C.P. Francis v. C.P. Joseph and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1071; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 645
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Justice Sarasa Venkatanarayana Bhatti
- Decided
- 3 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11369/2025
- Sections
- 100(5), 67, 5, 100, 141, 63
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 645 : 2025 INSC 1071 C.P. Francis v.
C.P. Joseph and Others (Civil Appeal No. 11369 of 2025)
03 September 2025 [Ahsanuddin Amanullah and S.V.N. Bhatti,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court, while invoking the Proviso to s.100(5), CPC, was correct in referring to and applying s.67, Indian Succession Act, 1925; whether s.67, Indian Succession Act, 1925 is attracted to determine the succession to the suit schedule property or not. Headnotes† Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – s.100(5) – Indian Succession Act, 1925 – s.67 – High Court allowed the second appeal on an additional question of law framed without any basis in the pleadings or evidence and relying on s.67, Indian Succession Act, the Will (Exhibit B-3) was declared as a void bequest in favour of the Appellant – Challenge to:
Held: 1.1 High Court is competent and endowed with discretionary jurisdiction to formulate a substantial question of law not stated when the second appeal was admitted – It is entitled to formulate an additional substantial question of law for reasons to be recorded if it is of the view that the case involves such a question of law – The proviso to sub-section 5 of s.100, CPC comes into operation in exceptional cases, albeit for strong and convincing reasons to be specifically recorded by the High Court. [Para 19] 1.2 Further, the plea needed for invoking s.67 either by choice or inadvertence, was not pleaded by Respondents – The plaint referred to the will and the allegation that “since the will executed by fraud and misrepresentation upon the ailed mother and forced upon the ailed father, it carries no legal validity, and it is to be neglected” – The plea u/s.67 can be an additional or alternative plea, which would have resulted into an additional issue, and an establishment of a relationship, where one of the attestors to the legatee of the will would have fallen for consideration – Introducing * Author 646 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports s.67 at the stage of Second Appeal does not merely raise a new legal argument; rather, it creates an entirely new case for the plaintiffs. [Paras 19, 20] 1.3 The original case required the defendant to prove the testators’ mental capacity and also the absence of suspicious circumstances in bringing into existence Exhibit B-3 – A case u/s.67 would require the Appellant to meet a completely different legal challenge, one which is based on the identity of an attesting witness and the legal consequences arising from the said identity – The evidence of DW1, the propounder of Exhibit B-3, and DW5, an attesting witness to Exhibit B-3 is bereft of at least a suggestion that would be expected in a matter as serious as the present. [Paras 20, 22] 1.4 The Court has power and jurisdiction to suit or non-suit a party on the adduced pleadings, issues and evidence, but not on a totally new and unexpected case, more particularly at the stage of s.100 – The root of the matter is fundamentally anchored to the specific cause of action and the factual matrix pleaded by the parties. [Para 22] 1.5 From the beginning, the plaintiffs’ case was built on a factual challenge; wherein, they contended that the testators lacked a sound disposing state of mind, and the will was a product of forgery, misrepresentation, and undue influence – These two aspects have been successfully established by the Appellant, and the findings favour the Appellant. [Para 22] 1.6 Thus, in the circumstances of this case, the High Court fell in error by not recording reasons for framing the additional substantial question of law – An additional substantial question of law was framed without pleadings, issues and reasons and a finding was recorded – The will was duly executed and proved, however was not given effect to by applying s.67 – The point is answered in favour of the Appellant – Impugned judgment set aside. [Para 23] 1.7 In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, point no. 2 is not examined and answered – Exhibit B-3 stipulated a few obligations for discharge by the Appellant – Appellant has neither deposited nor paid the amount directed in Exhibit B-3 to any of the other beneficiaries – The parents made a contemporaneous arrangement in bequeathing the suit schedule to the Appellant – The testamentary succession finally opens through the present adjudication, and therefore, Appellant to compensate the other legatees, as directed. [Para 23] [2025] 9 S.C.R. 647C.P. Francis v. C.P. Joseph and Others Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – s.100(5) – Framing of additional substantial question of law – Principles for, stated. [Paras 18-18.6] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.141 – Leading question – Suggestion in oral evidence of a party – Importance – Summarised.
