Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 834; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 34
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice K. Vinod Chandran
- Decided
- 14 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9471/2025
- Sections
- 96C, 264, 266, 26(1), 8(1), 12
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 34 : 2025 INSC 834 Mandeep Singh & Ors.
v.
State of Punjab and Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 9471 of 2025)
14 July 2025 [Sudhanshu Dhulia* and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The matter pertains to legality of recruitment/selection of Assistant Professors and Librarians in Government Degree colleges of Punjab. The Division Bench of the High Court has reversed the findings of the Single Judge and has thereby upheld the selections made by the State. Whether there is a gross illegality in the recruitment process.
Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art.320 – Punjab Public Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1955 – UGC (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and Other Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher Education)
Regulations, 2010 – Recruitment – Legality of recruitment of Assistant Professors and Librarians, in Government Degree Colleges in the State – The Single Judge of the High Court quashed the entire recruitment process for being in violation of law inasmuch as the Commission not having been excluded as per procedure prescribed and State having not followed the UGC guidelines and adopting an arbitrary process for the recruitment – In intra-court appeals, vide the impugned order dated 23.09.2024, the Division Bench of the High Court upheld the recruitment by quashing the order passed by the Single Judge of the High Court – Correctness:
Held: In the present case, the State has miserably failed to justify the departure from the standard norms of the recruitment process – There is a gross illegality in the recruitment process – Art.320(3) of the Constitution provides that the Commission shall be consulted * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 35Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. in the recruitment of different services – This Court in Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, had recognised the importance of Regulations framed under the proviso to Art.320(3) of the Constitution and had cautioned against the casual bypassing of the Regulations – In the case at hand, Regulations as contemplated under the Proviso were already in existence in Punjab known as Punjab Public Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1955 – The posts of Assistant Professors and Librarians in Degree Colleges were within the purview of the Commission – Thus, selection of these posts was within the purview of the State Commission, and it was mandatory that it ought to be consulted – The respondents have tried to meet this deficiency by stating that the State had amended the 1955 Regulations in March 2022 (by retrospective effect), by mentioning these posts in the 1955 Regulations and these posts were then taken out from the purview of Commission – However, the amendment was made after concluding the entire recruitment process and giving appointment letters to the selected candidates – It was hence a post facto exercise – The 1955 Regulations prescribed a procedure under which posts within the purview of the Commission could be withdrawn – It is admitted that in the present case the required procedure was not followed – In case the State government was dissatisfied with the manner in which the Commission was conducting the recruitment ought to have followed the due procedure and withdrawn the posts from the purview of the Commission in accordance with the 1955 Regulations – As far as UGC Regulations are concerned, a method of selection to these posts is also provided in the 2010 UGC Regulations which has not been followed in the present case – Besides that, there are multiple deficiencies – The giving away of a rigorous criteria laid down in the UGC regulations with a single, multiple-choice question based written test, and the complete elimination of the viva-voce, all establish the arbitrary nature of the exercise which cannot pass the test of reasonableness laid down u/Art.14 of the Constitution – Hence, the Single Judge had rightly struck down the entire selection process, and the Division Bench of the High Court erred in interfering with that conclusion. [Paras 9, 24, 25, 26, 28, 31, 40, 56, 59, 60] UGC Act, 1956 – UGC Regulations of 2010 – UGC Regulations 2018 – The distinction between adoption by incorporation as opposed to reference – Discussed:
