Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 619; [2025] 6 S.C.R. 100
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 1 May 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5245/2024
- Sections
- 20, 15, 18, 2, 12, 164(5), 65, 22, 29(2), 3, 19, 17
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 100 : 2025 INSC 619 Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v.
High Court of Madras (Criminal Appeal No. 5245 of 2024)
02 May 2025 [Sudhanshu Dhulia and Prashant Kumar Mishra,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the charge of criminal contempt is proved against the appellants-contemnors beyond all reasonable doubt; whether the conviction of the appellants by the High Court for criminal contempt of Court and the sentence imposed ought to be upheld. Headnotes† Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 – ss.15(1) r/w 18(1) – In Execution Petition filed by the decree holder, contemnors produced interim orders passed by the High Court staying the decree – On verification it was found that the said orders were fraudulently created by committing forgery and impersonation in the name of the Judge of the High Court – High Court held the appellants responsible in preparation of the bogus High Court interim orders and held them guilty of contempt – Correctness:
Held: When a person is found to have utilised an order of a court which he or she knows to be incorrect for conferring benefit on persons who are not entitled to the same, the very utilisation of the fabricated order by the person concerned would be sufficient to hold him/her guilty of contempt, irrespective of the fact whether he or she himself or herself is the author of fabrication – High Court initiated suo motu contempt on proved and admitted facts that Contemnor No.3 produced fake interim orders of the High Court and the same were prepared by Contemnor No.4 and 7 – On facts, it is established beyond all reasonable doubt that the appellants-contemnors have either used or created fake High Court interim orders – It is not a case of mere probability of commission of offence rather it is a proved case of commission * Author [2025] 6 S.C.R. 101Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras of offence – Creating fake orders of the Court is one of the most dreaded acts of contempt of court – It not only thwarts the administration of justice, but it has inbuilt intention by committing forgery of record – Charge of contempt proved against the appellants beyond all reasonable doubt – Conviction confirmed, however, the sentence is modified from simple imprisonment for six months to simple imprisonment for one month – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.466, 468, 471. [Paras 8, 16, 17] Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 – s.20 – Limitation for actions for contempt – Originating point for calculating the period of limitation, as interpreted in Pallav Sheth’s case – Appellant pleaded that the entire contempt proceeding was barred by limitation since it should have been initiated within one year from date of production of fake interim orders i.e. 18.04.2018 however, the notice was issued after four years in 2022: Held: Contempt action must be initiated either by filing of an application or by the Court issuing notice suo motu within a period of one year from the date on which the contempt is alleged to have been committed – The writ petition for initiation of action against the appellants was filed by the Decree Holder on 20.08.2018 i.e. immediately after four months from 17.04.2018 when the fake orders were produced before the Court – On facts, it was on 05.09.2018 when the contempt proceedings were drawn by the High Court though actual notice was issued later on by the Division Bench in the year 2022 as the case bundle of writ petition was missing in the Registry of the High Court – However, it does not mean that the contempt was initiated in the year 2022 – As held in Pallav Sheth case, s.20 has to be construed in a manner which would avoid such an anomaly and concluded that the date of initiation of suo motu contempt action is regarded as the initiation by the Court for the purpose of s.20 – Therefore, initiation of contempt action shall be treated to have been taken on 05.09.2018 when Single Judge dealing with the writ petition so directed and this date being within one year from 17.04.2018 when the fake orders were presented before the Court, the present contempt action was not barred by limitation. [Paras 14, 15] Contempt of Court – Exercise of power – Object:
Held: The sole object of the Court wielding its power to punish for contempt is always for maintaining the purity of administration 102 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of justice – Nothing is more incumbent upon the courts of justice than to preserve their proceedings from being misrepresented, nor is there anything more pernicious when the order of the court is forged and produced to gain undue advantage. [Para 8] Case Law Cited Pallav Sheth v. Custodian & Ors. [2001] Supp. 1 SCR 387 : (2001) 7 SCC 549 – relied on.
