Mrs. Varshatai W/O. Sh. Sanjay Bagade v. The State of Maharashtra Through Its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 486; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 625
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice K. Vinod Chandran
- Decided
- 14 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5187/2025
- Sections
- 308, 318, 308(1), 3, 3(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 625 : 2025 INSC 486 Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v.
The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 5187-5188 of 2025)
15 April 2025 [Sudhanshu Dhulia* and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether use of Urdu on a signboard of the building of Municipal Council in Maharashtra is violative of any provision of law. Headnotes† Maharashtra Municipal Council, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Township Act, 1965 – ss.308, 318 – Maharashtra Local Authorities (Official Languages) Act, 2022 – Use of Urdu on the signboard of the Municipality in Maharashtra – Board displaying the name of the Municipal Council on its building in Marathi at the top with translation below in Urdu language – Challenged by the appellant-former member of Municipal Council – High Court held that 2022 Act does not prohibit the use of an additional language which is Urdu in the instant case, on the signboard of Municipal Council building – Interference with:
Held: Not called for – High Court was right in its conclusion – There is no prohibition on using any other language, especially one included in the VIIIth Schedule of the Constitution – Enactment recognizes that language essentially is a tool of communication which cannot be condemned, when this language is being used by a community or group – Marathi and Urdu occupy the same position under Schedule VIII of the Constitution – Purpose for use of Urdu is merely communication – Municipal Council is there to provide services to the local community of the area and cater to their immediate day-to-day needs – If people or a group of people, residing within the area covered by the Municipal Council are familiar with Urdu, then there should not be any objection if Urdu is used in addition to the official language-Marathi, at least on the signboard * Author 626 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of the Municipal Council – Language is a medium for exchange of ideas that brings people holding diverse views and beliefs closer and it should not become a cause of their division – Display of an additional language cannot, by itself, be said to be in violation of the provisions of the 2022 Act – No prohibition on the use of Urdu under the 2022 Act or in any provision of law – Case of the appellant based on a misconception of law. [Paras 15, 19, 46, 49] Language – Urdu language – Usage and recognition – Prejudice against Urdu – Elucidation:
Held: Urdu is the finest specimen of ganga-jamuni tahzeeb, or the Hindustani tahzeeb, which is the composite cultural ethos of the plains of northern and central India – Urdu was the sixth most spoken scheduled language of India – It is spoken by at least a part of the population in all States and Union Territories, except the north-eastern States – Prejudice against Urdu, arises from the misconception that Urdu is alien to India, however, it is incorrect as Urdu, like Marathi and Hindi, is Indo-Aryan language – Urdu language was born in this land, it developed and flourished in India and attained ever greater refinement and became the language of choice for many acclaimed poets – Even today, language used by the common people of the country is replete with words of Urdu language – One cannot have a dayto-day conversation in Hindi without using words of Urdu or words derived from Urdu – Urdu words have a heavy influence on Court parlance, both in criminal and civil law – Influence of Urdu writ large in the language of Indian courts – Urdu language has been adopted by many States and Union Territories in India as the second official language in exercise of powers conferred by Art. 345 – Furthermore, Urdu and Hindi are not two languages, but is one language, both having broad similarities – Constitution of India. [Paras 18, 20, 27, 37-39, 41] Language – Language and religion – Primary purpose of a language – Explanation:
Held: Language is not religion – Language does not even represent religion – Language belongs to a community, to a region, to people; and not to a religion – Language is culture – Language is the yardstick to measure the civilizational march of a community and its people – Primary purpose of a language will always remain communication – Language as a representative of culture makes [2025] 4 S.C.R. 627Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc. discussion on it both sensitive and delicate – People of India have taken great pain in resolving the language issue at the Centre, which is the unique achievement considering the linguistic diversity of the nation – Language is a medium for exchange of ideas that brings people holding diverse views and beliefs closer and it should not become a cause of their division – Misconceptions, perhaps even the prejudices against a language have to be courageously and truthfully tested against the reality, which is the great diversity of the nation. [Paras 17-21, 46, 48] Constitution of India – Schedule VIII – Arts. 345, 351 – Power of the State to adopt official languages – States with more than one official language – Stated. [Paras 21-26] Case Law Cited Uttar Pradesh Hindi Sahitya Sammelan v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2014] 13 SCR 675 : (2014) 9 SCC 716 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited GRANVILLE AUSTIN, Language and the Constitution-the half-hearted compromise, THE INDIAN CONSTITUTION:
