Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1048; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2199
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari
- Decided
- 28 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3777/2025
- Sections
- 276C(1), 245C, 276, 245H, 245, 276C, 276C(2), 279(1), 132, 132(4), 482, 245D(4)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2199 : 2025 INSC 1048 Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v.
The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 3777-3779 of 2025)
28 August 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari* and Vijay Bishnoi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether continuation of the prosecution initiated by the revenue u/s.276C(1), Income Tax Act, 1961 against the appellant after passing an order by the Settlement Commission, would amount to abuse of process of Court; whether in the facts of the present case, the High Court was justified to dismiss the quashing petition filed by the appellant, and if not, what relief can be granted. Headnotes† Income Tax Act, 1961 – ss.276C(1), 245H(1) proviso to, 245D(4), 245I – Search conducted at the residence of the appellant, unaccounted cash of Rs.4,93,84,300/- was seized – Proceedings for the offence u/s.276C(1) for assessment year 2017-2018 initiated by Revenue – Appellant filed quashing petition before the High Court seeking quashing of the complaint and pending proceedings – Later, appellant also filed an application u/s.245C before the Settlement Commissioner – Application partly allowed vide order dated 26.11.2019; settlement was entered by the Revenue with the appellant, granting him immunity from levy of penalty – However, High Court dismissed the quashing petition – Interference with: Held: 1.1 The departmental circular dated 24.04.2008, Prosecution Manual, 2009, and CBDT’s circular dated 09.09.2019, provide when the prosecution ought to be lodged by Revenue – The said Circulars were issued to regulate the lodging of prosecution in genuine cases and to weed out the problems of the tax payers, and also to understand when can the prosecution for s.276 ought to be lodged and continued. [Para 24] 1.2 If an assessee has made suppression of income without disclosing the manner in which the excess amount was earned and * Author 2200 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports concealed the account making wilful attempt to evade the tax which may be imposable and chargeable or payable, he/she is required to be prosecuted – Therefore, the recourse to lodge prosecution was made permissible subject to the department’s circular dated 24.04.2008 which provided for confirmation by ITAT in case the penalty imposed u/s.276C(1) is exceeding Rs.50,000/-. [Para 32] 1.3 The said circular was in vogue on the date of the grant of sanction by Principal Director Income Tax (Investigation), Chennai (PDIT) to respondent-Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation), Chennai (DDIT) for lodging the prosecution against the appellant – The said circular was reaffirmed by the Prosecution Manual, 2009 and the clarification issued by the CBDT in 2019 – As such, the circulars were binding on the authorities and required to be adhered to while lodging the prosecution by the Revenue. [Para 32] 1.4 Thus, the prosecution lodged with the help of proviso to sub-section (1) to s.245H was in defiance to the circular dated 24.04.2008 which was in vogue – Admittedly, the complaint was filed by DDIT after sanction of PDIT before the ACMM on 11.08.2018 – Application u/s.245(C) was filed by the appellant before the Settlement Commission later – In the settlement proceedings, assessee disclosed all the facts material to the computation of his additional income and fully satisfied the provisions of s.245H – The Commission found that overall additional income is not on account of any suppression of any material facts and it does not disclose any variance from the manner in which the said income had been earned – As such the immunity from penalty under IT Act was granted in exercise of powers u/s.245H. [Paras 33, 36] 1.5 On the date of lodging the prosecution, the finding of concealment of income or imposition of the penalty of more than Rs.50,000/was not recorded by the ITAT – Nothing on record to show that any wilful attempt to evade the payment of tax by assessee was made – No explanation put forth by Revenue to demonstrate as to why PDIT or DDIT did not comply the procedure while lodging prosecution in this case – Therefore, the act of the authority in continuing prosecution is in blatant disregard to their own binding circular dated 24.04.2008 and in defiance to the guidelines of the Department – It was the duty of the PDIT and DDIT to look into the facts that in absence of any findings of imposition of penalty due to concealment of fact, the said prosecution cannot be proved against the assessee. [Paras 33, 36] [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2201Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
