Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences & Anr. v. Bikartan Das & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 733; [2023] 11 S.C.R. 731
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice 2023 [dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, Justice Cji and J.B. Pardiwala, Justice J.] Headnotes Issue for Consideration: High Court
- Decided
- 16 Aug 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3339/2023
- Sections
- 5, 14, 24, 7, 16, 19, 38
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
CASE DETAILS
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES & ANR.
v.
BIKARTAN DAS & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 3339 of 2023)
AUGUST 16, 2023
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI AND J.B. PARDIWALA, J.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: High Court, if erred in setting aside the order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal and holding that respondent No.1 was entitled to the benefit of enhancement of retirement age from 60 to 65 years as applicable to the AYUSH doctors working under the Ministry of AYUSH.
Service Law – Grant of benefit of enhancement of retirement age – Unsustainability:
Held: Respondent No.1 was appointed as a Research Assistant by the appellant-Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences (CCRAS) and was functioning as a Researcher under the Research Council and his service conditions were also different compared to the AYUSH doctors serving with the Ministry of AYUSH – Appellant-Council is a registered autonomous body and is administratively controlled by the Ministry of AYUSH, Government of India – The recruitment rules, procedure and the service conditions of its employees are governed by the Bye-Laws and Memorandum of Association of the Council – High Court misdirected itself saying that the benefit of enhanced age of superannuation can also be granted if the duties performed are the same like AYUSH doctors – Governing body of the Council is not obliged to take a decision in tune with the decision of the Ministry of AYUSH regarding superannuation more particularly having made it clear that enhancement of retirement age is not applicable [2023] 11 S.C.R. 731 : 2023 INSC 733 732 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
to an autonomous body like CCRAS – Age of superannuation is always governed by the statutory rules governing appointment on a particular post – Hence, even if it is averred that the nature of work involved in the two posts is similar, the same cannot be a ground to increase or alter the service conditions of an employee as each post is governed by its own set of rules – Impugned order not sustainable, set aside – Society Registration Act, 1860. [Paras 23, 34, 44 and 48] Service Law – Interim relief for continuation in service granted – Impropriety:
Held: Court or the Tribunal should be slow and circumspect in granting interim relief for continuation in service, unless prima facie evidence of unimpeachable character is produced because if the public servant succeeds, he can always be compensated – But if he fails, he would have enjoyed undeserved benefit of extended service and caused injustice to his immediate junior – In the present case, High Court went to the extent of granting interim relief extending the period of service beyond 60 years till the disposal of the Original Petition by the CAT – By virtue of such interim order which the High Court ordinarily should not grant, the respondent No. 1 although was to retire in 2018 yet continued in service till 2021 – It is only when Supreme Court stayed the operation of the impugned order passed by the High Court while issuing notice that the service of the respondent No.1 came to an end. [Para 48] Service Law – Memorandum of Association of the Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences – Bye-Laws – Clauses 25(b), 34, 35 and 47 – Plea of respondent No.1 was that the provisions of FR 56(bb) would apply to him in his capacity as an employee of the Council in view of Clause 35, Bye-Laws of the Council by which the provisions of the FR and SR would apply to the employees of the Council mutatis mutandis: Held: Clauses 25(b), 34, 35 and 47 of the Bye-Laws in the Memorandum of Association indicate that the employees are recruited through a selection committee of the Council – It further indicates that the Fundamental Rules, 1922 will have no direct application in cases where the governing body finalises the rules of superannuation – In terms of Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws, the governing body had decided the age of superannuation to be 60 years on 01.12.1998 – The said decision was ratified on 27.01.2000 - CAT rightly
733CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS took the view that the plea canvassed on behalf of the respondent No.1 that the Council failed to consider the Clause 35 of the Bye-Laws which states that the FR, Supplementary Rule (SR) and General Financial Rules (GFR) as amended from time to time shall apply mutatis mutandis to employees of the Council, was without any merit and deserved to be rejected – CAT rightly rejected such argument because the applicability would be subject to the provision specific to the Clause 34 governing superannuation of the employees of the Council – There is nothing in Clause 35 of the Bye-Laws on the basis of which, it could be said that the same will have an overriding effect on Clause 34 as regards the age of retirement – Clause 47 of the Bye- Laws makes it abundantly clear that for the matters not specifically provided in the Bye-Laws, the rules applicable to the government employees would apply – However, as there is a specific provision regarding superannuation in Clause 34, the rules governing the government services in respect of superannuation are not applicable to the employees of the Council unless it is in accordance with Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws – Fundamental Rules, 1922. [Paras 25, 28 and 29] Words and Phrases – “or”, “and” – Interpretation – Plea of respondent No.1 that clause 34 of the Bye-Laws should be read in two parts- the first part states that the Rules governing the retirement of employees of the Government of India as amended from time to time would apply to the employees of the Central Council; the second part of Clause 34 which reads “or as desired by the governing body” is merely an enabling provision empowering the governing body to take a decision whether an employee deserves to be retained beyond the prescribed age of superannuation and that such power should not be read in a negative form to clothe the governing body with the power to prescribe lesser age of superannuation than what has been prescribed by the Central Government from time to time:
Held: Such argument cannot be accepted – The word “or” is normally disjunctive and the word “and” is normally conjunctive – Both of them can be read as vice-versa, but that interpretation is adopted only where the intention of the legislature is manifest – In the present case, the language of Clause 34 is very clear. What is important to note while reading the Clause 34 is the word “or” – Thereafter, there is a proviso which says that an 734 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
employee can be retained in service after prescribed age of superannuation if he continues to be physically fit and efficient and it is in the interest of the Central Counsel to retain him in the service – The expression “the rules governing the retirement of employees of Government of India as amended from time to time” is separated from the rest of the part of the Bye-Law by the word “or” which is disjunctive and giving natural meaning to the said word separates the rules that may be framed by the Government of India and the rules that the Council may desire to frame as regards the age of retirement of the employees of the Council – Interpretation of Statutes. [Paras 30-32] Service Law – Age of retirement vis-à-vis service conditions relating to pay and allowances and revision of pay – Respondent No.1 contended that as the terms and conditions of the services of the employees of the Council on all other aspects like the Provident Fund/ GPF, Pension, Gratuity, Leave Rules, Scales of Pay, Conduct Rules and other conditions of services are the same as applicable to the employees of the Central Government as set out in Clauses 31, 32, 33, 42, 44 and 47 respectively of the Bye-Laws, the matter of age of superannuation of the respondent No. 1 should not be treated differently:
Held: What should be the age of superannuation is a matter of policy – It is not within the domain of the court to legislate – It is only if a policy decision or a notification is arbitrary it may invite the frowns of Article 14 of the Constitution – The question of age of retirement stands on a different footing from the service conditions relating to pay and allowances and revision of pay. [Para 35] Service Law – Claim of respondent No.1-Research Assistant that his age of superannuation be at par with the AYUSH Doctors – Infringement of Article 14 alleged:
Held: It is too late in the day for the respondent No.1 to raise all such issues including infringement of Article 14 on the ground of artificial distinction between the Research Assistant and AYUSH Doctors – Respondent No.1 knew from the date of his appointment that he was being appointed as a Research Assistant – His service conditions and mode of recruitment are different compared to the AYUSH Doctors – It is a different thing that he might have treated the patients but that by itself would not entitle him to claim that his age of superannuation should be at par with the AYUSH Doctors – Present case is not one of discrimination – Article 14 has no application having regard to the facts of the present case – Constitution of India – Article 14. [Paras 37 and 39] Constitution of India – Article 226 – Extraordinary jurisdiction – Principles of law governing – Issue of Writ of certiorari – Discussed.