CORNERSTONE OF A NATION, Oxford University Press (2000) at pp. 265-307, pp 274, pp 277-278, pp 272; A.M ZAIDI, THE
ENCYCLOPAEDIA OF INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS-VOL-8:
1921-1924: INDIA AT THE CROSS-ROADS at p. 635; A.M ZAIDI,
THE ENCYCLOPAEDIA OF INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS-
VOL-10: 1930-1935: THE BATTLE FOR SWARAJ at p. 442;
Jawaharlal Nehru, The Unity of India, Foreign Affairs, Volume 16, No. 2 (Jan. 1938), pp. 231-243; Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol IX p. 1415; AMRIT RAI, A HOUSE DIVIDED: THE ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF HINDI/HINDAVI, Oxford University Press (1984) p. 3, 6, 8-13, 285-289; Gyan Chand Jain, Urdu Hindi ya Hindustani, Hindustani Zaban (Jan-April, 1974); Danial Latifi, Urdu in UP, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 36, No.7 (Feb 17-23, 2001), pp. 533-535 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Maharashtra Municipal Council, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Township Act, 1965; Maharashtra Local Authorities (Official Languages) Act, 2022; Uttar Pradesh Official Languages Act, 1951.
628 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Sign board of Municipal Council; Urdu language; Linguistic diversity; Mother tongues; Part XVII of the Constitution; Language issue; Cocanada Session of 1923; Congress Constitution of 1934; Hindustani; Indian National Pact; Constituent Assembly’s Rules of Procedure; Use of Urdu on signboard of the building of Municipal Council in Maharashtra; Language, a tool of communication; Marathi and Urdu; Display of additional language; Language and religion; Primary purpose of language; Language is not religion; Prejudice against Urdu; Ganga-jamuni tahzeeb; Hindustani tahzeeb; Composite cultural ethos; Indo-Aryan language.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 5187-5188 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 10.04.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Nagpur in WP No. 1568 of 2023 & WP No. 2703 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Kunal Cheema, Satyajeetsingh Raghuwanshi, Raghav Deshpande, Shubham Chandankhede, Ms. Kirti, Ms. Saloni Shukla.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sudhanshu Dhulia, J.
‘When you learn a language, you don’t just learn to speak and write a new language. You also learn to be open-minded, liberal, tolerant, kind and considerate towards all mankind.’ – Mouloud Benzadi [2025] 4 S.C.R. 629Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc.
1. Leave granted.
2. The appellant before this Court is apparently not pleased with the use of Urdu on the signboard of the new building of the Municipal Council, Patur (hereinafter referred to as ‘Municipal Council’) in district Akola, Maharashtra. The board of the Council displays “Municipal Council, Patur”, in Marathi at the top, with its translation below in Urdu language.
3. According to the appellant, who is a former member of the Municipal Council, the work of the Municipal Council can only be conducted in Marathi, and the use of Urdu in any manner is impermissible, even though it may just be a writing on the signboard of the Municipal Council.
4. The appellant first raised her objection before the Municipal Council itself. The Council made its deliberations on the question raised by the appellant and ultimately through its resolution dated 14.02.2020, the Municipal Council rejected the appellant’s objection by a majority, and it was resolved that the use of Urdu in addition to Marathi on the signboard of the Municipal Council is perfectly justified. At this stage, we may mention that the signboard is mainly in Marathi, with Urdu appearing below on the signboard, since a significant number of Council members and residents within the Municipal Council area are familiar with Urdu language. This is not a new practice and in fact, it was pleaded before the Collector that this was displayed on the signboard since the existence of the Municipal Council, from the year 1956.
5. The appellant, not satisfied with the resolution, however, moved an application under Section 308 of the Maharashtra Municipal Council, Nagar Panchayats and Industrial Township Act, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1965 Act’) before the Collector Akola, praying for setting aside of the Municipal Council’s resolution. This application was allowed, and the following order was passed on 15.12.2020: “Application of applicant, under section 308 of Maharashtra Municipal Council, Nagar Panchayati and Industrial Township Act, 1965 similarly, Maharashtra Municipal Council, Nagar Panchayati and Industrial Township Act, 1965 in respect of section 308 is allowed as per the Government circular explanatory instruction no.
