Sakshi Arha v. The Rajasthan High Court and Others
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 559; [2023] 9 S.C.R. 583
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Ajay Rastogi, Justice Bela M. Trivedi * Judicial Service – Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, Justice More Backward Class (Ncl) and From the Economically Weaker Section (Ews)
- Decided
- 18 May 2023
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 16428/2022
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
SAKSHI ARHA
v.
THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS
(Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 16428 of 2022)
MAY 18, 2023
[AJAY RASTOGI AND BELA M. TRIVEDI, JJ.] Judicial Service – Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, 2010 – r. 10 – Selection for the post of Civil Judge – Submission of caste certificate – Certificate not accepted – Benefit of Reservation not given – An advertisement issued by respondent dated 22.07.2021, selection process held for the post of Civil Judge – Appellants being members of Other backward Classes (Non-creamy layer), More Backward Class (NCL) and from the Economically weaker Section (EWS), applied for the post in their respective reserved category – Exam conducted – Appellants scored higher marks in their category, however, their certificate relating to category was somewhere later to 31.08.2021 i.e last date of application form, the benefit of reservation not extended to appellant – Writ filed before the High Court was dismissed – Held: (Per Ajay Rastogi, J.): In the given facts and circumstances, when the rules are silent and there is no such instruction that the certificate of the category has to be produced of the period on or before the last date of the application under the advertisement and each of the applicants has produced the certificate relating to category on being demanded by the recruiting authority when the list came to be published of the candidates who were provisionally called for interview on 04.08.2022, each of the applicants indisputedly has furnished their certificate of the category to which they belong at the time of advertisement and had participated in the process of selection – High Court had gone wrong and was influenced with the condition of eligibility to be looked into on the last date of application – Respondents directed to consider candidature of each of the appellant for appointment with consequential benefits – Held (Per Bela M. Trivedi, J.) (Dissenting) : It is no more res integra that in absence of a fixed date indicated in the advertisement inviting applications, with reference to which the requisite eligibility is to be judged, and when the rules are silent, [2023] 9 S.C.R. 583 : 2023 INSC 559 A B C D E F G H 584 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
the only certain date for the scrutiny of the eligibility of a candidate would be the last date for making the applications – Hence, this Court found no error having been committed by the High Court while passing the impugned judgments and orders.
Placing the matter before Hon'ble CJI for constitution of appropriate Bench, the Court Per AJAY RASTOGI, J.
HELD : 1. It is true that the general rule is that while participating in the recruitment process, the person must possess the eligibility qualification on the last date fixed for such purpose unless there is any express provision to the contrary and there can be no relaxation in the matter of holding requisite eligibility qualification by the date fixed and this has to be established by producing necessary certificate or degree, as the case may be. But, at the same time, in order to avail the benefit of reservation or weightage, necessary certificates have to be produced but they are in the nature of proof for the purpose of seeking entitlement to claim the benefit of reservation, but it has no nexus with the last date of the application and, it may not be proper to apply any rigid principle in the absence of any rule to the contrary. As a matter of caution, every infraction of the rule relating to submission of proof in availing the benefit of reservation may not necessarily result in rejection of the candidature.[Para 32][606-F-H; 607-A]
2. The reservation of vacancies of various categories as referred to in Rule 10 is not a condition of eligibility for the candidate to participate in the selection process as the certificate of category for the purpose of claiming reservation will arise not at the stage when the application form is filled making selfdeclaration by the individual candidate to participate in the selection process but at the stage when the select list is to be prepared of the candidates who have participated in the selection process since the final select list has to be published categorywise by giving the benefit of reservation to the candidates who have participated in the process of selection and for no other purpose and when the respondent has demanded from the applicant to furnish their respective certificate of the category to which one had participated in the selection process under its notice A B C D E F G H dated 04th August, 2022, indisputedly each of the applicant had furnished the certificate of their category to which one belong at the time of advertisement when demanded by the recruiting authority in terms of Clause 6(i) & (iii) read with Clause 22(3) of the advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021. [Para 34][607-E-H]
3. That apart, taking into consideration the Scheme of Rules, 2010, which is indisputedly, silent on the subject issue and the advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021 nowhere indicates that the caste certificate/certificate of category has to be produced of the period prior to the last date of the application (31st August, 2021) in the instant case. To the contrary, Clause 6(i) & (iii) read with Clause 22(3) of the advertisement, such certificate of category which one claimed for seeking the benefit of reservation, has to be produced on demand by the recruiting authority. [Para 38][610- B-C]
4. In the given facts and circumstances, when the rules are silent and there is no such instruction that the certificate of the category has to be produced of the period on or before the last date of the application under the advertisement and each of the applicants has produced the certificate relating to category on being demanded by the recruiting authority when the list came to be published of the candidates who were provisionally called for interview on 04th August, 2022, each of the applicants indisputedly has furnished their certificate of the category to which they belong at the time of advertisement and had participated in the process of selection. At this stage, the High Court had gone wrong and was influenced with the condition of eligibility to be looked into on the last date of application, while examining the production of certificate of the category to which the candidate belong and participated in the selection process is in no manner co-related with the conditions of eligibility and the judgments relied upon to non-suite the claim of the appellants has no application in the facts of the instant case. [Para 39][610-D-F]
5. The appeals succeed and are accordingly allowed. The impugned judgment of the High Court is hereby quashed and set SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND
OTHERS
A B C D E F G H 586 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
aside and the respondents are directed to consider candidature of each of the appellant for appointment with consequential benefits including seniority to the post of Civil Judge on their participation in the selection process held pursuant to advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021.[Para 43][612-C-D] Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India and Others (2007) 4 SCC 54 : [2007] 3 SCR 95; Jyoti Beniwal v.
