Dr. Sunil Kumar Singh v. Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 264; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2130
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 25 Feb 2025
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 530/2024
- Sections
- 151A, 479, 456
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 2130 : 2025 INSC 264 Dr. Sunil Kumar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
(Writ Petition (Civil) No. 530 of 2024)
25 February 2025 [Surya Kant* and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(1) Whether the instant writ petition is maintainable in view of Article 212 (1) of the Constitution of India and whether the proceedings of the ethics committee are amenable to judicial review?
(2) Whether this court can review the proportionality of the punishment imposed by the house in exercise of its writ jurisdiction?
(3) If so, whether the petitioner’s expulsion is disproportionate to the misconduct attributed to him and whether it merits any interference?
(4) If so, whether this court is empowered to determine the quantum of punishment that may be imposed on the petitioner? Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art.212(1) – Whether the instant Writ Petition is maintainable in view of Art.212(1) of the Constitution of India and whether the proceedings of the Ethics Committee are amenable to judicial review:
Held: The protection u/Art.212(1) operates only with respect to the ‘Proceedings in the Legislature’ on the grounds of ‘Procedural Irregularities’ – It could not have been the intent of the lawmakers to circumscribe Constitutional Courts unconditionally from scrutinising the validity of the actions of the Legislature, which may encroach upon the Fundamental Rights of the members and/or citizens – The ‘Proceedings in the Legislature’ comprise the formal steps, debates, and motions undertaken to facilitate deliberations within the House – Art. 212(1) of the Constitution provides immunity for the manner of such proceedings, and hence, Constitutional Courts would exercise restraint when such proceedings are called into question on the grounds of procedural irregularity – A ‘Legislative Decision’, on the other hand, is the culmination of the legislative procedure—the formal expression of the will of the House on a given * Author [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2131Dr. Sunil K umar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
matter – These decisions of the Legislature, though emanating from a coordinate branch of Government, are not immune from scrutiny by Constitutional Courts – In the instant case, the Impugned Report recommending the expulsion of the Petitioner was made by the Ethics Committee in the discharge of its administrative functions – The present action of the Ethics Committee is purely administrative in nature, aimed at enforcing discipline and ethical standards amongst the members of the House – It is well established that administrative actions, even when undertaken by legislative bodies or their committees, are subject to judicial review where they affect the rights and interests of individuals – In this context, the present action resulting in civil consequences for the Petitioner, cannot be immune from judicial review under the pretext of legislative privilege. [Paras 11, 13, 14, 17, 19, 21] Punishment – Proportionality of punishment – Can the Courts examine the proportionality of punishment imposed on a member while reviewing the validity of the action taken by the House:
Held: The doctrine of proportionality is fundamentally embedded in the concept of fairness in action across domestic, foreign, and international legal systems – This principle ensures that measures taken are appropriate, necessary, and balanced in relation to the objectives they seek to achieve – There is no absolute bar on the Constitutional Courts to examine the proportionality of the punishment imposed on a member while reviewing the validity of the action taken by the House – By focusing on the proportionality of punishment, courts must ensure that justice aligns with constitutional values and societal norms, thereby upholding the integrity of the democratic process – At this point, it must be added that the determination of what constitutes a disproportionate measure is inherently complex and context-dependent – Such assessment requires a nuanced scrutiny of the specific circumstances surrounding each case – This means that a one-size-fits-all definition is impractical while adjudicating proportionality and the courts must exercise their discretion in a prudent and judicious manner. [Paras 54, 62, 63] Punishment – Proportionality of punishment – Guiding principles for courts to consider while scrutinising the proportionality of actions taken by the House against its member(s):