In Re: Bineet Kumar Singh [2001] 3 SCR 424 : (2001) 5 SCC 501; In Re : Vinay Chandra Mishra [1995] 2 SCR 638 : (1995) 2 SCC 584; Pritam Pal v. High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur, through Registrar [1992] 1 SCR 864 : (1993) Supp. 1 SCC 529; Khushi Ram v. Sheo Vati & Anr. (1953) 1 SCC 726 – referred to. List of Acts Contempt of Courts Act, 1971; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Contempt of court; Criminal contempt; Contempt proceedings; Suo motu contempt action; Creating fake orders of the Court; Fraudulent creation of bogus orders; Creation of forged High Court order; Forgery of record; Forgery and impersonation in the name of the Judge of the High Court; Fake interim orders of the High Court; Charge of contempt proved; Beyond all reasonable doubt; Report of the CBCID; Tamil Nadu Forensic Science Laboratory; Probability of commission of offence; Contempt proceeding not barred by limitation; Utilisation of the fabricated order; Standard of strict proof.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No. 5245 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.08.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in SMCRLCP No. 2493 of 2022 With Criminal Appeal No. 4219 of 2024 and Criminal Appeal No. 2403 of 2025 [2025] 6 S.C.R. 103Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. Sonia Mathur, Nachiketa Joshi, S. Nagamuthu, Sr. Advs., Tadimalla Bhaskar Gowtham, Ms. Shubhi Bhardwaj, Subhodh Patil, Aditya Sharma, Ajay Awasthi, Alabhya Dhamija, Ms. Richa Vishwakarma, Ms. Shriya Gilhotra, Ms. Stuti Wason, Purushottam Tiwari, M.P. Parthiban, Bilal Mansoor, Shreyas Kaushal, S. Geyolin Selvam, Alagiri K, P. V. K. Deivendran, Vairawan A.S. Advs. for the Respondent:
S Guru Krishnakumar, Sr. Adv., Siddharth Naidu, Ashwin K, V. Balachandran, S. Hariharan, K. M. Kalidharun, Vikash Singh. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
Appeal arising out of Criminal Appeal Diary No. 45480 of 2024 is admitted.
2. The three appellants before us namely, Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan in Criminal Appeal No. 5245 of 2024 (Contemnor No. 4 before the High Court), M. Muruganandam in Criminal Appeal No. 4219 of 2024 (Contemnor No. 3 before the High Court) and S. Amal Raj in Criminal Appeal arising out of Criminal Appeal Diary No. 45480 of 2024 (Contemnor No. 7 before the High Court) stand convicted by the High Court for committing contempt of Court and have been sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of six months. The appellants have called in question the legality and validity of the judgment and order of the High Court in the present appeals.
FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The District Munsiff Court, Tiruchengode passed a decree dated 17.11.2004 in O.S. No. 212 of 2000 in favour of J.K.K. Rangammal Charitable Trust 1 ordering recovery of possession and arrears of 1 “Decree Holder”
104 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports rent from the Contemnor Nos. 1 to 3. The Contemnors preferred appeal suits which were dismissed. The Decree Holder preferred Execution Petition and when the Court Amin went to execute the decree to effect delivery of possession on 17.04.2018 the Contemnor Nos. 1 to 3 produced interim orders passed by the High Court of Madras in C.R.P. Nos. 1467 – 1469 of 2018 staying the decree.
3.1. The Decree Holder applied and obtained the copies of the said orders produced by the Contemnors in Execution Petition Nos. 14, 17 and 18 of 2014 and also entered caveat before the High Court. On verification, it was found, the said orders produced before the Execution Court were fraudulently created by committing forgery and impersonation in the name of the Judge of the High Court of Madras.
3.2. The Decree Holder submitted a complaint to the High Court and Superintendent of Police, Namakkal District on 03.05.2018 and 15.05.2018 respectively. The Registrar General, High Court, forwarded the complaint to the Superintendent of Police, Namakkal on 18.07.2018.
The Decree Holder then preferred W.P. No. 22410 of 2018 before the High Court to direct the Superintendent of Police, Namakkal to take action on the complaint dated 15.05.2018. In the meanwhile, First Information Report in Crime No. 8 of 2018 was registered by the District Crime Branch, Namakkal for offences under Sections 466, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 18602 against the Contemnor Nos. 1 to 3/Judgment Debtors. The writ petition was disposed of on 05.09.2018 directing the registry to place the matter before the Division Bench, dealing with the criminal contempt matters, after obtaining necessary orders from the Hon’ble Chief Justice, for the Division Bench to proceed with the matter in terms of Section 15 (1) read with Section 18 (1) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The Superintendent of Police, Namakkal District, was also directed to monitor the investigation in DCB Crime No. 8 of 2018.
