Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1016; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1379
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 22 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11008/2025
- Sections
- 14, 3C(1), 13, 3C, 3B, 2, 3A, 3D, 12, 4, 3C(2), 13(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1379 : 2025 INSC 1016 Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v.
Bishop John Rodrigues and Others (Civil Appeal No. 11008 of 2025)
22 August 2025 [Surya Kant* and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the validity of the acquisition of land under Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; whether the High Court rightly rejected the Society’s preliminary objection; whether the 2018 Amendment impacts the law laid down in Tarabai’s case; and whether the High Court rightly set aside the public notice and the order approving the acquisition proposal.
Headnotes† Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) (Amendment) Act, 2017 – ss.3B, 3C(1) – Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – s.14 – Declaration of a slum rehabilitation area – Rights of landowners to redevelop a Slum Rehabilitation Area – Certain land owned by the Church Trust, a public trust – Subject land was part of the larger plot, and the same was encroached upon by hutment dwellers, and a section of it was thereupon declared a Slum Area – Over time, the hutment area (Subject Slum) expanded, and the notification was amended – In the intervening period, the dwellers of the subject slum formed the Cooperative Housing Society – Communication regarding the redevelopment of the Subject Slum between the Church Trust and the Society – Society also entered into an agreement with the developer for the development of the Subject Slum – On the proposal of the Society, the Subject Slum declared a Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area) in 2020 – Developer and the Church trust filed proposals for redevelopment of the subject slum – Slum Rehabilitation Authority-SRA rejected the Church Trust’s proposal for redevelopment – Society then submitted an application for the acquisition of the Subject Land – SRA issued * Author 1380 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a public notice calling for objections from all interested parties to the proposal for acquisition – Church Trust submitted its objection, however acquisition proceedings were initiated – Church Trust then filed writ petition seeking quashing of the public notice – During pendency, the CEO, SRA approved the acquisition proposal on the premise that the Church Trust had not filed an SR Scheme within 120 days – Amended writ petition filed by Church Trust seeking setting aside of the order approving the acquisition proposal – High Court set aside the public notice order and the acquisition proposal approval order, declaring the acquisition void; and holding that the Church Trust had a preferential right to develop the subject land, directed the SRA to consider the proposal of the landowner for redevelopment – Correctness:
Held: On facts and the colourable conduct of the appellants, the acquisition proceedings cannot be allowed to sustain – High Court rightly set aside these proceedings, protecting the statutory rights and interests of the Church Trust over the Subject Land and preventing the appellants from illegally grabbing it – Preliminary objection by the Society that the public notice was merely an invitation for objections to the acquisition proposal, and the approval order was simply a recommendation to the State fails – Where the solitary object of the notice and order, to acquire the Subject Land, the High Court was justified to intervene at a preliminary stage, in exercise of its plenary jurisdiction u/Art.226 – Not doing so would have invited more complications on account of creation of third-party rights by the private builder and consequential multiplicity of litigation – Notice and the order are traceable to the statutory framework of the Slums Act, and having been issued in purported exercise of statutory power were amenable to judicial review – On a bare perusal of the 2018 Amendment, it seems that no attempt has been made to remove or dilute the preferential right of the landowner to redevelop an SR Area – Tarabai’s case lead to only one conclusion, that the owner has a primary right to undertake development, and none of the provisions have been amended – s.3C(1) declaration is a stage prior to redevelopment being initiated u/s.13, and issuance of a notice u/s.3C is meant to accord hearing to a landowner and invite objections, if any, against declaration as an SR Area – Thus, it cannot be said that the new mechanism within s.3C no longer necessitates a separate notice-cum-invitation on the landowner – Claim of the appellants that the owner is expected to present an SR Scheme within 120 days of the s.3C(1) Declaration without any notice-cum-invitation wholly misconceived – On a conspectus of [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1381Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others the 2018 Amendment and the perceived resultant variation on the pre-amendment legislative policy, the holistic interpretation