[Para 21-21.3] Case Law Cited Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari [2001] 1 SCR 948 : (2001) 3 SCC 179; Mehboob-Ur-Rehman v. Ahsanul Ghani [2019] 2 SCR 169 : (2019) 19 SCC 415; Gian Dass v. Gram Panchayat [2006] Supp. 3 SCR 781 : (2006) 6 SCC 271; Kirpa Ram v. Surendra Deo Gaur [2020] 13 SCR 1030 : (2021) 13 SCC 57; Kshitish Chandra Purkait v. Santosh Kumar Purkait [1997] Supp. 1 SCR 201 : (1997) 5 SCC 438; R. Nagraj (Dead) through LRs. and Anr. v. Rajmani and Ors., 2025 INSC 478 : [2025] 4 SCR 734; Suresh Lataruji Ramteke v. Sumanbai Pandurang Petkar [2023] 12 SCR 488 : (2023) 17 SCC 624 – relied on.
Laxmibai v. Bhagwantbuva [2013] 1 SCR 632 : AIR 2013 SC 1204; Gnanambal Ammal v. T. Raju Ayyar [1950] 1 SCR 949 : (1950) SCC 978; K.S. Palanisami v. Hindu Community in General & Citizens of Gobichettipalayam [2017] 4 SCR 511 : (2017) 13 SCC 15 – referred to.
Yeshpal Jashbhai Parikh (Original Accused) v. Rasiklal Umedchand Parikh (Original Complainant, Opponent, 1955 AIR BOM 318; Radha Kishan Aggarwal v. Network Ltd., 2011 SCC OnLine DEL 3896; JS Bhalla v. GJ Bhawnani, 23 (1983) DLT 125 – referred to. Browne v. Dunn (1893) 6 R 67 – referred to.
List of Acts Indian Succession Act, 1925; Civil Procedure Code, 1908; Evidence Act, 1872; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Proviso to Section 100(5), CPC; Additional substantial question of law; Additional question of law framed without any basis in pleadings or evidence; Testamentary succession; Will; Plaint schedule 648 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports properties; Succession to suit schedule property; Will duly executed and proved; Testators’ sound disposing state of mind; Section 67, Indian Succession Act, 1925; Testators; Testators’ mental capacity; Absence of suspicious circumstances; Will not a product of forgery, misrepresentation, and undue influence; Admission; Partition; Intestate succession; Forgery; Misrepresentation; Undue influence; Admission in pleading and evidence; Bequeath; Void bequest; Settlement deed; Void; Fraud; Suggestion in oral evidence; Leading question.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11369 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.01.2025 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in RSA No. 94 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
V. Chitambaresh, Sr. Adv., Sarath S. Janardanan, S.K. Adhithyan, Mrs. Vishnupriya P. Govind.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Mathai M. Paikaday, Sr. Adv., Shishir Pinaki, Philip Mathai Paikaday, A.B. Jaleel, Ms. Nazlin Jaleel, Nijaz Jaleel, Akshay Sahay, Ms. Shradha Narayan.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment S.V.N. Bhatti, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. CR Pius and Philomina Pius possessed, as absolute owners, an extent of 7.875 cents of property in survey no. 60/6 of Elamkulam village and 3.233 cents in survey no. 60/6 of Elamkulam village, Kanyanoor Taluk, Ernakulam District, as described in plaint A and B schedules. On 24.11.2004, CR Pius died. On 27.11.2008, Philomina Pius died. The children/grandchildren of Pius and Philomina are the parties to the present litigation, and their genealogy is illustrated as follows: [2025] 9 S.C.R. 649C.P. Francis v. C.P. Joseph and Others Philomina Pius (co-testatrix)
Died on 24.11.2008 C.R. Pius (co-testator)
Died on 24.11.2004 C.P. Francis - Appellant/ Defendant No.1(DW-1)
C.P.
Joseph R1/P1 (DW-3 - Scribe)
C.P.
Raphel - R2/ P2 C.P.
George - R3/ P3 C.P.