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
North Delhi Municipal Corporation v. Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma and Others 2021 SCC Online SC 540 – held not applicable.
Central Council for Research in Unani Medicine v. Dr. Salma Khatoon and Others 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1332; V.M. Gadre v. M.G. Diwan and Others (1996) 3 SCC 454 : [1996] 3 SCR 480; Census Commissioner and Others v. R. Krishnamurthy (2015) 2 SCC 796 : [2014] 11 SCR 463; State of Himachal Pradesh and Others v. Rajesh Chander Sood and Others (2016) 10 SCC 77 : [2016] 6 SCR 851; T.M. Sampath and Others v. Secretary Ministry of Water Resources and Others (2015) 5 SCC 333 : [2015] 1 SCR 748; State of Maharashtra and Another v. Bhagwan and Others (2022) 4 SCC 193; Tamil Nadu Education Department Ministerial and General Subordinate Services Association and Others v. State of Tamil Nadu and Others (1980) 3 SCC 97 : [1980] 1 SCR 1026; State of Bihar and Another v. Teachers’ Association of Govt. Engineering College and Others (2000) 10 SCC 527; Kerala Assistant Public Prosecutors Associations v. State of Kerala and Others AIR 2018 SC 2652 : [2018] 6 SCR 1139; Union of India and Others v. Lieut (Mrs) E. Iacats (1997) 7 SCC 334; New Okhla Industrial Development Authority and Another v. B D Singhal and Others AIR 2021 SC 3457; T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa and Another AIR 1954 SC 440 : [1955] SCR 250; Syed Yakoob v. K.S. Radhakrishnan and Others AIR 1964 SC 477 : [1964] SCR 64; Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chandra Rai and Others (2003) 6 SCC 675 : [2003] 2 Suppl. SCR 290; Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Ahmad Ishaque and Others AIR 1955 SC 233 : [1955] SCR 1104; K.M. Shanmugam v. The S.R.V.S. (P) Ltd. and Others AIR 1963 SC 1626 : [1964] SCR 809; Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde and Others v. Mallikarjun Bhavanappa Tirumale AIR 1960 SC 137 : [1960] SCR 890; Indian Overseas Bank v. I.O.B. Staff Canteen Workers' Union and Another AIR 2000 SC
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS 736 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
1508 : [2000] 2 SCR 1212; Ebrahim Aboobakar and Hawabai Aboobakar v. The Custodian General of Evacuee Property, New Delhi (1952) 1 SCC 798; Parry and Company Limited v. Commercial Employees’ Association, Madras and Another (1952) 1 SCC 449 : AIR 1952 SC 179 : [1952] SCR 519; Rai Brij Raj Krishna and Another v. Messrs S.K. Shaw and Brothers, AIR 1951 SC 115 : [1951] SCR 145; G. Veerappa Pillai v. Messrs Raman and Raman Ltd. Kumbakonam, Tanjore District and Others (1952) 1 SCC 334 – referred to.
Justice G.P. Singh in the Principles of Statutory Interpretation (Thirteenth Edition 2012) page 485 – referred to.
Anisminic Ltd. v. Foreign Compensation Commission and Another (1969) 2 AC 147; King v. Nat Bell Liquors Ltd. (1922) 2 AC 128 (PC); Colonial Bank of Australasia v. Willan (1874) LR 5 PC 417; R. v. Brighton and Area Rent Tribunal (1950) 1 All England Reporter 946 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No.3339 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 17.12.2020 of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in WPC No. 30620 of 2020.
Appearances:
Aman Lekhi, Sr. Adv., Harish Pandey, Adv. for the Appellants. K. M. Nataraj, ASG, Col. R. Bala, Sr. Adv., Naresh Kumar, Gurmeet Singh Makker, Kanu Agrawal, Kush Chaturvedi, Ketan Paul, Madhav Sinhal, Dr. Arun Kumar Yadav, Yogesh Kumar Mahur, Harkesh Prashar, Ronak Karanpuria, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
J. B. PARDIWALA, J.
1. This appeal by special leave is at the instance of the Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences (CCRAS), Ministry of Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy (AYUSH), Government of India (appellant No. 1) and its Director General (appellant No. 2). The two appellants before us were the original respondents before the High Court of Orissa. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 17.12.2020 passed by the High Court of Orissa, Cuttack in W.P. (C) No. 30620 of 2020 by which the High Court allowed the writ application filed by the original petitioner (respondent No. 1) before us, setting aside the order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Cuttack Bench, Cuttack and thereby holding that the respondent No. 1 herein, namely, Dr. Bikartan Das is entitled to the benefit of enhancement of retirement age from 60 to 65 years as applicable to the AYUSH doctors working under the Ministry of AYUSH.
FACTUAL MATRIX
2. The respondent No. 1 herein was appointed by the Council as a Research Assistant w.e.f. 07.10.1985. The Office Order No. 183 of 1985 dated 11.10.1985 reads thus:
“No. P.1-67/86-CRIA/DDSR/Estt./748(5) Dt 11.10.85 OFFICE ORDER No. 183/85 Dr. Bikartan Das is appointed as a Research Assistant (AY) with effect from the forenoon of the 7th October, 1985 until further orders in the Central Research Institute (AY), Unit, Bhubaneshwar-9. He will be on probation for a period of two years from this date. He will draw a basic pay of Rs. 425/- per month in the scale of Rs. 425-15-500 PB-15-560-20-700 with usual allowance admissible under the rules. (Dr. PREM KISHORE )
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR (AY) I/C”
3. The Government of India in its Ministry of Health and Family Welfare vide letter dated 01.12.1998 addressed to the Council, approved the decision of the Council to enhance the benefit of extension in age of retirement from 58 years to 60 years in respect of employees of the Council w.e.f. 31.05.1998 in accordance with the guidelines issued by the Department
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 738 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
of Personnel and Training (DoPT) vide O.M. No. 25012/8/98-Estt. (A) dated 13.05.1998.
