State Represented By Inspector of Police, Cbi, Acb, Visakhapatnam v. Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 758; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 988
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice Sarasa Venkatanarayana Bhatti
- Decided
- 22 May 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2784-2794/2025
- Sections
- 239, 13(2), 19(1), 13(1), 177, 173, 227, 209, 91
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 988 : 2025 INSC 758 State Represented By Inspector of Police, CBI, ACB, Visakhapatnam v.
Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others (Criminal Appeal No(s). 2784-2794 of 2025)
22 May 2025 [Pankaj Mithal and S.V.N. Bhatti,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the two letters could have been looked at or relied upon by the Special Court for exercising its jurisdiction u/s.239, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Headnotes† Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.239 – Discharge – Material to be relied upon – FIR registered by CBI, charges filed u/ss.120B r/w. 420, 468, 471, IPC and s.13(2) r/w 13(1)(d), PC Act alleging that the accused conspired to purchase cotton at lower prices, hoarded these cotton stocks and resold it to Cotton Corporation of India (CCI) at higher MSP rates through benami farmers, causing wrongful loss to CCI and wrongful gain to the accused persons – Accused persons filed petition u/s.239 and inter alia relied on letters dtd. 08.01.2007 addressed by the CBI to the CCI and the reply of CCI dated 31.01.2007 stating that there was no loss caused to CCI – Accused were discharged relying on the letter dtd. 31.01.2007 – Interference with:
Held: The discharge was ordered not by referring to any of the situations referred in s.239, but by relying on the documents made available by the accused – The procedure followed by the special court and confirmed by the High Court is illegal and contrary to the binding precedent – The passing remark by the High Court that there is no material for cheating and forgery belies the existence of allegations and documents – For discharge, the special court and the High Court ought to have considered the chargesheet and list of documents, in the background of allegations made against * Author [2025] 5 S.C.R. 989State Represented By Inspector of Police, CBI, ACB, Visakhapatnam v. Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others the accused – However, they considered the material invited at the instance of the defence for ordering discharge – Discretionary limit as set out u/s.239 not complied with – Impugned orders set aside, discharge petitions filed by the accused dismissed – Special court to exercise its jurisdiction in terms of s.239 uninfluenced by any of the observations made herein. [Paras 27, 28] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.239 – Jurisdiction under – Exercise of discretion – Duty of Magistrate – Discussed. [Paras 25.1-25.3, 26-26.3] Case Law Cited Satish Mehra v. Delhi Administration and Another [1996] Supp. 4 SCR 197 : (1996) 9 SCC 766; State of Bihar v. Ramesh Singh [1978] 1 SCR 257 : (1977) 4 SCC 39; Supdt. and Remembrancer of Legal Affairs, West Bengal v. Anil Kumar Bhunja and Others [1980] 1 SCR 323 : (1979) 4 SCC 274; State of Orissa v. Debendranath Padhi [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 460 : (2005) 1 SCC 568; State of Rajasthan v. Swarn Singh @ Baba, Criminal Appeal No. 856 of 2024; Sheoraj Singh Ahlawat v. State of U.P. [2012] 10 SCR 1034 : (2013) 11 SCC 476; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Rakesh Mishra [2015] 3 SCR 765 : (2015) 13 SCC 8; State of Rajasthan v. Ashok Kumar Kashyap [2021] 4 SCR 158 : (2021) 11 SCC 191; Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal and Another [1979] 2 SCR 229 : (1979) 3 SCC 4 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Section 239 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Discharge; Cotton stocks; Cotton stocks hoarded; Hoarded cotton stocks resold; Benami farmers; Minimum Support Price (MSP); Higher MSP rates; Cotton Corporation of India (CCI); Wrongful loss; Wrongful gain; Conspiracy; Modus operandi; Forgery; Fabrication, Forged documents; Abused official position; Agricultural Market Committee (AMC); Cotton Purchase Officer (CPO); Suo motu FIR; Reliance on material invited at the instance of the defence; Reliance on the documents made available by the accused.
990 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 2784-2794 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.12.2021 of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amravati in CRLRC Nos.3388 and 3393 of 2017, CRLRC Nos. 6, 9, 12, 15, 29, 424, 512, 513 and 861 of 2018 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
K M Nataraj, A.S.G., Ms. Rukhmini Bobde, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Anuj Srinivas Udupa, Ms. Vanshaja Shukla, Ashok Panigrahi, Ms. Seema Patnaha.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Shoeb Alam, Sr. Advs., Ms. Mahima Pandey, Mullapudi Rambabu, M/s. M. Rambabu And Co., Rajat Singh, Sarthak Chandra, Dev Sareen, K V Girish Chowdary, D Satya Sumanth, Ms. Tatini Basu. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment S.V.N. Bhatti, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The criminal appeals arise from the common order dated 27.12.2021 in Criminal RC No. 3388/2017 and ten other cases in the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati. The prosecution/CBI is the Appellant in the batch of appeals.
