Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 463; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 714
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Justice Augustine George Masih
- Decided
- 8 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3957/2023
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 714 : 2025 INSC 463 Sakshi Arha v.
The Rajasthan High Court & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023)
08 April 2025 [Abhay S. Oka, Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Augustine George Masih,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The present set of appeals have travelled to this 3-Judge Bench as a result of the split verdict delivered through Judgment dated 18.05.2023 in Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023 and other connected matters. All the candidates had successfully cleared their preliminary examination, followed by mains examination, as per the requirements of marks in their respective categories. However, none of these candidates had their certificates issued as per the date specified in the Subsequent Notice (dated 04.08.2022), their names were not included in the list of the candidates called for interview. Headnotes† Judicial Services – Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, 2010 – Recruitment – Reservation – Submission of caste certificate – Rajasthan High Court-respondent no.1 invited applications for appointment to the post of Civil Judge Cadre being the “Civil Judge Examination 2021” – Last date for receipt of applications was 31.08.2021 – A Notice dated 04.08.2022 (Subsequent Notice) was issued, which mentioned that the concerned reserved category certificates ought not to have been issued beyond 31.08.2021 – The appellants in all the appeals belong to different reserved categories, i.e., Other Backward Classes (Non Creamy Layer) (OBC-NCL) etc. – None of these candidates had their certificates issued as per the date specified in the Subsequent Notice, their names were not included in the list of the candidates called for interview – The appellants contended that the High Court of Rajasthan has erred in not considering that the conditions introduced by the Subsequent Notice, which arbitrarily limited the appellants’ chances in the selection process, despite they having a * Author [2025] 4 S.C.R. 715Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court & Ors. OBC-NCL/MBC-NCL certificate since 2016, which was valid as per the advertisement – This condition, therefore, violated fundamental rights of the appellant(s) – Moreover, there was no such requirement in the 2010 Rules as has been introduced by the Subsequent Notice – Correctness:
Held: The Subsequent Notice, which was issued by the Rajasthan High Court on 04.08.2022, cannot be said to be arbitrary or without any basis – It specified that the certificate belonging to the concerned reserved category should have been issued prior or upto 31.08.2021 i.e. the last date of receipt of the application in pursuance to the Advertisement – This was because the Advertisement required a candidate to possess eligibility upto the cut-off date – As regards the specifications regarding a certificate issued between 31.08.2018 and 30.08.2020 along with the affidavit is concerned, this was based on the Government Circulars dated 09.09.2015 and 08.08.2019 which clarified that the certificate issued will be valid for one year extendable by three years with affidavit – Thus, the Subsequent Notice issued was in consonance with law and as per the Advertisement, applicable Rules, instructions and circulars issued by the competent authority – The plea of the appellants is unsustainable and deserves to be rejected – No relaxation can be granted in the given facts and circumstances of the case nor can it be claimed as a matter of right in the absence of any such discretionary clause in the Advertisement/Rules/Instructions. [Para 36] Case Law Cited Indra Sawhney and Others v. Union of India and Others [1992] Supp. 2 SCR 454 : (1992) Supp. 3 SCC 217 – followed.
Rekha Chaturvedi (Smt) v. University of Rajasthan and Others [1993] 1 SCR 186 : (1993) Supp. 3 SCC 168 – relied on.
Ram Kumar Gijroya v. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board and Another (2016) 4 SCC 754 – distinguished.
Bhupinderpal Singh and Others v. State of Punjab and Others (2000) 5 SCC 262; Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India and Others [2007] 3 SCR 95 : (2007) 4 SCC 54; Divya v. Union of India and Others [2023] 15 SCR 44 : (2024) 1 SCC 448; Indra Sawhney v. Union of India and Others [1999] Supp. 5 SCR 229 : (2000) 1 SCC 168; Ashoka Kumar Thakur v. State of Bihar and Others [1995] Supp. 3 SCR 269 : (1995) 5 SCC 403 – referred to. 716 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, 2010.