36 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: The distinction here is that in case of adoption by incorporation, the subsequent amendment or repeal of the incorporated statute will be of no consequences on the incorporation – The adoption then becomes frozen at the point in time when the incorporation was made – But the question whether a provision of law is adopted by reference or incorporation also depends upon the language of the order/statute in which such provision is being adopted – It may also depend upon the conduct of the State and how it has been recognised and accepted in that State – 2018 UGC Regulations may have repealed the 2010 UGC Regulations but still they were being considered and recognised in the State of Punjab for all purposes, even after its repeal – In the instant case, this Court has already referred the order dated 30.07.2013 whereby the State Government had adopted 2010 Regulations and the reasons assigned by the State Government in doing so which was to uplift the standard of higher education. [Para 38] Constitution of India – Art.320(3) – Art.320(3)(a) – Nature and Scope:
Held: Art.320(3) speaks of a variety of matters where the Commission is to be consulted- (a) Recruitment in Service and
(c) disciplinary matters, being two such instances – Whereas Art.320(3)(c) is generally concerned with individual matters relating to disciplinary proceedings, Art.320(3)(a) deals with policy issues where an entire recruitment process is at stake. [Para 20] Constitution of India – Art.14 – Duties and Responsibilities of State and its instrumentality:
Held: The State and its instrumentalities have a duty and responsibility to act fairly and reasonably in terms of the mandate of Art.14 of the Constitution – Any decision taken by the State must be reasoned, and not arbitrary – This Court has consistently held that when a thing is done in a post-haste manner, mala fides would be presumed, and further that anything done in undue haste can also be termed as arbitrary and cannot be condoned in law – In the present case there are multiple deficiencies, as stated above – The giving away of a rigorous criteria laid down in the UGC regulations with a single, multiple-choice question based written test, and the complete elimination of the viva-voce, all establish the arbitrary nature of the exercise which cannot pass the test of reasonableness [2025] 8 S.C.R. 37Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. laid down under Art.14 of the Constitution – Hence, the Single Judge had rightly struck down the entire selection process, and the Division Bench of the High Court erred in interfering with that conclusion. [Paras 52, 56] Public Service Commissions – Purpose, Role and Evolution in India – Discussed. [Paras 8-16] Case Law Cited Sivanandan C.T. v. High Court of Kerala [2023] 11 SCR 674 : (2024) 3 SCC 799 – followed.
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. Union of India [1979] 2 SCR 1038 : (1979) 2 SCC 529; Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India [1979] 3 SCR 1014 : (1979) 3 SCC 489; Gambhirdan K. Gadhvi v. State of Gujarat [2022] 4 SCR 406 : (2022) 5 SCC 179; State of T.N. v. Adhiyaman Educational & Research Institute [1995] 2 SCR 1075 : (1995) 4 SCC 104; Fuljit Kaur v. State of Punjab [2010] 7 SCR 317 : (2010) 11 SCC 455; Bahadursinh Lakhubhai Gohil v. Jagdishbhai M. Kamalia [2003] Supp. 6 SCR 1023 : (2004) 2 SCC 65; Zenit Mataplast (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra [2009] 14 SCR 403 : (2009) 10 SCC 388; Bannari Amman Sugars Ltd. v. CTO [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 264 : (2005) 1 SCC 625 – relied on.
State of U.P v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava [1958] 1 SCR 533 : 1957 SCC OnLine SC 4; Kalyani Mathivanan v. KV Jeyaraj & Ors. [2015] 3 SCR 467: (2015) 6 SCC 363; Cherukuri Mani v. Chief Secretary, Govt of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. [2014] 6 SCR 750 : (2015) 13 SCC 722; Dharmin Bai Kashyap v. Babli Sahu [2023] 11 SCR 150 : (2023) 10 SCC 461; Babu Verghese & Ors. v. Bar Council of India & Ors. [1999] 1 SCR 1121 : (1999) 3 SCC 422 – referred to.
