M/S Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 849; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 174
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice K.V. Viswanathan, Justice Joymalya Bagchi
- Decided
- 15 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9540/2018
- Sections
- 2A, 16(1), 7A, 7, 2, 25, 5, 106
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 174 : 2025 INSC 849 M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd.
v.
Union of India & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 9540 of 2018)
15 July 2025 [K.V. Viswanathan* and Joymalya Bagchi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the EPF Authorities were justified in treating the appellant and the Respondent No.3 as one unit for the purpose of the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952. Headnotes† Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 – s.2A – Establishment to include all departments and branches – Appellant’s unit manufactured tablets and syrups, while the Respondent No.3 manufactured injections and capsules – Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner (APFC) held that the appellant was part and parcel of the Respondent No.3 for the purpose of applicability of the EPF Act on account of having various common factors inter alia unity of management with commonality of some Directors belonging to the same HUF; unity of finance; both the units dealing with products of pharmaceutical industry, etc. – Order upheld by the Appellate Tribunal and High Court:
Held: Appellant and respondent No.3 were engaged in the same industry i.e. pharmaceutical; they carried on business in premises built on contiguous plots of land; shared common telephone and facsimile numbers; had common website and e-mail IDs; their Registered Office/Head Office and administrative office were the same; both employed common security to guard the premises; there was unity of management inasmuch as while the two brothers were Directors of respondent No.3; one of them was also the Director of the appellant while another brother and wife of one the brothers were Directors in the appellant Company – There was also unity of finance inasmuch as the HUF of one the brothers and his family members funded both the companies – These findings by the APFC cumulatively establish beyond doubt that the two entities were * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 175M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. rightly treated as common for the purpose of the EPF Act – Plea of the appellant that since the appellant and respondent No.3 are two different juristic entities thus, s.2A cannot be applied and also, the theory of clubbing cannot be invoked is rejected – Authorities justified in seeking remittance of the dues from September 1995 – No merit in the appeal – Theory of clubbing. [Paras 12, 31, 34-37] Theory of clubbing – Determination of unity of ownership; unity of management and control; features demonstrating the presence of functional integrality – Tests for:
Held: No absolute and invariable test can be laid down for all cases – The real purpose of the test is to find out the true relation between the Parts, Branches and Units – If in their true relation they constitute one integrated whole, it could be said that establishment is one and if not, they are to be treated as separate units – Each case has to be decided on its own peculiar facts, with regard to the scheme and object of the statute under consideration and in the context of the claim – In a given case, unity of ownership, management and control may be the important test, while in certain other cases Functional Integrality or general unity may be the determinative consideration – In some instances, unity of employment could be the most vital test – The employer/management’s own conduct in mixing up or not mixing up the capital, staff and management could in a given case be a significant pointer – Mere separate registration under the different statutes cannot be a basis to claim that the units are separate – Similarly, maintenance of separate accounts and independent financial statement is also not conclusive – Onus lies on the employer/management to lead necessary evidence to bring home their contention – Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 – s.2A. [Para 34] Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 – s.2A – Establishment to include all departments and branches – Plea of the appellant that since the appellant and respondent No.3 are two different juristic entities thus, s.2A cannot be applied and also, the theory of clubbing cannot be invoked:
Held: Rejected – While s.2A sets out that the establishment will include all departments and branches it does not deal with a scenario as to the tests for determining whether two juristic entities are set up as an artificial device and subterfuge to sidestep the provisions of the Act – Artificial devices, subterfuges and facades are commonly 176 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports resorted to, to create a smokescreen of separate entities for a variety of purposes – Courts faced with such a scenario have a duty to lift the veil and see behind applying the well-established tests to determine whether the entities are really separate entities or are they really a single entity – Hence, the contention that s.2A cannot be applied if ostensibly two separately registered entities under the Companies Act are involved is rejected, especially when the Court is