Held: These parameters are not exhaustive, as considerations will inevitably vary from case to case – An indicative list of such 2132 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports parameters includes:(a) Degree of obstruction caused by the member in the proceedings of the House; (b) Whether the behaviour of the member has brought disrepute to the dignity of the entire House;
(c) The previous conduct of the erring member; (d) The subsequent conduct of the erring member, such as expressing remorse, cooperation with the institutional scrutiny mechanism; (e) Availability of lesser restrictive measures to discipline the delinquent member; (f) Whether crude expressions uttered are deliberate and motivated or a mere outcome of language largely influenced by the local dialect; (g) Whether the measure adopted is suitable for furthering the desired purpose; and (h) Balancing the interest of society, particularly the electorates, with those of the erring members. [Para 64] Punishment – Expulsion – Proportionality of Petitioner’s Expulsion – Was the Petitioner’s expulsion proportionate to the offence alleged against him, and whether it merits any interference:
Held: The punishment of expulsion imposed on the Petitioner is harsh and disproportionate – While the petitioner’s conduct in the house was abhorrent and his subsequent demeanour before the ethics committee was evasive and high-handed, the house ought to exercise magnanimity as custodian of constitutional values – The punishment of expulsion was highly excessive and disproportionate to the nature of the misconduct – Disproportionate punishments are violative of the fundamental rights enshrined in Arts.14 and 21 of the constitution – A more measured and balanced approach would have sufficed to address the misconduct while upholding the dignity and decorum of the House. [Paras 68-71, 75-78] Constitution of India – Art.142 – Quantum of Punishment – Power of Supreme Court u/Art.142:
Held: In ordinary course, when a court concludes that the punishment imposed by the disciplinary authority is disproportionate to the gravity of the misconduct, it does not generally substitute its own assessment of the appropriate penalty – Instead, the established judicial approach is to remit the matter to the disciplinary authority for reconsideration – In exercise of its powers u/Art.142 of the constitution, this court is vested with the authority to substitute the punishment where the facts and circumstances so warrant – The expulsion of the Petitioner is disproportionate and undoubtedly infringes his Fundamental Rights guaranteed u/Art.14 of the Constitution – Furthermore, the expulsion also has a direct impact on a vast number of stakeholders, particularly the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2133Dr. Sunil K umar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
electorates he represents – The Petitioner has already undergone almost 7 months of expulsion – If this matter is now remanded to the Ethics Committee for reconsideration of the appropriate punishment, the ensuing process is likely to be protracted, which might deprive the Petitioner in participating in the ensuing Sessions – Balancing the competing considerations, the period of expulsion already undergone by the Petitioner is deemed to be considered as a period of his suspension; and in view of this Court, constitutes sufficient punishment for the misconduct displayed by him – As a segue thereto, the Petitioner is directed to be reinstated as member of the BLC with immediate effect. [Paras 79-84, 86] Case Law Cited Ashish Shelar and Ors. v. The Maharashtra Legislative Assembly and Anr. [2022] 18 SCR 762 : (2022) 12 SCC 273; Dev Singh v. Punjab Tourism Development Corpn. Ltd. & Anr. (2003) 8 SCC 9; LIC of India v. R. Dhandapani [2005] Supp. 5 SCR 488 : (2006) 13 SCC 613; Kulja Industries Ltd. v. Chief General Manager, Western Telecom Project BSNL & Ors. [2013] 14 SCR 430 : (2014) 14 SCC 731; Vice-Chairman and Managing Director, City & Industrial Development Corporation of Maharashtra Ltd. & Anr. v. Shishir Realty (P) Ltd. & Ors. [2021] 13 SCR 190 : (2022) 16 SCC 527; Teri Oat Estates (P) Ltd. v. U.T., Chandigarh & Ors. [2003] Supp. 6 SCR 1235 : (2004) 2 SCC 130; Chairman, All India Railway Recruitment Board & Anr. v. K. Shyam Kumar & Ors. [2010] 6 SCR 291 : (2010) 6 SCC 614; Modern Dental College & Research Centre & Ors. v. State of M.P. & Ors. [2016] 3 SCR 579 : (2016) 7 SCC 353; Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India & Ors. [2020] 1 SCR 812 : (2020) 3 SCC 637; Association for Democratic Reforms & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. [2024] 2 SCR 420 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 150; Internet and Mobile Association of India v. Reserve Bank of India [2020] 2 SCR 297 : (2020) 10 SCC 274; Shivu & Anr. v. Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka & Anr. [2007] 2 SCR 555 : (2007) 4 SCC 713; Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab [1983] 1 SCR 145 : (1982) 3 SCC 24; Lehna v. State of Haryana [2002] 1 SCR 377 : (2002) 3 SCC 76; Frank Vitus v. Narcotics Control Bureau & Ors., 2024 INSC 479 : [2024] 7 SCR 97; Munish Bhasin and Ors. v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) and Anr. [2009] 2 SCR 806 : (2009) 4 SCC 45; Mohammed Zubair v. State of NCT of Delhi and Ors. [2022] 18 SCR 494 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 897; Parvez Noordin Lokhandwalla v. State of Maharashtra & Anr. [2020] 11 SCR 117 : (2020) 10 SCC 77; Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India [1978] 2 SCR 621 : (1978) 1 SCC 248; Arnesh Kumar v. State of 2134 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Bihar & Anr. [2014] 8 SCR 128 : (2014) 8 SCC 273; Raja Ram Pal v. The Hon’ble Speaker of Lok Sabha & Ors. [2007] 1 SCR 317 : (2007) 3 SCC 184; Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India & Ors. [1988] 1 SCR 512 : (1987) 4 SCC 611; Deputy Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangthan & Ors. v. J. Hussain [2013] 9 SCR 898 : (2013) 10 SCC 106; B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India and Ors. [1995] Supp. 4 SCR 644 : (1995) 6 SCC 749 – relied on. The Queen v Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food and Secretary of State for Health ex parte Fedesa et al [1990] ECR I-4023 [13] – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Cf. G. LübbeWolff, The Principle of Proportionality in the Case-Law of the German Federal Constitutional Court, Human Rights Law Journal 2014, vol. 34, pg. 12; Sauter W. Proportionality in EU Law: A Balancing Act? Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, 2013;15:439-466; Kathleen M. Sullivan, The Justices of Rules and Standards, 106 Harv. L. Rev. 22, 61 (1992); Erwin Chemerinsky, Constitutional Law 529–31 (Aspen Pub. 2001).
List of Websites Principle of Proportionality, European Union, https://www. google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=h ttps://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/glossary/principle-ofproportionality.html&ved=2ahUKEwjR9aun6NSLAxXhzDgGHTA sHtcQFnoECCQQAQ&usg=AOvVaw14i3cuEILjPFx1jQZjNOuR.
List of Keywords Article 212(1) of Constitution of India; Ethics Committee; Judicial Review; Punishment; Proportionality of the punishment; Maintainability of writ petition; Constitutional Courts; Misconduct; Expulsion; Misdemeanour; Legislature; Proceedings in Legislature; Legislative Decision; Immunity; Constitutional Supremacy; Expression unius est exclusion alterius; Irregularity of procedure; Administrative functions; Legislative function; Legislative privilege. Case Arising From CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (Civil) No.
530 of 2024 Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2135Dr. Sunil K umar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioner:
Dr. Abhishek Singhvi, Gopal Sankarnarayanan, Sr. Advs., Yash Johri, Ms. Priyansha Sharma, Ms. Shristi Sinha, Vishal Sinha, Pradyut Kashyap.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ranjit Kumar, Ms. Meenakshi Arora, Sr. Advs., Navin Kumar Jha, Aditya Prakash Sahay, Sushil Kumar Singh, Akash Dikshit, Chandan Kumar, Divyansh Mishra, Chandratanay Chaube, Ankit Agarwal, Ms. Viyushti Rawat, Ashish Shukla.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
1. The Petitioner has invoked the writ jurisdiction of this Court under Article 32 of the Constitution of India, laying challenge to Report No. 1/2024 dated 14.06.2024 (Impugned Report), submitted by the Ethics Committee of the Bihar Legislative Council (BLC) recommending his expulsion as a Member of Legislative Council ( MLC). The consequential notification dated 26.07.2024 relieving the Petitioner from the membership of the BLC issued by the BLC’s Secretariat (Impugned Notification), is also assailed.
A. FActuAl MAtrix
2. The present controversy arises from allegations of unparliamentary conduct by the Petitioner, including the use of derogatory expressions in his capacity as an MLC within the House of the BLC. This conduct of the Petitioner prompted the initiation of proceedings against him by the Ethics Committee. The allegations were found to be substantiated, leading the Ethics Committee to recommend the Petitioner’s expulsion from the BLC. Subsequently, a resolution to that effect was passed by a majority of the members of BLC, formalising the decision to expel and relieve the Petitioner. The facts giving rise to the present petition are set out hereinbelow:
2.1. The Petitioner is a member of the political party known as the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD). He was elected as a member of 2136 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the BLC on 29.06.2020 for a period of six years. The Petitioner was also nominated as the Chief Whip by the RJD in the BLC.
