Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 425; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 369
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 1 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4499/2025
- Sections
- 19
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 369 : 2025 INSC 425 Jomon K.K.
v.
Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 4499-4500 of 2025)
02 April 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Manmohan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appellant who did not hold a current Lascar’s licence but was the holder of a Syrang’s licence (superior to Lascar’s licence) could have been considered qualified to participate in the recruitment process for the post of “Boat Lascar” under Kerala State Water Transport Department and appointed as “Boat Lascar”. Headnotes† Special Rules of 1975 for the Kerala State Water Transport Subordinate Service (Operating Wing) – r.6 – Appellant who did not hold a current Lascar’s licence, as required, but was the holder of a Syrang’s licence (superior to Lascar’s licence), if was qualified to participate in the recruitment process for the post of “Boat Lascar” and appointed as “Boat Lascar” – Appellant’s appointment as “Boat Lascar” was cancelled: Held: The advertisement did not require anything else other than what the Special Rules require – Possession of a current Lascar’s licence was an essential qualification for the post of Lascar – This was laid down in the qualifications required; which when read with r.6 shows that apart from those having a current Lascar’s licence, none else was eligible – The word “current” is significant as the Rules insist on a subsisting licence, i.e., a certificate of competency, which is valid and operative during the time the last date for receiving applications intervene – However, the appellant did not have the ‘current’ Lascar’s licence on the last date for receiving applications – On a conjoint reading of r.6, Special Rules and the advertisement, both mentioning a particular qualification, i.e., a current Lascar’s licence, which each aspirant had to possess for being considered eligible to participate in the process of selection, thereby creating a distinct class, it was aspirants falling in such class alone who could have applied for being considered – Thus, any aspirant, even though possessing a Syrang’s licence or a Driver’s * Author 370 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports licence not being part of such distinct class, could not have been considered eligible – Furthermore, not only the qualifications but the nature of duties required to be performed and the nature of service to be rendered by a Lascar and a Syrang are different – Merely because the post of Lascar is a feeder post for promotion to the post of Syrang does not per se make the holder of a Syrang’s licence qualified for the job of a Lascar – High Court rightly held that KPSC could not have included candidates with licences other than a Lascar’s licence in the “Ranked List” and proceeded to recommend those candidates for appointment – An appointment made contrary to the statutory rule would be void – On merits, no legally protected right of the appellant having been affected by the impugned action, he has no valid claim. [Paras 22-24, 28-31] Public employment – Selection – Exclusion of aspirants from selection process, if justified – Factors to be considered – Whether overqualification can be a disqualification:
Held: Whether or not the action of the employer to exclude an aspirant from the process of selection (on the ground that either he is over qualified for a particular post or has qualifications which, being over and above what is ordained by statutory rules or rules framed under the proviso to Rule 309 of the Constitution, does not match the qualification specifically required) is justified has to be decided considering the rules governing the selection, the qualifications prescribed, the nature of duty to be performed, the nature of service to be rendered and a host of other factors – At times, the employer’s need to have the right people at the right place, and not always the higher qualified, has to be conceded – There are decisions holding that over-qualification cannot be a disqualification since such an approach amounts to discouraging the acquisition of qualifications on the one hand and on the other, such an approach could be seen as arbitrary, discriminatory and not in national interest – However, this principle cannot be put in a straitjacket imposing rigid or inflexible rules or norms – Each case has to be decided on its own peculiar facts and there can be no universally accepted rule that every time, a higher qualified candidate is to be preferred to a candidate who matches the essential qualification required for the post. [Para 36] Public employment – Equality of opportunity – Absence of – Effect – Appellant did not hold a current Lascar’s licence, as required, but was the holder of a Syrang’s licence (superior to Lascar’s licence) – Appellant was appointed as “Boat Lascar” however, his appointment was later cancelled:
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 371Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc. Held: The aggrieved are all those who had similar or even better qualifications than the appellant but who had not applied for the post because they were unaware of the fact that persons not having a current Lascar’s licence would also be eligible to apply and compete in the process – Equality of opportunity in matters of public employment being a sine qua non for a fair and transparent selection process, such equality is conspicuously absent in the present case – If persons holding Syrang’s licence who are better equipped than persons holding Lascar’s licence are allowed to apply and participate in the process for appointment on the post of Lascar, the probability of the persons holding Lascar’s licence being outperformed by the persons holding Syrang’s licence would be quite high – In case all the vacant posts of Lascar are filled up by persons having Syrang’s licence but not having a current Lascar’s licence as per the statutory requirement, that would pose a real difficulty for persons not so fortunate and