4. On 27.09.2017, the Union Cabinet took a decision to enhance the age of superannuation up to 65 years for the AYUSH doctors working under the Ministry of AYUSH (respondent No. 2 herein) and in the Central Government Health Scheme (for short, ‘the CGHS’) Hospitals.
5. By way of letter dated 31.10.2017, the Ministry of AYUSH clarified that the effect of the Cabinet decision referred to above would be applicable only to the AYUSH doctors directly working under the Ministry of AYUSH and in the CGHS Hospitals. It was clarified that the decision to enhance the age of superannuation up to 65 years would not be applicable to the autonomous bodies functioning under the Ministry of AYUSH. The letter dated 31.10.2017 addressed by the Ministry of AYUSH to the Director General, CCRAS and CCRUM, reads thus:
“ FTS No. 32797/2017 Ministry of Ayurvedic, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha & Homoeopathy (AYUSH)
(Research Desk)
‘B’ – Block, GPO Complex, AYUSH Bhawan, Behind the INA Market, New Delhi – 110023 Dated: 31st October, 2017 To The Director General, CCRAS and CCRUM 61-65, Institutional Area, Opposite “D” Block, Janakpuri, New Delhi – 110058.
Subject: Enhancement of superannuation age to 65 years -reg. Sir, I am directed to say that the Ministry has been receiving a number of representations from various officials of the Councils regarding
739CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] enhancement of superannuation age to 65 years. It is stated that as per Press Information Bureau the Union Cabinet has taken the following decision:- “The superannuation age has been enhanced to 65 years in respect of doctors under the administrative control of the respective Ministry/Department [M/o AYUSH (AYUSH Doctors), Department of Defence (civilian doctors under Directorate General of Armed Forces Medical Service), Department of Defence Production (Indian Ordnance Factories Health Service Medical Officers), Dental Doctors under D/o Health & Family Welfare, Dental doctors under Ministry of Railways and of doctors working in Higher Education and Technical Institutions under Department of Higher Education]”.
2. The decision of the Cabinet is applicable to the AYUSH doctors directly working under the administrative control of Ministry of AYUSH i.e. AYUSH doctors working under CGHS. The decision of the Union Cabinet is not applicable to autonomous bodies functioning under Ministry of AYUSH i.e. Research Councils/National Institutes.
3. All such representations are therefore being sent to the respective Councils. It is requested that the Councils may inform them accordingly. Yours faithfully, N. K. Lakhanpal Senior Consultant”
6. By order dated 24.11.2017, the Ministry of AYUSH enhanced the age of superannuation to 65 years for the AYUSH doctors working in the Ministry of AYUSH and in CGHS Hospitals w.e.f. 27.09.2017. The order dated 24.11.2017 reads thus:
“ F.NO. D.14019/4/2016-E-I(AYUSH)
Government of India Ministry of Ayurveda, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha and Homoeopathy AYUSH Bhawan, ‘B’ Block, GPO Complex, 740 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
INA, New Delhi - 110023 Dated, the 24th November, 2017.
ORDER
The President is pleased to enhance the age of superannuation of the AYUSH doctors under the Ministry of AYUSH and working in CGHS Dispensaries/Hospitals to 65 years with effect from 27.09.2017, i.e. the date of the approval of the Union Cabinet.
2. The doctors shall hold the administrative posts only till the date of attaining the age of 62 years and thereafter their services shall be placed in non-administrative positions.
(ROSHAN JAGGI)
Joint Secretary to the Government of India Tel.24651953”
7. By notification dated 05.01.2018, the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, DoPT notified the Fundamental (Amendment) Rules, 2018 whereby Rule 56(bb) in the Fundamental Rules, 1922 (FRs) was substituted and the age of superannuation of AYUSH doctors was enhanced to 65 years. The notification reads thus:
“MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL, PUBLIC GRIEVANCES
AND PENSIONS
(Department of Personnel and Training)
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 5th January, 2018 G.S.R. 27(E).—In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to article 309 of the Constitution, the President hereby makes the following rules further to amend the Fundamental Rules, 1922, namely:—
(1) These rules may be called the Fundamental (Amendment) Rules, 2018.
(2) In the Fundamental Rules, 1922, in rule 56, for clause (bb), the following shall be substituted, namely:— “(bb) The age of superannuation in respect of General Duty Medical Officers and Specialists included in Teaching, Non-Teaching and Public Health sub-cadres of Central Health Service, AYUSH doctors, Civilian doctors under Directorate General of Armed Forces Medical Services, Medical officers of Indian Ordnance Factories Health Services, dental doctors working under Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, doctors of Indian Railways Medical Service and dental doctors under Ministry of Railways, doctors of General Duty Medical Officers sub-cadre of Central Armed Police Forces and Assam Rifles and Specialist Medical officers of Central Armed Police Forces and Assam Rifles shall be sixty-five years:
Provided that notwithstanding anything contained in any other rules, above doctors except in Central Armed Police Forces and Assam Rifles shall hold the administrative posts till the date of attaining the age of sixty-two years and thereafter their services shall be placed in Non-Administrative positions.”
[F.No.25012/4/2016-Estt.(A-IV)] GYANENDRA DEV TRIPATHI, Jt. Secy.”
8. By letter dated 25.01.2018, the appellant Council circulated the clarification letter issued by the Ministry of AYUSH dated 31.10.2017 referred to in para 5 as above. The letter reads thus:
“F 3-8/2017-CCRAS/Vig/3094 Dated: 25 JAN 2018 To All the Heads of Institutes/Centres/Units functioning under this Council.
Sub: - Enhancement of superannuation age of 65 years.
Sir/Madam The undersigned is directed to circulate herewith the clarification on the subject mentioned above received from Ministry of AYUSH vide letter FTS No.32797/2017 dated 31.10.2017 for information. The contents of Ministry’s letter may be circulated among all officers working under your control.
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 742 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Yours faithfully
(SB MISRA)
Administrative Officer (Vigilance)
For Director General”
It is pertinent to note that the letter issued by the appellant Council dated 25.01.2018 referred to above was never made a subject matter of challenge.
