Dr. Sharmad v. State of Kerala and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 70; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 414
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 9 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13422/2024
- Sections
- 19
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 414 : 2025 INSC 70 Dr. Sharmad v.
State of Kerala and Others (Civil Appeal No. 13422 of 2024)
10 January 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Prashant Kumar Mishra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court was justified in interfering with the order granting promotion to the appellant to the post of Associate Professor, Department of Neurosurgery, Medical Education Service, Health and Family Welfare Department, Kerala on 06.02.2013. Headnotes† Service Law – Promotional appointment – Post-qualification experience, when not required – Vacancy for the post of Associate Professor arose on 13.11.2012 – Appellant had acquired M.Ch degree on 31.07.2008 – Completed 5 years as Assistant Professor on 30.07.2013 (was promoted as Assistant Professor on 11.01.2007) – In the meanwhile, he was Promoted as Associate Professor on 06.02.2013 – Challenged by respondent no.3, application dismissed by Kerala Administrative Tribunal – High Court set aside the promotion of the appellant to the post of Associate Professor holding that he lacked 5 years physical teaching experience as Assistant Professor after acquiring the degree of M.Ch.– Sustainability:
Held: Not sustainable, set aside – A plain and literal reading of the G.O. dated 07.04.2008, the executive order governing the recruitment in question does not show that 5 years’ experience of physical teaching as an Assistant Professor after acquiring M.Ch. degree was one of the requisite qualifications – The G.O., read as a whole, evinces the view of the Government that where the experience had to be gained posterior to the acquisition of qualification, it had directly stated so – Government did not demand such postqualification experience for the posts under consideration – Although, normally, experience gained after acquiring a particular qualification could justifiably be insisted upon by the employer, there could be * Author [2025] 1 S.C.R. 415Dr. Sharmad v. State of Kerala and Others exceptions and the present case is one such exception – On the date of occurrence of vacancy i.e. 13.11.2012, the appellant had physical teaching experience of more than 5 years as Assistant Professor (having joined on 11.01.2007) and thus was eligible, in terms of the recruitment rules i.e., G.O. dated 07.04.2008 – High Court erred in placing reliance on r.28(b)(1A) – Judgment of the Tribunal restored – Impugned judgment in Civil Appeal No. 13423 of 2024 also set aside – Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules, 1958 – Note to r.28(b)(1A). [Paras 14, 26, 23, 29] Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules, 1958 – Part – II, Rule 10(ab), Rule 10(a)(i) – Promotional appointments – Whether Rule 10(ab) has application to the promotional appointment in question – ‘Recruitment Rules’ if not defined, can mean executive Government orders where Special Rules are absent:
Held: ‘Recruitment Rules’ is used in Rule 10(ab) as an alternative to Special Rules, without the same being defined – Without ‘Recruitment Rules’ being defined, it can take colour from Rule 10(a)(i) and mean and include executive orders of the Government where Special Rules are absent – Even if the 1958 Rules were applicable, nothing turns on it because Rule 10(ab) itself consciously uses the expression “unless otherwise specified” – Rule 10 is entirely irrelevant and immaterial for appointment on promotion in the Administrative and Teaching Cadres of the Medical Education Services – The recruitment rules, i.e., G.O. dated 07.04.2008 was issued superseding all existing rules and orders in force on the method of appointment of the faculties under medical education service – The executive must, therefore, be deemed to be aware of what the 1958 Rules, which are the general rules, provided– Notwithstanding the same, G.O. dated 07.04.2008 was issued governing recruitment in two branches i.e. Administrative and Teaching Cadres – G.O. dated 07.04.2008 is, thus, a special rule as distinguished from a general rule like the 1958 Rules – Thus, the distinction in the qualifications for posts in Branch-I and Branch-II in G.O. dated 07.04.2008 would constitute the specification which is excluded from the purview of Rule 10(ab) and such rule had/ has no application to the promotional appointment in question. [Paras 17-20] Maxims – “expressio unius est exclusio alterius” – Whatever has not been included has impliedly been excluded – 416 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Applicability – Exclusion of the words “after acquiring postgraduate degree”, if was deliberate in recruitment rules, i.e., G.O. dated 07.04.2008 for appointments on promotion to posts in Branch II i.e. Teaching Cadre:
Held: Yes – In G.O. dated 07.04.2008, the words “after acquiring postgraduate degree” were specifically included in the column for experience qua eligibility criteria for appointment on the posts of Director of Medical Education and Joint Director of Medical Education/Principals of Medical Colleges, i.e., posts in Branch I i.e. Administrative Cadre – If, indeed, it were the intention of the executive that aspirants for the post of Associate Professor were also required to have physical teaching experience in the feeder posts for specified number of years “after acquiring postgraduate degree”, it defies reason as to why the same qualification was not included for appointments on promotion to posts borne in Branch II i.e. Teaching Cadre but included for the posts borne in Branch I i.e. Administrative Cadre. [Para 22] Case Law Cited Shesharao Jangluji Bagde v. Bhaiyya s/o Govindrao Karale, 1990 INSC 288 : [1990] Supp. 1 SCR 521 : (1991) Supp. 1 SCC 367 – referred to.