of the Slums Act made in Tarabai’s case squarely applicable on post-2018 Amendment actions/events, barring the now legislatively stipulated timeline within which a redevelopment scheme has to be submitted by an interested landowner – As regards the validity of acquisition, there vests a preferential right in favour of the Church Trust, over and above the SRA, occupants, or other stakeholders, to develop the Subject Land – Trust ought to have been invited by the SRA to submit a proposal and undertake such redevelopment after the declaration was issued – Thus, the SRA cannot proceed for acquisition of the Subject Land unless such a notice-cum-invitation is extended, and thereafter, the right of the Church Trust is extinguished if it fails to submit a redevelopment scheme within the prescribed period of 120 days – High Court rightly held that there was no compliance of these preconditions by the SRA before initiating the acquisition, and the entire process liable to be invalidated – High Court also rightly found from the conduct of the appellants that the acquisition proceedings arose from an exercise of power in bad faith – Furthermore, no notice-cum-invitation for redevelopment u/s.13 was issued to the Church Trust as such the Church Trust’s preferential right to redevelop the Subject Land remains intact and in the absence of a valid notice or opportunity, there existed no legal basis to extinguish this right, thus, the acquisition was, vitiated in law, falling afoul of the prescribed procedure – There was no waiver of preferential right to develop SR area – Adverse inferences drawn from the appellants’ disconcerting conduct throughout the acquisition proceedings – Record reveals a concerted and motivated attempt by the parties to acquire the Subject Land – SRA’s actions expose its attempts to thwart any possibility of the Church Trust exercising its preferential right – SRA and its CEO appear to have abandoned their public duty to uphold the Rule of Law and protect the rights of the landowner – On the contrary, the facts reveal a prejudiced attempt by the SRA to undermine legislative and judicial efforts and hand over the Subject Land and the benefits of its rehabilitation to the developer – Such actions of a public authority, marred by collusion and connivance and motivated by extraneous profit interests of private builders, are highly depreciable and underline the possibility of bureaucratic misuse of statutory provisions – Impugned judgement of the High Court upheld – Church Trust to submit an SR Scheme for the redevelopment of the Subject Slum, within a period of 120 days – SRA and the State to process the Church Trust’s proposal within 60 days – Constitution of India – Art. 226. [Paras 17 - 53] 1382 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Tarabai Nagar Co-op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others, SLP (C) 19774 of 2018 – relied on. Indian Cork Mills (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 1214 – referred to.
List of Acts Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) (Amendment) Act, 2017;
Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Slum Areas; Acquisition; Church Trust; Preferential right; Owner has a primary right; Bad faith; Public trust; Plenary jurisdiction; Executive overreach; Issuance of notice; Declaration under section 3C(1); Hearing to landowners; Validity of acquisition; Declaration of a slum rehabilitation area; Rights of landowners to redevelop a Slum Rehabilitation Area; Hutment dwellers; Cooperative Housing Society; Redevelopment of the Subject Slum; Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area); Slum Rehabilitation Authority-SRA; Acquisition proposal.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11008 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.06.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WP No. 1212 of 2022 With Civil Appeal No(s). 11009 and 11010 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Shyam Divan, Siddharth Bhatnagar, Sudhanshu S. Choudhari, Nikhil Sakhardande, Sr. Advs., Sanjeev Singh, Arpit Rai, Sudipto Sircar, Ms. Tushima, Aviral Kashyap, Amol Nirmalkumar Suryawanshi, Ms. Gautami Yadav, Soura Subha Ghosh, Tavish Bhushan Prasad, [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1383Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others Ms. Sanaya Patel, Shesh Raj Bharti, Soumya Dutta, Siddhant Upmanyu, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Milind Sathe, Chander Uday Singh, Shyam Mehta, Shyam Divan, Siddharth Bhatnagar, Sr. Advs., Ms. Neha Mehta, Bhushan Deshmukh, Aditya Miskita, Ms. Harsh Lata, Umair Merchant, Ms. Aayushi Gohil, Ms. Harsh Lata, Sunil Kumar Verma, Aman Raj Gandhi, Parthasarathy Bose, Ms. Panchi Agarwal, Pranaya Goyal,, Bharat Bagla, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Varad Kilor, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Adarsh Dubey, Sachin Patil, Ravi Tyagi, Mayank Mishra, Ms. Manmilan Sidhu, Chirag Sharma, Ms. Sudiksha Saina, Ms. Saksha Jha, Shikhar Misra, Ms. Bhumika Bhatnagar, Ms. Ria Chanda, P. V. Yogeswaran, Amol Nirmalkumar Suryawanshi, Sanjeev Singh, Arpit Rai, Sudipto Sircar, Ms. Tushima, Aviral Kashyap. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave granted.