630 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 4(b) it has been ordered to the Municipal Council that Rajbhasha Marathi shall be used 100% in the Government proceedings.”
6. Some members of the Municipal Council challenged this order before the Divisional Commissioner, Amravati in revision under Section 318 of the 1965 Act. The Divisional Commissioner vide order dated 30.04.2021 set aside the order of the Collector, against which Writ Petition No. 2219 of 2021 was filed by the appellant before the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench).
7. The main ground of challenge by the appellant before the High Court was that Marathi is the official language of the State and all work conducted by government or government bodies, including local bodies, must be done only in Marathi. Therefore, according to the appellant, the use of Urdu in any manner is wrong, and should not be permitted.
8. In their reply, the members of the Municipal Council, apart from presenting their case on merits, raised a preliminary objection that the appellant’s application before the Collector under Section 308 of the 1965 Act, was not maintainable in the first place. It was argued that there is a resolution of the Municipal Council upholding its decision of displaying Urdu on the signboard of the Council, and in terms of the plain language of Section 308 of 1965 Act, any application, seeking suspension of execution of a Municipal Council’s resolution, can only be entertained by the Collector when moved by the Chief Officer of the Municipal Council; which was not the case here.
9. Sub-section (1) of Section 308 was amended in the year 2018. Prior to this amendment, if the Collector was of the opinion that the execution of any order or resolution of a Council was likely to cause injury or annoyance to the public and may lead to a breach of peace, or was unlawful, he had the powers to suspend its execution or prohibit its enforcement. The Collector could even exercise such power suo motu in an appropriate situation. All the same, subsequent to the amendment in sub-section (1) of Section 308 in the year 2018, it can be done only when such a resolution is sent by the Chief Officer before the Collector.
10. Section 308(1) of 1965 Act before and after the amendment reads as under:
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 631Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc. Old New “Section 308. Powers to suspend execution of orders and resolutions of Council on certain grounds-
(1) If, in the opinion of the Collector, the execution of any order or resolution of a Council, or the doing of anything which is about to be done or is being done by or on behalf of a Council, is causing or is likely to cause injury or annoyance to the public or is against public interest or to lead a breach of the peace or is unlawful, he may by order in writing under his signature suspend the execution or prohibit the doing thereof.”
“Section 308. Powers to suspend execution of orders and resolutions of Council on certain grounds-
( 1 ) I f t h e C o u n c i l o r a n y Committee resolves contrary to provisions of this Act or any other law, or rules, bye-laws, or the Government directions, then it shall be the responsibility of the Chief Officer to send it to the Collector for suspension of execution of such a resolution or prohibition of doing thereof, within the period of three days from the receipt of the said resolution. The Collector shall decide on such proposal within the period of thirty days from the date of receipt of such proposal …”
(Emphasis provided)
11. It is therefore clear that, after the amendment, the Collector can exercise powers only when the Chief Officer of the Municipal Council brings it to the Collector’s notice that the Municipal Council has passed a resolution contrary to the provision of the 1965 Act or any other law, rule or bye-laws. In such a situation, the Chief Officer of the Municipal Council alone has the responsibility to move an appropriate application before the Collector in terms of Section 308(1) of the 1965 Act and more importantly it is only on an application moved before the Collector by the Chief Officer of the Municipal Council that the powers can be exercised by the Collector under the amended Section 308 of 1965 Act. In this case, the application was admittedly not made by the Chief Officer of the Municipal Council but by the appellant, which should not have been entertained in the first place. 632 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
12. The High Court accepted this argument of the members of the Municipal Council, but nevertheless, the High Court also went into the merits of the matter and ultimately did not consider it a case calling for any interference. In its order dated 30.06.2021, while dismissing the petition it was said:
“16. Even on facts, this Court is not at all impressed with the contentions sought to be raised on behalf of the petitioner. It is obvious that the Government Resolution / circulars being executive instructions would not prevail over statutory provisions. Even otherwise, resolution of the Municipal Council was passed by majority and it is still in force. The resolution specifically states that the writing on the board on the new building of Municipal Council would be in Marathi at the top and below that in Urdu language. There cannot be any dispute about the fact that as per entry No.22 of the VIII th Schedule of the Constitution of India, Urdu is very much included in the list of languages. Thus, this Court sees no reason to entertain the contentions raised on behalf of the petitioner. Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed.”