List of Keywords Judicial Services; Recruitment; Selection Process; Reservation; Subsequent notice; Rajasthan Judicial Service Examination, 2021; Other Backward Classes (NonCreamy Layer) (OBC-NCL), Most Backward Classes (Non-Creamy Layer) (MBC-NCL) or Economically Weaker Section (EWS); OBC-NCL certificate; Ignorantia juris non excusat.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.09.2022 of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur in DBCWP No. 12374 of 2022 With Civil Appeal No(s). 3958-3961, 3963, 3962 and 3909 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
K. Paari Vendhan, Rishabh Sancheti, Ms. Padma Priya, Jaswant Singh Lakhawat, Naman Jain, Abhisar Bhanu, Prashant Bhushan, Ms. Alice Raj, Ms. Nisha Tiwari, Pallav Mongia, Anubhav Mishra, Archit Upadhayay.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Raju Ramachandran, Sr. Adv., Gopal Jha, Vikram Aditya Narayan, Mrs. Abeda Sheikh, Nishant Verma, Ajay Choudhary.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Augustine George Masih, J.
1. The present set of appeals have travelled to this 3-Judge Bench as a result of the split verdict delivered through Judgment dated 18.05.2023 in Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023 and other connected matters, including Civil Appeal No. 3908 of 2023 which was de-tagged [2025] 4 S.C.R. 717Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court & Ors. from the instant batch vide Order dated 06.11.2024, by Division Bench of this Court.
2. The factual backdrop in the present set of appeals is being culled primarily from the Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023, as it is agreed that the issue involved in these appeals arises from the 2010 Rules which regulate the appointment of Civil Judges in the state of Rajasthan and the relevant facts are identical.
2.1 The Rajasthan High Court – Respondent No. 1 published an Advertisement dated 22.07.2021 (hereinafter referred to as “Advertisement”) inviting applications for appointment to the post of Civil Judge Cadre being the “Civil Judge Examination 2021” as per the Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, 2010 (hereinafter referred to as “2010 Rules), which was admittedly silent on the aspect of the last date of issuance of the concerned certificates for each reserved category. The last date for receipt of the applications was 31.08.2021. Preliminary Test was held on 28.11.2021 followed by the conduct of the Mains Examinations on 30.04.2022 to 01.05.2022. A Notice dated 04.08.2022 (hereinafter referred to as “Subsequent Notice”) was issued, which mentioned that the concerned reserved category certificates ought not to have been issued beyond 31.08.2021.
3. The Appellants in all the appeals belong to different reserved categories, i.e., Other Backward Classes (Non-Creamy Layer) (hereinafter referred to as “OBC-NCL”), Most Backward Classes (Non-Creamy Layer) (hereinafter referred to as “MBC-NCL”) or Economically Weaker Section (hereinafter referred to as “EWS”) categories. These candidates successfully cleared their preliminary examination, followed by mains examination, as per the requirements of marks in their respective categories. However, as none of these candidates had their certificates issued as per the date specified in the Subsequent Notice, their names were not included in the list of the candidates called for interview.
4. This grievance compelled the Appellants to file a series of separate writ petitions before the High Court of Rajasthan, both at Jodhpur, and the Bench at Jaipur. The first and foremost writ was moved by Ms. Jyoti Beniwal, the Appellant in Civil Appeal No. 3909 of 2023 herein, before the Division Bench of High Court of Rajasthan as D.B. Civil Writ Petition No 11784 of 2022, challenging the condition imposed by the 718 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Rajasthan High Court in its Subsequent Notice, requiring candidates under the reserved category to submit a certificate issued within one year of the application deadline i.e. 31.08.2021 or a certificate issued between 31.08.2018 and 30.08.2020, along with an affidavit. The petitioner therein, having cleared the preliminary and mains examinations, contended that no deadline for submitting the OBC- NCL certificate was specified in the Advertisement, and therefore, the late imposition of this condition is arbitrary and unjust. Citing Ram Kumar Gijroya v. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board and Another,1 petitioner therein sought to be interviewed under the OBC-NCL category, referring to the lack of such a deadline in the Advertisement.
