Powergrid Corporation of India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 626; [2025] 6 S.C.R. 123
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 4 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5857/2011
- Sections
- 125, 110, 76(1), 38, 178
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 123 : 2025 INSC 626 Powergrid Corporation of India Limited v.
Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 5857-5858 of 2011)
05 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The questions arose for consideration whether the appellate tribunal and Central Electricity Regulatory Commission justified in rejecting the appellant’s claim of additional capitalization due to replacement of the damaged Inter-connecting Transformers-ICTs; whether the self-insurance policy of the appellant covered the cost of replacement of the damaged ICTs; and whether the Member Secretary of NRPC should have been directed by the appellate tribunal to issue revised availability certificate for the transmission assets.
Headnotes† Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2004 – Reg. 53 – Additional capitalisation – Claim of – Appellant owned and operated transmission systems in the northern region-R I and R II – Inter-connecting transformers in the R I transmission system got burnt and damaged due to internal faults – Transformers from R II temporarily taken out and diverted to R I – Appellant restored the transformers at R-1 and ICTs taken out from R II were restored by new/repaired transformers – Petition by the appellant before the respondent-CERC claiming decapitalization for the transformers taken out from R II and additional capitalization for the new/repaired transformer installed at R I – Claim not allowed by CERC holding that the net cost for such replacement has to be met out from the insurance fund reserve maintained by the appellant under the internal insurance policy; and also did not accede to the prayer of the appellant for giving directions to the Northern Regional Power Committee for issuance of revised availability certificate – Appeal thereagainst, dismissed by the appellate tribunal – Interference:
* Author 124 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: Not called for – Appellate tribunal and CERC justified in rejecting the appellant’s claim of additional capitalization due to replacement of the damaged ICTs – Reg. 53 provides that additional capital expenditure incurred after the commercial operation date and upto the cut-off-date may be admitted by the CERC if such expenditure relates to deferred liabilities, deferred works, procurement of initial spares, etc. – Reg. 53 does not include within its scope replacement of transformers due to damage or failure – As per Reg. 53(2)(iv) any additional work/services which becomes necessary for the efficient and successful operation of the project but not included in the original project cost may be admitted by CERC as additional capital expenditure – All that the appellant had done was diversion and replacement of transformers which cannot be construed as doing any additional work/services u/Reg.53(2)(iv) – Nothing on record to show that prior to the breakdown of transformers the transmission systems were in bad shape or had started wearing out – As regards the self-insurance policy, the loss caused to the appellant by fire would be covered by the policy as it covered all fires which caused loss without any exception and as all the ICTs were operating until those got burnt – Proximate cause for the damage to the transformers is the implosion/explosion in the internal/external machinery of the transformers which caused fire – Self-insurance policy of the appellant covered the cost of replacement of the damaged ICTs – Appellate tribunal justified in directing the appellant to finance the net cost from the self-insurance fund reserve as part of the operation and maintenance charges – As decapitalization and additional capitalization of the replaced ICTs have not been allowed, issuance of direction to NRPC for revised availability certificate for the transmission assets does not arise. [Paras 28-35, 37-39] Case Law Cited New India Assurance Company Limited v. Zuari Industries Limited [2009] 13 SCR 1101 : (2009) 9 SCC 70 – relied on.
Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Renew Wind Energy (Rajkot) Private Limited [2023] 7 SCR 670 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 411 – held inapplicable.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003; Electricity Regulatory Commission Act, 1998; Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2004.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 125Powergrid Corporation of India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.
List of Keywords Electricity; Central transmission utility; Transmission systems; Inter- State Transmission Systems; De-capitalization of transformers; Additional capitalization; Replacement for damaged transformers; Northern Regional Power Committee; Inter-connecting Transformers; Revision tariff; Self-insurance reserve policy; Fire risk; Machinery breakdown; Self-insurance reserve; Proximate cause; Revised availability certificate; Central Electricity Regulatory Commission; Cost of replacement of the damaged ICTs; Certificate for transmission assets; New/repaired transformers; Approval of transmission charges; Additional capital expenditure.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 5857-5858 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.03.2011 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity in Appeal Nos. 91-92 of 2009 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. Swapna Seshadri, Pramod Dayal, Nikunj Dayal, Utkarsh Singh, Ms. Sneha Singh Baghel.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Pradeep Misra, Daleep Dhyani, Manoj Kumar Sharma.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
This order will dispose of both Civil Appeal Nos. 5857 and 5858 of 2011.
2. Since both the civil appeals filed by the appellant under Section 125 of the Electricity Act, 2003 arise out of the common order dated 23.03.2011 passed by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity in Appeal Nos. 91-92 of 2009 with the issue being inter-related and between the same parties, both the appeals were heard together and are being disposed of by this common order.
126 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3. Appellant in this case is Powergrid Corporation of India Limited.