2 ‘IPC’ [2025] 6 S.C.R. 105Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras
3.3. On 10.09.2018, the Contemnor No. 4/Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan 3 was arrested by the District Crime Branch, Namakkal and he made a statement about the manner in which the fake order copies were prepared with the help of Contemnor No. 6/P. Meiyappan 4 in a Digital Net Centre at Bhavani.
3.4. On 11.09.2018, Contemnor No. 3/M. Muruganandam 5 was arrested. He disclosed the manner in which the fraudulent order copies were obtained by the Contemnor No. 4 and Contemnor No. 7. The District Crime Branch, Namkkal completed the investigation and submitted a report on 14.08.2019 in C.C. No. 537 of 2020 before the Judicial Magistrate, Komarapalayam against the Contemnor Nos. 1 to 5.
3.5. On account of the case bundle relating to W.P. No. 22410 of 2018 missing in the Registry, the criminal contempt was not numbered from 2018 to 2022. On the Division Bench being informed regularly, the bundle was traced, and the contempt petition was numbered as 2493 of 2022. Initially, statutory notice was issued to the Contemnor Nos. 1 to 5 and thereafter to the Contemnor No. 6 and Contemnor No. 7 when they were also found to be involved in the process of preparation of the fake order of the High Court. Since the Contemnor nos. 1 and 2 died during proceedings, the same stood abated against them.
3.6. The Division Bench framed charges against Contemnor Nos. 1, 3, 4 & 5 on 19.12.2022 to the following effect:
“Since S. Sundaram (2nd contemnor) has died, no charge could be framed against him.
2 . T h a t , y o u , A n g a m u t h u ( 1 s t c o n t e m n o r ) , Muruganandam (3 rd contemnor), Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan (4th contemnor) and Thangamani (5th contemnor) along with the deceased Sundaram submitted the photocopies of the following three fake orders of this Court, all dated 12.03.2018 to 3 ‘C4’ 4 ‘C6’ 5 ‘C3’ 106 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the bailiff, when he came for executing the decree as set out above.
i. C.R.P.No.1467 of 2018 and C.M.P.No.2038 of 2018 ii. C.R.P.No.1468 of 2018 and C.M.P.No.2039 of 2018 and iii. C.R.P.No.1469 of 2018 and C.M.P.No.2040 of 2018 The above three orders appear to have been passed by Hon’ble Mrs. Justice Pushpa Sathyanarayana on 12.03.2018, whereas, the records of the Registry show that no such Civil Revision Petitions were even filed, and the said Hon’ble Judge was not holding the C.R.P. roster on 12.03.2018 and therefore, it is evident that these three orders have been fabricated.”
3.7. Basing the affidavits filed by the Contemnor Nos. 1 and 3 to 5, during pendency of the contempt proceedings, the High Court suo motu impleaded Contemnor Nos. 6 & 7 on the ground that the material available on record including the police report revealed that these two contemnors are also involved in the preparation and handing over of the fake High Court’s orders to the litigants, Contemnor Nos. 3 and 5. Accordingly, charges were framed by the High Court on 16.04.2024 against the Contemnor Nos. 6 & 7 as under:
“That, you, P. Meiyappan (6th contemnor) and S.