2. The dispute under consideration in these Civil Appeals concerns the validity of the acquisition of a portion of land located at CTS No. B-960 in Village Bandra, Taluka Andheri, Mumbai, measuring 1,596.40 sq. m. (Subject Land) under the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Slums Act). The High Court of Judicature at Bombay (High Court), vide the Impugned Judgement dated 11.06.2024, has: (i) allowed the writ petition filed by the landowner, declaring the acquisition void; and
(ii) directed the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) to consider the proposal of the landowner for redevelopment. The instant appeals have thus been preferred by the proposed housing society of slum dwellers, the developer selected by the said society, and the SRA.
3. The instant appeals involve an in-depth analysis of the text as well as the legislative policy behind Chapter I-A of the Slums Act, specifically regarding the rights of landowners to redevelop a Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area) and the corresponding duties of the SRA. At the outset, we note that by a judgement of even date, titled Tarabai Nagar 1384 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and others,1 a 2-Judge Bench of this Court, including one of us (Surya Kant, J.), has dealt with a substantial part of the arguments raised in these appeals. The Bench, therein, upheld the decision of another Division Bench of the High Court in Indian Cork Mills (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra,2 laying down that: (i) the private owner of a Slum Rehabilitation Area has a preferential right to develop it; (ii) as part of this right, the owner must be notified and invited to undertake such redevelopment; and (iii) without such notice being issued and such right being extinguished, it would be untenable for the State or the SRA to acquire the land under Section 14.
4. The legislative interpretation we are tasked with undertaking in these appeals has largely been addressed by the Bench in Tarabai (supra). Having previously examined the law regarding the questions answered therein, this Court does not need to revisit the analysis of the Slums Act. The only remaining issue for us to consider through this judgement is the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) (Amendment) Act, 2017 (2018 Amendment). A. LegisLAtive scheme
5. The legislative scheme of the Slums Act prior to the 2018 Amendment has already been detailed extensively in Tarabai (supra). 3 However, before delving into the facts of this case, it would be apposite to first explore the impact of the said Amendment on the slum rehabilitation framework envisaged in Chapter I-A of the Slums Act.
6. The Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) (Amendment) Act, 2017, which came into force on 26.04.2018, was enacted to improve the practical implementation of the Slums Act and to expand the scope of slum rehabilitation. It introduced various improvements, both significant and minor, into the legislative framework for slum rehabilitation.
7. Section 3B is one of the key areas where such a change was implemented.4 1 Supreme Court of India, Civil Appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 19774 of 2018, judgement dated 22.08.2025.
2 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 1214.
3 See Paragraphs 5 to 38 of Tarabai (supra).
4 For pre-2018 Amendment version, see Paragraph 19 of Tarabai (supra). [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1385Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others
7.1. In sub-section (1), the Legislature introduced the ability for the SRA to amend an already operative General Slum Rehabilitation Scheme (General SR Scheme).
7.2. Further, the provisions which, prior to the Amendment, were included in sub-section (4), 5 namely, the matters which shall be provided for in the General SR Scheme, have now been relocated to sub-section (5). While the scheme itself and its tenor remain unchanged, the scope of these matters has been broadened. For example, provisions for compensation in lieu of transit accommodation, as well as for the grant of tenements to non-protected occupiers, were introduced. Most notably, the Legislature has amended the stakeholders specified in Clauses (c) and (g) (which correspond to Clauses (c) and (e), respectively, before the 2018 Amendment) from ‘landholders and occupants’ to ‘owners, landholders and occupants’. It is worth noting that although the term ‘owner’ was already defined in Section 2(f) of the Slums Act,6 it has been included in the procedure for Slum Rehabilitation Schemes (SR Schemes)
only after the 2018 Amendment.
7.3. In its place, a new sub-section (4) has been added, stipulating that the General SR Scheme shall be deemed to be ‘Development Control Regulations’ under the Maharashtra Town Planning Act, 1966 for an SR Area and clarifying that the General SR Scheme shall prevail over any other Development Control Regulations in force, such as the Development Control and Promotion Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 2034 (DCPR 2034).