9. The respondent No. 1 herein preferred a representation dated 22.03.2018 addressed to the appellant No. 2 herein with an appeal to enhance his age of superannuation up to 65 years i.e., up to 30.04.2023 instead of 30.04.2018. It appears from the materials on record that the representation preferred by the respondent No. 1 herein before the above was rejected and a notification dated 04.04.2018 was issued by the Council stating that the respondent No. 1 herein would retire w.e.f. 30.04.2018 upon attaining the superannuation age of 60 years. The notification dated 04.04.2018 reads thus:
“F. No. 26-3 / 2018-C.C.R.A.S. / Est. 17 Date: 04.04.2018 Notification It is hereby notified that Dr. Bikartan Das, Assistant Director (AYUSH), Central Ayurvedic Research Institute for Hepatobiliary Disorder, Bhubaneswar is retiring from Council service on attaining the age of superannuation at 60 years on 30.04.2018 (pm). His date of birth is 04.04.1958.
Accordingly, his name will be removed from the list of C.C.R.A.S. Signature in English Illegible R.K. Ahluwalia Dated 27.03.2018 Dy. Director (Administration)
Through Director General”
10. The respondent No. 1 being dissatisfied with the aforesaid went before the CAT, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack by way of Original Application No. 210 of 2018 and prayed for the following reliefs:
“The Hon’ble Tribunal may be graciously pleased to admit the Original Application, call for the records and issue notice to the Respondents and upon hearing the parties declare the impugned letter of clarification of Ministry of AYUSH dtd. 31.10.2017 as under Annexure-4 Series and the letter dtd. 04.04.2018 under Annexure 3 directing the Applicant to retire on 30.04.2018 on attaining age of 60 years, to be illegal, arbitrary unreasonable and discriminatory and quash the same and direct the Respondent to allow the Applicant to continue in the service upto 65 years as per amended rules.
x x x Pending finalization of the Original Application, the Applicant prays to stay the order under Annexure-3 and allow the Applicant to continue in the service.”
11. By order dated 17.04.2018 the CAT issued notice, however, declined to grant any interim relief as prayed for by the respondent No. 1 herein. As CAT declined to grant any interim relief and the respondent No. 1 was to retire on 30.04.2018, he went before the High Court of Orissa, Cuttack by filing W. P. (C) No. 6663 of 2018 questioning the order passed by the CAT declining to grant any interim relief. The High Court passed the following order dated 25.04.2018:
“SI. No. of Order- 03 Date of Order- 25.04.2018 Heard Mr. B. Senapati, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Bose, learned Asst. Solicitor General.
This Writ Petition has been filed by the petitioner challenging the order dated 17.04.2018 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack in O.A. No. 260/210/2018 wherein the Tribunal while issuing notice directed the opposite parties to file their reply on the interim prayers and regular counter.
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 744 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
As it appears that the Central Government has taken a decision under the Ministry of AYUSH to enhance the age of retirement of the Doctors up to 65 years. However, so far as the petitioner is concerned, since the notice of superannuation was issued to him, he has approached the Tribunal. Since the Original Application is pending before the Tribunal, without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, we dispose of this Writ Petition with an observation that since the Doctors who are similarly after continuing the age of 65 years after attaining the age of 60 years, let the Petitioner continue in the service and let the notice of superannuation under Annexure-3 shall remain stayed till disposal of the Original Application.
Mr. Bose, learned Assistant Solicitor General submitted that the central government will file their counter within a period of two weeks from today before the Tribunal, in such event the Tribunal may dispose of the Original Application at the earliest, preferably by end of June, 2018. Accordingly, we request the Tribunal may dispose of the Original Application at the earliest/as per its schedule. However, the petitioner shall not claim any equity.
Sd.- S. Panda, J.
Sd.-K.R. Mohapatra”
12. Thus, from the aforesaid, it appears that the High Court protected the respondent No. 1 till the disposal of the original application by the CAT. By virtue of the aforesaid order, the respondent No. 1 continued in service beyond 30.04.2018.
13. CAT ultimately adjudicated the original application filed by the respondent No. 1 herein and vide its order dated 02.11.2020 rejected the same holding that the respondent no. 1 is not entitled to seek parity with AYUSH doctors in regard to the age of superannuation.
14. The sum and substance of the findings recorded by the CAT may be summarised as under:
(i) The Fundamental Rules notified under Article 309 of the Constitution of India are applicable to the employees working directly under the Government of India. Its applicability to the employees of the Council is on account of Clauses 34 and 35 respectively of the Bye-Laws. This issue was considered by the Hyderabad Bench of the CAT vide order dated 04.09.2020, wherein it was observed that- “Clause 34 of the bye-law makes it crystal clear that the Governing Body has to take a decision in regard to the enhancement of the retirement age. The Governing body has no necessity to take a decision in the context of the Ministry of AYUSH, Govt. of India having made it clear that enhancement of retirement age is not applicable to an autonomous body like CCRAS. Therefore, the G.O.I. rule of not extending the enhancement of retirement age to CCRAS compliments the clauses 35 & 47 of the byelaws. We do not find any error in the decision taken by the respondents in terms of the bye laws.”
(Emphasis supplied)
(ii) CAT did not accept the respondent No. 1’s argument of Clause 35 and application of the Fundamental Rules mutatis mutandis to the employees of the Council saying that the clause relates to the general applicability of FRs, Supplementary Rule (SRs) and General Financial Rules (GFRs) to the Council employees; the same is subject to the provision specific to Clause 34 governing superannuation of the employees of the Council. There is nothing in Clause 35 of the Bye- Laws to have an overriding effect on Clause 34 regarding retirement age.
(iii) Clause 47 of the Bye-Laws makes it clear that for the matters not specifically provided in the Bye-Laws, the rules applicable to the government employees would apply. But since there is a specific provision regarding superannuation in Clause 34, the rules governing government servants in respect of superannuation will not be applicable to the employees of the Council unless it is in accordance with Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws.
(iv) There is nothing in the Cabinet resolution in question and in the amended FR-56(bb) to show that these decisions are applicable to the employees of the autonomous institutions. The assumption of the respondent No. 1 that the FR-56, as amended from time to time, is automatically applicable to the Council employees is not correct since
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 746 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
it is subject to the provisions of Clauses 34 & 35 respectively of the Bye-Laws.
(v) There is nothing wrong with the clarification letter dated 31.10.2017. It cannot be stated to be overriding the Cabinet decision in question, and the objection to the letter on that ground is not sustainable. The clarification letter was circulated by the Council by a subsequent letter dated 25.01.2018 among its officers, after issuance of the first amendment to FR-56. This implies that the Council, which is the employer of the respondent No.1, had consciously accepted the clarification of the Ministry. The respondent No. 1 had not challenged the Council’s letter dated 25.01.2018 but had only challenged the AYUSH Ministry’s letter dated. 31.10.2017.