2.2. The elections for the 17th Legislative Assembly in the State of Bihar were held in November 2020, wherein a coalition government, comprising the Janata Dal (United) (JDU) led by the incumbent Chief Minister along with the RJD and the Indian National Congress (INC), was formed. This coalition, however, wedged apart in January 2024, and a new alliance between the JDU and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) was entered into to form the Government in the State.
2.3. Following these developments, the Hon’ble Governor of Bihar was scheduled to deliver his address on 13.02.2024, at the 206th Session of the BLC. As soon as the Governor’s address was completed and during the motion of thanks, the Petitioner and another MLC, Md. Sohaib approached the well of the House and hurled indecent slogans against the Chief Minister. They mocked him as “Paltu Ram”, imitated his body language and sarcastically remarked that “the man who has not contested a single Mukhiya election till date is the Chief Minister of Bihar”. The Petitioner then alluded to the Chief Minister as an ‘expert in manipulations’ and insinuated that he was “just like a snake sheds its skin every year”. This indecorous fracas led to the proceedings of the House being indubitably obstructed, followed by a complaint on 19.02.2024 lodged against the Petitioner and Md. Sohaib before the Chairman of the BLC by a fellow MLC belonging to the Ruling Party JDU.
2.4. The Chairman of BLC issued a letter to the Petitioner and Md. Sohaib informing them about the complaint, which was then forwarded to the Ethics Committee for necessary enquiry. The letter also required both the MLCs to remain present and join the enquiry proceedings on 03.05.2024 before the Ethics Committee.
2.5. Md. Sohaib joined the enquiry proceedings on 03.05.2024 and expressed regret for his conduct in writing and further assured a display of restraint and caution in the future.
2.6. The Petitioner, in stark contrast, did not appear before the Ethics Committee on the date fixed and instead sought exemption, citing engagements and scheduling conflicts due to the onset [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2137Dr. Sunil Kumar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
of the Lok Sabha elections. The Petitioner did not join even the subsequent proceedings and continued seeking exemption from appearing for one or the other reason, which are delineated for the sake of convenience:
Date of proceedings Requests from Petitioner Response of the Ethics Committee 03.05.2024 • The Petitioner was a star campaigner for his party in the ongoing Lok Sabha elections and was in charge of the Saran Constituency.
Exempted and directed to appear on 22.05.2024 22.05.2024 • Busy on account of himself being a candidate in elections of the Board of Directors, National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India (NAFAED).
Exempted and directed to be present on 31.05.2024 as a last opportunity.
31.05.2024 • Tried to place the onus on the Ethics Committee by stating: “I do not know what is the hurry, haste and impatience that the Committee has again fixed the date 31.05.2025 to present the opinion”.
• He demanded information regarding the charges against him and the necessary evidence corroborating such allegations.
Exempted, but the request regarding the relevant documents was denied on the grounds of confidentiality;
however, Petitioner was permitted to peruse the same on the next date of proceeding, i.e.
06.06.2024.
06.06.2024 • Sought exemption on the grounds of his father’s illness.
One last opportunity was given to the Petitioner to present his side, and the Ethics Committee resolved to take action in case the Petitioner did not turn up for proceedings scheduled on 12.06.2024.
2138 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2.7. The Petitioner eventually appeared before the Ethics Committee for the first time on 12.06.2024, when a copy of the charges was duly supplied to him. The Petitioner instead of addressing the Ethics Committee on those charges, started questioning its very authority and legitimacy. Having chosen to continue his pattern of defiance, the Petitioner communicated to the Ethics Committee that it was not competent to question him, given his position as the Opposition’s Chief Whip. Following a heated discussion between them, the Ethics Committee concluded the proceedings without the Petitioner having addressed any of the charges levelled against him. The next date of the proceedings was then fixed on 19.06.2024.