Sebastian - R4/P4 (PW-1)
Desty Thomas - (R5/ P5)
Clara Jacob - R6 Mariya (Deceased)
Kavita Antony - R7/ Defendant no.3 Savitha Sachin- R8/ Defendant no.4
3. On 15.12.1999, Philomina Pius executed a registered settlement deed in favour of CP Sebastian/Fourth Plaintiff, whereunder, she has settled an extent of 4 cents out of 7 cents in favour of the fourth plaintiff and retained 3.235 cents (Plaint B Schedule). Pius, admittedly, has been the absolute owner and possessor of Plaint A schedule property. On 27.01.2003, CR Pius and Philomina Pius executed the registered joint will in favour of CP Francis/Appellant for the Plaint A and B schedule properties. Antony (DW6), husband of Kavitha Antony/Defendant No. 3, and Ponsy (DW5), wife of Appellant, have subscribed their signatures as attestors. The salient features of the will dated 27.01.2003 are noted as follows:
3.1 All three daughters have been given their share and married off. The fourth plaintiff was given 4 cents of the land as per the settlement deed dated 15.12.1999. Hence, they are not entitled to any right in the plaint schedule.
3.2 The properties in the plaint schedule A will be bequeathed to D1 after the death of one of the testators, and after the death of the second testator, properties in the plaint schedule B will be bequeathed to the Appellant.
3.3 That Appellant has to pay Rs.1,00,000/- to Maria, Rs. 50,000/- to daughter Thresia, Rs. 50,000/- to daughter Clara, Rs. 1,00,000/to Son Joseph, Rs. 1,00,000/- to son Raphael, and Rs. 1,00,000/to son George, within 5 years of death of both the parents. Reportedly, if the said amount is not paid to the respective 650 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports children, they can have a charge on the schedule properties to recover the amounts.
4. Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 in the Civil Appeal filed OS No. 722/2009 before the Munsiff Court, Ernakulam, against the Appellant and three others for the reliefs of partition of the plaint schedule properties into eight equal shares by meets and bounds and allotment of 1/8th share to each one of the children of Pius and Philomina. The plaint prays for the perpetual injunction restraining the Appellant from alienating the property or creating third-party interests.
5. OS No. 722/2009 was dismissed on 03.09.2011. Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 filed AS No. 6 of 2012, and the learned Additional District Judge vide the decree and judgment dated 26.08.2013 dismissed the appeal. Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 filed RSA No. 94/2014 before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam. Through the impugned judgment, the second appeal was allowed, and hence, the Civil Appeal was filed at the instance of the 1 st defendant. The impugned judgment placed reliance on Section 67 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (‘the Act’). It allowed the appeal by recording a finding that one of the attesting witnesses/Ponsy (DW5) is the wife of the Appellant, and consequently, by operation of Section 67 of the Act, the testamentary succession in favour of Appellant, being void, fails as a testamentary succession.
6. We have heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. V. Chitambaresh and Mr. Mathai M. Paikaday, and the Learned Counsel Mr. Akshay Sahay for the Appellant and Respondents.
7. It is argued for the Appellant that the impugned judgment exceeded the jurisdictional limitation of Section 100 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (‘the CPC’).
7.1 The second appeal was admitted on the substantial questions of law raised in the memorandum of appeal. However, the second appeal has been allowed on an additional question of law framed by the Court, which reads as follows:
“Whether Ext. A4/B3 Will is void under Section 67 of the Indian Succession Act in view of the attestation of the same, who is the first defendant, and, DW6, who is the husband of the third defendant, since benefits are reserved in the said Will in favour of those defendants?”