The Rajasthan High Court, Jodhpur Through Its Registrar General and Another (D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.11784/2022); Rakesh Kumar Sharma v.
State (NCT of Delhi) and Others (2013) 11 SCC 58;
Rekha Chaturvedi (Smt.) v. University of Rajasthan and Others (1993) 3 Supp SCC 168 : [1993] 1 SCR 186;
Bhupinderpal Singh and Others v. State of Punjab and Others (2000) 5 SCC 262; Jasbir Rani and Others v.
State of Punjab and Another (2002) 1 SCC 124 : [2001] 4 Suppl. SCR 494; Shankar K. Mandal and Others v.
State of Bihar and Others (2003) 9 SCC 519 : [2003] 3 SCR 796; Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, Jee & Others (2005) 9 SCC 779 : [2004] 5 Suppl. SCR 79; Ram Kumar Gijroya v. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board and Another (2016) 4 SCC 754; Karn Singh Yadav v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi and Others (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1341 - referred to.
Case Law Reference [2007] 3 SCR 95 referred to para 14 (2013) 11 SCC 58 referred to para 20 [1993] 1 SCR 186 referred to para 26 (2000) 5 SCC 262 referred to para 26 [2001] 4 Suppl. SCR 494 referred to para 26 [2003] 3 SCR 796 referred to para 26 [2004] 5 Suppl. SCR 79 referred to para 35 (2016) 4 SCC 754 referred to para 36 A B C D E F G H Per BELA M. TRIVEDI, J. (Dissenting)
HELD : 1. At the outset, it deserves to be noted that the certificates to the persons belonging to the reserved categories like SC/ST/OBC-NCL/MBC-NCL/EWS are being issued by the competent authorities of the respective State Governments keeping in view the provisions contained in the Constitution of India and the guidelines/principles laid down by this Court from time to time. The status of a person whether he belongs to SC or ST category depends on the caste which he belongs to by birth, and such status would remain unchanged and would be static, however, the status of a person whether he belongs to OBC- NCL/MBC-NCL/EWS would depend upon his/her social and economic status, and such status would keep on changing depending on his/her income and therefore would be dynamic. It is very well settled position of law that the persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes were and are treated as a separate category, and the principle of “creamy layer” does not apply to the said categories. It applies only to the persons belonging to the socially and the economically backward classes. Ergo, the date of issuance of certificate to the persons belonging to OBC-NCL/MBC-NCL/EWS categories assumes significance for the purpose of ascertaining as to whether the candidate claiming to belong to a particular reserved category on the date when he/she applied for the post in question under such category, in fact belonged to the said category on the date on which such application was made or on the date prescribed in the advertisement. [Para 14][625-D-G]
2. Having regard to the said instructions contained in the said advertisement dated 22.07.2021, there remains no shadow of doubt that if a candidate had applied under any of the reserved categories, he or she was expected to have a valid certificate issued by the competent authority as per rules in the prescribed format, to show his or her eligibility to apply under such category. The time limit for making such application as stated in Clause 17 of the said advertisement was upto 5 PM on 31.08.2021. Under the circumstances, the candidate was expected to have the SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND
OTHERS
A B C D E F G H 588 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
requisite certificate to show that he or she belonged to the concerned reserved category, on the date of making application or on the last date fixed for the submission of applications i.e. 31.08.2021. Such certificate to be produced by the concerned candidate had to be a valid certificate issued by the competent authority in consonance with the circulars issued by the State Government dated 09.09.2015 and as clarified in the Circular dated 08.08.2019, which governed the issue with regard to the validity of such certificates. [Para 22][630-C-E]
3. All the appellants had produced their respective certificates which were obtained by them after the last date fixed for the submission of the application i.e., 31.08.2021, and had also not produced the documents/affidavits in support thereof, in compliance with the circulars dated 09.09.2015 and 08.08.2019. Therefore, the certificates produced by the appellants at the time of interview could not said to be valid certificates as mandated in the advertisement dated 22.07.2021 by the respondents. [Para 23][630-H; 631-A]
4. It was sought to be submitted by counsel for the appellants that there was no specific date mentioned in the advertisement dated 22.07.2021 as to the validity period of the certificates to be furnished by the appellants, and subsequent notice dated 04.08.2022 directing the appellants to produce the certificates as mentioned therein was highly unreasonable, and tantamount to changing the rules of game after the process of selection had started. The Court does not find any substance in the said argument. As stated earlier, there were specific instructions given in the advertisement that the candidates applying under the reserved categories had to submit the valid certificates issued by the competent authority, and therefore such certificates had to be in consonance with the circulars of the State Government dated 09.09.2015 and 08.08.2019 which governed the validity period of such certificates. The subsequent notice dated 04.08.2022 given by the respondent High Court requiring the candidates belonging to OBC/MBC(NCL) to produce the certificates issued not prior to one year from the last date fixed A B C D E F G H for the submission of application form i.e., 31.08.2021, was absolutely in consonance with the said circulars issued by the State Government. It was also mentioned in the said notice dated 04.08.2022 that in case the OBC/MBC(NCL) certificate was issued between 31.08.2018 and 30.08.2020, an affidavit in prescribed format along with the caste certificate had to be produced. For the EWS category, it was stated that the Income and Asset certificate required for seeking reservation in EWS category must not have been issued prior to 01.04.2021 and in case the Income and Asset certificate was issued between 01.04.2019 and 31.03.2021, then an affidavit in the prescribed format along with the certificate had to be produced. It was specifically mentioned therein that SC/ST/OBC/MBC/EWS certificate, as the case may be, must not have been issued after the last date of submission of the application form i.e., 31.08.2021. Such instructions requiring the reserved category candidates to produce the requisite certificates could neither be said to be unreasonable nor could be construed as changing the rules of game after selection process was started, they being in consonance with the important instructions given in the advertisement dated 22.07.2021, and in consonance with the circulars issued by the State Government with regard to the validity period of caste certificates. [Para 24][631-B-H; 632-A]