2.8. The Ethics Committee, in somewhat of an unusual manner, preponed the proceedings from 19.06.2024 to 14.06.2024 without any notice to the Petitioner. The Ethics Committee then discussed the behaviour of the Petitioner during the previous proceedings and concluded that his conduct was wholly unjustified. The Ethics Committee further mooted the demeanour of both the MLCs, i.e. the Petitioner and Md. Sohaib and closed the proceedings.
2.9. The Ethics Committee thereafter submitted the Impugned Report, recommending the expulsion of the Petitioner from membership of the BLC. As regards to Md. Sohaib, the Ethics Committee recommended his suspension for two days in the upcoming Session.
2.10. The Ethics Committee’s report, along with its recommendations for taking punitive measures against the Petitioner as well as Md. Sohaib was presented and discussed on 26.07.2024 in the House. After due deliberations, the majority of the House accepted the recommendations and consequently, the Petitioner was expelled from his membership of the BLC forthwith. Md. Sohaib, on the other hand, was suspended for the first two days of the 208th Session of the House.
2.11. As a sequel thereto, the Secretariat of BLC issued the Impugned Notification dated 26.07.2024, relieving the Petitioner from membership of the BLC and notifying the resultant vacancy caused by such expulsion. The aforesaid measures [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2139Dr. Sunil Kumar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
have prompted the Petitioner to approach this Court through these writ proceedings.
2.12. We may hasten to add that during the pendency of this petition, Respondent No. 6, Election Commission of India (Election Commission), issued a Press Note dated 30.12.2024 declaring the bye-election for the seat held by the Petitioner before his expulsion. The election process was resolved to be completed before 25.01.2025. Considering the impact of the notified election on the outcome of this petition, vide order dated 15.01.2025 the declaration of the result of such byeelection was stayed.
B. contentions on BehAlF oF the Petitioner
3. Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Mr. Gopal Sankarnarayanan, learned Senior Counsels appearing on behalf of the Petitioner vehemently contended that the Impugned Report and the consequential Notification are illegal and unconstitutional. They argued that the actions against the Petitioner were actuated by mala fide and suffered from gross illegalities, both in procedure and substance.
4. Dr. Singhvi and Mr. Sankarnarayanan canvassed the following grounds in support of their submissions:
a) The expulsion of the Petitioner from the membership of BLC was violative of the principles of natural justice, fair and just play, as the relevant material, including the video clip containing his transgressions were not furnished to him. The Petitioner was denied access to the material evidence on the pretext that the proceedings of the House are confidential and could only be perused by him during the meetings of the Ethics Committee. The Petitioner was thus caused inexorable prejudice in the matter of preparing his defence.
b) The Ethics Committee explicitly assured the Petitioner on 12.06.2024 that charges would be framed only after receiving all the relevant material, for which the next date of proceeding was fixed on 19.06.2024. The Ethics Committee, however unilaterally and deliberately advanced the date of hearing to 14.06.2024 without his knowledge. The Petitioner has thus been condemned unheard, and in a manner which reeks of malice and amounts to gross illegality.
2140 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports c) Not only this, the Ethics Committee’s report dated 14.06.2024 was circulated selectively with the members belonging to the Ruling Party, and was kept confidential from the members belonging to the Opposition Parties. Such members being in the minority could not effectively participate in the proceedings. d) In any event, the Petitioner has been hammered with severe punishment, disproportionate to the attributed misconduct and also in comparison to another MLC Md. Sohaib, who, despite facing somewhat similar allegations, was awarded suspension of two days from the upcoming Session.
e) It is settled law that a ‘graded’ approach is required where the House is disciplining its members. Deviation from such an approach in the case of the Petitioner is not based on any sufficient material, and the disproportionate punishment imposed on him falls foul of the Fundamental Rights enshrined in Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
c. contentions on BehAlF oF resPondents
5. Contrarily, Mr. Ranjit Kumar, learned Senior Counsel representing Respondent Nos. 1 to 5, strongly opposed the instant Writ Petition urging that the Impugned Report and Notification expelling the Petitioner from the BLC are based on concrete evidence. He submitted that the action against the Petitioner was taken following due process of law, which has been approved by the majority of the House and thus warrants no interference.