1.6 Even after passing the order by the Settlement Commission on 26.11.2019, it was brought to the notice of the High Court, but the authorities were persistent to pursue the prosecution without looking into the procedural lapses on their part – Revenue acted in blatant disregard to binding statutory instructions – Such willful noncompliance of their own directives is a serious lapse and undermines the principles of fairness, consistency and accountability, which is unjustified and unlawful – Impugned order set aside – Prosecution lodged by the Revenue against the appellant, quashed – Costs of Rs.2,00,000/- imposed on the Revenue, to be paid to the appellant. [Paras 36, 38] Income Tax Act, 1961 – s.276C – Wilful attempt to evade tax, etc. – s.276C(1) vis-à-vis s.276C(2) – Operation and applicability – Distinction between – s.279(1) – Chapter XIXA- ‘Settlement of Cases’ – Wanchoo Committee’s Report of December, 1971 – Settlement mechanism set up, intent and purpose of – Departmental circular dated 24.04.2008; Prosecution Manual, 2009; and CBDT’s clarification in 2019 qua the criteria to be followed for launching prosecution in respect of certain categories of offence under the IT Act, including s.276C(1) – Circulars are binding on the authorities administering the provisions of the IT Act – Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 1975 (41 of 1975) – Circulars/Notices. [Paras 12, 14-18, 20-24, 31] Case Law Cited Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wite Industries [2008] 14 SCR 653 : (2008) 13 SCC 1 – followed. Ranadey Micronutrients v. CCE [1996] Supp. 5 SCR 755 : (1996) 10 SCC 387; Paper Products Ltd. v. CCE (1999) 7 SCC 84; UCO Bank v. CIT [1999] 3 SCR 635 : (1999) 4 SCC 599; J.K. Lakshmi Cement Limited v. Commercial Tax Officer, Pali [2016] 5 SCR 261 : (2016) 16 SCC 213; Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax, Rohtak v. Merino Panel Product Limited [2022] 18 SCR 28 : (2023) 2 SCC 597 – relied on.
M/s K.C. Builders Ltd. v. CIT [2004] 1 SCR 1134 : (2004) 2 SCC 731 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Wanchoo Committee’s, report of December, 1971 – referred to. 2202 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Income Tax Act, 1961; Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 1975 (41 of 1975).
List of Keywords Section 276C(1), Income Tax Act, 1961; Proviso to sub-section
(1) to Section 245H, Income Tax Act, 1961; Sections 245D(4), 245I, Income Tax Act, 1961; Wilful attempt to evade tax; Search; Unaccounted cash seized; Proceedings for offence under Section 276C(1), Income Tax Act, 1961; Prosecution initiated by revenue under Section 276C(1), Income Tax Act, 1961; Settlement Commissioner; Settlement entered by the Revenue; Immunity from levy of penalty; Settlement Commission; Settlement proceedings; Departmental circular; Prosecution Manual, 2009; CBDT’s circular; Clarification by CBDT; Binding circulars; No suppression of any material facts; Computation of additional income; Assessee disclosed all the facts material; Order passed by the Settlement Commission; Application under Section 245C, Income Tax Act, 1961; Grant of sanction by Principal Director Income Tax (Investigation), Chennai (PDIT) to Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation), Chennai (DDIT); Jurisdiction of DDIT; Section 279(1), Income Tax Act, 1961; Wanchoo Committee; Black Money and Tax Evasion; No wilful attempt to evade the payment of tax; No mens rea of the assessee; Binding statutory instructions; Abuse of process of Court; Costs imposed on Revenue; Quashing.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 3777-3779 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.11.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in CRLOP No. 28763 of 2018 in CRMP Nos. 16786 and 16787 of 2018 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Preetesh Kapur, Sr. Adv., R. Sivaraman, B. R. Varshini, Ms. Vandana Vyas, S. Mohan, Aditya Sharan, Ravi Raghunath.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Mrs. Nisha Bagchi, Sr. Adv., Raj Bahadur Yadav, V Chandrashekhara Bharathi, Udai Khanna, Navanjay Mahapatra.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2203Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.K. Maheshwari, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The appellant invoked the jurisdiction of the High Court 1 in Crl. OP. No. 28763 of 2018 for quashing of the proceedings of EOC No. 242 of 2018 initiated by the Revenue, before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate (E.O.II), Egmore, Chennai, for the offence under Section 276C(1) 2 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, (in short “IT Act”) for assessment year 2017-2018. The High Court vide the impugned judgement dismissed the quashing petition filed by the appellant. Challenging the same, he has knocked the doors of this Court preferring the instant appeals. The consequence of the dismissal of quashing petition has led to the appellant facing trial for an offence in which settlement was entered by the Revenue with the appellant, granting him immunity from levy of penalty.
3. Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts are that, on 24.04.2016, search under Section 132 3 of the IT Act was conducted at the residence of the appellant, and unaccounted cash of Rs. 4,93,84,300/- was seized. After taking statement of the appellant under Section 132(4) of the IT Act, a show-cause notice was issued on 31.10.2017 as to why prosecution should not be initiated against him. On assailing the same in the writ petition filed by the appellant, it was dismissed on 17.11.2017 being premature, observing that issuance of showcause notice is an administrative act and in absence of reply, it cannot be questioned in the writ petition. The said order was put to challenge in Writ Appeal No. 1617 of 2017 which was dismissed as infructuous vide order dated 06.09.2020 taking into consideration the subsequent developments and the order of the Settlement Commission passed on 26.11.2019. The Division Bench observed that the complaint filed in furtherance to show-cause notice was not challenged before the learned Single Judge in a writ petition, 1 High Court of Judicature at Madras.
2 Wilful attempt to evade tax, etc.
3 Search and seizure.
2204 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports therefore, the said issue cannot be looked into in this appeal, leaving it open to be decided in the appropriate proceedings. During pendency, the Principal Director Income Tax (Investigation), Chennai, (in short “PDIT”) exercised power under Section 279(1) 4 of the IT Act, and vide order dated 21.06.2018, accorded sanction to Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation), Chennai, (in short “DDIT”) to initiate prosecution against the appellant. Thereafter, respondent-DDIT filed complaint on 11.08.2018 against the appellant for an offence under Section 276C(1) alleging wilful attempt to evade tax with respect to assessment year 2017-2018 and for not filing the correct return of income.
4. Being aggrieved, the appellant filed quashing petition under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure (in short “CrPC”) being Crl. O.P. No. 28763 of 2018 along with Crl. M.P. Nos. 16786 and 16787 of 2018 praying for quashing of the complaint and pending proceedings. Pertinently, the appellant also filed an application under Section 245C5 of the IT Act on 07.12.2018 before the Settlement Commissioner, Additional Bench, Chennai, (in short “Settlement Commission”) disclosing the entire additional income and sought immunity from levy of penalty as well as prosecution in the matter of alleged evasion of proposed tax. The Settlement Commission in exercise of powers under Section 245D(4) 6 of IT Act, partly allowed the said application vide order dated 26.11.2019 and granted immunity from levy of penalty, refraining itself to grant immunity from prosecution due to pendency of quashing petition before the High Court of Madras.
5. By the order impugned, the High Court dismissed the quashing petition and referring the averments of the complaint observed that for the assessment year 2017-2018, the amount seized has not been shown in earnings, which may amount to evasion of proposed tax. The defence put forth by the appellant was that the seized amount was an earning of the assessment year 2016-2017 and not of assessment year 2017-2018 for which settlement has been arrived at as per the order of the Settlement Commission. The said defence did not find favour on the pretext that it can be taken by the 4 Prosecution to be at instance of Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner] or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner.
5 Application for settlement of cases.
6 Procedure on receipt of an application under Section 245 C. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2205Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
appellant during trial. It was also observed that the complaint was filed prior and the application before the Settlement Commission was subsequent, therefore, the stand of the appellant indicating that the seized amount was income of the assessment year 2016-2017 may also be looked into during trial. The question of competence of DDIT to initiate the prosecution against the appellant under Section 279(1) of the IT Act also did not turn in favour of the appellant in the order impugned.