Nazir Ahmed v. King-Emperor (LR 63 IA 372) – referred to. Books and Periodicals Cited Dr. Naresh Chandra Roy, The Working of the Public Service Commission in Bengal, Indian Political Science Conference, Third Session, Mysore, Dec 1940, p.192; Macaulay Committee Report; Lee Commission in its report of 1924; Simon Commission Report. 38 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Constitution of India; Government of India Act, 1919; Public Service Commission (Function) Rules, 1926; Government of India Act, 1935; UGC Act, 1956; Punjab Public Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1955; UGC (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and Other Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher Education) Regulations, 2010; UGC Regulations, 2018; Punjab Educational Service (College Cadre) (Class II) Rules, 1976. List of Keywords Service Law; Recruitment/selection of Assistant Professors and Librarians; Duties and Responsibilities of State and its instrumentality; Public Service Commissions; Departmental Selection Committee; Article 320(3) & Article 320(3)(a) of Constitution; Distinction between adoption by incorporation as opposed to reference; Departure from the standard norms of the recruitment.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9471 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.09.2024 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in LPA No. 89 of 2023 With Civil Appeal No(s). 9472 and 9473 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Mrs. Rekha Palli, Sr. Adv., Preetesh Kapur, Sr. Adv, Nidhesh Gupta, Sr. Adv., Raju Ramachandran, Sr. Adv., Chritarth Palli, Vivek Sharma, Rajat Gupta, Mrs. Harsheen Madan Palli, Agam Aggarwal, Karan Dewan, Miss Aanchal Jain, Ms. Anindita Mitra, Vivek Sharma, Rajiv Sethi, Ms. Aditi Gupta.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Shadan Farasat, Sr.Adv./A.A.G., Vivek Jain, A.A.G., Kapil Sibal, Rakesh Dwivedi, Paramjit Singh Patwalia, Sr. Advs., Vikrant Pachnanda, Avinit Avasthi, Rishabh Parikh, Mukul Katyal, Yasir Saifi, Talha Abdul Rahman, M Shaz Khan, Sudhanshu Tewari, Rafid Akhter, Faizan Ahmad, Mohit D. Ram, Anup Jain, Ms. Nayan Gupta. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 39Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sudhanshu Dhulia, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The appellants before this Court have challenged the judgment dated 23.09.2024, of the Division Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court which has reversed the findings of the learned Single Judge and has thereby upheld the selections made by the State of Punjab for the posts of Assistant Professors and Librarians in Government Degree colleges of Punjab.
3. The brief facts of the case are as follows:
a. In January 2021, the State of Punjab had sent separate requisitions to the Punjab Public Service Commission (hereinafter referred to as ‘Commission’), for recruitment of 931 Assistant Professors (dated 15.01.2021) and 50 Librarians (dated 29.01.2021), in Government Degree Colleges in the State. Consequent to this and based on correspondences exchanged, the Commission engaged 24 subject experts to prepare the syllabus for the competitive examinations and honorarium was paid to them. b. Later, an additional 160 posts of Assistant Professors and 17 posts for Librarians were created and sanctioned for newly established colleges, and on 15.09.2021, the State’s Department of Higher Education (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Department’) sought Commission’s consent to fill these posts through the Departmental Selection Committee rather than the Commission.
c. The Commission replied by letter dated 16.09.2021, expressing their inability to respond on the ground of the Chairman having retired and the new appointment having not taken place. The Government then by a memorandum dated 17.09.2021 approved the recruitment of 160 and 17 posts of Assistant Professors and Librarians respectively, through Departmental Selection Committees which though had to follow the University Grants Commission (hereinafter ‘UGC’) guidelines or regulations. 40 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports d. A change in Government happened on 20.09.2021 after which on 09.10.2021, the selection process was reviewed in a meeting chaired by the Secretary, Department of Higher Education. In this meeting, the entire process of recruitment was changed and it was decided that selection would now be made only on the basis of a Written Test, which will be conducted by two separate selection committees of two State Universities:
(a) Punjab University, Patiala, and (b) the Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar. Further, it was decided that all the 1091 posts (931 plus 160 posts) of Assistant Professors and 67 posts (50 plus 17 posts) of Librarians; and not just the posts recently created, are to be filled through these departmental selection committees. This decision was placed for approval before the Chief Minister on 12.10.2021, with the observation that it shall subsequently be placed for approval before the Council of Ministers; latter approval was never obtained.
e. On 18.10.2021, Government issued a memorandum conveying to Director Public Instructions (Colleges) (hereinafter ‘DPI’) the decision for recruitment of 1091 Assistant Professors and 67 Librarians on the basis of two departmental selection committees of two State Universities. On 19.10.2021, advertisements for the above posts were issued.