(vi) There is nothing in the pleadings of the respondent No.1 to show that the amended FR-56(bb) is applicable to the employees of the Council, except for citing the provisions of the Bye-Laws. As per Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws, the rules governing the retirement of the government employees will be applicable to the employees of the Council as adopted by the Governing Body. This means that the unless the Governing Body adopts the changes in rules for the retirement of government servants, such changes are not automatically applicable to the employees of the Council.
(vii) The CAT placed reliance on the decision of this Court in DDA v. Joint Action Committee, Allottee of SFS Flats, reported in (2008) 2 SCC 672 to hold that there are certain specific grounds on which a policy decision can be subjected to judicial review, and in this situation there was no valid ground to challenge the policy decision of the AYUSH Ministry as per the clarification letter dated 31.10.2017.
(viii) In the last, the CAT considered that even if the respondent No.1’s contention that he had treated patients was to be accepted, such acceptance could not have negated the decision taken by the Ministry of AYUSH in its clarification letter dated 31.01.2017, which was further accepted by the Council in its subsequent letter dated 25.01.2018.
15. The respondent No. 1 feeling dissatisfied with the aforesaid order passed by the CAT challenged the same before the High Court in W.P.(C) No. 30620 of 2020. The High Court allowed the writ application filed by the respondent No. 1 holding as under:
“On the analysis of the above factual matrix, we find that though the petitioner is functioning as Researcher under the Research Council/ National Institute, but as a requirement for upgrading the research skill, he treats patients in the OPD and IPD. In fact, he performs similar nature of duties like AYUSH doctor. Though his service condition is covered by different laws, but for all practical purposes, the petitioner is performing like a doctor. Though there is a clear-cut distinguishing features between the AYUSH doctor and that of the petitioner. The petitioner herein is also treating the patients like AYUSH doctors in the OPDs and IPDs on regular basis.
The Clause-34 and 35 of the bye-laws extends the force of the argument of the petitioner to be treated as AYUSH doctor, even though he has been appointed as Researcher.
Clauses-34 & 35 of the said bye-laws deal with superannuation which read as under:
“34. The rules governing the retirement of employees of the Government of India as amended from time to time or as desired by the Governing Body shall apply to the employees of the Central Council. Provided that an employee can be retained in service after prescribed age of superannuation if he continues to be physically fit and efficient and it is in the interest of the Central Council to retain him in service.
35. The Fundamental and Supplementary Rules and General Financial Rules of Government of India as amended from time to time shall apply mutatis mutandis to employees of the Central Council.”
In view of the above, we are of the opinion that the view taken by the learned Tribunal vide its decision dated 02.11.2020 is erroneous.
The learned CAT, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack has failed to consider the petitioner’s duty and devotion in treating the OPD and IPD patients.
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 748 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Hence, the order dated 02.11.2020 passed by the learned CAT, Cuttack Bench, Cuttack is liable to be quashed and accordingly, it is quashed.” (Emphasis supplied)
16. Thus, the plain reading of the impugned order passed by the High Court referred to above would indicate that what weighed with the High Court was that the respondent No. 1 herein used to treat patients like AYUSH doctors in the Out-Patient Departments (OPDs) and In-Patient Departments (IPDs) on regular basis and the duty and devotion exhibited by the respondent No. 1 in treating the OPD and IPD patients would entitle him to claim the benefit of the enhanced age of superannuation i.e., up to 65 years. The High Court recorded the said finding despite acknowledging that the respondent No. 1 was appointed as a researcher under the Research Council and his service conditions were governed by different laws. Of course, the High Court also took support of Clauses 34 and 35 respectively of the Bye-Laws while granting relief to the respondent No. 1.
17. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellants are here before this Court with the present appeal.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS
18. Mr. Aman Lekhi, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants made the following submissions:
a. The issue involved in the present case is the entitlement to seek extension in superannuation age as per FR 56(bb) and its applicability to the appellant Council which is an autonomous body. The said FR has been amended from time to time and the rule applicable in the present case i.e. at the time of the retirement of the respondent No. 1 is of 05.01.2018.
b. The respondent No. 1 was an employee of CCRAS having joined as Research Assistant and his terms of service were governed under the Rules of CCRAS. Subsequently, he was promoted to the post of Research Officer and at the time of superannuation he was holding the post of an Assistant Director.
c. The relevant clauses of CCRAS which are applicable to the facts of the present case are Clauses 25(b), 34, 35 and 47 of CCRAS Bye- Laws which are extracted herein for the sake of convenience: “Appointments 25.(a)...
(b) Recruitments, appointments and promotions to all posts shall be made according to the recruitment rules laid down by the Governing Body or designated competent authority for the posts. Selection shall be made through the Selection Committees/Departmental Promotion Committees duly constituted with the approval of the respective appointing authority.
Superannuation
34. The rules governing the retirement of employees of Government of India as amended from time to time or as desired by the Governing Body shall apply to the employees of the Central Council. Provided that an employee can be retained in service after the prescribed age of superannuation if he continues to be physically fit and efficient and it is in the interest of the Central Council to retain him in service.
35. The Fundamental and Supplementary Rules and General Financial Rules of Government of India as amended from time to time shall apply mutatis mutandis to employees of the Central Council.
Xxx xxx xxx Other Conditions of Service
47. In respect of matters not provided for in these regulations the rules as applicable to Central Government servants regarding the general conditions of service, pay, allowances T.A. and daily allowances, foreign service terms, deputation in India and abroad, etc. and orders and decisions issued in this regard by the Central Government from time to time shall apply mutatis mutandis to the employees of the Central Council.”