lacking in higher intelligence, abilities and intellect, as they would cease to have a level playing field of competing with other similarly qualified candidates, and left to compete with candidates having higher qualifications despite the zone of consideration having been specially carved out for holders of current Lascar’s licence – If, in case, all the vacant posts of Lascar are filled up by persons having Syrang’s licence and such holders of Syrang’s licence do not participate in the process for direct recruitment to the post of Syrang, it is fairly likely that the persons holding Lascar’s licence would never secure any public employment which could not have been the intention of a welfare State. [Paras 26, 27] Constitution of India – Art. 142 – Exercise of power under – When not warranted – Discussed. [Paras 38-40] Code of Civil Procedure – Non-joinder of a necessary party – Special Rules of 1975 for the Kerala State Water Transport Subordinate Service (Operating Wing) – Possession of a current Lascar’s licence was an essential qualification for posts of “Boat Lascar” – Appellant was the holder of a Syrang’s licence, license superior to Lascar’s Licence – He was selected however, while he was awaiting offer of appointment, applications were filed in the Administrative Tribunal inter alia to declare candidates not possessing current Lascar’s Licence on the last date for receipt of applications as ineligible – Appellant was not impleaded in the proceedings despite being a necessary party – Appellant appointed – Tribunal allowed applications – Appellant’s appointment was 372 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports cancelled – Tribunal’s order challenged by the appellant, writ petitions dismissed by High Court:
Held: After appearing in a competitive examination and upon being selected, the appointees become an identified category and that if the rights of such appointees forming part of such identified category are to be affected by any determination, they should be impleaded in the proceedings as necessary parties – The non-joinder permits them to take the plea that the impugned order does not bind them – However, in the present case, the appellant did not immediately challenge the Tribunal’s order and challenged it only after his service came to be terminated – He took a chance of favourable consideration of his case by responding to the show cause – Having taken a chance and not being successful, he cannot, thereafter, succeed before this Court on the ground of his non-joinder as a necessary party. [Paras 17, 19] Case Law Cited Parvaiz Ahmed Parry v. State of Jammu and Kashmir [2015] 12 SCR 810 : (2015) 17 SCC 709; Chandra Shekhar Singh and Others v. State of Jharkhand, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 595 – distinguished. District Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi [1990] 2 SCR 559 : (1990) 3 SCC 655 – held applicable.
Pramod Kumar v. U.P. Secondary Education Services Commission [2008] 4 SCR 559 : (2008) 7 SCC 153 – relied on.
Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of India and Anr. [1998] 2 SCR 795 : 1998 4 SCC 409; P.M. Latha and Anr. v. State of Kerala and Ors. [2003] 2 SCR 653 : (2003) 3 SCC 541; K. Ajit Babu v. Union of India [1997] Supp. 3 SCR 56 : (1997) 6 SCC 473; Rama Rao v. M. G. Maheshwara Rao [2007] 9 SCR 446 : (2007) 14 SCC 54; Ranjan Kumar v. State of Bihar (2014) 16 SCC 187; Kulwant Singh v. Dayaram [2014] 11 SCR 1053 : (2015) 3 SCC 177; Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India [2007] 3 SCR 95 : (2007) 4 SCC 54 – referred to.
List of Acts Special Rules of 1975 for the Kerala State Water Transport Subordinate Service (Operating Wing); Kerala Inland Vessels Rules, 2010; Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958; Constitution of India; Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 373Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc. List of Keywords Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC); Kerala State Water Transport Department; Boat Lascar; Current lascar’s licence; “Current”; Syrang’s licence; Eligibility criteria; Essential qualification; Public employment; Recruitment process; Overqualification; Higher qualifications than what was required; Distinct class; Nature of duties; Nature of service; Statutory prescription; Equality of opportunity in public employment; Sine qua non; Fair and transparent selection process; Over-qualification not a disqualification; Lack of public employment opportunities; Over qualified candidates; Non-joinder of necessary parties; Identified category; Article 142 of the Constitution of India.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 4499-4500 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 02.12.2019 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in OPKAT Nos. 153 and 154 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
P. N Ravindran, Sr. Adv., P. S. Sudheer, Rishi Maheshwari, Ms. Anne Mathew, Bharat Sood, Jai Govind M J.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Santhosh K, Vipin Nair, Mohd Aman Alam, Aditya Narendranath, Mrs. M.B.Ramya, Mrs. Madhavi Yadav, Mrs. Deeksha Gupta.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
The appeal
1. These appeals, by special leave, take exception to the common judgment and order dated 2 nd December, 2019 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam dismissing the appellant’s writ petitions. 1 1 O.P.(KAT) No. 153 of 2019 and O.P.(KAT) No. 154 of 2019 374 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports FacTs
2. Facts giving rise to these appeals, which are not in dispute, are these: a. An advertisement dated 17th October, 2012 was published by the Secretary of Kerala Public Service Commission 2 inviting applications from interested candidates for filling up 12 vacant posts of “Boat Lascar” under the Kerala State Water Transport Department. 3 The method of appointment was indicated as ‘direct recruitment’ and the qualifications stipulated therein read as follows:
7. Qualifications:
(1) Literacy in Malayalam or Tamil or Kannada
(2) Possession of Current Lascar’s Licence Note :- Candidates should possess current Lascar’s Licence on the last date for receipt of applications, during Practical Test and Interview also.