ARGUMENTS OF THE APPELLANT
6. Mr. Preetesh Kapur, learned senior counsel for the appellant has strenuously urged that the order passed by the Settlement Commission in exercise of power under Sub-Section (4) of Section 245D shall be conclusive unless reopened as per Section 245D(6) within the time specified in sub-section (6B) of IT Act. In the present case, on receiving an application under Section 245C, the Settlement Commission passed an order granting immunity against levy of penalty in favour of the appellant, though rejected the plea for immunity from prosecution due to pendency of quash petition before the High Court. It is urged that the order of the Settlement Commission is conclusive in terms of Section 245-I 7 , with respect to the matters specified therein.
7. It is further urged that the guidelines dated 24.04.2008 issued by Ministry of Finance, Government of India, for ‘streamlining the procedure and to identify the cases for processing to lodge prosecution under Direct Tax law – matter reg.’, (in short “2008 circular”), has not been complied with by DDIT. Referring to clause (iii), it is said that in all cases where the penalty under Section 271(1)(C) exceeding Rs. 50,000/- is imposed and confirmed by Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (in short “ITAT”), the complaints may be filed within a period of 60 days of the receipt of the order of ITAT and not prior. Further, as per the ‘Prosecution Manual, 2009’, Clause 1.4 of Chapter III clearly stipulates when can prosecution be initiated. As per the Manual, it was advised that the initiation of prosecution under Section 276C(1) shall be only after confirmation of concealment and penalty by the ITAT. Recently on 09.09.2019, the Ministry of 7 Order of settlement to be conclusive.
2206 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Finance, Government of India, issued another notification laying down ‘procedure for identification and processing of cases for prosecution under Direct Tax Laws-reg.’ (in short “2019 circular’), whereby if the tax liability is below Rs. 25 lakhs, such cases shall not be processed for prosecution except with the previous administrative approval of the Collegium consisting of CCIT/DGIT rank officers and only after confirmation of the order imposing penalty by the ITAT.
8. In the instant case, the prosecution is with respect to the assessment year 2017-2018. As per the order of the Settlement Commission, the total undisclosed income has been shown as Rs. 61,50,000/-, to which the tax liability would come to less than Rs. 25 lakhs, therefore, without the permission of the Collegium, lodging of prosecution for the allegation below the said threshold lacked competence. Lastly, it is urged that after grant of immunity from the penalty by the Settlement Commission, continuation of the prosecution in violation of the guidelines would amount to gross abuse of the process of law, therefore, order impugned passed by the High Court may be set-aside quashing the complaint lodged by Revenue.
ARGUMENTS OF THE RESPONDENTS
9. Per contra, Ms. Nisha Baghchi, learned senior counsel for the revenue has vociferously contended that the complaint was filed by the respondent-DDIT prior to filing of application under Section 245C of the IT Act, therefore, in terms of the first proviso to Section 245H(1) 8 , appellant cannot be given any immunity from the prosecution. It is urged that the prosecution under Section 276C(1) against a person is for wilful attempt to evade any tax imposable or penalty or interest chargeable under the IT Act, and is penal in nature. In the facts of the present case, unaccounted cash was found at the residence of the appellant which was not disclosed in the return of the assessment year 2017-2018. Therefore, even after passing an order by the Settlement Commission, prosecution initiated prior to filing an application under Section 245C of IT Act are saved from granting immunity and can be proceeded with, however, the High Court was justified in dismissing the quash petition filed by the appellant.
8 Power of Settlement Commission to grant immunity from prosecution and penalty. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2207Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION
10. On the basis of the submissions as advanced by the learned senior counsel for the parties, in our view on the facts, the following questions fall for consideration:
i) Whether continuation of the prosecution initiated by the revenue under Section 276C(1) against the appellant after passing an order by the Settlement Commission, would amount to abuse of process of Court?
ii) Whether in the facts of the present case, the High Court was justified to dismiss the quashing petition filed by the appellant, and if not, what relief can be granted?
