Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 785; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 881
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 28 May 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2867/2025
- Sections
- 157, 158, 176, 190, 173, 2
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 881 : 2025 INSC 785 Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v.
State of Assam and Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No. 2867 of 2025)
28 May 2025 [Surya Kant* and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The instant matter arises from a series of encounters reported in the State of Assam (Respondent No. 1), the authenticity of which has been called into question on various counts. The appellant asserted that no meaningful or effective inquiry has been undertaken in respect of these cases and the guidelines laid down in People’s Union for Civil Liberties & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. has been flouted blatantly.
Headnotes† Public Interest Litigation – Fake Police Encounters – Directions by the Supreme Court – Whether the allegations made by the appellant prima facie establish violation of the guidelines laid down by this Court in PUCL:
Held: Upon a comprehensive examination, it emerges that several instances cited by the appellant to demonstrate procedural non-compliance of PUCL guidelines are factually incorrect or incomplete – The appellant has failed to independently place on record any cogent or verifiable material to substantiate the allegations – After minutely scanning such data, prima facie it seems that barring a few cases, it is difficult to infer that there has been a procedural breakdown or the PUCL guidelines were flagrantly violated – Further, in the absence of independent corroboration or affidavits from affected persons, the assertions remain more or less speculative – However, the records furnished by the State themselves indicate that some instances may warrant further evaluation to ascertain whether the guidelines laid down in PUCL have been meticulously complied with, in both letter and spirit – This Court cannot remain indifferent where the rights and dignity of individuals, particularly in the context of alleged extra-judicial actions, are at stake – To ensure justice to the victims and their * Author 882 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports families, and to uphold the sanctity of the procedure established by law, it is held that the issues raised in the instant petition merit a fair and impartial inquiry – The Constitutional Courts must act to preserve both legality and accountability – Therefore, the impugned Judgment of the High Court dated 27.01.2023 is set aside – The matter is directed to be reinstated on the board of the Assam Human Rights Commission (AHRC) for necessary inquiry into the allegations independently and expeditiously, in accordance with law – The AHRC is directed to issue a public notice inviting all individuals who claim to be aggrieved (victims and their family members) by the alleged police encounters to come forward and furnish relevant information or evidence before the AHRC – The State of Assam is directed to extend full cooperation to the AHRC – Further, the ASLSA directed to make legal assistance available to individuals seeking support in approaching or presenting their case before the AHRC for which its Member Secretary is also directed to issue specific instructions to the District and Taluk level officers. [Paras 32, 36, 38, 55] Public Interest Litigation – Alleged cause espoused by a third party – Locus standi:
Held: It is trite law that since the evolution of the PIL jurisdiction, particularly post the landmark pronouncements beginning in 1984, the doctrine of locus standi has been considerably liberalised – Widening of the gates to justice, comes an enhanced responsibility upon the court to ensure that this jurisdiction is not invoked in a manner that causes more harm than good – Where the alleged cause espoused by a third party in the form of a PIL relates to a specific individual or a closed set of individuals—particularly where the implications of judicial intervention may directly alter or jeopardize the legal position of the victim or their kin—it becomes imperative for the courts to tread with utmost circumspection – The danger of an unintended miscarriage of justice or irreversible prejudice being caused to an invisible and voiceless victim or their family, merely because a well-meaning but distanced individual has approached a Writ Court, cannot be discounted – In such situations, it is not sufficient for the court to proceed solely on the averments of the person advancing the cause before the court – Instead, it becomes obligatory for the court to independently explore mechanisms—institutional or otherwise—that can facilitate direct communication with the victim or their family, thereby enabling [2025] 5 S.C.R. 883Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors. them to make an informed choice about participation or redressal through judicial means. [Paras 19, 20, 21] Fake Police Encounters – Context and framework of guidelines laid down in judgment of PUCL – Discussed. [Paras 11-17] Role of National and State Human Rights Commissions – Discussed. [Paras 40-46] Case Law Cited People’s Union for Civil Liberties & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors [2014] 12 SCR 54 : (2014) 10 SCC 635; Extra Judicial Execution Victim and Anr. vs. Union of India and Ors., Writ Petition (Crl.) No.129/2012 (decided by Supreme Court) – referred to. List of Acts Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993; AHRC (Procedure)