b. Incidentally, in terms of the Special Rules of 1975 4 for the Kerala State Water Transport Subordinate Service (Operating Wing), 5 the service would consist of 3 classes of officers. While Class I comprised 2 categories, Classes II and III comprised 3 categories, viz. Category 1, Category 2 and Category 3. Syrang, Driver and Lascar are listed at Categories 1, 2 and 3, respectively, of Class III. In terms of the Schedule appended to the Special Rules, the post of Syrang can be filled up either by direct recruitment or by promotion from among Lascars in the ratio of 1:1 whereas appointment on the post of Lascar is entirely by direct recruitment. It is also provided in the Schedule that while literacy in Malayalam or Tamil or Kannada is the common qualification required for appointment as Syrang as well as Lascar, an individual aspiring for the post of Syrang must possess current Syrang’s licence while an individual aspiring for appointment on the post of Lascar is similarly required to possess a current Lascar’s Licence.
2 KPSC
3 the department 4 the Special Rules 5 Subordinate Service [2025] 5 S.C.R. 375Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc. c. The licence noted above is a certificate of competency that is referred to in Chapter III of the Kerala Inland Vessels Rules, 2010. In terms thereof, any aspiring individual fulfilling the qualifications statutorily prescribed is issued a certificate of competency upon succeeding in the “viva voce examination” that is conducted either for a Syrang’s licence or a Lascar’s licence. Inter alia, while a person aspiring for a Syrang’s licence is required to be 10 th standard pass, it is 8 th standard pass for anyone aspiring for a Lascar’s licence.
d. By a letter dated 9 th October, 2012 addressed to the Director of the Department, the Director of Ports 6 conveyed to the following effect:
… This is to communicate formally that the Syrang, Master and Driver Certificate issued by the Chief Examiner under the KIV Rules· 2010 is a certificate superior to Lascar Certificate. Hence those who possess Syrang, Master and Driver Certificate will be proficient in Lascar work also. Thus Syrang and Master Certificate can be considered more than equivalent to Lascar Certificate and such persons are eligible for the job ‘lacer’ (sic, lascar) also.
This communication is issued based on the representation received from a few candidates who applied to the Public Service Commission for Lascar job in order to enable them to complete the application process. Copy of their representation is enclosed. However the final selection may be done based on practical test, on the skills required, type of vessel and other requirements of the organization. … e. The appellant was the holder of a Syrang’s licence, which was valid when he noticed the advertisement.
f. Perceiving that possession of a Syrang’s licence makes him eligible to apply for the post of Lascar which, incidentally, happens to be the feeder post for promotion to the post of 6 the Director 376 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Syrang, the appellant offered his candidature and acquitted himself creditably resulting in his name figuring at serial number 1 (OX category) in the “Ranked List” which was circulated vide No. 257/17/ERVI and brought into force with effect from 22 nd February, 2017. He had secured 45.67 marks. Based on such rank, the Secretary, KPSC informed the appellant vide letter dated 2 nd May, 2017 as follows:
… You are informed that you have been advised for recruitment as Boat Lascar on Rs.8,960 -14,260/- in the above Department against BC Turn. The selection is subject to Rule 3(c) and 10(b) of the Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958.
Further instructions will be issued to you in due course by the above Department.
… g. While the appellant was awaiting an offer of appointment, on 8 th May, 2017 and 27 th July, 2017, two sets of original applications under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 19857 were filed before the Thiruvananthapuram and Ernakulam Benches of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal. 8 h. The prayer in O.A. No. 857 of 2017 was for a declaration that inclusion of ineligible candidates, who do not possess the essential qualification, is oppressive, arbitrary and illegal; a direction be issued to restructure the “Ranked List” by removing all such ineligible candidates; and to pass incidental orders. In OA (EKM) 1566 of 2017, similarly, the Tribunal was urged to declare candidates who did not have valid and current Lascar’s licence as on 17 th October, 2012, i.e., the last date for receipt of applications, as not eligible to be included in the “Ranked List” as well as for issuance of a direction to KPSC to recast the “Ranked List” by excluding the candidates not possessing valid Lascar’s licence on 17 th October, 2012.
