Sangita Sinha v. Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 450; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 551
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 3 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4972/2025
- Sections
- 16, 9
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 551 : 2025 INSC 450 Sangita Sinha v.
Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 4972 of 2025)
04 April 2025 [Dipankar Datta and Manmohan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether a suit for specific performance of an agreement to sell is liable to be decreed if the buyer had accepted the refund of the majority of the earnest money deposit/advance consideration, during the pendency of the suit.
Headnotes† Specific Performance Act, 1963 – Specific performance of an agreement – Acceptance by buyer of refund of consideration amount – Effect on relief of specific performance – Unregistered agreement to sell executed between the buyer-respondent no. 1 and the seller – Buyer paid certain sum in cash and issued three post-dated cheques – Upon failure of seller to execute the sale deed, buyer filed a suit seeking specific performance of agreement to sell – Seller made a complaint to the police stating that her signatures had been fraudulently taken on the agreement to sell and seller issued a letter cancelling the agreement, and refunded some amount through demand drafts and returned two of three post dated cheques, which were subsequently encashed – On death of the seller, respondent no. 3-step grandson of seller impleaded along with appellant in whose favour subject property had been bequeathed – Trial court passed the judgment in favour of the buyer – High Court upheld the same – Correctness:
Held: Conduct of buyer in encashing the demand drafts establishes beyond doubt that the buyer was not willing to perform her part of agreement to sell and proceed with execution of the sale deed, and the fact that entire advance consideration/earnest money had not been returned to the buyer is irrelevant and immaterial – Act of buyer in encashing the demand drafts leads to an irresistible * Author 552 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports conclusion that the agreement stood cancelled – Seller had issued a letter cancelling the Agreement to Sell prior to the filing of the suit, the same constitutes a jurisdictional fact as till the said cancellation is set aside, the buyer is not entitled to the relief of specific performance – Thus, in absence of a prayer for declaratory relief that cancellation of the agreement is bad in law, suit for specific performance not maintainable – Plea that appellant lacked the locus standi to file the present appeal as she did not have any right, interest or title over the subject property is misconceived on facts – Appellant is a beneficiary under the Will executed by the original owner/seller, whereby the subject property was bequeathed in her favour – Appellant, being a necessary and interested party to the lis, has the locus to file the present appeal – Furthermore, the onus to establish readiness and willingness is on the buyer and the failure to establish the same disentitles the buyer from the equitable and discretionary relief of specific performance – Buyer failed to disclose in the plaint that the seller had issued the cancellation letter, enclosing demand drafts and cheques which amounts to suppression of material fact, disentitling her from the discretionary relief of specific performance – Thus, agreement to sell cannot be specifically enforced – Impugned judgment set aside – Sale deed executed in favour of buyer declared null and void. [Paras 15, 17-21, 25-30] Specific performance – Specific performance of – Grant of relief – ‘Readiness’ and ‘willingness’ to perform contract – Explanation:
Held: ‘Readiness’ and ‘willingness’ are not one but two separate elements – ‘Readiness’ means the capacity of the buyer to perform the contract, which would include the financial position to pay the sale consideration – ‘Willingness’ refers to the intention of the buyer as a purchaser to perform his part of the contract, which is inferred by scrutinising the conduct of the buyer/purchaser, including attending circumstances – Continuous readiness and willingness on the part of the buyer/purchaser from the date of execution of Agreement to Sell till the date of the decree, is a condition precedent for grant of relief of specific performance – It is not enough to show the readiness and willingness up to the date of the plaint as the conduct must be such as to disclose readiness and willingness at all times from the date of the contract and throughout the pendency of the suit up to the decree. [Paras 17-20] [2025] 4 S.C.R. 553Sangita Sinha v. Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors. Case Law Cited R. Kandasamy (Since Dead) & Ors. v. T.R.K. Sarawathy & Anr., Civil Appeal No. 3015 of 2013 decided on 21st November 2024; Mehboob-Ur-Rehman (Dead) through Legal Representatives v. Ahsanul Ghani [2019] 2 SCR 169 : (2019) 19 SCC 415; C.S. Venkatesh v. A.S.C. Murthy (Dead) by Legal Representatives and Ors. [2020] 2 SCR 676 : (2020) 3 SCC 280; Kamal Kumar v. Premlata Joshi and Ors. [2019] 1 SCR 54 : (2019) 3 SCC 704; P. Daivasigamani v. S. Sambandan [2022] 18 SCR 199 : (2022) 14 SCC 793; Gomathinayagam Pillai and Ors. v. Palaniswami Nadar [1967] 1 SCR 227; Vijay Kumar and Others v. Om Parkash, 2018 SCC OnLine SC 1913; J.P. Builders and Another v. A. Ramadas Rao and Another [2010] 15 SCR 538 : (2011) 1 SCC 429; Umabai and Another v. Nilkanth Dhondiba Chavan (Dead) By LRs. and Another [2005] 3 SCR 521 : (2005) 6 SCC 243; I.S. Sikandar (Dead) By LRs. v. K. Subramani and Others [2013] 17 SCR 24 : (2013) 15 SCC 27; A. Kanthamani v. Nasreen Ahmed [2017] 2 SCR 610 : (2017) 4 SCC 654; Shrisht Dhawan (Smt) v. Shaw Bros. [1991] Supp. 3 SCR 446 : (1992) 1 SCC 534; Citadel Fine Pharmaceuticals v. Ramaniyam Real Estates Private Limited and Another [2011] 13 SCR 605 : (2011) 9 SCC 147 – referred to. List of Acts Specific Performance Act, 1963 List of Keywords Specific relief; Agreement to sell; Equitable and discretionary relief of specific performance; Readiness and Willingness’ to perform contract; Cancellation of agreement; Encashing demand drafts; Acceptance by buyer of refund of consideration; Necessary and interested party; Suppression of material facts; Suit for specific performance of an agreement to sell; Refund of the majority of the earnest money deposit/advance consideration during the pendency of the suit; Locus to file.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 4972 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 09.05.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Patna in F.A. No. 83 of 2018 554 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
S. B. Upadhyay, Sr. Adv., Ms. Indu Kaul, Rajiv Kumar Sinha, Raj Kumar, Abhinav Kathuria.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Mungeshwar Sahoo, Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad Sr. Advs., Samrandra Kumar, Vivek Kumar Srivastva, Pawan Kumar, Ravi Bhushan Upadhyay, Ramesh Kumar Mishra, Shivam Tiwary, Vishal Arun Mishra, Ramesh Kumar Mishra, Shivam Tiwary, Ms. Anusha Rathore, Shivank S. Singh.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Manmohan, J
1. Leave granted.
2. The primary issue that arises for consideration in the present civil appeal is whether a suit for specific performance of an Agreement to Sell is liable to be decreed if the buyer had accepted the refund of majority of the earnest money deposit/advance consideration, during the pendency of the civil suit?
3. Brief facts leading to the present appeal are as under:-
3.1. Late Kushum Kumari (“original defendant” / “seller”) was allotted the subject property by the People’s Cooperative House Construction Society Limited (“Society”) vide a registered sublease dated 2nd April 1968.
3.2. On 25th January 2008, an unregistered Agreement to Sell with respect to the subject property was executed between the “Respondent No.1-buyer”-plaintiff and the seller for a total sale consideration of Rs. 25,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Lakhs). At the time of the execution of the Agreement to Sell, the Respondent No.1-buyer paid a sum of Rs.2,51,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty One Thousand) in cash to the seller and issued three post-dated cheques worth Rs.7,50,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakh Fifty Thousand).
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 555Sangita Sinha v. Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors.
3.3. It is the case of Respondent No.1-buyer that when she visited the subject property along with her husband on 11th February 2008, the tenants of the seller created a scuffle and forced them to return. In the circumstance, the Respondent No.1buyer issued legal notices dated 23 rd February 2008 and 23 rd April 2008, expressing her intention to pay the balance sale consideration and to get the property registered in her favour.
3.4. Upon the failure of the seller to execute the sale deed, Respondent No.1-buyer filed a suit before the Trial Court, Sub Judge-IV, Patna under the Specific Performance Act, 1963 (“Act, 1963)” seeking specific performance of the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 and the same was registered as Title Suit No. TS/176/2008 (“subject suit”).
3.5. The subject suit was contested by the seller by filing a written statement, stating therein that she came to know about the Agreement to Sell dated 25th January 2008 on 5th February 2008 and immediately thereafter, made a complaint dated 6th February 2008 with the Inspector of Police-cum-Station House Officer, Kankarbagh Police Station, Patna stating that her signatures had been fraudulently taken on the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008. It was further stated that the seller issued a letter dated 7 th January 2008 cancelling the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 and refunded Rs.2,11,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) through five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008 in lieu of the cash and returned two of the three post-dated cheques of Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Thousand) each, which were issued by the seller. Vide Order dated 16 th December 2008, issues were framed by the Trial Court.
3.6. Upon the demise of the seller, the Respondent No.3 herein, who is the step grandson of the seller, was impleaded as substituted defendant no. 1 and the appellant herein was impleaded as defendant no. 3 as the subject property had been bequeathed in her favour by way of a Will dated 23 rd September 2002 executed by the original owner/seller.
3.7. After consideration of the depositions of PW-1 (Respondent No.1 herein) and her husband, PW-2, the Trial Court framed three additional issues vide order dated 21 st January 2013. 556 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports The issues were framed once again on 27 th April 2018, and a judgment was passed in favour of Respondent No.1-buyer on the same date.