ANALYSIS AND APPRECIATION
11. Since both the said questions are inter-connected, therefore, the facts and legal points are appreciated simultaneously. In this relation, some of the relevant provisions of the IT Act are required to be referred, which are reproduced as under – “276C. Wilful attempt to evade tax, etc.—(1) If a person wilfully attempts in any manner whatsoever to evade any tax, penalty or interest chargeable [or imposable, or under reports his income,] under this Act, he shall, without prejudice to any penalty that may be imposable on him under any other provision of this Act, be punishable,—
(i) in a case where the amount sought to be evaded [or tax on under-reported income] exceeds [twentyfive hundred thousand rupees], with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than six months but which may extend to seven years and with fine;
(ii) in any other case, with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three months but which may extend to [two years] and with fine.
(2) If a person wilfully attempts in any manner whatsoever to evade the payment of any tax, penalty or interest under this Act, he shall, without prejudice to any penalty that may be imposable on him under any other provision of 2208 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports this Act, be punishable with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three months but which may extend to [two years] and shall, in the discretion of the court, also be liable to fine.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, a wilful attempt to evade any tax, penalty or interest chargeable or imposable under this Act or the payment thereof shall include a case where any person—
(i) has in his possession or control any books of account or other documents (being books of account or other documents relevant to any proceeding under this Act) containing a false entry or statement; or
(ii) makes or causes to be made any false entry or statement in such books of account or other documents; or
(iii) wilfully omits or causes to be omitted any relevant entry or statement in such books of account or other documents; or
(iv) causes any other circumstance to exist which will have the effect of enabling such person to evade any tax, penalty or interest chargeable or imposable under this Act or the payment thereof.”
12. From the above, it is clear that Section 276C deals with two situations. Sub-section (1) pertains to a wilful attempt to evade tax, penalty, or interest that is ‘chargeable’, ‘imposable’, or related to ‘under-reporting of income’. In contrast, sub-section (2) addresses the wilful attempt to evade the ‘payment’ of any tax, penalty, or interest under the Act. Therefore, both sub-sections operate in separate spheres and different stages. The fundamental distinction between the applicability of sub-section (1) and sub-section (2) lies to the stage at which the offence allegedly occurs. Section 276C(1) is primarily intended to deter and penalize wilful and deliberate attempts by an assessee for evasion of taxes, penalties and interest prior to their imposition or charging. The provision applies where there is a conscious and intentional effort to evade tax liability, distinguishing such conduct from bona-fide errors or differences in interpretation. The gist of the offence under sub-section (1) of Section 276C lies in the wilful attempt to evade the very imposition [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2209Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
of liability, and what is made punishable under this sub-section is not the ‘actual evasion’ but the ‘wilful attempt’ to evade as described in the proviso to Section 276C.
13. For the allegations as alleged against appellant, prosecution under Section 279(1) was initiated by respondent-DDIT in accordance with sanction given by PDIT. The appellant also challenged the jurisdiction of the DDIT before the High Court, contending that she was not competent to initiate prosecution under Section 279(1) of the IT Act. In the said context, it is relevant to refer Section 279 of IT Act, which is reproduced below for ready reference as thus:
“279. Prosecution to be at instance of Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner. —
(1) A person shall not be proceeded against for an offence under section 275A, [ section 275B,] section 276, section 276A, section 276B, section 276BB, section 276C, section 276CC,section 276D, 7[section 277 , section 277A or section 278] except with the previous sanction of the [Principal Commissioner or Commissioner] or Commissioner (Appeals) or the appropriate authority:
Provided that the [Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner] or, as the case may be, [Principal Director General or Director] General may issue such instructions or directions to the aforesaid income-tax authorities as he may deem fit for institution of proceedings under this sub-section.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, “appropriate authority” shall have the same meaning as in clause (c) of section 269UA.] (1A) A person shall not be proceeded against for an offence under section 276C or section 277 in relation to the assessment for an assessment year in respect of which the penalty imposed or imposable on him under [section 270A or] clause (iii) of sub-section (1) of section 271 has been reduced or waived by an order under section 273A.] 2210 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(2) Any offence under this Chapter may, either before or after the institution of proceedings, be compounded by the [Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief Commissioner] or a [Principal Director General or Director General].