Regulations, 2001; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Public interest litigation; Police encounters; Encounter killing; Inviolable guarantees of life and personal liberty; Imperatives of law enforcement; Fake encounters; Primacy of rule of law; Glorifying police encounters; Public heroism; Extra-judicial killings; Use of excessive or unlawful force by public authorities; Derogation from principles of due process; Traditional adversarial system; Unintended miscarriage of justice; Invisible and voiceless victim or their family; Abuse of power; Public interest jurisdiction; Procedural safeguards; Constitutional obligations; Accountability of law enforcement; Right to life; Article 21 of the Constitution; Nonconsideration of ballistic and forensic reports; Partial compliance; Fairness and objectivity in investigative process; Domestic human rights architecture; Independent watchdogs; Principle of fairness; Witness protection protocols.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
2867 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.01.2023 of the Gauhati High Court in PIL No. 86 of 2021 884 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Prashant Bhushan, Ms. Ria Yadav, Shiyas Kr.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Chinmoy Pradip Sharma, Sr. A.A.G., Devajit Saikia, Advocate General (Assam), Nalin Kohli, Parthiv Goswami, Sr. Advs., Shuvodeep Roy, Saurabh Tripathi, Deepayan Dutta, Digvijay Dam, Krishnajyoti Deka, Anshul Malik, Ms. Shruti Agrawal, Ms. Vanshaja Shukla, Ms. Ankeeta Appanna, Siddhant Yadav, Ms. Anasuya Choudhury, Ms. Atiga Singh, Abhinav Jha. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave granted.
2. The instant matter arises from a series of encounters reported in the State of Assam (Respondent No. 1), the authenticity of which has been called into question on various counts. At the heart of these proceedings lie concerns that straddle the delicate boundary between the imperatives of law enforcement and the inviolable guarantees of life and personal liberty enshrined in our Constitution.
3. This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 27.01.2023 (Impugned Judgment), whereby the High Court of Gauhati (High Court) dismissed PIL No. 86/2021, inter alia seeking: (i) records of all alleged fake encounters in the State of Assam, (ii) registration of FIR against the erring police officials and (iii) independent investigation against such officials in compliance with the guidelines laid down by this Court in People’s Union for Civil Liberties & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. 1 The petition was dismissed by the High Court, holding that the PIL was premature and the documents placed on record only made out vague assertions. Nevertheless, the High Court directed that the Appellant shall be 1 People’s Union for Civil Liberties & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors, (2014) 10 SCC 635. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 885Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors. provided all legally permissible documents in connection with all such cases, if so applied.
4. The Appellant is before us asserting that no meaningful or effective inquiry has been undertaken in respect of these cases and the guidelines laid down in PUCL (supra) has been flouted blatantly. A. FActuAl BAckground
5. Before adverting to the issues and contentions raised by the parties, we deem it appropriate to narrate the factual background leading to the instant appeal briefly.
5.1. The Appellant in the Writ Petition filed before the High Court alleged that as many as 80 fake encounters took place in the State of Assam between May, 2021 and December, 2021.
According to him, 28 persons were killed and 48 were left injured, during these encounters. It was further alleged that police authorities have justified these actions on the basis that escape attempts from the accused persons prompted them to open fire in purported self-defence, resulting in death or injury.
5.2. Alarmed by the growing incidence of police encounters, the Appellant firstly addressed a complaint on 10.07.2021 to the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), Respondent No. 4 herein. The Appellant beseeched the NHRC about the multiple incidents of police encounters and requested to take cognizance of the matter. Shortly thereafter, on 12.07.2021, the Assam Human Rights Commission (AHRC), Respondent No. 5 herein, also sent a suo-moto notice to the Government of Assam and sought a report. It appears from the records that AHRC had already taken notice of the issue pertaining to increasing incidents of encounters on 07.07.2021, i.e., prior to the complaint addressed by the Appellant to the NHRC.
5.3. The NHRC on 29.11.2021, transferred the Appellant’s complaint to the AHRC on the premise that the latter had already taken note of the issue. Not long after, on 20.12.2021, the Appellant filed the aforestated PIL Petition before the High Court, raising the issue of the alleged fake encounters. It may be apposite to add here that during the pendency of the proceedings before 886 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the High Court, the full bench of the AHRC on 12.01.2022, disposed of the matter before it on the ground that the subject matter was pending adjudication before the High Court and Regulation 7(XII) of the AHRC (Procedure) Regulations, 2001 do not permit entertaining of complaints that are subjudice before any other Court/Tribunal.