3.8. The judgment dated 27 th April 2018 and the decree dated 10 th May 2018 were challenged by the appellant herein in First Appeal No. 83 of 2018. The said appeal was dismissed by the Patna High Court vide the impugned Judgment dated 9 th May 2024.
3.9. Upon the present Special Leave Petition being filed, this Court, while issuing notice, had directed parties to maintain status quo with respect to the possession on 20th August 2024.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
4. Shri S.B. Upadhyay, learned senior counsel for the appellant, stated that the signatures of the seller on the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 had been fraudulently obtained by Respondent No.3 herein. He stated that the seller-defendant signed some blank papers believing the same to be related to the Will that she had executed in favour of the appellant on 23rd September 2002.
5. He stated that upon the discovery of the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 on 5 th February 2008, the seller made a criminal complaint dated 6 th February 2008 with the Inspector of Policecum-Station House Officer, Kankarbagh, Patna that her signatures had been fraudulently obtained on the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008.
6. He stated that on 7 th February 2008, the seller wrote a letter to Respondent No.1-buyer cancelling the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 enclosing therewith five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008 amounting to Rs. 2,11,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) in lieu of the cash and two of the three post-dated cheques of Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Thousand) each, which were issued by the Respondent No.1-buyer.
7. He pointed out that the Respondent No.1-buyer as well as her husband-PW2, in their depositions, have admitted that they had received five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008 amounting to Rs. 2,11,000/-(Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) in lieu of the cash and also received two of the three post-dated cheques of Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Thousand) along with the letter [2025] 4 S.C.R. 557Sangita Sinha v. Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors. cancelling the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 in March 2008. He explained that five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008 of Rs.2,11,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) were encashed by the Respondent No.1-buyer in July 2008, after institution of the subject suit on 5 th May 2008. He submitted that the encashment of the demand drafts amounted to revocation of the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008. He contended that the subject suit was filed by the Respondent No.1-buyer after revocation of the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008, without seeking any relief against the revocation and without disclosing that she was in receipt of the demand drafts and post-dated cheques.
8. He contended that the subject suit was filed on the basis of an Agreement to Sell which stood cancelled and as such, the same was not maintainable. He submitted that existence of a valid agreement is sine qua non for grant of relief of specific performance. He pointed out that, in similar circumstances, this Court in R. Kandasamy (Since Dead) & Ors. vs. T.R.K. Sarawathy & Anr. (Civil Appeal No. 3015 of 2013 decided on 21 st November 2024), had set aside the judgment and decree passed in favour of the Respondent No.1buyer inter alia on the ground that a non-existent Agreement to Sell cannot be enforced by a Court of law.
9. Even otherwise, he contended that the Respondent No.1-buyer was not ready and willing to perform the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008. He stated that a mere averment that the Respondent No.1-buyer is ready and willing to perform the contract will not suffice as readiness and willingness must be inferred in overall circumstances of the case, including the conduct of the Respondent No.1-buyer prior and subsequent to the filing of the suit.
10. He pointed out that the Respondent No.1-buyer in her crossexamination, had admitted that at the time of execution of the agreement, she was not aware of the balance in her bank account and at the time when the three post-dated cheques for Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Thousand) were issued, there was no sufficient balance in her account. He contended that the conduct of the Respondent No.1-buyer in encashing the demand drafts proved that she was not ready or willing to perform the contract. In support of his contentions, he relied upon the judgments of this Court in Mehboob-Ur-Rehman (Dead) through Legal Representatives 558 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports vs. Ahsanul Ghani (2019) 19 SCC 415 and C.S. Venkatesh vs. A.S.C. Murthy (Dead) by Legal Representatives and Ors. (2020)
3 SCC 280.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT NO. 1
11. Per contra, Mr. Mungeshwar Sahoo, learned senior counsel for the Respondent No.1-buyer stated that the suit had been decreed in favour of the Respondent No.1-buyer by the Trial Court after rightly appreciating the evidence and a sale deed had been executed subsequently in favour of the Respondent No.1-buyer upon deposit of Rs. 24,61,000/- (Rupees Twenty Four Lakh Sixty One Thousand) before the Trial Court. He contended that the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court had been rightly upheld by the High Court. He stated that the entire case of the appellant in the present proceedings is based upon reappreciation of evidence and the same cannot be permitted at this stage.
12. He stated that the entire earnest money/advance consideration had not been refunded/returned by the seller. He stated that the Respondent No.1-buyer had paid Rs.2,51,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty One Thousand) in cash to the seller against which the seller had refunded Rs.2,11,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) through five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008. Therefore, according to him, an amount of Rs. 40,000/- (Rupees Forty Thousand) remained with the seller as earnest money/advance consideration. He contended that as the balance sale consideration had been paid subsequently, the cancellation of the Agreement to Sell dated 25th January 2008 was not valid.