f. In a little over a month, the exam was conducted and the result was announced on 28.11.2021. Meanwhile, in the first week of November, Writ Petitions were filed before the High Court, challenging the memorandum dated 18.10.2021 and advertisements dated 19.10.2021. On 26.11.2021 in CWP No. 22446 of 2021, before the results were published, while issuing notice, it was clarified that the selection shall be subject to the result of the writ petition.
g. Vide order dated 08.08.2022, the learned Single Judge allowed the Writ Petitions and quashed the entire recruitment process for being in violation of law inasmuch as the Commission not having been excluded as per procedure prescribed and State having not followed the UGC guidelines and adopting an arbitrary process for the recruitment.
h. Against the order of the learned Single Judge, the State of Punjab as well as the candidates who were selected/appointed [2025] 8 S.C.R. 41Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. filed intra-court appeals. Vide the impugned order dated 23.09.2024, the Division Bench of the High Court allowed these intra-court appeals and upheld the recruitment by quashing the order passed by the learned Single Judge. Assailing the same, appellants are before us.
4. Before the learned Single Judge, the Division Bench as well as before this Court, the appellants’ have been consistent in their submission that the recruitment process was vitiated on more than one count. Most importantly the recruitment was made in violation of UGC Regulations of 2010 (hereinafter ‘2010 UGC Regulations’) which were adopted by the State of Punjab on 30.07.2013, and which mandated an entirely different criterion and procedure for recruitment. Further the selection to these posts ought to have been made through the Commission, as admittedly these were the posts within the purview of Commission [under Article 320 of the Constitution of India read with Punjab Public Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1955 (hereinafter ‘the 1955 Regulations’)]. In any case, the entire process is arbitrary and was followed not in the interest of the State or for the cause of higher education but for narrow political gains.
5. The State and the private respondents would though argue that Article 320(3) is directory and not mandatory in nature. They would submit that the State government is empowered to decide its own method and procedure of recruitment for the posts of Assistant Professors and Librarians in Degree colleges under the State government; and it is not bound to make these selections through the Commission.
6. We have heard Senior Advocates Mr. Raju Ramchandran, Mr. Nidhesh Gupta, Mr. Preetesh Kapur and Mrs. Rekha Palli appearing for the appellants, and Senior Advocates Mr. Kapil Sibal, Mr. Rakesh Dwivedi and Mr. P.S. Patwalia for the private respondents. We have also heard Mr. Shadan Farasat, Additional Advocate-General appearing on behalf of the State of Punjab.
7. It is first necessary to narrate the sequence of events and their context as this would give us a better perspective. A large number of posts of Assistant Professor and Librarians in Degree Colleges remained unfilled for the last 20 years or so in Punjab. The last selection to these posts was only made in the year 2002, and this too got into trouble due to allegations of corruption which led to a 42 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports protracted litigation. Later, another recruitment was attempted in the year 2008 for 265 posts which was again stuck in litigation for many years. The issue of large unfilled vacancies in Punjab had come earlier before this Court by the guest/part-time faculties where a Three-Judge Bench of this Court vide its order dated 02.12.2014 had directed the Commission to fill the sanctioned vacant posts as soon as possible. The relevant portion of that order reads as under: “4. We do not intend to keep these Special Leave Petitions on board. Accordingly, we dispose of the Special Leave Petitions with an observation that the Punjab Public Service Commission, Patiala will take all effective steps to fill up all the sanctioned posts of the lecturers in the State of Punjab as expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within 12 months’ time from today.”
The argument of the State is that the main reason for these vacancies remaining unfilled for all these years was that these posts were within the purview of the Commission which had failed to fill these posts and hence the decision taken by the State to remove these posts from the purview of the Commission and to expedite the process of selection was in public interest.
8. The Commission has a duty to make selections for different services in response to the requisition of the State government. In the present case, in January 2021, the State government had sent two requisitions for the recruitment of 931 Assistant Professors and 50 Librarians respectively, yet no decision had been taken by the Commission.