interpreting a beneficial legislation like the EPF Act. [Paras 12, 31] Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 – s.16(1)(d) – Benefit of infancy protection for the period 26.09.1995 to 22.09.1997 u/s.16(1)(d) as it then stood, if to be given: Held: No – In the present case, the claim for infancy protection under the erstwhile s.16(1)(d) would not arise in view of the finding of clubbing – Being an integrated unit of respondent no.3 since 1995, no separate infancy protection will enure to the benefit of appellant. [Para 36] Case Law Cited Management of Pratap Press, New Delhi v. Secretary, Delhi Press Workers’ Union, Delhi and Another, AIR 1960 SC 1213; Regional Provident Fund Commissioner and Another v. Dharamsi Morarji Chemical Co. Ltd. (1998) 2 SCC 446; Regional Provident Fund Commr. v. Raj’s Continental Exports (P) Ltd. [2007] 3 SCR 636 : (2007) 4 SCC 239; Associated Cement Companies Limited, Chaibassa Cement Works, Jhinkpani v. Workmen [1960] 1 SCR 703 : AIR 1960 SC 56; L.N. Gadodia & Sons v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner [2011] 11 SCR 5008 : (2011) 13 SCC 517; Shree Vishal Printers Ltd. v. Provident Fund Commissioner [2019] 12 SCR 146 : (2019) 9 SCC 508; Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. Naraini Udyog [1996] Supp. 3 SCR 202 : (1996) 5 SCC 522; Sayaji Mills Ltd. v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner [1985] 2 SCR 516 : (1984) Supp. SCC 610; The Honorary Secretary, South India Millowners’ Association and Others v. The Secretary, Coimbatore Distruict Textile Workers’ Union [1962] Supp. 2 SCR 926; Management of Wenger and Co. v. Their Workmen [1963] Supp. 2 SCR 862; Rajasthan Prem Krishan Goods Transport Co. v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, New Delhi and Others, [1996] Supp. 3 SCR 1 : (1996) 9 SCC 454; Sumangali v. Regional Director, Employees’ State Insurance Corporation [2008] 10 SCR 1129 : (2008) 9 SCC 106 – referred to.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 177M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. List of Acts Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952.
List of Keywords Establishment to include all departments and branches; One unit for the purpose of the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952; Two entities treated as common for the purpose of the EPF Act; Common factors; Both units dealing with products of Pharmaceutical industry; Both units engaged in the same industry; Part and parcel; Tablets and syrups, Injections and capsules; Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner (APFC); Business in premises built on contiguous plots of land; Common telephone and facsimile numbers; Common website and e-mail IDs; Same registered Office/Head Office and administrative office; Common security to guard the premises; Unity of ownership; Unity of finance; Unity of management; Two different juristic entities; Theory of clubbing invoked; Remittance of the dues; Functional integrality; General unity; Unity of employment; Mixing up/not mixing up the capital, staff and management; Separate registration under different statutes; Separate units; Maintenance of separate accounts; Independent financial statement; Artificial devices, subterfuges and facades; Duty to lift the veil; Infancy protection; Integrated unit; Beneficial legislation; Unity of labour; Transferability of employees.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9540 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.04.2016 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Indore in WP No. 2503 of 2011 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Gagan Gupta, Sr. Adv., Ananta Prasad Mishra.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Brijender Chahar, A.S.G., Vishnu Jain, Ms. Mani Munjal, Shantanu Sharma, Aaditya Dixit, Amrish Kumar, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Siddharth, Prateek Goyal, Harshit Manwani, Ujjwal Singh. 178 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. The present appeal arises out of a judgment and order of the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore dated 22.04.2016 in Writ Petition No. 2503 of 2011. By the said judgment and order, the High Court dismissed the writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India filed by the appellantherein and upheld the order of the Employees’ Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal, (for short ‘the Appellate Tribunal’) New Delhi dated 24.01.2011 which order had, in turn, upheld the order dated 17.02.2006 passed by the Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, (for short ‘APFC’) Indore. The APFC had held that the appellant was part and parcel of M/s Vindas Chemical Industries Private Limited (hereinafter referred to as ‘Vindas’) – the third respondent herein for the purpose of applicability of the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (for short the ‘EPF Act’) with effect from September, 1995. Appropriate consequential directions to remit the dues were also passed. Aggrieved by the judgment and order of the High Court, the appellant has preferred this appeal, by way of special leave.
BRIEF FACTS: -
2. Indisputably, on 22.11.1988, Dr. Darshan Kataria and his brother Niranjan Kataria set up the respondent No.3-Vindas for manufacturing injections and capsules of certain specified drugs.
2.1 The factory was situated at Plot No.65, Sector-1, Pithampur, District Dhar, Madhya Pradesh. Vindas was incorporated with the Registrar of Companies, Madhya Pradesh.