5. It is needless to say that when a candidate applies under a particular reserved category, he or she is required to have the certificate of that particular category on the date on which he or she makes the application to show his or her eligibility to apply under the said category. If such certificates are obtained subsequent to date of their application or subsequent to the last date of submission of the applications mentioned in the advertisement, such certificates could not be said to be valid certificates, more particularly in cases where the candidate applies under OBC-NCL or EWS, which category is highly dynamic and not static, as the economic status of the candidate would keep on changing depending on the income of the candidate. [Para 25][632- B-C]
6. It is no more res integra that in absence of a fixed date indicated in the advertisement inviting applications, with reference SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND
OTHERS
A B C D E F G H 590 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
to which the requisite eligibility is to be judged, and when the rules are silent, the only certain date for the scrutiny of the eligibility of a candidate would be the last date for making the applications. It cannot be gain said that the date of interview or selection would always be uncertain and the uncertainty of the date may lead to an anomalous situation in as much as even those candidates who were not eligible to apply under the reserved category on the date of making application, may apply under the reserved category and subsequently obtain the certificate by the time the interviews are held. In such circumstance, the possibility of playing mischief also cannot be ruled out. In the instant case, the last date for the submission of applications was 31.08.2021 and the interviews were fixed in August 2022. So, there was a gap of one full year between the last date for submission of the applications and the date of interview, during which period the economic status and resultant status of “creamy layer/non-creamy layer/EWS” of the candidates might have also changed. Therefore, the exposition of law settled by this Court is that in absence of a fixed date indicated in the advertisement, and when the rules are also silent, the last date fixed for submitting the applications would be the date for the scrutiny of the eligibility of the candidates. [Para 29][633-F-H; 634-A-B]
7. It is also pertinent to note that if the appellants were allowed to produce the certificates issued after the last date fixed for the submission of applications mentioned in the advertisement i.e. 31.08.2021, the other candidates similarly situated as the appellants might raise a grievance for not giving them such opportunity. The appellants who are the defaulters could not be given preferential treatment by accepting the certificates produced by them as valid, though the same were obtained by them after the last date for the submission of applications fixed in the advertisement. The said certificates were also not supported by the requisite affidavits as per the Government circulars dated 09.09.2015 and 08.08.2019. [Para 33][635-H; 636- A-B]
8. In view of the afore-stated factual and legal aspects of the matter, the Court does not find any error having been A B C D E F G H committed by the High Court while passing the impugned judgments and orders. [Para 34][636-C] Dr. M.V. Nair v. Union of India & Ors. (1993) 2 SCC 429; Ashok Kumar Sharma & Ors. v. Chander Shekhar & Anr. (1997) 4 SCC 18 : [1997] 2 SCR 896 – relied on.
Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, JEE & Ors. (2005) 9 SCC 779 : [2004] 5 Suppl. SCR 79; Ram Kumar Gijroya v.
Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board and Anr.
(2016) 4 SCC 754; Karn Singh Yadav v. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1341;
Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India & Ors. (2007)
4 SCC 54 : [2007] 3 SCR 95; Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors. (2013) 11 SCC 58; Indra Sawhney & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. 1992 Supp
(3) 217 : [1992] 2 Suppl. SCR 454; M. Nagaraj & Ors.
v. Union of India & Ors. (2006) 8 SCC 212 : [2006] 7 Suppl. SCR 336; Ashoka Kumar Thakur v. Union of India & Ors. (2008) 6 SCC 1 : [2008] 4 SCR 1; Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India W.P. (C) 55/2019; Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan and Others (1993) 3 Supp SCC 168 : [1993] 1 SCR 186 - referred to.
Case Law Reference [2004] 5 Suppl. SCR 79 referred to para 12 (2016) 4 SCC 754 referred to para 12 [2007] 3 SCR 95 referred to para 12 (2013) 11 SCC 58 referred to para 12 [1992] 2 Suppl. SCR 454 referred to para 15 [2006] 7 Suppl. SCR 336 referred to para 16 [2008] 4 SCR 1 referred to para 17 (1993) 2 SCC 429 relied on para 30 SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND
OTHERS
A B C D E F G H 592 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
[1993] 1 SCR 186 referred to para 31 [1997] 2 SCR 896 relied on para 32 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 3957 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 06.09.2022 of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur in DBCWP No. 12374 of 2022. With Civil Appeal Nos. 3958-3961, 3963, 3962, 3908 and 3909 of 2023. Rishabh Sancheti, Ms. Padma Priya, Anchit Bhandari, Suyash Jain, Chirag Kalani, Zeeshan Ali, K. Paari Vendhan, Abhisar Bhanu, Prince, Archit Upadhyay, Shubham Mishra, Vaibhav Shahi, Mrs. Prashita Mishra, Anvesh Soni, Pallav Mongia, Ankush Mangal, Tushar Srivastava, Advs. for the Appellant.