13. Even otherwise, he stated that a bilateral agreement cannot be unilaterally cancelled by a party by returning the earnest money. According to him, a (bilateral) agreement can only be cancelled by a Court of law or by executing a subsequent agreement, cancelling the prior agreement. He stated that in the event parties are permitted to unilaterally cancel the agreement, the purchaser will be left remediless as any third party can intervene by offering a higher earnest money.
14. He contended that the seller passed away before she could prove her defense by leading evidence. He stated that neither the appellant nor the Respondent No.3 herein had deposed in support of the written statement filed by the seller. He therefore stated that the written [2025] 4 S.C.R. 559Sangita Sinha v. Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors. statement of the seller had not been proved. He also contended that the appellant did not have the locus to file the present appeal. According to him, the appellant had no right, title or interest in the subject property and the findings of the Trial Court or the High Court do not affect the appellant in any manner.
COURT’S REASONING
RESPONDENT NO.1 WAS NOT WILLING TO PERFORM THE
AGREEMENT TO SELL
15. Having heard learned senior counsel / learned counsel for the parties and having perused the paper book, the admitted position that emerges is that Respondent No.1-buyer had paid Rs. 2,51,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty One Thousand) in cash and handed over three post-dated cheques of Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Thousand) each at the time of execution of the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008. It is also not disputed that the Respondent No.1-buyer had subsequently received a letter dated 7 th February 2008 cancelling the Agreement to Sell dated 25 th January 2008 enclosing therewith five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008 totaling to Rs.2,11,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) (in lieu of the cash paid by the Respondent No.1-buyer) along with two of the three post-dated cheques of Rs.2,50,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Thousand) each, which had been issued initially by the Respondent No.1-buyer. Further, the third post-dated cheque which was not returned to the Respondent No.1-buyer had not been encashed. The Respondent No.1-buyer has admitted that the letter dated 7th February 2008 had been received prior to filing of the suit for specific performance and five demand drafts dated 7 th February 2008 totaling to Rs.2,11,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Eleven Thousand) had been encashed in July, 2008 after institution of the subject suit on 5 th May 2008, without raising any objection with respect to the difference in the cash amount and the demand drafts furnished by the seller.
16. It is settled law that under the Act, 1963, prior to the 2018 Amendment, specific performance was a discretionary and equitable relief. In Kamal Kumar vs. Premlata Joshi and Ors. (2019) 3 SCC 704, which has been followed in P. Daivasigamani vs. S. Sambandan (2022) 14 SCC 793, this Court framed material questions which 560 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports require consideration prior to grant of relief of specific performance. The relevant portion of the judgment in Kamal Kumar (supra) is reproduced hereinbelow:
“7. It is a settled principle of law that the grant of relief of specific performance is a discretionary and equitable relief. The material questions, which are required to be gone into for grant of the relief of specific performance, are:
7.1. First, whether there exists a valid and concluded contract between the parties for sale/purchase of the suit property.
7.2. Second, whether the plaintiff has been ready and willing to perform his part of contract and whether he is still ready and willing to perform his part as mentioned in the contract.
7.3. Third, whether the plaintiff has, in fact, performed his part of the contract and, if so, how and to what extent and in what manner he has performed and whether such performance was in conformity with the terms of the contract;
7.4. Fourth, whether it will be equitable to grant the relief of specific performance to the plaintiff against the defendant in relation to suit property or it will cause any kind of hardship to the defendant and, if so, how and in what manner and the extent if such relief is eventually granted to the plaintiff;
7.5. Lastly, whether the plaintiff is entitled for grant of any other alternative relief, namely, refund of earnest money, etc. and, if so, on what grounds.
8. In our opinion, the aforementioned questions are part of the statutory requirements [See Sections 16(c), 20, 21, 22, 23 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 and Forms 47/48 of Appendices A to C of the Code of Civil Procedure]. These requirements have to be properly pleaded by the parties in their respective pleadings and proved with the aid of evidence in accordance with law. It is only then the Court is entitled to exercise its discretion and accordingly grant or refuse the relief of specific performance depending upon the case made out by the parties on facts.”
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 561Sangita Sinha v. Bhawana Bhardwaj and Ors.
17. It is trite law that ‘readiness’ and ‘willingness’ are not one but two separate elements. ‘Readiness’ means the capacity of the Respondent No.1-buyer to perform the contract, which would include the financial position to pay the sale consideration. ‘Willingness’ refers to the intention of the Respondent No.1-buyer as a purchaser to perform his part of the contract, which is inferred by scrutinising the conduct of the Respondent No.1-buyer /purchaser, including attending circumstances.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.