4. In Appeal No. 91 of 2009, the challenge made was to the order dated 03.02.2009 passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission in Petition No. 68 of 2008. In Appeal No. 92 of 2009, challenge made was to the order dated 03.02.2009 passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission in Petition No. 80/2008. Both Appeal Nos. 91 and 92 of 2009 were dismissed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission vide the order dated 23.03.2011 (impugned order).
5. Hence, the two appeals.
6. This Court by order dated 01.08.2011 had issued notice.
7. Relevant facts may be briefly noted.
8. Appellant Powergrid Corporation of India Limited (for short ‘Powergrid’) is a public sector undertaking of the Government of India. It is mainly engaged in the business of transmission of power through its transmission network. It discharges its statutory functions under the Electricity Act, 2003 and transmits electricity throughout the country. On the other hand, respondent No. 1 is the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission. It is a statutory body established under the provisions of the erstwhile Electricity Regulatory Commission Act, 1998 (since repealed). After coming into force of the Electricity Act, 2003, the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (‘CERC’ for short) began to exercise its functions under the said statute.
9. At the relevant point of time, appellant was a central transmission utility responsible for establishing transmission assets of Inter- State Transmission Systems (‘ISTS’ for short) dealing with planning and transmission of electricity. Amongst others, appellant owned and operated two transmission systems in the northern region: Rihand I and Rihand II. Rihand I comprises of Mandola and Ballabgarh sub-stations whereas Rihand II comprises of Kaithal, Mainpuri and Abdullapur sub-stations. Rihand I had three Inter-connecting Transformers (‘ICT’ for short): one at Ballabgarh and two at Mandola. Rihand II had four ICTs: two at Kaithal and two at Mainpuri.
10. Between 28.04.2006 and 09.05.2006, all the three transformers in the Rihand I transmission system failed and broke down. In fact, those [2025] 6 S.C.R. 127Powergrid Corporation of India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.
were burnt and damaged due to internal faults. Considering that it was peak summer season with high anticipated load demand in the National Capital Territory of Delhi, the transformers were required to be replaced immediately. According to the appellant, procurement of new transformers would have taken a long time. Therefore, it was decided to temporarily take out one transformer each from Mainpuri and Kaithal sub-stations and to divert the same to Ballabgarh and Mandola. It was also decided to divert one transformer which was procured for Bahadurgarh sub-station to Mandola as commissioning at Bahadurgarh was scheduled later.
11. Accordingly, appellant restored the transformers at Ballabgarh and Mandola during the period from 29.05.2006 to 19.06.2006. The ICTs that were taken out from Mainpuri and Kaithal were restored by January and February, 2007 by new/repaired transformers.
12. Thereafter, appellant filed a petition before the CERC for approval of the transmission charges for the three replaced ICTs in Rihand I based on the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2004 (referred to hereinafter as ‘the Tariff Regulations’). The said petition was registered as Petition No. 68 of 2008. Appellant claimed de-capitalization for the transformers taken out from Mainpuri and Kaithal and additional capitalization for the new/repaired transformer originally procured for Bahadurgarh sub-station and installed at the two sub-stations of Mandola and Ballabgarh.
13. By order dated 03.02.2009, CERC did not allow the claim of the appellant and dismissed Petition No. 68 of 2008.
14. Aggrieved thereby, appellant preferred Appeal No. 91 of 2009 before the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (‘Appellate Tribunal’ for short).
15. On 09.05.2006, the tariff for the Rihand transmission systems were determined by the CERC for the period from 01.04.2004 to 02.04.2009. On 04.09.2008, appellant filed a petition before the CERC for revision of tariff in respect of the Rihand transmission system for the period upto 02.04.2009 considering the net additional capitalization on account of replacement of the three burnt ICTs at Mandola and Ballabgarh. Appellant also sought for a direction to the Northern Regional Power Committee for issuance of revised 128 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports availability certificate excluding the period when the three ICTs were decapitalized and not in use. According to the appellant, an availability certificate was required for claiming full transmission charges and incentives. It was registered as Petition No. 80 of 2008.
16. CERC vide the order dated 03.02.2009 disallowed the claim of the appellant for decapitalization of the damaged transformers and recapitalization of the installed transformers as replacement for the damaged transformers. CERC further held that the net cost for such replacement has to be met out from the insurance fund reserve maintained by the appellant under the internal insurance policy for which contribution was being paid by the beneficiaries in the form of operations and maintenance expenses. Further, CERC also did not accede to the prayer of the appellant for giving directions to the Northern Regional Power Committee for issuance of revised availability certificate. Accordingly, vide the aforesaid order dated 03.02.2009, Petition No. 80 of 2008 filed by the appellant was dismissed.
17. This led to filing of Appeal No. 92 of 2009 by the appellant before the Appellate Tribunal. Both the appeals were heard together by the Appellate Tribunal; and vide the impugned order dated 23.03.2011 dismissed the two appeals as being devoid of merit.
18. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that Appellate Tribunal had virtually rubber stamped the findings arrived at by the CERC. That apart it had interpreted Regulation 53(2)(iv) and Note 2 of the Tariff Regulations in a most illogical manner. If this is the interpretation, then no transmission licensee will ever get additional capitalization on restoration and replacement of the ICTs. He also submits that interpretation of the Appellate Tribunal viz-a-viz the self-insurance policy is wholly illogical without appreciating that the fire had occurred as a result of the machinery breakdown and hence it is not covered under the self-insurance policy.
18.1. Because of such erroneous decision, appellant has been denied Rs. 15.63 crores on account of capitalization and Rs. 4.58 crores on account of tariff qua Rihand I transmission system and Rs. 3.54 crores on account of capitalization qua Rihand II transmission system.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 129Powergrid Corporation of India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.
18.2. He submits that in April-May, 2006, the three ICTs at Mandola and Ballabhgarh were damaged due to internal faults i.e. machinery breakdown which resulted in the burning of the ICTs.
19. Learned counsel again referred to Regulation 53(2) of the Tariff Regulations and submits that any work that may be required to be done by a transmission licensee for successfully operating the transmission system is permissible expenditure for capitalization, whether it is a new work or a replacement. Any other interpretation would render the aforesaid provision particularly Note 2 meaningless. Contrary to this Appellate Tribunal has returned a finding that replacement of ICTs/transformers is neither an additional work necessary for efficient and successful operation nor an old asset requiring replacement. Such a finding is unsustainable.
19.1. It is further submitted that Appellate Tribunal was not justified in denying decapitalization and additional capitalization of the ICTs on the ground that it was the responsibility of the appellant for maintenance of the transmission system. Appellant’s decapitalization and capitalization were under the terms of accepted accounting practice. By not factoring in the said expenditure as additional capitalization for the value of the ICTs has led to a non-cost reflective tariff being paid to the appellant. Finding rendered by the Appellate Tribunal that provisions of Regulation 53 of the Tariff Regulations does not cover replacement of damaged ICTs/transformers is incorrect for the reason that any additional expenditure is contemplated to be an additional capitalization if it relates to the efficient and successful operation of the project. Regulation 53 cannot be interpreted in a narrow and pedantic manner.
19.2. Referring to the self-insurance policy of the appellant, learned counsel submits that the same covers losses from fire, whether it is internal or external or even if it is due to machinery breakdown. Fire was not the direct cause of the damage to the ICTs/transformers; rather it was machinery failure that possibly led to the fire. Learned counsel submits that if the fire had caused the machinery breakdown, the coverage will be available under the self-insurance policy as the proximate cause in such a case would be the fire. In this connection he has placed reliance on a decision of 130 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports this Court in New India Assurance Company Limited Vs.
Zuari Industries Limited 1. He has also placed reliance on another decision of this Court in Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited Vs. Renew Wind Energy (Rajkot) Private Limited 2to contend that Appellate Tribunal virtually rubber stamped the decision of CERC.
20. On the other hand, learned counsel for some of the respondents i.e. respondent Nos.2 to 5 and 10, who are the beneficiaries, supported the order of CERC as well as that of the Appellate Tribunal.
20.1. It is submitted that appellant under the statute is under an obligation to maintain a healthy transmission system. For maintenance of the transmission system, the beneficiaries are not required to pay additional amount. The very concept of additional capitalization is based on the premise that in case any additional benefit is given to the beneficiaries, the amount can be capitalized. It is contended that by replacement of the failed transformers no additional benefit is given to the beneficiaries. Hence, the amount claimed for replacement of the transformers cannot be capitalized.
20.2. Appellant had also shown a huge figure as cost of the installed transformers though such transformers were not new ones. Actual cost of the transformers would be much less. The differential amount cannot be capitalized.
20.3. Adverting to Regulation 53 of the Tariff Regulations, it is submitted that additional capitalization can be claimed only in respect of the works in the original scope of the project. That apart, additional capitalization can be claimed due to change in law or on account of any award passed in arbitration, decree of court, etc. Replacement of transformers does not fall in any of such categories. Hence, the amounts claimed in both the appeals cannot be capitalized.
20.4. The self-insurance reserve policy of the appellant covers unsecured risks. The policy does not say that it will not cover the risk regarding failure of transformers. If the appellant had
1 (2009) 9 SCC 70
2 2023 SCC OnLine SC 411 [2025] 6 S.C.R. 131Powergrid Corporation of India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors.
not secured that risk in the policy, it cannot be allowed to penalise the beneficiaries.
20.5. Learned counsel has also justified the decision of the Appellate Tribunal declining to issue directions to Northern Regional Power Committee (NRPC).
20.6. It is therefore submitted that there is no merit in the appeals which should be dismissed.
21. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
22. Upon perusal of the materials on record and after hearing learned counsel for the parties, we are of the view that the following questions arise for our consideration in this case:
1. Whether the Appellate Tribunal and respondent No.1 were justified in rejecting the claim made by the appellant of additional capitalization due to replacement of the damaged ICTs?
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.