6. In this vein, while opposing the Writ Petition, Mr. Kumar advanced the following submissions:
a) At the outset, the Writ Petition is not maintainable. It is liable to be dismissed in terms of Article 212 (1) of the Constitution of India, which states that ‘the validity of any proceedings in the Legislature of a State shall not be called in question on the ground of any alleged irregularity of procedure’.
b) It is the prerogative of the House to regulate its Business and Procedure, and the decision so taken cannot be tested on the bedrock of proportionality. The issue of proportionality should be left to the wisdom of the House. In other words, the Court cannot examine the quantum of punishment imposed upon the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2141Dr. Sunil K umar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
Petitioner, as such a recourse would amount to reviewing the validity of the proceedings of the House.
c) The Ethics Committee adhered to the principles of audi alteram partem as the Petitioner was given reasonable opportunity of being heard. Such a plea is fortified by the fact that the Ethics Committee asked the Petitioner to join its proceedings on 03.05.2024, 22.05.2024, 31.05.2024, 06.06.2024 and 12.06.2024. In fact, it is the Petitioner who deliberately and for reasons best known to him, failed to avail such opportunity. He kept on either avoiding the proceedings or threatening the Ethics Committee with one or the other objection until 12.06.2024 when he entered appearance for the first time.
d) The Petitioner was duly served with the list of charges as soon as he appeared on 12.06.2024. He, however instead of addressing the charges, questioned the very legality and the authority of the Ethics Committee itself. The Petitioner, being a member of the House, is deemed to have knowledge of the formation of the Ethics Committee under Article 208 of the Constitution and the manner in which its proceedings are conducted.
e) The Petitioner cannot raise the plea of proportionality and seek parity with the other MLC, Md. Sohaib for the reason that the latter duly appeared before the Ethics Committee and cooperated in the proceedings. On the other hand, the Petitioner remained defiant and disregarded the prescribed procedure. Being the Chief Whip of the Opposition, he held a greater responsibility towards the policies, rules and constitutional authority of the House.
f) The Petitioner has a habit of degrading the authority of the House through his indecent and unparliamentary acts for which he was earlier also suspended from the House on 28.03.2022 in the 200 th Session of the BLC.
7. Mr. Ankit Agarwal, counsel for Respondent No. 6—the Election Commission, submitted that in view of Section 151A of the Representation of People Act, 1951 (RP Act), the Commission was duty-bound to notify the elections as soon as the vacancy occurred. He further submitted that the Election Commission had nothing to add on the merits of the case.
2142 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
8. Ms. Meenakshi Arora, learned Senior Counsel, entered appearance for the Intervener, Shri Lalan Prasad, who is the aspirant for election to the MLC seat declared vacant upon the expulsion of the Petitioner. She also asserted that the bye-election declared by the Election Commission for the vacant seat aligned with Section 151A of the RP Act. According to her Section 151A of the RP Act is triggered the moment a ‘legal vacancy’ occurs, mandating the immediate election to fill up the same.
d. issues For considerAtion
9. Having traversed the sequence of events as they emanated, the contentions put forth on behalf of the parties as well as the material on record, we are of the considered view that the following vital issues require analysis:
i. Whether the instant Writ Petition is maintainable in view of Article 212 (1) of the Constitution of India and whether the proceedings of the Ethics Committee are amenable to judicial review? ii. Can this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction review the proportionality of the punishment imposed by the House? iii. If so, whether the Petitioner’s expulsion is disproportionate to the misconduct attributed to him and whether it merits any interference?
iv. If Issue No. (iii) is answered in the affirmative, whether this Court is empowered to determine the quantum of punishment that may be imposed on the Petitioner?
e. A nAlysis E.1. Whether the instant Writ Petition is maintainable in view of Article 212 (1) of the Constitution of India and whether the proceedings of the Ethics Committee are amenable to judicial review?
10. The Respondents have raised an objection against the very maintainability of the Writ Petition in view of Article 212(1) of the Constitution of India. Since this argument strikes at the core of the instant matter, we find it imperative to address this contention at the very outset. Article 212 (1) of the Constitution of India bars any [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2143Dr. Sunil K umar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
enquiry regarding any proceeding in the Legislature on the grounds of alleged irregularity of procedure.