7.4. For complete clarity, the relevant portion of the amended version of Section 3B is reproduced below:
“3B. Slum Rehabilitation Schemes. – (1) The Slum Rehabilitation Authority concerned, with the previous sanction of the State Government, shall prepare or amend the general Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for the areas specified under sub-section (1) of section 3A, for rehabilitation or relocation of protected 5 See Paragraph 19 of Tarabai (supra).
6 See Paragraph 7 of Tarabai (supra).
1386 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports occupiers and other occupiers of the building in such areas.
[xxxx]
(4) The general Slum Rehabilitation Scheme published under sub-section (3) shall be deemed Development Control Regulations under the provisions of Chapter III of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (Mah. XXXVII of 1966), for the said area and the provisions of the general Slum Rehabilitation Scheme shall prevail over the Development Control Regulations, published under the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (Mah. XXXVII of 1966).
(5) The Slum Rehabilitation Scheme so notified under sub-section (3) shall, generally lay down the parameters for declaration of any land as the Slum Rehabilitation Area and indicate the manner in which rehabilitation of the occupants of the area declared as Slum Rehabilitation Area shall be carried out. In particular, it shall provide for all or any of the following matters, that is to say,- [xxxx]
(c) provision for obligatory participation of the owners, landholders and occupants of the land declared as the Slum Rehabilitation Area under the approved Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in the implementation of such Scheme;
(d) provision relating to transit accommodation or entitlement of compensation in lieu of transit accommodation to the slum dwellers pending development of the Slum Rehabilitation Area;
(e) provision relating to allotment of tenements either in-situ or otherwise, on development free of cost to the protected occupiers of the building in such Slum Rehabilitation Area;
(f) provision relating to allotment of tenements either in-situ or otherwise, on ownership or on [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1387Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others rent, to the other non-protected occupiers up to the 1st January 2011, subject to the availability of tenements as per the terms and conditions and guidelines so notified in the Official Gazette, by the Chief Executive Officer with the prior approval of the State Government;
(g) scheme for development of the Slum Rehabilitation Areas under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme by the landholders and occupants by themselves or through a developer and the terms and conditions of such development; and the option available to the Slum Rehabilitation Authority for taking up such development in the event of non-participation of the landholders or occupants;
[xxxx] ”
8. The process for declaring land as an SR Area under Section 3C(1) was also augmented. 7 Following the amendment, the CEO must provide the owners and other stakeholders a 30-day notice and an opportunity to be heard before issuing a reasoned order. Only then can the CEO declare the land an SR Area (Section 3C(1) Declaration). However, the method of publication/publicity of the Section 3C(1) Declaration remains unchanged. For reference, the text of the amended Section 3C(1) is provided below.
“3C. Declaration of a slum rehabilitation area. –
(1) As soon as may be, after the publication of any Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, the Chief Executive Officer on being satisfied about the circumstances in respect of any land, whether or not previously declared as slum area, justifying its declaration as the Slum Rehabilitation Area which may include community economic activity area, for implementing the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, shall after giving the land owners, including any public authorities or local bodies under the State Government constituted under any law enacted by the State Legislature, thirty days notice and after giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard, by an order published in the Official Gazette, and 7 For pre-2018 Amendment version, see Paragraph 20 of Tarabai (supra). 1388 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports thereafter within forty-five days, declare such land to be a “Slum Rehabilitation Area”. The order declaring the Slum Rehabilitation Area (hereinafter referred to as “the slum rehabilitation order”), shall also be given wide publicity in such manner as may be specified by the Chief Executive Officer of the Slum Rehabilitation Authority. Thereafter, notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force, in such Slum Rehabilitation Area, the permission or the No Objection Certificate of the land owning authority or agency shall not be required:
Provided that, only in respect of any land which is required for Vital Public Project purpose, as per orders of the State Government and where the State Government either directly or through any public authority has undertaken the responsibility of relocation and rehabilitation of the protected and other occupiers of the building, then the Chief Executive Officer shall, exclude the land required for Vital Public Project from the Slum Rehabilitation Area and issue an order to omit such land from the Slum Rehabilitation Area. Where the State Government either directly or through any public authority has undertaken the responsibility of relocation and rehabilitation of the protected and other occupiers of the building, such public authority shall prepare the Scheme of such rehabilitation or relocation and get it approved by the Chief Executive Officer within the period specified in the Scheme which shall not be more than ninety days.