Arun Kumar Agarwal (Dr.) v. State of Bihar, 1991 INSC 115 : [1991] 2 SCR 491 : (1991) Supp. 1 SCC 287; Indian Airlines Ltd. v. S Gopalakrishnan, 2000 INSC 590 : [2000] Supp. 5 SCR 548 : (2001) 2 SCC 362; Sirajudheen v. Public Service Commission, 1999 (1) LLN 408; Rabi v. State of Kerala, 2007 SCC OnLine Ker 418; A. Basheer v. Saiful Islam A., 2014 SCC OnLine Ker 18469 – distinguished.
List of Acts Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules, 1958; Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.
List of Keywords Promotional appointment; Post-qualification experience; Associate Professor; Assistant Professor; Department of Neurosurgery; Medical Education Service, Health and Family Welfare Department, Kerala; 5 years physical teaching experience as Assistant Professor; Degree of M.Ch.; Executive order; Requisite qualifications; Kerala [2025] 1 S.C.R. 417Dr. Sharmad v. State of Kerala and Others Administrative Tribunal; Experience posterior to the acquisition of qualification; Medical education service; Administrative and Teaching Cadres, Branch-I and Branch-II; Recruitment rules; General rules; Special rules; Specified number of years; “After acquiring postgraduate degree”; Experience; Eligibility criteria; Feeder posts; “Expressio unius est exclusio alterius”; Maxims; Lecturer; Senior Lecturer; Paediatrics; Post Graduate (PG) qualification. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 13422 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.01.2017 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in O.P. No. 1360 of 2013 With Civil Appeal No. 13423 of 2024 Appearances for Parties V Giri, Sr. Adv., K. Rajeev, Rahul Narang, Ms. Niveditha R Menon, Pranav Krishna, Aditya Verma, Tarun Kumar, Advs. for the Appellant. V Chitambaresh, Sr. Adv., C. K. Sasi, Ms. Meena K Poulose, M Gireesh Kumar, Ankur S. Kulkarni, Ms. Puspita Basak, Tarun, Advs. for the Respondents.
Romy Chacko, Sr. Adv., Anup Kumar, Ashwin Romy, Mrs. Neha Jaiswal, Ms. Shruti Singh, Ms. Pragya Chaoudhary, Akshat Singh, Advs. for the Intervenor.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 13422 of 2024
1. This appeal, by special leave, carried by the appellant 1 to this Court takes exception to the judgment and order dated 20 th January, 2017 of a Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam2 allowing 1 Dr. Sharmad 2 High Court 418 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports a writ petition3 presented by the third respondent4 . The High Court set aside the judgment and order dated 15 th March, 2013 of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal at Thiruvananthapuram 5 , which dismissed the original application 6 of Dr. Jyothish filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 in limine.
2. A short question arises for decision in the appeal. It is, whether the High Court was justified in interfering with the order granting promotion to Dr. Sharmad to the post of Assistant Professor, Department of Neurosurgery, Medical Education Service, Health and Family Welfare Department, Kerala7 on 06th February, 2013.
3. For the purpose of a decision on this appeal, it would be appropriate to note the respective profile of Dr. Sharmad and Dr. Jyothish. The same is indicated in a tabular form hereunder:
Dr. Sharmad Dr. Jyothish Appointed as Lecturer (with MBBS) on 22.10.1999.
Appointed as Lecturer, with M. Ch degree, on 09.03.2005.
Promoted as Assistant Professor on 11.01.2007.
Promoted as Assistant Professor on 22.07.2008.
Acquired M. Ch degree on 31.07.2008.
------- Completed 5 years on the post of Assistant Professor, after acquisition of M. Ch degree, on 30.07.2013.
Completed 5 years on the post of Assistant Professor on 21.07.2013.
Promoted as Associate Professor on 06.02.2013.
Promoted as Associate Professor in May, 2023.
Promoted as Professor on 09.05.2023.
Promoted as Professor on 11.11.2024.
To retire on 31.05.2029. To retire on 30.04.2031.
3 OP (KAT) No.1360 of 2013 4 Dr. Jyothish 5 Tribunal 6 OA 476 of 2013 7 the said post [2025] 1 S.C.R. 419Dr. Sharmad v. State of Kerala and Others
4. It is not in dispute that the vacancy on the said post of Associate Professor, which is the bone of contention in this appeal, arose on 13th November, 2012. For recruitment in the Medical Education Service under the Health and Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Kerala, rules under the proviso to clause (2) of Article 309 of the Constitution of India have not been framed. However, recruitment from time to time has been made in terms of Government Orders issued by the relevant department. At the time of occurrence of the vacancy on the said post of Assistant Professor, Government Order 8 dated 07 th April, 2008 was in force. It was issued in “supersession of all existing rules and orders in force regarding qualification and method of appointment of the faculties under Medical Education Services”. The said G.O. provided qualifications for appointment in Branch – I i.e. Administrative Cadre and Branch – II i.e. Teaching Cadre. The discipline of neurosurgery was included under Head ‘C’ of Branch - II i.e. medical (super specialties). The categories of faculties covered by the said G.O. were (i) Professor, (ii) Associate Professor, and (iii) Assistant Professor.