13. This order was challenged before this Court in SLP (Civil) No. 13820 of 2021. During arguments in this SLP, the appellant’s contention was that now a new legislation i.e. the Maharashtra Local Authorities (Official Languages) Act, 2022 (hereinafter ‘2022 Act’) had been enacted during the pendency of the SLP, in terms of which, the use of Urdu language on the signboard of the Municipal Council is not permitted. Consequently, this Court had passed the following order on 29.04.2022:
“The challenge in the present special leave petition is to an order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay dated 30.06.2021 wherein challenge to the decision of the Municipal Council to write the name of Municipal Council on the sign Board in Urdu language as well remained unsuccessful.
The learned counsel for the petitioner and learned counsel for the State has pointed out that a recent enactment by the State of Maharashtra i.e. Maharashtra Act No.XXXI of 2022 (Maharashtra Local Authorities (Official Languages) [2025] 4 S.C.R. 633Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc. Act, 2022) which mandates that ‘all sign boards, name plates, notice boards and other display matters pertaining to public interface and public interest to the Local Authority or any Department or office thereof’ shall be in Marathi. Since the Act has come into force during the pendency of the present proceedings, we find that the order of the High Court on account of subsequent development is not sustainable. However, it shall be open to the aggrieved person to seek recourse to the remedy as may be available to him against the impugned Act in accordance with law. The special leave petition is disposed of in above terms. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.”
14. Under these circumstances, the matter was heard again by the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench), and an order was passed on 10.04.2024, which is presently under challenge before this Court:
“5. Perusal of the Act of 2022, would indicate that Marathi has been declared as official language of all the Local Authorities in the State of Maharashtra, to be used for all official purposes as well as purposes related to public interface and public interest in all offices of the Local Authorities. Section 3 (1) (a) to (i) of the Act of 2022 elucidates as to in which communications, actions, forms, signboards etc. the Marathi language is to be used.
6. We are herewith concerned with the display of the name of the Municipal Council on its building, which in addition to Marathi, has also been written in Urdu script.
7. A perusal of the Act of 2022, would indicate, that all that it does, is to ensure that the business and affairs of the Council, are to be conducted in Marathi language, including Marathi script. Insofar as the erection of signboard and display of the name of the Municipal Council is concerned, it does not prohibit use of an additional language, to display the name, in addition to the name being displayed in Marathi language. Till such time, Marathi language continues to be the official language of the Local Authorities, in terms of the Act of 2022, in our considered opinion, 634 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the use of an additional language to display the name of Municipal Council on its building would not indicate any violation of the provisions of the Act of 2022. What is to be also noted is that there is no prohibition in the Act of 2022 for any such use of a language, in addition to the official language, in view of which, insofar as Writ Petition No.2703/2023 is concerned, the impugned communication dated 10/02/2023 by the Administrator, cannot be sustained and the same is hereby quashed and set aside. The writ petition is accordingly allowed in the above terms. No order as to costs.
8. Insofar as Writ Petition No.1568/2023 is concerned, in view of what has been said above, we do not see any reason to interfere therein. The writ petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.”
15. The High Court to our mind rightly concluded that the 2022 Act, on which the appellant placed significant reliance, does not prohibit the use of an additional language, which is Urdu in the present case, on the signboard of the Municipal Council building. The argument before the High Court in the second round of litigation by the present appellant was that Section 3(1) of the 2022 Act provides for Marathi to be the official language of all local authorities in the State, except for the purposes specified in sub-section (2) and the only exception which was provided was the use of English in the specified communications under sub-section (2). All the same, this argument is incorrect. There is no prohibition on using any other language, especially one included in the VIIIth Schedule of the Constitution of India. Sub-section (2) of Section 3 is an enabling provision to use English in situations where the communications, in which the subject matter of the communication cannot be properly conveyed in Marathi or in situations where the persons to whom such communications are addressed cannot understand Marathi. This makes it more than explicit that even the enactment recognizes that language essentially is a tool of communication; which, according to us, cannot be condemned, when this language is being used by a community or group. We have to emphasize that Marathi and Urdu occupy the same position under Schedule VIII of the Constitution of India.