Gopal Jha, Ajay Choudhary, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgments of the Court were delivered by
RASTOGI, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The present batch of appellants before us are the members of Other Backward Classes (Non-Creamy Layer i.e., NCL); More Backward Class (NCL) and from the category of Economically Weaker Section (EWS), finally qualified in the selection process held for the post of Civil Judge pursuant to an advertisement issued by the respondent dated 22nd July, 2021 but they have not been considered in the category to which they belong for the reason that the certificate of the category which was furnished by each of the appellant is subsequent to the last date indicated in the advertisement, i.e., 31st August, 2021 and each of them unfortunately could not qualify in open category, filed writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution that came to be dismissed by the Division Bench of the High Court, which is the subject matter of challenge before this Court.
3. The brief facts of the case emanate from the record are that the post of Civil Judge to which we are concerned is included in the A B C D E F G H Schedule appended to Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, 2010 (hereinafter being referred to as the “Rules, 2010”) and is to be filled up only by direct recruitment based on the result of competitive examination conducted by the recruiting authority as provided under Part IV of the Rules, 2010.
4. Apart from the method of recruitment, it may be noticed that the reservation is being provided to the members of Scheduled Castes/ Schedule Tribes/Other Backward Classes/More Backward Classes/ Persons with Disabilities and Women Candidates under Rule 10 of the Rules, 2010. With the stipulation under Rule 10(2) & (5) that in the event of non-availability of suitable candidates amongst OBC/MBC in a particular year of recruitment, the vacancies so reserved for them shall be filled in accordance with the normal procedure and such of the unfilled vacancies be carried forward to the subsequent recruitment year.
5. That as per the Scheme of examination referred to under Rule 20 of the Rules, 2010, the competitive examination for recruitment to the post of Civil Judge shall be conducted by the recruiting authority in two stages i.e. preliminary examination followed with Main examination as per the Scheme specified in Part-IV of the Rules, 2010. With the stipulation that the marks obtained in the preliminary examination by the candidates who are declared qualified for admission to the Main examination shall not be counted for determining their merit and those who qualified in the Main examination will be called for interview and the marks secured in the Main examination and interview shall be the governing factor in determining merit and those who finally placed in the merit list, their names will be recommended by the recruiting authority for appointment under Rule 24 and the appointments will be made by the appointing authority in consultation with the Court in terms of Rule 26 of Rules, 2010.
6. Around 120 vacancies of the year 2020-21 of Civil Judge came to be advertised by the respondent pursuant to advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021 and category-wise reservation was indicated in the tabulation chart as referred to under Clause 4 of the advertisement, which is reproduced as under:- SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 594 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
*Out of 05 posts reserved for persons with Benchmark Disabilities, 01(one) post is reserved for blindness and low vision, 01 (one) for deaf and hard of hearing, 01 (one) for locomotor disability including cerebral palsy, leprosy cured, dwarfism, acid attack victims and muscular dystrophy and 02 (two) for autism, intellectual disability, specific learning disability and mental illness and multiple disabilities from the amongst persons under Clauses (a) to (d) including deaf-blindness in the posts identified for each disabilities.
7. Under Clause 5 of the advertisement, it is indicated that in the absence of vacancies reserved of various categories remained unfilled, what method has to be adopted in filling those unfilled vacancies with a note appended thereto that the applicants who are from the State of Rajasthan and members of Other Backward Class (Creamy Layer)/ More Backward Class (Creamy Layer) and applicants from other than the State of Rajasthan and members of SC/ST/OBC (Creamy Layer/ Non-Creamy Layer) and More Backward Class (Creamy Layer/Non- Creamy Layer) and Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) shall be considered in general category and as referred to under Clause 6(i) and
(iii) of the advertisement, caste certificate issued as per Rules in the prescribed format by the competent authority has to be produced for seeking reservation and under Clause 22(3) (Other Important Instructions), it was indicated that the applicant has to produce on demand of the recruiting authority all such documents/certificates while claiming benefit of reservation required by the Rajasthan High Court or the A B C D E F G H concerned recruiting authority. The extract of Clause 6(i) and (iii) read with Clause 22(3) of the advertisement are reproduced hereunder: “6. In the context of Certificate of various categories
(i) Caste Certificate issued as per rules in the prescribed format by the Competent Authority will have to be produced for reservation in the Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Other Backward Class and Highly Backward Class.
(ii) ……
(iii) Certificate issued as per rules in the prescribed format by the Competent Authority shall have to produce in the event of applicant belongs to Economic Weaker Section.
….
“22. Other Important Instructions :- (1)-(2) ……….
(3) It would be mandatory for the applicants to submit all concerning original documents/certificates, on the basis of which they raise any claim on being demanded by the Rajasthan High Court or concerned Appointing authority.
(4) …….”
8. The instructions indicated that in terms of Clause 6(i) & (iii) read with Clause 22(3), the applicants who claim the benefit of reservation, such certificate/document has to be produced on demand by the High Court or concerned Appointing authority. Thus, it is clear that there is no requirement to furnish the caste certificate of the category claiming benefit of reservation either at the stage of filling the application form or at any lager stage, however, it has to be produced on demand by the recruiting authority. It may be noticed that the reservation for MBC (NCL) and EWC are for the first time introduced in the instant selection process held pursuant to an advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021.
9. The relevant requirement was notified by the respondent to be furnished by the applicant claiming reservation against reserved vacancies OBC-NCL, MBC-NCL or EWS category as the case may be, with the stipulation that the certificate must be of the period not prior to one year of the last date of submission of application i.e. 31st August, 2021 for the SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 596 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
first time by its notice dated 04th August, 2022 of which reference has been made. The extract of the documents demanded by the respondent in reference to the certificate relating to category, is reproduced as under:- “(iii) Certificate relating to category a. OBC/MBC (Non Creamy Layer) certificate issued not prior to one year from the last date of submission of the application form i.e. 31.08.2021.
b. In case OBC/MBC (Non Creamy Layer) certificate is issued between 31.08.2018 and 30.08.2020, an affidavit in prescribed format along with caste certificate has to be produced.
c. In case of EWS category – Income & Asset required for seeking reservation in EWS category must not be issued prior to 01.04.2021.