9. Article 320(3) of the Constitution provides that the Commission shall be consulted in the recruitment of different services. The relevant portion of Article 320 of the Constitution reads as follows: “Article 320: Functions of Public Service Commissions- (1)...
(2)...
(3) The Union Public Service Commission or the State Public Service Commission, as the case may be, shall be consulted— [2025] 8 S.C.R. 43Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors.
(a) on all matters relating to methods of recruitment to civil services and for civil posts;
(b) on the principles to be followed in making appointments to civil services and posts and in making promotions and transfers from one service to another and on the suitability of candidates for such appointments, promotions or transfers;
(c) on all disciplinary matters affecting a person serving under the Government of India or the Government of a State in a civil capacity, including memorials or petitions relating to such matters;
(d) on any claim by or in respect of a person who is serving or has served under the Government of India or the Government of a State or under the Crown in India or under the Government of an Indian State, in a civil capacity, that any costs incurred by him in defending legal proceedings instituted against him in respect of acts done or purporting to be done in the execution of his duty should be paid out of the Consolidated Fund of India, or, as the case may be, out of the Consolidated Fund of the State;
(e) on any claim for the award of a pension in respect of injuries sustained by a person while serving under the Government of India or the Government of a State or under the Crown in India or under the Government of an Indian State, in a civil capacity, and any question as to the amount of any such award, and it shall be the duty of a Public Service Commission to advise on any matter so referred to them and on any other matter which the President, or, as the case may be, the Governor of the State, may refer to them:
Provided that the President as respects the all-India services and also as respects other services and posts in connection with the affairs of the Union, and the Governor, as respects other services and posts in connection with the affairs of a State, may make regulations specifying the matters in which either generally, or in any particular 44 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports class of case or in any particular circumstances, it shall not be necessary for a Public Service Commission to be consulted.”
Public Service Commission at the Union and at the State levels are constitutional bodies. There is a purpose for which these institutions have been created, which we shall discuss in a while. All the same, it is not necessary that all posts in the States or Union must be filled through Commission. It is not mandatory. But there is a method prescribed under the law to take out these posts from the purview of the Commission. This has been violated in the present case; is the argument. But first, for the role of the Commission.
10. Impartiality, fairness and recognition of merit while selecting Public Servants are absolutely necessary in modern democracies. The basic purpose of a Union Public Service Commission or State Public Service Commission(s) for that matter, is to remove impartiality and political influence while making selection on Public Posts. It is necessary to have an impartial Public Service Commission in a Democracy, or everything will be reduced to a mere scramble for jobs 1 . The concept is not new. It goes back to the Government of India Act, 1919, and even earlier to the pre 1857 era. The East India Company, which had under its administration a vast area, felt the need to replace the system based on recommendations and nominations to a meritbased system, which was also the recommendation of the Macaulay Committee Report2 . A Civil Service Commission was then established in 1854 to conduct competitive examinations which were held for the first time in the year 1855.
11. It was the Government of India Act, 1919 that formally introduced the concept of Public Service Commissions in India. Section 96C 3 provided for the establishment of a Central Public Service 1 Dr. Naresh Chandra Roy, The Working of the Public Service Commission in Bengal, Indian Political Science Conference, Third Session, Mysore, Dec 1940, p.192. 2 See Macaulay Report on the Indian Civil Service 1854. 3 Section 96C: Public Service Commission- (1) There shall be established in India a public service commission, consisting of not more than five members, of whom one shall be chairman, appointed by the Secretary of State in Council. Each member shall be removed before the expiry of his term of office, except by order of the Secretary of State in Council. The qualifications for the appointment, and the pay and pension (if any) attaching to the office of chairman and member, shall be prescribed by rules made by the Secretary of State in Council.