5. The High Court of Rajasthan, vide Order dated 18.08.2022, rejected the request, observing that OBC-NCL status is determined annually and requires a valid certificate at the time of the application submission. Relying on this Court’s decision in Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India and Others,2 it observed that where no specific date is provided for document submission, the cut-off date for application submission is applicable. The Division Bench also referred to other decisions, namely, Gaurav Sharma v. State of U.P. through Principal Secy. and 3 Others3 , and Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) and Others,4 which affirmed the necessity of certificates by the cut-off date. Thus, the certificate of the year 2016, as presented by the petitioner therein, was deemed to have failed to meet the requirements as per the law, and the writ petition was dismissed.
6. In the meantime, Ms Sakshi Arha, the Appellant in the Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023, had also moved the Jaipur Bench of the High Court of Rajasthan in D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 12374 of 2022. Her petition was tagged along with other similar petitions, lead case thereof being D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 12022 of 2022, titled as Kuldeep Bhatia Vs. Registrar Examination, Rajasthan High Court which were taken up together. As the said petitions came up for
1 (2016) 4 SCC 754
2 (2007) 4 SCC 54
3 2017 SCC OnLine All 1286
4 (2013) 11 SCC 58
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 719Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court & Ors. hearing, the Court on considering the factual and legal similarity of the dispute, viz-à-viz the case of Ms Jyoti Beniwal (supra), the cases were dismissed vide Common Order dated 06.09.2022.
7. This resulted in the Appellants moving this Court by way of separate Special Leave Petitions which were vide separate orders tagged along with Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023.
8. Since the Division Bench as mentioned above, could not unanimously conclude the fate of these Appellants at stake, the instant set of appeals have travelled before this 3-Judge Bench.
9. The counsels on behalf of the Appellants have argued that the High Court of Rajasthan has erred in not considering that the conditions introduced by the Subsequent Notice arbitrarily limited the Appellants’ chances in the selection process, despite they having a OBC- NCL/MBC-NCL certificate since 2016, which was valid as per the Advertisement. This condition, therefore, violated fundamental rights of the Appellant(s). Moreover, there was no such requirement in the 2010 Rules as has been introduced by the Subsequent Notice.
10. They have further argued that while passing the impugned Order(s), the High Court of Rajasthan wrongly relied on Ashok Kumar Sonkar (supra), which dealt with the qualification criteria. The factual matrix therein concerned with an income-based exclusion from OBC-NCL, which was not the case herein.
11. Moreover, the decision in Ram Kumar Girjoya (supra) was binding on the Court as the Advertisement only necessitated a valid caste certificate as per the prescribed format but had not mandated its issuance within a specified period. The Appellants in the instant appeals are certified to be candidate of OBC-NCL/MBC-NCL category by the competent authority – which had considered the report of Tehsildar – and also the Income Tax Returns for the Assessment Years 2015-2016 to 2022-2023.
12. The decisions rendered by this Court in Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, JEE and Others5 and Dheerender Singh Paliwal v. Union Public Service Commission6 were also brought to our attention to argue
5 (2005) 9 SCC 779
6 (2017) 11 SCC 276
720 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports instances of relaxations that have been previously provided to candidates for submission of proof for the concerned documents, relying on which, respective candidates have made their claim for reservation.
13. In response to the collective submissions of the Appellants, Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the Rajasthan High Court, argued that the benefit of OBC/MBC reservation in a public service is contingent on having been issued a NCL Certificate, which as per the Circulars dated 09.09.2015 and 08.08.2015 of the State of Rajasthan, is valid for a period of one year, and a certificate preceding past two years can be validated subsequently, through an affidavit to the said effect. The Advertisement explicitly provided for the candidate to produce a legally valid certificate. Thus, the action of the Respondent, to not include the Appellants in the list of candidates eligible to participate in the interview in the category of OBC-NCL/MBC-NCL, is in compliance with the law being neither malafide nor arbitrary. Moreover, the High Court of Rajasthan balanced the equity by directing that the result of the Appellant(s) concerned be declared treating them as if they had applied under the General Category.
14. It was further submitted that the decision in Ashok Kumar Sonkar (supra) clarified that in case of absence of a specified cut-off date, the last date of submission of form for the concerned advertisement is deemed so. Withal, this Court in Rakesh Kumar Sharma (supra) observed that if a relaxation is given to accept a concerned certificate after the cut-off date, it would be prejudicial to candidates who had not applied for the said reason.