In case Income & Asset Certificate issued between 01.04.2020 and 31.03.2021, an affidavit in prescribed format along with certificate has to be produced.
d. SC/ST/OBC/MBC/EWS certificate, as the case may be must not have been issued after the last date of submission of the application form i.e. 31.08.2021.”
(emphasis supplied)
10. It is not the case of the respondent that either of the appellant does not belong to the respective reserved category i.e. OBC-NCL, MBC-NCL or EWS but their certificate relating to category is of the date later to the cut-off date i.e. 31st August, 2021 but each of the applicant although was permitted to appear in the interview under the interim order of the High Court but were not permitted to claim the benefit of their certificate relating to category which was furnished and were treated to be in the open category.
11. When the result came to be finally published, indisputedly, each of the applicant secured higher marks in their respective category i.e. OBC-NCL, MBC-NCL or EWS as the case may be, and the candidates lower in merit have been selected by the respondent but since their certificate relating to category is somewhere later to the cutoff date i.e. 31st August, 2021 (the last date of application form), the A B C D E F G H benefit of reservation has not been extended and since each of the applicant failed to qualify in the open category, they were finally denied from being considered for appointment to the post of Civil Judge and this fact can be further supported from the result of recruitment of Civil Judge Cadre 2021 published by respondent by notice dated 30th August, 2022 that indicates that the present appellants have secured higher marks in their respective category qua those who have been finally recommended for appointment in the category of OBC-NCL, MBC- NCL or EWS category to which the present appellants are concerned and for convenience, comparative statement prepared by the respondent, in the tabulation form is reproduced as under:- “OBC-NCL category - SLP(C) No.5654/2023, SLP(C) No.16428/ 2022, SLP(C) Nos.18296-18299/2022 “MBC-NCL category – Sunil Gurjar SLP(C) No.19179/22 & Kuldeep Bhatia SLP(C) No.21644/22 S.No. Name of the Petitioner Marks Obtained Cut off General Cut Off Marks
MBC-NCL
Date of
MBC-NCL
Certificates Date of
MBC-NCL
Certificate required as per Respondents
1. Sunil Singh Gurjar 172 179.5 141 18.06.2018 & 16.06.2022 31.08.2018 to 31.08.2021
2. Kuldeep Bhatia 141.5 179.5 141 03.08.2012 & 09.03.2022 “-do-“ “EWS category – Parul Jain SLP(C) Diary No.1581 of 2023 SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 598 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
12. It is not disputed by the respondent that each of the applicant is holding the certificate of their respective category and it is of prior date when demanded by the respondent under its notice dated 04th August, 2022.
13. This has come on record that circulars are issued by the State of Rajasthan for the purpose of obtaining the certificate relating to category in reference to seeking employment issued by the Department of Social Justice and Empowerment, Jaipur dated 09th September, 2015 followed with 08th October, 2019 indicating the validity of certificate of OBC-NCL, MBC-NCL or EBC and since there was a lot of confusion and the circulars were not accessible to the people at large and litigation was pending before the Courts, the State Government stepped in and in furtherance thereof, issued its directive dated 17th October, 2022 and came with the clarification that if for any reason, the candidate has not produced a certificate issued till the last date of application form and produces a certificate after the last date of filling up of application then in that case, candidate should submit an affidavit that he was having the eligibility of respective category and if the information is found incorrect, then appointment can be cancelled. The extract of the clarification made by the Government in meeting out the exigencies as demanded and to streamline the on-going litigation, under its directive dated 17th October, 2022 is reproduced as under:- “If for any reason a candidate has not produced a certificate issued till the last date of application form and produces a certificate which is issued after the last date of filling application form then in that case candidate should write an affidavit to this aspect that he was having the qualification of respective class and if the information is found incorrect then the appointment shall be cancelled.”
14. For the sake of repetition, it may be noticed that it is not the case of the respondent that either the appellant is not holding eligibility of A B C D E F G H the respective category of which he/she belongs in terms of advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021 and their only fault is that their certificate relating to category is of a date later to the last date of application (i.e. 31st August, 2021) in terms of notice dated 04th October, 2022 demanding for furnishing the certificate relating to category to which they were provisionally called for interview.
15. On a writ petition being filed by the appellants assailing the action of the respondent in not permitting them of claiming benefit of reservation to which they belong and each of them have qualified after securing more marks over the cut-off of respective category, the Division Bench of the High Court has non-suited their claim on the premise that each of them had failed to furnish certificate of their category as required on the last date of application i.e. 31st August, 2021 by placing reliance on the judgment of this Court in Ashok Kumar Sonkar vs. Union of India and Others (2007) 4 SCC 54 held that the last date of application is a touchstone for determining the eligibility and since each of them had failed to furnish their respective certificate relating to category on or before 31st August, 2021, they are held ineligible from being considered in the respective category and since each of them had not been able to qualify in the open category considered unsuitable for appointment to the post of Civil Judge, under the impugned judgment dated 18th August, 2022 in the case of Jyoti Beniwal vs. The Rajasthan High Court, Jodhpur Through Its Registrar General and Another (D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.11784/2022) and that was referred to in the subsequent writ petitions filed and all were disposed of placing reliance on the judgment of Jyoti Beniwal (Supra) by subsequent impugned judgment dated 06th September, 2022 and in the case of appellant Parul Jain, separate judgment was passed on 18th November, 2022 relying on the same judgment of High Court in Jyoti Beniwal (Supra) and that became the subject matter of challenge in appeal before us.