Amal Raj (7th contemnor) along with Contemnor Nos.3 to 5, including the deceased, P. Angamuthu and S. Sundaram, created fake orders of this Court, all dated 12.03.2018 and aided in producing it to the bailiff, when he came for executing the decree as set out in the order dated 19.12.2022:
i. C.R.P.No. 1467 of 2018 and C.M.P.No.2038 of 2018 ii. C.R.P.No.1468 of 2018 and C.M.P.No.2039 of 2018 and iii. C.R.P.No.1469 of 2018 and C.M.P.No.2040 of 2018 The above three orders appear to have been passed by Hon’ble Mrs. Justice Pushpa Sathyanarayana on [2025] 6 S.C.R. 107Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras 12.03.2018, whereas, the records of the Registry show that no such Civil Revision Petitions were even filed and the said Hon’ble Judge was not holding the C.R.P. roster on 12.03.2018 and therefore, it is evident that these three orders have been fabricated. The above act of yours prima facie attracts Section 2(c)(iii) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, which is punishable under Section 12, ibid., in that, by submitting the aforesaid three photocopies of the orders of this Court, you have interfered with the administration of justice, in the execution of proceedings before the District Munsif, Tiruchengode”
3.8. The Contemnor Nos. 3 and 5 preferred Crl. O.P. No. 17492 of 2023 for reinvestigation/fresh investigation of the crime registered against them. The Division Bench passed an order on 21.09.2023 directing the DGP to form a Special Team whereupon the DGP transferred the investigation to CBCID (OCU) and renumbered as Crime No. 2 of 2023. A detailed investigation was carried out by CBCID, and voluminous incriminating materials were collected against the Contemnor Nos. 4 to 6.
3.9. P. Meiyappan/Contemnor No. 6 6 and S. Amal Raj/Contemnor No. 7 7 were also arrested by the CBCID. The statement of two witnesses namely, Thangaraj and Shanthi was recorded under Section 164(5) of Cr. P. C. before the Judicial Magistrate No. II, Namakkal. Sample voices of C3 and C4 were also recorded by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Namakkal for comparison with the cell phone conversation held between them. CBCID filed first status report in the contempt petition on 18.10.2023 and also verified the record relating to C.R.P. Nos. 1467 – 1469 of 2018. The material objects were recovered from the Digital Net Centre, Bhavani and sent to the Tamil Nadu Forensic Science Laboratory.8 The CBCID filed second status report in the contempt petition on 19.12.2023 and thereafter third status report was filed on 12.02.2024. Basing above status reports, C6 & C7 were impleaded.
6 ‘C6’ 7 ‘C7’ 8 ‘FSL’ 108 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3.10. In his affidavit in response to the contempt notice, the C3 admitted that in the Execution case he and other tenants were guided by C4 to prefer revision before the High Court. According to him, the Judgment Debtor, in three suits, paid a sum of Rs. 15,000/- for preferring revision. On the relevant date his wife handed over the copy of bogus interim order to the Court Amin which was given to him by C4 through one Mr. P. Meiyappan. He categorically states that since C4 was handling his case for the last two decades, there was no occasion to doubt the genuineness of the High Court order. When he contacted C4, he stated that one Mr. Thangapandian, advocate had given the said order to him. This conversation was recorded in the automated Samsung android phone. He had given transcript of the conversation between him and C4 to the police along with the certificate under Section 65-B (4) of the Evidence Act, 1872.
3.11. The High Court after considering the materials and the submissions made by the appellants found that the three appellants are responsible in preparation of the bogus High Court interim orders and have accordingly sentenced them to undergo simple imprisonment for six months. The High Court found that the Contemnor Nos. 1 and 2 are also involved but since they have died, the case stood abated against them. Insofar as C6 is concerned, the High Court has given him the benefit of doubt.
SUBMISSIONS
4. Ms. Sonia Mathur, learned senior counsel and Mr. S. Nagamuthu, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellants/contemnors would submit that the initiation of contempt against the appellant/ contemnors is barred by limitation in view of the provisions contained in Section 20 of Contempt of Court Acts, 1971. It is also argued that formal charges are not framed against the appellants/contemnors without which contempt cannot proceed. It is vehemently argued that standard of proof in a criminal contempt is the same as required in a criminal case, therefore, the High Court has erred in holding that standard of strict proof is not required for conviction in a contempt matter. It is lastly submitted that the High Court having given benefit of doubt to C6 and has acquitted Contemnor No. 5, wife of the C3, [2025] 6 S.C.R. 109Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras the same yardstick should have been applied against the appellant/ C3 and thus, he deserves to be acquitted.
5. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent/High Court and Intervenor/Decree Holder have supported the impugned order. According to them, the present appellants have been found involved in creation of forged High Court order which have rightly been dealt with by the High Court by punishing them for committing contempt of Court. It is submitted that when the contempt proceedings are drawn suo motu by the High Court the law of limitation is not attracted. There being sufficient material against the appellants/contemnors, it is not a case where they have been found guilty and sentenced on the basis of probabilities, but it is a case of cogent material available against them.
ANALYSIS
6. The High Court has recorded the finding of guilt against the appellants/ contemnors on the basis of the report filed by CBCID and the affidavits filed by the appellants in response to the statutory notice issued against them. The report of the CBCID was in turn founded on the statement of witnesses as well as telephonic conversations held between C3 and C4 as also between C6 and C4. It has also come on record that C4 has forwarded the format for the preparation of fake stay order copies received from the advocate Thangapandian through P. Meiyappan’s email. Thereafter, C4 prepared the fake stay order copies and handed over the same to the accused, Thangamani, Sundaram and Angamuthu through P. Meiyappan. C4 further stated in his confession statement to the CBCID that Contemnor No. 7/S. Amal Raj 9 is the person who floated the idea of preparing the forged High Court stay orders. The properties were seized from the Digital Net Centre, Bhavani where the fake stay orders were prepared and the same were sent to the FSL. The High Court has extracted the report of the FSL in para 30 of the impugned order. Moreover, C3 in his affidavit has alleged that C4 was the person who guided them throughout in the litigation and it was he (C4) who handed over fake orders through P. Meiyappan. Paragraph Nos. 12, 13, 15 & 16 of his affidavit have been reproduced by the High Court which 9 ‘C7’ 110 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports clearly supports the finding recorded by the High Court. Thus, the case against the appellants/C3, C4 & C7 for committing contempt has been found proved by the High Court on the basis of cogent and reliable material available on record and the same is recorded after considering their stand taken in the affidavit.
7. Having deeply scrutinised the material, we are satisfied that the finding recorded by the High Court does not suffer from any illegality or perversity. The present is not a case where it is not known as to who produced the fake interim orders of the High Court or who prepared the same. The chain of events emerging from 18.04.2018 onwards, when the fake orders were presented at the time when the bailiff tried to effect delivery of possession, have been found established. As a matter of fact, C3 admits that he submitted the fake orders before the Court Amin. From the conversation recorded between C3 and C4 as produced before the CBCID and as mentioned in the affidavits, clearly accuses that it was C4 who was responsible for handing over the orders through P Meiyappan. It was C7 who floated the idea of preparing the forged orders. Thus, all three appellants/contemnors have rightly been convicted.
8. The sole object of the Court wielding its power to punish for contempt is always for maintaining the purity of administration of justice. Nothing is more incumbent upon the courts of justice than to preserve their proceedings from being misrepresented, nor is there anything more pernicious when the order of the court is forged and produced to gain undue advantage. A misleading or a wrong statement deliberately and wilfully made by a party to the proceedings to obtain a favourable order would undoubtedly tantamount to interference with the due course of judicial proceedings. When a person is found to have utilised an order of a court which he or she knows to be incorrect for conferring benefit on persons who are not entitled to the same, the very utilisation of the fabricated order by the person concerned would be sufficient to hold him/her guilty of contempt, irrespective of the fact whether he or she himself or herself is the author of fabrication. [See: In Re: Bineet Kumar Singh10 ). Thus, C3, who is the beneficiary of the fake interim orders is rightly held guilty of contempt.
10 (2001) 5 SCC 501
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 111Shanmugam @ Lakshminarayanan v. High Court of Madras
9. In re: “Vinay Chandra Mishra”11, this Court has held that the Judiciary is the guardian of the rule of law and the duty to protect the same is apart from the function of adjudicating the disputes between the parties and it is for this purpose that the courts are entrusted with the extraordinary power of punishing those who indulge in acts whether inside or outside the courts, which tend to undermine their authority and bring them in disrepute and disrespect by scandalising them and obstructing them from discharging their duties without fear or favour.
10. It has been argued by learned senior counsel for the appellants that they were not given proper opportunity to defend, inasmuch as, the charges were not framed against them in a formal manner nor explained to them. This argument deserves to be rejected at the outset in view of the settled proposition in “Vinay Chandra Mishra”(supra) in the following words:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.