7 O.A. No. 857 of 2017 and O.A. (EKM) No. 1566 of 2017 8 Tribunal [2025] 5 S.C.R. 377Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc. i. Importantly, in OA No. 857 of 2017, no private party figured in the array of respondents and there were only three official respondents (Director of the department, the Director and KPSC). In OA (EKM) No. 1566 of 2017, apart from the official respondents, only 5 of the several selected candidates were joined as respondents. The appellant was not one among the five private respondents who were impleaded in the said application. j. During the pendency of the original applications before the Tribunal, the appellant came to be appointed on 28 th July, 2017 as “Boat Lascar”.
k. The reply statement filed by the Director before the Tribunal on 20th February, 2018 is extracted hereunder:
“2. Port Department is implementing KIV Rules 2010.
Director of Ports is the competent Authority to oversee the various regulations, under the provisions of KIV Rules 2010. KIV Rules insist that the MASTER, DRIVER AND SYRANG certificates will be issued only after 2 years from the date of issue of Lascar certificate by the Chief Examiner, Department of Ports. So the persons who got competency certificates for Master, Driver and Syrang also have sufficient eligibilities to be the boat lascar. The above competency certificate holders are also eligible to apply for the post of Lascar and it is stated by the Director of Ports in the letter No.B3-389/2011 dated 9.10.2012.”
l. In due course, the original applications were heard by the Tribunal. Vide its judgment and order dated 9 th March, 2018, 9 the Tribunal allowed both the original applications and directed KPSC to recast the “Ranked List” and to cancel the advice to appoint ineligible candidates.
m. Acting in pursuance of the Tribunal’s order, KPSC issued a show cause notice dated 31 st July, 2018 to the appellant calling upon him to explain why the advice for his appointment be not treated as cancelled. The appellant responded thereto by his reply dated 10th August, 2018. Thereafter, KPSC issued an order 9 Tribunal’s order 378 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports dated 24 th October, 2018 cancelling the advice for appointment of the appellant following which the Director cancelled the appellant’s appointment as “Boat Lascar” by his order dated 27 th October, 2018.
n. On 3rd November, 2018, the appellant challenged the Tribunal’s order before the High Court in separate writ petitions. However, a Division Bench of the High Court by the common impugned judgment and order dismissed such writ petitions.
conTenTions oF The parTies
3. Mr. P. N. Ravindran, learned senior counsel for the appellant, argued that both the Tribunal in allowing the original applications as well as the High Court in dismissing the writ petitions fell in error in not appreciating that a higher qualification could never have been regarded as a disqualification for appointment on the post of Lascar.
4. Mr. Ravindran relied on the decisions in Parvaiz Ahmed Parry v. State of Jammu and Kashmir10 and Chandra Shekhar Singh and Others v. State of Jharkhand11 in support of the contention that a candidate having a higher degree in the subject prescribed under the advertisement cannot be disqualified by reason of ineligibility for not possessing the required degree.
5. Mr. Ravindran further argued that by the time the Tribunal was moved by the unsuccessful candidates, the appellant had not been appointed. However, he did figure in the “Ranked List”. During the pendency of the original applications, the appellant came to be appointed. Despite such appointment, he was not impleaded as a respondent in either of the two original applications filed before the Tribunal. When the original applications were filed, seeking exclusion of candidates holding Syrang’s licence and recasting of the “Ranked List”, without the appellant being included as a respondent, no adverse order could have been passed by the Tribunal qua him. Since the appellant was not impleaded as a respondent in the original applications, the same were defective and no relief could have been granted to the unsuccessful candidates/original applicants.
10 (2015) 17 SCC 709
11 2025 SCC OnLine SC 595 [2025] 5 S.C.R. 379Jomon K.K. v. Shajimon P. & Ors. Etc.
6. Mr. Ravindran also submitted that assuming this Court were not inclined to accept the claim of the appellant that he could have been considered for selection despite not possessing a current Lascar’s licence, it was contended that this was an eminently fit case for exercise of power by this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution. Reliance was placed on the Constitution Bench decision in Supreme Court Bar Association vs Union Of India and Anr.12 .
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.