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 651C.P. Francis v. C.P. Joseph and Others 7.2 The impugned judgment refers to an opportunity of further hearing given to the counsel on the additional question of law framed by the Court. According to him, the same should not have been at the first instance framed or answered. To be precise, the additional question of law was framed without any basis in the pleadings or evidence, and was not even put as a suggestion to the witnesses. The parties to the litigation are brothers and sisters. Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 have chosen to regulate the succession to Plaint A and B schedule properties from testamentary to intestate succession. The emphasis was on the capacity of late Pius and Philomina in executing a valid and binding will regulating the succession to the scheduled properties. Therefore, the Appellant was invited to join issue on the proof of Exhibits B-2 and B-3. The Appellant discharged the burden to claim testamentary succession to the suit properties. The findings of fact on valid execution and sound disposing state of testators are concurrent findings of fact by all three courts. The High Court relied on Section 67 of the Act and declared Exhibit B-3 as a void bequest in favour of the Appellant. The High Court’s findings grant a new prayer based on an entirely new reasoning. In this light, it is contended that Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 have chosen a plea, namely, that the testators were not having a sound disposing state of mind, and that the registered will dated 27.01.2003 is not out of their free will. The impugned judgment, adverting to a new case, ought not to have ignored the validly executed and proved will. An argument has been advanced on the interpretation of Section 67, and also that the grounds available to challenge Section 67 of the Act as violative of equality of law and equal protection of law under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The courts are under an obligation to give effect to the disposition contemplated by the testator once the execution of the will dated 27.01.2003 is proved in accordance with law. He prays for the setting aside of the impugned judgment.
8. Mr. Mathai M. Paikaday, appearing for Respondent Nos. 1 to 5, contends that though the impugned judgment refers to an additional question of law, it is, in fact, a substantial question of law framed by the High Court under Section 100(5) of the CPC. The impugned judgment records that further opportunity was afforded to the parties 652 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to address the Court on the additional question of law framed by the Court. There is substantial compliance with Section 100 of the CPC. He further argues, to sustain the findings recorded on the additional question of law, that the finding is not based on an incorrect plea or fact. There is no gainsaying that DW5 is the wife of the Appellant, and pleadings and issues are absent on the applicability of Section 67 of the Act. A plain reading of Section 67 makes the bequest in favour of the Appellant void. Section 67 has been on the statute book for 100 years, and the effect of being void once the circumstances are satisfied has stood the test of time. The learned senior counsel argues that the points urged by the Appellant do not fall within the ambit of Article 136 of the Constitution of India, much as the succession to the suit schedule is guided by intestate succession and all the children of Pius and Philomina would be entitled to a 1/8 th share. Advocate Akshay Sahay, appearing for Respondents, adopts the argument of the Appellant and contends that the other attesting witness is also the son-in-law of the executants of the will. The wish and desire of the testators must be respected, and the opening of intestate succession would defeat the last wish of late Pius and late Philomina.
9. We have taken note of the submissions and perused the record. Before we take up the submissions of the learned counsel, we preface the journey of the parties in the present litigation by setting out the pleadings and the resulting issues between the parties.
10. The plaint in OS No. 722 of 2009 is summarised by retaining the cause pleaded by Respondent Nos. 1 to 6:
10.1 The plaintiffs sought partition of the properties into eight equal shares, along with a permanent prohibitory injunction against alienation. The plaintiffs contend that, though the deed dated 15.12.1999 was styled as a settlement deed, it was expanded for the marriage of two sisters. The plaintiffs assert that their father, C.R. Pius, suffered from physical and mental ailments, including cerebral palsy, senile changes, and Parkinson’s disease, from 1998 until his death, rendering him mentally incapable of making rational decisions. They, hence, state that the said will carries no legal validity, as the first defendant, his wife and the third defendant’s husband misrepresented the mother.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 653C.P. Francis v. C.P. Joseph and Others 10.2 They note that the joint will was falsely created and forged by the first defendant, his wife (DW5), and the husband of the third defendant (DW6) through misrepresentation and undue influence over their incapacitated father and elderly mother. They claimed the mother was too old to understand the document properly.
10.3 The plaintiffs asserted that their parents died intestate, and therefore, all children held joint ownership and possession of the plaint schedule properties. The defendants are trying to alienate the property on the basis of the alleged will, ignoring the plaintiffs’ 1/8 th share each in the plaint schedule properties. Furthermore, the plaintiffs are not interested in continuing with joint possession and therefore seek partition.
10.4 The plaintiffs alleged that the cause of action arose on 24.11.2004 (father’s death) and 27.11.2008 (mother’s death).
11. The first defendant, to resist the claim of intestate succession, has set up Exhibit B-2, a registered settlement deed. The pleadings in the written statement are summarised as follows:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.