(2) Any person aggrieved by the order of the Chief Executive Officer may, within thirty days of the publication of such slum rehabilitation order, prefer an appeal to the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee. The decision of the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee in such appeal shall be final.
(3) On the completion of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, the Slum Rehabilitation Area shall cease to be such area.”
9. Substantial changes were also made to Section 3D, which, inter alia, modifies Sections 13 and 14 for their applicability to Chapter I-A of the Slums Act.8 8 For pre-2018 Amendment version, see Paragraphs 27 and 28 of Tarabai (supra). [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1389Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others
9.1. Sub-clause (iii) of Clause (c) of this Section describes the applicability of Section 13 to an SR Area. Through the 2018 Amendment, significant changes have been made to the text of the provision. For reference, Section 13, as it would apply under Chapter I-A after the amendment, reads as follows:
“13. Power of Slum Rehabilitation Authority t o d e v e l o p S l u m R e h a b i l i t a t i o n A r e a . –
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (10) of section 12, the Chief Executive Officer shall, after any land has been declared as the Slum Rehabilitation Area, including community economic activity area, if the owners, landholders or occupants of such land do not come forward within a reasonable time, which shall not be more than one hundred and twenty days, required for relocation and rehabilitation of protected and other occupiers justifying with the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for redevelopment of such land, by order, determine to redevelop such land by entrusting into any agency or other developer for the purpose.
(2) Where on declaration of any land as Slum Rehabilitation Area, the Chief Executive Officer is satisfied that, the land in the Slum Rehabilitation Area has been or is being developed by the owners, landholders or occupants or developers in contravention of the plans duly approved, or any restrictions or conditions imposed under sub-section
(10) of section 12, or in contravention of any provision of any Slum Rehabilitation Scheme or any condition specified in the approval or has not been developed within the time, as specified under such conditions of approval, he may, by order, determine to develop the land declared as Slum Rehabilitation Area by entrusting it to any agency or the other developer recognized by him for the purpose.
(3) The agency or the other developer so appointed shall within a period of forty-five days of the order of the Chief Executive Officer, be required to deposit 1390 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports an amount of compensation payable to the outgoing landowners or occupants or developers, as the case may be, for expenditure incurred by them on payment made to any public authority, local bodies for receiving approvals for the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme and construction of rehabilitation tenements as determined by the Chief Executive Officer:
Provided that, such compensation shall not be payable by the agency appointed by the Chief Executive Officer, for any expenditure incurred towards construction to meet conditional obligations made to any third party by the landowners or occupants or previous developers, as the case may be. The Chief Executive Officer before passing such order shall obtain report from approved valuer independently appointed on his behalf and by the concerned parties to the proceeding before the Chief Executive Officer:
Provided further that, before passing such order by the Chief Executive Officer, the concerned landowner or occupant or developer, as the case may be, shall be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard and time which shall not be more than thirty days of showing cause why the order should not be passed:
Provided also that, an appeal, if any, against the order of the Chief Executive Officer shall be filed before the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee and order of the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee shall be final and binding on all the parties.”
9.2. With this amendment, the notion of ‘reasonable time’ in subsection (1) has been qualified with the phrase, “which shall not be more than one hundred and twenty days.” Previously, no such qualification was provided for. Additionally, the pre-condition under sub-section (1) has changed from ‘come forward … with a scheme for redevelopment’ to ‘come forward … for redevelopment of such land’.