3. On 27.06.2006, the CBI, Visakhapatnam registered FIR RC No. 11(A)/2006-CBI/VSP under sections 120B read with 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (‘IPC’) and sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (‘PC Act’). The registration of crime was against one, Rayapati Subba Rao/A-1 and a few other unknown individuals.
4. Between November 1994 and May 2006, A-1 served as Cotton Purchase Officer (‘CPO’) in the Cotton Corporation of India (‘CCI’), Guntur Branch. The alleged offences for which the suo motu FIR was [2025] 5 S.C.R. 991State Represented By Inspector of Police, CBI, ACB, Visakhapatnam v. Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others registered by the CBI are said to have happened in the financial year 2004-05. The CCI, as part of a policy, buys cotton at the Minimum Support Price (‘MSP’) on a year-to-year basis. The CCI, for the financial 2004-05, released the policy of MSP through letters CCI/ HO/PUR/MSP/2002-2003 dated 10.01.2003, CCI/HO/PUR/2004-2005 dated 18.10.2004, and CCI/HO/PUR/2005-2006 dated 26.12.2005.
5. The relevant parts of the above circulars are excerpted below: “CCI/HO/PUR/MSP/2002-2003 (…)
Through this letter, it is again advised that whenever kapas purchases are effected under MSP, the same should be made only from the market yards/functional market yards and in the presence of representatives of the APMCs so that cotton farmers get due benefit of MSP operations.
(…)
The kapas produce brought directly by farmers only in the market yard be purchased and prices be offered based on the quality of kapas under MSP guidelines so that farmers get due benefit for their produce.
xxx xxx xxx CCI/HO/PUR/MSP/2004-05 (…)
The kapas meeting the quality parameters of FAQ grade, can be purchased at the minimum support price without any quantitative limits. However, in actual practice, a good portion of daily arrivals may fall short of the FAQ grade parameters and in order to help the cotton farmers, Corporation may purchase below FAQ grade kapas with suitable discounts from the support price of the concerned variety.
(…)
Needless to say all purchases under MSP are to be made strictly through the market yards and in the presence of APMC representatives.
xxx xxx xxx 992 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports CCI/HO/PUR/MSP/2005-2006 (…)
As the main objective of MSP operations is to protect the interests of the cotton farmers therefore through this circular, it is again advised that whenever kapas purchases are effected under MSP, the same should be made only from the market yards/functional market yards and in the presence of officials/representatives of the APMCs so that the farmers get due benefit of MSP operations.
(…)
The kapas produce brought directly by farmers only in the market yard/notified market yards be purchased and prices be offered based on the quality of kapas under MSP guidelines so farmers get due benefit for their produce. xxx xxx xxx”
6. The investigation into RC No. 11(A)/2006-CBI/VSP disclosed a pattern of buying cotton at the then prevailing market rate, which is lower than the MSP and selling the hoarded cotton to CCI and availing the MSP made available for the farmers of cotton. The investigation revealed an alleged conspiracy between A-1 and one RVK Prasad/A-3, proprietor of M/s Balachamundeswari Cotton Company Limited. Notably, A-3 is the son of A-1. The investigation further implicated Syed John Syda/A-2, a supervisor at the Agricultural Market Committee (‘AMC’), Phirangipuram and 45 others as accused in RC No. 11(A)/2006-CBI/VSP.
7. The modus operandi, briefly stated as per the prosecution, is that A-1 and A-3 allegedly purchased cotton from genuine farmers at lower prices before the announcement of MSP by the Government of India, and they hoarded these cotton stocks. Once CCI started purchasing cotton at MSP, A-1, with the support of A-3, resold the hoarded cotton under benami names of farmers, A-4 to A-47, to CCI at the higher MSP rates. These transactions occurred at Pericherla and Phirangipuram in the Guntur District, and Madhira in the Khammam District, where A-1 was the in-charge CPO during the 2004-2005 financial year. Many of the farmers (A-4 to A-47) allegedly did not have sufficient land to cultivate the large quantities of cotton they purportedly sold to CCI. A few of the accused did not [2025] 5 S.C.R. 993State Represented By Inspector of Police, CBI, ACB, Visakhapatnam v. Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others have cultivable land at all, while a few others had very small holdings, and the volume of cotton sold at MSP is disproportionate to their land holdings. Bank accounts were opened in the names of these farmers, often introduced by A-3 or his employees. Payments from CCI (in the form of cheques) were routed through these accounts and allegedly were encashed and utilized by A-3 and A-2 by forging the signatures of farmers on takpatties and katachitta (weighment slips) pertaining to Phirangipuram. The investigation revealed that the thumb impressions were used on relevant material, whereas the said person acknowledged through signature in English/Telugu.