2.2 Subsequently, on 05.09.1990, Shri Vasudev Kataria and Smt. Rajni Kataria, wife of Darshan Kataria incorporated the appellant-Company with the Registrar of Companies in the State of Maharashtra. Later it transpires from the record that Mr. Darshan Kataria was also a director in the appellant- Company.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 179M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. 2.3 However, the factory of the appellant was set up and business of production of tablets and later liquid syrups was set up at Plot No. 65/1, Sector-1, Pithampur, Dhar, Madhya Pradesh. It is also undisputed that Vindas was covered under the EPF Act. 2.4 Inspections were carried out at the appellant’s premises on 17/20.01.2005 and a communication was sent on 24.01.2005 to deposit the provident fund contribution and administrative charges w.e.f. 01.04.2004, though it was mentioned that the date was liable to change and a final decision would be taken after the inspection of previous records.
2.5 The appellant, by its reply of 04.02.2005, opposed the applicability of the EPF Act on the ground that the workers/ employees did not exceed the prescribed number. It must also be pointed out that in the communication of 20.01.2005, the issue that was highlighted by the Department was about the number of employees exceeding twenty.
2.6 Another inspection was carried out on 28.03.2005 and in the inspection note it was categorically stated that the establishment of the appellant was situated within the premises of Vindas-the third respondent and common security was employed for both the establishments and that the Managing Director of Vindas was Dr. Darshan Kataria.
2.7 Thereafter, on 29.04.2005, a summons to appear in person under Section 7A of the EPF Act was issued to the appellant. Section 7A empowers the authorities to conduct such enquiry as they may deem necessary and pass orders with regard to disputes about coverage of establishments under the EPF Act. The appellant was asked to produce all the attested copies of the relevant records to determine the amount due for the period April, 2004 to March, 2005.
2.8 The appellant, though by its reply dated 03.05.2005, denied any liability however, stated that they were voluntarily accepting coverage of the unit and will start contributing from 01.04.2005. Hence, this appeal really concerns the period prior to 01.04.2005 and the liability thereon. The appellant also responded to the summons by its letters of 13.06.2005, 10.10.2005 and 17.10.2005.
180 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 2.9 What is significant is in the submission of 10.10.2005, the appellant adverted to the proceedings at the hearing on 23.09.2005 wherein they were informed that the authorities are evaluating the possibility of clubbing the unit of the appellant with Vindas-respondent No.3 and that the appellant was provided with the inspection reports of the unit of Vindas- Respondent No.3. The appellant also in the submission of 10.10.2005 dealt with in detail as to how clubbing with Vindas- Respondent No.3 was not warranted and how the appellant was an independent and separate entity.
2.10 It is also not in dispute that the Inspection Report of 28.03.2005 along with the Inspection Report of 17.01.2005 and 20.01.2005 have been furnished to the appellant on 10.10.2005, as set out in the written submissions filed before us.
2.11 When matters stood thus, it appears that there was a further report of 10.11.2005 where again clubbing of the two units, namely, of the appellant and of Vindas was adverted to by the Department to which the appellant filed its submission on 20.12.2005 disputing the said position.
2.12 On 17.02.2006, the APFC passed an order rejecting the contentions of the appellant, including the contention on the locus standi of the Trade Union which had raised the issue of the two units being the same by holding that the issue of locus standi was immaterial if otherwise a case for clubbing was established. The APFC found the following common factors:a) that both the units dealt with products of pharmaceutical industry;
b) that both worked from the same premises with the common entry and without any visible demarcation with addresses of the appellant being Plot No. 65/1, Sector-1, Pithampur and of Vindas – Respondent No.3 being Plot No. 65, Sector-1, Pithampur, District Dhar;
c) that the telephone nos. of both the appellant and Vindasrespondent No.3 were common and the order set out the actual telephone no. That the entire factory was guarded by the same security personnel, namely, M/s Benaras Security Services;
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 181M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. d) that both the companies maintained their common Administrative Office at 102, Prabhudeep Apartment, 11 Indrapuri Colony, Indore and the Administrative Office had common telephone nos. and facsimile no.;
e) That the two companies shared the same website and same e-mail IDs;
f) that the Registered Office of the appellant at 210, Adamji Building, 413, Narsi Natha Street, Masjid Bunder Road, Mumbai was the Head Office of Respondent No.3-Vindas with same telephone no. and facsimile no.
g) That there was commonality of some Directors and that too belonging to the same Hindu Undivided Family.;
h) That the source of finance was the same Hindu Undivided Family in the name of Director, Creditor or Shareholder; 2.13 In view of this, the APFC found that there was Unity of Purpose and Functional Integrality as there was common factory, common administration/Head Office/Registered Office, common e-mail ID/website and common source of finance.