9.3. Notably, when the 2018 Amendment was originally introduced, the final proviso in Section 13 referred to the Grievance Redressal Committee (GRC). However, in 2023, with a retrospective [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1391Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others amendment, this body was renamed as the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee (AGRC).9
9.4. Although the amendment has kept the procedure for land acquisition under Chapter I-A untouched, it would be prudent for us to reproduce Section 14, as it applies to the said Chapter: “14. Power of State Government to acquire land. –
(1) Where on any representation from the Chief Executive Officer it appears to the State Government that, in order to enable the Slum Rehabilitation Authority to carry out development under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in any Slum Rehabilitation Area it is necessary that such area, or any land within adjoining or surrounded by any such area should be acquired, the State Government may acquire the land by publishing in the Official Gazette, a notice to the effect that the State Government has decided to acquire the land in pursuance of this section:
Provided that, before publishing such notice, the State Government, or as the case may be, the Competent Authority may call upon by notice the owner of, or any other person who, in its or his opinion may be interested in, such land to show cause in writing why the land should not be acquired with reasons therefor, to the Competent Authority within the period specified in the notice; and the Competent Authority shall, with all reasonable despatch, forward any objections so submitted together with his report in respect thereof to the State Government and on considering the report and the objections, if any, the State Government may pass such order as it deems fit.
Provided further that, the State Government may delegate its powers under this sub-section to any officer not below the rank of Commissioner.
(1A) The acquisition of land for any purpose mentioned in sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be a public purpose.
9 Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) (Amendment, Re-enactment of Rules and Notification of Apex and other Grievance Redressal Committees and Validation) Act, 2023, s 4. 1392 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(2) When a notice as aforesaid is published in the Official Gazette, the land shall, on and from the date on which the notice is so published, vest absolutely in the State Government free from all encumbrances.”
10. As in Tarabai (supra), the instant case also pertains to an SR Area under Chapter I-A. It is, thus, clarified that wherever the provisions of Chapters IV and V are referred to in this Judgement, the reference is to the modified provisions which are now encapsulated in Section 3D.
B. FActs
11. Having considered the changes introduced through the 2018 Amendment, we now proceed to observe the facts in detail, as portrayed below.
11.1. The plot bearing CTS No. B-960 in Village Bandra, Taluka Andheri, Mumbai, admeasuring a total area of 9,371.30 sq. m., is owned by the Basilica of Our Lady of the Mount (Church Trust), a Public Trust based in Mumbai. The Church Trust operates the Mount Mary Church in Bandra, Mumbai, where, at the relevant time, Bishop John Rodrigues served as the Rector and the sole trustee. The Subject Land, measuring 1,596.40 sq. m., is part of this larger plot.
11.2. The Subject Land has reportedly been encroached upon by hutment dwellers since the 1930s, and a section admeasuring 1,334 sq. m. was thereupon declared a Slum Area under Section 4 of the Slums Act on 30.11.1978. Over time, the hutment area (Subject Slum) expanded, and the notification dated 30.11.1978 was accordingly amended on 12.06.2002, increasing the declared Slum Area to 1,532 sq. m. Subsequently, through further expansion, the Subject Slum extended into an adjoining plot bearing CTS No. B-967, owned by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC).
11.3. In the intervening period, the dwellers of the Subject Slum formed the Shri Kadeshwari Cooperative Housing Society Ltd. (Proposed) (Kadeshwari Society). It appears from the records that there were 35 identified tenements in the Subject Slum, prior to 01.01.2000, who are all members of Kadeshwari Society.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1393Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others
11.4. Since 2012, Kadeshwari Society and the Church Trust (through its sole trustee) have been in communication regarding the redevelopment of the Subject Slum. The record indicates that the parties had initially met for this purpose, but it was subsequently identified that the land fell within the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ), which impacted the feasibility of any attempted redevelopment project.
11.5. In due course, however, the Government sought to relax restrictions on the redevelopment of slums in CRZ areas, making rehabilitation on the Subject Land feasible. This sparked a fresh round of communication among the parties.
11.6. In this context, vide letter dated 13.06.2013, the Church Trust called on Kadeshwari Society to: (i) submit written consent of all the 35 slum dwellers eligible for rehabilitation; (ii) procure a resolution passed by the General Body of Kadeshwari Society authorising redevelopment; and (iii) to permit the Society’s chosen developer to submit a tentative offer for redevelopment, subject to the outcome of a tender process.
11.7. Kadeshwari Society initially appointed M/s Accord Estates as its preferred developer and notified the Church Trust accordingly. The Society also appears to have entered into development agreements, individual agreements, and tripartite agreements with this developer. However, no further steps were taken in the following years until 2017.