16. Learned counsel for the appellants jointly submit that it was nowhere indicated at any stage that certificate of the category upto which date is to be furnished by the applicants/candidates while claiming reservation and each of the appellant holds the certificate of their respective category and accordingly, each of them mentioned in their application form with regard to the category they intend to participate in the selection process and although the permission granted to appear in the preliminary examination was provisional but no one has examined at SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 600 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
any stage that what is the requirement and since there is no reference made either in the Scheme of Rules, 2010 or in the advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021 to the certificate of category to which the appellant claim has to be furnished is of which date or year. Each of them had bona fidely pleaded that the certificate of the category which is being obtained is issued by the competent authority after due compliance for all practical purposes and in the given facts and circumstances, the rigor which has been put by the Division Bench of the High Court under the impugned judgment taking 31st August, 2021 as a sacrosanct date for furnishing the certificate relating to category is nowhere prescribed either under the Rules of 2010 or in the advertisement to which we are concerned hence, the premise on which the High Court has proceeded is completely misconceived.
17. Learned counsel further submits that the judgment on which reliance has been placed is not at all applicable on the facts of the instant case for the reason that the judgments relied upon are related to the minimum academic qualification and in the cases where rules are silent or there is no administrative instruction issued by the competent authority/ recruiting authority before the selection process being initiated are in place, this Court has stepped in and laid down a principle that in the absence of rules indicating the requirement of holding academic qualification, the last date of filling application is considered to be a benchmark for the applicant to possess the minimum academic qualification.
18. But we are not dealing in this case with minimum academic qualification or the date of birth which is defined under the Scheme of Rules, 2010. In the given facts and circumstances, the premise on which the claim of the present appellants has been non-suited by the High Court that they failed to furnish the certificate of category on or before 31st August, 2021 is completely without basis/foundation having no nexus and they all have been put to surprise while it was notified to them demanding to furnish the certificate relating to category on or before 31st August, 2021, which was the last date of submission of application but it was, for the first time, notified when the provisional list of candidates calling for interview was published on 04th August, 2022.
19. Learned counsel further submits that they all are coming from rural background and belonging to a poor strata in society, having no means to know the advanced technology which is available in the urban A B C D E F G H cities and with the minimal facilities available at their end, still they are able to crack the competitive examination and when this is not the case of the respondents that either of the appellant is not a member of a category which was indicated by him/her in application form originally filed to non-suite them at the stage when they finally qualified the competitive test and as informed that vacancies are available because of non-joining by the candidates, they can easily be adjusted against the unfilled advertised vacancies without disturbing or taking away the rights of the persons/candidates who have been appointed on being declared successful by this authority.
20. Per contra, while supporting the finding recorded by the High Court, learned counsel for the respondent submits that this being settled by this Court in a catena of judgments that eligibility is to be looked into on the last date of submission of application or the cut-off date indicated in the relevant rules. In the instant case, when the rules are silent in such circumstances, what being laid down by this Court is the law on the subject and the eligibility of the applicant is to be looked into on the last date of application which in the instant case is 31st August, 2021 and admittedly, each of the applicant was not holding their certificate related to category as demanded of the period prior to 31st August, 2021 and accordingly, no error was committed by the respondent and have rightly been treated in open category and it is not the case of the appellant that any candidate who has been recommended and appointed in open category is lower in the order of merit in the selection process held by the respondent pursuant to advertisement dated 21st July, 2021 and in support of his submission, learned counsel has placed reliance on the judgment of this Court reported in Ashok Kumar Sonkar (Supra) followed with Rakesh Kumar Sharma vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and Others (2013) 11 SCC 58 and submits that this being a settled law held by this Court and relied upon by the High Court, no error has been committed by the High Court, which may called for interference of this Court.
21. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and with their assistance perused the material available on record.
22. It is not disputed that the post of Civil Judge is included in the Schedule appended to the Rules, 2010 and is to be filled up by direct recruitment in terms of Part IV and the advertisement was notified by the respondents on 22nd July, 2021 holding selection against 120 vacancies of Civil Judge for the year 2020-2021.
SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 602 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
23. It is not disputed that the Rules of 2010 is a complete code and silent in reference to the date when certificate of the category has to be furnished and so far as the advertisement is concerned, it nowhere indicates as to what should be the crucial date for the purpose of furnishing the caste related certificate by the applicants who intended to participate in the selection process and admittedly each of the appellant holds the certificate of the category and the period prior to as have been notified by the respondent while their provisional list of the candidates to be called for interview has been published on 04th August, 2022.
24. It may be noticed that reservation to MBC (NCL) and EWS category has been introduced for the first time and the candidates are completely alien to the procedure and the format in which the certificate of their category has to be furnished and so far as the candidates who appeared in EWS quota is concerned, it has been submitted that father of the appellant Parul Jain submitted the Income-Tax Returns of the previous years and applied for EWS certificate on E-mitra kiosk on 16th August, 2021 and the appellant was assured that she will receive EWS certificate within 6-7 days but despite the appellant demanding her certificate, it was issued by the E-mitra kiosk on 07th September, 2021 but it is not disputed by the respondent that the appellant belongs to EWS category.
