S Shobha v. Muthoot Finance Ltd.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 117; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1147
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 24 Jan 2025
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 2625/2025
- Sections
- 31(2)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1147 : 2025 INSC 117 S Shobha v.
Muthoot Finance Ltd.
(Special Leave Petition (C) No(s). 2625-2627 of 2025) 24 January 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the respondent-Muthoot Finance Ltd. is a “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and therefore amenable to writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art.12 and 226 – The Division Bench of the High Court held that Muthoot Finance Ltd. is not a “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and therefore not amenable to writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of Constitution:
Held: (1) For issuing writ against a legal entity, it would have to be an instrumentality or agency of a State or should have been entrusted with such functions as are Governmental or closely associated therewith by being of public importance or being fundamental to the life of the people and hence Governmental;
(2) A writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India may be maintainable against (i) the State Government;
(ii) Authority; (iii) a statutory body; (iv) an instrumentality or agency of the State; (v) a company which is financed and owned by the State; (vi) a private body run substantially on State funding; (vii) a private body discharging public duty or positive obligation of public nature; and (viii) a person or a body under liability to discharge any function under any Statute, to compel it to perform such a statutory function; (3) Although, a non-banking finance company like the Muthoot Finance Ltd. is duty bound to follow and abide by the guidelines provided by the Reserve Bank of India for smooth conduct of its affairs in carrying on its business, yet those are of regulatory measures to keep a check and provide guideline and not a participatory dominance or control over the affairs of the 1148 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports company; (4) A private company carrying on banking business as a Scheduled bank cannot be termed as a company carrying on any public function or public duty; (5) Normally, mandamus is issued to a public body or authority to compel it to perform some public duty cast upon it by some statute or statutory rule – In exceptional cases a writ of mandamus or a writ in the nature of mandamus may issue to a private body, but only where a public duty is cast upon such private body by a statute or statutory rule and only to compel such body to perform its public duty ; (6) Merely because a statue or a rule having the force of a statute requires a company or some other body to do a particular thing, it does not possess the attribute of a statutory body; (7) If a private body is discharging a public function and the denial of any rights is in connection with the public duty imposed on such body, the public law remedy can be enforced – The duty cast on the public body may be either statutory or otherwise and the source of such power is immaterial but, nevertheless, there must be the public law element in such action – The Division Bench of the High Court is right in taking the view that Muthoot Finance Ltd. is not a “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and therefore not amenable to writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of Constitution – Thus, no case for interference made out. [Paras 3, 9] Case Law Cited LIC of India v. Escorts Ltd. [1984] 3 SCR 643 : AIR 1986 SC 1370 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Halsbury's Laws of England, 3rd Ed. Vol.30, 12 p.682. List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords State; Article 12 of Constitution; Muthoot Finance Ltd.; Authority; Statutory body; Instrumentality or agency of the State; Company financed and owned by the State; Private body run substantially on State funding; Private body discharging public duty. [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1149S Shobha v. Muthoot Finance Ltd. Case Arising From EXTRAORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition(C) No(s). 2625-2627 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.07.2024 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in WA Nos. 418, 490 and 491 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioner:
Brajesh Kumar, Saurav Kumar, Ms. Neha Kumari Singh, Sachin Verma.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. Delay condoned.
2. The High Court in its impugned order has observed in para 5 as under:- “5. While the Court examined the appeals and considered the controversy raised in the petitions, a conspicuous aspect surfaced that the petitions were filed against the Company named Muthoot Finance Limited. Admittedly, the respondent – Company is a Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956. It does not answer the definition of “State” within meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. Nor the transaction of loan by pledging gold between the petitioner and the respondent could be said to be involving any public function or could be said to be in the public realm. Also the Company is not discharging any function which has the trapping of sovereign function. Respondent – Company is a Private Company registered under the law. It is not a “State”.
5.1 Once the above position is clear, the writ petitions would not lie against the respondent – Company. Learned Single Judge could not have, therefore, entertained the petitions on that ground alone.