16. Before us is a fellow citizen who has taken great pains to take this matter twice to the High Court and then twice again before this Court. [2025] 4 S.C.R. 635Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc. What the appellant thinks may also be the thinking of many of our fellow citizens. These need to be addressed.
17. Let our concepts be clear. Language is not religion. Language does not even represent religion. Language belongs to a community, to a region, to people; and not to a religion.
18. Language is culture. Language is the yardstick to measure the civilizational march of a community and its people. So is the case of Urdu, which is the finest specimen of ganga-jamuni tahzeeb, or the Hindustani tahzeeb, which is the composite cultural ethos of the plains of northern and central India. But before language became a tool for learning, its earliest and primary purpose will always remain communication.
19. Coming back to our case, the purpose here for the use of Urdu is merely communication. All the municipal council wanted to do was to make an effective communication. This is the primary purpose of a language, which the Bombay High Court has laid emphasis on.
20. We must respect and rejoice in our diversity, including our many languages. India has more than hundred major languages. Then there are other languages known as dialects or ‘Mother Tongues’ which also run into hundreds. According to the 2001 Census, India had a total of 122 major languages including the 22 scheduled languages, and a total of 234 mother tongues. Urdu was the sixth most spoken scheduled language of India. In fact, it is spoken by at least a part of the population in all States and Union Territories, except perhaps in our north-eastern States. In the 2011 Census, the number of mother tongues increased to 270. However, it is to be noted that this number was also arrived at by taking into consideration only those mother tongues which had more than ten thousand speakers. Thus, it would not be wrong to say that the actual number of mother tongues in India would run into thousands. Such is the immense linguistic diversity of India!
21. The Constitution of India though mentions twenty-two Indian languages in its VIII th Schedule, which includes both Marathi and Urdu, and significantly, ‘English’ is not a language mentioned in the VIIIth Schedule as it is not an Indian language. With this linguistic diversity, India is the most multilingual country in the world. In such a country, what should be the language for communication and use throughout the country, and what should be the national language became a vexed question 636 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports during the debate in the Constituent Assembly. We have to keep in mind that language is not just a language, it is also representative of a culture. That makes a discussion on language both sensitive and delicate and this is where one of our principal Constitutional values of ‘tolerance’ must also come into play. We, the people of India, have taken great pain in resolving the language issue at the Centre, which is our unique achievement considering the linguistic diversity of the nation as we have been mentioning repeatedly. According to Granville Austin, the Constituent Assembly had almost come to a breaking point while resolving the question of language or what should be the national language1 . Finally, the members of the Constituent Assembly agreed on ‘Hindi’ to be the “Rajbhasha” i.e. the official language of the Union of India with English to be used for a period of 15 years from commencement of the Constitution, though Parliament was given the powers to extend this period.
22. Part XVII of our Constitution is on the official language. Article 351 emphasizes on the spread of Hindi language and to develop the language, inter alia, by assimilating the forms and style and expressions used in “Hindustani” and other languages of the VIIIth Schedule and wherever necessary or desirable, by drawing vocabulary, primarily from Sanskrit but also secondarily from other languages.
23. We must now refer to Article 345 which relates to the Official language of a State:
“345. Official language or languages of a State:
Subject to the provisions of articles 346 and 347, the Legislature of a State may by law adopt any one or more of the languages in use in the State or Hindi as the language or languages to be used for all or any of the official purposes of that State:
Provided that, until the Legislature of the State otherwise provides by law, the English language shall continue to be used for those official purposes within the State for which it was being used immediately before the commencement of this Constitution.”
1 See Granville Austin, Language and the Constitution-the half-hearted compromise, The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation, Oxford University Press (2000) at pp. 265-307. [2025] 4 S.C.R. 637Mrs. Varshatai w/o. Sh. Sanjay bagade v. The State of Maharashtra through its Secretary, Ministry of Law and Judiciary, Mantralaya, Mumbai and Ors. Etc. This Article empowers State legislatures to adopt Hindi or any other language in use in that State as the official language of that State.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.