5.4. The Appellant moved an application in the PIL proceedings seeking copies of the FIRs registered pursuant to these police encounters. The High Court granted him liberty to apply to the Prosecuting Inspectors of each district in the State of Assam for accessing the same. He consequently applied to the concerned authorities. The Appellant appears to have maintained that there were 101 known incidents at that point of time. However, only the authorities of 12 districts (out of total of 30), supplied him copies of 41 FIRs.
5.5. In the meantime, the Respondent No. 1, filed several compliance affidavits before the High Court in the pending proceedings, candidly acknowledging that between May 2021 and August 2022, 171 instance of police encounters had taken place wherein 56 persons were killed including 4 custodial deaths, and 145 persons were injured. As such, the scope of the Petition was expanded, and all 171 alleged police encounters between May 2021 and August 2022 came to be scrutinised.
5.6. The High Court, however, after considering the affidavits filed by the parties and other material on record, dismissed the petition holding that that “unless proper foundational facts are brought to the notice of the court, a Public Interest Litigation in such a matter cannot be maintained merely on the basis of some vague and unsubstantiated assertions”. The High Court returned a categorical finding that the Appellant has failed to point out any infirmity in the procedure adopted in any of the enquiry proceedings or any guideline laid down in PUCL (supra) based on the materials brought on record. Given the foregoing, the High Court also turned down the prayer to constitute a Special Investigation Team (SIT) or hand over the investigation of these encounters to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). The High Court ofcourse directed that the Appellant shall be provided all legally permissible documents in connection with all such cases. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 887Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors. B. contentions on BehAlF oF the A ppellAnt
6. Mr. Prashant Bhushan, learned counsel for the Appellant, strongly contended that the High Court has fell in error in overlooking the fact that 56 persons have lost their lives and 145 have been grievously injured in police encounters. According to him, the guidelines laid down in PUCL (supra) were not adhered to in any of these incidents.
7. In support of his contentions, Mr. Bhushan has advanced the following submissions:
a) At the outset, any imputation on the bona fides of the Appellant is unfounded. The Appellant is a permanent resident of the State of Assam and being a practicing advocate, espouses the cause of transparency and accountability of public institutions. The majority of the victims and/or their families are either unaware of their rights or are scared to approach the police officials seeking further investigation.
b) The FIRs pertaining to the incidents of police encounters have been registered against the victims i.e., the persons killed or injured and not against the concerned police officials. The registration of FIRs is in violation of the guidelines laid down by this Court in Para 31.2 of the judgment in PUCL (supra) which prescribes that in the event of an encounter leading to death, an FIR shall be registered and forwarded to the jurisdictional court under Section 157 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC).
c) The investigation into these incidents of police encounters has not been conducted in an independent manner. In this regard, Para 31.3 of the judgment in PUCL (supra) mandates that an independent investigation into the incident shall be conducted by the Crime Investigation Department (CID) or police team of another police station under the supervision of a senior officer. However, the investigation into these police encounters was conducted by officers from the same police station.
d) Such so-called investigation was merely an eye wash and nothing more than a superficial exercise, intended to create an illusion of accountability. It was riddled with a glaring conflict of interest, and not only did it compromise the integrity of the 888 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports process but also provided the officers involved with a convenient opportunity to shield themselves from scrutiny and evade any real consequences for their misconduct.
e) A perusal of the 41 FIRs supplied to the Appellant, 12 of which were also placed on record before the High Court, clearly indicates a somewhat similar modus operandi adopted by the police officials who have justified the killings and injury caused to people on the pretext that they were trying to flee. This gives rise to the apprehension that the police officials have undertaken these encounters in a premeditated manner and not in self defence as proclaimed by them.
f) The guidelines laid down by this Court in PUCL (supra) mandates that the concerned police official must surrender their weapon for forensic/ballistic analysis. In breach of the prescribed guidelines, the Magisterial inquiries in several incidents remain silent on this aspect, offering no indication as to whether any ballistic or forensic examinations were ever conducted. The Appellant has illustratively pointed out the inquiry reports in the cases of deaths of Dimasa National Liberation Army (DNLA) cadres, suspects of the United People’s Revolutionary Front, Kanwaldeep Singh Sindhu, Sorangi China, and Bubu Konwar which do not refer to the forensic analysis.
