07.03.2022, petitioner’s case (along with 7 others) was rejected without assigning any reasons.
6. The State in its counter affidavit explained its position - that while the petitioner has been considered for premature release 9 times, his case has been rejected repeatedly because:
“while considering proposal for premature release of prisoners, the consistent stand now being adopted by the Government is that persons involved in the murder of women and children and persons convicted in offences relating to POCSO cases shall not be granted premature release. Since the petitioner involved in the murder of a woman his premature release was rejected by Government in accordance with the above stand.”
(emphasis supplied)
Further, that in 2020, general guidelines were to be framed by a specially constituted committee5 for determining the eligibility of prisoners with regards to grant of premature release. This committee finally proposed premature release of 67 convicts (from those who had earlier been rejected for whatever reason) after assessing their individual cases. The state government by its proceeding dated 20.04.2022, approved the proposal excluding certain convicts who had been involved in: most cruel murder, committed murder of woman and children, or murder with rape, and those undergoing treatment for mental illness, whose relatives were reluctant to receive them. These restrictions, along with other more detailed guidelines, 5 This committee consisted of Additional Chief Secretary Home & Vigilance Department as Chairman, Law Secretary, and Director General of Prions and Correctional Services as Members.
JOSEPH v. THE STATE OF KERALA [S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.] 512 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
have been incorporated in a government order6 dated 04.06.2022 issued by the Home Department of the State of Kerala.
7. On 01.09.2022, the state government rejected for the third time, the Advisory Board’s recommendation to release the petitioner. Aggrieved, the petitioner has preferred the present writ petition.
Contentions of parties
8. Mr. Adolf Mathew, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, challenged the state government’s repeated rejection of his plea for premature release. It was pointed out that the remission policy prevailing on the date of the conviction would have to apply. Attention was drawn to Rule 545A of the 1958 Rules which stipulates release can be considered after 14 years; Rule 216(1), 244(2) and 299(c) of the 1958 Rules which state that the inmate shall be released after completion of 20 years of sentence; and the recommendations of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) which prescribes mandatory release after 25 years of sentence. Furthermore, even in terms of Rule 377 of the new Prison Rules, 2014, the petitioner is entitled to release after 20 years. It was argued that since the petitioner has not only completed 14 years or 20 years, but even 25 years of actual imprisonment, at this juncture - regardless of which rules are applied, it was manifestly illegal to keep him incarcerated in perpetuity.
9. Mr. Mathew strongly opposed the state’s policy dated 14.06.2022 (and executive instruction dated 20.04.2022 cited in the state’s counter affidavit) which listed certain crimes, the commission of which put the convict beyond the scope for grant of remission. The executive instruction (which explicitly prohibits the release of a prisoner involved in the “murder of a woman”), it was argued – not only came after his completion of 25 years of incarceration, but in any case could not override the statutory provisions. Counsel submitted that the petitioner had a legal right to be considered for remission given the safeguards of a convict under Articles 20 and 21 of the Constitution of India; this legal right was guaranteed by the Prison Act, and the Rules framed under it.
6 G.O.(Ms.) NO. 116/2022/HOME dated 14.06.2022.
10. Relying on replies received (under the Right to Information Act, 2005) from the respective jails in which the petitioner has been lodged – counsel demonstrated that from 2000-2016, a total of 28 convicts sentenced to life imprisonment, who were involved in the murder of a woman, had been granted premature release. However, despite being recommended three times by the Advisory Board with detailed remarks on his reformation, the State government had rejected his case for premature release without assigning any reasoning, in its orders. This, it was argued, was grounds for setting aside these orders.
11. Lastly, counsel pointed to material produced by the respondent state itself, to demonstrate that the Jail Advisory Board had found the petitioner, who is aged 67 years old, to be hardworking, disciplined, and reformed, and prayed for his premature release.
12. To supplement his submissions, counsel placed reliance on various judgments of this court, including – State of Haryana v. Jagdish7, Maru Ram, v. Union of India8, General Officer Commanding-in-Chief v. Subhash Chandra Yadav9, State of Haryana v. Mahender Singh10, and State v. H. Nilofer Nisha11.
13. Mr. Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel, appearing on behalf of the state, submitted that the petitioner cannot claim a fundamental right to be released on remission, and that the prayer sought in the writ petition – for this court’s direction to the government to release him – was simply not maintainable.
14. Counsel argued that grant of remission, is solely at the executive’s discretion, and an act of mercy, granted on account of good conduct and term of imprisonment. It is not an indefeasible right; rather the convict only has a right to be considered for remission, which he had been, in the present case. The decision, however, of whether to be granted remission, was an act of exercising discretion which solely fell within the domain of the executive. 7 [2010] 3 SCR 716 8 [1981] 1 SCR 1196 9 [1988] 3 SCR 62 10 [2007] 11 SCR 932
11 (2020) 14 SCC 161
JOSEPH v. THE STATE OF KERALA [S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.] 514 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
15. Mr. Gupta drew attention to the nature of the crime – that it was premediated and cold-blooded murder, with robbery. The assault of an innocent young woman by someone she reposed trust in, her brother-in-law no less, who proceeded to rob her belongings and lay her to her death in such a horrific manner, it was argued was one which shocked the collective conscience of society. Mr. Gupta submitted that these factors, which no doubt weighed on the sentencing court (which did not grant the death penalty), must also weigh on the state authority granting remission, to guide its exercise of discretion.
16.Counsel for the State, relied on the following judgments to persuade this court – Ramdas Athawale v. Union of India12, Union of India v. V. Sriharan13, State of Haryana v. Mahender Singh (supra), Swamy Shraddananda (2) @ Mural Manohar Mishra v. State of Karnataka14, State of Madhya Pradesh v. Ratan Singh15 and Rajan v. The Home Secretary, Home Department of Tamil Nadu16.
Analysis and conclusion A. Applicable statutory provisions, rules, etc.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.