5.2 Noticeably, learned Single Judge was aware of the said aspect that the respondent – Company did not have the 1150 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports status of the “State” under Article 12 of the Constitution. What was reasoned by the learned Single Judge to entertain the petitions notwithstanding the aforesaid aspect was that, since the financier had acted contrary to some interim order, the petitions merited entertainment. The Court does not endorse to the said view and to make the petitions maintainable on the said ground 5.3 The following was observed by learned Single Judge, “Since on this fact the financier has acted contrary to the interim order, the petition merited entertainment notwithstanding the fact that the respondent is a private financier and would not completely answer its status as being a State under Article 12 of the Constitution of India who performs public functions and loan is granted under the statutory requirement, as enunciated by Reserve Bank of India.
On all these factors, the petitions are entertained. The amount of Rs.24,39,085/- is in deposit before this Court.” 5.4 Thus, it is clear that though the learned Single Judge was well aware that the respondent – Company did not fall within the purview of the ‘state’ or its instrumentality under Article 12 of the Constitution, he proceeded to entertain the petitions and passed the order. The party-inperson submitted that it was a COVID-19 time when she approached the High Court by way of petitions, therefore, they ought to have been entertained. The Court is not impressed with the submission.
5.5 The remedy for the petitioner may be to institute the civil suit and to seek appropriate relief. It was further pointed out by learned advocate for the appellant that the loan agreement between the Company and the petitioner contains an arbitration clause. The loan agreement figures on record (page No.88 onwards) which is found to be containing arbitration clause. Paragraph No.6 (page No.100) of the loan agreement is the arbitration clause.”
3. The Division Bench of the High Court is right in taking the view that Muthoot Finance Ltd. is not a “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and therefore not amenable to writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of Constitution. [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1151S Shobha v. Muthoot Finance Ltd.
4. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that although the Finance Company may not be strictly falling within the ambit of State yet being a non-banking financial institution is governed by the rules and regulations framed by the RBI and if the statutory rules and regulations framed by the RBI are breached by a non-finance banking company then as a statutory authority such finance company is amenable to writ jurisdiction.
5. We are afraid the position of law is otherwise.
6. In the case of LIC of India v. Escorts Ltd. reported in AIR 1986 SC 1370, it was contended before this Court that the Life Insurance Corporation was an instrumentality of the State and was debarred by Article 14 from acting arbitrarily. It was also contended that it was obligatory upon the Corporation to disclose the reasons for its action complained of, namely, its requisition to call an extra-ordinary general meeting of the company for the purpose of moving a Resolution to remove some Directors and appoint others in their place. Such argument was opposed by the State, contending that the actions of the State or an instrumentality of the State, which do not properly belong to the field of public law but belong to the field of private law, were not subject to judicial review. Dealing with the said contentions, this Court observed:- “While we do find considerable force in the contention of the learned Attorney-General it may not be necessary for us to enter into any lengthy discussion of the topic, as we shall presently see. We also desire to warn ourselves against readily referring to English cases on questions of Constitutional law’ Administrative Law and Public Law as the law in India in these branches has forced ahead of the law in England, guided as we are by our Constitution and uninhibited as we are by the technical rules which have hampered the development of the English law. While we do not for a moment doubt that every action of the State or an instrumentality of the State must be informed by reason and that, in appropriate cases actions uninformed by reason may be questioned as arbitrary in proceedings under Art.226 or Art.32 of the Constitution, we do not construe Art.14 as a charter for judicial review of State actions and to call upon the State to account for its actions in its manifold activities by stating reason; for such actions. 1152 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports For example, if the action of the State is political or sovereign in character, the Court will keep away from it ‘the Court will not debate academic matters or concern itself with the intricacies of trade and commerce. If the action of the State is related to contractual obligation or obligations arising out of the contract, the Court may not ordinarily examine it unless the action has some public law character attached to it. Broadly speaking, the Court will examine actions of State if they pertain to the public law domain and refrain from examining them if they pertain to the private law field. The difficulty will lie in demarcating the frontier between the public law domain and the private law field. It is impossible to draw the line with precision and we do not want to attempt it. The question must be decided in each case with reference to the particular action, the activity in which the State or the instrumentality of the State is engaged when performing the action, the public law or private law character of then action and a host of other relevant circumstances. When the State or an instrumentality of the State ventures into the corporate world and purchases the shares of a company, it assumes to itself the ordinary role of a share holder, and dons the robes of a share-holder, with all the rights available to such a share-holder there is no reason why the State as a share-holder should be expected to state its reasons when it seeks to change the management, by a resolution of the Company, like any other shareholder..”