(2) The public service commission shall discharge, in regard to recruitment and control of the public services in India, such functions as may be assigned thereto by rules made by the Secretary of State in Council [2025] 8 S.C.R. 45Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. Commission in India. But the Public Service Commission was not set up immediately till its need was emphasized by the Lee Commission in its report of 1924:
“Wherever democratic institutions exist, experience has shown that to secure an efficient Civil Service it is essential to protect it so far as possible from political or personal influences and to give it that position of stability and security which is vital to its successful working as the impartial and efficient instrument by which Governments, of whatever political complexion, may give effect to their policies. In countries where this principle has been neglected, and where the “spoils system” has taken place, an inefficient and disorganized Civil Service has been the inevitable result and corruption has been rampant. In America a Civil Service Commission has been constituted to control recruitment of the Services, but, for the purposes of India it is from the Dominions of the British Empire that more relevant and useful lessons can perhaps be drawn.
Canada, Australia and South Africa now possess Public or Civil Services Acts regulating the position and control of the Public Services, and a common feature of them all is the constitution of a Public Service Commission, to which the duty of administering the Acts is entrusted. It was this need which framers of the Government of India Act had in mind when they made provision in Section 96C for the establishment of a Public Service Commission to discharge “in regard to recruitment and control of the Public Services in India such functions as may be assigned thereto by rules made by the Secretary of State in Council”. Since the passing of the Act, a prolonged correspondence, extending over nearly four years, has been passed between the Secretary of State, the Government of India, and Local Governments, regarding the function and machinery of the body to be set up. No decisions have, however, been arrived at, and the subject has been referred to this Commission for consideration”4 4 Report of the Royal Commission on Superior Civil Services in India, dated 27th March, 1924 at pp.13-14 and 16.
46 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
12. It was based on the recommendation of the Lee Commission that the Commission was formed as contemplated under the Government of India Act, 1919. The Central Public Service Commission was thus established in the year 1926, and its functions were governed by the Public Service Commission (Function) Rules, 1926. Till this stage, the role of a similar Commission at Provincial level was not much in discussions.
13. It was only with the Simon Commission Report that we have an official recommendation for the first time for the setting up of Provincial Public Service Commissions. It is well-known that the formation of the Simon Commission was resented by the leaders of the Indian freedom struggle, primarily because it had no Indian representative, and because senior officials of the British Raj had questioned the very ability of Indians to draft a Constitution. In response, an all-party committee under the chairmanship of Congress stalwart Motilal Nehru was formed, which was tasked with drafting a Constitution for India. The report submitted by this committee (which came to be known as the Nehru Report) also favoured the creation of a Permanent Public Service Commission to deal with issues such as the recruitment, appointment, emoluments etc. of civil servants in India.
14. Finally, a Federal Public Service Commission and Public Service Commissions for Provinces were established under Section 264 5 of the Government of India Act, 1935 and their functions were given in Section 266, which was pari materia to Article 320 of the Constitution.
15. While the Constituent Assembly was busy in drafting the Constitution for free India, the Public Service Commission at the Centre and in some of the States were already functioning.
5 264. Public Service Commission: (1) Subject to the provisions of this Section, there shall be a Public Service Commission for the Federation and a Public Service Commission for each Province.
(2) Two or more Provinces may agree-
(a) that there shall be one Public Service Commission for that group of Provinces; or
(b) that the Public Service Commission for one of the Provinces shall serve the needs of all the Provinces, and any such agreement may contain such incidental and consequential provisions as may appear necessary or desirable for giving effect to the purposes of the agreement and shall, in the case of an agreement that there shall be one Commission for a group of Provinces, specify by what Governor or Governors the functions which are under this Part of this Act to be discharged by the Governor of a Province are to be discharged.
(3) The Public Service Commission for the Federation, if requested so to do by the Governor of a Province, may, with the approval of the Governor-General, agree to serve all or any of the needs of the Province… [2025] 8 S.C.R. 47Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors.
16. During discussion on Public Service Commissions in the Constituent Assembly Debates, Dr. P.S Deshmukh highlighted the purpose and importance of the Public Service Commissions in these words: “...these Commissions are said to be a necessity of a modern State. These Commissions are primarily meant to keep appointments away from day to day politics, party preferences and influences and the attempt is made, by having recourse to these Commissions, that the appointments shall be as far as possible on merit and there shall be no interference in their choice or in their selection from day to day by the executive authorities of the State.”