8. The prosecution alleges wrongful loss under the MSP for a sum of Rs. 21,19,35,646/- to the CCI/Government of India, and the wrongful gain is to the accused persons. The premise of the accusation is that the MSP is meant and intended for cotton farmers and growers, and through the alleged modus operandi, it has been subverted by the accused for gain. On 31.12.2009, chargesheet no. 31/2009, along with a list of documents (452), were filed before the special judge for CBI cases against A-1 to A-48. On 09.06.2011, the learned special court took cognizance of the chargesheet and numbered the case as CC No. 16/2011. The gist of the chargesheet against the accused is stated thus:
8.1 The chargesheet first reiterates the conspiracy and modus operandi. After which, it details the procedure for cotton purchase by CCI, including (i) testing quality, (ii) fixing rates under MSP,
(iii) weighment, preparation of katachitta, (iv) takpatti, and (v) payment through cheques via the AMC. The chargesheet notes that A-1 was in charge of Pericherla, Phirangipuram, and Madhira centers, and alleges that A-3 connived with A-7 to open bank accounts in the names of the villagers of Jamalapuram and Banjara. A-1 and A-3 purchased cotton at lower prices before the MSP announcement and purportedly resold it to CCI at MSP through benami farmers. It lists the farmers (A-4 to A-47), their bank account details, amounts credited, and alleged land possession, highlighting discrepancies between land held and cotton sold.
8.2 The chargesheet also specifically mentions that A-2 forged the signatures of farmers on bidding slips, takpatties and weighment slips. The Government Examiner of Questioned 994 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Documents’ (‘GEQD’) opinion also confirms the alleged forgery. It also highlights discrepancies in fathers’ names and residential addresses mentioned in the Bidding Slip versus actual details. Further, it states that many farmers denied selling such large quantities or even visiting the market centres. Some stated they signed blank cheque books at the instance of A-3 or A-7, and the chargesheet further notes that employees of A-3’s company (M/s Balachamundeswari Cotton Company) were also shown as farmers selling cotton by availing the subject MSP.
8.3 The chargesheet concludes that A-1 abused his official position, conspired with others, and caused wrongful loss to CCI and gain to themselves to the tune of Rs. 21,19,35,646/- by showing procurement from traders and fictitious persons under the guise of small and marginal farmers. Consequently, sanction for prosecution against A-1 (Rayapati Subba Rao) under Section 19(1) of the PC Act was obtained, and no sanction was sought for A-2 (Syed John Syda) as he had retired.
8.4 Therefore, charges were filed under sections 120-B read with sections 420, 468, 471 IPC and section 13(2) read with section 13(1)(d) of the PC Act.
9. The record discloses that before the framing of charges was taken up by the special court, the accused filed Criminal MP No. 1056/17 to summon the letter dated 08.01.2007 addressed by the CBI to the Deputy General Manager of CCI, Guntur and the reply of the CCI dated 31.01.2007 to the CBI. It is contextual to note two aspects of the matter – (a) documents have been summoned before the charge is considered by the special court, and (b) the communication by CBI and the reply given by CCI to CBI.
9.1 The CBI in its letter dated 08.01.2007 to CCI posed questions pertaining to the difference in purchases made by A-1, the deviation of rules by A-1, the loss caused by A-1’s purchase, complaints made by AMC or farmers against A-1, objections by audits and unsold cotton purchased by A-1 resulting in loss. 9.2 The reply by CCI dated 31.01.2007 replies to these queries by noting that the purchases were made as per the MSP guidelines in force for the year, and no loss was caused by A-1. The reply further notes that no complaints were received from the AMC [2025] 5 S.C.R. 995State Represented By Inspector of Police, CBI, ACB, Visakhapatnam v. Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others against the purchases made by A-1, no objections were raised by statutory auditors and all the purchases made by A-1 were sold and lifted by buyers.
10. The Respondent Nos. 1 to 11 filed Criminal MPs in CC no. 16/2011 under section 239 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (‘CrPC’). The details of the alleged wrongful gain, Criminal MP, Criminal Revision, and the Criminal Appeal in the Court are stated in the following table: Wrongful gain by the accused.
Crl. M.P.
Nos in CC No.16/2011 Before the High Court SLP Nos. Respondent - Accused Rs. 32,72,020/- 827/2016 3388/2017 SLP (Crl.)
Nos.