25. It is also not disputed that either in the advertisement which was initially notified on 22nd July, 2021 or at the stage of preliminary examination held on 11th January, 2022 followed with Main examination held on 30th April, 2022 to 01st May, 2022, it was nowhere notified that the certificate of the category has to be furnished of the period prior to 31st August, 2021 and only when the list came to be published of the candidates provisionally qualified for interview on 04th August, 2022, the respondent came out with a defence that cut-off date for furnishing caste related certificate should be prior to one year from the last date of submission of application i.e. 31st August, 2021 and since each of the applicant from OBC-NCL, MBC-NCL or EWS has furnished their respective certificate of the category after it was brought to their notice by the provisional list published on 04th August, 2022 and so far as the candidate belonging to EWS category is concerned, appellant furnished her caste certificate dated 07th September, 2021 with delay of seven days.
A B C D E F G H
26. In the Scheme of rules, age has to be looked into as on the first date of January following the last date fixed for receipt of application, if one is not holding the age in terms of Rule 17, the applicant stands disqualified provided relaxed by the appointing authority and Rule 18 of the Scheme prescribes the academic qualification and it is nowhere indicated as to when the academic qualification of the applicant is to be looked into and here this Court has stepped in and the exposition of law on the subject from Rekha Chaturvedi (Smt.) vs. University of Rajasthan and Others 1993 Supp (3) SCC 168 is consistent and is no more res integra that if the rules are silent and no date is being notified on which the qualification/eligibility of the applicant is to be looked into, the best course is to be taken care is the last date of application. To take a judicial note, reference can be made of Rekha Chaturvedi (Supra) which was further noticed in the case of Bhupinderpal Singh and Others vs. State of Punjab and Others (2000) 5 SCC 262, Jasbir Rani and Others vs. State of Punjab and Another (2002) 1 SCC 124, Shankar K. Mandal and Others vs. State of Bihar and Others (2003) 9 SCC 519 followed with Ashok Kumar Sonkar (Supra) and Rakesh Kumar Sharma (Supra).
27. This Court in Rekha Chaturvedi (Supra) held as under:- ”10. The contention that the required qualifications of the candidates should be examined with reference to the date of selection and not with reference to the last date for making applications has only to be stated to be rejected. The date of selection is invariably uncertain. In the absence of knowledge of such date the candidates who apply for the posts would be unable to state whether they are qualified for the posts in question or not, if they are yet to acquire the qualifications. Unless the advertisement mentions a fixed date with reference to which the qualifications are to be judged, whether the said date is of selection or otherwise, it would not be possible for the candidates who do not possess the requisite qualifications in praesenti even to make applications for the posts. The uncertainty of the date may also lead to a contrary consequence, viz., even those candidates who do not have the qualifications in praesenti and are likely to acquire them at an uncertain future date, may apply for the posts thus swelling the number of applications. But a still worse consequence may follow, in that it may leave open a scope for malpractices. SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 604 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
The date of selection may be so fixed or manipulated as to entertain some applicants and reject others, arbitrarily. Hence, in the absence of a fixed date indicated in the advertisement/notification inviting applications with reference to which the requisite qualifications should be judged, the only certain date for the scrutiny of the qualifications will be the last date for making the applications. We have, therefore, no hesitation in holding that when the Selection Committee in the present case, as argued by Shri Manoj Swarup, took into consideration the requisite qualifications as on the date of selection rather than on the last date of preferring applications, it acted with patent illegality, and on this ground itself the selections in question are liable to be quashed. Reference in this connection may also be made to two recent decisions of this Court in A. P. Public Service Commission, Hyderabad v. B. Sarat Chandra [(1990) 2 SCC 669 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 377 : (1990) 4 SLR 235 : (1990) 13 ATC 708] and District Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society, Vizianagaram v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi [(1990) 3
SCC 655 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 520 : (1990) 4 SLR 237 : (1990) 14
ATC 766].”
(Emphasis supplied)
28. It was later followed in the case of Ashok Kumar Sonkar (Supra), wherein this Court held as under:- “17. In Bhupinderpal Singh v. State of Punjab [(2000) 5 SCC 262 : 2000 SCC (L&S) 639] this Court moreover disapproved the prevailing practice in the State of Punjab to determine the eligibility with reference to the date of interview, inter alia, stating: (SCC pp. 267-68, para 13)
“13. Placing reliance on the decisions of this Court in Ashok Kumar Sharma v. Chander Shekhar [(1997) 4 SCC 18 : 1997 SCC (L&S) 913], A.P. Public Service Commission v. B. Sarat Chandra [(1990) 2 SCC 669 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 377 : (1990)
13 ATC 708], Distt. Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare Residential School Society v. M. Tripura Sundari Devi [(1990) 3 SCC 655 : 1990 SCC (L&S) 520 :
(1990) 14 ATC 766], Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan [1993 Supp (3) SCC 168 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 951 :
A B C D E F G H (1993) 25 ATC 234], M.V. Nair (Dr.) v. Union of India [(1993) 2 SCC 429 : 1993 SCC (L&S) 512 : (1993) 24 ATC 236] and U.P. Public Service Commission v. Alpana [(1994) 2 SCC 723 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 742 : (1994) 27 ATC 101] the High Court has held (i) that the cut-off date by reference to which the eligibility requirement must be satisfied by the candidate seeking a public employment is the date appointed by the relevant service rules and if there be no cut-off date appointed by the rules then such date as may be appointed for the purpose in the advertisement calling for applications; (ii) that if there be no such date appointed then the eligibility criteria shall be applied by reference to the last date appointed by which the applications have to be received by the competent authority. The view taken by the High Court is supported by several decisions of this Court and is therefore well settled and hence cannot be found fault with. However, there are certain special features of this case which need to be taken care of and justice be done by invoking the jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution vested in this Court so as to advance the cause of justice.”