17. Our entire purpose here of giving this background to the formation of Public Service Commission in India both at the Union as well as State level, was to emphasize the purpose for its establishment, which was to have an impartial and autonomous body which should select the best possible persons for Government posts, and to have fairness and transparency in the procedure. The present dispute which is before this Court reflects this concern.
18. Article 320(3)(a) of the Constitution, inter alia, states that the State Public Service Commission “shall be consulted on all matters relating to methods of recruitment to civil services and for civil posts”. The provision appears to be mandatory as the words “shall be consulted” suggest. All the same, the learned counsel for the respondents would rely on a 1957 Constitution Bench decision of this Court in State of U.P v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava 1957 SCC OnLine SC 4 which had laid down that the provision is not mandatory but merely directory.
19. The above decision is binding on us. Yet, we must examine the context in which the above judgment was rendered. The context is important. Although the findings in the judgment are generally worded, this Court in Manbodhan Lal Srivastava was not dealing with Article 320(3)(a), as is the case before us, but was concerned with Article 320(3)(c) i.e. a disciplinary matter in an individual case. In Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, a government servant who was posted as an officer-on-special-duty in the Education Department from 1948 to 1951 was accused of giving favours to his friends and relatives, while working in a Book Selection Committee, as he had approved books written by his 14 year old nephew and other publishers from whom he had taken certain money on interest. In 48 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports August 1952, he was suspended from service and a departmental enquiry was conducted against him. On the recommendations of the departmental enquiry report, the Government issued a show cause notice under Article 311(2) of the Constitution and finally, after hearing the concerned employee, the Government issued a notification reducing his rank and compulsorily retiring him. These were the facts of the case before this Court.
20. Article 320(3) speaks of a variety of matters where the Commission is to be consulted- (a) Recruitment in Service and (c) disciplinary matters, being two such instances. Whereas Article 320(3)(c) is generally concerned with individual matters relating to disciplinary proceedings, Article 320(3)(a) deals with policy issues where an entire recruitment process is at stake. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, was a case dealing with Article 320(3)(c), and not with Article 320(3)(a), which is before us.
21. Another question in Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, was whether Article 311 of the Constitution of India is subject to Article 320(3)(c). Para 4 of the Judgment reads like this:
“Hence, the main question in controversy in Appeal No.
27 of 1955, is whether the High Court was right in taking the view that Article 311 was subject to the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution, which were mandatory, and as such, non-compliance with those provisions in the instant case, was fatal to the proceedings ending with the order passed by the Government on September 12, 1953.”
22. The judgment also restricts itself to the facts relating to Article 320(3)(c). This is how it concludes :
“13. In view of these considerations, it must be held that the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) are not mandatory and that non-compliance with those provisions, does not afford a cause of action to the respondent in a court of law. It is not for this Court further to consider what other remedy, if any, the respondent has. Appeal No. 27 is, therefore, allowed and Appeal No. 28 dismissed. In view of the fact that the appellant did not strictly comply with the terms of Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution, we direct that each party bear its own costs throughout.”
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 49Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors.
23. Thus, it was in the background of the above facts that it was held by this Court that consultation with the Commission to be directory and not mandatory. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava also emphasized the purpose of the proviso to Article 320(3) of the Constitution which states that the Governor of a State is empowered to make regulations specifying the matters in which it is not necessary for the State to consult the Public Service Commission. This is what was said by this Court:
“7…Perhaps, because of the use of the word “shall”
in several parts of Article 320, the High Court was led to assume that the provisions of Article 320(3)(c) were mandatory, but in our opinion, there are several cogent reasons for holding to the contrary. In the first place, the proviso to Article 320, itself, contemplates that the President or the Governor, as the case may be, “may make regulations specifying the matters in which either generally, or in any particular class of case or in particular circumstances, it shall not be necessary for a Public Service Commission to be consulted”. The words quoted above give a clear indication of the intention of the Constitution makers that they did envisage certain cases or classes of cases in which the Commission need not be consulted. If the provisions of Article 320 were of a mandatory character, the Constitution would not have left it to the discretion of the Head of the Executive Government to undo those provisions by making regulations to the contrary. If it had been intended by the makers of the Constitution that consultation with the Commission should be mandatory, the proviso would not have been there, or, at any rate, in the terms in which it stands. That does not amount to saying that it is open to the Executive Government, completely to ignore the existence of the Commission or to pick and choose cases in which it may or may not be consulted.