The APFC disregarded the aspect of separate registration with the Registrar of Companies and different Government Departments and held that the two units are one and the same for the purpose of the EPF Act.
2.14 The appellant filed an appeal under Section 7-I of the EPF Act before the Appellate Tribunal. According to the appellant, after the Appellate Tribunal adjourned the hearing to 09.12.2010, the files were not traceable and no further notice of hearing after 09.12.2010 was received. In spite of that, on 24.01.2011, the Appellate Tribunal dismissed the appeal.
2.15 A Writ Petition being W.P. No. 2503 of 2011 filed before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Indore Bench was unsuccessful. That is how the case presents itself before us.
CONTENTIONS OF LEARNED COUNSEL: -
3. We have heard Mr. Gagan Gupta, learned Senior Advocate, for the appellant and Mr. Siddharth, learned counsel for the APFC- Respondent No. 2 Authorities and Mr. Brijender Chahar, learned Additional Solicitor General for the Union of India.
182 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. Mr. Gagan Gupta, learned Senior Advocate, contends that initially the Authorities proceeded on the basis of the numerical strength of the employees being in excess of 20 at the appellant’s unit and the aspect of clubbing was introduced as an afterthought. That notice of clubbing ought to have been issued to Vindas-respondent No.3 instead of issuing to the appellant; that Section 2A of the EPF Act cannot apply to two juristic entities; that both the appellant and the respondent No.3-Vindas are separately registered under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, the Factories Act, 1948 and the two entities hold separate account numbers/registrations under the Central Sales Tax, Central Excise, Service Tax, ESI and also hold separate PAN and Corporate Identification Nos.
5. Learned Senior Advocate contends that the electricity and water connections for both the establishments are separate and that the Municipal Corporation Property Tax is being separately levied. Learned Senior Advocate further contends that the summon issued was for the period April, 2004 to March, 2005. However, the APFC, by its order, has directed compliance from September, 1995. Learned Senior Advocate contents that admittedly there was no interchange of employees. Learned Senior Advocate relied on the award of the Labour Court dated 21.07.2010 where the stand of the employees of the appellant that they should be permitted to work at Respondent No.3-Vindas was rejected. Learned Senior Advocate contended that there was no functional integrality or interdependence between the two establishments and that while the appellant manufactures tablets and syrup, respondent No.3-Vindas manufactures injections and capsules. Without prejudice, learned Senior Advocate contends that in the event of the submissions being rejected, the benefit of infancy protection be given for the period 26.09.1995 to 22.09.1997 under Section 16(1)(d) of the EPF Act as it then stood. Learned Senior Advocate relied on the judgments of this Court in Management of Pratap Press, New Delhi vs. Secretary, Delhi Press Workers’ Union, Delhi and Another, AIR1960 SC 1213, Regional Provident Fund Commissioner and Another vs. Dharamsi Morarji Chemical Co. Ltd., (1998) 2 SCC 446 and Regional Provident Fund Commr. vs. Raj’s Continental Exports (P) Ltd, (2007) 4 SCC 239 in support of his submissions.