Distinction between ‘public law’ and ‘private law’: Difficult as this distinction is and incapable of precise demarcation, it is yet necessary to keep the broad distinction in mind. Lord Denning in his book “The Closing Chapter” has this to say on the subject:
“The first thing to notice is that public law is confined to ‘public authorities’. What are ‘public authorities’? There is only one avenue of Approach. It is by asking, in the words of Section 31(2)(b) of the Supreme Court Act 1981:
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1153S Shobha v. Muthoot Finance Ltd. What is the ‘nature of the persons and bodies against whom relief may be granted by such orders’, that is, by mandamus, prohibition or certiorari?
These are divided into two main categories:
First, the persons or bodies who have legal authority to determine questions affecting the common law or statutory rights or obligations of other persons as individuals. That is the formula stated by Lord Justice Atkin in R. v. Electricity Commissioners, ex parte London Electricity Joint Committee Co., (1920) Ltd, (1924) 1 KB 171/205 as broadened by Lord Diplock in O’Reilly v. Mackman (1982) 3, WLR 1096/1104).
Second, the persons or bodies who are entrusted by Parliament with functions, powers and duties which involve the making of decisions of a public nature….To which I would add the words of Lord Goddard, C.J. in R. v. National Joint Council for Dental Technicians, ex parte Neate (1953) 1 QB 704/707):
“The bodies to which in modern times the remedies of these prerogative writs have been applied have all been statutory bodies on whom Parliament has conferred statutory powers and duties which, when exercised, may lead to the detriment of subjects who may have to submit to their jurisdiction”.
But those categories are not exhaustive. The courts can extend them to any other person or body of a public nature exercising public duties which it is desirable to control by the remedy of judicial review.
There are many cases which give guidance, but I will just give some illustrations.
Every body which is created by statute and whose powers and duties are defined by statute is a ‘public authority’. So Government departments, local authorities, police authorities, and statutory undertakings and corporations, are all ‘public authorities’. So are members of a statutory tribunal or inquiry, and the board of visitors of a prison. The 1154 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Criminal Injuries Compensation Board is a public authority. So also, I suggest, is a university incorporated by Royal charter; and the managers of a State School. So is the Boundary Commission: and the Committee of Lloyd’s.
But a limited liability company incorporated under the Companies Acts is not a ‘public authority’; (see Tozer v. National Greyhound Racing Club Ltd. (1983) Times, 16 May). Nor is an unincorporated association like the Jockey Club…”. (see pp. 122, 123, 124)
38. Sir Harry Woolf, a Lord Justice of Court of Appeal, points out the distinction in the following words:- “I regard public law as being the system which enforces the proper performance by public bodies of the duties which they owe to the public. I regard private law as being the system which protects the private rights of private individuals or the private rights of public bodies. The critical distinction arises out of the fact that it is the public as a whole, or in the case of local government the public in the locality, who are the beneficiaries of what is protected by public law and it is the individuals or bodies entitled to the rights who are the beneficiaries of the protection provided by private law “. (see page 221 of his Article “Public Law Private Law: Why the Divide? A personal View (published in “Public Law” Summer (1986)”). The learned Law Lord stated further in the same Article, at page 223:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.