Once, relevant regulations have been made, they are meant to be followed in letter and in spirit and it goes without saying that consultation with the Commission on all disciplinary matters affecting a public servant has been specifically provided for, in order, first, to give an assurance to the Services that a wholly independent body not directly 50 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports concerned with the making of orders adversely affecting public servants, has considered the action proposed to be taken against a particular public servant, with an open mind; and secondly, to afford the Government unbiased advice and opinion on matters vitally affecting the morale of public services. It is, therefore, incumbent upon the Executive Government, when it proposes to take any disciplinary action against a public servant, to consult the Commission as to whether the action proposed to be taken was justified and was not in excess of the requirements of the situation.”
(Emphasis Provided)
Thus, even if, for arguments sake, consultation with Commission is held to be directory then also there is no doubt that once Regulations are framed these are to be followed, “in letter and spirit”.
24. In other words, this Court in Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, had recognised the importance of Regulations framed under the proviso to Article 320(3) of the Constitution and had cautioned against the casual bypassing of the Regulations. In the case at hand, Regulations as contemplated under the Proviso were already in existence in Punjab known as Punjab Public Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1955. For our purposes, it is relevant to note that with these Regulations the State had taken out certain posts outside the purview of the Commission. Admittedly, the posts of Assistant Professors and Librarians in Degree Colleges were not amongst them. In other words, these posts were within the purview of the Commission. Thus, selection of these posts was within the purview of the State Commission, and it was mandatory that it ought to be consulted.
25. The respondents have tried to meet this deficiency by stating that the State had amended the 1955 Regulations in March 2022 (by retrospective effect), by mentioning these posts in the 1955 Regulations and these posts were then taken out from the purview of Commission. All the same, we are unable to accept this argument inasmuch as the amendment was made after concluding the entire recruitment process and giving appointment letters to the selected candidates. It was hence a post facto exercise. The Government [2025] 8 S.C.R. 51Mandeep Singh & Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. had already made its selections on the posts which could only have been done by the Commission under Article 320 of the Constitution of India.
26. This apart, the 1955 Regulations prescribed a procedure under which posts within the purview of the Commission could be withdrawn. Part III-B and Part III-C of the ‘Regulations and Instructions Governing the Work of the Punjab Public Service Commission’ provide a procedure for the exclusion of posts/services from the purview of the Commission. Regulation 20 reads as under:
“20. For exclusion of posts/services and other matters from the purview of the Punjab Public Service Commission, the following procedure is to be followed:
(i) Individual proposals for taking out posts from the purview of the Commission would be processed by the Administrative Departments concerned. After the Department had taken a tentative decision to take out certain posts from the purview of the Commission, the Department would obtain the views/comments of the Public Service Commission by making a self-contained reference to the Commission.
(ii) On receipt of the comments/views of the Commission, the matter would further be examined by the Department concerned keeping in view the comments/views so received and the advice of the Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms. If the Department comes to a definite conclusion that the posts in question must be taken out of the purview of the Commission, the Department would take the matter to the Council of Ministers incorporating the advice of the Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms in the Memorandum to be placed before the Council of Ministers.
(iii) After the proposal of the Administrative Department is approved by the Council of Ministers, necessary action to amend the Punjab Public Service Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulations, 1955 would be taken by the Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms.”
52 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
27. Further, Part III-C of the Regulations provides that in cases where a difference of opinion between a Department of Government and Public Service Commission arises then what is to be done. Regulation 21 reads as under:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.