6. Mr. Siddharth, learned counsel for the EPF Authorities countered the submissions by contending that the question as to what constitutes an establishment is a mixed question of fact and law which ought to [2025] 8 S.C.R. 183M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. be answered in the context of the facts of the given case, keeping in mind the object of the statute. The learned counsel contended that the appellant and Vindas-Respondent No.3 constituted a common establishment for the purpose of the EPF Act and that the findings of the APFC on the aspect of the two entities being engaged in the pharmaceutical business, carrying on the business in the same factory premises by sharing the common telephone/facsimile nos., same website and e-mail ID called for no interference. According to the learned counsel the unity in management and unity in finance and the existence of common administrative/Head Office/Registered Office also pointed to the functional integrality. Learned counsel contended that the burden to establish that there was no unity was on the appellant which the appellant failed to discharge; that since the appellant and respondent No.3 would be collectively assessed but since the liability will be only for the respective employees of the units there was no need to issue separate summons to Vindas- Respondent No.3; that the order of the Labour Court cannot bind the authorities under the EPF Act as the rights under the two Acts are different and that the Labour Court when it decided that there was no unity of employment did not have occasion to deal with the other aspects dealt with by the APFC. Learned counsel refuted the arguments of the appellant that they were not heard by the Tribunal since no document was placed to establish the fact that no notice was issued to the appellant by the Tribunal and that, in any event, the said argument was not raised before the High Court. Learned counsel relied on the judgments of this Court in Associated Cement Companies Limited, Chaibassa Cement Works, Jhinkpani vs. Workmen, AIR 1960 SC 56, L.N. Gadodia & Sons vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, (2011) 13 SCC 517, Shree Vishal Printers Ltd. vs. Provident Fund Commissioner, (2019) 9 SCC 508 and Regional Provident Fund Commissioner vs. Naraini Udyog, (1996) 5 SCC 522 to make good his submissions.
7. We have considered the submissions of the respective parties and carefully perused the records of the case.
QUESTION FOR CONSIDERATION: -
8. The question that arises for consideration is whether the EPF Authorities were justified in treating the appellant and the Vindas- Respondent No. 3 as one unit for the purpose of the EPF Act? 184 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
CERTAIN PRELIMINARY ASPECTS: -
9. Before we deal with the main issue, we would, at the outset, dispose of certain preliminary points raised for consideration. The aspect of violation of natural justice before the Tribunal was not argued before the High Court. In any event, we are considering the matter in detail on merits here and, as such, that aspect need not detain us any further. The contention based on the award of the Labour Court dated 21.07.2010 also does not carry the case of the appellant any further. First of all, the APFC, by its order of 17.02.2006, elaborately considered the matter applying the various tests and concluded that the two units are the same for the purpose of the EPF Act. The issue before the Labour Court was about the entitlement of the workers of the appellant to claim employment in Vindas-respondent No.3 and while answering that reference the Labour Court held that there was no clear evidence regarding the aspect of the workers of the appellant having worked in the unit of respondent No.3-Vindas. None of the other indicia for clubbing referred to by the APFC were considered relevant. In any case, in view of the multiplicity of factors adverted to by the APFC, the award has no bearing for the determination of the issue.
ANALYSIS AND REASONS: -
EPF ACT - A BENEFICIAL LEGISLATION
10. The EPF Act is a beneficial legislation intended to provide for the institution of provident funds, pension fund and deposit-linked insurance fund for employees in factories and other establishments. It is a welfare legislation intended to ameliorate the conditions of workmen in factories and other establishments. This Court in Sayaji Mills Ltd. vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, 1984 Supp. SCC 610 has held that the EPF Act should be construed so as to advance the object with which it is passed and any construction which would facilitate evasion of the provisions of the Act should be avoided.
LAW ON CLUBBING: -
11. The crucial issue that arises for consideration in this case is - whether the authorities were justified in treating the appellant and Vindasrespondent No.3 as one unit for the purpose of the EPF Act and [2025] 8 S.C.R. 185M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. were the correct tests to determine the same applied? Section 2-A of the EPF Act reads as under:- “2A. Establishment to include all departments and branches.—For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that where an establishment consists of different departments or has branches, whether situate in the same place or in different places, all such departments or branches shall be treated as parts of the same establishment.”
12. The argument of the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant that since the appellant and Vindas-respondent No.3 are two different juristic entities and that would not be covered within the sweep of Section 2A is only stated to be rejected. While Section 2A sets out that the establishment will include all departments and branches it does not deal with a scenario as to the tests for determining whether two juristic entities are set up as an artificial device and subterfuge to sidestep the provisions of the Act.
13. The question in this case has to be answered by applying the wellestablished theories to determine what would constitute unity of ownership or unity of management and control and the features that will demonstrate the presence of functional integrality. This issue is no longer res integra and has been settled by a long line of judgments of this Court.