g) Regardless of the clear mandate laid down in PUCL (supra), which expressly requires a Magisterial inquiry or an independent investigation even in cases involving grievous injuries, this crucial procedural safeguard has been disregarded. In the majority of such instances, no such inquiry or investigation has been initiated, reflecting a serious departure from the established legal framework intended to ensure transparency and accountability.
h) The State of Assam has failed to indicate the present status of investigation in all the 171 cases leading to death or grievous injury. The table tendered before this Court on 25.02.2025 indicates that charge sheet has been filed in 5 out of the 41 cases leading to death. However, the charge sheets have not been placed on record, and it is feared that they may be against the victims, not the concerned police personnel.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 889Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors. c. contentions on BehAlF oF the respondent ( s)
8. Mr. Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General of India, along with Mr. Devajit Saikia, Advocate General and Mr. Nalin Kohli, Additional Advocate General for the State of Assam, appearing for Respondent Nos. 1-3 have vehemently asserted that the High Court has rightly dismissed the PIL as the Appellant failed to establish or point out any lacunae in the investigation conducted into the instances of police encounters.
9. Their submissions may be summarised as follows:
a) The issues raised in the instant petition are vague, baseless and whimsical, and the High Court rightly dismissed the same as being premature. As per the reports submitted by the Superintendent of Police of all the districts, the guidelines issued by this Court in PUCL (supra) have been diligently observed in all death cases.
b) In all instances where police encounters have resulted in death, separate FIRs have been lodged; independent investigations have been conducted; and Magisterial inquiries have also been ordered. In its affidavit dated 29.09.2022, the State of Assam has categorically stated that 171 cases have been registered and that investigations are currently underway.
c) The reliance placed by the Appellant on Para 31.3 of the judgment in PUCL (supra) to suggest that ‘an independent investigation into the incident shall be conducted by the CID or police team of another police station’ in every incident, is completely misplaced and incorrect. The judgment does not contemplate the registration of FIR at a different police station. The Appellant’s contention in this regard is thoroughly untenable as the FIR has to be registered by the police station having jurisdiction over the matter. The Appellant’s claim in this regard would make the investigation unnecessarily onerous and timeconsuming. Similarly, the need for constituting an independent investigating agency would arise only when a prima facie case has been made out that investigation is not being carried out in accordance with the due procedure prescribed by law.
d) Fair and impartial magisterial inquiries have been conducted in all incidents where death has been caused in police encounters. 890 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports More importantly, all these inquiries have been undertaken strictly per the guidelines in PUCL (supra). The particulars of the stage of investigation or conduct of magisterial inquiry in all 171 cases were placed before the High Court vide the affidavit dated 29.09.2022.
e) Insofar as the reference to forensic/ballistic reports is concerned, the Appellant has sought to present unsubstantiaed claims without being supported by any cogent facts. He has selectively read the reports and deliberately concealed the fact that ballistic examination reports and forensic reports were yet to be received in some cases, and in others, were received later. Those reports were duly considered before filing of the charge sheet or final report.
f) The Appellant’s contention that PUCL (supra) applies even in cases of grievous injury is totally erroneous. The judgment only provides that the guidelines will also apply to grievous injury cases in police encounters, as far as possible. The phrase ‘as far as possible’ shows that compliance and adherence to the guidelines need not be made in a strict sense.
g) The allegation of the Appellant that the State of Assam has failed to indicate the present status of the investigation is also entirely misplaced. It is noteworthy that the State of Assam, in its counter-affidavit dated 29.04.2024, has stated that out of a total of 171 cases, charge sheets have been filed in 125 cases, forwarding reports were submitted in 23 cases, and that the remaining 23 cases were still pending investigation. The competent police officials have investigated all the cases under the supervision of the Superintendent of Police of the concerned districts.
d. issues For considerAtion
10. Having regard to the rival submissions, we find that the following issues arise for our consideration:
a) Whether the allegations made by the Appellant prima facie establish violation of the guidelines laid down by this Court in PUCL (supra) ?
b) If so, what are the remedial measures?
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 891Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors. e. A nAlysis E.1. Understanding the Context and Framework of the Guidelines laid down in PUCL (supra)
11. The instant controversy, in its core, revolves around the alleged infraction of the PUCL (supra) guidelines. We therefore deem it appropriate to firstly advert to the context, intent, and purport of those guidelines.