(Emphasis supplied)
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 750 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
d. A bare perusal of the aforesaid rules indicates that the employees are recruited through a selection committee of the Council and the FRs will not directly apply where the Governing Body finalises the rules of superannuation.
e. In terms of Clause 34, the Governing Body had decided to fix the age of superannuation to be 60 years on 01.12.1998. The said decision was ratified on 27.01.2000 in the 14th Meeting of the Governing Body of CCRAS as Agenda Item No. GB 14.4.
f. The decision of the Governing Body as aforementioned applied on 30.04.2018 i.e. the date of superannuation of the Respondent. g. No reference has been made by the respondent No. 1 to the aforementioned decision of the governing body in his representation. In fact, the Respondent relied on Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws which on its terms indicates that the rules governing the retirement of employees of Government of India will not apply in the instant case.
h. Reliance placed by the respondent No. 1 in its representation on the case of Salma Khatoon is equally inapt as the relevant rule in the said case was different from the Clause 34 of Bye-Laws herein. The said case pertained to the Central Council for Research in Unani Medicine (‘CCRUM’) which is governed by its own rules and regulation and the applicable rule in that case was worded differently. Moreover, the said case is still pending before the High Court of Delhi. The interim order in favour of Salma Khatoon was vacated by this Court in the case of Central Council for Research in Unani Medicine v. Dr. Salma Khatoon and Others reported as 2020 SCC OnLine SC 1332.
i. The Central Administrative Tribunal, Cuttack Bench (‘CAT’) rightly held that the assumption of the respondent No. 1 that FR 56 is automatically applicable is not correct as it is subject to Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws of CCRAS.
j. The very same grounds as aforesaid were urged by the Appellants in the Counter Affidavit fi led by them before the High Court of Orissa.
k. While passing the impugned order, the High Court acknowledges that the respondent No. 1 was working as a Researcher and his service conditions were covered by a different clause. Strangely, however, the High Court makes no reference to Clause 34 of the Bye-Laws. This is despite the fact that the appellants had clearly pleaded that the respondent was not entitled to relief in terms of Clause 34 and that FR 56 was not applicable to him. Pertinently, this submission has been recorded by the High Court itself as also the clarification of 31.10.2017 and the separate method of recruitment. These factors were not considered while passing the impugned order.
l. The impugned order of the High Court is unsustainable as it is against the following settled propositions of law:
(i) Even a Constitutional Court cannot substitute the existing service conditions of an employee. V.M. Gadre v. M.G. Diwan and Others, (1996) 3 SCC 454 para 10 at page 459.
(ii) A writ in the nature of mandamus cannot be issued to frame a policy in a particular manner. Census Commissioner and Others v. R. Krishnamurthy, (2015) 2 SCC 796 para 25-26 at page 806-807.
(iii) The Court cannot fasten monetary liability on State instrumentality unless it emerges from the rights and liabilities canvassed in the lis itself. State of Himachal Pradesh and Others v. Rajesh Chander Sood and Others, (2016) 10 SCC 77 para 88 at page 160.
(iv) Employees of autonomous bodies are governed by their own rules and Bye-Laws and they cannot claim parity with government employees. T.M. Sampath and Others v. Secretary, Ministry of Water Resources and Others, (2015) 5 SCC 333 para 3 at page 336 & para 15 at page 345; State of Maharashtra and Another v. Bhagwan and Others, (2022) 4 SCC 193 para 24-26 at page 203-204.
m. The reliance placed by the respondent No. 1 on the judgment of this Court North Delhi Municipal Corporation v. Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma and Others reported in 2021 SCC Online SC 540 is completely
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 752 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
misplaced. The issue in the said case pertained to different dates of enhancement of age of superannuation of AYUSH and CHS doctors of NDMC. In the said case, the policy decision of enhancing the age of superannuation to 65 years was adopted by NDMC for AYUSH doctors but it was applied from a later date which was found to be discriminatory. Whereas, in the present case the appellant is an autonomous body with its own service rules and the government decision was never adopted by the Governing Body at any point of time.
n. The reference made to the appointment of Director of the Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda (‘ITRA’) in context with the retirement age of 65 years is wholly misplaced. The appointments to ITRA are made as per the provisions of the Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda Act, 2020. Section 5(e) of the Act, 2020 provides for the tenure of the Director of 5 years or until the age of 65 years whichever is earlier. Hence, the respondent No. 1 who is not covered under the provisions of the said Act cannot claim parity with the employees of ITRA.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT NO. 1
19. Mr. Col. R. Balasubramanian, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent No. 1 made the following submissions:
a. His client is an AYUSH Doctor being fully and duly qualified in Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine and Surgery (BAMS). The fact that his client is an AYUSH Doctor is admitted by the appellants in their counter affidavit filed before the CAT. As per the existing rule, those who have completed BAMS from any University of India, which is recognised by the Central Council for Indian Medicine (CCIM) and who have registered under any State Council of Indian Medicine or CCIM, New Delhi are AYUSH Doctors. This is also admitted by AYUSH in their RTI reply.
b. That being a duly qualified AYUSH doctor, the respondent No. 1 was appointed as a Research Associate in the Central Research Institute (Ayurveda), Bhuvaneshwar under the Control of the Ministry of AYUSH, vide appointment letter dated 03.10.1985. The terms of appointment specifically stated inter alia, in para 2 (vi) & (vii) thereof, that “Private or Consultancy service is strictly prohibited” and that “Other terms and conditions of service will be governed by the rules and instruction applicable to similar personnel under the Government of India” respectively. Further it was stated that the pay and dearness allowances etc. will be as applicable to the Central Government servants of equivalent status and will be governed by the CCS Rules as amended by the Government of India from time to time.
c. The fact that the Institute where the respondent No. 1was serving is under the ‘pervasive control’ of the Government/Ministry is admitted by the appellants in their counter affidavit filed before the CAT and also in the Counter affidavit filed before the High Court. Therefore, two factual aspects are admitted and it is beyond any doubt that (i) the respondent No. 1 is an AYUSH Doctor and (ii) the Institute is under the administrative control of the Ministry of AYUSH.
d. In view of the aforesaid admitted facts, it is evident more particularly from the Union Cabinet decision of the appellants that the Government of India had approved the enhancement of age of superannuation from 60 to 65 years. This decision of the Cabinet was applicable to the respondent No. 1. In terms of the said decision at “iii. that the superannuation age has been enhanced to 65 years in respect of doctors under their administrative control of the respective Ministries/ Departments [M/o of AYUSH (AYUSH Doctors,………”.
e. The Cabinet has not made any distinction or difference in treatment between the AYUSH Doctors working under the administrative control of the Ministry of AYUSH in the matter of enhancement of retirement age up to 65 years. It is reiterated that only two conditions are required to be satisfied to avail the enhanced age of superannuation up to 65 years of age viz., (i) AYUSH Doctor and (ii) being under the Administrative Control of the Ministry. Therefore, the respondent No. 1 is squarely covered by the Cabinet’s decision and is entitled to the enhanced age of retirement of 65 years.
f. That accordingly, Rule 56(bb) of the Fundamental Rules, 1922, which is a statutory rule framed under the Proviso to Article 309 of
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 754 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
the Constitution of India, was amended vide Gazette Notification dated 05th January, 2018 in terms of which the age of superannuation inter alia of the AYUSH doctors [3rd line of amended Rule (bb) shall be sixty-five years. This was further amended vide the Gazette Notification dated 11.08.2018 categorically laying down that the age of superannuation of doctors belonging to various cadres including AYUSH and working under the Ministry of AYUSH shall be 62 years unless they opt to continue in teaching, consultancy, etc in which case it shall extend up to 65 years. Therefore, even in the 2nd Gazette all the AYUSH doctors working under the Ministry of AYUSH were included without any distinction whether working in the Ministry or in any autonomous body.