14. The earliest case where this issue was discussed was in Associated Cement Companies Ltd. (supra) where this Court had to examine the question whether the lay off of the workers in certain sections of the Chaibasa Cement Works due to a strike on the part of the workmen at the Rajanka limestone quarry was justified under Section 25-E (iii) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Section 25-E (iii) of the I.D. Act stated that no compensation was to be paid to workmen who have been laid off due to a strike or slowing-down of production on the part of workmen in another part of establishment. In the process of examining the said question, this Court held as under:- “11. The Act not having prescribed any specific tests for determining what is ‘one establishment’, we must fall back on such considerations as in the ordinary industrial or business sense determine the unity of an industrial establishment, having regard no doubt to the scheme and 186 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports object of the Act and other relevant provisions of the Mines Act, 1952, or the Factories Act, 1948. What then is ‘one establishment’ in the ordinary industrial or business sense? The question of unity or oneness presents difficulties when the industrial establishment consists of parts, units, departments, branches etc. If it is strictly unitary in the sense of having one location and one unit only, there is little difficulty in saying that it is one establishment. Where, however, the industrial undertaking has parts, branches, departments, units etc. with different locations, near or distant, the question arises what tests should be applied for determining what constitutes ‘one establishment’. Several tests were referred to in the course of arguments before us, such as, geographical proximity, unity of ownership, management and control, unity of employment and conditions of service, functional integrality, general unity of purpose etc. To most of these we have referred while summarising the evidence of Mr Dongray and the findings of the Tribunal thereon. It is, perhaps, impossible to lay down any one test as an absolute and invariable test for all cases. The real purpose of these tests is to find out the true relation between the parts, branches, units etc. If in their true relation they constitute one integrated whole, we say that the establishment is one; if on the contrary they do not constitute one integrated whole, each unit is then a separate unit. How the relation between the units will be judged must depend on the facts proved, having regard to the scheme and object of the statute which gives the right of unemployment compensation and also prescribes disqualification therefor. Thus, in one case the unity of ownership, management and control may be the important test; in another case functional integrality or general unity may be the important test; and in still another case, the important test may be the unity of employment. Indeed, in a large number of cases several tests may fall for consideration at the same time. The difficulty of applying these tests arises because of the complexities of modern industrial organisation; many enterprises may have functional integrality between factories which are separately owned; some may be integrated in part with [2025] 8 S.C.R. 187M/s Torino Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. units or factories having the same ownership and in part with factories or plants which are independently owned. In the midst of all these complexities it may be difficult to discover the real thread of unity. In an American decision (Donald L. Nordling v. Ford Motor Company, (1950) 28 AIR, 2d 272 there is an example of an industrial product consisting of 3800 or 4000 parts, about 900 of which came out of one plant; some came from other plants owned by the same Company and still others came from plants independently owned, and a shutdown caused by a strike or other labour dispute at any one of the plants might conceivably cause a closure of the main plant or factory.”
15. As was rightly pointed out, it is impossible to lay down any one test as an absolute and invariable test for all cases.
16. Associated Cement Companies Ltd. (supra) was followed in Pratap Press (supra). In Pratap Press (supra), the issue was whether the profit or loss of the Press and the publications “Vir Arjun” and “Daily Pratap” were to be pooled for the question of deciding bonus. While the employer contended that the press and Vir Arjun were one establishment and Daily Pratap was a separate partnership firm, the workers contended that the accounts of all the three should be taken into account or alternatively only the Press should be taken into account. While answering the issue, the Court acknowledged that the question whether the two activities in which the single owner is engaged are one industrial unit or two distinct industrial units was not always easy of solution and no hard and fast rule could be laid down. It was also acknowledged that each case has to be decided on its own peculiar facts. It was held that in some cases, two activities would be so closely linked that no reasonable man would consider them as independent industries. Para 2 of the said judgment is set out hereunder:- “2. The question whether the two activities in which the single owner is engaged are one industrial unit or two distinct industrial units is not always easy of solution. No hard and fast rule can be laid down for the decision of the question and each case has to be decided on its own peculiar facts. In some cases the two activities each of which by itself comes within the definition of industry are so closely linked together that no reasonable man would 188 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports consider them as independent industries. There may be other cases where the connection between the two activities is not by itself sufficient to justify an answer one way or the other, but the employer’s own conduct in mixing up or not mixing up the capital, staff and management may often provide a certain answer”.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.