29. It has been transpired and culled out from the aforementioned decision that:-
(i) the cut-off date by reference to which the eligibility requirement must be satisfied by the applicant seeking a public employment is the date notified in the relevant service rules.
(ii) If there is no cut-off appointed date indicated under the rules then such date shall be as appointed for the purpose in the advertisement calling for applications.
(iii) If there is no such date appointed then the eligibility criteria shall be applied by reference to the last date notified by which the applications were to be received by the recruiting authority.
30. These principles have been settled by this Court and is no more res integra for further discussion that when the rules are silent and no date is notified to satisfy the eligibility requirement under the advertisement, the eligibility criteria shall be applied by reference to the last date of application by which applications are to be received by the recruiting authority.
SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 606 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
31. Let us examine the Scheme of Rules, 2010 in other way and Part IV in particular, which provides the method of recruitment in the cadre of Civil Judge, Rule 19 postulates that the candidate has to submit a character certificate while participating for direct recruitment which may qualify him for employment in service, has to be not more than six months prior to the date of application which the candidate has to enclose while the application form is filled for participation in the selection process and if we proceed on the principles as aforestated, the question arises that if the candidate who has participated in the selection process after furnishing the character certificate along with the application form in terms of Rule 19, if at a later stage in the process of selection involves in any act of moral turpitude before he is actually appointed whether the appointing authority is under an obligation to give him appointment if his name is finally placed in the order of merit, the answer indeed is in negative and the reason is that the character certificate enclosed by the applicant at the time of filling the application form in terms of Rule 19 is only for the purpose of satisfaction in reference to the character of the applicant/candidate who intends to participate in the process of recruitment which may qualify him for employment in service, but if he later gets himself involved in any act of moral turpitude, although there is no restriction/embargo, but the authority is always in its competence to take into consideration the later developments and upto the date of appointment if the candidate finally selected is found to be unsuitable for appointment which indeed he did not carry at the time when the application form was filled and that too on the last date of application, but that can always be considered as material to adjudge the suitability of the candidate for being considered for appointment and in the given situation the theory of last date of application becomes completely otiose.
32. It is true that the general rule is that while participating in the recruitment process, the person must possess the eligibility qualification on the last date fixed for such purpose unless there is any express provision to the contrary and there can be no relaxation in the matter of holding requisite eligibility qualification by the date fixed and this has to be established by producing necessary certificate or degree, as the case may be. But, at the same time, in order to avail the benefit of reservation or weightage, necessary certificates have to be produced but they are in the nature of proof for the purpose of seeking entitlement to claim the benefit of reservation, but it has no nexus with the last date of the A B C D E F G H application and, it may not be proper to apply any rigid principle in the absence of any rule to the contrary. As a matter of caution, every infraction of the rule relating to submission of proof in availing the benefit of reservation may not necessarily result in rejection of the candidature.
33. In the similar circumstances, the vacancies are reserved for various categories i.e. SC/ST/OBC/MBC/Persons with Disabilities and women candidates under the Scheme of Rules, 2010 and that has been notified category-wise under Clause 4 of the advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021 with which we are concerned, and it goes without saying that the candidate must be a member of the reserved category at the time when the application form is filled pursuant to the advertisement in question, but at the same time so far as the scheme of examination and syllabus, as provided in Rule 20 of the Rules, 2010 is concerned, for holding competitive examination for the post of Civil Judge conducted by the recruiting authority is common for all and each of the candidate regardless the category to which one belongs, has to undergo the same process of qualifying the preliminary examination followed with main examination and interview, except that the candidates are admitted to the main examination followed with interview in terms of the total number of vacancies category-wise.
34. The reservation of vacancies of various categories as referred to in Rule 10 is not a condition of eligibility for the candidate to participate in the selection process as the certificate of category for the purpose of claiming reservation will arise not at the stage when the application form is filled making self-declaration by the individual candidate to participate in the selection process but at the stage when the select list is to be prepared of the candidates who have participated in the selection process since the final select list has to be published category-wise by giving the benefit of reservation to the candidates who have participated in the process of selection and for no other purpose and when the respondent has demanded from the applicant to furnish their respective certificate of the category to which one had participated in the selection process under its notice dated 04th August, 2022, indisputedly each of the applicant had furnished the certificate of their category to which one belong at the time of advertisement when demanded by the recruiting authority in terms of Clause 6(i) & (iii) read with Clause 22(3) of the advertisement dated 22nd July, 2021.
SAKSHI ARHA v. THE RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AND OTHERS [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 608 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 9 S.C.R.
35. This Court in Dolly Chhanda vs. Chairman, Jee & Others (2005) 9 SCC 779, has considered the situation where the incumbent has failed to furnish the certificate seeking benefit of reservation and after examining the Scheme, this Court in the given circumstances, held as under:
“7. The general rule is that while applying for any course of study or a post, a person must possess the eligibility qualification on the last date fixed for such purpose either in the admission brochure or in application form, as the case may be, unless there is an express provision to the contrary. There can be no relaxation in this regard i.e. in the matter of holding the requisite eligibility qualification by the date fixed. This has to be established by producing the necessary certificates, degrees or marksheets. Similarly, in order to avail of the benefit of reservation or weightage, etc. necessary certificates have to be produced. These are documents in the nature of proof of holding of particular qualification or percentage of marks secured or entitlement to benefit of reservation. Depending upon the facts of a case, there can be some relaxation in the matter of submission of proof and it will not be proper to apply any rigid principle as it pertains in the domain of procedure. Every infraction of the rule relating to submission of proof need not necessarily result in rejection of candidature.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.