g. That contrary to the Cabinet decision, the impugned letter dated 31.10.2017 was issued denying the extension of age up to 65 years to the AYUSH doctors working in autonomous bodies like the respondent No. 1. Para 2 of said letter is not sustainable in law and on facts for the following amongst other reasons:i. That the decision was a Cabinet decision and the same could not have been diluted or misinterpreted by the impugned letter of a subordinate functionary viz., a Senior Consultant working in the Ministry of AYUSH by excluding the AYUSH Doctors working in the autonomous bodies under the administrative control of the Ministry of AYUSH. ii. That there is no Cabinet approval to exclude the AYUSH doctors working in autonomous bodies. Therefore, the impugned letter is contrary to the Cabinet decision and on this count alone the same cannot be enforced against the respondent No. 1.
iii. The letter dated 31.10.2017 in any case stood overruled/superseded in view of the subsequent Gazettes dated 05.01.2018 and 11.08.2018 respectively.
iv. That the sub classification introduced by the impugned letter besides being contrary to the Cabinet decision, is a suspect classification, and it is directly violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21 respectively of the Constitution of India. The reason being first, there is no rationale or nexus with the object which it seeks to achieve i.e, exclusion of the AYUSH Doctors working in autonomous bodies and secondly, it creates an artificial distinction of AYUSH doctors working in the Ministry and elsewhere, although both are similarly qualified and discharge functions of OPD/IPD treatment of patients including surgery etc, albeit at different places. The respondent No. 1 also drew NPA (Non-Practicing Allowance). These facts have not been disputed.
v. That it is well settled in law where the classification has no nexus with the object it seeks to achieve and that there is artificial distinction the same would fall foul of Articles 14 and 21 in the matter of conditions of service of an employee.
vi. That even otherwise, the respondent No. 1 is entitled to the benefit of enhanced age of retirement of 65 years on the strength of plain reading of Clause 34 of the Society Rules extracted @ Pg 12 of the Judgement by the High Court, on which extensive reliance is placed by the appellants contending that the applicability of the extension of age is dependent upon the decision to be taken by the Governing Body of the autonomous body, and hence the Central Govt rule of age of superannuation is not automatic. This contention is not correct for the following reasons:
- Clause 34 is in two parts. The first part is that the rules governing the retirement of employees of the Government of India as amended from to time shall apply to the employees of the Central Council. The plain and simple reading of this part makes it clear and unambiguous that the rules governing the retirement of Central Government employees as amended from time to time shall apply.
- The second part of Clause 34 “or as desired by the Governing Body” is merely an enabling provision to enable the Governing Body to take a decision regarding retention of an employee beyond the prescribed age of superannuation. In other words, the ‘desire’ of Governing Body is to extend the age of an employee even beyond prescribed age if he continues to be physically fit and efficient and it is in the interest of the Council to retain him in service.
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 756 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
- Therefore, the second part of Clause 34 really gives power to the Governing Body to retain an employee even after the prescribed age of superannuation provided the conditions for grant of such retention is met. This power cannot be negatively read to clothe the Governing Body with power to prescribe less age of superannuation than what is prescribed by the Central Government from time to time.
- While the age of superannuation of an employee of the Central Council shall be at par with the age of superannuation prescribed by the Central Government, the Governing body has the enabling power to retain the employee even beyond the age of superannuation in organisational interest.
- It is submitted that Clause 34 cannot be read negatively to deny the age of increase given by the Cabinet to AYUSH Doctors by wrongly interpreting Clause 34.
vii. That the terms and conditions of service of employees of the Council on all other aspects like Provident Fund/ GPF, Pension, Gratuity, Leave Rules, Scales of Pay, Conduct Rules, and other conditions of service are the same as applicable to Central Government employees as set out in Clauses 31, 32, 33, 42, 44, and 47 respectively of the Rules. Therefore, in the matter of age of superannuation the respondent No. 1 cannot be treated differently.
viii. That the appellants on one hand claim that the AYUSH doctors working in autonomous bodies are not entitled to increase in age of superannuation up to 65 years whereas other AYUSH doctors working in the Ministry of AYUSH and other autonomous institutions have been granted extension of age up to 65 years.
ix. That similarly, AYUSH doctors working in CGHS have been granted increase in age up to 65 years vide letter dated 24.11.2017. Therefore, the letter not to grant identical benefit to the respondent No. 1 is not only arbitrary but it is discriminatory and hence it is unsustainable. h. This Court has dealt with the issue of extension of age of superannuation of similar AYUSH doctors working in the NDMC in Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma (supra), where in paras 23 and 24 it was held as follows: “23. The common contention of the appellants before us is that classification of AYUSH doctors and doctors under CHS in different categories is reasonable and permissible in law. This however does not appeal to us and we are inclined to agree with the findings of the Tribunal and the Delhi High Court that the classification is discriminatory and unreasonable since doctors under both segments are performing the same function of treating and healing their patients. The only difference is that AYUSH doctors are using indigenous systems of medicine like Ayurveda, Unani, etc. and CHS doctors are using Allopathy for tending to their patients. In our understanding, the mode of treatment by itself under the prevalent scheme of things, does not qualify as an intelligible differentia. Therefore, such unreasonable classification and discrimination based on it would surely be inconsistent with Article 14 of the Constitution. The order of AYUSH Ministry dated 24.11.2017 extending the age of superannuation to 65 Years also endorses such a view. This extension is in tune with the notification of Ministry of Health and Family Welfare dated 31.05.2016.
24. The doctors, both under AYUSH and CHS, render service to patients and on this core aspect, there is nothing to distinguish them. Therefore, no rational justification is seen for having different dates for bestowing the benefit of extended age of superannuation to these two categories of doctors. Hence, the order of AYUSH Ministry (F. No. D. 14019/4/2016-E-I (AYUSH)) dated 24.11.2017 must be retrospectively applied from 31.05.2016 to all concerned respondentdoctors, in the present appeals. All consequences must follow from this conclusion.”
i. The appeal deserves to be dismissed with costs and directions be issued to the appellants to release the consequential benefits including arrears of salary for the period from 01.05 2018 to 30.04.2023 which would cover the entire period of 5 years of increase in age of superannuation. The respondent No. 1 worked from 25.04.2018 following the order of stay grated by the High Court till 05.04.2021 when stay was granted by this Court following which the services of the respondent No. 1 were abruptly ended. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE INTERVENORS/
APPLICANTS IN I.A. NO. 90789 OF 2022 IN SLP (C) NO. 4110 OF 2021
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 758 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
20. It is the case of the intervenors/applicants that their W.P.(C) Nos. 9554 of 2018 and 9584 of 2018 respectively are pending adjudication before the High Court of Delhi and one Original Application No. 272 of 2020 before CAT, Lucknow Bench. They submitted that the final outcome of the present appeal will have a direct impact on the aforesaid litigations. The intervenors claim that they are doctors under another corporation of AYUSH, namely, CCRUM.