15. The reliance placed by the Appellants on Ram Kumar Girjoya (supra) is also distinguishable from the instant factual matrix as the candidates herein do not possess a valid certificate to claim the benefit of reservation. Moreover, while Ram Kumar Girjoya (supra) was referred to a larger bench by this Court vide Order dated 24.01.2020 in SLP (Civil) No. 14948 of 2016 and had its observations affirmed by the 3-Judge Bench vide Order dated 28.09.2022 in Karn Singh Yadav v. Government of NCT of Delhi and Others,7 it did not provide any substantive relief to the Appellant therein.
7 (2024) 2 SCC 588
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 721Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court & Ors.
16. We have heard the learned counsels at extensive length while pressing their respective submissions. Before we determine the fate of the Appellants before us, it is crucial to analyse the juxtaposition of the series of arguments presented before us, besides the settled legal positions.
17. Undoubtedly, while the status of a candidate belonging to the Scheduled Caste (hereinafter referred to as “SC”) or Scheduled Tribe (hereinafter referred to as “ST”) is determined by virtue of one’s birth. However, as opposed to the unabating virtue of being an SC or ST candidate, the status of a candidate claiming to be OBC-NCL or MBC-NCL or EWS is constantly subject to transposition owing to their social or economic status with the concerned jurisdiction. It is on the strength of this reasoning that the decision of 9-Judge Bench of this Court in Indra Sawhney and Others v. Union of India and Others8 further categorized the backward classes into “Creamy” and “Non-Creamy” layers as an attempt to differentiate the affluent strata therein, so as to allow for the reservation for those who are truly warranting of the affirmative action by the state.
18. Tracing these footsteps, numerous decisions subsequently rendered by this Court crystalized this dynamic nature of status of other backward classes as against that of SCs or STs. Moreover, this court in a subsequent decision in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India and Others9 clarified that while our nation, Republic of India, remains a caste-based society, the Constitution mandates that caste alone cannot be the basis for discrimination. Accordingly, reservation is justified only when the concern of both, backwardness and underrepresentation in services is addressed sufficiently. It further went on to observe that a caste may be identified as a backward class, but, the creamy layer ought to be excluded as the said set of strata is neither socially, nor economically backward. The inclusion of castes in the backward classes list requires relevant data and must avoid extraneous factors. Improper inclusion of forward castes or failure to exclude the creamy layer undermines the system, depriving the genuinely disadvantaged of benefits. The Bench therein, also dealt with the decision in Ashoka Kumar Thakur v. 8 (1992) Supp. 3 SCC 217
9 (2000) 1 SCC 168
722 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports State of Bihar and Others,10 in which, the Central Government had issued an Office Memorandum dated 08.09.1993 to provide for reservation to certain categories, and admittedly, they belonged to creamy layer.
19. As the determination is clearly varied, it is important to partake the correct implementation of the laws of the land, and, as that attempt, the NCL certificate was introduced in the year 1993 by the Central Government. As part of the said policy, the Tehsildar of the concerned State Government was empowered to issue the said certificate, subject to the relevant guidelines and procedure, as may have been laid down by the respective State Governments.
20. In light of the powers conferred thereof, the State of Rajasthan through its Department of Social Justice and Empowerment keeps issuing relevant directions and/or guidelines vis-à-vis issuances of necessary caste certificates. A perusal of the said circulars establishes a clear position as to its validity.
21. The Circular dated 09.09.2015 notified that a certificate for NCL category shall only be valid for a period of one year. Moreover, if it is a case that the concerned applicant has not transgressed out of the said category in the following year, an affidavit by him/her, as provided in the Appendix-D, would allow the initially issued certificate to be deemed as valid. However, the maximum period to allow for this practice to continue is three years.
21.1 As a reference, the relevant paragraph of the Circular dated 09.09.2015 is reproduced below:
"4. Validity Period of Caste Certificate:
1. The validity of caste certificates issued for SC / ST will be lifetime whereas the certificate for OBC will be issued only once but the fact that the person is not in the creamy layer will be recognised on the basis of a valid affidavit up to three years.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.