11.8. Citing inaction on the part of M/s Accord Estates, Kadeshwari Society terminated all agreements with this firm and its promoter. It, instead, resolved to enter into an agreement with another developer, namely, M/s Saldanha Real Estates Pvt. Ltd. (Saldanha), for the redevelopment of the Subject Slum. Consequently, on 28.12.2017, Kadeshwari Society entered into a Development Agreement with and executed a Power of Attorney in favour of Saldanha. The developer also entered into individual Development Agreements with the slum dwellers.
11.9. Having crystallised this relationship, Kadeshwari Society then besought the Church Trust to grant a No-Objection Certificate to Saldanha, allowing it to redevelop the Subject Land and to rehabilitate the slum dwellers on it.
1394 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11.10. Meanwhile, Saldanha also approached the Church Trust with a proposal to purchase the Subject Land on an ‘as-is-whereis’ basis. Saldanha and the sole trustee of the Church Trust deliberated on this issue on 21.03.2018, pursuant to which the developer forwarded an offer of INR 2.5 crores for the Subject Land. The offer was later revised to INR 3 crores, but the parties did not proceed with this deal.
11.11. It is pertinent to highlight at this stage that the Church Trust intended to develop the Subject Land along with the rest of its land in CTS No. B-960, as well as some other adjoining plots, totalling approximately 10,709 sq. m. in land area. The plan was to redevelop ‘Nirmala Colony’, including the Subject Land, as a contiguous project.
11.12. However, when this proposal was presented to the slum dwellers, Kadeshwari Society sent a communication dated 04.02.2019 to the Church Trust, opposing a composite project and requesting the Trust to allow independent redevelopment of the Subject Land by Saldanha.
11.13. This was followed by a series of communications between Kadeshwari Society and the Church Trust, where the former sought an NOC for redevelopment by Saldanha, while the latter attempted to obtain consent from the slum dwellers for combined development.
11.14. In this backdrop, Kadeshwari Society submitted a proposal dated 24.09.2019 before the SRA for the declaration of the entire Subject Slum, now covering 1,976.60 sq. m. (1,596.40 sq. m. being the Subject Land and 380.20 sq. m. being BMC’s land), as an SR Area under Section 3C(1).10
11.15. Parallelly, the Church Trust sent a letter dated 07.02.2020 to the Chief Executive Officer of the SRA (CEO), informing that it was in communication with the slum dwellers. It stated that the representatives of the Trust had met with the members of Kadeshwari Society, and the dwellers had accepted the feasibility of the composite development. The Church Trust 10 Reproduced in Paragraph 8.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1395Saldanha Real Estate Private Limited v. Bishop John Rodrigues and Others also submitted a feasibility report prepared by its architect for the redevelopment of the area.
11.16. The SRA, however, disregarded the Church Trust’s communication and, instead, acted on the proposal of the Kadeshwari Society. It issued public notices as well as a specific notice to the Trust on 30.09.2020, calling for objections to the proposal for a Section 3C(1) Declaration.
11.17. The Church Trust filed its written objections and attended the subsequent hearing on the proposal. It conveyed its intention to redevelop the Subject Property on its own, without the interference of a third-party. The Trust also averred that the Subject Land was not densely populated, and the structures thereon had sufficient ventilation, light, sanitation, and facilities, considering which it should not be designated as a slum.
11.18. The CEO after the hearing the parties, vide order dated 29.12.2020, rejected the objections of the Church Trust and declared the Subject Slum as an SR Area. The Section 3C(1) Declaration dated 29.12.2020 was published in the Official Gazette on 31.12.2020, and the order and the declaration were also forwarded by the SRA to the Church Trust on 05.01.2021.
11.19. Aggrieved, the Church Trust challenged the order dated 29.12.2020 through statutory appeal under Section 3C(2) 11 bearing Application No. 20 of 2021 before the AGRC on 01.02.2021. The AGRC does not appear to have heard the appeal even a single time, and it has remained pending to date.
11.20. Following the declaration dated 29.12.2020, Saldanha and the Church Trust filed their respective proposals for redevelopment.
11.21. Saldanha filed its proposal dated 23.04.2021 in accordance with SRA’s Circular No. 144 12 and Regulation 33(10) of the 11 Reproduced in Paragraph 8.
12 See Paragraph 38 of Tarabai (supra).
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.