11. Having given our thoughtful consideration, we find ourselves unable to concur with the contentions asseverated by the Respondents that the decision of the Ethics Committee is shielded by the immunity proffered under Article 212(1). We say so because it is no longer res integra that there is no absolute bar on calling into question the decisions taken by the Legislature. The protection under Article 212(1) operates only with respect to the ‘Proceedings in the Legislature’ on the grounds of ‘Procedural Irregularities’. It could not have been the intent of the lawmakers to circumscribe Constitutional Courts unconditionally from scrutinising the validity of the actions of the Legislature, which may encroach upon the Fundamental Rights of the members and/or citizens.
12. To simplify the understanding of the embargo postulated under Article 212(1), we deem it appropriate to distinguish the terms— ‘Proceedings in the Legislature’ and ‘Legislative Decision’. These terms represent distinct concepts, each serving a different function in the law-making process.
13. To further explicate, the ‘Proceedings in the Legislature’ comprise the formal steps, debates, and motions undertaken to facilitate deliberations within the House. It is a structured mechanism that ensures due consideration of a proposed measure, allowing for discussion, amendment, and scrutiny before reaching a final resolution. These procedural steps are not ends in themselves but are designed to channel legislative discourse towards a definitive outcome. Article 212(1) of the Constitution provides immunity for the manner of such proceedings, and hence, Constitutional Courts would exercise restraint when such proceedings are called into question on the grounds of procedural irregularity.
14. A ‘Legislative Decision’, on the other hand, is the culmination of the legislative procedure—the formal expression of the will of the House on a given matter. While Proceedings of the Legislature provide the framework within which members exercise their deliberative functions, the Legislative Decision is the authoritative determination that follows such deliberation. These decisions of the Legislature, though emanating from a coordinate branch of Government, are not immune from scrutiny by Constitutional Courts. Judicial review of Legislative 2144 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Decisions is not an encroachment upon legislative dominion but a necessary safeguard to uphold constitutional supremacy.
15. In this regard, we deem it apposite to underscore the applicability of the principle of ‘expression unius est exclusion alterius’, namely, that whatever has not been included has, by implication, been excluded. Applying the aforesaid principle, we have no doubt in concluding that the prohibition under Article 212(1) operates only with respect to the scrutiny of ‘Proceedings in the Legislature’ on the touchstone of ‘Irregularity of Procedure’. It does not oust the power of judicial review of the decisions of the Legislature, whether Legislative or Administrative, on the grounds of illegality or unconstitutionality.
16. Constitutional courts are entrusted with the responsibility of ensuring the lawfulness of the decisions of the Legislature rather than substituting their judgment to decide the rights of the parties. A decision-making authority, be it the Legislature or otherwise, while exercising its powers, must act within the limits prescribed by the Constitution. Any determination by the authority concerned, if found to be in excess of its constitutional authority or violative of Fundamental Rights, is subject to judicial probe. Such overarching decisions cannot be sustained to preserve integrity in the legal system by preventing excess and abuse of power.
17. Reverting to the facts of the instant case, the Impugned Report recommending the expulsion of the Petitioner was made by the Ethics Committee in the discharge of its administrative functions. These functions have been assigned in the Rules framed by the State Legislature under Article 208 of the Constitution. The Rules so enacted govern the internal functioning, discipline of the House and the procedure by which the House regulates its affairs. However, such administrative actions, even though referable to the Rules formulated under Article 208 of the Constitution, do not constitute the legislative functions of the House. As discussed in the preceding paragraphs, the legislative functions pertain to law-making, deliberation, and policy formulation, whereas the present action of the Ethics Committee is purely administrative in nature, aimed at enforcing discipline and ethical standards amongst the members of the House.
18. The distinction between legislative and administrative functions is well recognized in constitutional jurisprudence. When a legislative body frames rules under Article 208 and subsequently enforces them [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2145Dr. Sunil K umar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
through disciplinary measures, such enforcement is an exercise of administrative power rather than legislative power.
19. It is well established that administrative actions, even when undertaken by legislative bodies or their committees, are subject to judicial review where they affect the rights and interests of individuals. In fact, this Court in Ashish Shelar and Ors. v. The Maharashtra Legislative Assembly and Anr. 1 has held that the substantive disciplinary or rationality of the self-security measure inflicted upon the erring member is open to judicial review on the touch stone of being unconstitutional, grossly illegal, irrational or arbitrary.