21. Submissions canvassed on their behalf are as under:
a. That the Intervenors/applicants are qualified Unani Doctors by qualification and are equivalent to any other qualified Doctors, be it MBBS Doctors or otherwise.
b. The Intervenors/applicants are working under the Direct Administrative Control of Ministry of AYUSH and their service conditions are governed by the Ministry in spite of them performing the duties in CCRUM.
c. The Intervenors/applicants have been receiving the Non- Practicing Allowance while working under CCRUM which clearly indicates that the Intervenors/applicants are indeed qualified doctors at par with the other Doctors who also get the same allowances.
d. The Recruitment Rules which apply to the Intervenors/ applicants are: “for functional purpose, a medical officer (Ayurveda) when posted in the Ministry of AYUSH will be designated as Research officer (Ayurveda) and thus the medical officer and Research officer are one and the same and there cannot be any distinction between the two”.
e. That the Government of India (Cabinet) vide its order has granted the benefit of enhancement of superannuation age to 65 years to the doctors under the administrative control of the respective Ministries/Department (Ministry of AYUSH) (AYUSH doctors) which is fully applicable to the doctors working under the appellant council but the Ministry of AYUSH erroneously by their mis-interpretation has excluded the benefits to doctors working under autonomous bodies like the council. It is because of the wrong interpretation made by the Ministry of AYUSH, the said benefit was erroneously denied to the AYUSH doctors like the Intervenors/applicants.
f. That the Govt. of India vide its own order dated 02.11.2020 has given the said benefit to the Director of ITRA and enhanced the age of superannuation to 65 years. Therefore, as per own interpretation made by the Ministry of AYUSH, the benefit of enhancement of superannuation of age is fully applicable to all doctors (working in any capacity including researcher) who are under the administrative control of AYUSH and when Govt. of India (Cabinet) did not exclude the autonomous institution like Intervenors/applicants council then the Ministry of AYUSH has no right to differentiate and deny the benefit of superannuation to the Intervenors/applicants.
g. It is submitted that Clauses-34 & 35 of the Bye-Laws issued by the CCRAS, deals with superannuation and prescribes that the Fundamental and Supplementary Rules and General Financial Rules of the Government of India as amended from time to time shall apply mutatis mutandis to the employees of the Central Council.
h. It is submitted that the Intervenors/applicants during their entire tenure performed duties like treating patients in OPD and IPD along with research activities which would clearly establish that the Intervenors/applicants have been attending the patients, both, the OPDs and IPDs. The Intervenors/applicants have worked for prestigious hospitals like the RML & DDU while performing duties which include treating the patients along with Research work. i. It is submitted that Non-Practicing Allowance has been given to the doctors working under Intervenor/applicants council and the said benefit was given to the Intervenor/applicants as well which clearly contradicts the stand of council that the Intervenors/ applicants were not performing the duties of doctors. In fact, the Non-Practicing Allowance has been sanctioned only on the basis that the Intervenors/applicants are qualified doctors and are performing the duties of Clinical Doctor which includes the OPD
CENTRAL COUNCIL FOR RESEARCH IN AYURVEDIC
SCIENCES v. BIKARTAN DAS [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 760 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
& IPD duties and thus are not allowed to practice outside the scope of their official duties and in lieu were given the Non-Practicing Allowance.
j. It is submitted that those doctors are considered as AYUSH doctors who have completed the degree course either in BAMS, BHMS, BUMS, BNYS & BSM in Ayurveda, Homeopathy, Unami, Siddha, Yoga and Naturopathy and are at par with any other qualified Doctors.
k. The Intervenors/applicants Council is an autonomous body under the Ministry of AYUSH, Government of India and the Council has a Governing Body comprising of the Union Minister- In-Charge of AYUSH as its President and Secretary, Ministry of AYUSH as its Vice President. Its Bye-Laws reveal the pervasive control of the Union Government over the Central Council.
l. The aforesaid is clearly depicted from the Bye-Laws of Intervenor/applicants council. That the Clauses - 34 and 35 of the Bye-Laws deal with the superannuation of the employees of the Council which are quoted herein below: Clauses-34 & 35 of the said Bye-Laws deal with superannuation which read as under: “34. The rules governing the retirement of employees of the Government of India as amended from time to time or as desired by the Governing Body shall apply to the employees of the Central Council. Provided that an employee can be retired in service after prescribed age of superannuation if he continues to be physically fit and efficient and it is in the interest of the Central Council to retain him in service.
35. The Fundamental and Supplementary Rules and General Financial Rules of Government of India as amended from time to time shall apply mutatis mutandis to employees of the Central Council.”
m. That, the clarification of Ministry of AYUSH vide its letter dated 31.10.2017 is not only misconceived but also uncalled for, arbitrary and discriminatory. The same is also contrary to the object for which the Central Council is established. The aforesaid clarification would rather frustrate the objectives for which the Central Council was established. The same is against Public Policy and liable to be struck down and the High Court of Orrisa rightly gave decision in favour of the respondent in the instant appeal.
n. That the Intervenor/applicants though were appointed as researcher but along with that they have been performing duties of doctors like treating patient in OPD, IPD etc. and for which requisite certificate was issued to them time to time.
ANALYSIS
22. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through materials placed on record the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment?
23. The appellant Council is an autonomous body registered under the Society Registration Act, 1860 and is administratively controlled by the Ministry of AYUSH, Government of India. It is a body constituted for the purpose of undertaking, cooperating, formulating, developing and promoting the research on scientific guidelines in Ayurvedic Sciences. The recruitment rules, procedure and the service conditions of these employees are governed by the Bye-Laws and Memorandum of Association of the Council.
24. With a view to appreciate the rival contentions raised by the litigating parties before us, we must look into the Clauses 25(b), 34, 35 and 47 of the Bye-Laws in the Memorandum of Association of the Central Council for Research in Ayurvedic Sciences:
“Appointments
25. (a)...
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.