5941 to 5951 of R1/A-46 Rs. 31,55,052/- 1513/2016 3393/2017 R2/A-24 Rs. 86,72,235/- 243/2017 6/2018 R3/A-15 Rs. 66,72,370/- 245/2017 9/2018 R4/A-40 Rs. 42,64,355/- 1512/2016 12/2018 R5/A-23 Rs. 58,63,905/- 1515/2016 15/2018 R6/A-41 Rs. 33,84,317/- 244/2017 29/2018 R7/A-27 Rs. 61,59,585/- 1510/2016 424/2018 R8/A-17 Rs. 44,00,432/- 1516/2016 512/2018 R9/A-47 Rs. 35,80,291/- 1511/2016 513/2018 R10/A-21 Rs. 49,67,779/- 1514/2016 861/2018 R11/A-26
11. The accused raised the objection that the subject chargesheet is without merit and groundless, primarily because there exists no case for framing charges under sections 120B, 420 and 471 of the IPC. They make this objection by noting that (i) there are no witnesses or documents that prove wrongful loss to CCI, (ii) there is no specific overt act of forgery, fabrication, or use of forged documents by these accused, (iii) the court in Visakhapatnam is jurisdictionally barred from trying transactions related to Madhira Centre under section 177 of CrPC, (iv) there are contradictions with respect to land holdings and amounts credited in the chargesheet, (v) the Petitioners are legitimate cultivators, either holding land personally, or cultivating on lease and (vi) the CCI letter dated 31.01.2007 states that there was no loss caused to CCI.
996 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
12. The CBI opposed the prayer for discharge and the summary of the objections raised by the accused, noting that there is sufficient evidence of conspiracy, cheating and forgery, resulting in wrongful gain/loss as the case may be. The CBI further places stress on the modus operandi used by the accused to procure cotton at low prices and sell it to CCI at MSP through benami transactions. It further stresses the GEQD’s opinion, which supports the allegation of forgery. Consequently, the CBI alleges that there is a diversion of the MSP benefit, which has caused a loss to the public exchequer. The CBI finally notes in its opposition that the application for discharge is merely an attempt to prolong the trial.
13. The special court, through a similar order and reasoning, allowed the prayer for discharge under section 239 of the CrPC. The view of the special court is that the letter dated 31.01.2007 of the CCI is an important document that categorically states that purchases by A-1 were as per MSP guidelines, and there were no differences compared to other officers. Crucially, the court held that no loss was caused by A-1 in this regard. The special court then found that there was (i) no wrongful loss, (ii) no prima facie case, and (iii) an abuse of the process of law by requiring a full trial despite the letter by CCI dated 31.01.2007. In this light, the special court held that the threshold under section 239 of the CrPC was met since the material did not create a strong and serious suspicion. Therefore, the special court allowed the discharge petition.
14. To appreciate the grounds of challenge to the order of discharge, it is necessary to reproduce the following paragraphs from the order dated 05.09.2017 of the special court.
“11. A combined reading of Sections 239 and 240 Cr.P.C. makes it abundantly clear, that before a charge is framed, trial Court is expected to consider the material placed before it to decide whether charges could be framed against the accused.
12. Bearing the said crucial aspects in mind, if we switch back to the material placed before the Court, the petitioner along with some other accused filed Crl.M.P.1056/17 to summon certain documents from the custody of Cotton Corporation of India, Guntur.
(…)
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 997State Represented By Inspector of Police, CBI, ACB, Visakhapatnam v. Eluri Srinivasa Chakravarthi and Others
17. In the result the petition is allowed with a finding that the petitioner is entitled to get discharge from main case. Accordingly, the petitioner is discharged from main case.”
15. CBI filed a criminal revision case before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh, and through the common order impugned in the criminal appeals, the revisions were dismissed. The High Court, in assessing the scope of revisional jurisdiction and the principles of discharge under section 239 of the CrPC, affirmed that a judge can sift and weigh evidence to find a prima facie case, justifying a charge if ‘grave suspicion’ exists but allowing discharge if only ‘some suspicion’ arises or if two views are equally possible and the evidence gives rise to some suspicion but not grave suspicion, the accused can be discharged. The judge is not merely a ‘post office’ and must consider broad probabilities and basic infirmities without conducting a full trial, ensuring that facts at face value disclose all ingredients of the alleged offense. In this specific case, the High Court relied on the letter from the CCI dated 31.01.2007, which asserted that no financial loss to CCI was caused by the accused, that all purchases adhered to MSP guidelines, and no complaints were received, thereby directly contradicting the prosecution’s central claim of a Rs. 21 crore loss and procedural violations. Given the CCI’s exonerating letter, the High Court found no incorrectness, illegality, or impropriety in the special court’s order discharging the accused due to allegations being groundless.
16. We have heard advocate Ms. Rukhmini Bobde for the appellant and Mr. Shoeb Alam, learned senior counsel, for the respondents/accused.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.