20. There can thus be no doubt that if such an administrative decision is found to be arbitrary, mala fide, or in violation of constitutional rights, it is open to judicial intervention in the same manner as any other executive action of the State. Determining whether an impugned action or breach is an exempted irregularity or justiciable illegality is a matter of judicial interpretation and would undoubtedly fall within the ambit of Constitutional Courts.
21. We also clarify here that the scrutiny in the instant Writ Petition pertains to the recommendation of the Ethics Committee subsequently ratified by the majority of the House. This Court is not concerned with the procedure adopted either by the Ethics Committee or the House while making or acting on such recommendation. In this context, the present action resulting in civil consequences for the Petitioner, cannot be immune from judicial review under the pretext of legislative privilege.
22. We cannot be ignorant that the grounds raised before us traverse beyond mere procedural irregularity and challenge the Petitioner’s expulsion on the footing of proportionality. Needless to say, the imposed punishment has a significant impact on the Petitioner’s Fundamental Rights and a chilling effect on the representative democratic framework of our society, issues that we have dealt with in greater detail, in the later parts of this judgement.
23. Consequently, on an overall consideration of legal position, we are of the view that the Respondent’s argument qua maintainability of the Writ Petition must fail. We hold that the action of the Ethics Committee 1 Ashish Shelar and Ors. v. Maharashtra Legislative Assembly and Anr. (2022) 12 SCC 273. 2146 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports neither forms part of the ‘Proceedings of the Legislature’ nor is it tantamount to a ‘Legislative Decision’. Accordingly, entertaining the instant petition would not fall foul of the restrictions imposed by Article 212 (1) of the Constitution.
E.2. Can the Courts examine the proportionality of punishment imposed on a member while reviewing the validity of the action taken by the House?
24. Having held that the instant Writ Petition is maintainable, it would now be apposite to address the preliminary question of plausibility of judicial interference in the issue concerning the proportion of punishment, when examining the validity of the action taken by the House. We will undertake the analysis of this issue through a twopronged approach: (i) the relevance and nature of the ‘doctrine of proportionality’; and (ii) the role of Constitutional Courts in reviewing a decision taken by the House.
E.2.1. The Doctrine of Proportionality: A dynamic precept
25. The expression ‘proportion’ is derived from the Latin term proportio, which corresponds to comparative size, number or degree. The ‘doctrine of proportionality’ essentially signifies that any action should be steeped in reason or logic. This concept highlights the need for clear justification in decision-making, asserting that decisions made without sufficient objective reasoning are often at odds with intended goals. In order to holistically understand the ‘doctrine of proportionality’ and the manner in which it is applied, it is, therefore, imperative to examine its disposition in: (i) the domestic sphere; and
(ii) in international jurisprudence.
E.2.1.1 The Domestic Sphere
26. The doctrine of proportionality in Indian jurisprudence is guided by the principle of selecting the most appropriate and least restrictive measures to achieve the intended objective. The courts’ role is limited to ensuring a proper balance between the adverse effects of an action or penalty on an individual’s rights, liberties, or interests and the purpose it seeks to serve. In summary, while there may be a range of discretionary choices, it is within the courts’ purview to assess whether the chosen measure excessively infringes upon rights. [2025] 2 S.C.R. 2147Dr. Sunil Kumar Singh v.
Bihar Legislative Council (Through Secretary) and Ors.
27. The test of proportionality, in this context, is satisfied by considering a myriad of factors such as fairness, justice, absence of vindictiveness, predominance of objectivity, adherence to natural justice, fair play, and the recognition of mitigating circumstances etc. These factors, while not exhaustive, are instrumental in maintaining the delicate balance between imposing consequences for wrongful actions and ensuring that such measures do not result in right-based transgressions.
28. In the Indian legal spectrum, the notion of proportionality finds its place in a multitude of legal issues. To instantiate:
(i) Service and Labour Laws
29. This Court has time and again highlighted the importance of proportionality when dealing with the question of punishment or disciplinary action for misconduct at the workplace, whether it be in public service or private organisations. The nature of the misconduct, the circumstances of the occurrence, the history and effect of the incident are all factors which ought to be taken into consideration.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.