(3) Where any proceeding has been taken against any person under sub-section (1), any statement made or account or other document produced by such person before any of the income-tax authorities specified in [clauses (a) to (g)] of section 116 shall not be inadmissible as evidence for the purpose of such proceedings merely on the ground that such statement was made or such account or other document was produced in the belief that the penalty imposable would be reduced or waived, [under section 273A] or that the offence in respect of which such proceeding was taken would be compounded.
[Explanation.—For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that the power of the Board to issue orders, instructions or directions under this Act shall include and shall be deemed always to have included the power to issue instructions or directions (including instructions or directions to obtain the previous approval of the Board) to other income-tax authorities for the proper composition of offences under this section.]”
14. From the above, in addition to the other offences, looking to the allegations of the present case, the prosecution under Section 276C may be lodged with permission of the PDIT. Sub-section (1)(a) creates a bar that the person shall not be proceeded under Section 276C in relation to the assessment for the assessment year of which penalty imposed or imposable on him, has been reduced or waived.
15. It is also pertinent to refer that the IT Act envisages a robust settlement mechanism under Chapter XIXA, which is titled – ‘Settlement of Cases’. It was inserted by means of the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Act, 1975 (41 of 1975) w.e.f. 01.04.1976. The said amendment was brought pursuant to the recommendations of the ‘Direct Taxes Enquiry Committee’, popularly known as the [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2211Vijay Krishnaswami @ Krishnaswami Vijayakumar v. The Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation)
‘Wanchoo Committee’, report of December, 1971. ‘Chapter 2’ of the said report, titled ‘Black Money and Tax Evasion’, in particular paragraphs 2.32 to 2.34 can be gainfully referred to in order to understand the intent and purpose behind setting up a settlement mechanism under the IT Act:
“Settlement Machinery 2.32 This, however, does not mean that the door for compromise with an errant taxpayer should forever remain closed. In the administration of fiscal laws, whose primary objective is to raise revenue, there has to be room for compromise and settlement. A rigid attitude would not only inhibit a one-time tax-evader or an unintending defaulter from making a clean breast of his affairs, but would also unnecessarily strain the investigational resources of the Department in cases of doubtful benefit to revenue, while needlessly proliferating litigation and holding up collections. We would, therefore, suggest that there should be a provision in the law for a settlement with the taxpayer at any stage of the proceedings. In the United Kingdom, the ‘confession’ method has been in vogue since 1923.
In the U.S. law also, there is a provision for compromise with the taxpayer as to his tax liabilities. A provision of this type facilitating settlement in individual cases will have this advantage over general disclosure schemes that misuse thereof will be difficult and the disclosure will not normally breed further tax evasion. Each individual case can be considered on its merits and full disclosures not only of the income but of the modus operandi of its buildup can be insisted on, thus sealing off chances of continued evasion through similar practices.
2.33 To ensure that the settlement is fair, prompt and independent, we would suggest that there should be a high-level machinery for administering the provisions, which would also incidentally relieve the field officer of an onerous responsibility and the risk of having to face adverse criticism which, we are told, has been responsible for the slow rate of disposal of disclosure petitions. We 2212 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports would, therefore, recommend that settlements may be entrusted to a separate body within the Department, to be called the Direct Taxes Settlement Tribunal. It will be a permanent body with three members. The strength of the Tribunal can be increased later, depending on the work-load. To ensure impartial and quick decisions, and to encourage officers with integrity and wide knowledge and experience to accept assignments on the Tribunal, we recommend that its members should be given the same status and emoluments as the members of the Central Board of Direct Taxes.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.