5. Insofar as Branch – I i.e. Administrative Cadre is concerned, the same bore two posts i.e. Director of Medical Education and Joint Director of Medical Education/Principals of Medical Colleges. Under the column experience, we find the requirement for appointment on the posts of Director of Medical Education and Joint Director of Medical Education/Principals to be common. The same reads as under: “Minimum 10 years of Physical Teaching Experience in Government Medical Colleges (under Medical Education Department in Kerala) after acquiring postgraduate degree”.
(emphasis supplied)
6. For recruitment and appointment on the posts of Professor, Associate Professor and Assistant Professor, the educational qualifications appear to be the same. An aspirant must have the degree of M. Ch in Neurosurgery or DNB (Neurosurgery). The experience criteria required for the said three posts, however, vary. The same are set out hereunder:
8 G.O.
420 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Professor Associate Professor Assistant Professor One year Physical Teaching experience as Associate Professor.
Five years Physical Teaching experience as Assistant Professor.
Three years Physical Teaching experience as Senior Lecturer/ Lecturer.
7. If the experience criteria required for appointment on the posts under Branch - I i.e. – Administrative Cadre are juxtaposed with the experience criteria required for appointment on the teaching posts of Professor/Associate Professor/Assistant Professor, what stands out is that in case of posts in the teaching cadre, the words “after acquiring postgraduate degree” are conspicuous by its absence under the column ‘experience’.
8. Dr. Jyothish claimed before the High Court that notwithstanding absence of such words under the column experience for Branch - II i.e. Teaching Cadre, the said requirement has to be read into it. Reference was made by him to Rules 10 and 28, Part II of the Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules, 1958 9 to contend that Dr. Sharmad did not possess the requisite experience to satisfy the mandatory eligibility qualifications and was illegally appointed on promotion to the said post of Associate Professor by the official respondents. On the contrary, Dr. Sharmad claimed, in light of the criteria for experience for appointment in Branch - I i.e. Administrative Cadre, that it is not the requirement of G.O. dated 07th April, 2008 that an aspirant ought to have 5 (five) years physical teaching experience as an Assistant Professor (regular) after acquiring postgraduate degree. In such view of the matter, the official respondents did not commit any illegality in promoting Dr. Sharmad as an Associate Professor even before efflux of 5 (five) years since acquisition of the degree of M. Ch.
9. The official respondents sought to defend the promotion of Dr. Sharmad to the said post of Associate Professor by referring to G.O. dated 14 th December, 2009 issued by the Health and Family Welfare Department on the subject of pay and allowances, inter alia, of the members of the Kerala Medical Education Service. According to them, G.O. dated 14 th December, 2009 abrogated G.O dated 07 th 9 KS and SSR [2025] 1 S.C.R. 421Dr. Sharmad v. State of Kerala and Others April, 2008 and in terms of the former, Dr. Sharmad did satisfy the eligibility criteria for promotion to the said post of Associate Professor. While providing for revised scale of pay for Associate Professors, G.O. dated 14 th December, 2009 laid down as follows:
1.5 Revised scale of Associate Professors a) Medical & Dental i) *** ii) Incumbent Assistant Professors with five years (for teachers with Super specialty degree in the concerned discipline this will be two years after acquiring Superspeciality degree) teaching experience as Assistant Professor in the current pay scale of Rs. 12000-18300 including Time Bound Higher Grade service and a total service of 8 years after acquiring Post Graduate Degree (5 years for Superspeciality degree holders) in all grades put together will be promoted and placed in the pay band of Rs.37,400- 67,000 with Academic Grade Pay of Rs.9,000 and shall be redesignated as Associate Professors;
however they will have to publish two Research papers within a period of two years promotion in Peer Indexed/National Journals as per MCI/DCI regulations; however for teachers of Dental Colleges, as per the Dental Council of India regulations, only Post PG teaching experience will be reckoned as eligible service for placement as Associate Professor.
iii) Incumbent Assistant Professors who have not completed 5 years teaching service (or having less than 2 years service for superspeciality degree holders) in the cadre of Assistant Professor (including TBCP/CAP grade) as on 01.01.2006 will be placed in the appropriate stage in the pay band of Rs.15,600- 39,100 and Academic Grade Pay of Rs.8,000/-, till they complete the required period of 5/2 years respectively. Thereafter on completion of 5 years service as Assistant Professor, including Time Bound Cadre Promotion grade in pre-revised scale (2 years 422 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports for superspeciality degree holders) and a total service of 8 years after acquiring Post graduate Degree (5 years for superspeciality degree holders) in all grades put together, they will be promoted and placed in the appropriate stage in the Pay band of Rs.37,400- 67,000 with Academic Grade pay of Rs.9,000/- and redesignated as Associate Professor, subject to fulfilling academic performance requirements to be specified. However they will have to publish two Research papers within a period of two years in Peer Indexed/National Journals as per MOI regulations;
provided that for Dental College teachers, only post PG teaching experience will be reckoned as per Dental Council of India norms for promotion.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.