12. The PUCL case arose against the backdrop of allegations of fake or staged police encounters in the State of Maharashtra and other parts of the country, where individuals purported to be criminals were killed by the police. The petitioner therein, PUCL, sought court-monitored guidelines to curb the misuse of power and ensure accountability and transparency in such encounters, in light of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
13. This Court recognised the gravity of the issue, noting that fake encounters are extra-judicial killings and must be subject to strict legal scrutiny. While issuing sixteen (16) mandatory guidelines, this Court held that any encounter killing must be investigated fairly and independently, and cannot be treated as justified merely on the claim of self-defence by the Police.
14. To examine the contention at hand, we deem it appropriate to extract a few guidelines that have been contested before us:
“31.1. Whenever the Police is in receipt of any intelligence or tip-off regarding criminal movements or activities pertaining to the Commission of grave criminal offence, it shall be reduced into writing in some form (preferably into case diary) or in some electronic form. Such recording need not reveal details of the suspect or the location to which the party is headed. If such intelligence or tip-off is received by a higher authority, the same may be noted in some form without revealing details of the suspect or the location.
31.2. If pursuant to the tip-off or receipt of any intelligence, as above, encounter takes place and firearm is used by the police party and as a result of that, death 892 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports occurs, an FIR to that effect shall be registered and the same shall be forwarded to the court under Section 157 of the Code without any delay. While forwarding the report under Section 157 of the Code, the procedure prescribed under Section 158 of the Code shall be followed.
31.3. An independent investigation into the incident/ encounter shall be conducted by the CID or police team of another police station under the supervision of a senior officer (at least a level above the head of the police party engaged in the encounter). The team conducting inquiry/investigation shall, at a minimum, seek...
31.4. A Magisterial inquiry under Section 176 of the Code must invariably be held in all cases of death which occur in the course of police firing and a report thereof must be sent to Judicial Magistrate having jurisdiction under Section 190 of the Code.
31.5. The involvement of NHRC is not necessary unless there is serious doubt about independent and impartial investigation. However, the information of the incident without any delay must be sent to NHRC or the State Human Rights Commission, as the case may be.
*****
31.7. It should be ensured that there is no delay in sending FIR, diary entries, panchnamas, sketch, etc., to the concerned Court.
31.8. After full investigation into the incident, the report should be sent to the competent court under Section 173 of the Code. The trial, pursuant to the chargesheet submitted by the Investigating Officer, must be concluded expeditiously.
31.9. In the event of death, the next of kin of the alleged criminal/victim must be informed at the earliest.
***** [2025] 5 S.C.R. 893Arif Md. Yeasin Jwadder v. State of Assam and Ors.
31.13. The police officer(s) concerned must surrender his/ her weapons for forensic and ballistic analysis, including any other material, as required by the investigating team, subject to the rights under Article 20 of the Constitution. *****
31.16. If the family of the victim finds that the above procedure has not been followed or there exists a pattern of abuse or lack of independent investigation or impartiality by any of the functionaries as above mentioned, it may make a complaint to the Sessions Judge having territorial jurisdiction over the place of incident. Upon such complaint being made, the concerned Sessions Judge shall look into the merits of the complaint and address the grievances raised therein.
32. The above guidelines will also be applicable to grievous injury cases in police encounter, as far as possible.”
15. It may be seen that the guidelines provide for the registration of FIR, independent investigation, Magisterial inquiry, involvement of forensic science, informing the next of kin, compensation and information to the NHRC and State Human Rights Commission (SHRC), among others. These guidelines, in a way, reaffirm the primacy of the Rule of Law as the bedrock of our constitutional democracy. This Court authoritatively held that no individual or institution, including the Police or law enforcement agencies, is above the law. It cautioned against the emerging culture of glorifying police encounters as indicators of effective policing or public heroism and observed that such glorification distorts the role of the Police in a constitutional democracy and fosters a climate of impunity, where extra-judicial methods are valorised over legal processes.
16. It needs no emphasis that, the use of excessive or unlawful force by public authorities, irrespective of the nature of the offence or the antecedents of the victim, cannot be condoned or legitimised on any pretext. Any derogation from the principles of due process, even in the name of expediency or public safety, erodes the foundation of a democratic and civilised society.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.